Sarabloh Bibek - How far to take it - Followup with Bhai Kulbir Singh
Harpreet Singh · 26 Sep 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Ji
Daas wanted to discuss this issue but need an answer to the following question before I can proceed further:
What are the types of Sarabloh Bibek rehat? As far as I remember you posted somewhere in other thread that its two types:
1. Eating out of hands of bibekis only
2. Eating out of hands of amritdharis
Is this correct? Or is there any other version?
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Sarabloh Bibek - How far to take it - Followup with Bhai Kulbir Singh
Kulbir Singh · 26 Sep 2005
Veer Harpreet Singh jeeo,
---------
1. Eating out of hands of bibekis only
2. Eating out of hands of amritdharis
Is this correct? Or is there any other version?
---------
"2" is mandatory. "1" is what most Singhs follow.
"2" means eating from hands of amritdharis only. These amritdharis can be non-bibekis too. This is mandatory bibek.
"1" is eating from those Gursikhs who follow "2" i.e. ones who eat only from amritdharis.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Sarabloh Bibek - How far to take it - Followup with Bhai Kulbir Singh
Harpreet Singh · 26 Sep 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Veerj Kulbir Singh Jio
Thank you very much for your promt reply.
I can now go ahead and discuss this.
I was talking to someone very recently and was told that at a samagam there were two langars. Intersetingly both were sarablohi langars. But the difference was:
1. First one was specifically for only SARABLOHI BIBEKIS preparing for Sarablohi bibekis.
2.BIBEKIS (who keep only from hand of amritdharis but are not strict on sarabloh) for everyone else but cooked in sarabloh utensils.
My question now is "Sarabloh and Bibek - can we separate them out? I mean if someone eats only from hands of amridharis but is not very strict on sarabloh utelsils - Should a sarabloh bibeki not eat from hands of such gursikh?"
Bhuk chuk di khima
Daas
Harpreet Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Sarabloh Bibek - How far to take it - Followup with Bhai Kulbir Singh
Kulbir Singh · 26 Sep 2005
----------
My question now is "Sarabloh and Bibek - can we separate them out? I mean if someone eats only from hands of amridharis but is not very strict on sarabloh utelsils - Should a sarabloh bibeki not eat from hands of such gursikh?"
-----------
If someone wants to keep more rehit what can you tell him but as far as we understand and as far as Singhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee went, it is perfectly fine for a Sarblohi Singh to eat from the hands of a non-sarblohi but Bibeki Singh provided that the food is cooked in Sarbloh.
In other words, if a Bibek Singh who is not a Sarblohi, cooks food in Sarbloh, it is okay for a Sarblohi Singh to eat from him. I know, Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee used to accept such food. We at Tapoban Sahib accept such food.
Baaki Guru Sahib diyaan Guru Sahib hee jaanday hunn
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Sarabloh Bibek - How far to take it - Followup with Bhai Kulbir Singh
Harpreet Singh · 26 Sep 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Veerji
Again thank you for the reply. I also thought the same as yourself and that's what heard all my life from puratan gursikhs.
I think this new trend of only sarablohis cooking for sarablohis in guru ka langar will lead to labelling of langars a lot. Langar should not have divisions. People who want to be so strict that they won't eat from hands of sarablohis only is a new class I never heard before.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Sarabloh Bibek - How far to take it - Followup with Bhai Kulbir Singh
Kulbir Singh · 26 Sep 2005
I totally agree.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Sarabloh Bibek - How far to take it - Followup with Bhai Kulbir Singh
Simran Singh · 26 Sep 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
These practices are reminiscient of Brahminism and the believe that one type of person is inherently better than another to the extent that one will not eat out of the hands of another. This is just wrong. The Gurus preached equality and humbleness and rejected the belief of segregating people and treating different groups differently. Was the grain harvested by Amritdharis? Was the grain packaged by Amritdharis? Why not control the whole process if you are going to makes such a big deal about who prepared the food? Food doesn't become pure just because it is prepared from an Amritdhari. In my opnion, these kind of practices are unnecessary, egotistical, and ultimately lead you away from what matters most: Bhagti.
Let us leave extremism behind us and remember these words of the Guru
Manas Kee Jaat Subhae Ekaye Pehachanabo
Recognize all Humans as Equal
Aval Allahe Noor Upaya Kudrat Ke Subh Bande
God created the world, all humans are of God.
Ek Pitah Ekas Ke Hum barak
There is one God and we are all his children (yes, even non amritdharis)
Bul Chuk Maaf
Age: 16
Gender: male
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Sarabloh Bibek - How far to take it - Followup with Bhai Kulbir Singh
Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 27 Sep 2005
Simran Singh,
----These practices are reminiscient of Brahminism and the believe that one type of person is inherently better than another to the extent that one will not eat out of the hands of another. This is just wrong.----
The practice of Sarbloh bebik has nothing to do with ego. Those that keep it do not think that they are better than those that don’t. The only reason that a bebeki person will not eat from another person’s hand is because that person is not bebeki/amritdhari.
How does this practice have anything to do with Brahminism? We are following guru ji’s hukum and keeping rehit. One can say that you are following the modern Western culture by eating from any random person’s hand.
----The Gurus preached equality and humbleness and rejected the belief of segregating people and treating different groups differently.----
Just because one does not want to eat from another person’s hand, how is that going against guru ji’s teachings? Or how is that group treating others different? Guru ji has told us in bani many times not to eat from manmukhs hands. Should we not listen to guru ji’s hukum?
----Was the grain harvested by Amritdharis? Was the grain packaged by Amritdharis? Why not control the whole process if you are going to makes such a big deal about who prepared the food?----
the grain is a dry substance.
----Food doesn't become pure just because it is prepared from an Amritdhari. In my opnion, these kind of practices are unnecessary, egotistical, and ultimately lead you away from what matters most: Bhagti.-----
You are wrong. What we eat affects us spiritually. How is food that is prepared by an amritdhari person, who follows guru ji’s hukum, and does paath while preparing it not pure? Eating from a Manmukh who does not listen to guru ji’s hukum is not pure and takes one away from Bhagti.
But if you still think that eating from a manmukhs hand is pure and can give us bhagti then let me know. That’s just amazing, I mean then there is no need for us to take amrit if one can be pure and obtain bhagti from eating from a manmukhs hands.
Manmukh Seti Sang Karey, Muh Kalakh Daag Lagaaey
Whosoever associates with a manmukh, blackens and stains his own face.
Choraan, Jaaran, Randiaan, Kuttaneeya Di Baan.
Vedinaa Ki Dosti Vedinaa Ka Khaann
Sifti Saar Naa Jannani, Sada Vasey Shaitaan.
It is the habit of thieves, adulterers, prostitutes, and pimps that they contract friendship with the irreligious or faithless and eat their food; they know not the worth of God's praise and Satan ever abides within them.
Dalrajkaur Khalsa
[%sig%]
Re: Sarabloh Bibek - How far to take it - Followup with Bhai Kulbir Singh
Akali Nihung · 27 Sep 2005
From what I've learnt from the sangat of Gursikhs is that a Gursikh is entitled to refuse seva from someone if he knows that they a not following any of Guru Jee's Hukam. It could be any Hukam wether not giving Daswand, abandoning a kakar, not doing kesi ishnaan, not doing nitnem, not keeping sarbloh bibek etc. However this is not a rule but someting one can exercise.
I am therefore suprised at Kulbir Singh's comments. I would like to ask Kulbir Singh if there any other Hukams of Guru Jee that someone can avoid & you guys will accept their seva. If your answer is no then why the excemption for Sarbloh is this not a Hukam according to your thought.
This thought does not follow what you guys have said before so please clarify if this is a Hukam or if there are such things as an excemption from Hukams.
Please do not reply by saying that Bhai Randhir Singh did this or the other. We should not be following personalities but look at Gurmat & logic and in any case what Bhai Sahib did or didn't will not be a good argument for people outside your organisation. Secondly I've spoken to people in the akj and they say people have misinterpreted Bhai Shaib and even made things up to suit their view, so as Bhai Sahib is not around to ask then we shouldn't base our views on hearsay.