Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

How the 5 are selected...

How the 5 are selected...

Zorawar Singh · 24 Sep 2005

if we look at the thread about women as Punj pyares, it becomes clear that alot of youth do not know how the Punj Pyares are selected. The arguments against bibian doing seva are so sad, I find it hard to believe educated westernised youth can even think of such things and then try and pass them as Gurmat. The 5 selected should always be the 5 most beloved, i.e. the 5 with the highest jeevan, no matter if they are male of female. From an old post: The Punj Pyaaray are selected by the Sangat. The sangat of amritdharis only, gathers before an amrit sinchaar. Only those amritdharis should be present who do not have to get peshed. The Singh sitting at tabiyaah announces that there will be an amrit sinchaar and the Sangat should suggest names for the punj pyaaray. The members of the sangat may then suggest names. If someone has an objection to the name, they may voice their objection as well. Once all names are suggested, those not mentioned are asked to leave the darbar. Those who have committed a bujjer kurehit even in the past and have been forgiven cannot be selected for this seva. Those who were named are to remain and if any of them do not feel they should do seva can give their reasons now. Again, if there are objections they should be made clear at this point because once selection is made, no one (under normal circumstances) should challenge the appointments. Only those people can do seva who have the Nitnem banis memorised and can recite them out loud. Also, this seva is restricted to those who are physically able and are not diseased or missing limbs, etc. Each candidate then rises and matha teks to Guru Sahib and stands with folded hands in front of Guru Sahib. He is asked if he is tyaar-bar-tyaar meaning abstained from 4 kurehits, does 7 nitnem banis, keeps 5 kakaars, gives dasvandh and keeps bibek. If the answer is yes, they are asked follow up questions that the Sangat of candidates may have. The candidate himself may also mention any problem or issue. The measure of chardi kala can only be rehit. We have no kamaiee-meter or anything like this so the only way to judge chardi kala is rehit. The more rehit a Singh keeps, the better and the Singhs with best rehit should be selected for this seva (rehit in my mind includes not just bibek, sarbloh but also things like bani and amritvela). The Sangat then can accept that person into seva. A person may voice his/her concern about doing seva but cannot refuse the sangat's orders to do so. You asked about age: generally speaking those Gursikhs are selected who have been on the Gursikhi path for some time, but this is not a rule. Any Gursikhs can be selected if the Sangat so chooses. Once the Punj Pyaaray are selected, An ardaas for final sudhaiee is done and the Punj Pyaaray are formed. They then can choose sevadars for other duties in the amrit sinchar such as Degh and Naam DriR. Those candidates who want amrit are first brought to the darbar followed then by the peshee candidates. Amrit is administered in Bir Aasan, first to those candidates who will receive for the first time. Bir Asan is left knee on the ground and right knee up. Amrit is adminstered by all five Gursikhs from the original bata. Each Pyaara in turn puts amrit in hands to drink, in eyes and then in kesh. No one pyaara can administer amrit alone or split the original bata into different batas. I've missed a lot of details and have done as brief a summary as possible. I can add other details as required and ask other Gursikhs to also add their input.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

vichar · 24 Sep 2005

zorawar singh -" Also, this seva is restricted to those who are physically able and are not diseased or missing limbs, etc." if a gurmukh singh has part of his finger missing, this does NOT make him physically INcapable of taking part in the ceremony the reason why such a singh canNOT be in the panj, is because his physical form is not the same as bhai dharam singh, bhai daya singh, bhai sahib singh, bhai mokham singh, bhai himmat singh.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

vichar · 24 Sep 2005

zorawar singh- "The more rehit a Singh keeps, the better and the Singhs with best rehit should be selected for this seva (rehit in my mind includes not just bibek, sarbloh but also things like bani and amritvela)." even you have recognised SINGHS make up the panj, as above you refer to singhs only ...................................... why 5 singhs...........u think about that, why did 5 singhs give their head, why were there no singhnees no singhnees were in the panj chosen by dasm patsah, (he chose them because he is the cause of all causes) so thats why 5 pyare are always 5 singhs................simple. TRUTH IS ALWAYS THE TRUTH MANMUKHS TRY AND CHANGE THE TRUTH THROUGH THEIR OWN MANMAT

Re: How the 5 are selected...

... · 24 Sep 2005

Assumption: self-selected Punj I think you are arguing this: That the the first Punj just happened to be males because they stood up. That the chance coincidence that they were males doesn't mean anything because they were self-selected, not selected by Guru ji. For the sake of argument, we will assume it was a totally chance incident which God did not preordain from the beginning of time (or at least from the time that he sent Guru ji to this world) and about which Guru ji didn't know in advance. (Which is a big assumption.) So we assume first 5 were self-selected. But after that, Guru ji had the opportunity to appoint Kaurs. But Guru ji didn't. No distinction was made on former caste/location/color/etc. but a distinction was made on sex. Two theories So we have two theories: one, the theory that has been prevailing in the Panth since its inception that Guru ji has said 5 Singhs are my Roop and are authorized to perform Amrit Sanchar. Two, that Guru ji created generic Khalsas and any Khalsas male or female are able to be a member of Panj. If, for some reason, the divine play ordained for the 10th Master had ended right after taking Amrit from the 5 Piyare, we wouldn't have much source material to test our theories. But we do. In every case of Guru ji appointing anyone to the 5 Piyare, Guru ji only appointed Singhs. At Anandpur (after that eventful) day, at Sabo ki Talwandi (known as Damdama Sahib), at Nanded. Just an example, Guru ji appointed the following 5 Singhs or 5 Piyare that gave Amrit to Baba Banda Singh Bahadur at Nanded: Bhai Daya Singh ji Bhai Dharam Singh ji Bhai Santokh Singh ji Bhai Hari Singh ji Bhai Gurbaksh Singh ji There were a separate set of 5 Singhs or 5 Piyare sent along with Banda Singh Bahadur to Punjab from Hazur Sahib, the leader of whom was Baba Binod Singh ji (who was a descendant of Guru Angad Dev ji). No sisters were among them. Opportunity to appoint women So Guru Sahib didn't appoint any women as Panj. But was there perhaps not an opportunity to do so? There are some posters saying that during Guru ji's time there were no cars, so why drive a car? Well, (ingnoring environmental or other matters) cars are a technology that wasn't not available then, but were women a technology that wasn't available then? (??) Of course not. In trying to reach for some sort of argument, some veers/bhenjis are making some bold assertions: "Well, maybe there weren't any women there." (Leaving aside the fact that, Is a questionable assertion like this supposed to be the foundation of a major change in Panthic rehit) However, just like all of the other settlements created by Guru Sahib (Kartarpur, Goindwal, Amritsar), families lived at Anandpur. Secondly, the invitations for Basakhi 1699 were sent out 1 yr in advance. People reached there with their families. The families of the original Panj were there; they took Amrit afterwards. When Guru Sahib was at Sabo ki Talwandi, times were "normal" again and families were visiting Guru Sahib. Dalla (remember him? the fellow who wanted a pirhi jinna than in Sachkhand, but Guru ji wouldn't give it without Amrit) took Amrit "parivar samet" (with family). There were others too. Guru ji also interacted with Mata Bhag Kaur ji (Amritdhari, Kaur name). She took amrit. I've already asked the question of why Guru ji didn't appoint a single woman as a Panj one of the first posts. I don't think anyone has addressed that. Maybe some think that women were weak then. Even though I think this argument is irreverencing our mothers/sisters of that time, let's accept it. But at least, Mata Bhag Kaur ji (she of the huge kirpans/cannons at Hazur Sahib) would have been fit to be in the Panj? If Guru ji had wanted, His Holiness could have appointed her. But he didn't. (See above on Nanded). So where does that leave theory two? Not in good shape. Theory two has major problems given our source data. All that holds it up is some speculation. But theory one fits perfectly -- i.e., that Guru ji did what Guru ji said. So must we. [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

+_+ · 24 Sep 2005

Kulbir Singh said at khalsa camp that you could do panj di seva if you had commited a bujjar kurehit and then peshed, aslong as it wasnt adultery. Slightly confused. so when your forgiven by the five, your not actually forgiven?

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Zorawar Singh · 25 Sep 2005

The aim of the process of Sodh Sudhian (selection) is to get the 5 most beloved Sikhs from the sangat to do this seva. In this process if a bibi is nominated, then she has never done a kurehit, and she does alot of bani, gives daswand, strict amrit vela, and a very high jeevan, compared to the others, then there is no reason at all for her not to be selected. Then she is the most beloved. Mr Vichaar (because I do not think a bibi would write such things). You are comapring a bibi with disabled. There is nothing wrong with either, but I do not think a bibi can be compared to disabled, but should be compared to males. Gurbani says we are all the same. From the last thread it is clear, the biggest reason many of males cannot accept bibian in Panj, is because the sick minds of some cannot see beyond a bibi periods. It is a natural process, and not a weakness at all, neither does it make the saroop of a bibi incomplete. These are saddest of arguments, the kind muslims use against women. It is offensive when you compare this dinosaur mentality, and try to pass it as Gurmat.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

akjgreat · 25 Sep 2005

vichar sed-" if a gurmukh singh has part of his finger missing, this does NOT make him physically INcapable of taking part in the ceremony the reason why such a singh canNOT be in the panj, is because his physical form is not the same as bhai dharam singh, bhai daya singh, bhai sahib singh, bhai mokham singh, bhai himmat singh." i have to agree, this is not a sex issue, i am not sexist a singh with a small deformity, (eg) missing part of a finger, cannot be in panj, because his form isn't the TRUE FORM of the PANJ PYARE a singhnee does'nt have the form of the original panj, therefore cannot be in panj. its about FORM not SEX if original panj were 5 singhees, then singhs should not be able to be in panj.....because this doesnt reflect the true form of the panj.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Jagjit Singh · 26 Sep 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji kefateh Pyare jio, the form of the original five were 5 jeevan wale souls. Please read Gurbani, the body is just the vessel. So today 5 jeevanwale souls should aslo be selected. If one of them worthy souls has the vessel of a female, then so be it. It is the credit of that soul, that she has achieved so much in her jeevan. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji kefateh

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Legolas · 26 Sep 2005

. . . Excellent post. Makes sense. Again it is not a sexist issue it is one of form. If Guru Sahib Ji wanted to include the form of a female in panj they had ample opportunity to do so, BUT chose not to, that is their parogative and we must abide by it. [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

thekedaar · 26 Sep 2005

Zorawar Singh wrote this above: "The measure of chardi kala can only be rehit. We have no kamaiee-meter or anything like this so the only way to judge chardi kala is rehit. " I disagree with this statement. Rehit in itself is not a measure of Chardikala. A person's Chardikala is measured by their inner spirituality and pyaar for Gursikhi and Waheguru. Rehit is a way in which this pyaar is built and displayed. Rehit also increases discipline to further this Pyaar. Rehit is also important because it is a Hukam of Guru Jee to follow Rehit. But in itself, Rehit does not mean anything. The final product is spirituality. Rehit is a means to reach spirituality. Sometimes you will see people who allegedly follow so much Rehit, do so much Paath, wake up at Amrit Vela, keep Sarbloh Bibek, etc., but it is apparent that they have no spirituality. They are full of Krodh, Hunkaar, Jealousy, Hypocrisy, etc. They have made their Rehit into an empty ritual, whilst still fully absorbed by duality. Indeed, sometimes, the fact that they follow their Rehit is in itself a source of Hunkaar for them - they show it off to the rest of the world!!! Therefore, just to re-iterate - Rehit in itself does not mean you are Chardikala, but is an important part towards becoming Chardikala.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

... · 26 Sep 2005

thekedar, how are you going to measure how much piaar someone has? What if someone is swaying and being "lot-pot" at a ran sabaiee but at home doesn't do a single amrit vela? Appearances can be deceiving. I think a Singh should be selected for seva only after their jeevan has been observed. But the greatest show of piaar for Sikhi is the amount of rehit we keep.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Jasmin · 26 Sep 2005

Dear Zorawar Singh- When you say never done a kurehit, do you mean never in their lives, or never sense becaming Amritdaree?

Re: How the 5 are selected...

RoopKaur · 26 Sep 2005

>Sometimes you will see people who allegedly follow so much Rehit, do so much Paath, wake up at Amrit Vela, keep Sarbloh Bibek, etc., but it is apparent that they have no spirituality. They are full of Krodh, Hunkaar, Jealousy, Hypocrisy, etc. They have made their Rehit into an empty ritual, whilst still fully absorbed by duality. Indeed, sometimes, the fact that they follow their Rehit is in itself a source of Hunkaar for them - they show it off to the rest of the world!!!< The key word in your statement is allegedly, because if someone really does a lot of paath and naam abhyaas, they cannot help it but become pure through the paaras kalaa of naam and bani. During the sodhaee of the punj, I am sure the real rehit of the candidates is what we measure, not what they do allegedly. The only real argument I have seen against women not being in panj is that they did not give their heads when guru ji asked for them. But all the men that are in panj pyarey now did not stand up at that time either, why are they panj pyarey? The bibiaa did not give their heads at that moment, but they do give them now. Also about form. We do not judge the spirituality of the panj by their biological characteristics, if that was the case then we have to have panj that are the same biological make up that the first panj had. If we do not have panj with the same biological make up as the first panj at every amrit sanchaar, then this argument is invalid. For all those who said guru ji never appointed women for panj. This is a generalisation and an assumption, since you have no way of documenting every single amrit sanchaar that went on. The term SIngh, is in many cases used as a collective, for both Singhs and kaurs. It is used to differentiate between the Khalsa of Guru ji, and others. THerefore when someone says the Tapoban Singhs went to India or something, they do not mean that only the male members went, but they refer to the whole group of SInghs and singhneeaa as a collective. Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji said we should get amrit shuck from panj Sikhs, he could have mentioned there that bibiaa cannot do seva, but he did not, he said five SIKHS, I beleive that Kaurs are also SIKHS just like Singhs.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

moorakh · 26 Sep 2005

if it about form, pyareo, then why not select people with the same skin colour, same hair colour, same weight, same height, and same body measurements as the original punj pyare? you MUST MATCH THE FORM !!!!

Re: How the 5 are selected...

... · 26 Sep 2005

Jasmin, If someone has committe a kurehit before becoming amritdhari that is forgotten. Bujjer Kurehits only apply to amritdharis. So if someone was a meat eating smoking mona who slept around, if s/he became a chardi kala Gursikh, their past would not refeclt on them at all and they could do seva.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Legolas · 27 Sep 2005

moorakh , Why don't you go ask Guru gobind singh Ji about that ? Guru Ji chose Singhs on ALL the occasions, why don't you ask Guru Ji if He selected the same skin colour, hair colour, weight, height. Mock, but you are mocking Guru's maryadha.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Reply · 27 Sep 2005

Zorawar Singh ji, Although initially I thought it may be presumputous of you to assume that "alot of youth do not know how the Punj Pyares are selected", but maybe some don't know, so it's good you posted this. Anyway, the method of selection of Panj Piyare is the method used by Guru Govind Singh ji: the fittest, most dedicated Singhs are appointed for the duty (as reflected in your post above). [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Reply · 27 Sep 2005

>The only real argument I have seen against women not being in panj is that they did not give their heads when guru ji asked for them. Roop Kaur ji, The misconception by Bibi-Punj veers/bhenjis that the 5-Singh position is based solely on the 5 Piyare of 1699 has been addressed. It starts with "Assumption: self-selected Punj". [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Reply · 27 Sep 2005

Let us say that Guru Govind Singh ji had appointed Bibis in the Panj Piyare (maybe not even in 1699, but later). In that case, Bibian in the Panj would have been a well-established Panthic maryada which no one could dare change. And, if we happened to go to some country to preach Sikhism and the residents said that they will accept it as long as Bibian are not in the Panj, we would have to stand our ground, because numbers are not more important to us than our Guru ji. (To accept that Guru ji made a mistake would be unacceptable.) But similarly, today, if some people find the hukum (command) of 5 Singhs not in accord with their feminist beliefs, there is nothing we can do about it. Under no circumstances can we admit that Guru ji was too scared to appoint Bibis in the Panj lest His Holiness lose his followers. [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Reply · 27 Sep 2005

>Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji said we should get amrit shuck from panj Sikhs Bhenji, where are you getting this? Are you reading the English translation of What is Amrit? Here is the real "What is Amrit" (Amri ki hai): ------- (5) The Gurmat Method of Giving Amrit Bhai Sahib- It is a matter of great regret and surpise that you have personally partook of Amrit and have witnessed ceremonies for giving Amrit many times, you you have not understood the secrets of the Gurmat method of giving Amrit. In order to give Gurmat Amrit, the following equipment and methods are used: 1. In the presence of Guru Granth Sahib, at least six Gurmukh Singhs are required, for whom it is necessary to be practitioners of Nam, gourmets of the Nam, lovers of Gurbani, Nitnemi, and firmness in Gurmat lifestyle. There should not be even one transgressor (kurehitia) among them. There should not even be an ang-heen (without ang) among them. (Note: the word used in the original Punjabi is "Singh") Bhai Randhir Singh ji, "What is Amrit" in "Gurmat Vichar", pp. 34 ------- "Don't make Sikhi conform to you; conform yourself to Sikhi" - A frequent poster [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Reply · 27 Sep 2005

>These people are Sick! Some people think unisexualism is sick. Western khul-khel is sick. And that includes Bhai Randhir Singh ji. (Read Singhan da Panth Nirala.) He was probably a Taksali sicko too. Some people think the unisexualism whereby people would go around giving bear hugs to women not their wife ("Khalsa has no gender") is sick. I don't know how old you are, but the just the idea of you sitting gode-to-gode with and modhe-to-modhe (shoulder-to-shoulder) with a young female is positively revolting. (Nothing personal against you specifically, just any man.) [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Reply · 27 Sep 2005

>For all those who said guru ji never appointed women for panj. This is a generalisation and an assumption, since you have no way of documenting every single amrit sanchaar that went on. Roop Kaur ji, So, your argument is that if we don't have records for every amrit sanchar since 1699, anybody can propose any changes? Let's say that someone says we start using copper bowls instead of Sarb Loh (iron). Could you tell us how you would refute that? Do you have records handy of every amrit sanchar since 1699 to show that sarb loh was used every time? If not, could you still say that use of sarb loh (and not any other material) is a must? "Don't make Sikhi conform to you; conform yourself to Sikhi" - A frequent poster [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Reply · 27 Sep 2005

>From the last thread it is clear, the biggest reason many of males cannot accept bibian in Panj, is because the sick minds of some cannot see beyond a bibi periods. Zorawar Singh ji, Again, hukum is hukum. The hukum for taking amrit from 5 Singhs is a valid command from Guru Govind Singh ji and every one must obey. It is a separate matter that we come up for different reasons why Guru ji gave such and such of a command. E.g., on the matter of kes, in no way is the Panth in agreement on the reason for hair, but no one has the right to question the hukum. Giving more detail: Gurdarshan Singh of Washington DC (he's the author of Sikh Faith, a question and answer book) vehemently disagrees with the standard reasons for kes (that it's for spirituality, for accord with nature, for bravery). Refuting all these reasons, he says the real reason is just because it is Guru ji's hukum. The same may be said for the hukum to take amrit from 5 Singhs. The reasons we come up with are possibly our own manmat (and possibly not), but hukum still stands. [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Reply · 27 Sep 2005

Author: Reply >sant samaj/taksal You seem to be stuck in a groupism mode, Zoravar Singh ji. I think you may be laboring under the thought that the AKJ stands for and has always stood for and has always included Bibis in the Panj. I am surmising the reason for this is you and some others have become "westernized" as you mentioned on another thread. While the commands and guidance of only Guru Govind Singh ji and no one else matter in the end, just to dispell this notion for other readers: [u]The Olden Maryada of the Akhand Kirtani Jatha[/u] "As a result of the company of Mahapurkhs, this humble servant has certain memory that in this Jatha, the Prasad-distributing Singh used to be completely ready (tiar-bar-tiar), and they only used to take water and clean the hands of those completely ready Singhs whose Singhnis were adopters of the keski rehit, then used to have the prasad of the Panj Piyare only to them and those Singhs whose Singhnis were keski-less did not get the the portion for the Panj Piyare. Neither did such Singhs ever take the prasad of the Panj Piyare." page 175, Son chiri chari gain, Bhai Jodh Singh (Note: the word used in the original Punjabi is "Singh") [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

thekedaar · 27 Sep 2005

i just want to repeat that i agree with "..." that an individual's Jeevan is the most important element as to whether they should do seva in the Punj. Also, Rehit is an important way of displaying this - but Rehit must be seen in the overall character or personality of that person. A strong Rehit is necessary for a Jeevan Wala GurSikh but it is not sufficient - I just disagreed with Zorawar Singh's assertive statement that Rehit is singularly the most important factor. Roop Kaur, I used the word "allegedly" because to Joe Public, who comes across these apparently Chardikala Sikhs, their Rehit would make them seem as if they had a great Jeevan. People would see or know of them getting up at Amrit Vela, keeping Sarabloh Bibek, reading loads of Bani, seeing them Jap Naam with a Maala in their hand all the time, etc. But after spending some time with them, one would realise that this is just an external front. Reading Bani, waking up at Amritvela and keeping Bibeki Rehit is just an external ritual to gain flavour in a "religious" society. I know of people like this - so I am speaking from experience. Average Joe thinks they are so great, but really they are so hypocritical, slanderous, jealous and egotistical, that it makes you realise their Rehit is just a sham, because they haven't adopted the true love, compassion and mercy that Guru Jee teaches us through Gurbani. By the way, this is not a disrespect to those Singhs that do keep Rehit and do adopt the true values of the Guru - these are the really amazing GurSikhs. But I just wanted to point out that the overall Jeevan is the most important factor - this does include their Rehit, but Rehit in itself is not sufficient, as Zorawar Singh asserted above.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Reply · 27 Sep 2005

Some people reading have various levels of historical awareness, so I wanted to spell this out, just in case someone doesn't know: There were one set of Panj Piyare selected or self-selected in 1699. These were Bhai Daya Singh ji Bhai Dharam Singh ji Bhai Mohkam Singh ji Bhai Himmat Singh ji Bhai Sahib Singh ji (Interestingly, they had come to the sharn of Guru Govind Singh ji at Anandpur long before 1699 and most of them had descendants that lived to the 20th century.) After 1699, some of them attained martyrdom and others were appointed in their place as necessary. For example, at Nanded, the following Singhs prepared amrit for Madho Das (who became Banda Bahadur): Bhai Daya Singh ji Bhai Dharam Singh ji Bhai Santokh Singh ji Bhai Hari Singh ji Bhai Gurbaksh Singh ji The Panj Piyare that were sent to Punjab from Nanded (Hazur Sahib) with Banda Bahadur were: Bhai Binod Singh ji Bhai Kahan Singh (son of Bhai Binod Singh) Bhai Baaj Singh ji Bhai Daya Singh ji (not the 1699 Bhai Sahib) Bhai Ram Singh (Brother of Bhai Baaj Singh) In no case was a sister selected, even though spiritually and physically advanced women such as Mata Bhag Kaur ji were available from Sabo ki Talwandi to Nanded. How do we know that its supposed to be 5 Singhs in the Panj? From the same place we know about an Amrit Sanchar at all or that there are supposed to be 5 and not 7 or 3. [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

RoopKaur · 27 Sep 2005

>Let us say that Guru Govind Singh ji had appointed Bibis in the Panj Piyare (maybe not even in 1699, but later). In that case, Bibian in the Panj would have been a well-established Panthic maryada which no one could dare change. And, if we happened to go to some country to preach Sikhism and the residents said that they will accept it as long as Bibian are not in the Panj, we would have to stand our ground, because numbers are not more important to us than our Guru ji. (To accept that Guru ji made a mistake would be unacceptable.)< This is not a true statement. Guru ji had appointed women to lead sangat when they established the manji system, but how many women do you see leading sangat today? Guru had required women to wear a keski, just like singhs, how many women do you see wearing Keskieaa. I would argue that most of the fundamental things in our panth, Eg. Laridaar Saroop, Panj Kakaars, Naam Driraaee, Sarbloh Bibek etc, are not well esablished, but infact the opposite has happened. So this argument does not hold true.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

RoopKaur · 27 Sep 2005

>It starts with "Assumption: self-selected Punj".< THis is a philosophical argument, and going by your reasoning, we can say that people like Hitler and Indira Gandhi are ok because if we say they were wrong, that means we are assuming that GUru ji made a mistake when he let that happen. It is not about guru ji making mistakes or not, because we all know and agree that guru ji is abhul. It is about looking at the bigger picture, and the bigger picture is that the panj were able to pass the test not becuase they were males, but because of their spiritual level or their avastha.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

RoopKaur · 27 Sep 2005

>So, your argument is that if we don't have records for every amrit sanchar since 1699, anybody can propose any changes? Let's say that someone says we start using copper bowls instead of Sarb Loh (iron). Could you tell us how you would refute that? Do you have records handy of every amrit sanchar since 1699 to show that sarb loh was used every time? If not, could you still say that use of sarb loh (and not any other material) is a must?< The usage of sarbloh is what makes it amrit, it is one of the ingredients. Yet for the panj pyarey it is not their biological make up that affects the amrit, but their avastha and kamaee. If it were their biological make up, then we would have to get panj with the same biological make up as the first panj, because the change would make a difference in panj. But since we do not, we know that is is not the biology but the avastha that we should be concerned with.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

RoopKaur · 27 Sep 2005

>page 175, Son chiri chari gain, Bhai Jodh Singh (Note: the word used in the original Punjabi is "Singh") I would like to bring to your attention, that the problem of being keski less is mostly a singhnee problem because they have come under the influence of the opppressive indian and western culture. It would not make sense to tell singhneea that they could only have deg if their SIngh adopted the keski rehit because all Singhs already adopt the keski rehit. Also, in households, it was the singhnee that did not cooking, so there was also a question of bibek involved. A rehitvaan singhnee would not have to worry about this since she would be doing the cooking, but if a SInghs singhnee did not wear keski and did cooking, it would no longer be considered bibeki because that singhnee displays a dhill.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

vichar · 27 Sep 2005

"The aim of the process of Sodh Sudhian (selection) is to get the 5 most beloved Sikhs from the sangat to do this seva" if there was a bram gyani singh whos naam was 24/7, but has part of his lilttle toe missing, he cannot be in panj can you explain this???? "You are comapring a bibi with disabled. There is nothing wrong with either, but I do not think a bibi can be compared to disabled" i didnt say theres anything WRONG, all i said is neither can do panj seva, this is just guru' hukam. moorakh- "if it about form, pyareo, then why not select people with the same skin colour, same hair colour, same weight, same height, and same body measurements as the original punj pyare? you MUST MATCH THE FORM !!!!" the form must be that originally designed by god, 5 healthy singhs.......you are digging youreself in a hole by speaking utter rubbish and trying to complicate/twist what i have said. a singh without missing limb has a true form, just like those in original panj. form of one vessel with angh missing isn't true, therefore cant be in panj. if you cannot see the difference between s singh with light skin, a singh with dark skin, and a singh without a hand....theres no point me arguing with you. [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

vichar · 27 Sep 2005

roop kaur - "Guru ji had appointed women to lead sangat when they established the manji system, but how many women do you see leading sangat today? Guru had required women to wear a keski, just like singhs, how many women do you see wearing Keskieaa. I would argue that most of the fundamental things in our panth, Eg. Laridaar Saroop, Panj Kakaars, Naam Driraaee, Sarbloh Bibek etc, are not well esablished" women may have lead sanghat, but they have never been put in panj. yes youre right, many things have been forgotton like sarbloh bibek, panj kakkar(keski), nam drir you think, who has reminded us of what guru gobind singh taught the khalsa? let me tell you, Bhai Randhir Singh, and you know what bhai sahib said in his book..............5 pyare are made of 5 SINGHS " In the presence of Guru Granth Sahib, at least six Gurmukh Singhs are required"

Re: How the 5 are selected...

akjgreat · 27 Sep 2005

roop kaur, you have resulted to talking nonsense, read reply jis post, with an open frame of mind think of right and wrong, think of gurmat, not manmat.....ignore what youre mind says its driven by 5 thieves you are speaking false, youre arguments are false, and you are arguing for the sake of arguing

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Zorawar Singh · 27 Sep 2005

I do not want to burst "reply" bubble, as he took a number of posts to write what he could have written in one. But when the word Singh used in many texts, it actualy refers to ALL GURSIKHS. it is similar to the way we may use he in most writing. The assumption is based on the fact that the reader understands it is for both genders. So when Bhai Sahib wrote Singhan da Panth Narala, that panth contains both genders not just males. Most sensible would assume that is obvious! Its distinctness is with both Singhs and singhnis, as all rules apply to both. Clearly the fact is the anti-bibi camp does not have a leg to stand on. It has used the maryada argument and has ripped apart, it has used re-inactment argument and has been ripped again, it has used the period argument, and just shown how sick it is, and now it is just clutching at straws.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Legolas · 28 Sep 2005

Actually Zorawar Singh, you have not ripped anything, rather you are just pandering to the politically correct, "Reply" has made some excellent points and totally hold up - Mess with Guru Sahib Ji's maryadha at your peril ! [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

. · 28 Sep 2005

twisting bhai sahibs words is PAAP "In the presence of Guru Granth Sahib, at least six Gurmukh Singhs are required" zorawar singh this shows youre intelligence, and is a perfect example of manmat - twisting things to fit youre own manmat. a family maember of mine took amrit in india, not long after bhai sahib, babu mal singh was in panj pyare, and funnily enough there were NO SINGHNEES.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Kulbir Singh · 28 Sep 2005

-------- Kulbir Singh said at khalsa camp that you could do panj di seva if you had commited a bujjar kurehit and then peshed, aslong as it wasnt adultery. -------- I never said this. My views are - if one commits any bajjar kurehit, one cannot do sewa in Panj again. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: How the 5 are selected...

vivek · 28 Sep 2005

so what are the facts supporting bibia in panj? i havnt come across any yet one sujjestion is all any khalsa individual can take part in panj seva however this sujjestion has already been contradicted, as a gurmukh singh with part of a limb missing cannot do seva even if deformity is so small that it will not physically cause a problem in the amrit sanchar. so are theyre any more points in support of bibia in panj? well sikhi says men and women are equal, which i agree with, but does this mean a man should be able to do everything a women can and vice versa? the answer is no, not allowing women in panj doesnt make them unequal....because there is a reason, in 1699 no women gave their heads IF in 1699 bibia gave their heads then bibia should be allowed in panj, however this didnt happen i agree with a point above, if in 1699 5 singhnees gave their heads, then panj should always be made of women. there are other points, like is god unfair for putting all 10 gurus in male bodies? would you say god has treated women unfairly by doing such an act? what is inequality? for inequality between men and women, one sex must be disadvantaged (making the situation unfair) not allowing bibia in panj does not disadvantage women in anyway, its modern thinking which sujjest women should be able to do everything men can, and if they cant its sexist this is why divorce rates are so high, and married couple are always fighting, and never happy sikhi says men and women are equal, neither are in situations where one sex is disadvanted from the other yes in sggsji, it highlights the similarities in the relationship between bhagat - god and wife and husband. western thinking sujjests cooking is unfair, man should cook for wife aswell. sikhi says cooking is langhar seva, wife serving gurmukh husband is very fruitful, because 1) its seva 2) its following gurus instructions, therefore please guru and wife will benefit more than husband benefits from not cooking read ranggle sajjan, you will see perfect relation between wife and husband which is EQUAL, but note, men and women have different roles......... having different roles doesnt make either sex unequal as westerners sujjest.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Singh · 29 Sep 2005

the whole restriction on bibian is completely baseless. Write as many long posts with the same repetitive tripe. The bottom line is you have not one line in Gurbani to back up your views. Once again men deciding on what women can and cannot do, according to mens own insecurities...

Re: How the 5 are selected...

tarrandeep kaur · 29 Sep 2005

mmmmmmmmmmm <<<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> mmmmmmm im a singhni, and im not insecure lol. yes i blieve men and women are equal but we have differnet roles. i dont think its right for women to serve in the panj, it is not the true form. all of the gurus wer male, the original panj piayre selected by guru gobind singh jee we rall singhs. i agree with 'reply' and 'viveks' points completely. its funny tht the only singhni sayin tht bibian shud b in the panj is roop kaur penji. wer are all the other singhneea? why rnt they postin. it seems tht all the singhs r stikin up for the bibia lol. wats the point if most of the singhneea dnt have a problem wiv it. any1 look how many posts people r postin, and no ones gettin anywer lol. we all are stikin 2 our own views. therfore lets jus leave it at tht. (im bein a hypocrit cos im wastin tym postin this lol) and lets concentrate on more important things :-) bhul chuk maaf karna vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Harjinder Singh · 29 Sep 2005

Why the singnees mainly associated with AKJ feel or believe that singhnees can be in Punj. Another Answer in addition to those already mentioned is that It is manily the AKJ these days where the Rehat for the Singhs and Singhnees is exactly the same and thats why both feel that they can fulfill the following Gurwak Khalsa Mero Roop Hai Khas Khalsey Mai Ho Karo Niwas Where as it is mostly the Singhnees other than those associated with AKJ who do not believe Dastar or Keski to be a mendatory rehit for the Singhnees contrary to All the Singhs from all Jathebandis believe Keski a mendatory rehit for the Singhs. Without Keski or Dastar as mendatory rehat, no singhnee can consider/believe herself to be roop of Guru Sahib where as all the singhnees, who find no difference in the rehat they have to keep and the rehai that Singhs have to keep, firmly believe that singhnees can also be Khas roop of Guru Sahib and hence qualify for the Punj. Guru sahib has entrusted his Khalsa to the following two Bani and Bana Our Bani is one ( ie One Guru Guru Granth sahib Ji) and Our Bana is also one ( to become physical roop of Guru Sahib or Punj) Bani is what we have to be from inside Bana is what we have to be from outside Let all our mothers/sisters/daughters be encouraged to have what they deserve not less than any other sikh of Guru Sahib for the chardikala of Guru Khalsa Panth. [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

vivek · 29 Sep 2005

singh - "the whole restriction on bibian is completely baseless. Write as many long posts with the same repetitive tripe. The bottom line is you have not one line in Gurbani to back up your views. Once again men deciding on what women can and cannot do, according to mens own insecurities" there are valid points which support singhneaa not being allowed in panj, however i have not read any points which are in favour of singhnees in panj therefore i can say the argument for bibian in panj is baseless. singh-"The bottom line is you have not one line in Gurbani to back up your views." singh did you not know siri guru granth sahib was written before panj pyare / start of khalsa?? there isnt anything in siri guru granth sahib which says anything about selection of panj, nor indeed is there any line which sujjest bibia should be allowed to be in panj. please give me a simple list of points which support bibia being in panj.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

vivek · 29 Sep 2005

harjindersingh"Why the singnees mainly associated with AKJ feel or believe that singhnees can be in Punj." no akj singhnee believes bibia shud be in panj, because bhai randhir singh wrote in his book panj pyare are made up of 5 gurmikh SINGHS. if one doesnt accept what bhai sahib writes, technically you cannot call youreself akj, because bhai sahib started akj, and reminded us of the rehit left by dasm patsah.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Singh · 30 Sep 2005

Vivek or Mr Taxmen, it has already been pointed out when Bhai Sahib mentioned Singhs, it actually refreed to all khalsa. see post below. Clearly you did read but in your sharatee manner you choose to ignore it. Naughty, Naughty!! So will sant samaj or taksal present even one Gurbani tuk that shows bibian are unfit to do seva????? Author: Zorawar Singh Date: 09-27-05 14:45 I do not want to burst "reply" bubble, as he took a number of posts to write what he could have written in one. But when the word Singh used in many texts, it actualy refers to ALL GURSIKHS. it is similar to the way we may use he in most writing. The assumption is based on the fact that the reader understands it is for both genders. So when Bhai Sahib wrote Singhan da Panth Narala, that panth contains both genders not just males. Most sensible would assume that is obvious! Its distinctness is with both Singhs and singhnis, as all rules apply to both. Clearly the fact is the anti-bibi camp does not have a leg to stand on. It has used the maryada argument and has ripped apart, it has used re-inactment argument and has been ripped again, it has used the period argument, and just shown how sick it is, and now it is just clutching at straws.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

we all got names · 30 Sep 2005

1699 till now haha look how long its been and it comes up now and we have a fine example leading it baba jagir kaur whats wrong with u people okay u know i'm all for equal rights i have nothing againts women but if u feminists really wanna take things up how about asking guru ji why he only came in a man's form why not at least one women missionaries want to turn sikhi into a science too many doubts to make it appeal to the scientific mind doubting baba deep singh ji shaheedi too doubt all u want

Re: How the 5 are selected...

vichar · 30 Sep 2005

you still have not given one good reason to support women in panj all you have done is try and interpret what bhai sahib said in a different way, if youre interpretation of bhai sahibs quote is write, why is it that akj never has, and still doesnt select bibia for panj seva? by there way where is the following quote from "Singhan da Panth Narala"? and how do you know the meaning is not literal? what if the panth is supposed to be run by singhs? to me to try and corrupt the following quote is maha paap........ "In the presence of Guru Granth Sahib, at least six Gurmukh Singhs are required, for whom it is necessary to be practitioners of Nam" look at the quote, and tell me, how you can use it to support bibia in panj> bibia arent mentioned!

Re: How the 5 are selected...

akjgreat · 30 Sep 2005

"In the presence of Guru Granth Sahib, at least six Gurmukh Singhs are required, for whom it is necessary to be practitioners of Nam" the quote shud be taken literally as far as i know no women were ever in panj in akj amrit sanchars of old. i can ask my relative who spent time with bhai sahib just to confirm, if you want.....but i alredy no the anwer because hes arranged amrit sanchars in the past and only singhs were in panj.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Kulbir Singh · 30 Sep 2005

Read Gurmat Bibek by Bhai Sahib. In that book, there is an article on how langar should be according to Gurmat. Bhai Sahib only mentions Singhs in that langar and not Bibiyaan. Are we to assume that according to Bhai Sahib only Singhs can do sewa in langar? The word "Singhs" when used as a generic term refers to both males and females. As for doing sewa in Punj, a Bibi did do sewa in punj at the time of Bhai Sahib. Bhai Sahib Dalip Singh, who was very close to Bhai Sahib and was a jyot-vigaasi Singh narrated this story about how once a Bibi did do sewa in Punj Pyaray. The story goes as follows: A Bibi wanted to chhak amrit but her husband was not ready yet. When she could not persuade her husband, he went for amrit alone. First, she was refused amrit but after viewing her bairaag, and her commitment to do anything to receive amrit, she was blessed with amrit on the condition that she would not keep physical relationship with her husband untill he took amrit. Amrit Sinchaar was done in pure chardi kala. Giani Dalip Singh was in punj pyaray. After the samagam, after she left the samagam place, she just sat on the side of a small river. Her husband looking for her came to get her. She was in pure bairaag at that time and told her husband that she had no place to go now, since he (her husband) was not an amritdhari. When her husband could not persuade her to go home, he agreed to chhak amrit. They hurriedly went back to the samagam place and requested Singhs to conduct another amrit sinchaar for the husband of that bibi. They found out that one of the Singhs who had done sewa in Punj previously was gone by then. The Singhs then took that bibi in punj pyaray and this way her husband got amrit. This story is true and can be confirmed from any puratan Singh alive today. Singhs from Bhai Sahib narrated this story to us. I personally am of the opinion that Bibiyaan can do sewa in Punj. Baaki Guru Sahib diyaan Guru Sahib jaanday hunn. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Singh22 · 30 Sep 2005

so baba deep singh shaheedi is the latest reason why bibian cannot do seva....!!****!

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Reply · 30 Sep 2005

I just wanted to state that "Singhan da Panth Nirala" is being taken far out of context. I am guessing that neither dear veer Zorawar Singh ji and piare vichar ji have read "Singhan da Panth Nirala". Actually, that article has almost nothing to do with the title given to it. My point regarding it was just that the content of it would show Bhai Randhir Singh ji as having the same views as the "Taksali sickos". The reason I asked Zorawar Singh veerji to read it is that if he had read it (and the rest of Bhai Randhir Singh ji's works), I don't think he would be castigating Taksal and Sant Smaj when, in fact, most of Bhai Randhir Singh ji's views line up quite well with Taksal/Sant Smaj whereas they greatly contrast with Missionary/SGPC thinking. Either that or he would have to say that Bhai Randir Singh ji is also "sick" and doesn't have the right to comment on any matter of maryada/rehit. Zorawar Singh ji- Although many weaknesses have come into the AKJ (as also Taksal and others), do you really think that Bibi-in-Punj is a bona fide, established AKJ position from the beginning which has been practiced, preached, and continued up till now? Or is it something that you think should be the position? [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Singh · 30 Sep 2005

reply, i suggest you read bhai kulbir singh ji post. Then before you tell others to read, read yourself!

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Admin · 30 Sep 2005

Message for "Vivek": Vivek, if you have specific questions like the ones you raised in the post (that we have not approved for going off topic), please contact us at [address removed]. We assure you that you have a misunderstanding about the whole issue. We will be glad to address your questions, if you decide to email us. Admin.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Zorawar Singh · 01 Oct 2005

I think these threads should now be closed as per the Akal thakht decision to stop discussion on the matter. I personally disagree with it, because it is just sweeping everything under the carpet, and the report will never actually appear, just like the dasam granth report has never appeared. Once again the sant samaj has helped the RSS stop something positive happening in Sikhi.

Re: How the 5 are selected...

amarjeet singh · 01 Oct 2005

bhai kulbir singh i am under the impression that the stroy you have realeted to us is false as are the ones about bhai sahib randhir singh mentioning anything about bindian in in his book. also if singh is a general term then how come when bhai sahib says taht the singhs must remove their pyjama in the amrit sanchaar singhnia keep their pyjama on? when bhai sahib said "In the presence of Guru Granth Sahib, at least six Gurmukh Singhs are required, for whom it is necessary to be practitioners of Nam" that is what he meant, it was a specific comment not a general phrase

Re: How the 5 are selected...

vichar · 01 Oct 2005

but i must say with all evidence, reading his books i have to say youre story is false here is a phrase "singha da panth nirala" it is a "phrase", therefore its generic here is a statement "In the presence of Guru Granth Sahib, at least six Gurmukh Singhs are required, for whom it is necessary to be practitioners of Nam" a statement is different from a phrase, meaning of a phrase depends on context a statement is literal/factual

Re: How the 5 are selected...

Reply · 01 Oct 2005

Zorawar Singh ji, Although I had heard about the Akal Takhat commission, I hadn't heard for a call to suspend (open) discussion. Where did you read this? Anyway, if this is the case, like you I think further discussion/clarification would have been useful, but I will have to support the hukum. With Gursikh love to you and all the others who participated on both sides, Reply [%sig%]

Re: How the 5 are selected...

dhoor singh · 01 Oct 2005

if some veers thinks that in 1699 Tha fives were male and they were not angheen thats why fives should be only singh for always and not angheen do we need to find panj from the same proffesion same casts and same regions and same names And whole bani and rehat namays r only for males because it only says sant not santni sikh not sikhni gurmukh not gurmukhni bhagat not bhagatni does that means female r free to do what ever they wants and there is no rehat for them if its for both of them then why panj piyaray means only panj males? rehni

Re: How the 5 are selected...

akjgreat · 02 Oct 2005

singhan da panth nirala is a PHRASE therefor its generic and meaning depends on context In the presence of Guru Granth Sahib, at least six Gurmukh Singhs are required, for whom it is necessary to be practitioners of Nam - this is a STATEMENT theres a difference, statements are factual/literal a phrase is not.