Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

girls, dastaar and clothes

girls, dastaar and clothes

science · 27 Sep 2005

gurfateh ji there are a couple of points id like to make and i would like these points to be viewed carefully before making judgements. firstly, i know many girls who wear dastaar and are are not akj. thus they dont hold the keski as important as the other kakaars but rather wear it bcos it is in the family or to find a suitable marriage partner. do you think wearing a keski for this reason is disrespectful or inappropriate? secondly, i have seen those who follow tapoban and the uniform they wear is the baana, so i know wht their reacion would be. my best frend is engaged to be married soon. she wears a dasttar and is not akj. she plans to wear a suit for the laavan, but a lengha for afterwards. she has been slated as 'two faced' and 'not following rehat'. this girl is a chardikala singhnee who is amritdhari. plz can some sum1 tell me why lenghas are percieved as 'sinful' when wearing a dastaar. pul chuk maaf [%sig%]

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

RoopKaur · 27 Sep 2005

>plz can some sum1 tell me why lenghas are percieved as 'sinful' when wearing a dastaar.< First of all, think of why is she wearing a lehenga? Is it to look good and pretty? Where is she wearing the lehenga to? If it is to a party, that is manmat because not only is she participating in a ritual that is full of manmat such as kaamic music and wasting time on dancing and such, she is doing the double mistake of representing Guru Ji through her dastaar and participating in such filth. If on the other hand she is going to a rainsbayee wearing a lehenga, why would you want to look like a typical female in the presence of guru ji, and reject the bana guru ji gave? THis does not make sense. A singhnee should be tyaar bar tyaar at all times, just like SInghs, how would she fight a battle wearing a lehenga? Clothes like sarees and lehengaas are not part of the Sikh tradition, but mostly the Hindu tradition. They reflect the oppressive mentalities of those cultures towards women. Guru ji took his daughters out of this reppresive situation in all ways, mentallly, physically, and even freed them through clothing. I do not understand why so many singhnees long to go back to these reppressive markers so much, whether it be through dress, wearing make up, plucking eyebrows etc. A Singhnee is part of the Khalsa, how is it that they can be exempt from wearing the uniform? Imagine a Marines officer wearing a tutu dress worn for ballet or a RCMP officer wearing a swimming suit on duty. A singhnee is always on duty as a member of the Khalsa Panth, why would she wear inferior clothes and reject the Khalsa uniform? I think the saddest thing I see today is that girls with dastaars getting dragged under inferior ideologies of beauty and appearance. What kind of example are they setting for the younger generations of singhneea who need strong and able role models. Can we really say we are from the same family as Mata Bhaag Kaur and Mata SUndari Ji while we reject SIkh traditions, and instead give under social pressures and long for other inferior traditons?

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

??????????? · 27 Sep 2005

i would like to say that i attended a wedding where a singhnee overdid the wedding dress and would look like a bollywood bride without the dastaar. she is not a close friend of mine but i wouldn't ike to enclose names. this singhnee is amritdhari amd turned up at the gurudwaara with a red net lengha, choora up to the elbows, gold jewelerry round the neck, red socks, tikka n the dastaar, bindi and cocunuts tradiitionally worn on the arms. personally, i dont have any objections in my mind to the lengha and dastaar, but the rest of it is an example in which you would find yourself askin where is the line drawn. this girl is not amritdhari as how you descrbed above. im sorry i dont have anythin alse to add to the post. im also looking for answers [%sig%]

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

sortmy life · 27 Sep 2005

this is confusing, i would also like to know he answer [%sig%]

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

Jaspal Kaur · 27 Sep 2005

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji Bibi Roop Kaur Ji has made all the valid points to why a GURU KI SINGHNEE should wear bana but not lengha's. Just like a guru ka sikh is expected to recite bani instead of vedas, in the same manner guru ji gives hukham for his sikhs to wear the appropriate clothing according gurmat. If one wishes to be married under guru ji's blessing's by taking four lavan, rather than a court marriage, then one should also realise the respect and rehit in terms of being married under guru ji's hukham. Look at the thread "wedding in december" and you will automatically see and feel that yeh there is a difference. My dear phenji's in there are giving a fine example of what sikhi is. Then imagine a bibi ji in a lengha. Like Roop Kaur penji say's, i also feel that the bibi ji in a lengha would not be able to defend her self in that situation. If one wants to argue by saying that no by naam jap one has the true piyar for guru ji then one would not even consider thinking of clothings such as mentioned above. Mai Bhago ji she is something undescribable, what would one have to say on that point when thinking of her. Our true singhar on our dastar's should be our chakkars, chandoa, mala and other forms of shastars. Atleast they give out a strong and positive image and in it self is parchar. Please for give me for i may have made many mistakes. Veer's and phenji's we can only humbly do ardas to guru ji, that we all learn guru ji's hukham with sehaj and piyar. vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

wots wrong? · 27 Sep 2005

wots wrong with wearing a lenga on your edding day after the gurudwara? its not a party and it is your wedding! an event that cums once in a lifetime, not jus ne day

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

kabadi · 27 Sep 2005

KESKI IS NOT FOR AKJ ONLY.,.. its for all sikhs.... whether its a KAKKAR or NOT... its still a part of a sikhs appearance, and rehit i dont think any thing is wrong with a lengha... but makeup is wrong

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

Harjas Kaur · 28 Sep 2005

This question has been answered in full by Roop Kaur ji's excellent post. If anyone still has doubt or confusion, please go back and reread it. [quote]First of all, think of why is she wearing a lehenga? Is it to look good and pretty?[/quote] [quote]why would you want to look like a typical female in the presence of guru ji, and reject the bana guru ji gave? THis does not make sense.[/quote] hayt rog kaa sagal sansaaraa. The whole world is caught in the disease of attachment. taribaDh rog meh baDhay bikaaraa. ||2|| In the disease of the three qualities, corruption is multiplied. ||2|| rogay martaa rogay janmai. In disease the mortals die, and in disease they are born. rogay fir fir jonee bharmai. In disease they wander in reincarnation again and again. -SGGS p. 1140 A Gursikh is liberated from the disease of worldliness, sensuality, manipulation of others by appearance and false attractiveness. Be liberated. Read Gurbani. Say paat. Eat healthy, spiritually charged food with Naam vibration. Think thoughts infused with Naam vibration. Spend your time listening to the Lord's praises, not your own. Be Khalsa. Protect the sangat from harm. This is your honor. This is your beauty. And you can't do any of this in clothes which are too tight and intended to draw the wrong kind of attractiveness or flattery. [%sig%]

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

kabadi · 28 Sep 2005

how is a lengha revealing in anyway?, id say its less revealing than those tite pajamis that are worn with a chola

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

soorma · 28 Sep 2005

y r der so much conflict about rehat and stuff sum ppl talk dwn on the akj rehat n sum on da taksali personily we shudnt put ourshelves under such catagories becuz dey cause conflict

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

* · 28 Sep 2005

The real issue is why wear a lengha when you can just wear Guru Sahib's baana? You could just as easily ask if wearing jeans is okay with a dastaar or a skirt or a saree. Where will it end? The best clothing to wear is what Guru Sahib gave us to wear -- Gurmukhi baana. You should wear it on your birthday and your wedding day and every other day before, after and in between. A Gursikh must always be tyaar bar tyaar. One cannot possibly be tyaar bar tyaar while wearing a lengha.

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

Jasmin · 28 Sep 2005

Is Gurmukhi baana suited to colder climates? Also were can I get some of this baana?

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

* · 28 Sep 2005

Gurmukhi baana is suited for any climate. You can get chollay made of heavier material for winter and lighter fabrics for summer. In winter, you can wear tights under your pajami and layer yourself under and over your cholla too. As for where to get baana, where abouts are you situated?

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

i hate paintballing :-( · 28 Sep 2005

kabadi stop bein silly ye pyjama are tite but we wer a chola as well so u can only see the bottom part of the pajama, by the shins. how can u say lengha is more decent than chola.

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

Jasmin · 28 Sep 2005

Southeast CT., U.S.

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

* · 29 Sep 2005

Jasmin Kaur Bhain Jee, come to Toronto...we'll get you some nice baana made here :)

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

Garjkaur · 29 Sep 2005

>>>A Singhnee is part of the Khalsa, how is it that they can be exempt from wearing the uniform? Imagine a Marines officer wearing a tutu dress worn for ballet or a RCMP officer wearing a swimming suit on duty. A singhnee is always on duty as a member of the Khalsa Panth, why would she wear inferior clothes and reject the Khalsa uniform? I think the saddest thing I see today is that girls with dastaars getting dragged under inferior ideologies of beauty and appearance. <<<<< Roopkaur panjee couldn't have put it any better. lenga = MANMAT make up = MANMAT palty shalty, nuching tupping, kamic music = MANMAT gurmukhi baana = gurmat -> tyaar bar tyaar singhni

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

science · 30 Sep 2005

thank you for your replies. my bhenji effered to in the post has confirmed that the english registry of the wedding is the time when she is considering wearing the lenga and not to the gurudwara. neither does she plan on listening to kaamic music at parties or nefink like that........wot now?

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

simple singhani · 30 Sep 2005

what happens if u HAVE to wear a skirt to school??? what then??

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

what bana? · 02 Oct 2005

Many have this mistaken belief that a nihang-type chola constitutes bana and it is therefore our Guru's hukum that we wear cholays......please. Cholas were a particular type of clothing worn during a particular period of time in southeast Asia - you will find that muslims, hindus, and sikhs wore these garments. Moreover, Sikhs across India at that time most likely (correct me with facts if I am indeed wrong) did not wear the exact type of clothing. Even now, compare the "bana" worn by Sant Jarnail Singh ji Bhindranwale (long kurta and kashera), with the "bana" worn by nihangs - there is a significant difference! So is Sant Jarnail Singh ji not wearing "bana" or is a nihang jathedar like Baba Nihal Singh ji not wearing "bana"? Clothing is clothing - you are no more wearing bana by wearing a nihang chola than you are by wearing a pair of jeans. As long as the clothing is modest, respectful, you are fine. If bana means anything, it means the wearing of your 5 kakkars - not a robe/chola or a kurta, pajama. For those that choose to wear cholay to futher identify themselves as Sikhs, all the power to you but do not think that those who don't are somehow disobeying Guru ji's hukum - such a hukum regarding clothing does not exist. [%sig%]

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

sarbjit · 02 Oct 2005

i agree with "what bana" just because some people decide to wear jeans and T-shirt it doesnt mean that theyre less of a sikh and would you say the same 2 a guy wearing jeans and T-shirt with a dumalla?

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

singh · 02 Oct 2005

Bana has been worn since the time of Guru Gobind Singh jee. If anyone questions what Bana is then, go see any amrit sinchaar. All the punj pyaaray dress in essentially the same way regardless of the jatha. That's the common bana. If someone wears bana, it projects the image of a Khalsa. We are such a pathetic community that we love to abandon our heritage. We are ashamed to see Singhs and Singhnees dressed in cholas. What projects Khalsa to you? What shouts out "I am a child of Guru Gobind Singh": is it jeans and a sweatshirt? Or a tank top? Or how about any of the clothes girls wear today? Or is it a chola? Yeah, I think the answer is pretty clear. Chola is bana. Wearing bana is a part of rehit.

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

what bana? · 02 Oct 2005

It has nothing to do with shame or being embarrassed. I fail to see how a chola is considered bana. Why is there no definition of bana with regards to specified clothing? If a particular type of clothing is considered bana, then why do differences exist ? Consider the example of Sant Jarnail Singh ji I gave - was he not wearing bana? Was he acting against rehit? Answer the question. I agree that bani and bana are a must for Sikhs but bana does not mean a particular type of clothing - if anything, it must mean the discipline of wearing your 5 kakkars. I have nothing backing up this view - but it makes more sense to me than the wearing of period clothing as bana. The Panj Piare of today wear clothing somewhat similar to the clothing they believe was worn by the original Panj Piare. I really doubt the original Panj Piare wore bright, satiny cholay that I've seen some of the modern Panj wearing. Moreover, who cares what the Panj Piare wear during Amrit Sanchaar? Should there come a time or a place where the Panj did not have access to their traditional uniform but some Guru de piarey desperately wanted Guru's bakshish (amrit), would it matter if the Panj wore kurtay when they did Amrit Sanchaar? I don't think so. Furthermore, many have said there is nothing wrong with bibian being part of the Panj Piare, because the Panj Piare represent the spirits of the Panj not their exact physiques. If that is the case, then why would I choose to place importance in the clothes worn by the Panj Piare when their very bodies are an unimportant consideration? If one chooses to wear cholas, as the traditional uniform of Sikhs, I think that is great, but that is a personal choice and I reiterate, I see no difference in a Singh wearing a chola and a Singh wearing jeans or a suit. What projects Khalsa to me? The 5 kakkars and the character and nobility that nam-abhiasee Singhs and Singhnis possess. Whether they are wearing track pants or cholas is utterly insignificant to me.

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

singh · 02 Oct 2005

who says Sant Jarnail Singh style cholay are wrong? There can be some variety in what is considered bana. A chola style kurta pyjama is fine, as is the traditional "taksali" style of chola. How do you make the leap from nihang cholas are bana and taksali cholas are a different .........so everyone can wear jeans and its chardi kala....? So should amrit abhilakhis and punj pyaaray dress in shirts/pants? Would they look like Khalsa then? What if there was no khanda or bata and someone wanted amrit? Would a spoon and ceramic bowl suffice? Where do we stop when making these exceptions? Singhs have been wearing cholas since the Khalsa was started. They look like Khalsas. Singhs dressed in sweatshirts and jeans do not project the tyaar-bar-tyaar chardi kala spirit that a Singh in a chola does. Just doesn't work.

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

Common Sense · 03 Oct 2005

""""" why would you want to look like a typical female in the presence of guru ji, and reject the bana guru ji gave? THis does not make sense. """"" Who told you that guru ji gave you the bana (you mean chola??) and told you not to wear anything else? I am totally against dolled up image of a Gursikh but you seem to be suggesting that ONLY bana chola is an acceptable dress for us. Don't mislead others. singh, sorry to break the news to you but wearing chola doesn't make you a "Khalsa". If it did, I would be the first one wear it. Shirt/pant is just as appropriate a bana (dress) as chola or kurta-pyjaama. Older gursikhs prefer what they feel comfortable with and the young gursikhs wear what makes them comfortable. I have seen some very "fashionable" chola wearing singhs and kaurs too. Let's just not go into the "tyaar-bar-tyaar chardi kala spirit" in this thread!!

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

Singh · 03 Oct 2005

Just would like to add that the Keski is firstly better known as a dastaar. It is written in the Bani that the human form is only complete with a dastaar therefore whether Akhand Kirtani Jatha or not, all Singhnis should wear a dastaar as in true Gursikhi there is no spiritual difference between a man and woman. It is only due to the Indian Culture we are from where Singhnis are told not to wear a dastaar and opt for a shawl or chunni instead. Don't follow the Indian culture as indian culture does not fit into Sikhi culture. Indian culture is about berating women, making them wear veils similar to the Islamic Purdah, something our Gurus had forbidden, or abandoning baby girls or expecting widows to throw themselves onto their husband's funeral pyre!!

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

Kulbir Singh · 03 Oct 2005

Common Sense, ---------- singh, sorry to break the news to you but wearing chola doesn't make you a "Khalsa". If it did, I would be the first one wear it. Shirt/pant is just as appropriate a bana (dress) as chola or kurta-pyjaama. ------- It it pretty appalling to read your comments that Bana is as good as Pant-Shirt. Can you imagine Punj Pyaray in Three-piece suits wearing ties? I personally can never imagine this. How could you even think that pant shirt and baana are the same? I request you to reconsider your statement. If even one person who has regard for Baana, loses his faith in baana after reading your nonsense post, you will not be able to escape the karmic repercussions arising from this. Don't do disservice to Panth by undermining our dress - Baana. Kulbir Singh

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

DDT · 03 Oct 2005

there really is no differnece between nihung baana and other baana . nihung singhs wear smaller chola because its more puraatan and its better for combat. With a longer chola if ure doing shaster vidyia ure chola waves upward and it disrupts the movement. Most taksali singhs wear longer baana because Taksal is a place to do bhagti. the singhs sit for long periods of time and do santhiya so it would be more practical in confortable to wear longer chola. that is also the case for dastaars. Nigung singhs wear larger dumalla cause its easier for them. when ure sitting for long periods of time there it is probably easier to wear a smaller dastaar then a large dumalla

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

RoopKaur · 03 Oct 2005

Let me tell you a story... Once, a long, long time ago, in a place now called North America, there lived people who walked around with their own names, own way of living, own way of dressing, own way of doing everything. Thngs went on like this for a long, long time, and everyone was happy and at peace. Although sometimes one group would get into a fight with another, for the most part they lived worry free lives. Then... one day the U-RO-P-N's came and their world was never the same again. The U-RO-P-N's had a mission. "We must make these savages more like us or we will never get them under our control" So they started destroying these people's way of living, every little thing of their past life was a target. "We must first change their names, they are so long and awkward, how will we control them if we can't even say their names. So from their tradiotional names like Shawnadhithit, they turned to Sarah, Suzan, Samantha or Sam, Steve and Shawn. Then the U-RO-P-N's said to themselves "Ok, now we must change their barberious ways of living. They live like savages and animals, and we must make them live like us, in the civilized manner" So the barter system was replaced with currency. Spears were replaced with guns. teepees were replaced with houses. But the most important change was that their local religions, traditions and beliefs were reaplaced with something new called Christianity. "How will we know which ones are controlled by us, and which ones are defiant?" A U-RO-P-N asked his boss. "You are totally right. We need markers to see who is under our control or not. We will make them wear our clothes, and those who we control will wear them, while those who still cling to their own traditions, who refuse to be our pawns, who are stubborn in their set of beliefs, well they will refuse us and we will know who are our friends, and who are our enemies" We will use further force in these savages, and we will make them CIVILISED! If its the last thing we do!" Said the boss, while wolfing down some meat he got in trade from these people. His beaver cap fell off his head from the energy and passion he put into his last statement. And so the people of the land were forced to abandone their traditional clothes and wear trousers, shirts, suits and boots on their feet. And as things went along in this fashion, they kept losing more and more control of their culture, their beliefs, their religions, and kept getting more and more attached to, dependent on, and under the control of the U-RO-P-Ns. *******THE END******* The moral of the story: This is a very simplified version of how Europeans, both French and english settlers and colonists, ruined the aboriginal culture of North America. The Khalsa Panth right now is also getting destroyed. We all know that our history has been extremely tampered with (we have lost the fifth kakaar, we have lost our sarbloh tradition etc). The injustices the panth suffered after the partition, and continues to suffer today leave know doubt in that Sikhs and their way of living is not accepted or even wanted in India, or other parts of the world. But the saddest, and most disgusting attack on the panth is from people who claim to be part of Sikhi, who should technically support Sikhi culture but instead join forces with dokhis of the panth to rally against it. People like this make the job of those who wish to destroy Sikhi, to annihilate every aspect of it much easier. To campare pant and shirt and say it is equal to banaa is part of this agenda, whether one does it knowingly or otherwise, they are aiding those who wish to destroy Sikhi's ankh, maan and izzat. My humble benti is, please, open your eyes and look at the halaats that the panth is going through, and when you make comments like this, think about what you are doing for Sikhi's future. As for the lehenga, this dress was originally a dress for prostitutes, and has now become a fashion. This is the same thing with short hair. Before those women that were demoralised in public or were prostitutes or held other undignified jobs would have their hair shorn and the rest of the women wore their hair long. Why would a daughter of shahan shah Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji wear the clothes originally meant for prostitutes?

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

what bana? · 04 Oct 2005

I withdraw whatever I have said in this thread. My questions (and my thoughts) on this topic still remain the same; however, the internet is not the best medium for such a discussion - It seems that regardless of the "genuiness" of the question or thought behind the question, one is automatically deemed to be anti-Sikh or ignorant if they hold differing views. Perhaps it is easier to place labels than address the issues. Perhaps it is also easier to dismiss Sikhs with genuinely differing ideas by labelling them anti-Sikh or ignorant rather than accepting a difference in opinion....especially considering it all comes down to opinion -clothing as rehit has very little substantiation. Regardless, for fear that younger Sikhs may take this discussion the wrong way and see it as advocacy for disowning their uniforms, I withdraw my comments.

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

Common Sense · 05 Oct 2005

''''''" As for the lehenga, this dress was originally a dress for prostitutes, and has now become a fashion. ''''''' Have your mother, grandmother or great grandmother ever lived in Punjab.? Ask them if any one of them or other sikh women of the time ever wore a ghaGraa (lehenga). I know my grandmother and she was hell of gursikh.

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

kaurr. · 05 Oct 2005

why would you only wear the lengha to the party afterwards? why not wear the lengha to the gurdwara as well? maybe becuase you think guru sahib is at the gurdwara and will not be at the party? wrong!..guru ji is EVERYWHERE. he can see u at the gurdwara, at the party, all the time, anywehre u are, he's right there beside u. "..nerha hai, door naa jaaneyo.." He is near, don't think He is far away. so once again, if wearing a lengha is okay, then why not wear it to the gurdwara? i personally believe wearing a lengha is NOT OKAY as ur legs are bare naked with just a kapra flowing around, which is almost like a sari. cover up, girl! [%sig%]

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

guruji's_student · 09 Apr 2006

well if a girl wears a dastar and isnt akj .. so wot!! is still khalsas uniform!! its liek is it ok for a singh to wear dastar and not be akj ? and were only supposed 2 belive in KHALSA PANTH!! no jathebandis waheguru

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

w/ever · 09 Apr 2006

"firstly, i know many girls who wear dastaar and are are not akj. thus they dont hold the keski as important as the other kakaars but rather wear it bcos it is in the family or to find a suitable marriage partner. do you think wearing a keski for this reason is disrespectful or inappropriate?" ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ i would just like to note for the record many Singhnia are not "akj" and wear dastaar BECASUE they WANT TO and see it as an important feature of being a Singh/Singhni and it is NOT because they want a suitable marriage partner or because it is in the family! please do not make these types of presumptions, does yourself or anyone else no good!!!

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

. · 09 Apr 2006

simple singhani: what happens if u HAVE to wear a skirt to school??? what then?? does anyone know the answer to this

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

???? · 09 Apr 2006

If you feel, as a sikh you don't want to wear a skirt then I think thats where your parents need to make a stance about this with the school. They take the advice of a sikh human rights organization. If your provide valid reasons, then quite a few schools take that into consideration.

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

anon · 09 Apr 2006

most scools will let u wear trousers unda skirts if u ask nicely

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

anon · 10 Apr 2006

"Author: RoopKaur Date: 10-03-05 16:05 Let me tell you a story..." Great post penji ur totally rite 2day ppl are changing traditions which have been there for centuries what right jave we to change them. Bana was the original dress code so ahy change this. There have been loads of great posts 2 many 2 mention! This is just my opinion and i might be completely wrng but dont u need bani 2 wear bana? bana is bana there are many stlyes doesnt mean some are classed as bana and others arent. looking at this post i see alot of penjis who know what they are talkin about and its a shame that so many sighnees now adays care what they look like unlike some penji who have posted i would like to have these sighnees as sangat there are not many sighnis round me! vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji kee fateh!

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

ns · 10 Apr 2006

100% SPOT ON RoopKaur Jeeo

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

okay · 10 Apr 2006

how about we all bicker and lose laha and sit on forums instead of reading bani

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

worthless · 10 Apr 2006

* how about we all bicker and lose laha and sit on forums instead of reading bani * so what are you doing on a forum forums are a good way of learning about sikhi, i know this from experience. if you dont want to contribute thats fine. but please dont discourage other people, because a lot of us geniunely want to learn, and are just voicing our opinions. i think everyone is entitled to that. bhul chuk maaf karo ji waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

ks · 11 Apr 2006

sikhi isn't as small as having to wear certain clothing. If it was important enough, the Guru would have given out templates for cholay.

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

shirtaan pantaan FOOKOOOO · 11 Apr 2006

I myself wore shirts jeans and present day baby underwears.Recently I kept hair and started to wear bana sometimes.The bana is AWESOME.Thats it.The only problem why sikhs dont wear it is because of lack of sikhi inside.People are conscious of fellow people,thats it. Why do we use western calendar? Why do we use western week days? Why do we wear western dress? BECAUSE we dont know WHERE WE HAVE COME FROM AND TO WHOM WE BELONG. The western people can attack our punjab and make it their home for hundred years.They can attack north america and make it their home.They can roam almost naked anywhere they want to.They can have all type of hair cuts etc.And we sikhs of the Dasmesh Pita feel conscious of wearing Bana while living in west. Does a kanjarr with an earing and tatto and proudly walking on the street feel conscious of how kanjarr and khurrrooooo he is looking? WAke up sikhs.This world is of waheguroo and hence this world is OURS. KHALISTAN ZINDABAD RAJ KAREGA KHALSA

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

ks · 12 Apr 2006

the problem with defining a chola as bana is that you immediately tie Sikhi down to punjab. The Gurus gave us something much bigger than that. Why would we want to limit Sikhi to 1500-1700s era punjab? what are the defining characteristics of bana? Freedom of movement, modesty, what? Start listing those and you'll soon have an answer that trancsends any particular time period or people. That is the true path of Sikhi.

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

Moderate · 12 Apr 2006

Fateh, To the original post, its good if a singhni wears a dastar even if she is not akj, as the dastars is part of our image. Its good shes going to be getting married wearing a dastar. As for her wearing a lengha to the court marriage bit, then thats upto her. ITS NOT REALLY A BIG DEAL. She can do what she wants so long as she still represents guru. So long as its descent, and she looks descent its acceptable. A nihung style chola is the only bana for sikhs. There are many forms. It would be great if she wore bana, being a chola, a suit or more traditional sikh clothing, as is my understanding a lengha has more hindu origins. At the end of the day, it matters not, guru ji loves everyone and thats all that matters. I dont think guru will be mad at us just cuz we wear diff clothes. But the more pride one has in sikhi, the more love we have, the more we want to replicate our guru and be just like him, and we will do that at our own speed. Best of luck on her wedding

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

wnd · 17 Apr 2006

Kulbir Singh, do you wear bana to work?

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

... · 17 Apr 2006

Kulbir Singh is in India but to answer you question, yes, he does.

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

PTE SINGH · 18 Apr 2006

I was aware of only one item of clothing that is considered 'religious clothing' that my friends is the Kashara, nothing else. One of the purposes behind the Kashara is that it equalised people in the same way that the suffix Singh or Kaur does. Clothes, like names, throughout history have been used to discriminate between casts, class and creeds. Only certain people or groups were allowed to wear certain clothes and some items denoted certain things, many items of clothes were designed to supress people. The Kashara as well as reminding us of or obligations to control lust was supposed to stop the supressive aspects that clothing had on women and the 'lower castes'. To stop us from being hindered in our everyday life by the restrictions of clothing, like in other social orders. The clothes do not make the man (or women in this case) [%sig%]

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

Sher Khalsa · 07 May 2006

kulbir singh does not wear bana to work (meaning chola, kurta pajama), atleast not the last time i saw him on the train

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

?? · 08 May 2006

last time I saw him on the way back from work, he was dressed in bana. But what do you care anyway? if he needs to dress differently at work, so what?

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

Sher Khalsa · 08 May 2006

i dont care, someoen above said kulbir singh wears bana to work, and i responded by saying, i dont think he does. and what do you care for anwyasy if i responded or not. what are you getting all okha for and getting your kashera all up in a knot.

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

raj kaur · 08 May 2006

ok...sum ppl dont wear banays at work...but so wat...wats the point anyways...oh well..i read sum of the posts and it seems to me that u guys think that singnees with dastaars cannot wear a lenga...and i tottaly agree on that...i mean guru ji told us that our banas is a chola...and/or suit... i was just thinking...that...i see sum girls with dasttars wearing make-up...i i no that its so wrong..but i mean they r putting themselves as a bad role model for the yougsters who r going to be chardikala singhnees in the future...do u get where im taking this..or no..i hope u r...cause if u no anyone who is doing this please help to get then to stop...we dont want to loose any more singhnees than we have in the past... dont think i said anything wrong cause im a chardikala singhnee myself...and i dont do any of this dumb stuff...im a daughter of guru gobind singh ji...

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

Sher Khalsa · 08 May 2006

raj kaur aka chardi kala singhni.. lol...where did guru sahib say wearing a suit is ok?

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

wasting my time · 10 May 2006

thing is salwar kameez is not traditional Punjabi dress, lehnga is. wearing make up does not make you an evil person or not a gurmukh wearing a pair of trousers or a shirt does not make you less of a singh, wearing a lehnga does not make you less of a singhnee the body is creation of god, it is beautiful, if you can't control your kaam do not blame the woman for not covering up, blame your own dirty mind for not being able to see past the flesh I know singhnees who wear make-up and are chardi klaa, doing sukhmani sahib twice a day, who are we to judge. Bebe Nanaki ji , Guru Nanaks sister wore lehnga makeup and jewels, she was the first Sikh follower, she did not wear a dastaar or bana and was blessed by Guru Nanak. Mata Sahib kaur mother of the khalsa, did not wear a dastaar or wear a bana, most of the gurus wives wore full lehngha suit. don't make sikhi into something that suits your own beliefs, don't distort history to suit your own maryada. Dont try and change HISTORY SO IT LOOKS LIKE YOU. what has been has been, no matter how much you say you can never change the truth. Guru Nanak tried to destroy the brahmin way of looking down on women, and you are doing exactly the same thing, condemning women for being beautiful because you have no control over your own kaam. The body is a creation of god when you look at a woman be it in dastaar lehnga or trousers, what do you see A filthy woman, or a sister, a mother. the dirt is in your mind not in the clothes sometimes i think that sikh have becoem the very thing, religious bigots who have no care for peoples hearts but empty rituals and clothing garbs sach kaho sun leho sabhey jin prem kiyo tin hi prabh payo

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

rsingh · 10 May 2006

'wasting my time', you're not just wasting yours, but everyone elses as well. Now, where did you learn about what Bebe Nanaki and Mata Saahib Kaur wore? Do you have any references? Or are you just going by paintings and what suits your mind? I can just as easily say that they did wear dastars. Prove that they didn't. Especially Mata Sahib Kaur. Do you honestly think that what you wear has no bearing on your atma? Why do you choose what you wear? Why do people wear makeup? Or tight clothes? Or jewellery? Is it not to look good and presentable to society? This is exactly what sikhi teaches us to rise above. Be pleasing to the guru, don't worry about others. Someone who is truly chardi kala will not need to waste time and money applying makeup. What for? If you are immersed in banee and naam, are you really going to care about what the materialistic world thinks about your looks? If you've truly given your head to your guru, you're not going to waste your time and money on trying to please the minds and eyes of this materialistic society. The body is beautiful when it has the glow of naam on it. You won't be able to beautify the body any more than it already is. Just because some manmukh finds it beautiful doesn't make it so. People need to appreciate their bodies as they are and overcome the pressures of society to look a certain way. That's what makeup and fashion are all about. You are surrendering to the whims and will of popular culture. This is not the way of the Khalsa. The Khalsa overcomes these pressures and has enough confidence to accept what they are physically. The Khalsa is always above worrying about looks. How can a Khalsa immersed in naam spend time worrying about what looks good to the general public and then spend time altering their form to please these people's eyes? Such people are caught up in the world ocean of maya and need to delve deeper into sikhi. The Khalsa only worries about pleasing the guru and guru kay sikh. Nobody else.

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

Singh · 10 May 2006

"wasting my time" please prove that Bibi Nanaki wore makeup and jewels. Please also show that Mata Sahib Kaur did not wear a Dastar. Awaiting historical sources/references. Both men and women are to dress simply with simple clothes. Neither are meant to put excessive time into beautifying themselves for their own ego or to attract the opposite sex. It is YOUR idea that women have to wear make up and jewellery to beautify themselves, that is backward and repressive to women. Huge amounts of pressure are put on modern women (of any religion/race) by society to conform to a certain image and frankly there is little pressure if any on men to have to look after what they look like. This is gender inequality, yet because it is practised widespread in western countries, we assume that it is "modern" and thus correct. One final point; doing two Sukhmani Sahibs a day does not mean it is acceptable to wear makeup, neither is the fact that some people do it a valid argument. There are many people who do large amounts of Paath or Simran, or Rehat, but for various reasons never progress at all with their spirituality.

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

singhni · 10 May 2006

"wasting my time" you say that you know of chardi kala bibyian who wear make up and recite sukhmani paat etc - lol im sorry but this makes me laugh. the words of chardi kala and make up dont go together. Seeing a singhni in make up breaks my heart (me being a singhni myself) and to be totally honest, look really ugly! Kinda ironic considering they trying to make themselves look "beautiful" haha... Read and follow what Guru Sahib has told us ji and you will get your answers.

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

learner · 15 May 2006

I feel that some of the arguments are running off track and we are forgetting the point. In regards to jewellary, make up, lengha's... we have got to ask the fundamental reason - ' why are we doing this?' This should be the case in any aspect of our lifes. The fact that people ask if the above things are ok, represents that somewhere deep within them they already know it isn't the best idea.... they are just looking for one person to say 'yeah its all gud'... just so that they can put their mind at ease and carry on with those things. We all know the fundamental reasons for lengha's and makeup and jewelery... its all kaam.... asking anyone why they do the above the reply is cos i feel comfortable... but really we all know why.... whether people admit it or not... trying to look nice is not for personal reasons, its so that u can say to urself ' when someone looks at me i went them like what they see....' Jewellary/gold is a form of attachment and a way to please the ego. Maharaj has warned us from maya and we should practice humility by letting these things go... (I also admit here that there can be siinghs/singhnees that have reached that level where they don't have that attachment or kaam aspect, so wearing jewelary wouldn't make any difference, but if they have reached that stage they would also be aware of the examples being set and the thought processes they may cause in other people minds....so such things wouldn't even enter their minds ) Personally, wearing guru ji's dastaar and then wearing a lengha to look nice is a contradiction. On one hand we are saying, maharaj let me follw the path of the Khalsa, give me your roop, let me represent the Khalsa with this dastaar'.... and on the other hand we are saying ' maharaj, let me wear your dastaar but let me look gud in a lengha and makeup because the roop you have given me doesn't meet societies requirments' Baana is a gift that allows us to practice humility and not care about the materialistic things of the world. Wearing this 'different' and simplistic types of clothes (chola) esp in western society is a difficult thing to do... why? because we are scared of what people think... they may think that i am not a gora!... Khlasa image is extremely important. Maharaj doesn't want us to blend in and not be seen... Khalsa should be visible wherhere s/he goes. On a personal note, I still have not chalked up the courage to wear baana all the time. I recently started wearing it to programmes and then everytime when i goto my local gurdvara.... i do ardaas that vaheguru gives me the strength to represent the khalsa with all my ability all the time.... Since i started wearing the baana, ive also noted one other thing, which shows the importance of it. Wearing the Khalsa uniform triples the responsibility we feel... what i mean is, unfortunately there are many people with kes and dastaar and kaRe that do manmat and wrong things... that ends up showing sikhi in a bad light....and unfortunately is making people immune to the fact that people with kes, kaRe and dastaars should not be doing those things, however with a baana u know that u goto behave and follow guru's hukam and be an example to everyone all the time.... baana is a huge deterent from doing anything wrong....that includes the way u speak as well as your actions. So hopefully we can see the importance of baana. We shouldnt have the attitude that bana and western clothes are the same.... baana (kakkars and chola, kamarkassa, hazooria) these are all the nishanee of a khalsa... we must ensure we never blend in so much that we lose the baana, or the khasla would have lost an extremely large proportion of its true identity and self control. Please forgive me for any mistakes I have made and do ardaas that daas may also pluck up the courage and not be thoughtfull of other peoples perceptions. K Singh Vaheguru ji ki Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh [%sig%]

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

babao · 15 May 2006

doing 2 sukhmani sahibs a day doesnt make u chardikala u cud do sukhmani sahib all day but if u pierce your ears and wear indecent clothing your kamai will be quickly lost its like pouring water into a buket with massive holes buket is rehit, water is naam and gurbani

Re: girls, dastaar and clothes

Juggy Double D · 18 May 2006

The standard dress for a Amritdhari is bana! That may have some practical implications, but thats just tough. When you took Amrit you promise to keep the roop of the Guru. And that includes his bana. No jeans, no fancy leather jackets, no skirts, no swimsuit, just bana! You have to understand that the Guru is everywhere. There's no point wearing bana (the khalsa uniform) just on the occasions when you go to the Gurdwara (because you think you are meeting the Guru in that buidling) THE GURU IS EVERYWHERE!. How would you like to present yourself to Guru ji? Wearing jeans and a leather jacket, or HIS UNIFORM the bana!!! Everywhere the Guru is present and therefore Everywhere you must wear his bana!! [%sig%]