Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within
sort my life out · 21 Sep 2005
Considering some of the recent discussion on here; I thought the following posting from The Learning Zone might be of some interest.
Please focus on the substantive issue and not nit pick over any particular comments in the posting per se.
Posting follows:
"There is a growing problem of finding suitable matches for Sikh boys wearing even symbolic turbans. It is not unusual to see Sikh mothers coming to the Gurdwara with turban wearing cute little sons but with bare-headed daughters with cut hair-styles! (So, more scarves are kept outside the Gurwaras to cover heads.)
First immigrant generation Sikhs cut their hair because they could not get jobs. I saw youngish Sikhs in the early sixties weeping day and night after cutting their hair, ("I ca'nt bear to look at myslef in the mirror; what will my parents say back home?").
Today, I see young Sikh boys in a similar situation because they feel Sikh girls reject them outright as marriage partners. They start cutting their hair much against their own or their parents' wishes. They feel that it is the only way to get married. The question is, what sort of life partners would such girls make, whose pre-condition is the giving up of Sikh identity and, presumably, related family values and responsibilities? It should not come as a surprise that an increasing number of marriages break up within 6 months or one year. Just look at the matrimonial advertisements these days.
This should be a wake up call to Sikh girls looking for stable marriage partners. Please reflect: those turban wearing Sikh boys at least have the courage to announce their Sikh identity and hopefully, related family values to the world. Do not reject their Sikh identity without at least taking a closer look and comparing notes for compatability. Either you want a successful
married life or you do not. There must be a good reason why sometimes even a clean-shaven Sikh fathers, and many Sikh mothers want their sons to keep Sikh identity and values. Are they giving the same 'sikhia' to their daughters? "
Gurmukh Singh
Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within
Zorawar Singh · 21 Sep 2005
The problem here is a lack of parchaar of keski. These young girls have no role models that stand out to look up to. So many boys see Singhs in bana and are inspired. Bibian with keskis are rare, especially young ones who speak english.
Look at many young girls today, they have cut hair and also do not wear karas. You will see every boy, even a mona wears a kara. This shows the difference in pride of sikhi between mona boys and mona girls.
So girls have lost their identity. Their mothers have cut hair, so they copy.
The problem is further increased by sant baba followers, Uk nangs and others who are actively doing parchaar against keski. They complain that girls who wear keskis are not feminine enough. I do think these people want their wives to singhnis and also be bollywood.
Until we do not actively promote keskis for all Amritdhari bibis, more and more young punjabi girls will grow up knowing nothing about identity.
Muslims girls prey on this when they approach punjabi girls for convertions. I hope those sad people who are so anti-keski think about this, before they continue on their missions.
Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within
Confused Khalsa · 21 Sep 2005
I share very similar views to yourself jee.
If a person is willing to give up their Sikh identity, and go against their Guru in order to appease the opposite sex - what type of role model will they make for the couples children. what religion will they follow?
the one were you go to the gurudwara on sundays? - this reminds me of Guru Nanak Dev ji were he constantly denounced ritual worship. Doing something because everyone else does it, not really understand anything about it. Simply to save face....
Hopefully the next generation wont make the same mistakes that the older sikhs did, and sacrifice their sikhi for their wallets.
Sir Javay Ta Javai - Meri Sikhi Sidkh Na Jaavai
for the sake of Maya...
jugroop singh · 22 Sep 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
when Singhnis wear just a chunni, it is forever falling-off.
when they tie a patka, then their Joora is not sitting upon their Dasam Duaaar.
for the sake of worldly fashion, they are doing the following:
- becoming bare-headed in the presence of Siree Guru Sahib Ji and not being tyaar-bar-tyaar generally.
- not understanding the significance of Kes as the sanctified bodily part which sits upon the thrown of the Dasam Duaar. Kes is a supreme nishani of Siree Guru Sahib Ji's Kirpa - therefore his Nishani should sit upon the highest point of our body; why are we relegating it to 'behind the back of our head somewhere'?
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within
singhee laad · 22 Sep 2005
Legolas u said....
"I have never heard of any Sant Mahapursh doing "parchaar" against keski, infact all I have heard actively promote it, so stop with your idiotic lies!"
Pehova vala saad on his first visit to UK, at southall gurdwara spoke against jatha and keski, he said " these poeple (AKJ) want women to wear dastars, its equality they say, ok then for equality will the akj men wear suits and banga as well?" and "these people (akj) say you shouldn't do joth (diva) hindus do it, i say to them hindus do tutty (go toilet) why dont you stop that?"
He was challenged after the programme but would not talk to us....i heard this for myself not 2nd hand information.
Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within
sort my life out · 22 Sep 2005
I did say "Please focus on the substantive issue ..... "
Would that be too hard to do now?
Pretty pretty (pun intended) please!
Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within
Zorawar Singh · 23 Sep 2005
no lies here! one example has already been given. Others include in some universities girls are told them AKJ lot (i.e. keski wale girls) are fanatics, stay away from them. Uk nangs - everyone knows what they say about shaving kesh, wear keskis with lengas, so lets not even go there. Lastly the sant baba followers who go ape just at the mention of a keski.
If you are not going to promote the Khalsa Roop of a Bibi, then how do you expect young girls to be proud of being Sikhs?
Legolas wrote:
> Zorawar Singh, a person with such a beautiful name you do come
> out with some real ****.
>
> <<< The problem is further increased by sant baba followers, Uk
> nangs and others who are actively doing parchaar against keski.
> They complain that girls who wear keskis are not feminine
> enough. I do think these people want their wives to singhnis
> and also be bollywood. >>>>
>
> I have never heard of any Sant Mahapursh doing "parchaar"
> against keski, infact all I have heard actively promote it, so
> stop with your idiotic lies!
Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within
A Kaur (London) · 26 Sep 2005
WkKWkf
I have cut hair but I would like to meet a Keshdhari guy. I have met 3 to date and all 3 of them have acted and behaved irrationally not the way in which I would have expected. In actual fact, all 3 behaved worse than monay guys.
The question is - has this meant I am not interested in Keshdhari guys? The answer is no, I maintain an open mind.
Conclusion - why do we constantly have the pigeon hole people into boxes?
WkKWkf
Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within
A Kaur (London) · 27 Sep 2005
Stats and Jasmin
I have no issue with the fact that I cut my hair - and to be frank, I am not asking your opinion to whether I should or should not.
If you read properly, you shall see that I have stated that keshdhari men are not necessarily all sincere and innocent as they 'purport' to be. I have come across 3 whom all have lead 'dis-tasteful' lives and that has NOTHING to do with the fact that I cut my hair.
Finally, the way I follow the religion does not make it inappropriate for me to comment upon the usage of the Khanda.
Rather than make curt comments to me - and by the way, how can you two make comments about me when YOU do not even know me... TRY to focus on subject topics and grow up.
Thanking you for your useless input.
Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within
A Kaur (London) · 29 Sep 2005
Jasmin Ji
I respect that you are so religious and think you are have the right to suggest that I am 'smug'.... and that Keshdhari men may take an interest in me IF I were to change my ways? and my attitude may have offended these guys?
What planet are you on?
I am not even going to respond back to a person like you. To make such shallow, pathetic comments.. you are clearly trying to win 'brownie' points... Let me be the first to congratulate you!!!
Well done Jasmin!!!!!
A
Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within
A Kaur (London) · 29 Sep 2005
Stats Ji
Thanks for your long reply back.
The only comment I would make is that, this particular thread was about the Khanda NOT kesh or Keshdhari men.
Yes, this is the same A Kaur (London)....
I can face the heat in the kitchen so I won't shy away from comments which I percieve as unjustified.
[%sig%]
Re: Matrimonial threat to Sikh identity from within
A Kaur (London) · 29 Sep 2005
Stats Ji
Apologies – I realised whilst at lunch that I got the threads confused! Yep, shoot me down with an arrow (that was a joke).
Q: "Why would you feel one way about the Khanda and differently about Kesh?"
This is really a good question to me. It is really valid in sofar as from where you are sitting you probably see me as either a) confused or b) a walking and talking contradiction or c) stupid!.
To be perfectly honest, I do respect the Khanda and Kesh with the same principles. However, as I have chosen to cut my hair, I do not think that this removes the right for me to have objections to the Khanda being depicted on non Sikh websites, off licence stores etc.
As I am typing this, I really don’t have a valid argument either way and so I will not comment any further.
I know you and others will view this as cowardly but I will not rant and rave unless I have a plausible explanation.
WkKWkf