Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

Kulbir Singh · 21 Sep 2005

Sikhs have to remove kirpan when air travelling. Even a small 3-4 inches kirpan is not allowed. Something must be done about this. 1. Which body or association must we approach to fight for our right to wear a Kirpan. 2) Is there is single body at international level or do we have to approach each country separately? I think it is about time we did something about this. I request all Gursikhs, irrespective of their backgrounds or jathebandi affiliations to work together on this very important case. All lawyers, please recommend what we can do. Anyone? Kulbir Singh

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 21 Sep 2005

Vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa Vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!! Great initiative, Bhai Kulbir Singh ji. Personally I think there should be ALL organizations behind this campaign. To spearhead the campaign I would suggest a five-member committee should include: 1) Executive member of UNITED SIKHS 2) Executive member of SMART 3) Executive member of Sikh Coalition 4) Executive member of Khalsa Alliance 5) Executive member of Shahbaaz Khalsa This is just a brainstorming ... And they would be directly responsible. I think the SGPC, Akaal Takhat, five takhats, all sansthas, all jathas, and all gurmat organizations must be behind them. We would probably have to approach: 1) United Nations 2) International Air Transporation Association 3) International Policy Institute for Counter Terrorism 4) Amnesty International 5) Travel Industry Association of America 6) National Transporation Safety Board (US) 7) Transporation Safety Board of Canada and there are probably more... these are just ideas ... Most important governments to convince would be: 1) Sachee Sarkaar. Everythign else is KOOORRRR !!!! but... anyway.... *sigh* 1) USA - once they accept, others will follow 2) UK 3) India 4) Canada 5) Australia please forgive my mistakes Vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa Vaaheguroojeekeefathehhhhhhhh !!!!!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

unknown · 21 Sep 2005

start with the NCAA and get canadian goverment to endorse the plea thats how you gotta go about it.......and to get the gorement to endorse the idea u need all the gurdwareh behind u, cuz they got tha $$......and they're the ones who can direct our communities votes for the party in power...... to get it done we gotta be political about it, not everyone sign a petition online kinda thing

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

jss · 21 Sep 2005

a key thing we need to address and come up with a viable solution is... how to prevent terrorists from using the sikh privilege of carrying the kirpan on to the plane.. i mean..when we approach the governments...they'll probably say...well anyone can don a turban and claim to be sikh and bring on a kirpan...what happens if terrorists want to use our articles of religion in their terror campaign?... i'm not sure there's a solution to that one...it's a hard one to regulate...like do we have singhs at the airport pointing out the amritdharis from the non amritdharis? would people claiming to be amritdhari have to write a short quiz befor boarding to make sure they are amritdhari?... there's gotta be some way to differentiate them from imposters...it'd be interesting to see the ideas we can come up with... great thread kulbir veerji

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

Iron Man · 22 Sep 2005

it wont happen anytime soon. Especially after 9/11 what if some muslim dresses up like a sikh, takes what looks like a kirpan on board and hijacks a plane? then all sikhs will have such a black mark on them... the only way to prevent that would be to A) have our own airline (like jews have el al) B) do what el al does (ie interview and interrogate every person who wants to wear a kirpan on board a plane to ensure they are sikh first of all, and sane.) it also doesnt help that in the 80s some sikhs did hijack planes.. also, india allows kirpans on domestic flights, but because of other countires rules, they dont allow them on international flights.

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

Reply · 22 Sep 2005

Kulbir Singh ji, Here some information that I am aware of. If there are mistakes, someone can please add more information, but this should be a good starting point. [u]Regulatory agencies for airline travel[/u] In the United States, regulations for airlines had always been set by the Federal Aviation Admininistration. (). But then there is also the Transport Security Administration (), which was created after the 2001 attacks to help create the illusion of greater security. "In February 2002, TSA assumed responsibility for security at the nation’s airports" In Canada, regulations for airlines (and other forms of transport) are set by Transport Canada (), but there is also the Canadian Air Transport Security Authority (CATSA) . The US and Canadian agencies ban different, but mostly similar, lists of items. (See ). The fact that there are a few differences means that countries have leeway to set their own individual policies. But, normally, it seems they work to minimize differences, because travellers having items OK in one country, but prohibited in a country they are travelling to might be inconvenienced. Secondly, countries have control over airlines flying to or even over their airspace. This means the US regulating flights from Canada to Mexico. Also, the fact is that the US is a global hegemon and it makes other countries do whatever it wants them to do. An example is that European countries are moving to implement biometric passports because the US has said it won't allow visa-less entry for Europeans without such passports. If the US determines that a jetliner hijacked over Europe or someplace else could possibly be diverted to do damage to the US or even US or friendly interests in allied countries, it will ensure all of the regulations it desires to be in place are in place. [u]Whether knives and swords are allowed or will be allowed on planes[/u] (Yes, I know it's a kirpan, but we are using the airline regulation terminology here.) While small knives were allowed before 9/11, they are not allowed now. And if you are wondering whether someone can cause mischief on a plane with a small knife, the answer is yes: "Peter Bradley wasn't a terrorist, but aboard Alaska Airlines Flight 259 nearly 2 years ago he behaved like one. Suffering from encephalitis, a condition that can cause delirium, Bradley pulled out a pocketknife, threatened passengers and assaulted flight attendants who tried to calm him. Then he barged through the cockpit door." "As pilots struggled to control the jet, Bradley pushed the captain and fought the first officer. Passengers tackled him to keep him at bay." "In the months that followed, crewmembers aboard Flight 259 pushed for more protection aboard commercial jets." "Last December, a 46-year-old Texas man forced an American Airlines jet to land after threatening crewmembers with a 2-inch knife." "Overseas, similar incidents occurred. In June 1999, a man forced his way into the cockpit of an All Nippon Airways airliner in Japan and fatally stabbed the pilot." But these kinds of incidents would perhaps be tolerated if it hadn't been for the 9/11 attack: "Preliminary reports indicate that the hijackers were armed with nothing more than knives. Horrifically, these simple weapons were apparently used to murder members of the flight crew as they bravely attempted to alert the FAA," So, on September 13, 2001, (2 days after the New York attacks) the FAA responded with, among other things: "A total ban on knives of any material. Previously, knives with blades shorter than four inches had been allowed." The list of items prohibited for taking on one's person: http://66.102.7.104/search?q=cache:YZ9Vx3SOpxoJ:www.tsa.dot.gov/interweb/assetlibrary/ Permitted_and_Prohibited_Items.pdf+knives+faa&hl=en includes knives (of any type/design/size) no. The same for sabers and swords, but one can check all three into baggage. Similarly, in Canada, "Knives or knife-like objects of any length (such as hunting knives, scuba knives, swords, sabres, meat cleavers, straight razors and religious knives)" Transport Canada Since the 9/11 attack has become the prism for determining whatever is done in America these days, they are just not going to allow knives of any type for anyone. And, yes, they know about kirpans (at least the top officials do), and they are not going to allow religious knives either. [%sig%]

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

Reply · 22 Sep 2005

Kulbir Singh ji, Who gave you a right to wear a kirpan? Sachi sarkar? OK, fine so we just wear the kirpan, but no one is giving us a right to do so. We have no power and noone is going to listen to us. The whole excercise of begging shows exactly how powerless we have become. (Note that Guru Govind Singh ji did not petition anyone to begin wearing arms.) I am sympathizing with your sentiments but pointing out the obstacles. >All lawyers, please recommend what we can do. On what basis would the lawyers file suit? In the US, the right to bear arms is enshrined in its constitution, but people still cannot bear any kind of arms (much less firearms) in airplanes. What makes you think they would deign to make an exception for us? Really, they're not going to make an exception; rather it would have to be an allowance for small knives of all sorts, which have already proved to be a nuisance in my post above. If such an exception were made and there were a later hijacking or even just mischief (by non-Sikhs), the media will hilight the fact that the small knives exception had been made for the benefit of Sikhs, thereby earning us the wrath of the general populace. >All lawyers, please recommend what we can do. Don't take your kirpan off. Kar kirpa ji mentioned: >"1) USA - once they accept, others will follow" But how are you going to convince the US to do this? Sikhs are just a tiny speck in the US (unlike in Canada). And Sikhs did not really do anything for the US, unlike for Britain, which helped during the Save the Turban campaign. It is not going to happen, so we might as well not expend political capital on it. This is different from saying we shouldn't fight turban bans in Canada and so forth, as well as Kirpan bans in schools. That is a different situation, and political capital spent on that has a likelihood of good returns. [%sig%]

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

Reply · 22 Sep 2005

The fact is that we are weak and take our kirpans off ourselves; what government is going to believe that we can't take our kirpans off once in a while? Singh ji: Sikhs are denied the right to wear kirpan during flights. Government: Really? How would you know? Singh ji: I went on a flight to UK and had to take my kirpan off. Government: Oh? Singh ji: Yes, [speculation, here] I didn't eat anything on the way and went to a Gurdwara upon arrival, said Japji, and put my kirpan back on. Government: Did that make it OK? Singh ji: I think so. Government: Good, well, why don't you just do that -- problem solved. [%sig%]

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

Reply · 22 Sep 2005

One answer to this whole problem may be in the form of a Khalsa airlines (there was another thread on this topic). That too is fraught with problems given our current state. The Tribune in Chandigarh was started by Sardar Dyal Singh Majithia, but he later became a Brahmo Smaji and handed over the lagam (reigns) of the Tribune to a trust, which is in the hands of Arya Smajis today (correct if wrong). On, the other hand, if we make a trust in the first place, perhaps under the leadership of the SGPC, look at the current Jagir Kaur situations where she has let the children of Committee members study for free (worth crores) and also pocketed money in NRI quotas. Nothing but corruption comes out of anything we do. We need to have a pool of honest and educated Sikhs before we embark on this kind of undertaking. So creating good people is probably the best seva along these lines that you can do at the moment, Kulbir Singh ji. [%sig%]

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

Sohagani · 22 Sep 2005

It would be great if this could get off the ground. But, when dealing with the United States, it would be nearly impossible to allow any type of sharp metal object into the air. To most people, Sikhs look like terrorists, and terrorists look like Sikhs. That being said, a terrorist could easily pose as a Sikh, and do something a Sikh wouldn't do. You may not be able to hi-jack an aircraft with a 3-4 inch blade, but you could definitely cause some havoc if you wanted. At the end of the day, the United States would never allow it.

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

Liongking · 22 Sep 2005

Thing is though - will this nto lead to terrorists clothing as Sikhs to bomb planes, and now have an excuse to wear a what they would call- a Kirpan.. So there's a risk of Agents/terrorists clothing as Sikhs and - you know...

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

gabroo · 22 Sep 2005

if i were a layman, englishman (or any other native countryman), how could you prove to me that it would be necessary for you to keep your kirpan on board. assume that i am a jury member or member of public who needs to be convinced. becaus eotherwise it would seem illogical and non-sensical to me. why on earth should you be allowed to carry it if you can put it back on afterwards. i have a feeling that if such a thing was brought into public light (tv, newspapers), there would be an overwhelming majority AGAINST such a thing. because people's own logic and common sense would tell them that it makes sense NOT to allow it. i think all gursikh should be able to provide a strong answer on this. so if there could be some posts on this... an ideal answer can then be chosen... one that would could directly answer the above type of person. and so sikh in various countries know where they stand, in terms of answering any public questioning.

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

Singh · 22 Sep 2005

i dont think we should start petitioning for like all sizes of kirpans i think you guys should start with a smaller size like 3-4 inches because atleast that way they mite go for it, but then again any terrorist can say there a sikh and bring a kirpan on to the plane....

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

Scientific · 22 Sep 2005

Kulbir Singh Ji The issue of the kirpan on the plane and for airport staff workers on airside has been around for sometime. Though at first site it appears that we are being discriminated against we have to look carefully at this situation and see the flip side of the argument. The kirpan is carried by a large number of people in the Sikh community, spanning different age groups, socio-economic backgrounds. At the point of taking amrit, despite there being a responsibility of the panj pyaray to assess the readiness of an individual to bear an arm (because as symbolic as one would like to make it out- it is an ARM) there will undoubetedly be irresponsible characters wearing kirpans. You only have to watch the fights that happen at annual elections in the gurudwaras to see people reaching for kirpans. In the vast majority of cases 'all other means' have not been exhausted when the general secretary draws his weapon and threatens to behead the opposition party leader. There are countless cases like this across the west (including canada). Some of these instances have shamefully been picked up in the media. This leads me to the crunch point. Imagine a scenario where a young amritdhari man/woman boards a plane looking quite calm and normal. No one is aware that he is a well controlled paranoid schizophrenic patient, who is coping well in the community. (I am working as a pyschiatrist and i have come across amritdhari sikhs who are schizophrenic in the community and they wear kirpans - and beleive me its scary!) Plane takes off and everything is ok. Man becomes a little edgy since he has never flown on an airplane alone. Before long he is pacing up and down the aisles looking very agitated. Other passengers are nervous because he appears to be talking to herself. The patient appears to be suffering an acute stress reaction. An air steward approachs him to ask what is going on. The sikh man, who is already at a heightened state of arousal, immediately percieves this as a threatening move and in his fear reaches for the kirpan. All hell breaks lose. He is restrained by several staff members, much to the relief of the traumatised passengers witnessing this daunting situation unfold and are shocked at the realisation that this Sikh passenger is carrying a dagger or knife on board a plane. The situation is contained and everything looks to be fine. Right?? WRONG. The real damage is about to be inflicted by the media who are always on the prowl for such dramatic events. Before you know it 'Mad turbanned man in knife air rage attack" is plastered across the tabloids with a picture of a hand cuffed sardar ji being rushed away by the feds. There are stories of heroic acts to safe guard the passengers against this 'monstrous terrorist" who drew his dagger in a completelty unprovoked incident. There is next to no sympathy for his mental illness and the fact that he just happens to be a sikh. The focus is all on the outrage that these guys with turbans are allowed on what are deemed to be secure planes with knifes. Have the western govts not learned anything from 9/11 etc etc. You must be getting the picture now. The sikh nation would certainly get the limelight with just one such case. Just look at how much damage the case of the mistaken identity post 9/11 has done to Sikhs in North America. At least in that instance we could blame people for ignorance and there is a potential fix of educating the masses that can be put into place. With this case, despite the low risk of such an event happening two conclusions can be made. 1. It is far more beneficial for sikhs to not wear kirpans on the plane. 2. There is absolutely no way any government will allow or even listen to the Sikhs with their plea to allow kirpans on the plane. I hope you dont take these views as anti-sikh but you have to be logical and practical when it comes to such issues. Scientific

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

question · 22 Sep 2005

A question that popped into my head was this: if we take off our kiprans because we say we are majboor and don't have a choice, what if 5 years from now they have a rule like in France and say Sikhs or anyone else can't cover their heads on flights. It's not outside the realm of possibility. Would that make it ok for amritdhari Sikhs to take their dastaars and keskis off to fly? If not, then whats the difference between the kirpan and keski? Aren't they both kakaars? bhul chuk maaf.

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

Reply · 22 Sep 2005

unknown ji, >start with the NCAA and What NCAA do you mean? NCAA - National Collegiate Athletic Association?

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

Jasmin · 22 Sep 2005

Sometimes, I ask myself, do I have the qualifications as yet to speak on these issues? Heres an idea. I tend to view the kirpan as rather sysbolic. Not sysbolic in the sense of a cross pendent, yet still, essentially sysbolic or iconic. In light of this, why not make special kirpans for flying on planes? I would suggest a respectful material like a hard wood, or even metal, so long as it was not sharp. Wouldn't this make flying safer, even in India? I would have to agree with Scientific, and others who have stated that problems with any sharp metal object, on a plane, could be serious. Imposters or unstable persons, Sikh, or otherwise, could take advantage. No it's not the same as a keshi, turban. We are talking about sharp metal objects thousands of feet off the ground. I understand it could be an issue in a school or job situation, but on a plane? It's a little funny, I suppose you will accuse me of suggesting sword sized letter openers, which in a sense I am. Honestly I can't think of a better idea. Though, it might have helped on 9/11, most of the time you don't need to get in a real fight on a plane.

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

unknown · 22 Sep 2005

i meant NAA :P

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

observer · 22 Sep 2005

Kulbir Singh people like you have realized it now. You have isolated from the world and hence don't know what is going on around. You have to be part of the world and work together to achieve this goal. I am happy that you have come out and realized it. http://www.sikhcoalition.org/ has done lot of good work and need to do more. Go under Resources tab and you will find lots of great info. http://www.unitedsikhs.org/ We need to support these kind of organization, instead of being only resticted to a smaller group. Guru Nanak Sahib went out into the world and spread Sikhi, instead of staying at one place. I know that you are very knowledgable and a great Gursikh and world out need your services. So, please come out and join the flow.

Re: Fighting for Kirpan while air travelling

singh · 22 Sep 2005

waheguru, i wish there was some way we could have our kirpans on the airplanes. but the problem lies with terroritsts who will pose as singhs and maybe use the kirpan to their liking. As i am a singh, i would love to see airlines cancel this policy. but as a concerened person it is purely a safety measure.