Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

limited · 09 Sep 2005

Why do the Akhand Keertan Jatha Punj Pyare insist a husband and wife present themselves for Amrit TOGETHER? If the wife/husband is not interested, then why is the other person who wants to become Guru valaa/valee turned away by them? A Gur Sikhi jeevan walked together is not always possible, if one is not interested as the other half. The only reasoning I can see is that it minimises the likelihood of divorces. As the Rehit Maryada of the Jatha is above and beyond the one pescribed by the Akaal Takht, and if (with the blessings of vaheguru) practiced with discipline could make life a little difficult for an Amrit Dhari and non Amrit Dhari couple). please give me answer, because it seems unfair : ( thanks

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

ManjitSingh · 09 Sep 2005

The best and the only answer you can/should get for your question is from Panj Piare and only Panj Piare. No one else has the right to answer what Panj Piare did or will do. FYI Panj Piare are never unfair, it is your narrow thinking that makes you feel like that.

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

Hari Singh · 09 Sep 2005

I know of a situation where the Panj pyare did give a bibi Amrit, she's a dastardhari, while her husband is a mona. so if you really want amrit then talk to the panj and tell them ur willing to do anything for it and that you'll fulfull any conditions they set.

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

Harjas Kaur · 09 Sep 2005

I agree with Manjit Singh. I trust the wisdom of the Panj Pyare in this matter. If anyone wants to understand a decision they have made, you need to ask them for understanding. [%sig%]

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

limited · 09 Sep 2005

You're right Manjit Singh ji, I should get my answer from Punj Pyare. It just seems they are told what to do by the decision makers of the Jatha. It seems unfair because I don't think any of our Gurus would have turned a seeker away if they came without their spouse. i.e. India - Punjab - Anandpur sahib 1699 - the birth of the Khalsa - I think alot of the Sikhs gathered that day would have been without their wives and they were accepted by the Punj Pyare.

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

M Singh · 09 Sep 2005

The fact that we give Amrit a brand label 'AKJ, Taksal, Santa Da etc' shows our narrow mindedness. For your info, I know of an individual being turned down by the Punj Pyaray (these punj were not part of the 'AKJ') for the reason that he needed to take Amrit with his wife. Guru Ji's decision comes in the form of the Punj Pyaray on the day of that Amrit Sanchar. In essence Guru Ji decides if you are ready to have Amrit or not.

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

Amritpal Singh · 09 Sep 2005

Read this jeevan its has a senario of husband and wife and amrit sinchaar relevent to this thread [url]http://www.tapoban.org/Giani%20Dalip%20Singh.pdf[/url] [%sig%]

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

khalsa_force · 09 Sep 2005

even Sikh Rehit Maryada says tht u MUST try or motivate ur partner to be amritdhari if he/she is not.

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

Singh · 09 Sep 2005

As far as I know, many amrit sanchaars in the panth don't give amrit to people if they show up without a spouse. I've heard many cases of this happening in Taksal and other groups as well.

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

ssingh · 09 Sep 2005

seen/heard this in taksal

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

KHALISTANI · 09 Sep 2005

i belive u can take amrit without ure spouse but u cannot have children with them after someone told me this so i unno if its correct. however wat the punj say is the same as guru ji's hukam so u should respect it and it may not seem fair but after some thought i think u will change ure mind

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

daas · 09 Sep 2005

i recently had this discussion with some guru payare here in australia and they just said that sikhki is a grasthi jeevan and to do the seva of punj payare (which is the ultimate seva in my view coz u representing guru ji) your whole family needs to be amrithdhari and rehitdhari but most of the times, some punj are quite easy goin on these things but i think the panj were right in ur case as that is wat true gursikhi means bhul chuk maaf waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 09 Sep 2005

off topic.. One of my students just asked me this.. Why is Chhakkiang Amrit..a "SEWA" ?? Is being a Punj..SEWA ?? how ? Sewa is like wartaaing langgar..to all who are there..wartaaing degh to the sangat..washing the langgar bhandeh, chadraan, carpets etc etc.. BUT Amrit Sanchaar ? how is it sewa ? All thoughts welcome. our class will discuss this on Monday. Thanks in advance

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

charanjeev singh · 09 Sep 2005

waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh this topic is the most sensitive, it requires great great contemplation and great realization. what is the greatest sewa? the greatest sewa was done by the Guru. How? The Guru did the selfless service of giving us Naam. Then the Guru made Saadhs, true Sadhus, the truest disciples, Gurmukhs, by giving them Naam. Now. by the Grace of the Guru, the Guru again did the greatest Sewa by giving these Saadhs, Gurmukhs, the power to give the Naam to the lowly human being, with which s/he would become a Saadh. Without this Naam, the human would remain just an animal, but with Naam, s/he would become one with God, like a water drop that gets absorbed by the ocean. Hence, now, the Guru, who gave Naam to the Gurmukhs, and now the Gurmukhs have the biggest sewa to give the Naam to Niguraas, and make the lowest of the low, to the highest of the high. Hope this was of some help. bhul chuk mauf karna waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

MS · 09 Sep 2005

Simple, YOU reap what YOU Sow. Its only far to easy to blame somone else for OUR problems but at the end of the day it was YOU who chose to go through the Anand Karaj - a union of souls and quite clearly you must take Amrit as ONE i.e. both together. It was YOUR choice to go for an Anand Karaj with somone who had no interest in its true meaning and you probably had the same mentality at the time. You may have change however that does not in any way excuse the choices YOU made. It does seem unfair, but dont look at it like how a child does when they cant have their cake and eat it. We make choices, some good some bad, they all have consequences and this is not somone elses fault but our own because we CHOSE to do something a certain way. Ignorance is no bliss in the court of the lord. Dont be a child, take RESPONSIBILITY for ones actions and then maybe we can move on and make progress instead of being mad and bitter at somone else for OUR decisions.

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

limited · 10 Sep 2005

thank you for your replies, deep down iin my heart I know it makes sense for what our beloved Punj Pyare did, but one question still remains in my mind... "did our beloved Guru Jis insist on wife and husband to present themselves for Naam together?" Who knows??, but the Hukam of the Punj Pyare is the hukam of Guru ji. That I must accept with a peaceful heart. thanks

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

simple singhani · 10 Sep 2005

wjkk wjkf! The reason they dont give amrit to you if you havn't got ur husband/wife ther is because it can easily be broken...like if you wife wanted to go to...s restaurant..or listen 2 music..or go to a club extra...u wudnt b living the same lifestyle the whole i idea of getting married is so u have someone to help you..and lead u towards god. You wont feel like doing ur pathe if ur wife/husband doesn't want to. its jus common sense really. and alsoo...ur kids will be soo confused they will walking around lost!haha..who will they follow??? ther mum or dad...and you cant get them to favourtise can you? well this is my opnion sorry if i sed summit,.. wrong...btw..its not jus akj that refuse giving amrit like that...but i think its a good way...cus punj pyare dont give you amrit unless they think you can keep it! wjkk wjkf

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

Iron Man · 10 Sep 2005

The usual solution to this is you take amrit but you can never have relations with your wife or eat her jhoot etc. I have heard the phrasing "treat her as a sister" until she takes amrit and you redo anand karaj.

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

limited · 11 Sep 2005

I've politely told my wife that we can't have children until she becames a Guru Valee or starts taking steps in that direction, as it will be confusing for the poor soul. She accepts that, but time will tell hey. Rabh Rakh!

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

ss · 12 Sep 2005

I don't understand the stance of the AKJ on this wither , Guru Sahib at Anandpur 1699 didn't ask the gathering at Anandpur to go back and get your wives then you'll get amrit.

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

Amu · 12 Sep 2005

ss ji, how do you know? were you there?

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

manks · 13 Sep 2005

We are not the decision makers here. Reading through these postings, there appears to be differing opinions based on the Chinese Whispers scenario. Personally I think that until you as an individual stand in front of the Punj Pyaray, only then will you know if you as an individual can take Amrit. If you are refused for whatever reason, then you must accept it as Guru Ji's hukum and do what the Punj say in order to be able to take Amrit. If it means taking Amrit with your spouse then you must wait when the time is right and your spouse is willing. If you are allowed to take Amrit without your spouse then accept it as Guru Ji's kirpa. If you are allowed to take Amrit without your spouse, subject to withholding a marital relationship, then accept it as Guru Ji's hukam. The way I interpret this is that we all come with different Karam. Our struggle for attainment all depends on our previous kamai. Guru Ji's decision comes in the form of the Punj Pyaray, we must accept whatever it is. Don't listen to the rumours on the Grapevine, go in front of the Punj Pyaray and ask for the gift of Amrit and accept the outcome. Just my opinion!

Re: Not Accepted for Amrit by AKJ

Its wrong! · 13 Sep 2005

Wahey ji ke khalsa wahey ji ke fateh! I believe with Manjit Singh the panj pyare will decide weather or not you can take amrit! Wahey ji ke khalsa wahey ji ke fateh!