Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

AS · 26 Sep 2005

-This is happening in Punjab where Sikhi is the majority!!! Have a read... Admn order on kara, kirpan draws SGPC’s ire School to amend directive, says Principal Tribune News Service Ropar, September 26 Sikh students have been banned to wear kirpan and kara in Shiwalik Public School run by the district administration in Ropar city. The school Principal, in her written orders, a copy of which is also available with The Tribune, said the students were not permitted to wear any such objects that may be sharp, including heavy karas and kirpans. The orders were sent to the parents of each student in the school. The order said these things were strictly prohibited in the school. If any student was found wearing them, these would be impounded and the bearer would be fined Rs 500 besides disciplinary action. Besides the kirpan and kara, other things which were banned, included mobile phone, gold and silver jewellery, cash, CDs and cassettes and also in driving to school on two-wheelers. The SGPC has decided to launch an agitation against the decision of the school authorities. An SGPC member, Mr Gurinder Singh Gogi, said if the administration would not withdraw the circular issued by the school authorities, then the SGPC would launch a statewide agitation against it, he added. It was unfortunate the students of Punjab had to face such kind of discriminations. The decision of the school authorities met with widespread resentment among parents of the Sikh students. On conditions of the anonymity they said that kara and kirpan were compulsory for a baptised Sikh. It was unfortunate the school run by the administration was hurting sentiments of Sikhs. They also decided to take up matter with the higher authorities. When contacted the Principal of school, Ms Gurpreet Mathur, said that order was passed due to the safety of the students and not to hurt sentiments of Sikh community. As even in small dispute, the students could hurt each other with a kara and kirpan. She said tomorrow she would take necessary amendments in the order so that baptised Sikh students could carry things as per their religious beliefs.

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

UKSingh · 27 Sep 2005

THIS IS A MESS you hear this happening here iN uk and Canada/Usa BUT PANJAB!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Sorry for my intital reaction of paranoia/conspiracy theories, but this woudl be another stab in the back to GurSikhs from both national and local administration government. This can not happen in Panjab

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

Scientific · 27 Sep 2005

Was there a limit imposed on the size of the kirpan? I cant believe they would completely ban a small kirpan? I ask this because you have mentioned 'including heavy karas and kirpans' There may be issues around wearing karay which look quite offensive. As an example it is quite a trend in UK schools for Sikh boys to wear large karay (some with edges carved in). On many occasions these are used in fights and can be as damaging as knifes. As for large kirpans (if that is what they are referring to) its sensible to limit the size of the kirpan. Its probably not practical for youngsters to be wielding three foot kirpans around college. The complete ban of the kirpan( if this is what they are imposing) is outrageous and not much better than the french banning the turban. Scientific

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

Guru ji help me i'm so weak · 27 Sep 2005

psssst.....who said we don't need khalistan???? are the sikhs free??? in there own homeland!!!!!!!!

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

Harjas Kaur · 27 Sep 2005

[quote]As for large kirpans (if that is what they are referring to) its sensible to limit the size of the kirpan. Its probably not practical for youngsters to be wielding three foot kirpans around college.[/quote] It's actually "reasonable" arguments like these which are the justification for discrimination. People exaggerate fears of something citing extreme examples such as wearing 3 foot kirpans to college. Government officials are using aggression to demonize ALL kirpans by made up threats about their presence in schools. What "obvious" threat exists from Sikh kara? These are not reasonable arguments. They manipulate the most extreme fears to ostracize Sikhi in Indian society. The true intent and desire is to disarm and render vulnerable the Sikh community with laws, and regulations and "reasonable" accusations. There is NO legitimate justification to single out Sikh Kakkars for blanket discrimination. To badger families with fines, criminalization, hysteria mongering is the REAL threat. Sikh hatred is hiding behind "reasonable" rhetoric. The intent is to alienate Sikh students from Sikhi, eliminate Sikh students from an education, fine and jail Sikh parents for noncompliance, target an entire community for harassment, character assassination and genocide. It is COMPLETE proof that Sikh community is being stabbed in the back by Indian government. They intend to: Force Sikh students to abandon the articles of their faith! More than conspiracy, it is evidence of further erosion of trust of the Sikh community as human beings in their own Punjab, as equal citizens in India. Segregation and deprivation of opportunity are tools of genocide! Soon they will be arresting Gursikhs.....or, did they ever stop? [%sig%]

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

Reply · 27 Sep 2005

>Its probably not practical for youngsters to be wielding three foot kirpans around college. Scientific ji, Although a good number of your posts are interesting coming from a psychiatric perspective, I have to say that this is a total sellout position. You do know that the original form of the Kirpan is indeed 3 feet long. It is only our manmat which has led to the 6-inch kirpan being standardized. Anyway, reading your post I had thought you would end by saying something about grade-schoolers' immaturity but college students? Although there is probably one out of 100,000 who would wear a 3-foot kirpan to college, why does it need to be banned on a practicality basis? (If it's not practical, they won't wear it. If it is practical for somebody, let him wear it.) Also, we are talking about Punjab, where this is not a status quo, but a step backward. We cannot afford to lose the Punjab or we will have 0 rights anywhere. And nobody wields kirpans. They just carry them in their gatras 99.9% percent of the time. [%sig%]

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

Reply · 27 Sep 2005

>There may be issues around wearing karay which look quite offensive. As an example it is quite a trend in UK schools for Sikh boys to wear large karay (some with edges carved in). On many occasions these are used in fights and can be as damaging as knifes. The "heavy" kara is actually the real form of the kara. These days, most people wear something that looks like a bracelet. >On many occasions these are used in fights and can be as damaging as knifes. Although it would be perhaps OK (depending on the situation) to use a kara as a last resort, there is no excuse whatsoever for just getting into fights and using your kakkars for personal, manmatti vengeance. Only those who have become saints first can become true warriors. [%sig%]

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

Scientific · 27 Sep 2005

Wearing a three foot kirpan isnt really necessary is it? Wearing a smaller shastar can be effective and more practical. Going to school/college (the last time i was there) wasnt really a dangerous place. Why not be practical without compromising the kakaars. No one is saying we shouldnt be allowed to wear the 5 Ks. We are talking about practicality. I agree the kara is true weapon but it makes sense to wear a lighter version. If this is causing offence then point revoked. S

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

AS · 27 Sep 2005

-Here's some good news, guys... School Principal booked for banning ‘kirpan’ Tribune News Service Ropar, September 27 Following Sikh religious bodies’ ire, the Ropar police today registered a case against the Principal of Shivalik Public School who had banned Sikh students from wearing “kirpan” and “kara”. Besides, Akal Takht Jathedar Joginder Singh Vedanti sought explanation from the school Principal on the matter in the evening. A case of hurting the sentiments of the Sikh community was registered against the Principal in the evening after the Deputy Commissioner, Ropar, who is also the Chairman of the school, directed the SSP to register a case. The issue was discussed at length at a meeting held at Akal Takht in Amritsar when the Jathedar of Takht Sri Kesgrah Sahib, Mr Tarlochan Singh, highlighted the matter. Mr Tarlochan Singh told The Tribune from Amritsar that all the five Jathedars of different Takhts took serious note of the order passed by the Principal, Ms Gurpreet Mathur. The SSP, Mr Surinder Pal Singh, confirmed to The Tribune that a case for hurting the sentiments of the Sikh community under Section 153-A of the IPC had been registered against Ms Gurpreet Mathur, on the recommendations of the Deputy Commissioner, Mr H.I.S. Garewal. The inquiry had been handed over to the DSP, Anandpur Sahib. Meanwhile, Ms Mathur today issued a circular stating that the order had been amended accordingly by adding that except for Amritdhari Sikhs, nobody else was allowed to carry heavy kara and kirpan. She further said: “I apologise if anybody’s religious sentiments were hurt due to the earlier circular.”

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

Harjas Kaur · 27 Sep 2005

[quote]Wearing a three foot kirpan isnt really necessary is it? Wearing a smaller shastar can be effective and more practical. Going to school/college (the last time i was there) wasnt really a dangerous place. Why not be practical without compromising the kakaars. [/quote] The problem with your position is simply this. You are looking for reason in the argument of Indian government school system to justify the ban. In this you are collaborating with our enemies. You are feeding them justifications, agreeing with them about the "threat" and "innappropriateness" and potential "danger" of Sikh Kakkars. If someone has this impression of Sikh Kakkars, you do not educate them and explain the religious significance? You agree they are right and we should suppress our outward appearance to accomodate discriminatory fears and prejudices? Note, that you have taken to extreme's for examples as the only way you can validate the concerns of the Indian Government. There is no mention by the Indian School authorities about 3 foot Kirpans. There is only talk of a general ban not wanting Sikh kids to wear kirpans/karas on school premises. So how is your argument practical? It practically agree's with the position that Sikh kakkars are inherently dangerous, bannable, unnecessary, and inappropriate in public school settings! Now, you backtrack to add that only kirpans of a certain regulated size are acceptable. And you talk about compromise, as if compromise was "reasonable." Do the hundreds of thousands of dead Sikhs in India and wanton tortures and arrests in Punjab over the last twenty years of oppression speak to you about "reason" on the part of Indian Government attitudes towards Sikh people? You do not see a link here between the Bollywood portrayals of the dangerous Sikh terrorists and the assumed inherent "dangerousness" of Sikh Kakkars? Do you realize they are intending a general ban here, for political reasons, not practical ones. And they will use any means via legislation including imitation of discriminatory laws in other countries to justify their restriction of the outward expression of Sikhi. Soon, people can only wear 6 inch kirpan and not heavy sarbloh kara. Then they will tighten the restriction to 5 inches, then 3 inches. Soon they will forbid anything except a symbolic representation, such as a small kirpan pin or thin steel bracelet. And then they will start to regulate against even that, or worse. They will use it as a yellow star badge to target you in public for arrest, mistreatment and murder. It's happened before. It will happen again. Minorities are never safe except in their OWN country. Genocide is a recurring history in every human government. Beware the warning signs. Do you realize what they are doing? Can you reasonably infer what this is about? It's about destroying Sikh identity! Have they illustrated one single scenario where people were endangered in a public school setting by an amritdharee kakkar wearing Sikh? No. So while you are talking "practicality" you concede on a point of discriminatory and political intimidation, intended to portray Gursikh people with Panj kakkar as dangerous, aka, even terrorists. This is completely in accord with what the Indian government has been doing for the last 20 years or so. THEY WANT TO DISARM AND CONTROL YOU! THEY WANT TO ASSIMILATE YOU! THEY WANT TO ERASE YOUR SIKHI! [%sig%]

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

Maybe · 27 Sep 2005

Harjas Kaur, you just ripped those posts.......just awesome.

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

Scientific · 28 Sep 2005

Take it easy and take a chill pill. You are very highly strung. I would be very concerned about someone like you carrying a three foot sword around lol!

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

kaur_p · 28 Sep 2005

i have studied in that school for many years. Pricipal is sikh himself..don't know under what circumstances they had to make this decision. [%sig%]

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

Scientific · 29 Sep 2005

Always a good idea to know the circumstances instead of crying genocide everytime something like this happens.

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

Harjas Kaur · 29 Sep 2005

[quote]Take it easy and take a chill pill. You are very highly strung. I would be very concerned about someone like you carrying a three foot sword around lol![/quote] I'm sorry you can't accept the reality of genocide . Maybe you should open your eyes veerji, instead of making personal attacks against me, and instead look at the points I raised. They are valid concerns, and they should be concerns you share as a Sikh. If Sikh people protest injustice, we can protect our rights. But if Sikh community "compromises" and "concedes" we will lose every right! [quote]School Principal booked for banning ‘kirpan’ Tribune News Service Ropar, September 27 Following Sikh religious bodies’ ire, the Ropar police today registered a case against the Principal of Shivalik Public School who had banned Sikh students from wearing “kirpan” and “kara”. Besides, Akal Takht Jathedar Joginder Singh Vedanti sought explanation from the school Principal on the matter in the evening. A case of hurting the sentiments of the Sikh community was registered against the Principal in the evening after the Deputy Commissioner, Ropar, who is also the Chairman of the school, directed the SSP to register a case. The issue was discussed at length at a meeting held at Akal Takht in Amritsar when the Jathedar of Takht Sri Kesgrah Sahib, Mr Tarlochan Singh, highlighted the matter. Mr Tarlochan Singh told The Tribune from Amritsar that all the five Jathedars of different Takhts took serious note of the order passed by the Principal, Ms Gurpreet Mathur. The SSP, Mr Surinder Pal Singh, confirmed to The Tribune that a case for hurting the sentiments of the Sikh community under Section 153-A of the IPC had been registered against Ms Gurpreet Mathur, on the recommendations of the Deputy Commissioner, Mr H.I.S. Garewal. The inquiry had been handed over to the DSP, Anandpur Sahib. Meanwhile, Ms Mathur today issued a circular stating that the order had been amended accordingly by adding that except for Amritdhari Sikhs, nobody else was allowed to carry heavy kara and kirpan. She further said: “I apologise if anybody’s religious sentiments were hurt due to the earlier circular.” http://www.tribuneindia.com/2005/20050928/main8.htm[/quote] [%sig%]

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

Harjas Kaur · 29 Sep 2005

[quote]Always a good idea to know the circumstances instead of crying genocide everytime something like this happens.[/quote] Veerji, be reasonable with historical realities. Because genocide is happening even as we speak in some form or another, to people we may not even be aware of. That's how ordinary it is as a human behavior. Until the late 1990's, Punjab was high on the Amnesty International list for oppressive and genocidal responses to suppress the Sikh community. Do you really believe the hatred and prejudice which allowed these events to transpire has disappeared despite utterly no legal redress or accountability? [quote]ETHNOCIDE A contextual examination of some of its referents indicates that the term is often being used to refer to a sub-type of genocide, or to indicate processes that were excluded from inclusion in the 1948 convention on genocide. ...The close relationship between ethnocide and culturecide is evident in Beardsley’s specification that it refers to the “commission of acts of specified sorts with the intention to extinguish utterly or in substantial part, a culture. Among such ethnocidal acts are the deprivation of the opportunity to use a language, practice a religion, create art in customary ways, maintain basic social institutions, preserve memories and traditions, work in cooperation toward social goals.” The connection with genocide is explicitly developed in his contention that the extermination or dispersion of the sole bearers of a culture “is to commit both genocide and ethnocide.” (© Stuart D Stein. To be published in Encyclopedia of Race and Ethnic Studies, edited by Ellis Cashmore, Routledge, 2003) http://www.ess.uwe.ac.uk/genocide/culturecide.htm [/quote] [%sig%]

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

Harjas Kaur · 29 Sep 2005

Not so long ago in Punjab GENOCIDAL POLICIES AGAINST SIKHS IN PUNJAB? THE EVIDENCE IS OVERWHELMING http://www.punjabjustice.org/news/press.htm http://www.punjabjustice.org/india/frameset.htm [%sig%]

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

Scientific · 29 Sep 2005

Apologies for making a personal comment to you. Just trying to ease the tension. I am fully sympathetic of 84 and the atrocities that the Sikh panth suffered. Let me be 100% clear on that firstly. Now the point i was making in this instance is that we dont know the context within which someone made these comments. That was all i meant with my words. There may well have been any number of incidents in the school which led someone to make a knee jerk response like this. Always balance the facts. Look at every angle before jumping to conclusions. Your conclusions of an anti-sikh conspiracy may be correct but not without an interview and some background from the guy who is responsible for ordering the ban. It appears that the principal is a Sikh (not that this makes a huge difference but still....) If we all took a balanced view on events and dealt with the facts instead of getting emotional the world would be a better place. Extrapolating from events and drawing conclusions without the facts is what led to the massacre of thousands of Sikhs in Delhi. Observation: 2 Sikh body guards assasinate hindu prime minister Extrapolation: All sikhs are responsible Action: Kill the Sikhs This is what the world is reduced to with irrational thinking. The implications of such impulsive, sensless actions need not be discussed here since we all know what happened next. Scientific

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

we all got names · 30 Sep 2005

i dont understand why everyone is shocked its happening in punjab alot of things happening in punjab its not shocking expect more

Re: Ban of Kara & Kirpan in Punjab

nobody · 30 Sep 2005

"we all got names"-who are you??? can u email me please?