Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

wife amd husband

wife amd husband

modernist · 23 Sep 2005

why does guru ji in bani make reference to a woman(human) serving her husband(god)? why would he choose to describe a woman who treats her husband with utmost respect and devotion as an example of a what wife/husband should, but as well as a soul/god relationship should be? im not saying think your husband as god, but in the way guru ji explains, should a woman treat her dunyavi teh way guru ji describes? it is referred countless times in gurbani and it makes me wonder what gurus perception on a wife/woman is...... i mean, its written there as an example/metaphor, but on the worldy level, should we do that as well?

Re: wife amd husband

Reply · 23 Sep 2005

modernist ji, You just picked up on what the problem that feminists are going to have with Gurbani in the near future. There was a thread on this asking if Gurbani is going to be changed because of the feminists. () I answered that it already is being changed (in translations). Western feminists are already calling Gurbani sexist. (I will post excerpts later if I can.) Our desi feminists should take heed and drop the feminist rhetoric before they get caught between a rock and a hard place. [%sig%]

Re: wife amd husband

Reply · 23 Sep 2005

By the way if a wife treated her husband as God and her husband treated her as the Guru treats his Sikh (with full love), that would be a kind of heaven. But we seem to have fallen into a trap where women and men are fighting all the time, like Guru ji says Manmukhs do. [%sig%]

Re: wife amd husband

akjgreat · 23 Sep 2005

read ranggle sajjan, yes GURbani is ALLways TRUE, wife-husband relationship, is like bhagat-god relationship, thats why its used as a simarly nowadays few practice such a relationship, thats why everyone fights and divorces.

Re: wife amd husband

1 · 23 Sep 2005

the man-wife relationship is a microcosm of the soul-god relationship. the man provides for his wife in the worldly relationship, where she should serve him. this however will be disputed, but the woman should do what she has to do, not worry about the husband... this in turn will be noticed on the higher leved - god. he will see this devotion and service, and the wife will be in turn rewarded. there is an excellent example of this with fareed ji meeting the woman who received spiritual powers strictly on the seva of her husband. this is a note to all the women out there who are a little bit too modernized. serve your husband, expect the most from waheguru, he sees all.

Re: wife amd husband

vivek · 23 Sep 2005

absolutly, service of husband will please guru, thus the wife will be paid back in someway or other... dont say its not fair that wife must serve husband not viceversa, because she will benefit from it.

Re: wife amd husband

tarrandeep kaur · 24 Sep 2005

:-) i agree with vivek (isher singh) and 'l'

Re: wife amd husband

Jaspal Kaur · 24 Sep 2005

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji Hanji, Bibi Rajni Ji is one fine example of how she through devotion towards Sachepatsha excepted her Leprosy husband, when her father, who was a king, one day asked her, who do you think is most worthy. She replied to god who worships most and in anger her father (the king) said that you will be left with which ever male is seen first on the streets. She placed him in a large round basket and tied a rope or cloth to it, with which she would be able to pull him along as well. Eventually at one point she came across a pond asked her husband to wait there untill she comes back. In the mean time her husband saw an astonishing miracle. Black Crows would dive in the pond and come out white. He draged himself to the pond and let himself fall in leaving his little finger out. When he came out he was cured and looked like a prince. On return of Bibi Rajni ji she saw the basket near the pond and asked where her husband is. He replied that i am your husband, she did not believe him. He showed is little finger and dipped it in the pond and showed her the miracle as well. That pond has now become the sarovar at amritsar. As far as i remember that Guru Nanak Dev ji use to sit near by there and do simran. Please correct me if i am wrong its been years since i heard this sakhi only one or twice. Also if you have read the thread about Mata kartar kaur Bhai Randhir Singh Ji's wife you can also see,how much a woman devoted to Guru Ji will be devoted to her husband and other relations. Quite a while ago i remember watching a programme on an asian channel, where someone visited a true disciple of god. In one or two days he could not help asking the disciple, how there is so much piece and tranquility in your house. I have visited other couple and not most of them are like you two. He did not reply straight away. The following day he asked his wife to bring out a lamp during the day so that he could see properly, where as the sun was shining brightly. So she did. There were a few other things like that which he asked her to do and she did. The visitor was shocked at the disciple that he is asking her to do unusual things. Upon him asking that the disciple replied that, thats your answer to how there is so much piece in the household because we dont argue on each others points instead have respect for one another. Some years later as the wife of the disciple fell ill and was taking her last breaths she asked her husban that every time i served you food why did you ask for another seprate bowl of water to be put at the side. He replied that you would put so much effort into preparing and serving that food to me, so if i had dropped any on the ground i would be able to wash it and eat it rather than it going to waste. I have noticed that alot of the time we all tend to bicker on worldly things when we are astray from Guru ji. vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji

Re: wife amd husband

agreer · 24 Sep 2005

any bibian have any comments to add?

Re: wife amd husband

Singh · 24 Sep 2005

lavan say two bodies and one soul. Therefore both should serve each other. That is a marriage

Re: wife amd husband

Jaspal Kaur · 24 Sep 2005

Your second sakhi is a beautiful summation of the total love and respect that husband and wife should have for each other. We don't want to listen to such sahkis anymore and are paying for it with the hells that the homes of many in our community have become.

Re: wife amd husband

Singhni Miri Piri · 04 Nov 2005

WaheguruJiKaKhalsaWaheguruJiKiFateh You all are chatting nonsense. Haven't you got anything else better to think about other than wanting your wives to do your dirty work for you? I don't care whether there is a fareed story or any other. That still doesn't change the fact that you males are getting too ego. Furthermore, your wife doing all the seva for the husband still doesn't allow her to open her dhasam dhaur due to spending most of her time doing seva for her husband, when does her naam bhagti ever come in her life? Your husband is not a saint; he is only a mere human being in your life. The only thing you should be concerned about is what you are actually gaining from all this. Your true most beloved husband is Waheguru Ji; he should come before anyone else. Your husbands are not ill nor are they weak; they can do their own seva. I don't care whether it is tradition because we're not Hindus as Hindus believe their husbands are like a God, Guru Ji referred Waheguru Ji as your true husband. ipru pRBu swcw sohxw pweIAY gur bIcwir ]1] rhwau ] pir prabh saachaa sohanaa paaeeai gur beechaar ||1|| rehaao || God is your Husband; He is Handsome and True. He is obtained by reflecting upon the Guru. ||1||Pause|| If you wives actually believe that you should do seva for your husband then I can only say that you need to get a hobby. And realize the absolute truth and may God Bless you with common sense. What is so saintly about males? Nothing! I rather die than serving my husband for the rest of my life. What has he got that Waheguru Ji doesn't have? Don't encourage the youth to make such mere commitments otherwise females will always stick in the same spot of all these emotional attachments with their spouse. Females will always think of themselves lowly and males to be supreme. We are not Muslims nor are we Hindus as they believe that it is the wives role to do such worthless stuff. Take Mata Gulab Kaur as an example, what did she gain for serving her husband? when he passed away she began to realize the truth that her husband is nothing. And soon began to do more naam bhagti, and as a result reached enlightenment. It was then when she saw the beauty in naam. We are to praise and remember God only we are not to glorify any man. If disciples of such panth who spiritual roots are from the supreme and immortal being, stoop so low to glorify any human beings, then these Sikhs are bringing disgrace. WaheguruJiKaKhalsaWaheguruJiKiFateh

Re: wife amd husband

.. · 04 Nov 2005

why does gurbani use the simally of wife and husband to describe relationship between bhagat and god? answer - relationship has many simallarities ie - wife serves husband out of love.

Re: wife amd husband

khalsa · 04 Nov 2005

Gurbani also uses analigies like, to please the husband the wife does shingaar, does that mean women should do shingaar to please there husband, no its just using relevant examples to get the point across

Re: wife amd husband

here's a thought · 05 Nov 2005

Singhni Miri Piri, I'm a woman myself, so don't think that my comment has anything to do with a male ego hurt by your post. But I just had to comment on how you failed to give the deepest respect when referring to BHAGAT fareed ji. I'm not too familiar with historical stories, although I suspect that that "l" was discussing Bhagat Fareed Ji's story. Have some shame..that in your anger and frustration you could steep to such lowliness and not even use the term "Bhagat" or "ji" when discussing such a blessed saint of God.

Re: wife amd husband

!! · 06 Nov 2005

In sikhi husband and wife are equal. No doubt about this. Sikh & Hindu culture was/is very similar. In hinduism women do every possible thing to please her husband to get his love, attention & blessing without any question. Guru ji used husband/wife relationship as an example that a bhagat and god's relation should be like that of husband & wife. A bhagat or a true sikh must believe and obey god as absolute without any if's & but's. U do not question the will of God. Guru ji did not mean that a sikh woman should treat her husband as god. Try to understand the deep meaning of gurubani. Please do not take the wordly meaning of gurubani. [%sig%]

Re: wife amd husband

<^> · 06 Nov 2005

wife and husband are equal each have separate jobs women look after children, (note men cannot breast feed babies) and serve husband husband works , provides money and food for wife & children, and takes responsibilty for household. note also - in anand karaj wife walks behind husband, this is very significant both are equal, but its the mans jobs to wear trousers in the house.

Re: wife amd husband

:) · 06 Nov 2005

singhneea really we are lucky.we are doing more seva... guruji's proper sorted us out.its easier for us to get to sachkhand!!! erm..<^> dotn agree with when you said theres a reason for the husband to walk infront of the women.no reason at all.i dont think guruji would care who walked infront.doesnt make a difference.

Re: wife amd husband

Naam Shaakti · 06 Nov 2005

here's a thought , I apologize for being extremely rude.

Re: wife amd husband

uksingh · 06 Nov 2005

"dotn agree with when you said theres a reason for the husband to walk infront of the women.no reason at all.i dont think guruji would care who walked infront.doesnt make a difference." have you ever seen the singhnee walkin in front and singh behind?

Re: wife amd husband

<^> · 06 Nov 2005

chakavee ko jaisae soor baalehaa maan sarovar ha(n)sulaa || As the sun is dear to the chakvi duck, and the lake of Man Sarovar is dear to the swan, jio tharunee ko ka(n)th baalehaa thio maerai man raameeaa ||3|| and the husband is dear to his wife, so is the Lord to my mind. ||3||

Re: wife amd husband

<^> · 06 Nov 2005

goo bhais mago laavaeree || A milk cow, and a water buffalo, I beg of You, eik thaajan thuree cha(n)gaeree || and a fine Turkestani horse. ghar kee geehan cha(n)gee || A good wife to care for my home jan dhha(n)naa laevai ma(n)gee ||2||4|| - Your humble servant Dhanna begs for these things, Lord.

Re: wife amd husband

<^> · 06 Nov 2005

jio purakhai ghar bhagathee naar hai ath lochai bhagathee bhaae || The devoted wife in her husband's home has a great longing to perform loving devotional service to him; bahu ras saalanae savaaradhee khatt ras meet(h)ae paae || she prepares and offers to him all sorts of sweet delicacies and dishes of all flavors. thio baanee bhagath salaahadhae har naamai chith laae || In the same way, the devotees praise the Word of the Guru's Bani, and focus their consciousness on the Lord's Name.

Re: wife amd husband

khalistani · 06 Nov 2005

sant je said one day next thin u kno women r gonna say we shud walk in front of lavaan to vah vah look was comin to pass... bhula chuka maf

Re: wife amd husband

?? · 07 Nov 2005

????

Re: wife and husband

Ek Kaur · 07 Nov 2005

<^> ji, In the gurbani pankti's you have quoted, I think Guru Sahib has used traditional traditional relations betwewen husband and wife to represent and idilic relationshiop between sikh and Waheguru. In the pankti from the arti where Bhagat Dhanna ji requests a good wife for his home... is a depictation again of the bhagat and guru relationship. ie. as his sikh we request him to fulfil our worldly needs and we sing his praise. Note Guru sahib does not state the role of a good wife here. I could be wrong but I don't think that Guru Sahib has actually given order as to the way in which we should divide our home responsibilities. As Sikhi has always been a practical way of life... my opinion would be that we should divide our duties practically to suit individual households. For example if a wife happens to have an acedemic qualification but the husband doesn't it may make sense for her to go out and work as she could bring in a higher income annd support her spouse and child. My opinion only... VJKKVJKF

Re: wife amd husband

<^> · 07 Nov 2005

all you can do is try and twist gurbani to fit ur own mat you have no firm argument to support ur views all u do i s try and counter my points

Re: wife amd husband

RoopKaur · 07 Nov 2005

When a Singhnee does seva of her husband, she automatically gets half of his kamaaee. Also, this is an opurtunity for Singhnees to do seva, how could it ever be a bad thing? From both perspectives, its a good thing for Singhnee to do seva of her husband and serve him with love and devotion, as she will get fal for it in the end. Just look at the examplary relationship of Bhai Sahib and Mata Kartaar Kaur Ji, along with the historical examples already sited on this thread. Although the society we live in today is all upside down and mixed up, making it difficult to maintain the traditional roles, we can see the effects of these changes on the children of today's society.

Re: wife amd husband

miss kaur · 08 Nov 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I responding to this site for the first time...and being a young sikhi girl my perception on a wife and husband relationship and marriage is as such: there are certain roles that the males and females must take...this is not doubting the capability of the others BUT a man cannot bear a child as it is physically and biologically not possible. So when a woman is pregnant she must take care of herself and of the child she is carrying...therefore, by no fault of hers or the husbands, the male must take a physical responsibility to them. Although i appreciate the females should be given the same opportunities in the workplace etc etc but when Guruji talks about equality i think it was mainly referring to the fact that women in other faiths weren't allowed to read their holy scriptures i.e. because of their monthlys therefore classed as dirty. This is where equality is spoken about...that females should be able to read bani just like males, females should be able to do kirtan just like males. But on a worldly level my understanding is that you can learn from respecting and taking care of your husband how your love for your Guru should be. This does not discriminate towards women at all in fact as we are ALL classed as wives of God the males can actually learn from the women what and how that pyaar should be carried out and with what kind of dedication. This does not reflect on men being superior but in fact how humility can be learnt. I'm certainly learning a lot as i'm about to step into married life...and controlling your words and actions can be most difficult...but for the love of you husband you would rather control it than make it into a huge issue. Feminists have fought a long time for rights for this and rights for that...but i truely believe that we have been given roles to carry out. This is probably part of His huge plan - who are we to argue with that? All we can do is learn and apply to daily life as much as possible. If mistakes are made then hope that we learn from them and be able to pass on that knowledge to future generations. A good relationship between a husband and wife will lead to a better future. Forgive me for the words spoken. Comments would be highly appreciated. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!

Re: wife amd husband

miss kaur · 12 Nov 2005

any comments?

Re: wife amd husband

GSinngh · 17 Nov 2005

WJKK WJKF Hello miss kaur! I agree 110% with you! Especially when you say man can learn humility from his wife. That is so true! If all women were to behave in a feminist manner, they would be competing with their husbands rather than COMPLEMENTING them. When man and woman complement each other it would mean a happier marriage and as you say the man can learn how to have stronger pyaar for vaheguru! God has made creation in pairs, night/day, happiness/sorrow, man/woman etc. So it is only logical man and woman should complement each other. "But on a worldly level my understanding is that you can learn from respecting and taking care of your husband how your love for your Guru should be. This does not discriminate towards women at all in fact as we are ALL classed as wives of God the males can actually learn from the women what and how that pyaar should be carried out and with what kind of dedication. This does not reflect on men being superior but in fact how humility can be learnt." I read another article here:http://www.sikh-history.com/sikhhist/archivedf/feature-july.html This is written by a Kaur which makes it more interesting, but here are a few quotes that I think might agree with your views: It is not only in spiritual matters, that a woman enjoys a supreme status. The status of Sikh women in social sphere is equally honorable. Gurbani gives clear guidelines as to the qualities Sikh women must possess in order to lead a healthy and harmonious social life. "Possessed of thirty-two merits, holy truth is her progeny. Obedient, of noble mien, To her husband's wishes compliant The younger brother-in-law and elder sister-in-law too with her are pleased. To her brother-in-law and elder sister-in-law too with her are pleased Noblest of the whole family, To her brother-in-law imparting wise counsel. Blessed is the home in which she is present. Therein, says Nanak, servant of God, is life a bliss. ' SGGS, p. 371 Bhai Kahan Singh Nabha has listed thirty two qualities of an ideal woman, some of these are: beauty, cleanliness, modesty, humility, cheerfulness, concord, observance of religion, cleverness, knowledge, service, compassion, truth, dedicated love of her husband, purity of mind, patience, frugality, beneficence, sobriety, chivalry, active habits, interior decoration, respect of elders, proficiency in music, painting, poetry, domestic science, embroidery, hospitality, and child care. A woman possessing the above mentioned qualities is an ideal woman, a good wife, a good householder, a good mother, in fact, the best of the best in the family. She is capable of guiding other members of the family, and no doubt, her home will be happy, where nothing but supreme joy prevails. Such is the concept of equality between man and woman in Gurmat philosophy. It is a pity that the so called modern woman, in her frenzy for equal rights, has turned herself into a rival of her husband, instead of complementing him. In the rat race for equality, faith, love and sacrifice have become a casualty, and a feeling of mistrust has replaced the deep sense of gratitude and trust in each other. When the Guru advocates the qualities of sweetness and humility in a woman, he knows that a woman has these qualities in abundance, more than a man. They are almost a second nature to her. It is these qualities which make life worth living at the home front, and make her even superior to man. WJKK WJKF [%sig%]

Re: wife amd husband

miss kaur · 18 Nov 2005

GSingh - your words are so true. The article is very inspiring...Fortunately our Guruji has given woman such a high position that modern women miss that and look at it as being undermining...but how could our Guruji ever do that? They couldn't! Not that i am worthy of such qualities...i am slowly realising how man and woman attempting to follow Guruji's word can be helpful to each other...from a personal example...my fiance has very strong thoughts and views about sikhi and keeps it as a priority...i sometimes fall...and may make allowances here and there...BUT my only word to him is that if he sees me falling...then please help me to stay standing and not lose balance....and a good relationship will allow us to support each other even through difficult times of need... This eventually becomes more than a bond between male and female - it becomes the male and female relationship with Waheguru. That should be our aim in life... I feel so very honoured to have found a partner who will help, assist and increase my bond with Guruji... Message to All Women...please don't let yourself be dragged into the fight of equality for the wrong reasons...some things are best carried out by women...no matter how much you would like not to do it. WJKK WJKF