Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Dasam Granth?

Dasam Granth?

jinder · 21 Oct 2003

Had a quesetion, how many people have read Hikyaat in Dasam Granth.. Like the 401 tales, I want to read them badly? Any place where i can view online?

Re: Dasam Granth?

Khalsa Soulja · 22 Oct 2003

its the 404 tales. and no there is nowhere on teh net you can read it in english, there is a warped pro-hindu punjabi translation at the gobind sadan website.

Re: Dasam Granth?

jinder · 22 Oct 2003

okaay thanks, i don't know what gobind sadan is.. but thanks

Re: Dasam Granth?

domalla premee · 22 Oct 2003

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh Try this link: http://www.gurmat.info/srec/ dass

Re: Dasam Granth?

singh84 · 23 Oct 2003

Please DO NOT go to the gobind sadan website. they have released their own version of Sri Dasam Granth and are intending to hurt Sikhi. we cannot fall victim to their propoganda.

Re: Dasam Granth?

Confu Singh · 23 Oct 2003

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh! Bhaji, The Gobind Sadan site is a bit 'dodgy' but it does have PDF files of Dasam Granth in gurmukhi letters. Hikayat are towards the end in I believe. Hope this helps

Re: Dasam Granth?

p kaur · 27 Oct 2003

wjkk wjkf Like to know more about dasam granth and the history of it before i read it, some people say i shouldnt even talk about it but like to know why?

Re: Dasam Granth?

Confu Singh · 28 Oct 2003

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh! Bhenji, The granth which we call Dasam Granth today was compiled by Bhai Mani Singh ji before his shaheedi. It is composed of a number of granths by Guru Gobind Singh ji. When the various granths were collected together into one saroop, some of the Sikhs said that they did not approve of it. In order to settle the matter, it is said, that Bhai Sukha and Bhai Jinda did Ardas in front of Guru Granth Sahib ji and the Sangat before going to punish Massa Ranghar. The Ardas by the two Surmay was that if this Granth is not correct may we lay down our lives trying to avenge the insult done by Massa Ranghar to th House of Guru Nanak. If it is right, then we will be able to punich him and bring his head without becoming shaheed. The rest is history... THe Dasam Granth used to be Prakash in Gurdwara Sahibs until the late nineteenth century. The present day version used by most people was prepared by the Sanathan Sikh faction of the Singh Sabha movement (Amritsar) in 1902. They decided to include some bania but excluded others. The committee which worked on the report only had access to the old birs from Amritsar and not outside the city. Because of this, there is a shorter version of the Dasam Granth and a longer one. I hope this helps. If you have any more questions, I will try and answer as best as i can. Daas

Re: Dasam Granth?

Whatever · 29 Oct 2003

gobind sadan=cult

Re: Dasam Granth?

Sikh · 30 Oct 2003

domalla premee, thanks for the link!

Re: Dasam Granth?

.......... · 31 Oct 2003

the story mentioned above about Bhai Sukha Singh and Bhai jinda singh seems made up. Their seva had nothing to do with dasam granth, and is just using their name to promote pro-dasam granth views. THE dasam granth contains some banis with are no doubt written by Guru ji, i.e. Jaap sahib, akal Ustat, Bachittar Natik, and many more Most controversy seems based upon the Chitropakian sections. I read a book by Bhai Vir Singh who said when he first laid eyes on the dasam granth it was half the size of the present version. The section which was added which doubled its size was chitropakian. *****Admin Cut - see note in the end**** we have to be aware of how these granths have come into existence and not just accept everything that has been put in front of us. Alot of youth are just accepting dasma and sarbloh granth as equal to Guru Granth ji. And making stories and excuses for its contents. This is wrong. Guru Granth sahib is the Guru by itself. That is what Guru Gobind Singh wanted. ****admin cut**** Admin note: We had to cut some sections of this article as there is a controversey about Dasam Granth in Panth today. Siri Akal Takhat Sahib has issued an hukamnama against debating on Dasam Granth or criticizing it. *****************

Re: Dasam Granth?

mkhalsa · 31 Oct 2003

has anybody noticed how guru granth sahib jee writes about many stories such as prehlaad, ganika, hindu mythologies etc? has anyone stopped to think that perhaps these so called controversial stories are just guru sahib repeating these myths to us so that we can understand them and therefore understand guru granth sahib jee better?

Re: Dasam Granth?

kooker · 31 Oct 2003

Bhai Sukh & Jinda (Sukhdev Singh Sukha, and Harjinder Singh Jinda) are contemporary Shaheeds , don't mix them up with Bhai Sukh Singh and Mehtab Singh of the Massa Rangar era. [%sig%]

Re: Dasam Granth?

Ranjit · 26 Jun 2004

Has the original dasam granth been found?

Re: Dasam Granth?

Ranjit · 26 Jun 2004

Where was the books last lokadet??

Re: Dasam Granth?

Ranjit · 26 Jun 2004

Very facinating!! Is there a war going on now?

Re: Dasam Granth?

BirRaas Singh · 27 Jun 2004

in the letter from bhai mani singh shaheed to mata sundri ji, he mentions that he has managed to retrieve the banis of chritra upakhyans, these were in the original granth

Re: Dasam Granth?

disciple · 27 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh There are Puratan hand-written Saroops of SRI DASAM GRANTH SAHIB, these were hand written by BABA DEEP SINGH JI. He made copies of Dasam Granth. These Saroops are kept by Damdami Taksal and at Takhat Sri Hazur Sahib. They are the original Dasam Granth. No extra or less Bani. The first "original" Dasam Granth was simply all of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI's BANI, BACHANS, VIAKHIA put together in one compilation. There were no page numbers. For example, somebody has written essays and papers. They are scattered in diff piles all over their desk. They get them all together and put them in one neat pile. That's what the first compilation was. All of Maharaj's writings were put together. i hope this helps

Re: Dasam Granth?

Harpartap Singh · 28 Jun 2004

VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh! I believe that the story about Bhai Sukha Singh and Bhai Mehtaab Singh ji and the Dasam Granth is mentioned in the Mahaan Kosh. I do not know what the ultimate historic source of that story is :o( Can anybody help? H