Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Question for Sikh bibis associated with Sant Samaj

Question for Sikh bibis associated with Sant Samaj

S Singh · 22 Sep 2005

I want to know the opinions of Sikh girls/females associated with these Sant Samaj groups about the fact that the groups they defend every time, is against them doing seva in the Panj Pyaray and kirtan seva which is their fundamental God given right as Sikhs. How do they feel being treated like inferior beings? If you have any Anakh/dignity left inside you, for the love of god wake up! And stop defending these deras every time they do something wrong. What is wrong is wrong is wrong no matter how many times you try to defend it. Don’t cover your eyes, ears and mouth every time something goes against Gurmat and also lash out at us for standing up against these deras by referring to us as ‘Wahabis’, 'close minded' or other such irrelevant terms. And please this is not to be taken as disrespect towards you. All I wish to know is the opinions of the Bibis associated with Sant Samaj groups.

Re: Question for Sikh bibis associated with Sant Samaj

Reply · 22 Sep 2005

S Singh ji, Is there a way you are going to certify whether posters are bonafide "Dera members" for this thread? Also, since you are not a "Dera member" and yet are posting in this thread, one would assume that anybody else could post in this thread as well? >And please this is not to be taken as disrespect towards you. Well of course not. When a feminist says something against a group of women that's not calling women bad (manda akhiai). But when someone stands up for Guru-given maryada, that's calling women bad? [%sig%]

Re: Question for Sikh bibis associated with Sant Samaj

Reply · 22 Sep 2005

>seva in the Panj Pyaray and kirtan seva which is their fundamental God given right as Sikhs. Did Guru Govind Singh ji also have knowledge of this commandment of God's? It seems Guru ji did not; His Holiness never appointed Kaurs in the Panj Piyare at Anandpur, Sabo ki Talwandi, or Nanded? >How do they feel being treated like inferior beings? S Singh ji, why don't you take your argument up with Guru Dasmesh ji? Perhaps you could ask Mata Bhag Kaur ji how she felt "being treated like inferior being" by Guru Govind Singh ji. And how do you feel thinking that you are superior in knowledge of Gurmat that the Tenth Master himself did not have? [%sig%]

Re: Question for Sikh bibis associated with Sant Samaj

Gurpreet Kaur · 22 Sep 2005

Well I found it offensive, you just assumed we have no, or very less dignity left. FYI, the people I respect who are Mahapurush, do not hold the same views as the people who oppose women's sewa. Just because some people hold a certain view in a group, it doesnt mean everyone else agrees. I dont know why you say 'groups', I was only aware of one Sant Samaj. The Mahapurush I respect encourage women to do sewa through Kirtan and reading Gurbani/Taking a hukamnaama, this is why I started learning Kirtan from a very young age. GurFateh

Re: Question for Sikh bibis associated with Sant Samaj

Dogma · 22 Sep 2005

S Singh Jee, Could you please define "dera"? I see the term being used alot. Could you please define it as to what it means to you? Thank you Singh! Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh

Re: Question for Sikh bibis associated with Sant Samaj

Singh · 23 Sep 2005

funny how none of them could answer S Singhs question, just tried to find ways of having a go at him, distraction or tangent...... Relpy - the Guru-given maryada is Gurbani. it says we are all equal. It also says all souls are female. so the taksal/sant samaj idelogue is not backed by Guru at all...

Re: Question for Sikh bibis associated with Sant Samaj

........ · 23 Sep 2005

on the Baba Ranjit Singh Ji thread ppl said he was trying to get ppl to go against Baba Jarnail Singh Ji because they also sang dharna. Baba Jarnail Singh are respected among many sikhs, I wander what everyone has to say about them being against women in the Panj. I don't think it shows any inequality whatsoever as a female myself as onlg as there is a valid reason for it. Whether a valid reason exists I do not know but it is strange that most people anti-women in Panj, are actually people with a lot of kamai. As a side Q, Bhai Sahib would do sewa, did their jatha have women in the Panj, how did they feel about this? Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Question for Sikh bibis associated with Sant Samaj

AS · 25 Sep 2005

Panj Piare rejects plea to have Amritdhari women Perform Sewa at Harmandir Sahib Sunday 25th September, 2005 Ajaib Singh- Panthic Weekly Staff Amritsar Sahib (KP) - The Panj Piare of the Harmandir Sahib have blatantly rejected the plea by SGPC chief Bibi Jagir Kaur to allow baptised Sikh women to perform religious service inside the shrine. In a meeting held on Thursday the head of the Panj Piare, Gyani Gurbachan Singh, stated that the five priests in a resolution had made the decision to reject Jagir Kaur's plea to allow Amritdhari women to perform religious service along with male members inside the sanctum sanctorum of the Harmandir Sahib. This resolution was later submitted to the Akal Takht Jathedar Joginder Singh Vedanti who has the ultimate authority to finalize a decision in this regard. The Panj Piares are Gyani Gurbachan Singh, Gyani Mohan Singh, Gyani Jaswinder Singh, Gyani Jagtar Singh and Gyani Mal Singh. Earlier this year, Bibi Jagir Kaur had allowed amritdhari women to perform religious service subject to final approval from Vedanti. -What a sad situation this truly is. The main reason why a few Sadhs and Sants don't want women to do seva of Panj or Kirtan is because when women have their periods, according to them, they are considered unclean. What they need to realize is, without a woman's period you, me, or any other Baba of the Dam Dami Taksal or Sant Samaj wouldn't even be here on God's green earth today. That same linning of the uterus that is shed every month when women have their periods is what every human being is born, nourished in for 9 months. So if that is considred dirty or unclean then, in that case, we have all been born in dirt and filth. Vah Vah. These people must be true men of God! It's shameful...Sikhi is way above this Pindu style of thinking. Let's pull our heads out of our bums...alright. DHEG TEGH FATEH RAJ KAREGA KHALSA

Re: Question for Sikh bibis associated with Sant Samaj

Jasvir Kaur · 25 Sep 2005

imho...( no offense) most of those ladies i have met ( and talked to openly) were only "matha teking" etc to the Sants..due to "peer pressure"....the younger ones siad their mothers forced them to do it or somethign bad would fall on their heads,...the others said the "others..the sass, etc told them to do it for good luck..etc etc. I have NO HESITATION in concluding that MOST of this is BHEDD CHAAL. I myself had to face this sort of pressure when a local sant visited... i had been having soem doemstic problems and my sass, massis etc all ganged together to push me towards this baba ji....matha tek and ask him for blessings..all will be ok. I did...matha teked him RS 500..took his advise of5 japji sahibs daily, another shabad that says Ghar dee samgaree mein ikhathee ketee ( literally translated by this sant as Guru Ji's advise towards marital problem solving but now i know better)...and most interesting of all to MAKE 500 Atta balls and float them in flowing water while reading thsi shabad.... What a load of BULL. The Entire thing about Japji sahib etc was a SMOKE SCREEN for this Ghor Manmatt of atta balls and magic wand stuff - which of course NEVER WORKED. IF Atta balls worked..then not a single Sikh Woamn would be divorced/separated/victimised byher husband. JK

Re: Question for Sikh bibis associated with Sant Samaj

simren · 25 Sep 2005

Referring to the first post, i wish to tell you that there is something called kirpa...without it , You may wonder around in ego looking for your rights...if you are suppose to get the sewa you will...please..learn to live in phana. there are a lot of other sewa's than can be done...i don't think we should fight for sewa. You are suppose to offer the sewa to others if you have to. this is a basic of a sikh. if you want to do the sewa in harmandar sahib for example, do aardas and benti to maharaj....He will let it happen as how HE wish. Who are we to decide. When will we all learn this....so sad. "so sikh sakhaa banDhap hai bhaa-ee je gur kay bhaanay vich aavai" go to page 601 and read this hukamnamma. Bhul Chuk Maaf

Re: Question for Sikh bibis associated with Sant Samaj

AS · 25 Sep 2005

Sikh Women Today Sunday 4th September, 2005 Dr. Amrik Singh - Guest Columnist (KP)- Sikh women today are not only aware of their rights, roles and rigors, but they are also scripting narratives of their trials and tribulations in a multicultural setting. Their involvement in religious matters is germane to their essence and a source of inspiration for their families and friends. They are out to change the attitude of world in general and Sikhs in particular. They are leading strong movements against race, class and gender discrimination in educational institutions and at work places. Their encounter with the rest of the world has strengthened their identity as Sikhs and they are further exploring scriptures and history for supporting their assertive representation. The gender issue has not raised its head in Sikh circles before as it has done now, mainly after SGPC Chief Bibi Jagir Kaur accepted the demand of women’s advocates to give equal rights in the performance of Sikh ceremonies. The question of women at the center of religious ceremony has incensed Damdami Taksaal and Sant Samaj. Most Sikhs view it very unfortunate for the Panth, as they apprehend, it is going to have serious ramifications for the Sikh leadership. Baba Sarbjot Singh Bedi, Chief of Sant Samaj, Bhai Ranjit Singh a former Akal Takhat Jathedar and Baba Harnam Singh, Chief of Damdami Taksal addressing a press conference have given an ultimatum to Bibi Jagir Kaur, Chief of SGPC to either withdraw her controversial decision or face an open discussion on the issue. If there is no response, Sant Samaj and others will chalk out an action plan to thwart her move. The silver lining in the whole controversy, however, may be in the invitation of Sant Samaj to lay bare the role of women through a discussion based in Sikh traditions. Whether Bibi Jagir kaur will accept the challenge or not, will be seen in the due course of events. But there are quite many other scholars willing to jump into the fray to convince their viewpoint. The challenge of Chief of Sant Samaj, however, can’t be confined to Bibi Jagir Kaur alone. The controversy is going to affect Sikh community globally. Before chalking out any program, Sant Samaj should do their homework and determine whether they have the capacity to convince the whole Panth against the question of women’s rights as enshrined in the Holy Book. It isn’t clear yet whether the group owing their allegiance to Sant Samaj is genuinely fired up to prove their favor for Sikh men, or merely opposing it due to their personal bias against Badal and his cohorts. Some of them had earlier even tried to control the house of SGPC allegedly through covert support of the Chief Minister, Capt. Amrinder Singh, as alleged by Badal group. There may be a deep rooted dissatisfaction of all against Badal and Bibi Jagir Kaur for hammering down their influence in SGPC, known as the mini parliament of Sikhs. Many Sikh scholars say that the question of allowing women to perform religious rights is not controversial at all. All Sikhs who bow their heads to Sri Guru Granth Sahib can’t go against Sikh tenets. Moreover, there is an edict that whenever the Panth needs guidance, they can find it between the lines of the Adi Granth. Guru Nanak Dev hasn’t left any iota of doubt about the significance of women in society. In fact distancing women from the center is undesirable in Sikh society. They aren’t only natural and nurturing influence on Sikh seminaries, but also an integral part of the spiritual growth of the Sikh society. Capt. Gurdial Singh who lives in Fresno served in the Indian Army for a long time. On his visit to India earlier this year, he had submitted to SGPC his writing about the role of women in Sikh Society. I translated his writing into English. His whole idea was that along with educating Sikh boys, concentrate more on teaching girls about Sikhism. He said that there were multifold advantages as one girl taught was a family taught, and a family taught was a generation taught. The idea of Capt. Gurdial Singh was appreciated by many as it presented a vision of Sikh society in the future. The empowerment of women is the only recourse to revitalize Sikh society in the multidimensional crises. The enlightened women will be nucleus of strong value system that the Sikh society has been yearning for a long time. The other allegation of the Sant Samaj is that it is a conspiracy of Hindu organization, RSS to weaken Sikhism. Though it can’t be denied that RSS has tried to interfere with internal matters of Sikhism in the recent past, yet its involvement in the present controversy seems improbable. When questioned, many women wondered that there was no rhyme and reason in their allegation. It is very ill-timed that Damdami Taksal being the promoter of Sikh religiosity , should align with such an opinion. It has raised many questions as to its absolute authority on religious debates. All sects of Sikhism derive their legitimacy by interpreting Guru Granth Sahib in its true spirit to the masses. And it is evident that Gurbani doesn’t discriminate on gender issues. In fact, the gender issues have been taken up in a very highly developed manner. The fact that woman births the whole world and is a force behind all creations, has well been defined by Guru Nanak. Gurus have dealt deftly with gender representations in human discourses. The only Pursha is God; all others can win His favors through genuine seva. Gurbani, in fact, upholds the feminine principle as the highest point of aesthetic value that men can emulate when involved in serving the God. The total submission to God can result in Ananda; the way a woman’s consensual submission isn’t only for pleasure but for upholding her identity in relation to the Other. The identity formation of both man and woman is experienced in the state of lack. In this sense the Freudian view is more patriarchal and hence supports the superiority of the masculine. On the contrary, the Lacanian view doesn’t give primacy to the gender differences and supports the symbolic representation of the feminine in an arbitrary situation. The woman as site of desire may represent power in her being similarly as a patriarch constitutes his hierarchy. It is surprising that Gurus had incorporated a highly modern view of the gender relations in Gurbani. The argument that women cannot be representing Panj Piaras is in total violation of Sikh traditions and practices, also doesn’t hold much water. Who can deny the role of Mata Sahib Kaur when she exhorted the Guru to add Patase in the wonder concoction? Guru incorporated her view and the Khalsa’s goals and objective became all the more clearer. The Sant Samaj has been expressing its horror at the idea of giving representation to woman as if they are going to replace all Sikh institutions. The acceptance of Sikh women’s demand will have inconsequential effect on Sikh traditions and practices. Rites and rituals have no place in Sikh thought if they are observed only for their own sake. If any tradition is divorced from its objective, it is going to be counterproductive to the spirit of Sikhism. The purpose behind all practices is to create personal integrity, devotion, dedication and the spirit of sacrifice for the service of mankind. Who can better inculcate these values than enlightened Sikh women? It is said that Guru Amar Das Ji was initiated into Sikhi by Bibi Amro daughter of Second Guru Angad Dev ji. He was so much impressed by her way of reciting Guru’s verses that he decided to completely sacrifice his ego to the will of the Guru. When Guru Amar Das was anointed the third Sikh Guru, he made Bibi Amro as in charge of one of several Manjis established for the spread of Guru’s message. Bibi Amro’s memory is still preserved in Basarke in the form of a pond known as “ Amro da Talab.” The present debate should definitely take place with an open mind. No personal likes and dislikes should intervene in matters of pure thought and deliberation. The invitation of Sant Samaj and others should be for all those who want to learn about Sikh history. Debates and discussions with good faith are the need of the hour. Let there be a conference on this issue and let all those who hold tradition and convention as superimposed on Guru Granth Sahib Ji, clarify how they explain the subordination of women in Sikh thought.

Re: Question for Sikh bibis associated with Sant Samaj

Guru da Kookar · 26 Sep 2005

Guru Roop Khalsa jio, Waheguru jee ka Khalsa, Waheguru jee kee Fateh. Very well said Bhehenjee Jasvir Kaur jio. I think until every bibi of the Sikh quam will not start thinking like you we will not have chardi kala in the Panth. Well said it is only Bhead Chaal. We have to learn a lot from our bibian from history. As is said that the mother is the first teacher of the baby and whatever she teach, the baby is going to follow that. If all the bibian from the Sikh Quam learn to follow Gurbani and not these phekhi sant, babas the difference can be seen in short time and we will see Quam in chardi kala. Bibiao bheheno Guru has given a high status and equal right to yoy as to a man and do not loose your dignity by metha teke to these phekhi sants and have the inferiority complex. These phekhi cann't do anything and cann't change any one's life or fate except Waheguru. Vasta je Guru da please come back to Sikhi and stop following these sant, babas who themselves are born from a woman and still oppose the same woman. Eh tan Akirtaghan han hee tusi kion Guru jee de Beparteeti dian bhagi ban rahian jee. Eh sab de sab Bipar de chela he han, manu de santan jis ne keha see ke Aurat parr dee juthi hai, and they are following their ancestors only. they are true to their gurus( Bipar)........Par tusi tan Guru Nanak deian sher bachian ho. Jina da Pita do jahan da malik howe oh kise manukh( manmukh) de parie te metha take Soba nahi dinda( it doesn't look good that a son or daughter of KIng of King to bow before a Mangta( begger).Please aja vee sama hai.......... People who are the chelas to these pseudo sants what one can say to these ......I remember one proverb that I can quote for them if they it works and they start thinking the Gursikh's way and not of chelas way........ The COMMON SENSE is the SENSE which most of the COMMON people do not use in COMMON. Waheguru jee ka Khalsa. Waheguru jee kee Fateh. [%sig%]

Re: Question for Sikh bibis associated with Sant Samaj

.............................. · 27 Sep 2005

lol about the balls you were asked to float jasvir bhenji but I am a young girl and I would run to bow down to someone who I consider to be a BABA or a SANT without any encouragement from my parents. As for a person telling me to float anything etc that would make me think twice about that person. But often I find we can look at a person and realise if they are a true Gursikh or not. This is regardless of what anyone has to say about whether a true gursikh would not allow you to touch their feet. But for me, I don't think I've been wrong so far, I have met a lot of people that allow you to matha tek to them. I will but then I will never agree to meet that person again if I dont like them. Its strange that its always the ones I never liked that are the ones telling people to do anything apart from paath so I think God gave eyes and we should use them to decide who we think is worthy of spending time with and who is not. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Question for Sikh bibis associated with Sant Samaj

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Sep 2005

Author :................... But often I find we can look at a person and realise if they are a true Gursikh or not. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> WOW i envy you. As far as I am concerned...I am like the writer of GURBANI...He writes in Guru GRANTH JI.... "Rahio Sant mein toll..sadh bahutereh ditteh...[gurbani] rihau sMq mY tol..swD bhuqyry if`Ty [/gurbani] Meaning: I "looked" everywhere for "SANT"....but alas i only found plenty of "Sadhs" This is TRUE even today...go to any Indian City..and see the numbers of SADHS..SANTS..roaming in Gangs of hundreds.. IF a person whose GURBANI is in our GURU JI....finds it so difficult to "see" a "SANT" ( rare as Bird's milk)...i a mere human cant be having this wonderful 20/20 vision to be able to see so many sants...is my VISION really THAT GOOD ?? I wonder. Bhul Chuk Maaf