Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Beware of nangs gursikho

Beware of nangs gursikho

gursikhan_da_daas _/\_ · 14 Oct 2003

Khalsa Jio waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji fateh i was very interested in know bit about nihang singh's, then i started some research, i was shocked to see this website..... there are photographs of nihang singhs in baanaa killing goat with big swrd and colloecting goats blood in sarbloh baataa which they use for washing nishaan sahib. this is insult of guru maryada. This website oviously talks about akj and say we are brahmins of this centuary coz we are vegetarian and dont take drugs. they preach shiv, hindu god coz he use to consume drugs and they say khalsa panth follows him for consuming drugs. I am here telling you all this coz i want each and every gursikh who dont know reality of nangs to spare 15 min and explore each and every singhle page of this website. guru pyaaron i feel so proud to be sikh especially following strict maryada of guru gobhind singh ji, today preserved by AKJ. pyaaron go through each and every page and see what nangs are...... i was shocked to see that nangs dont even spare our taksaali veers. i am stated 2 or 3 points out of that website, but its not enough...... go explore and follow strictly the maryadaa given by akj singhs. ****** Akali Nihangs, apart from tobacco, do not consider any other drug ‘Kureht’ (taboo). They only consider them as possible ‘Ebh’ (vices) if abused. Drugs were and still are traditionally used on battlefield as painkillers ***** photgraphs of bhai sahib randhir singh ji, bhai amolak singh ji, baba fauza singh ji and calling them bogus. ***** Udhasis, the missionaries (top right) started by Baba Sri Chand Maharaj (photgraph shows him smoking, ciggerette in his hand). ***** Though Akali Nihangs do not speak of themselves as ‘Hindu’, they do see themselves of the Hindu Indian nation. For example, at Sach Khand Hazoor Sahib, Nander, like all Hazoori Sikhs, Nihangs will freely intermarry with Hindus ***** At present the main culprits of adopting the Nihang uniform and misrepresenting Nihangs and traditional Sikh Shastar Vidiya are individuals belonging to the Akhand Kirtani Jatha (A.K.J.). It has to be noted that individuals affliated to the A.K.J. may feel they are being 'victimised' or targetted specificially by this website. However, as stated clearly early in the Introduction to the website, we speak but the truth, and history, texts and present day actions testify to these facts presented here. Naam Kehat Gobhind Ka Soochi Payi Rasna Waheguru Waheguru Wahe jio Bhul Chuk Maaf Nimaanaa Daaas

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 14 Oct 2003

they are'nt nihungs, talk 2 ne real gur-sikh nihung that is not them they live the kahlsa way of life, juss more nomadic... plus a nihung does'nt want 2 advertise what they do like that... RSS

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

idiot · 15 Oct 2003

Khalsa jee, you felt hurt when they wrote: "At present the main culprits of adopting the Nihang uniform and misrepresenting Nihangs and traditional Sikh Shastar Vidiya are individuals belonging to the Akhand Kirtani Jatha (A.K.J.). " They might be a little harsh, but they are right.... AKJ, along with everyother panthic group that thinks taht tehy are doing "Gatkaa" or "Shastar Vidiya" is wrong. The only point they are making is that when it comes to the true martial arts of the SIkhs, AKJ is doing false advertisement... which is true.. gatkaa is NOT our true martial art.. its SHASTARVIDIYA. This art was used by our Guru Sahibaan, Guru Khalsaa Fauj, and guru kay laadlay like Baba Deep SIngh Jee, Banda SIngh Bahadur, Akali Phoola SIngh Jee, etc. etc.. all of which who were Akali Nihang SInghs... Nihang SIngh's have had this Shastar Vidiya and its maryada in thier families since the times of the Khalsa Fauj. SO they have the most purest form of our Martial Heritage.. Lets respect them for what they know.. its just recently that tehy have come out into the open with this knowledge.. prior to this, only nihang singhs had this vidiya available to them. So stop doing the so called "gatkaa" and learn the true battle art.. once you know it, you can publicize it all you want, just publicize the right thing.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 15 Oct 2003

hey idiot nihungs are also sikhs just like akj or ne other jatha baandi every1 deserves 2 do shaster vidia no matter whatttttttt

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

Singh · 15 Oct 2003

Idiot, all this talk of some super secret shaster vidiya that nihangs have is utter garbage. The reason nihangs in india are good at gatka or shaster vidiya if you will, is that they are belay and get to practice all the time for years on end. The martial arts that was practiced by singhs like Bhai Fauja Singh was the same thing, since he went and trained in the Nihang Dals. If the martial arts used by the AKJ singhs with Bhai Fauja Singh was fake, then the stuff used by Buddha Dal must be fake too, since that's where Bhai Fauja Singh learnt it from. And unlike them, he actually put his martial training to good use. This whole thing about only nihangs knowing the real thing is made up by the British nang Nidar. He has nothing else to offer anyone (in terms of Sikhee) so he and his chelay have created this myth to make themselves look special. Unfortunately, a lot of our youth have bought into this myth and help propogate it.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

simran_sewa_sacrifice · 15 Oct 2003

WAHEGUROO JI KA KHALSA WAHEGUROO JI KI FATEH!! ################################################ Lets respect them for what they know.. ################################################ EXCUSE Me but what can pakhandee, malesh, bajjar kurehti so called "khalsa" teach real gursikhs? how can these patit nindaks teach anyone about real bir rass when that is something only rehatwaan singhs can tell someone about. If you want someone to take this seriously, then please bring forward some real gursikhs that have some face infront of Guru Ji, not some cursed paapis who slander other Gursikhs and uncaringly commit bajjar kurehits. Only then can we say yes these people are credible and can show REAL shaster videya. It is my hope that these "nihangs" see the light of Gurmat and come to terms with real Gursikhee and stop introducing weakness into the youth. just my thoughts WAHEGUROO JI KA KHALSA WAHEGUROO JI KI FATEH!!

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

gursikhan_da_daas_/\_ · 15 Oct 2003

one buzurg nihang singh got arrested in punjab, india yesterday with 2kgs drugs. this swaroop ie thier baanaa represents sikhi, khalsa ....... shame on these people giving bad impression about sikhism really shame on these nangs waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

? · 15 Oct 2003

why dont all of u just get on with your sikhi? if something is wrong and u dont like it, then go to india and do summit about it. moaning on the net isnt gonna get u anywhere. nihungs in india will hardly have access to the net if they aint even living in houses. u see it as wrong then interact with them form relationship where u can talk or tell akhal takhat to do summit.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

singh · 15 Oct 2003

This whole thing about Shaster Vidiya, Akali Nihang, Nidar etc in the UK is unbelievable! For those who don't know, this is how it all started. A few years back, this guy turns up on the scene in the UK. He calls himself "Nidar Singh" although his real name is Sodhi Singh. He says that he's been to India and has learnt the "true" art of warfare and claims that the Gatka that everyone else does is false and compares such Gatka to a circus-act! At first he goes around and calls it "Jhatka Gatka". Then he re-brands it to "Shaster Vidiya". He says that he learnt this art from this old man in India. The funny thing is that this old man has only ever taught this "Shaster Vidiya" to Nidar. What a coincidence! Nidar says there are a couple of other guys who know it too in India, but they are just roaming around india like Udasis! So Nidar is basically saying that in the entire world, he's the only person that can really teach this art! Apart from him, nobody knows the real art - even all the Nihangs in India are doing what he calls "Gatka Baaj" or playful/mock Gatka. Another funny thing is that he prefers very much to mock AKJ for promoting Gatka in the west, but does not for even one moment knock Budha Dal and Tarna dal for doing the EXACT same Gatka. He likes to use those Nihangs as an image that he and his students follow (in appearing and behaving like them) but he then puts them down by saying that they too are just doing "Gatka Baaj"! The old man that Nidar learnt from doesn't even look like a Nihang! You can't have it both ways mate! continued in next post....

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

singh · 15 Oct 2003

Out of all the Sikh armies who knew Gatka in the past, he now reckons its just him who's left who knows it! Sounds very suspect to me, and probably to anyone else who has even a little common sense. He strongly promotes the taking of "bhang" and eating of meat - both of which are against the Rehat of a Gursikh. His websites have images of Hindu gods and he insults the Shaheed Singhs of the Khalsa Panth, who are infinitely better than him as they have given their lives for the Khalsa Panth, whereas he has just sought to put them down and cause splits in the Sikh youth. When Nidar first came on the scene, he was seen in a Judo suit. He came with a white Sikh who is a Gatka master called Nanak Dev Singh (who currently lives in France/Germany). What on earth is Nidar doing in a Judo suit if his art is meant to be authentic? Why on earth was he hanging around behind Nanak Dev Singh who also does the exact same Gatka as the rest of the world? Nidar is very clever. He fools his students into thinking that he has documentation to prove various fantasies he promotes and the students basically take his word for it. They dare not challenge him as they have very little knowledge on Sikh history and Gurmat anyway. The type of students he has are the "dossing type" who aren't into Sikhi for spiritual gain, but just to associate with the Sikh image or those who just like violence/drugs/womanising. Nidar seems clearly to be pushing 2 agendas. One is his own fame. The second is that of the fanatical-hindu RSS, who want to see the Sikhs amalgamated into the Hindu religion. Both agendas are false and our great Guru Sahib will show him defeat and the Khalsa will be victorious. Nidar teaches his art, which should really be known as "Nidar-Baaj" (the game of Nidar), in places such as Hindu Mandirs! Its strange how Hindus are falling over themselves to allow Nidar through their doors along with Sikh youth! continued in next post...

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

singh · 15 Oct 2003

Another very strange thing is that Nidar says he is an "Akali-Nihang", which proclaims to be a higher/better class of Sikh than the ordinary Sikh. This sounds very much like the Brahim's caste system. Of course, we all know that Guru Sahib abolished all castes and hierarchies., but Nidar seems to think he knows better! Nidar reckons that since he is a "Akali-Nihang", that he is a true warrior. If that is true, then what Seva is this warrior going to do for the Panth? Will he challenge and fight bravely against the enemies of the Panth? Will he seek to bring justice to all the wrong doings in the Panth, or will this "super hero" sit at home eating KFC chicken nuggest? You can guess which one he does. Another thing, Nidar says his art is the true art and it should be told to the entire world, but refuses to show his "Nidar-Baaj" to anyone other than his committed students! Come on Nidar! Try getting your story right! Nidar does not take part in any of the Gatka tournaments as he says that his art is not for show, but he is quite happy to turn up to these tournaments and whisper in people's ear about how he is amazing and everyone else is a circus-act. continued in next post....

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

singh · 15 Oct 2003

At the same time as refusing to compete, he lays down challenges to others on his website! What on earth is going on in your head? Try making some sense man! Don't the RSS teach you anything right? One of his challenges is to a well-respect Singh called Uptej Singh (Teji) who has travelled the world teaching Gatka. The funny thing is that he challenges Teji despite competing with him in India and being totally humiliated! So, two things here - Nidar challenges/competes when he feels like it but refuses to in Gatka tournaments, and Nidar's art (Nidar-Baaj) is so great that Teji managed to defeat him in a matter of seconds! Nidar's fight with Teji is on video film, so he doesn't deny it, just makes excuses about it, even though he was the one who challenged Teji! Nidar is always threatenig to bring out a website against AKJ or against Taksal. Well, guess what Nidar, we've been keeping an eye on you, and its your turn soon! Prepare to be humilated and exposed for the agent that you are! If you thought the above evidence is convincing, just wait! You'll wish you'd kept your Judo suit.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

Sikh · 15 Oct 2003

Singh, it would seem that you know him well. Have you ever spoken to him directly or are you sourcing your information from the likes of Bagel or Roshan - Teji Boys? I'm not from the AKJ, but feel that 'all' Singhs, should hold a meeting to discuss how to deal with this new threat and through parchar teach the masses to stay away from them. In no way do I condone Nidar and Jagdeep, but have you confronted them? I've spoken to the latter and he rabbits on about Sanatan Sikhi at any opportunity. HE will not change. All of us will one day, recieve punishment from Dharam Raj - if no one dares to sort these guys out, no doubt the 'Judge' will get his turn. Sanatan - Background Info.. Sanatan Dharma, as the name suggests owes its inception to none other than the eternal supreme soul- Brahm. Unlike other religions such as Christianity, Islam, Zoroastrians and Buddhism which all clearly show the name of their inceptors like Christ, Mohammed, Zarthustra and Buddha, Sanatan Dharma boasts its inception to the supreme soul Himself. All the religions except Sanatan can be classified into two parts: Pre-historic religions. Historic Religions. But Sanatan cannot be included in any of these two categories. It existed even before the birth of other religions and it exists even today. Sanatan shall exist in future also. History has witnessed the rise and fall of scores of religions and sects. But, Sanatan has withstood all kinds of upheavals and oppositions and continues to exist. Regarding the future of Sanatan, we have to keep in mind that since it has no beginning hence it will have no end. So, it is beyond the reach of 'natural-law of change' which states that one which has born shall inevitably come to an end. There has never been an exception to this rule nor there shall be one. Even the divine embodiments of almighty God in physical incarnations had to see their end. Thus, even the physical embodiment of even the eternal God is not an exception to this rule. Second meaning: Sanatan has no beginning and hence no end. It exists right from the moment of creation of universe to the time of Pralaya (the great deluge). It is Sanatan not because it owes its inception to the eternal God but because it is eternal in itself. It shall exist up to Pralaya and shall not be destroyed even after Pralaya when it will lie dormant but exist neverthless.With the beginning of new creation, Sanatan shall rise once again to protect mankind and help it prosper. But all said and done one should not have a misconception that all the other religions are false. Every religion guides the human being to its ultimate goal. But these religions being historic and propounded by somebody inevitably will see their end, of course except Sanatan Dharma. =========== Basically, they insist that Sikhism is Sanatan. Being Sat and Akaal it has always been present. These people have distanced themselves from 1978/1984 sakas, and propound only their own message. Under the cloak of 'Shashtar Vidiya', they attract people of all ages and will through their shrewdness no doubt convince the innocents that they are right and the rest of the Panth is wrong. Anyone can pop into their classes if they want a word. They are regularly held in the UK.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

idiot · 15 Oct 2003

>>>> simran_sewa_sacrifice wrote: "If the martial arts used by the AKJ singhs with Bhai Fauja Singh was fake, then the stuff used by Buddha Dal must be fake too, since that's where Bhai Fauja Singh learnt it from. And unlike them, he actually put his martial training to good use." <<<< I know for a fact that Shaheed Fauja Singh learned from Buddha Dal... I know he was trained propperly.. thats the not point.. CURRENTLY, the practices of "martial arts" in the panth today is useless... its for show.. its not the real thing. Everyone is doing this style of Gatkaa called "Jahir Gatkaa" including Taksal and AKJatha. Im just stating the facts here.. its no one's fault that they don't know the true art, its good taht they are trying though... Also, there is no way to actually prove that Shaheed Bhai Fauja SIngh was doing shastar vidiya, but i have faith taht he did. But 1 thing is for sure, whats happening now as far as "Sikh Martial Heritage" is nothing but "Jahir Gatkaa" or Showmanship Gatkaa. <<< simran_sewa_sacrifice wrote: "This whole thing about only nihangs knowing the real thing is made up by the British nang Nidar. He has nothing else to offer anyone (in terms of Sikhee) so he and his chelay have created this myth to make themselves look special. Unfortunately, a lot of our youth have bought into this myth and help propogate it." <<<< Khalsaa Jee, no one is telling to become his chela... First of all, everyone knows that in life, when you find something that interests you, you learn it from them and that's that. You dont have to learn what you don't want to. And what myth are you referring to interms of "to make themselves look special"? If anything they are not making themselves look special.. they are exposing thte truth, whats the harm in that??? You also wrote "unfortunately". Well, its very fortunate if the youth is in following the right direction in relation to shastar vidiya, sava rakhsha (self defense), and even 1 day kurbani. I dont see why there is so much confusion and hatred towards this... Grow up people.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

idiot · 15 Oct 2003

>>>>At first he goes around and calls it "Jhatka Gatka". Then he re-brands it to "Shaster Vidiya".<<<<< Singho, he started off saying it was Jhatka Gatkaa becuase there isn't any true title to thte art... YOu can call is Yudh, Yudh Vidiya, Shastar Vidiya, Shastar Yudhan, anything you want.... its the ART that matters... beleive it or not, Niddar Singh actually learned from his superiors... he was also taken in by Nihang Singh's once and taught the true battle arts. >>>>Another very strange thing is that Nidar says he is an "Akali-Nihang"<<<< Actually, he doesn't... He only has the title of Nihang and Shastar Vidiya Gurdev. Akali Nihang is for individuals who are jathedar are senior nihang singh's of the present... or Generals of the past, i.e. Akali Nihang Guru Gobind Singh Jee, Akali Nihang Baba Deep Singh Jee, Akali Nihang Phoola Singh Jee, etc.... <<<<>>>> Khalsa Jee, let's speak for ourselves and what seva WE can do for the panth... As a 3rd person, I can definitely say that he has done more seva than any of us on the internet, tapping away on the keyboards, becuase he actually has trained hundreds of students in shastar vidiya (sikhs and nonsikhs) with love and devotion without any discrimination. Why does everyone on this board persist to insult him... You dont have to follow his jhatka meat maryada!! The only thing that I am enforcing is MARTIAL HERITAGE... and no one has the right to insult Shastar Vidiya or Nihang Niddar SIngh until you have met him for yourselves, trained with him, discussed everything with him, and learned the effectiveness of Shastarvidiya over Gatkaa... daas has had the privelage to and it is life changing... i once also thought falsely of this... don't be mislead by the site... the only thing that is important on the site is the Techniques and Differences between shastarvidiya and jahir gatkaa and gatkaabaaj.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

idiot · 15 Oct 2003

>>>>Another thing, Nidar says his art is the true art and it should be told to the entire world, but refuses to show his "Nidar-Baaj" to anyone other than his committed students! Come on Nidar! Try getting your story right! Nidar does not take part in any of the Gatka tournaments as he says that his art is not for show, <<<<< Ridiculous.... how about you find out more about when and where he teaches before you insult him and shastar vidiya... because 1. He doesnt Charge anything. 2. He teaches students nationally and internationally. (I come to learn from him New Jersey, USA... Where he comes semi-annually and doesn't charge a dime. Maybe you should come and see what its REALLY like cuz everyone seems to be quite misinformed.) 3. The reason why he doesnt come to certain "Gatkaa Matches" is because the vaars of shastarvidiya are OFF-LIMITS and against the regulation rules in the contests, i.e. Yudh 2003 Rules and Regulations... What's the point of sparring when you can't use certain tactics? It becomes nothing but a game. <<<>>> Where do you get this stuff from? Have you met him? I think that would be more propper.. to just end all this Ninda and just meet the man, because he is such a nice guy... he will sit down and patiently explain everything until you understand. And all this about Nihang Singhs and Niddar Singh Jee not being a gursikh... DONT JUDGE.... becuase he is obviously not commenting on other's spirituality, just thier martial training.. Nindo Nindo Moko Log Nindo

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

{¿?}â„¢ · 15 Oct 2003

notice that idiot didnt touch on the topic of nidaars defeat at the hands of Tay-jee

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

idiot · 15 Oct 2003

<<<<>>> Sorry, i forgot.. The truth will unfold when you ask Niddar Singh what actually happend that day in india. I actually asked him, and all I am going to say here is that they were sparring for over 2 hrs... Each match lasts about 1 - 3 mins... they did hundreds... Uptej Singh might have won a few, but Niddar Singh had the upperhand. It was all for practice, not for personal gain or competition, so no one on Niddar Singh's side knows why Uptej Singh has blown this up so big under the pretense of "Uptej Singh beats Niddar SIngh".... But since he apparently has... Nihang Niddar Singh is giving Uptej Singh an OPEN CHALLENGE to a battle of "Haddh Torh".. Uptej SIngh Jee is welcome to spar with him and accept his challenge. So far Uptej Singh has not accepted the direct open challenge. Personally i think if Uptej Singh defeated Niddar SIngh so bad taht day, which he is claiming so... then please, accept the challenge and do it again. :) Just be a good sport. Most of what I have written from above is from the Open Challenge page, if you still have questions about it... refer to: It's very important to read this... If you are reading my post as a follower of Uptej Singh, then give the links I have provided a look.. The information provided is most impressive. Don't be biased with only Uptej Singh's side of the story. Study they matter, and make your own conclusions.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

simran_sewa_sacrifice · 15 Oct 2003

WAHEGUROO JI KA KHALSA WAHEGUROO JI KI FATEH!! Idiot u wrote >>>> simran_sewa_sacrifice wrote: "If the martial arts used by the AKJ singhs with Bhai Fauja Singh was fake, then the stuff used by Buddha Dal must be fake too, since that's where Bhai Fauja Singh learnt it from. And unlike them, he actually put his martial training to good use." <<<< <<< simran_sewa_sacrifice wrote: "This whole thing about only nihangs knowing the real thing is made up by the British nang Nidar. He has nothing else to offer anyone (in terms of Sikhee) so he and his chelay have created this myth to make themselves look special. Unfortunately, a lot of our youth have bought into this myth and help propogate it." <<<< sorry baba ji i am not the one who wrote that but anyway... last thing i wanna say on this is that if nadar is actually sincere then time will show it. but as of right now he is considered a slanderer ect. by most everyone, yes i hope we are all misunderstanding him and he is a genuine person (but I along with many others have serious doubts). WAHEGUROO JI KA KHALSA WAHEGUROO JI KI FATEH!!

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

Singh · 16 Oct 2003

Idiot wrote <> Idiot, you truly live up to your name. The only thing important on the site is the gatka stuff? The twisting of sikh history and slander of gursikhs isn't important?? Have you been smoking some bhang? And why on earth wouldn't we judge the nang by HIS OWN site, where he gives his beliefs? Are you saying all the stuff on the site isn't really him, he just got bored or something and did it for fun? Bottom line: He's a dirty nang and all his followers are dirty nangs. I've met a few here and there and I think everyone has seen what they write on the internet and can judge for themselves. He can have all the martial skills he wants, but they're useless if you have no jeevan and are a panthic traitor (pushing RSS ideologies and condemning Shaheed Singhs). Jeevans of real Nihangs was such that complete strangers would trust them with their daughters. The UK nangs of today... hahaha, keep your daughters well away. And his little match with Teji. I asked a couple of his close henchmen about this a while back and they started protesting and saying that it was actually a tie, and that you have to watch the video carefully. A little time passes and now it's gone from a tie to an overwhelming victory (in spite of the video evidence). Nice. And idiot, the gatka stuff is the least important part of his site. Anyone can learn a martial art. It's Sikhee that's the really important and difficult part. And these Nangs are trying to undermine Sikh history, traditions, rehit - in fact, the entire sikh way of life. They want to turn us into Hindus.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

nirgun · 16 Oct 2003

"idiot", what do you think about the nangs and marijuana, and what about them eating meat? and their beliefs about adultery before marriage being a "weakness", not a kureiht? and what about niddar and his buddies putting goats blood in sarbloh baatey? and washing the nishaan sahib in goats blood? some people say niddar even drinks goats blood in sarbloh, as parshaad.. :S.. although i'm probably a worse person than niddar is, and i'm NO ONE to talk, i still think he has some SERIOUS problems. is it really right for someone like THAT to be teaching ANYTHING to sikh youth? he's already screwed up the brains of so many! would you trust your own kids in the hands of someone like that?

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

Nihang Sirtor Singh Khalsa · 16 Oct 2003

singh. email me, I must talk to you on behalf of tarna dal california.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

singh · 16 Oct 2003

to all you nags out there, why don't u stop challenging other Sikhs an challenge the enemies of the panth like the rss?

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

nihang · 16 Oct 2003

all these nangs who do this nidar baaj or whatever they call it.... question 4 u all... u nangs say gatka tournament rules are for games only... so why did nidar play against teji? and lose!!!... and do u kill your opponent in a tournament?... if not then u also playing a game? u call gatka singhs to be playing with sticks but gatka singhs are real khalsa ... we fight real battles as in 1978 and 1984... u nangs just talk... and take drugs. where were the nangs in 78, 84 and all the time afterwards?... in the pay of the indian government!!! tell nidar next time he come to india well see which hadh nidar wantss to break. we will look out for him.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

kaur · 16 Oct 2003

to all the sangat this has been going on for years now and it doesnt look to be getting any better ( the growing rifts). the youth are going to get more confused when one party insults another both in bana. now you tell me what is the solution? lets be honest clear cut. 1)coming on here trying to create awareness but this site is limited to the few forum users? and not the sikh wide community at large. 2) hold a meeting with niddar singh air your concerns out, let him air his concerns out, and get a outside body in to govern the outcome towards some kind of agreement. you have to sit down and talk to this guy, saying things on the net will not solve this. as the months and years go by i see these articles on controversy, going back many years ago, but i dont see efforts to break out of this cycle by directly talkign to this guy. we come here a few people get to know teek, then we feel alarmed when we find out he has hundreds of students and feel they are being taken the wrong way. so do we tackle this as a problem at the branch or the root? thats why its vital to hold talks with him directly without feelings of defensiveness or passion which raise the wrong moods in discussions but straight talk from bani and facts with niddar singh directly face to face with the outcome for the sake and benefit of the panth.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

sangto · 16 Oct 2003

for some reaon sangat thinks that only uk nihangs do sukha and chatka..visit india all old prataan sumaayy walle nihang jatha bandian do chatka and sukha...The western world gets one glimpse of nihangs over the internet and are going ballistic. This has been going on for years now. Its part of their rehat, for some reason people can't accept it? Why NOT? how does it affect you? Nihang Jathebandian have been around since the time of the Guru's. Maybe rather trying to learn of them from books and from websites, you should actually get tickets and stay with Nihang Jathas for a while. nihangs are wicked... AS per the akj slandering on the site yea I a disagree with that, as thats nothing but pure hate, as per Nidaar Singh, he isn't recognized by Bhuda Daal, including Akali Nihang Santa Singh, and none of the singhs from Budha Dall (in india or around) who I've spoken with have heard of them. But in the end all Nihang Jathe Bandian, Tarna Daal, Budha Daal, Bidhi Chandh etc etc...all got sukha and dullay going. I spoke with a singh who grew up with nirmallay and he also backed up the Nihang maryada with histroic events and sakhian.. I noticed in the west we are trying to "soften" sikhi up and dilute it to something its not. Great Panthic Leaders like Sant Jarnail Singh never even objected to the Nihangs and their mayrada. maybe because he had better things to do, or maybe because their accepted that it was their maryada... In the end i agree nihangs are verry loose these days about their maryada compared to a little while ago, but nonetheless are still wicked.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

Sikh · 16 Oct 2003

Idiot is correct in terms of the difference between play/acting Jahir Gatka and Shashtar Vidiya. I'm sure Nidar Singh has alot to offer in the martial sense. However, even idiot has cleverly avoided their stance on modern sikh holocausts. They have no answer for this and even their Jathedar has admitted his mistakes on the re-building of the Akaal Takht. Having a weak Sikh leadership resulted on him getting off lightly!!! Idiot stated 'Khalsaa Jee, no one is telling to become his chela... First of all, everyone knows that in life, when you find something that interests you, you learn it from them and that's that' Currently, the Namdharis hold the Giyan of Gurmat Sangeet and Nidar Singh - Shashtar Vidiya (at least in the West). It is unfortunate that people like the Namdharis and the likes of Nidar hold their respective Vidiya. Sikhs really have no option, BUT to learn from these guys, and move on. It is a difficult situation, but many students of the Namdharis include bibian with Keskis etc. I myself will find it difficult to learn from say Namdharis, when they clearly hold a human as a Guru. I find it strange that the Nihangs are so stuck in the past with Shashtar Vidiya - why not adopt and learn modern warfare methods along with the old. In the US, some states allow guns to be carried freely. How many Singhs learn how to shoot pistols/automatic weapons or learn how to survive in the wild? Surely we would be better off with Miliatary type training. Shashtar Vidiya techniques, though effective in past war like situations will send you to prison if used on the street. Nidar Singh delves straight into taking out ones takhur sian...not pleasent and very impractical. Also on the list is gouging eyes, cutting various tendons+muscles using an array of indo-persian weapons (mostly illegal). What I find strange is that he repeats himself continuosly in his talks and almost never has anything new to add. Idiot mentioned that he does alot of Seva typing away? Was the site designed by him or one of his students? Is he aware of 'all' the contents if not?

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

Nihang Sirtor Singh Khalsa · 17 Oct 2003

Singho listen to Akali Nihang Baba Nihaal Singh Jee's katha on panthkhalsa site. You will learn of true Nihangs and gursikhs of Shiromani Tarna Dal, unlike these nangs in UK who arent even recognized by Buddha Dal!

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 17 Oct 2003

he guys is'nt it sangat who makes the decision for the panth? could'nt we get a petition 2 siri akaal takht on the niddar situation?

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

Baaaaj singh · 17 Oct 2003

veerjis talk to them open up communication hold dialogue with a panthic audience on video. see u gotto understand whats attracting youth there. think of this phycologically, what will pull the western educated bought up youth if you have something to offer whether panthic or anti panthic? sikh or non sikh? a) a cosmopolitan non biased prerequisite approach which throws open martial knowledge free to anyone and everyone with the catch " regardless of race religion creed or presonal belief " which like a pattern fits in perfectly well and refletcs with the multicultural societies we are bought up in. (now niddar and his other friends make this acceptance catch clear on their website promoted and advertised loud and clear when they are offering this vidia on the cyber world). b) methods talked about which seem to come across as biased ie teaching of ghatka, ( some inidviduals on jatha websites state ghatka shud only be taught to amritdharis). from marriage down to doing naam. see the average person will rather remember the bad things than the gud if to feel defensive such as they wont be seeing the gurmat parchar, naam, sikhi lifestyle, beer ras and knowledge jatha offer but rather the indifferences, just like the nindia of bhai sahib and shaheed singhs on niddar site outweighs what he offers such as the martial knowledge. nobody needs to explain here why things are done for certain reasons i myself honestly wudnt want an rss thug to know how to use ghatka or shastervidia on a sikh if they want to wipe sikhs out. The key term i want to highlight is presentation on a website which the audience views and has access to. But in the world and age of information we live in veeroh , whatever we write is captured by an audience. I know u know bhai sahib uptej singh not only teaches anyone and every1 he is a very warm selfless gurmukh with no irkha or malice towards any1. The whole point im making is as the average internet person the only contact i wud have of akj on the net if i knew hardly anything bout jatha are the 1 or two websites and the forums used and the individuals who talk on here that wud seem to reflect a view of akj. now the inidviduals speaking to me are not a mouthpiece of jatha but wud form an opinion on the average cyber user who wud have lack of knowledge. that is what people like niddar take advantage of, they are very carefully packaging and promoting their way in return on the front of their sites with fancy catches titles. the impact their making is big because people in society are changing, the world cultures religions are loosening their touch andbecoming more mingled. These lot are playing upon that. The only thing i can advise with to compare against their website wud be to add in new sections on this site and jatha site where the whole history of sikhi is bought out, ie essays on where the panj piarey came from? their history, from different parts of india from different races. right down to the different races who became one under sikhi, ie kabul sangats, rajistani singhs, sikhs from UP delhi then collected as a fauj in punjab. highlight the love of bhai knaiyya to show nowhere in history was this ever done but under the banner of the khalsa. so much more, but that which shows different people uniting under the banner of the khalsa, and khalsa is not some elite status title held by only punjabis with the punjabi mentality. Looking at some of the products of the niddar crew its a shame gud singhs have gone to waste, however all is not lost. Guru knows. there must be a reason why also certain sikhs with gud history chose to adopt that path. was there a weakness? lets analyse part of that weakness.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

Amarjit Singh · 17 Oct 2003

Funny someon said "and their beliefs about adultery before marriage being a "weakness", not a kureiht?, but the Bhatt Vahi account which I have recently read states that only Cohabiting with Muslim Woman is a kureiht, so eighter the account is unreliable (which I think) or the Nihangs are right.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

Balpreet Singh · 17 Oct 2003

I think the issue is one of translation. If I recall correctly, the term used is "muslee yudh" which is a Khalsa Bola which means pre-marital sex. If translated literally, then yes, it would mean with a Muslim. But if youw ant to translate all Khalsa Bola's literally you'd translated a Tankhaiya Sikh to mean "a salaried Sikh" and the reader would think, "hmm...that's not so bad...what's the big deal?".

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

booom · 18 Oct 2003

its a fact some singhs from jatha have been deluded into this nihung pathway and those people have turned out crazy. i reckon its down to this, like generally in life, in sikhi itself one experiences highs and lows during their journey, sometimes the lows can last long time. there is no support base when people are down. its not a jatha problem but rife in the whole panth. every1 is facing the same thing. some of us have family, friends contacts. whether someone can click with u on that level to understand you and boost u up is another thing. U wont be able tp keep that smooth flow, if the boat is rocking without sangat and support base that wud help u ( not to say jatha dont support each other, they cant be there 24 - 7 for work family other commitments). Then a person will find they are leading different lives one with jatha and one at home, family friends etc. Bang! neo nihungs come along become as friends change the flow by posing you questions when ur down, challange everything about u and the beliefs you hold dear, whats gonna happen? the way their gonna do it will be like some intellectual opposed to the "punjabi way" sidda talk , try to make themself appear superior to make an impression on your mind. sangatoh keep it tite together! help each other through this the more stronger we stand together the less weakness we give away the quicker they will go. moghuls turks british afghans ghandi all tried they cudnt do it. No one can!!!! THE KHALSA WILL ROCK AND SEND THUNDERS THROUGH THE RSS HEARTS BY CREATING AJMER SINGHS OUTOF THEM ONE DAY

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

. · 18 Oct 2003

I DONT GET IT???? wats the difference between current gatka and the soo called Shastar vidiya???? like wats so great about it that makes gatka seem soo bad. like i know gatka is a bit showmanship, but daym man, look at 84?? how many swords came out then..... ppl need to wake up... the chances of us using these kinds of marital arts are only for individual self defence. in terms of the panth, ppl need to learn military tactics and have military trianing.... if shastar vidiya is the sceince of weapons.. y aren't i seeing any rifles, or machine guns, or hand grenades and stuff on his website. This is what we use to fight nowadays. not lil kirpans..... :S

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

Mkhalsa · 18 Oct 2003

Didnt singhs with talvaars and sticks keep tanks and the whole indian army from entering the harmandir sahib complex with simple gatka moves for quite a while?

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

Gurcharan Singh · 18 Oct 2003

VAHEGURUJIKAKHALSA VAHEGURUJIKEFATEH I live in Punjab. I see nihangs here do displays. They do the worst gatka. They are teaching bad gatka here. They have no training and no accuracy. The videos on the website shows gatka like they do. I learn from Khalsa College. We have beaten them many times. They do jaher gatka. VAHEGURUJIKAKHALSA VAHEGURUJIKEFATEH

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

sooorma · 18 Oct 2003

how dare anybody cuss 84 movement as terrorist. what do they suggest let ur religion be genocided? dont stand up let the rapes and killings occur. so learning shastervidia is a gun and using it to defend sikhi is terrorist???? sikhs killed in delhi are used as an example to say if they knew martial heritage they can protect themselves, but when 84 singhs did, their terrorists???? why??? a rumour that this crew float around is that the whole reason 84 occured is because militants turned the darbar sahib intoa military camp. well sorry educated so called rss degree holding philosophers, but the general chief of staff mr sinha just blew your western view away when he declared ghandi planned to attack darbar sahib 2 years b4 it happened. these lot r going round promoting this idea blaming 84 on the singhs and not the goi, spreading misinformation at their uni talks presentations and web sites.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 18 Oct 2003

shaster vidia teaches dissapline, if u can use a sword u can use a gun

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

sikh princess · 19 Oct 2003

Hi, can I just say as a girl living in england and learning from Niddar Singh Nihang "savya Rakhsha" that he hasn't actually ever talked about maryada and has never told us to eat meat, I think you guys on this message board are doing more odd parchar than he his and making him out to be something he's not. he's just a simple family man, never bigs himself up and actually teaches wonderful self defence techniques that EMPOWER Sikh girls more than any of you guys or any AKJ guy or any other Sikh I know. With practical techniques and exercise and support taught in a very kind manner I have come to feel alot more happier when Im walking down the street because for a start I'm looking all around me, and secondly I've had practical lessons on what to do if someone grabs my wrist and drags me, or if someone tries ot punch me, or if someone grabs my throat, etc etc. the first lesson is always "saavdhani" - awareness. Look all around you, we're taught how to look behind us etc and I'm sorry its only obvious when you've learnt it. ummm thats all really. isn't self defence what its all about? hes teaching it and thats a big seva. vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

Amarjit Singh · 21 Oct 2003

WKWF Balpreet Singh I have never heard of Guru Gobind Singh useing whats usually termed as nihang or Khalsa boli, as if I am correct which I may not be this developed after Guru Ji's time, mainly during the persecution period of Sikhs. So where as Balpreet Singh is right about different tranalsations I think the term "muslee yudh" which is used in the controversal account means exactly what I've stated before. It's more then likely that the Khalsa Boli reffered to may have derived from the original term used in the account and then took on the new meaning you have refferred to later on. For the record I am not saying that the Nihangs or the account is right as I beleive both are wrong and premarital sex is not permitted in Sikhi, but thats only my opinion.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

sikh princess · 21 Oct 2003

where did the premarital sx issue come up, is it on the site somewhere? I must have missed it.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

Sikh · 22 Oct 2003

Considering the number of Sikh Web Designers, I'm very surprised that none have designed a site to counter allegations made against Bhai Fauja Singh and any other falsehood spread by Jagdeep and Niddar. Haveing re-read bits of the site, it is purely ego-oriented. The number of times they repeat how Sanatan and Shashtar Vidiya labels 'belong' to them is unreal. By repeating the same trash makes the writer sound extremely insecure. For godsake, they are just labels - no one owns anything on earth. Tut! when will they learn?

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

to bhenji · 23 Oct 2003

to bhenji who says she attends his classes He may not be like that it his classes. He does not need to. He has a website that says it all for him. When he starts classes like slough, they send out leaflets telling everyone to read the website before they attend the class.

Re: Beware of nangs gursikho

dizzy · 23 Oct 2003

VJKK VJKF! Hello people, looks like we have a nice LONG productive (not) discussion, well its not really a discussion is it. I mean you people talk about nindiya and whats going on here? Its not even like you are discussing faults, lies or someone doing something wrong, you are blatently 'cussing' a group of people. How many of you have actually met these people? How many have had a conversation with this man? Last one, how many have been to the classes run by this man? I don't know this man, but (I'm assuming) like alot of people on the 'net' have read about him and have jumped to conclusions. Look how much effort has gone into 'discussing' this group of people and then I look at some other posts made that are so much more practical to be spending time reading and answering, but I don't see much action there. Just so you all know and don't jump to some more conclusions, I'm not a Nihang, (by the way I'm not AKJ, I'm not Taksalli, I'm not from this jatha, or the other one and not even from the next one, I'm just a Sikh (shock horror!). Guru Ji Bless VJKK VJKF