Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

who is right and who is wrong?

who is right and who is wrong?

Anon. · 09 Sep 2005

gurfateh jee. A amrithdhari friend of mine told me not to ask why so much,she said it can lead to "conflict/ arguments", is this true? she also told me not to question sikhi so much, but if one does not question it, how will one learn about sikhi? who is right and who is wrong? Please enlighten some views.

Re: who is right and who is wrong?

Dalrajkaur · 09 Sep 2005

If you have a question about Sikhi that you want an answer to, you can ask as many questions as you want. By asking questions, you will get the answer to your questions.

Re: who is right and who is wrong?

***admin cut to name***** · 09 Sep 2005

Your wrong and they are wrong too.

Re: who is right and who is wrong?

Singh · 09 Sep 2005

I think it's ok to question what another Sikh tells you. But it's really better to accept what Guru Sahib says. If we accept what Guru Sahib says then he makes things happen. If we really believe "sir upar thada gur soora, Nanak taa(n) kay karaj poora) then we can walk fearlessly with no worries about anything. But if we don't really believe in this and think our own cleverness will solve our problems or we'll look out for ourselves, I don't think Guru Sahib will give his hand of protection in the same way. So if Guru Sahib says something, just accept. If a Sikh tells you something, then question it. But too much questioning and wondering and reflecting and not enough doing (like naam bani) leads to atheism and frustration.

Re: who is right and who is wrong?

little I · 09 Sep 2005

well said "So if Guru Sahib says something, just accept. If a Sikh tells you something, then question it." The answers to all your questions are in Gurbani. The sikh lifestyle is very simple, but sometimes we answer big questions (me included) and look for big answers - usually the answer is very simple - but we havent been blessed with the understanding. It is better to question things, and answer them through gurbani. This way you will fully understand your faith - rather than simply believing in things because someone said it was the right way. (Monkey Experiment)/Blind Faith.

Re: who is right and who is wrong?

Harjas Kaur · 11 Sep 2005

[quote]*she also told me not to question sikhi so much... *(she) told me not to ask why so much,she said it can lead to "conflict/ arguments"[/quote] Sometimes we have resistance to something. Our attitudes reject something and bring up the disagreement as a question. Sometimes someone's intent is not to learn, but to find fault with something using clever logic and argument. Sometimes people don't want us to share our faith as much as they want to convince us of their doubt. Ultimately, you have to search for your own answers in your own heart. It shouldn't trouble you what other people think or why. If you decide you want real truth, real understanding, real guidance, then you have to bow down your logic to Guruji. No one ever received answers by explaining themselves. To receive answers, you have to LISTEN! So I suggest you read Gurbani. But if you are filled with doubts, hesitations, reservations, disagreement, or dismissal of Sikhi, don't waste anybody's time. No one can explain to you what the truth is. You have to read Gurbani with your own eyes, your own ears, your own receptivity. har jas suneh na har gun gaavahi. They do not listen to the Lord's Praises, and they do not sing the Lord's Glories, baatan hee asmaan giraaveh. ||1|| but they try to bring down the sky with their talk. ||1|| aisay logan si-o ki-aa kahee-ai. What can anyone say to such people? -SGGS p. 332 [%sig%]

Re: who is right and who is wrong?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Sep 2005

SPOT ON Harjas Kaur Ji. People who have got something to hide..or feel insecure about.....will be afraid of QUESTIONS.. Gurmatt and Gurbani has nothing to be afraid about as it is GYAN..the Sun of Pure LIGHT/KNOWLEDGE...when Gurbani shines..all darkness, fright/untruths/falsehood/lies/insecurities..disappear like the NIGHT does when the Sun shines forth in all its Glory.. The PANDITS asked, The YOGIS asked, The Shankarcharyas Asked, The Siddhs asked, the Muslim Pirs asked.... <<<<<<<< ONLY GURU NANAK JI >> ANSWERED >> !!!! WHY..becasue ALL the rest had QUESTIONS.... only GURU JI had all the ANSWERS. Only the Perfect Nirankaar roop has all the answers. Go with genuine Ardass and ask GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB....and there is GUARANTEE that all your questions will be answered... All the GYAN of countless YUGs and Universes is there in GURBANI....the LIGHT of the Ages.. Only those "sikhs" who follow persons other than GURU JI ALONE..will talk like that....Shhh... Dont ask such a question... Just beleive what "Baba ji" said OK ??...because the Baba ji has been saying..Waddeh baba ji used to say this...implying that is thus 100% RIGHT....and so on the chain contin ues. BUT IF you ONLY ask GURU JI..no need to say such things. I answer questions by the DOZENS daily....never once had to tell anyone not to ask..because I PASS all my QUESTIONS directly to GURU JI for answers.

Re: who is right and who is wrong?

anon · 11 Sep 2005

would you care to expand on your theory as to why we are both wrong? a valid back up explanation would be great.