Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
Harjas Kaur · 21 Sep 2005
If a person really did this, the person is possessed by demonic jamdhoots for sure. Jamdhoots hate the Jyot. That person will go insane from these demons.
[%sig%]
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Sep 2005
he/she is already insane... or they wouldnt have doen this.
a by product of making it so easy to get free sroops...some dont know what to do with them when they lose their marbles..
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
jaspreet kaur · 22 Sep 2005
i thought jhamdoots are the angel messenger of death under the order from dharam rai?
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
Daljeet Singh · 23 Sep 2005
Yea you can't be possessed by jamdoots, they serve a common purpose, and their purpose is not to possess people but to punish them at the time of death.
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
Kulwant Singh Sandhra · 23 Sep 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
First of all I would like to share my upmost disguist and anger over such a violation. I am unaware of the full details but just the fact that someone can even postulate disrespecting saroops of Sri Guru Granth Sahib is the greatest insult to Sikhs.
It is REALLY UPSETTING to keep on hearing these kind of stories in the news. First there was that idiotic insane Bhaniara wala who dressed himself as Guru Gobind Singh Ji and was responsible for carrying out massacres of saroops of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. When will the Sikh Panth wake up, and put an end to this disrespect of our Guru
On another note, in response to a statement made by observer:
I dont agree with you here because lets not foget that Seva of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is a very mahaan Seva, that only Vadbhaagi people get a chance to do. Keeping a saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is a duty that carries a lot of responsibility with it, and this can benefit one's pyar for Sikhi. Also, think about the atmosphere created in that house which has a prakash of Guru Sahib. It is so magnificent thinking about that room where Guru Sahib shall illuminate it with its chaanan.
However, I am in total agreement that there should be some rule implemented that only allows certain people to obtain a saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib for their house. In other words, I think manmukhs (people who cut their hair) should NOT be able to have prakash of Guru Ji at their home because it is pretty evident that they will indulge in manmukh activities in their house, and therefore cause disrespect to Guru Sahib. I mean, if they are not even following the teachings of our Guru Sahibaans, then how are they going to make themself worthy of doing seva of Guru Ji. I know a family of keep a saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib but the man cuts his hair and is a frequent drinker, and keeps bottles of alcohol in his house. People like these should not be able to have a saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib at their home.
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
.............................. · 27 Sep 2005
which 2 ladies, indian what?
what is going tohappen to them now?
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!!
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
kirtan singh · 27 Sep 2005
the hindus see this everyday. their krisna murti was defaced. they cleaned it did maha pooja and asked for forgivness. they said person who did it must be tormented and this act. they also found the person and forgave him. the granth is on a paper which can be copied on another page.
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
.............................. · 27 Sep 2005
kirtan
it is the Sri GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI not the granth as you refer to our Guru as.
so there are copies, that is NOT the point!
OUR GURU DEMANDS THE RESPECT OF THE KING OF KINGS, OFCOURSE WE CAN FORGIVE BECAUSE THE PUNISHMENT IS FOR GOD TO DECIDE>
DONT PUT SINGH IN YOUR NAME IF YOU ARE NOT ONE OK
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
kirtan singh · 28 Sep 2005
First of my father was asikh killed in air india bombing. eversince i am always finding ways of why my father a very good sikh was killed. My mother is hindu and she is proud to be both. NOT ME how is this book going to bring my dad back. My mom will not make me change my name as my father was awell respected man. granth is just a book spoken by a man. we take pride in the sword, we fight at the meetings that we come to and if it does not go our way, we start throwning punches. How can some one respect our belifs.
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
Gurnit Singh · 29 Sep 2005
i think this kirtan person should stop including singh in their name
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
.............................. · 29 Sep 2005
kirtan singh sorry about your history and to some extent i can say ok i feel for you. but although u have gone through a lot you have to accept but first understand what hukam is, what karams are.
second, it is not that you can not understand valueless words Guru Ji say, but you don't want to. Read and understand and only then do you have the right to criticise. No matter what u say i dont think u have read Guru Ji's gurbani so dont post saying u have because that would convince me that u r a hindu RSS person trying to diss sikhi for the fun of it, especially as u add singh in your name yet complain that ur mother does not allow u to change ur name.
whoever u r, I think we can understand ur anger but please read Guru Ji's gurbani and also understand karam and whatGuru Ji are, who they are yeah?
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki Fateh Ji
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
we all got names · 30 Sep 2005
u know what kirtan
i have a buddy who's dad died in it too
and he aint full of hate like u
and interesting how u use a hindu reference
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
Harjas Kaur · 30 Sep 2005
[quote]She lives with her son who has unstable mental health[/quote]
He is possessed. Without a doubt. If he did this to Babaji, what on earth would he not do to his own family. He is a complete danger. Perhaps he will even kill his own mother and sister one day. He is to be avoided at all costs. Perhaps they should put him in an institution.
[%sig%]
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
Dhaiyalan(g) Saroopae · 30 Sep 2005
I think the whole sangat at Dixie should get up in Ardaas and ask Guru Sahib Himself to forgive this family for the beadbi they have committed. It is obvious that this young man and his family have already sown so much bad karma that they will have to pay for. Perhaps Guru Sahib will forgive them if the plea comes from Sangatee roop.
I am SURE that they will have to do SOMETHING as a punishment for this crime, but I think Sangat should together find some professional help for this young man.
This is a time to show the other communities the compassion that lies within Gursikhs. I think this family has admitted they have committed a major beadbi. I don't think we as a quam should as for blood, but rather beg for forgiveness from our Guru Sahib on behalf of these people.
I believe these people feel GENUINE remorse for what they have done, so I think all those sangat in Dixie should take that into account. This is not the case of Hindi Soldiers ripping and burning Guru Granth Sahib Jee in 1984. So I think we should handle it differently as well...
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
sikhi piari · 30 Sep 2005
Was teh beer that was ripped up lareedar saroop or padcheed? I am very confused because it says on other threads that only lareedar saroop was reall GUru.
Wot if this man has also been told the same and then thoght he wasn't ripping up THE SATGURU. Maybe he doesn't recognise his sin due to error?
BHUL CHUK MAAPH
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
Balpreet Singh · 30 Sep 2005
sikhi piarai wrote:
"Was teh beer that was ripped up lareedar saroop or padcheed? I am very confused because it says on other threads that only lareedar saroop was reall GUru.
Wot if this man has also been told the same and then thoght he wasn't ripping up THE SATGURU. Maybe he doesn't recognise his sin due to error?"
That's the absolute limit. I and other Singhs may believe that only Lareedaar Guru Granth Sahib jee should be installed, but I know that every single Singh who believes this would not stand for even a gutka or amrit keertan being dishonoured in any way. I don't care if someone rips a gutka, a pothi or pad-chhed saroop, any disrespect of bani is not tolerable.
The Panth stands united on this issue: no one can be allowed to disrespect bani in any way.
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
Harjas Kaur · 01 Oct 2005
[quote]Harjas Kaur Ji, your last response was hilarious! I think we should drown this boy because he seems to be possessed!
Irresponsible comments from individuals like you are the reason why mental health issues are not dealt with (within our community) and those with mental health issues within the Sikh community are so stigmatised.[/quote]
Enjoy your hilarity. I worked in a jail with criminally insane people. I know what unstable people with disorders of the brain are capable of. I didn't say drown him! I did say that if he is attacking Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, he is undoubtedly under evil influence.
You would be more than surprised how many violent assaults and murders are comiitted by unstable people. If he does an act this egregious, his judgement and anger are completely a threat. He should best be put out of the house before he harms someone. Believe me or not. There are thousands of cases of unpredictable violence, even torture and bizarre murder committed by the mentally ill. That's why they are sometimes kept on lockdown units.
[quote]Deinstitutionalization of the Mentally Ill:
The Crisis That No One Talks About
The final sign that something was going wrong in Ron's brain were casual acts of violence against complete strangers. I was with my father and Ron at the market. While my father was in the store, Ron suddenly jumped out of the car, ran over to a old man sitting on a bus bench, grabbed him by the shirt, pulled him up to a standing position, and punched him in the face, while making threats. When I asked Ron why he did that, Ron just laughed.
The violence escalated. He smashed in the windows of his car. Why? He gave evasive answers. One evening, I think on my 16th birthday, Ron for no apparent reason, packed a couple of suitcases, walked out the door in a huff, then returned a couple of minutes later -- and smashed in the front windows of the house we rented. From where we stood in the living room, we could see him kicking his suitcases across the lawn -- and the force that he was using was terrifying. My parents called the police. My brother stood on the front lawn grinning; about 45 minutes later, the police arrived -- just as my brother left.
During this period of a few weeks, there were repeated incidents of violence against strangers. I was scared, especially because my brother was saying some very weird, very strange things to me. My father put what was effectively a medieval castle bar across my bedroom door, giving me a little more sense of security.
Eventually, Ron reached a point where he went to talk to the community mental health center -- and they promptly decided that he was sufficiently dangerous to himself that they sent him to a mental hospital for observation. And this is where one tragedy -- my brother's descent into paranoid schizophrenia -- was compounded by another tragedy.
My brother was held for observation for 72 hours. Then, he was held for another 14 days for further observation and medication. But the psychiatrist in charge of our local hospital's locked ward told us that there was little chance of him being committed. As it was explained to my father, "By the time someone's been pumped full of Thorazine for 14 days, if they still seem dangerous to a judge, they have to be really dangerous." On at least one occasion, someone who purported to be an advocate for the rights of mental patients was present in court to make sure that all the i's were dotted and all the t's were crossed -- and that no one was locked up against their will in a mental hospital.
What? My brother attacked complete strangers for no reason whatsoever. He smashed in windows at our house, he was saying things that were clearly crazy, and he wasn't going to be kept in a mental hospital? Sad to say, this has been a recurring pattern of my brother's life ever since. He been arrested dozens of times for attacks on complete strangers. He has been arrested for all sorts of bizarre behaviors. He attacked my mother with a shovel once. He tried to strangle one of my sisters once. He tried to strangle our mother, a year later. He has lived in urine-soaked hotel rooms -- and sometimes he has been a homeless person...
One study completed in 1992 indicates that about 1000 murders a year are committed by mental patients who have refused treatment. Murder rates have fallen by about one-third since 1992, so those numbers may not still be accurate, but my point is that there are a lot of these murders by untreated mental patients.
I can point you to other examples of people who had come to the attention of the courts and were clearly insane, but were released. If they later commit a murder with a gun, they get a lot of attention, like Patrick Purdy, who murdered five children in Stockton in 1989. (Purdy's mental disability checks bought the guns he used in that schoolyard massacre.) Or the man with a 20 year history of mental illness-related crimes who murdered our landlord's daughter in Golden Gate Park in 1983, and wounded several others.
If they use a knife, they tend not to get the press coverage -- but the victims are still dead. How many of you saw the news story about Joshua Rudiger, arrested in San Francisco last year? The police charged him with murdering one homeless person, and trying to murder three others by slitting their throats. Rudiger explained to the police that he was a 2000 year old vampire. Oh yes, he had been in and out of mental hospitals for schizophrenia since he was 15, including an incident where he shot someone with a bow & arrow. For that incident he was ordered to receive treatment in a live-in treatment center -- and released! He never showed up, and no one went looking for him. Instead, he started killing people.
A couple of years ago, the pastor of the church that I attended asked me to talk to a man who had started attending our church. He was camping in a field behind our church, living out of a bicycle trailer with his dog. He didn't work; like many of the mentally ill living out of doors, he had a government mental disability check of about $600 a month. Ten minutes of conversation were quite sufficient to reveal his confused and irrational thinking; no surprise that he wasn't working.
He was upset that the courts had taken away his children away from him. Perhaps indicative of how disordered his thinking was, he showed me the paperwork that terminated his rights as a parent. The courts had taken away his children because he was showing them pornographic movies, then molesting them. Their mother was already in a mental institution.
You may ask, why didn't they prosecute this guy for child molestation and send him to prison? The children were five years old and younger. I speculate that it would have been a hard case to prove in a criminal trial; the children would have been further traumatized by preparing for the trial. Instead, they let this guy go. My wife still sees him bicycling around Rohnert Park with his dog. Doesn't that make you feel safe and secure?
http://www.claytoncramer.com/mental.htm[/quote]
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
kirtan singh · 01 Oct 2005
Ok i am not rss, I was born to sikh father hindu mother. True I am still in mouring because my mom worked so hard to make us successful. she loved my dad so much that she did not re marry. she was always looked down at whenever she went to gurudwara. we were treated as people who had no place in gurudwara. She then borrowed granth from her friend. she teaches the mukhi at home so i know every word. what have we done to sikhi that we are treated as harijans. lower cast. we still[mom, sister] collect and donate to dwara and now to hindu temple. if book says we are all equal then we should listen to the book, but we dont thats why i myself dont have respect.
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
we all got names · 01 Oct 2005
u know alot of people dont know what to do
so u got to understand from there point
think about it they did jap ji sahib did an ardaas
so u see they have respect for gurbani
maybe the lady didnt know what to do
like me anything that i ever get with gurbani written on it. even if its english translation i dont throw it away. it could be the smallest thing i dont throw it away even like wedding cards with gurbani on it or even ik onkar written on something. i put it in a box by the gutka's at home and cover it with something with respect. i dont know what to do with it. like calendars with gurbani written on it. i have no clue so i just keep them in a box and show as much respect as i can.
and if the guys mentally handicap
u cant get mad at them
they came to guru ji's house asking for forgiveness too
they admit fault
lets forgive and make sure it doesnt happen again
thats it
the gurudwara's should do katha on it
telling people what they are supposed to do
cuz most people dont know
u know if it was some other people that did it on purpose
like when i read the first post
all i thought was ak sentali
but then when the truth came out
we got to have compassion
Re: RIPPED UP GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI
.............................. · 02 Oct 2005
mate kirtan singh there's one thing I think u need to learn and that is to start to show some respect to Guru Ji, SrI Guru GRANTH Sahib JI is not a book, no matter what u maynot like about Guru Ji, they are still our Guru.
I'm sad to hear of your story but it doesnt stop Guru Being the Guru JI so please speak with respect.
The Guru is here to teach us, if some sikhs dont learn or treat others equally then how does that turn them into a mere book?
You may nt like the Guru, u may not believe in them but dont call the Guru a book.
Aboyut 'borrowing', that again is veryvery rude, please speak with some respect if u post again. Once again I can understand why u feel sad, or verysad, but that does not mean u talk disrespectfully about Guru Ji in front of the sangat, I'm sure you can say the same stuff in more respectful words ?
Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh