Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

Simran Singh · 09 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I am a 16 year old Sikh who tries to read and understand Gurbani. Often times when I read Asa Di Var I read lines that contradict common Sikh practices, such as the wearing of Bana (uniform) and thinking these are sacred. I asked some Sikhs about this and they said that the Bana is different for Sikhs, and it is holy for us compared to the Brahmin Bana. In essence, one Bana is false, while another is true. Why would Guru ji tell a certain people to remove their uniform, while recommend us to wear one? From what I understand, Gurbani conerns very little with the outside, and instead focuses on internal spirituality. I wear my Kara, Kirpan, Kanga, etc anyways. Again I dont know much about Gurbani and your responses/explanations would be appreciated. All of the principles in Gurbani I understand to be universal: one principle cannot be contradicted with another. Thus I think it is impossible that Guru ji could have told us to wear symbols. I still wear them every day, but I dont see the reason behind them. If I dont get a clear answer from this forum I may remove them altogether. These are the lines that I read that tell me not to wear symbols/uniforms. Bahar Dhoondat Buhat Dukh Pavaye. Searching for the Lord externally will bring much pain. Chodo Ves Bekh Chuturaee Dubidha Eh Phul Nahin Jeo Let go of outward symbols, thse will take you away from God and bear no fruit. Bhekhee prubhoo Na Labhaee You will not find God through symbols. Mathay Tilak Hath Mala Bana Gobind Ram Khilona Jana They wear a tilak on their heads and wear a specific uniform thinking that God will be pleased by these outward things. For this topic, I would appreciate it if everybody could cite at least one line from Gurbani. Gurbani is our ultimate Guru, everything else is below that from what I understand. We should constructively discuss through Gurbani, thus any recommendation/not recommendation of wearing symbols should come through Gurbani. I am searching for an answer from Gurbani. All of your help is appreciated, and I hope we can reach a decision on this through Gurbani. Age: 16 Gender: Male Bhul Chuk Maaf Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

moorakh · 09 Sep 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fatheh! gurmukh pyare veerjee, thank you for your post. from your post it seems to me that you are an intelligent person who uses gurbani as his support and is willing to live his life according to the guru's teachings. this is a very rare and special attitude and you are blessed by guru ji to be feeling this way. however, there is a shadow of kal jug above your head that is trying to take you away from your punj kakaars. right now you think that your thoughts of symbols and practicality and spirituality are real thoughts, practical thoughts, and they are supported by gurbani, but actually this is a dark cloud of maya and kaljug over your head that is trying to hide the divine light of guru ji's teachings from you. please allow me to explain in the next few paragraphs why the kakaars are an essential part of the sikh identity, why the asa di var shabads refer to a different concept, and how the sikh uniform is important to your spirituality. Firstly I would like to address the MISCONCEPTIONS because those are the foundation of your belief. First gurbani quote you gave was as follows: Bahar Dhoondat Buhat Dukh Pavaye. The interpretation of this is "by searching outwards, people have got a lot of pain." Does this mean searching for kakaars, or searching for God? The meaning of this shabad is that there is no need to go into forests, on mountains, or to try to reach some special physical place to meet God because God has made their home inside the human body. This shabad is for those people who think they can reach God by climbing a mountain, by staying under water, by hiding in a forest, or by going into outer space. This shabad does not have any relation to kakaars because kakaars are not used to find God. They are part of our uniform, which I will explain later in this post. The next shabad you gave is Chodo Ves Bekh Chuturaee Dubidha Eh Phul Nahin Jeo The intepretation of this is "Abandon these outward garments that are motivated by your cleverness and duality. There is no fruit from these." Does this mean that the kakaars are created from cleverness and duality? Guru Sahib made these kakaars. Did Guru Sahib have any cleverness or duality? This shabad refers to those people who try to use their outward appearance to fool others into thinking they are better, holier, nicer, richer, etc. This shabad is about abandoning false appearances and not cheating others. The only way that Kakaars can be a "false appearance" or a "bhekh" is when the person wears kakaars but is not a practicing Sikh. Otherwise, if you are a practicing Sikh then just like a police officer wears a police uniform, a army general wears a army uniform, a Sikh wears a Sikh uniform. This shabad has no relation to kakaars because kakaars are not motivated by cleverness, fraud, lying, or duality. The next shabad you gave is Bhekhee prubhoo Na Labhaee The interpretation of this is "You cannot find God by dressing like a holy person." This is absolutely true. You cannot find God just by wearing kakaars. However, that does not mean that the kakaars are useless. By the same token you could say that you cannot find the restaurant by getting in the car. Of course you need a map, of course you need directions, of course you need to drive the car. The same way, just having the punj kakaars will not help you reach God but using them to motivate your Sikhi, doing naam simran, doing nitnem, doing bhagti, and also representing your Sikh panth with your kakars, these things will make your spiritual life stronger and bring you closer to God. This shabad has no relation to the kakaars because most people do not just wear kakaars and then quit. They also practice Sikhi, which is assisted by their kakaars. The next shabad you gave is Mathay Tilak Hath Mala Bana Gobind Ram Khilona Jana The actual shabad is "Mathay Tilak Hath Mala Bana || Logan Ram Khilona Jana ||" The interpretation of this shabad is "People wear a tilak on their forehead, in their hand their have a mala, and they wear religious robes. People think that God is a toy." If you read this whole shabad you will realize that Bhagat Kabeer jee is speaking to those people who try to do things externally only, without having any faith on the inside. Bhagat Kabeer jee is saying that if you don't have faith and you don't do bhagti, then you cannot fool God. God is not a toy that you can just wear religious clothing and God will think you are religious. You need to have devotion as well. This shabad has nothing to do with the kakaars because firstly, people cannot fool God by wearing kakaars and pretending to be Sikhs. Secondly, wearing kakaars is not the end of the road. From the day you become amritdhari to the day you die, the kakaars are with you as a motivation for your Sikhi. Thirdly, those people who use their kakaars for the right reasons actually become more spiritual and become closer with God. Now, did Guru ji ever actually say that you should wear kakaars? Guru Gobind Singh Ji says in the following shabad that a person should take amrit from five khalsas and accept their given rehit. guru ji says never stay without weapons and without weapons and kes, a human is naked. guru ji says "This is my Will - listen my Dear Sikh - without weapons and kes - I cannot give you my blessings." Guru ji says, this is my command and those who follow it will have happiness. [gurbani] pWc isMG AMimRq jo dyvYN qW ko isr Dr Ck pun lyvY ][/gurbani] paa(n)ch si(n)gh a(n)mrith jo dhaevai(n) thaa(n) ko sir dhhar shhak pun laevai || [gurbani] pun iml pWco rihq jo BwKY qW ko mn myN idRV kr rwKY ][/gurbani] pun mil paa(n)cho rehith jo bhaakhai thaa(n) ko man mae(n) dhrirr kar raakhai || [gurbani] puMn sMg swry pRBU jI sunweI ibnw qyg qIrM rho nWh BweI ][/gurbani] pu(n)n sa(n)g saarae prabhoo jee sunaaee binaa thaeg theera(n) reho naa(n)h bhaaee || [gurbani] ibnw SSqR kysM nrM Byf jwno ghY kwn qW ko ikqY lY isDwno ][/gurbani] binaa shashathr kaesa(n) nara(n) bhaedd jaano gehai kaan thaa(n) ko kithai lai sidhhaano || [gurbani] iehY mor AwigAw suno hy ipAwry ][/gurbani] eihai mor aagiaa suno hae piaarae || [gurbani] ibnw qyg kysM idvo n dIdwry ][/gurbani] binaa thaeg kaesa(n) dhivo n dheedhaarae || [gurbani]iehY mor bYnw mMnY su joeI iqsY ie~C pUrI sBY jwn soeI ][/gurbani] eihai mor bainaa ma(n)nai s joee thisai eshh pooree sabhai jaan soee || There are many other examples of rehitnamas by Bhai Daya Singh ji and others who have said that the five kakaars are required by us for our uniform. But how do these help us in spirituality? Kes - simran. The main function of kes is simran. Kes is an extension of your soul and every kes does simran along with your inner voice. Kes is the stamp of a God-abiding person who lives in hukam and does not desecrate the natural form that God gave them. Gurbani shabads about hukam, simran, and bhagti all relate to this. Kanga - purity. The main function of kanga is to clean your kes. However it is an emblem of purity. If you keep your kes clean, while you are cleaning your kes you should be thinking of your Creator and cleaning your soul so that you can meet with your creator. Kanga is the stamp of a spiritually clean person who takes care of this temple-body in which God resides. Gurbani shabads about "greh mandir" and being clean on the inside relate to this. Kachhera - grihst jeevan. The main function of the kachera is to protect your private areas from exposure. The private areas being exposed causes embarrassment and also it only happens if you are going to the washroom, changing your kachhera, or having sex with your marriage partner. Wearing kachhera reminds a Sikh of their loyalty to their spouse, and their discipline in married life. The kachhera is the stamp of a disciplined person who lives in this world, but doesn't become absorbed in the bad ways of the world. Gurbani shabads about loyalty, grihst jeevan, and honesty relate to this. Kara - discipline. The main functions of the kara are to show your identity as a Sikh and to prevent you from mistakes. All actions begin with thoughts. Thoughts are turned into actions mostly by your hands. Your hands have karas, which remind you of who owns you. Who is your Guru. The kara is universal, never-ending, like your master. The kara is sarbloh, it can get stained if you don't care for it - like your rehit. The kara is the stamp of a person who is married to Akaal purakh, who does not take actions without reflecting on Guru's hukam, and who is focused on what their purpose is in the world. Gurbani shabads about slave to god, bride of God, and hukam are related to this. Kirpan - grace and honour. The main function of the kirpan is to protect yourself and others in case of life-threatening dangers. The kirpan is also used in gatka demonstrations, or for bhog of langar and degh. The kirpan represents God and the Guru. If you do kirpan bhet to food, it is considered equal to Guru Sahib taking part of the food. Kirpan is considered a representative of the Guru - it can give life or take life. It can rescue or destroy. Kirpan by your side reminds you of your duty in this world, and your responsibility to remain in control of your actions and to be brave in the face of oppression. Kirpan is the emblem of a person who stands up for human rights, who is loyal to the Guru, and who has strength and power but will use for the right cause. Gurbani shabads about spiritual warrior, protection of innocents, and standing against evil are related to this. Keski - royalty. The main function of the keski is to cover and protect your kes. Keski is worn by Gursikhs to show respect for their kes and their dasam duar. Tying a keski reminds you that you are a royal knight, a son in the universal royal army of Guru Gobind Singh and Mata Sahib Kaur. A keski reminds you to assert your rights, protect others rights, and to be united with your Sikh panth. Keski reminds you to never bow to worldly rulers, and never be oppressed or discouraged by political battles. Keski reminds you to be in Guru's hukam, and that your head belongs to the Guru. Keski is an emblem of a person who is sovereign, and will not be oppressed, but will not oppress others. Gurbani shabads about spiritual people being royalty, and spiritual people looking nice in God's court are related to this. Lastly, veerjee, when you wear your kakaars people recognize you as a Sikh. This makes you responsible for your actions. When you are responsible for your actions - what does that mean? That means that you must follow Gurbani. Therefore, wearing your kakaars makes you liable to follow Gurbani. Without kakaars, we are showing that we belong to Kal jug, not to Guru ji. If we belong to Guru ji and we are part of Guru ji's army then we wear kakaars and we follow Gurbani - one motivates the other. I hope this post has been helpful and I invite you to respond with any other comments or questions, or what you think about what i have said here. please forgive my mistakes Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fatheh! [%sig%]

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

Jasmin · 09 Sep 2005

Dear Simran Singh- The above is a beautiful and true post. I hope you read it carefully and reflect deeply upon it.

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

Simran Singh · 09 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh "Moorakh" Veerji: Thank you for your response. It is clear that your interpretations of the lines is different and directs them towards others, but not Sikhs. However, it is important to understand the context in which they are written. During this time, Sikhs were pure and followed only Guru's path. People of other faiths were putting on symbols and religious robes and claiming them to have spiritual significance. Guru Sahib refuted these people and took away these uniforms. In your response you state "Otherwise, if you are a practicing Sikh then just like a police officer wears a police uniform, a army general wears a army uniform, a Sikh wears a Sikh uniform." Why is Guru Sahib supposedly telling Brahmins to take off their uniform, while telling us to wear it? Could this happen? Never......... The lines that you state are not from Gurbani, but from other respected Gursikhs. While I respect them I do not hold them at the same level as our Guru Sahibaan....Guru Gobind Singh Ji himself said "Guru Manayo Granth." He intended us only to follow Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. The original posts asks for lines from Gurbani. Thank you again for your response, I will consider what you said, however the original statement still stands until it is refuted by Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Bhul Chuk maaf Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

charanjeev singh · 09 Sep 2005

Simran Singh, waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh The Panj Kakaars that were given to you from Guru Sahibhaan, are the true baana, and not cholas etc. This is the true baana; because they each serve a very important purpose for the inner being, for which you have stated is the true paath of sikhi. Each kakaar that has been given serve many many purposes for the inner soul. Very briefly Kesh: this is the inner practice of being loyal to the Guru and God, and accepting God's will or Hukam to keep what God has given us. Changing the Kesh is falling inwardly discrediting Gods gift living out of Hukam, which is the cause of all dukh. Very importantly, the Guru has said, that Kesh is my Mohr (stamp), meaning that a Sikh can only be Sikh if he/she has my Mohr. The Guru has further stated, that without Kesh and Shastar do not show me your face, or give me your darshan. (Ehai Morh Agyaa Suno Hey Pyareh. Bina Shastar Keshang Devo Na Didhaareh) Kanga: the kanga is very significant and important. it is representing cleanings of inner self and as well taking care of the outer gift of kesh, which without a person cannot be spiritual no matter how much one may try. the kanaga is also made of wood, joining us together with the earth, where we are one. every time we kanga our kesh, kesh that comes out also is showing us in the same way our innerself should be cleaned of the vices of kaam, krodh, lobh, moh, and hankaar. the kanga is very very important for a spirtual Gursikh. Kara: extremely important. it is firstly made of sarbloh, or iron, to remind us that we live in the iron age or kaljug. it reminds us of our duties to do good karam, sort of like God's handcuff. it also reminds us that God Waheguruu was always around from the beginning and will be true infinitless, and that is why the Kara does not have any beginning or end. it is very very important for a spiritual person to wear a kara. it represents the inner conciousness. Kirpaan: this is a very very important kakaar for a Gursikh to have. as humans beings, we have all been given 5 vices. They are as you know kaam krodh lob moh and hankaar; lust anger greed attachment and pride. krodh or anger is something that is very destructive. that is why there are many wars where innocents are killed brutally, and raped. this is why there is no social or political equalities in humankind. anger causes many many disfunctions in one self as well as society at large. The Guru gave us a Kirpaan to replace this bad krodh with defence for the depressed. it is very important for a spiritual person to be ready to protect the innocent people, and the kirpaan gives us this gift of spirituality to become Gods people. it is very important for a spiritual person to have a kirpaan. Kachera: everybody has a lot of lust. lust is something that can ruin a person for lifetimes, just because of a few moments, even seconds of false pleasure. the Guru gave us a gift to remind our innerself to be aware of these serpant like sins, and gave us a kacheraa. this kacheraa also must protect us from outwardly doing lustful acts, as well as protect us from inwardly lustful thoughts. it is very important for a spiritual person to have a kachera. also, the kacheraa keeps us always covered, and is stable and will not unwind, or fall, or make us naked even if we are running, horseback riding, wrestling, fighting in war, or even just doing housework. the kachera is so important as well as the shastar that Bhai Gurdas Jee in var. 41 pauri 15 says (seel jat kee kach pehar pakreoh hateaaraa. Translated it is: The sign of true chastity is the Kashera, you must wear this and hold weapons in hand ) the panj kakaars have many many many more reasons than the reasons mentioned above. these kakaars in essence are the true baana, for they represent inside spirituality while making us to be cautious of outwardly actions or karam the panj kakaars are very significant for inner spirituality. when it comes to wearing a chola, or malas, or chakars, they are nice to wear, it brings a sense of brotherhood to the khalsa, a uniform, a sign of high spirits. however, they are not needed to be a spiritual person. the 5 kakaars are. they will be some people on this board, who will begin to argue about keski being the kakaar and not the kesh. the panj kakaars that have been described very briefly are as ordained by the Akaal Takhat Sahib, which was as you know given this title and constructed by Waheguruu Himself in the form of Guru Hargobind Sahib. however, keeping the kesh covered is very important as you know. The Guru has also said 'Saabat Soorat Dastaar Sira'. As you have mentioned Guru Sahib saying, that looking outwardly brings alot of pain. this is the truth. however, the Kakaars, as mentioned above are actually gifts to look inwardly. < sRI vwihgurU jI kI Pqih ] sRi muKvwk pwiqswhI 1oooooo0 ] inswin isKI eIN pMj hriP Asq kwP ] hrigj nw bwsd eIN pMj muAwP ] 1] kVw kwrdo k`C kMGy ibdW ] iblw kys hyc Asq jumly insW ] 2] hrP hkwieq Asq AjI pMj kwP] ibdw nMd bwvr n goXm iKlwP ] 3] hu`kw hjwmq hlwlo hrwm ] bwrIsy ihnw krd rU isXw Pwm ] 4] 1] (AsPokt sÍYXy, sRI dsm gRMQ) The following five K's are the mark of Sikhi.These five can never be parted from the body. Kara, Kirpan, Kashera, Kangha, recognise these as four of them.The fifth is Kesh, without which the other four are useless. There are also four H's which must be avoided. Understand this without any doubt, no lies have been told. Hukka, taking tobacco (including any other type of intoxicants). Hajamat, removing of hair. Halalo, eating meat. Haram, adultery (sexual relationships outside of marriage). These are the four H's. Dyeing of beards (including any other body hair), and the wearing of mehndi (including other types of make up) are strictly forbidden. (Sri Dasam Granth) If the above does not show in Gurmukhi, you may view this shabad at http://www.damdamitaksal.com/lit_basicsfivek.htm Bhul chuk maaf karna waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

moorakh · 09 Sep 2005

Veerjee, waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh! thank you very much for your honest reply. firstly let me address your concern about hypocracy in updesh. Guru Maharaj would never give updesh to one person, and different to another person. Guru Sahib says: bani prabh kee sabh ko bolai aap addol na kabhoo dolai This Bani of God Speaks to Everyone God is Stable and so therefore Bani is also Stable This message in Gurbani is for all people. Guru Ji never told anybody to do "thiaag" of their uniform. In fact, the "Brahmin" people do not have a uniform. They have all different types of uniforms and they do not have a consistent one. But even if you can find something consistent, like a tilak, and a mala, then let us consider this: If a Brahmin wears "uniform" for Brahmin religion, but he is corrupt, then Guru ji will say: "Why are you wearing that uniform? You are actually corrupt." In the same way, If a Sikh wears "uniform" for the Sikh faith, but he is corrupt, then Guru ji will say: "Why are you wearing that uniform? You are actually corrupt." Guru ji's hukam is not different for different people. However it is different based on your avastha. Some hukams of Guru ji are more relevant to people with higher avastha, and some with lower avastha. For example, a person who is addicted to Kaam may learn his lesson if he reads a shabad about Kaam, while a person who is addicted to Krodh may learn his lesson if he reads a shabad about Krodh - even though Gurbani does speak to all people, everybody gets something different from it. In the case of Gursikhs wearing Bana, Guru ji is never telling anybody in Gurbani to *not* wear their religious clothing. Guru ji is saying that religious clothing alone cannot help you reach God. However, in the kal jug, Guru ji themselves have created such an institution that there are things that work together to help you to have a higher spiritual level and to reach God. These things include: 1) Gurbani 2) Gurmantar Vaheguru 3) Khande-ke-pahul 4) Punj Kakaars 5) Amrit Vela Now out of these you will say three are not valid. Why? Because three of these are not really mentioned in Guru Granth Sahib Ji. 1) Gurmantar Vaheguru 2) Khande-ke-pahul 3) Punj Kakaars There is an explanation for this. These three factors are directly for the Sikh community. Guru Granth Sahib ji is "sarab sanjhi gurbani" and it does not try to convert other people into Sikhs. If there was mention of Gurmantar Vaheguru, that would mean that all other people of other religions should drop their Guru's mantar and adopt Gurmantar Vaheguru. Second, if there was mention of khande-ke-pahul, that would mean that all people should drop their baptism ceremony of their religion, and take khande-ke-pahul. Third, if there was mention of punj kakaars, that would mean all people should drop their other uniforms and wear punj kakaars. However, Guru Granth Sahib ji contains gurbani that is relevant to all people from all walks of life, not just Sikhs. That is why these things are not mentioned here. However, there is a code for Sikhs. You know that Guru Hargobind Sahib introduced the concept of Miri and Piri. Miri is the concept of "meer" or political sovereignty and royalty. Piri is the concept of "peer" or spiritual devotion and discipline. Now, without the spiritual, there cannot be physical. However, in this world, physical is also needed to give structure to the spiritual. That is why we have "Miri Piri." Now, where Guru Gobind Singh ji said "Guru Manio Granth" -- that is not in Guru Granth Sahib Ji, so why do you follow it? You follow it because at that time, Guru Gobind Singh ji was on the "Gurgadhi", and he gave a hukam that from now on "Guru Manio Granth." And you, being a devoted Sikh, follow Guru's hukam. So you listened and now you accept Guru Granth Sahib Ji as your Guru - because Guru Gobind Singh ji said that you should do this. However, Guru Gobind Singh ji wrote many things while they were on "Gurgadhi" and you should follow those as "hukam" as well. Guru Gobind Singh Ji's bachans, Bhai Gurdas Ji's vaars, Bhai Nand Lal ji's vaars, and Bhai Daya Singh Ji's rehatnamas are like the "Piri" where Gurbani is the Miri. Where Guru Gobind Singh ji said "Guru Manio Granth," they also said "Khalsa Mero Satgur Poora" Who is the Khalsa? Khalsa is the sovereign property of the Guru - the Guru's devoted Sikhs - the Guru's children, such as Bhai Gurdas Ji, Bhai Nand Lal Ji, Bhai Daya Singh ji. Therefore, following Dasam Bani and the banis of those great Gursikhs is also in hukam for us because - no - those banis are not equivalent to Guru Granth Sahib Ji, just like Piri is not 100% at par with Miri, but they are extremely important for your spiritual advancement. If you avoid them, you are avoiding a large part of the Sikh teachings. In those banis, it does say that "Vaheguru" is the gurmantar - it does say you must take khande-ke-pahul, and it does say you must wear the punj kakaars. And these things are all said in Guru Gobind Singh ji's bani and by the punj pyare. So if you feel that you are a Guru-ka-Sikh, then the form of the guru is also Guru Gobind Singh ji and the punj pyare. Following their hukam is equal to following Gurbani of Guru Granth Sahib ji. You said that Guru Gobind Singh ji instructed us to only follow Guru Granth Sahib Ji. This is correct, and incorrect. Guru Gobind Singh ji instructed us to believe in only Guru Granth Sahib Ji as our Guru. But that does not mean that other writings such as Dasam Bani, Bhai Gurdas Ji's vaars, Bhai Nand Lal ji's vaars, and Bhai Daya Singh ji's rehatnamas are not applicable to us. Do you know that after 1699, many times when Sangat would come to visit Guru Gobind Singh ji and ask Guru ji to give them some divine command or some teaching, Guru ji would ask them to get a divine teaching from Bhai Daya Singh ji. That is how much love and respect Guru Gobind Singh ji had for his Khalsa. So Guru ji also wants you, his beloved Gursikh, to take the guidance and advice of his Khalsa - especially those whose writings have been accepted by the whole Khalsa Panth. Not just that, but Guru ji wants you to listen to Guru ji - and it is Guru Gobind Singh ji themselves that have written that you have to 1) listen to your punj pyare, 2) take khande-ke-pahul, and 3) wear the punj kakaars. So if you feel you are a Guru-ka-Sikh, then listen to Guru Gobind Singh ji, whose light is in Guru Granth Sahib ji. And for that - you only need this Gurbani proof: "So Sikh Sakha Bandap Hai Bhaee Jo Gur Kay Bhaanay Vich Aavai Apnay Bhaanai Jo Chalai Bhaee Vichhar Chottaa Khaavai" please forgive my mistakes, Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh ! [%sig%]

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

Sakhi · 09 Sep 2005

Veer Simran Singh Ji, Gurbani is not asking the brahmins to take there uniform off, he is asking them not to misrepresent themselves by wearing these uniforms and appearing holy. The pankiti is targeted towards imposters not actual bhagats.

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

... · 09 Sep 2005

'Sakhi' is absolutley right.

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

jugroop singh · 10 Sep 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Dearest Little Veer Simran Singh Ji, i wish i was as blessed as you - being able to read GurBani at the age of 16! Veer Ji, Veer/Bhain 'Saakhi' Ji has made the most pertinent point; the issue Siree Guru Sahib Ji is pointing to is hypocrisy - appearing to be one thing on the outside when in fact, that person is the complete opposite on the inside. in Anaand Sahib are contained many answers. regarding your query, a very definite answer lies in the three Pauris that deal with internal and external appearances - found on Ang 919: " By religious rituals, intuitive poise is not found; without intuitive poise, skepticism does not depart. Skepticism does not depart by contrived actions; everybody is tired of performing these rituals. The soul is polluted by skepticism; how can it be cleansed? Wash your mind by attaching it to the Shabad, and keep your consciousness focused on the Lord. Says Nanak, by Guru's Grace, intuitive poise is produced, and this skepticism is dispelled. - Inwardly polluted, and outwardly pure. Those who are outwardly pure and yet polluted within, lose their lives in the gamble. They contract this terrible disease of desire, and in their minds, they forget about dying. In the Vedas, the ultimate objective is the Naam, the Name of the Lord; but they do not hear this, and they wander around like demons. Says Nanak, those who forsake Truth and cling to falsehood, lose their lives in the gamble. - Inwardly pure, and outwardly pure. Those who are outwardly pure and also pure within, through the Guru, perform good deeds. Not even an iota of falsehood touches them; their hopes are absorbed in the Truth. Those who earn the jewel of this human life, are the most excellent of merchants. Says Nanak, those whose minds are pure, abide with the Guru forever". " Veer Simran Singh Ji, tell us what you think these three Pauris mean to you and then we can discuss. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

Singh · 10 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Veer Simran Singh Ji I too have doubted the place of wearing symbols in Gurbani. This is because when I go to the gurdwara, I bow only to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, indicating tht I only follow what my Guru says. As for stories (history) and the dasam granth, these both contain and promote some anti-sikh practices. In fact, the only authenticated writings of Guru Gobind Singh Ji are Jaap Sahib Akal Ustat and Shabad Hazarey. If we follow dasam granth, it will lead us to bathing in holy places (antigurmat) and worshipping Hindu Gods (antigurmat) and other profanities. History also contains some antigurmat statements such as the ideas that the Gurus had more than one wife. If we begin to look to other things except Gurbani, it will only lead to confusion. Gurbani is the ultimate source of wisdom. And so far in Gurbani I have found absolutely no promotion of wearing symbols, although I may be wrong. A few points that Moorakh veerji wrote that I found differently: Chodo Ves Bekh Chuturaee Dubidha Eh Phul Nahin Jeo The intepretation of this is "Abandon these outward garments that are motivated by your cleverness and duality. There is no fruit from these." Actually I found the original interpretation to be more accurate. Guru Sahib is listing what we need to give up. Chodo (give up): ves (symbols), Bhekh (symbols), Chururaee (duality), <

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

Simran Singh · 12 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Thank you for assisting me in determining what best to do in light of Gurbani. I think we have gained a lot from this discussion through Gurbani. In the future I hope we can continue to use Gurbani to discuss instead of other things such as history, dasam granth, etc. which contain some things against the Guru's teachings. The Sri Guru Granth Sahib is not incomplete that we must turn to other sources for wisdom. Guru Sahib left no doubt for us what to do. PrIdw pwiV ptolw Dj krI kMblVI pihryau ] fareedhaa paarr pattolaa dhhaj karee ka(n)balarree pehiraeo || Fareed, I have torn my clothes to tatters; now I wear only a rough blanket. ijn@I vysI shu imlY syeI vys kryau ]103] jinhee vaesee sahu milai saeee vaes karaeo ||103|| I wear only those clothes which will lead me to meet my Lord. ||103|| mÚ 3 ] ma 3 || Third Mehl: kwie ptolw pwVqI kMblVI pihryie ] kaae pattolaa paarrathee ka(n)balarree pehiraee || Why do you tear apart your fine clothes, and take to wearing a rough blanket? nwnk Gr hI bYiTAw shu imlY jy nIAiq rwis kryie ]104] naanak ghar hee bait(h)iaa sahu milai jae neeath raas karaee ||104|| O Nanak, even sitting in your own home, you can meet the Lord, if your mind is in the right place. ||104|| In this shabad, Fareed jee strayed somewhat from the Guru's beliefs by saying that we should wear tattered clothes thinking that they will lead us to God. Guru Amar Das immediately inserts a line saying that tattered clothes and outward things play no part in spirituality. This line demonstrates the extent the Gurus went to give us a clear message that outward things are unnecessary and need not be worn. For this reason it is only through our own manmat that we stray from Gurbani. Gurbani's stance on symbols is clear: they are unnecessary and direct our attention away from God. Thus my conclusion is to wear only those things that have some function and not insult Guru sahib by wearing them as symbols (for example attaching a small kirpan to a necklace as Bhekh), although I may be wrong. If someone can give a line from Gurbani supporting the wearing of symbols I will change it. I hope that others will follow in doing the same and lead their lives through Gurbani. Bhul chuk Maaf Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

... · 12 Sep 2005

Simran Singh, I'll give you a short reply based on what I have learned. Guruship by Guru Gobind Singh was given to the Khalsa in the tabiyaa of Guru Granth Sahib. The Khalsa or Guru Panth is something that tells us about rehit and things like this. Guru Granth Sahib doesn't tell us specifics of rehit like how or who to give dasvandh, how to matha tek, how to respect Guru Granth Sahib, and other such things. Guru Khalsa Panth is in Tabiya to answer these questions. Can you get naam by just appearing before Guru Granth Sahib at Gurdwara Sahib? No. You must get naam from Satguru Granth Sahib when the Punj Pyaaray are present and in attendance. If that doesn't convince you, then look at the sakhees who are beloved to Guru Sahib. Look at those who have please our master. What did they do? They all kept these rehits. Guru Sahib wasn't against symbols He was against the use of empty symbols and the belief that these were enough to lead to liberation. In of themselves they are not useful for liberation. But when we attach a meaning to them and incorporate them into our lives as tools they have a big meaning. If Guru Sahib was against symbolism and rituals, why did he himself use the Guruship ceremony? Why did he use Charan Pahul as an initiation? Don't think too much. Follow those that have followed this path before you and are following it now. Are you really capable of creating your own path? Think about it.

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

Sakhi · 12 Sep 2005

Veerji, All of our kakaars have a very specific purpose, to learn more please visit following topics on this forum. http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=34378&t=34184#reply_34378 http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=41820&t=41527#reply_41820

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

moorakh · 12 Sep 2005

Simran Singh veerjee, Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh! Although I have made efforts to convince you, it will only be with Guru's own kirpa that they will remove this cloud of kaljug from your mind. I understand what you are saying that wearing kakaars in a symbolic way, for example, as a necklace, is inappropriate. However, wearing proper kakaars is not manmat, actually it is central to the Sikh identity. Guru Gobind Singh Sahib also gave the title of "Guru" to the Khalsa and therefore the Khalsa is not incomplete or insufficient either. Therefore the hukams from the Sarbat Khalsa Panth and from Guru Gobind Singh Ji are also just as valid as the hukams in Guru Granth Sahib ji. If Guru Gobind Singh ji said to keep shastars and kes and to take khande-ke-pahul, then that is hukam of the Guru. If you believe Guru Gobind Singh ji is the same Guru as Guru Granth Sahib ji, then you must be obligated to follow your Guru's hukams. Just because somebody has convinced you that Dasam Granth Sahib has anti-gurmat teachings, does not mean that everything in Dasam Granth Sahib is anti-gurmat. If you think this way then you should stop (actually wait, forgive me..) you would hypothetically stop reading Jaap Sahib, Akaal Ustat, Zafarnama, etc. However you cannot stop reading these as they do not become changed just because you believe another part of Dasam Granth Sahib is altered. In the same way, Guru Sahib's hukams are constant, unwavering, and infinitely true. If you choose to ignore them, and roll the dice on your rehit, that is your choice. Please know that when you take the "support of Gurbani" then you are taking the "support of the Guru" and if you want to be true Sikh of the Guru, then you must follow hukams of the Guru. And it is hukam of Guru Gobind Singh ji that we must take khande-ke-pahul, listen to our Punj Pyare, wear shastars, and keep our kes uncut. please forgive my mistakes pyario - I wish you best Sikhi jeevan filled with bani, bana, seva, simran. Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh!

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

A Singh · 12 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I agree with Simran Singh--Gurbani is our only guru. It is 100% complete. No need to refer to other things. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

moorakh · 12 Sep 2005

Yes, Guru GRanth Sahib ji is my Guru. No, Guru Granth Sahib ji is not incomplete. However, Guru Gobind Singh ji is inside of Guru Granth Sahib ji. So following Guru Gobind Singh ji's hukams is equal to following Guru Granth Sahib ji because they are *ONE guru* So if Guru Gobind Singh ji said to take khande-ke-pahul, and listen to your punj pyare, and keep kes and shastars, then ... ? In the entire universe I would only accept the teachings of Guru Granth Sahib ji. But I am also subject to the hukams of the Guru Khalsa Panth. Guru Gobind Singh ji says "Khalsa Mero Satgur Poora" What about "Rehni Rehae Soee Sikh Mayraa Ohu Sahib Mai Us Ka Chayraa" What about the line we read every day in Ardas We say "Guru Granth Ji Manio Pragatt Guraa Kee Dayh" but in the ORIGINAL writings it says "Agya Bhaee Akaal Kee Thab hee chalaaio Panth Sabh Sikhan Ko Hukam Hai Guru Manio Granth Guru PANTH jee manio pragat Guraa Kee Dayh Jo prabh ko mil bo chahai Khoj SHABAD mai layh" this is the original version, showing that Guru is Granth and Guru's body is Panth

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

Ek Kaur · 13 Sep 2005

Dear Simran Singh you are half my age yet ten-fold my superior in that you are able to read, understand and apply our Guru’s teachings to your life. I possess only a small amount of understanding of Sikhi and of our Guru and therefore I will not attempt to quote Guru Sahib in supporting my comments. Veer ji / bhenji who humbly but incorrectly entitle themselves moorakh made distinct and fundemental point in their second post. Why do we accept Guru Granth Sahib ji as our living Guru? Because Guru Gobind Singh ji told us “Guru Maniyo Granth”? Guru Gobind singh ji gave us the five K’s too, so why question this when we do not question “Guru Maniyo Granth”? Is it because our now living guru (Guru Granth Sahib ji) does not tell us we should keep the five K’s? In which case does our living tell us "Guru Maniyo Granth"? True; Guru Nanak wore neither a janeo nor a karha. But Guru Nanak needed neither. True; Guru Nanak questioned false representation but Guru Nanak questioned the reason for wearing the symbol. Guru Nanak deconstructed failing systems of belief in order to reconstruct a faith in God. But later Guru Gobind Singh reconstructed a way of life that would be applicable to all ages of humanity. From what I have learned (all-be-it by word of history), Guru Gobind Singh ji gave us the five k’s to consolidate our beliefs. They are supposed to remind us of pious and non-pious actions and aid our conduct in daily lives. They are to be worn by us to remind us of who we are and what we stand for. They are not functionless symbols to the outer world – IF however the latter is your reason for wearing them… then, don’t wear them because then indeed you are adhering to a practice that Guru Granth Sahib ji condemns. I made the same mistake that you are talking about making. I took amrit at the age of nine of my own free will and choice. I threw it away at probably around your age by thinking “I don’t need the 5K’s to be close my Waheguru” and I removed all except my Kesh and Karha. Many years later I came to recognise the significance the K’s have in leading a specifically pious way of life which is available only through rehat maryada. Yes you may be able to live out rehat maryada without the symbolism but it’s tough doing this on your own. A Gursikh recognises a Gursikh through noticing the Bana. In losing the Bana you may lose valuable Gursikh company that will motivate you to live your life under Sikh Maryada and will motivate you to do naam simran.. and will motivate you to remember your lord Waheguru. Simran, Many people have put in time, effort, heart and soul in writing to you. This is for a reason. It pains a Gursikh to lose a Gursikh brother or sister. By all means continue in your quest for the truth and reason behind Bana but pleeeaaase don’t throw it away without understanding its value both to you as a person and to society at large.

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

charanjeev singh · 13 Sep 2005

Simran Singh writes: "Thus my conclusion is to wear only those things that have some function and not insult Guru sahib by wearing them as symbols (for example attaching a small kirpan to a necklace as Bhekh)" It seems that Simran Singh Veerji has indeed realized the funtions of the panj kakaars, and has concluded that they are indeed very important and serve as functional spirtitual gifts and aids insteads of being mere symbols. I think the lesson here is not to be wear the kakaars as mere symbols, but to realize their functionality and apply them to the art of living. Awesome. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

Sakhi · 13 Sep 2005

Simran Singh Ji, Why do you believe in Guru Granth Sahib Ji? Who asked you to consider them Guru? It was Guru Gobind Singh Ji....so how can we pick and choose the hukams we want to follow. We should follow all hukams of all our Gurus, we can't just say, fine we'll consider "Guru manyo Granth" but not anything else. [%sig%]

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

kksingh · 13 Sep 2005

So now we find so many contradictions. Man made wrtings dont hold water. Koran, grnath, bible then seem to be very confusing. so many denominations in christinity because so many wrote in bible each telling opposite of the other. in Koran same thing sunni , shiet and others. and in sikhi so many divisions. I think I will go to no religion. cut my hair, and follow life of nature. May the great being bless you all. simran jee you are young and smart run man run. we are having so much fighting all calling other idiot. run and belive in truth. the nature.

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

singh · 13 Sep 2005

kk, what contradictions are you finding? Someone can find a problem in anything if they're looking for one. To me Guru Sahib's condemnation of empty symbols is not even remotely problematic. It makes total sense. You want to cut your hair to "follow life of nature". Right. Which animal in nature have you seen with cut hair? How is cutting hair in any way linked to living a natural life? Wouldn't the opposite make sense? I think we have to stop losing sleep over statements like this. I think as Sikhs we have a duty to help clear confusion but if someone is adamant of ruining their spiritual lives, what can we do? I personally don't lose much sleep over it. Some people's karma just don't have Sikhi in them. Too bad for them but such is reality. So kk, I suggest you take a look at Sikhi again and realise that the fault is in your 'mat'. Otherwise good luck in "the nature".

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

charanjeev singh · 13 Sep 2005

"I think I will go to no religion. cut my hair, and follow life of nature" cutting your hair is doing exactly the opposite of what you are saying. following nature is allowing your kesh to grow naturally. so therefore i am confident that you will do what you preach, and hence you will follow the rules of nature and keep your kesh. There are two parts to a perfect human being. One is living within the self, and one is living in the world. They go hand in hand. That is why we have Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib, and Sri Harmandir Sahib. One is living in the world (Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib), and one is spiritual and living within the soul (Sri Harmandir Sahib). Very beautifully, Guru Hargobind Sahib made the Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib in such a way, that from the Takhat Sahib you would can see Sri Harmandir Sahib (rules of living will be made with the guidance of spirtual truth; however, from Sri Harmandir Sahib, you cannot see Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib (while meditating there is no distractions of any sort, there is perfect samaadhi) Therefore make your living decisions based on spirtuality. For example; keeping the kesh which is a living decision, is based on spiritual truth. Therefore we must adhere to both principles of Miri and Piri to be a perfect being. There are two concepts of a perfect being. Sant and Sapai. The sant aspect of the perfect being is bestowed by Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, and the sapai aspect of the perfect being is bestowed by the Khalsa Panth (Panj Pyareh). They go hand in hand, and you cannot have one without the other; or else one is incomplete. Therefore, as children of the perfect being (Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee), we must follow His directions and His life and principles and adhere to both, the spiritual (Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee), and well as the warrior (Rehat Marayada including Shastar) as prescribed by the perfect Guru. I am confident that Guru Sahib is with all of us, and will indeed take care and guide us to becoming perfect embodiments of the Khalsa, which indeed belong to the Primal being, and hence, Waheguruujikakhalsa! Waheguruujikifateh! bhul chuk mauf [%sig%]

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

A Singh · 09 Dec 2005

Interesting topic, many good points here......what is the function of kakars other than symbols? any gurbani tuks on this? thanks

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

KS · 18 May 2006

Vaheguroo Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguroo Ji Ki Fateh just to clarify a point by moorakh veerjee: The gurmanter Vaheguroo is indeed in gurbani....in the Bhatt Saloks near the end: Sutay Saacho Sree Nivaaso Aad Purakh Sadha Tooheen Waheguru Waheguru Waheguru Wahe Jio. Bhul Chuk Maaf Thank you, KS Vaheguroo Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguroo Ji Ki Fateh

Re: A question about Gurbani (I am only 16 so dont please dont get offended)

K Singh · 18 May 2006

Vaheguru I would just like to comment on one thing. In some of the above posts people have mentioned possiblity of contradictions, and there has been one incidence where a person has said that the tukh had been translated wrongly..... I would like to share a story from Bhai Harnam Singhs' biography where he goes to see Bhai Vir Singh who was doing the service of translating gurbani. Bhai Vir Singh was not very well and when asked the reason for his ill health..he said that he is extremely depressed. He has has this seva but when he finishes translating some gurbani, he goes to the next section and then when he looks back all the meanings have changed! He cann't get it right! I have also heard someone tell me that even Bhai Maskeen Singh turned around and said his Japji Sahib Katha was all wrong!!... in terms the meanings have changed (for him)... hopefully u see what i mean.. We can only understand according to what understanding maharaaj has given us... many respected Sikhs tell us that one line from Gurbani may mean something to one Singh and something completely different to another... so we should keep this in mind when 'disagreeing' with translations...... unless its just obviously way off!! jw kY jIA jYsI buiD hoeI ] jaa kai jeea jaisee budh hoee According to the wisdom within the mind, kih kbIr jwnYgw soeI ]45] kehi kubeer jaanaigaa soee says Kabeer, so does one come to understand. ||45|| Hopefully this sort of supports what i have tried to say.. but i can already see it could mean something else!..... Anyway i would like to commend Simran Singh as some of his questions and comments have been thought provoking and his love of gurbani is inspirational... I would also like to add another comment regarding places in gurbani where 'religious people' are told to stop all the false pakhand.... guru ji tells us this knowing completely well that since Sikhs will have such a unique identity there will be khasle that look the part but dnt act it... thus these warnings and advice are given to us just as much as anyone else... may a khalsa never fall into the trap of just looking the part..... pleasve forgive me for any mistakes