Forum
Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Jagjit Singh · 07 Sep 2005
Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, often there are endless controversial debates on messageboards. Some turn peoples mind to negative emotions. Some issues are genuinely controversial such as raagmala. Others are intentionally made controversial even though there is overwhelming evidence against the practice, such as kacchee bani, santdoom, Gurudoom, meat, and mool mantar. These issues are only made controversial as part of the self-interest of some groups, eventhough it is causing unnecessary division in the Panth.
For every controversial subject, if we had handwritten evidence by our beloved Guru Sahibaans, then you would think everyone should accept it. Surely our Guru Sahibaans are above any sant, mahapursh, jathebandie, or anything else.
In the case of mool mantar, we are blessed with 3 hand-written Mool Mantars, by our Guru Sahibaans. All of them are up to Gurprasad. Dass has never seen any evidence from our Guru Sahibaan to show that Mool Mantar is up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach. If there then please present it? If not then please accept Gurprasad, and stop causing unnecessary divisions. The less the better….
Below are
1) Handwritten Mool Mantar by Sahib Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib ji
2) Handwritten Mool Mantar by Sahib Siri Guru Har Rai Sahib ji
3) Hand written Mool Mantar by Sahib Siri Guru Tegh Bhahdhur ji
Waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Sumanjeet Kaur · 07 Sep 2005
Bhai Sahib ji, is this part of a granth or just separate pieces of paper that Guru Sahibans wrote on?
thank you.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Sep 2005
100% agreed veer ji.
Moolmantar is up to GURPARSAAD as written 31 times in Sri Guru Granth Ji Sahib at the beginning of every Raag. But some still hold on to what their Baba Says....so what to say...let them be baba followers instead of GURU Ji's followers.
jarnail Singh
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Harpartap Singh · 07 Sep 2005
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
All the puratan samprada's (Nirmala, Udhasi, Nihang, Taksal's etc) state that there are 5 mantars:
1. Gurmantar - Vaaheguruu
2. Beejmantar - IkOankaar
3. Mahamantar - IkOankaar to Gurprasaadhi
4. Muulmantar - see below
5. Malamantar - Japu Sahib
The strange thing is that they all agree on this one point that Muulmantar is up to Nanakhosibhisachu despite all the other differences in Maryada.
The pictures of the Mahamantar do not prove matters one way or the other Bhai Sahib.
By looking at the pavittar saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji, we can see that Guru ji did not necesarily state what the full name of each bani was i.e. at the beginning of sabads there are many different manglacharans used. Also, Guru ji in His wisdom did NOT state what is Rehhraas Sahib rather left it as 2 distinct parts i.e. SoDharu and SoPurkhu.
It was only with the start of the Singh Sabha movement that people within the Panth started to say that Muulmantar is up to Gurprasadi.
Whether someone simars on Mahamantar or Muulmantar or any of the others is the most important thing - NOT what it is called.
I don't know what the Singh Sabha reformers hoped to achieve when they introduced this controversy but it is fair to say that the British of the time were probably very happy at all the mischief that would subsequently arise as a result!
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Kulbir Singh · 07 Sep 2005
Harpartap Singh jeeo, I think you have shardha in Baba Karam Singh Hoti-Mardaan's samprada. For your knowledge, Sant Rarewalay preached that Mool Mantr is up to Gurprasad and so did Sant Jawala Singh Harkhowal (Both part of Hoti-Mardaan Samprada).
The reality is that there are only two entities - Naam and Gurbani - and these too are interwined and merged with each other. Naam is Gurmantr and rest is all Gurbani. All this talk of Maha Mantr and Mala Mantr and Gayatri Mantr is not based on Gurmat. According to Gurbani Beej Mantr is Naam i.e. Gurmantr but you are stating that Beej Mant is "Ik Oankaar". There is no provision in Sikhi to japp Ik Oankaar alone.
Mool Mantr i.e. Manglacharan is part of Gurbani and should be understood and recited like Gurbani. Naam should be japped with feeling.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
. · 07 Sep 2005
in siri guru granth sahib ji mool mantre appears upto gurprasad
why do people think it goes upto nanak hosi bhi sach?
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Jagjit singh · 07 Sep 2005
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, why is when Gurmat is so simple, that we intentionally complicate it with own Maat?
Veer Kulbir Singh has covered most points. But I would further add that I am very surprised that you have choosen to accept a snaatanist approach by putting the views of Udasis and Nirmalas, and rejected the Singh Sabha. Firstly, many of these groups do not even accept the importance of Amrit, which even Sahib Siri Guru Gobind Singh ji begged the Panj Pyares for.
Then why is something given more prominence because it is precieved to be older. Where do you think the Singh Sabha got their idealogue from? They did not just sit there and think up the new version of sikhi, like some new age sants are doing. Instead they spent almost 40 years researching every scripture, and text we have. So their Sikhi is no younger or older than anyone else, as it originates from the same texts. Yes, some their decisions were political minded such as not implementing dastaar for bibian, or meat. However to their credt they did manage to clean up sikhi, from many stick-on idealogues which were pushed by these very Udasis and Niramalas, who were the Mahants of the day, such as idol worship.
The handwritten Mool mantars speak for themselves, and proves beyond any doubt the Mool Mantar debate should never even happen, or any controversy exist. How can you deny Guru ji own handwritten Moolmantars? I am sure if we had a hukamnama written by Sahib Siri Guru Tegh Bhahdhur ji stating raagmala is bani and everyone should read it. You would be he first to push it. Why is it so different with Mool Mantar?
Even our local Sant babas in Yorkshire in the form of Amrit Parchaar Jatha are very strict on Mool mantar is up to Gurprasad.
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Harpartap Singh · 07 Sep 2005
All Gursikhs can simr any part of Gurbani - to say otherwise does not make sense.
As for the Singh Sabha movement - the fact is that they changed parts of maryada which they unilaterally did not like.
Guru Sahib has nowhere declared what the Muulmantar is. They have rather used many different Manglacharans as evidenced by the saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji.
I do not know about the Hoti Mardhan Sants - Sant Jagjit Singh ji Harkhowal (a friend of Sant Jarnail Singh ji Bhindrawala) has clearly stated to me the puratan belief not the new innovation.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Jagjit singh · 07 Sep 2005
waheguru ji kekhalsa waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare veer jio, you state that Guru Ji has nowhere declared what the Mool Mantar is. I have already presented 3 handwrittans copies above. Can you present any handwritten copy of Mool Mantar up to Nanak hose Bhai sach by any Guru Sahibaan? if not then the controversy should end.
I really do not think we should compare the contribution to the Panth between the Singh sabha movement, and that of groups like Sant Samaj.
I have never met Sant Jagjit Singh, but I am sure he is a Satkaryog Gursikh, but I have presented 3 handwritten Mool Mantars by 3 Guru Sahibaan. What they have written is far more important than any Gursikh, no matter how Great.
Does any Gursikh compare to sahib Siri Guru Tegh Bhahdhur ji, Sahib Siri Guru har Rai j, Sahib Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib ji?
I fail to see how any Gursikh can disagree with their Guru?
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
... · 07 Sep 2005
In these written texts, do the Guru Jee's state that this is the Mool-Mantar?
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
convinced · 07 Sep 2005
in the Guru Granth sahib it does say Mool mantar, the mool mantar just starts.
In the scans it does not say it is anything other than the Mool mantar
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
oy! · 07 Sep 2005
correction: it is Baba Jagjit Singh. I have been lucky to have had the company of him and he is one cool Gursikh. He keeps strict rehat and would find it highly amusing how he is bought into this topic.
Moving onto the topic - here we are arguing about where Mool Mantar ends. Damn it, listen to the message of Mool Mantar and stop fighting over where it ends.
If you think it ends at Gurparsaad, fine. If you think it ends on Nanak Hoseebhi Sach - fine. At least act upon it???
Whats important is that we act upon the message that wonderful Gurbanee has given us.
Why was this topic started in the first place?
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
... · 07 Sep 2005
I know Guru Granth Sahib doesn't say what it is Mool-Mantar ... my question is more about the scanned texts.
Did Guru Jee actually write on the texts that this is Mool-Mantar ... or is it just assumed by us that it is Mool-Mantar because it ends at GurParsaad?
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
John Singh · 07 Sep 2005
Itv seems the above pictures are written in pad-ched?? Or are my eyes not seeing right?
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Lionking · 07 Sep 2005
Infact Mool Mantar appears 33 tiems in Gurbani.
make a search on srigranth.org and choose Gurmukhi mode and copy the following in -
[gurbani]<> siq nwmu krqw purKu inrBau inrvYru[/gurbani]
[%sig%]
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
....... · 07 Sep 2005
i think it is because of the other mool mantar thread...
oy! wrote:
>> Why was this topic started in the first place?
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
UK Nihang Singh · 07 Sep 2005
Kulbir Singh,
I think you are wrong about Sant Ishar Singh Jee Rarewala I have been reading they book and they belived in Mool Mantar up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach and use to tell the sangat to jaap up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach.
Also like Harpartap Singh said Baba Jagjit Singh also belives Mool Mantar ends at Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach, Baba Jagjit Singh was very close with Sant Baba Jawala Singh Jee.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
charanjeev singh · 07 Sep 2005
the chakar of Shaheed Baba Deed Singh which is braghmaan at Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib has Ik Oankaar to Nanak Hosi Bhee Sach engraved. Pyareh Gursikhs believe this to be the Mool Mantar enscribed upon the Shastar of Baba Jee.
I take the Mool Mantar as such. It is the planting of your Sehaj Paath. What does that mean? Well, every Gursikh is suppose to do a sehaj paath of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee consistently throughout their entire life. Now, during the Amrit Sanchaar, the Panj Pyareh have instilled the seed for this Sehaj Paath, that we refer to as the Mool Mantar. So be it from EkOankaar to Gurparshad, or from EkOangkaar to Nanak Hosi Bhee Sach, the true beej that was planted was entire Shri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. So therefore, the mool mantar would be practiced when we have Sehaj Paath.
Furthermore, a sikh is also obligated to follow the Panth. Panth is the collective collaboration of Panch Jana or Gurmukhs. Hence, in early 1900's, when the Rehat Marayada was made, it was decided by the panth that the Mool Mantar would be to Gurparshad. However, Gursikhs are always above panth (hankaar). And therefore we have sanctions such as taksal, akj, and many other sant followings.
If you adhere to the principles of Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib on EVERY matter, then you can assurely say that the Mool Mantar is up to Gurparshad. If you take what you like, and push aside what doesnt fit into your matt, or the matt of your 'sant', then you have no right at all to discuss such a matter, even as a panch.
Let the panj pyareh beej the mantar of entire Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee within yourself, in the form of the Mool Mantar.
Guru Gobind Singh Jee has said, that follow the instructions of the Panj Pyarey. There must have been a reason that Guru Gobind Singh Jee didnt provide a full written Rehat Marayda, of course Guru Sahib could have, Guru Sahib is poora (perfect), and Guru sahib knows what was going to happen (what i happening), but Guru Sahib knows His own rang.
Lets just meet Waheguruu.
bhul chuk mauf
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
[%sig%]
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
singh 2 · 07 Sep 2005
Harpartap Singh,
Please elaborate on the 3 additional mantars you have mentioned apart from Gurmantar and Moolmantar. You have said the different Sampardah's recognise them but where have they come from? Who coined the phrases? Guru Sahib? Also to your knowledge are they all given to abhilakhee's at Amrit Sanchaars at these Sampardah's?
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
singh · 07 Sep 2005
Kulbir Singh,
This is third time i m posting this..please get this.
baba isher singh ji rara sahib (Nuvan ratan from bhai dya singh sampardha/Hoti Mardan Sampardha) would give either up to gurparsad or nanak hosi bhi sach to people by looking at one's avastha upon taking amrit in form of panj pyares. This is discussed in atamik bachan tape - you can download that tape in website- http://www.gursikhijeevan.com/media/audio/index.php?folder=files/Katha/Diwans_Of_Sant_Baba_Ishar_Singh_Ji/Atmik_Bachan
From a jaguaso state- he would give the mool mantar until nanak hosi bhi sach so it's reduce it's intensity
But if the person is not at jaguaso state and it's at the elevated state- then he would give it up to Gurparsad (Maha Mantar).
He off course did this not by own but this was followed by seena-basina tradition by his previous teachers coming from bhai dya singh sampardha.
So as far as bhai dya singh sampardha- mool mantar whether nanak hosi bhi sach or up to gurparsad is given by looking at one's avastha.
So i request Kulbir Singh not to twist bhai dya singh samparda saints teaching to suit his own beleifs.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
convinced · 07 Sep 2005
I am surprised people are mentioning taking the view of Gursikhs and ignoring the Gurus
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
singh · 07 Sep 2005
>>>
All the puratan samprada's (Nirmala, Udhasi, Nihang, Taksal's etc) state that there are 5 mantars:
1. Gurmantar - Vaaheguruu
2. Beejmantar - IkOankaar
3. Mahamantar - IkOankaar to Gurprasaadhi
4. Muulmantar - see below
5. Malamantar - Japu Sahib
>>>
Along with these mantars:
Satnam is also known an par porbala mantar (if i m not mistaken)
Good post harpartap singh.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
H · 07 Sep 2005
if we followed the SGPC Rehit Maryada to the T; we would only read 3 Bani's in the morning
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
singh · 07 Sep 2005
Speaking of Biij Mantar:
Kulbir Singh,
you will be very suprised to know - Sant baba Jawala Singh Ji Harkhowaley (which bhai sahib randhir singh ji himself called him- sant) used to jaap on Ikongkar (bij mantar) which was given by baba aya singh ji hoti mardan waley in form of panj pyares.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Kulbir Singh · 07 Sep 2005
Sant Rarewalay in one of his Katha (recorded on a cassette) has clearly said that mool mantr is up to Gurprasaad but he also acknowledges that some Mahapurakhs ask their shardhaaloos to japp till “hosi bhee sach”.
Having said that, as I said before, there are only two entities namely Naam and Gurbani. Any shabad of part of Gurbani can be used to do jaap if you are seeking some sidhi but if you want to do Sidhi of Vaheguru, then you have to japp Naam-Gurmantr and also recite lot of Baani.
Siri Jap jee Sahib starts with the Manglacharan up to “Gurprasaad” and then “Jap” is the name of the baani. Then comes the first salok – “Aad Sach” up to “hosi bhee sach”. Then comes 38 paurees and finally the last salok of “pavan Guru”. This is the body of Siri Jap jee Sahib – 38 Pauris and 2 saloks.
If you consider “Jap” to be part of Mool Mantr, then where did Siri Jap jee Sahib get its name from? Then what is the name of this baani? Many gursikhs who read Mool Mantr up to “hosi bhee sach” consider “Jap” to be a verb and they read as “Gurprasaad Japp”. This way they totally misinterpret the meanings of both “Gurprasaad” and of “Japp”. “Japp” is a noun i.e. name of the baani and “Gurprasaad” refers to the fact that Akal Purakh is attained through the prasaad (kirpa) of Guru.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
singh · 07 Sep 2005
>>>
Sant Rarewalay in one of his Katha (recorded on a cassette) has clearly said that mool mantr is up to Gurprasaad but he also acknowledges that some Mahapurakhs ask their shardhaaloos to japp till “hosi bhee sach”.
>>>
I fully agree with that. However, as i said - Sant rarewaley himself used to give his shardhaloos to jaap until hosi bhee sach depending on the avastha.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
moorakh · 07 Sep 2005
The pictures above do not have any headings of "mool mantar" nor has Guru sahib written that those are their "mool mantar" writings
It is assumed that Guru sahib was writing mool mantar but what if guru sahib was just writing manglacharan
In any case call me moorakh but my mahamantar, beejmantar, mool mantar, gur mantar, sarab mantar, sresht mantar, is only and only "V-A-H-E-G-U-R-U."
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
... · 07 Sep 2005
that's the exact point i was trying to make as "moorakh" has above.
guru sahib's may have just written a manglacharan ... in no conclusive way does the above prove whether the mool-mantar is up to GurParsaad or Hosee Bhi Such
Nothing new has been unearthed by Jagjit Singh ... just muddied the waters even further and caused unnecessary controversy.
Just Jap Waheguroo and read as much Bani as poss ... it's all good :)
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
shocked!!! · 07 Sep 2005
do none of the sant followers believe in the Gurus anymore??????
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
............. · 07 Sep 2005
tell me where in Gurbani does mool manter ever have a heading saying mool manter! This is the silliest argument that I have heard...
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Logical Singh · 07 Sep 2005
moorakh jee, can you or anyone else provide even one mul mantar ending at 'hosie bhi sach' written by our gurus? Surely if mulmantar was up to 'hosie bhi sach' then we would have had at least one handwritten mulmanter by our gurus that ends at 'hosie bi sach'.
The fact that they (Guru Jees) have written all the mulmantars up to 'gurparsad' is proof that the mulmantar ends at 'gurparsad'.
‘Jap’ is the name of the bani. That is where we get the name “jap jee sahib’ from. If ‘Jap' does not imply the name of the bani then where did ‘Jap Jee Sahib’ get it’s name from?
[%sig%]
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Sep 2005
The pictures above do not have any headings of "mool mantar" nor has Guru sahib written that those are their "mool mantar" writings
It is assumed that Guru sahib was writing mool mantar but what if guru sahib was just writing manglacharan
??????????????
Where in Guru Granth Sahib Jee does the WORD MOOLMANTAR-BEEJMANTAR-MANGLACHARAN appear ??
IF Guru Ji uses that "moolmantar" Heading in Guru Granth Ji then it may be OK to ask the above question ?? BUT then Guru Ji did not use the word "moolmantar-beejmantar" at all anywhere....its a man made invention.
Ek Onakaar to Gurparsaad is the manglacharan as per accepted Poetic Tradition of ALL POETS...besides Guru Sahib Jee. Each Poet in the beginning of his writings used to manglacharan his ISHT. Guru Ji's ISHT is WAHEGURU..hence EK Oankaar to Gurparsaad..makes Perfect Sense.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
yorkshire singh · 07 Sep 2005
Jagjit singh,
who is this amrit parchaar jatha of sant babas in yorkshire?
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Samandip Singh · 07 Sep 2005
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
When we try to find out the real mool mantar we can find proof in many places that are actually valid that Mool Mantar is up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach. For example, when we go to Sachkhand Siri Harmandar Sahib and pass through the Darshani Deordi and reach the main door, there is clearly right in front of our eyes engraved in the gold right obove the entrance our Mool Mantar and it is from Ik Oankar to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach. Even older proof of this is of that on the shashter of Amar Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Ji who is the first mukhi of Damdami Taksal and gained his knowledge in Satguru Guru Gobind Singh Ji's hazoori and from childhood was a sevak of Guru Ji. He would alaways dress with his shashters on him meaning always tiyar bar tiyar and his shashters are showed after Reheras Sahib everyday at Takht Sri Akal Takht Sahib. Out of these shasters there is a small chacker which is to be placed at the top of the dastar and on one side there is engraved the names of the ten guru sahibans and on the other there is engraved our Mool Mantar from Ik Oankar to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach. This is proof that during Guru Gobind Singh Ji's time Mool Mantar was up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach. More proof which is even better than this, Guru Gobind Singh Ji's pavittar Kamarkasa which Guru Ji wore and you can get darshan of this at Patiala Raj Darbar in Karanay. On Guru Ji's Kamarkasa it has written on it Mool Mantar from Ik Oankar to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach. This is more proof that Mool Mantar is up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach. Now some of you will say that we should follow Siri Akal Takht Sahibs maryada and we should. The real maryada of Siri Akal Takht Sahib is that of its founder Satguru Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji. Guru Ji made the first Jathedar of his takht the mahan vidvaan Bhai Sahib Bhai Gurdas Ji. Now Bhai Gurdas Ji writes in Satguru Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji in his 39th Vaar "Ikangar Ikang likh Oorrha Oangar Likhaya Satnam Karta Purkh Nirboh Hoye Nirver Sadaya Akaal Moorat Partakh Soye Nao Ajoni Saye Bhang Bhaya Gur Parsaad So Aadh Sach Jugeh Jugantar Hoonda Aiya Hai Bhi Hosi Sach nao Sach darsan Sat Guru Dakhaya" It is obvious that Bhai Gurdas Ji Siri Akal Takht Sahibs first jathedar is writing up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach. This is Siri Akal Takht Sahib's real marayda and we should join with the real marayada. Also when we get darshan of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, we will see that there are the dandiya after gurprasad. However this does not mean that the entire shahad has been finished. The entire shabad will only be finished when the aika or 1 desginating the end of the pauri comes. If we were to assume that wherever there was a dandi that is where the pauri ends we all kno that is not true. The shabad only ends when the number comes designated the number of the pauri. Also this can be proven by viyakran also. As Giani Balviderpal Singh, who is a professor at Nakodar College, states that according to viyakran, it takes 2 upvaaks to make 1 ikvaak. He says for example, we say the sentence the raagi singhs came and performed keertan. 'The raagi singhs came' is 1 upvaak. 'and perfermormed keertan' is the second upvaak. If I were to say the raagi singhs came... that would have no meaning to it. Likewise if i said performed keertan...that would also have no meaning to it. However if i put the two together it would form 'the raagi singhs came and performed keertan' and that has an actual meaning to it. The same is with Mool Mantar and there need to b 2 upvaaks to make 1 ikvaak and 2 upvaaks only happen if the Mool Mantar is up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach.From Ik Oankar to gurparsad is one upvaak and up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach is the 2nd upvaak. From Ik Oankar to gurprasad Guru Ji tells about Vaheguru, describes His qualities, and praises Him. Then the question is raised that when was Vaheguru like this? That is when the rest of the Mool Mantar up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach the second upvaak put together makes the Mool Mantar Ikvaak make sense by saying that Vaheguru was true is true and will be true forever more. So please dont get mistaken because this Mool Mantar has been here since Guru Ji's time and we should leave the books and learn gurmat. Also when we visit Sachkhand Siri Hazoor Sahib on the entrance the Mool Mantar is also engraved there and it is up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach. Sadh Sangat Ji please read this carefully and Guru Ji Kirpa Karn on us manmuks and show us the true path. Bhula chucka maaf karniya.
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
... · 07 Sep 2005
ppl can argue abt Mool Mantar all day ... strong evidence both ways - just as Samandip Singh has provided
Wahegurooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo Jap
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Trying to be Logical Singh · 08 Sep 2005
I have read this thread and the original thread which started this subject.
Some questions -
1) At what point do we disregard our Gurus and need to look for other proves? What about Guru Kak Bhachan? Where does this leave Gurmat? Does Gurmat now need other proves to back it up before we accept it?
2) All of mantars such as bij Manar, etc. Where is theory resourced? Harpratap Singh please reference it with Gurbani or Guru Kian Sakian?
3) Samandip Singh - your post is interesting....But can we accept Gursikhs above our Gurus?
4) Do you have photographic evidence of all of this, or it is hearsay?
5) If we accept for a second Harpratap Singh theories, how do we know what you have written is not one of these mantars? Just as you state that up to Gurprasad is another mantar, simirlarly up to Nanak Hose bhi Sach could also be another mantar, and up to Gurprasad is the actual Mool Mantar.
6) History states Baba Deep Singh was with the Nihang dals. What evidence do you have to say he was the first Jathedar of Damdami Taksal, and that damdami taksal was actually in existence in them days, apart from DT self-promotional texts.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Kulbir Singh · 08 Sep 2005
Samandip Singh jeeo,
Your argument that Mool Mantr is engraved in Darshani Deori up to “Hosi bhee Sach” is not solidi because this was engraved during the time of Raja Ranjit Singh and not at the time of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj or Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee Maharaaj. The 1800s can be called the dark age for Gurmat since this is the time when there was least clarity about Gurmat. Hindu-minded Sikhs e.g. spoiled Udaasee used to control Gurdwara Sahibaan and Sikhs had to sacrifice greatly to get back their Gurdwaras from these Mahants in the early 1900s. This is a different subject and can be discussed in another thread.
As for Mool Mantr engraved on Baba Deep Singh jee’s Shaster, one can use the same argument that some have been using about Guru Sahibaan’s nishaan. It does not say anywhere on the shaster that what is being written is the Mool Mantr i.e. there is no heading. Secondly, there is no proof that this shaster actually belongs to Baba Deep Singh jee. Baba jee got shaheed and at the time of his shaheedi he must have used all his Shasters. Who kept Baba jee’s shaster at that time and how do we know today that this particular chakker actually belongs to Baba jee?
----------
The entire shabad will only be finished when the aika or 1 desginating the end of the pauri comes. If we were to assume that wherever there was a dandi that is where the pauri ends we all kno that is not true. The shabad only ends when the number comes designated the number of the pauri.
------------
As you know, the Mool Mantr / Manglacharan appears in Gurbani more than 30 times but no where else does it have the number in the end. What would you deduce from that? If you say that the Mool Mantr is not complete up to Gurprasaad, then why is it appearing at numerous other places in Gurbani, without the number and without the second half of this Mool Mantr?
------------
Also this can be proven by viyakran also. As Giani Balviderpal Singh, who is a professor at Nakodar College, states that according to viyakran, it takes 2 upvaaks to make 1 ikvaak. He says for example, we say the sentence the raagi singhs came and performed keertan. 'The raagi singhs came' is 1 upvaak. 'and perfermormed keertan' is the second upvaak. If I were to say the raagi singhs came... that would have no meaning to it. Likewise if i said performed keertan...that would also have no meaning to it. However if i put the two together it would form 'the raagi singhs came and performed keertan' and that has an actual meaning to it. The same is with Mool Mantar and there need to b 2 upvaaks to make 1 ikvaak and 2 upvaaks only happen if the Mool Mantar is up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach.From Ik Oankar to gurparsad is one upvaak and up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach is the 2nd upvaak. From Ik Oankar to gurprasad Guru Ji tells about Vaheguru, describes His qualities, and praises Him. Then the question is raised that when was Vaheguru like this? That is when the rest of the Mool Mantar up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach the second upvaak put together makes the Mool Mantar Ikvaak make sense by saying that Vaheguru was true is true and will be true forever more.
-------------
This ooRa AiRA kind of kindergarten stuff can be used to fool gullible peasants but ones who have even an iota of Viyakaran knowledge can only feel sorry reading this. What two upvaaks are you talking about? Who says that there are two upvaaks in this so-called mool mantr? The reality is that if Giani Balvinderpal Singh knew viyakaran, he could have never made this argument.
By saying that the Manglacharan up to “Gurprasaad” is incomplete (an upvaak), you are only suggesting that at all other places other than Siri Jap jee Sahib, this Manglacharan appears as an upvaak only i.e. it is appearing as incomplete? What a lame argument this is.
The Takaaza of viyakaran is that the word “Jap” is the name of the baani and is separate from both Manglacharan (up to Gurprasaad) and the first salok – Aad Sach ……..”. Please tell us, according to Viyakaran, what is the meaning of the word “Japp”. If you accept that this is the name of the baani, then pray tell us how can this be part of Mool Mantr? If you say that “Japp” is not name of the baani, then pray tell us what is the name of the baani and is the Panth mistaken in calling this baani “Siri Japp jee Sahib”?
To have two upvaaks as the Giani you quoted claims, don’t you think that you need a conjunction like “and”, “or” etc? If there are two upvaaks, please tell us what is the conjunction or the joining word in this? The reality is that this is the most pathetic argument I have heard in favour of Mool Mantr up to “hosi bhee sach”.
As someone above wrote, the real Mool Mantra or Beej Mantr or Mala Mantr or whatever mantr is only Gurmantr. The other mantr is Gurbani as a whole. “Mool” means the root and the root is Naam and Naam is Gurmantr. Naam came first and Gurbani came after. Gurbani is the Katha of Naam and Naami Vaheguru. In Gurughar there is only one mantr. Gurbani does not sanction any other mantr other than Naam. So all this talk of Mool Mantr is futile. Reality is that Naam alone is all Mantras. It is true that Manglacharan is the basic foundation of Gurbani and all Gurbani explains Manglacharan but Manglacharan in turn can be concentrated into Naam Gurmantr.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Sikher · 08 Sep 2005
Samandip Singh has raised some very valid points
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
observer · 08 Sep 2005
naaaah mate! Bhai Kulbir singh has just ripped him apart!
Sikher wrote:
> Samandip Singh has raised some very valid points
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
moorakh · 08 Sep 2005
my mool mantar is vaheguru
i don't need any mantars
that is what my punj pyare told me.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Sukhdev Singh · 08 Sep 2005
"As someone above wrote, the real Mool Mantra or Beej Mantr or Mala Mantr or whatever mantr is only Gurmantr. The other mantr is Gurbani as a whole. “Mool” means the root and the root is Naam and Naam is Gurmantr. Naam came first and Gurbani came after. Gurbani is the Katha of Naam and Naami Vaheguru. In Gurughar there is only one mantr. Gurbani does not sanction any other mantr other than Naam. So all this talk of Mool Mantr is futile. Reality is that Naam alone is all Mantras. It is true that Manglacharan is the basic foundation of Gurbani and all Gurbani explains Manglacharan but Manglacharan in turn can be concentrated into Naam Gurmantr."
Couldn't have said it any better veer jeeo
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Niranjan Singh · 08 Sep 2005
Samandip Singh's argument that Moolmantar is up to “Hosi bhee Sach” because of the engraving in Darshani Deori is typical of the "proof" some of these guys provide.
An engraving doesn't prove anything. Take a look at the image below which is taken of the inner gate of Harmandir Sahib. Clearly this version of Moolmantar is upto "Gurparsad."
What does Samandip Singh say about that ?
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
moorakh · 08 Sep 2005
VAHEGURU is gurmantar
VAHEGURU is mool mantar
VAHEGURU is mahaa mantar
VAHEGURU is beej mantar
VAHEGURU is sarab mantar
VAHEGURU is sresht mantar
VAHEGURU is anand mantar
VAHEGURU is akaal mantar
VAHEGURU is amrit mantar
VAHEGURU is "namo mantar mantray namo jantar jantray"
VAHEGURU is "namo eist eistay namo tant tantray"
VAHEGURU is eik mantar
VAHEGURU is braham mantar
VAHEGURU is giaan mantar
VAHEGURU is kirpa mantar
VAHEGURU is daya mantar
VAHEGURU is mehar mantar
VAHEGURU is shakti mantar
VAHEGURU is bhagti mantar
VAHEGURU is param mantar
VAHEGURU is parvaan mantar
VAHEGURU is my mantar
VAHEGURU is your mantar
VAHEGURU is our mantar
VAHEGURU is the only mantar.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Harpartap Singh · 08 Sep 2005
Veero,
What every one seems to be arguing over is what portions of Gurbani are called. What's important is the message and to act upon it.
Bhai Kulbir Singh - as I mentioned above, just because a 'slok' comes after the word 'Japu' does not preclude it and the previous tuk from being called Muul Mantar together: this is the same as the two separate parts of Sri Guru Granth Saahib ji called So Dharu and So Purkhu being called Rehras Sahib together although they appear to be completely separate bani's.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Samandip Singh · 08 Sep 2005
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Bhai Niranjan Singh Jio, I must have made a mistake when i was writing. I am talking about when we go through the Darshani Deordi and accross the bridge up to the main door. The mool mantar above the main door is up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach. Bhai Kulvir Singh Ji how do we know that those shashters are not Baba Deep Singh Ji's.
"Upon seeing this Pathan Jahan Khan confronted Baba ji, both their heads were cut off as they struck each simultaneously. A Gursikh called out, "Baba ji, you promised to place your head at the feet of Sri Guru Ram Das Sahib ji at Sri Harimandir Sahib." When Baba ji heard this he picked up his head in his left hand, took up his sword in his right and continued fighting. The tyrants were so astounded by this event that some started to run away, as they left the battlefield they told their fellow soldiers that the General of the Sikhs is fighting without his head.
While fighting Baba ji progressed to the parkarma (the outer circle) of Sri Harmandir Sahib, with the Sikhs shouting war cries. Baba ji placed his head at the feet of Guru Sahib ji and after completing an ardas left the world for Sach Khand." (TAKEN FROM DAMDAMITAKSAL.COM)
There is no doubt in anyones mind that this event is not real. Of course there were gursikhs there along with baba ji or how could have this event even been noted? So the shashters have been there ever since. May vaheguru do mahaan kirpa and relieve of all our misunderstandings. Bhula Chuka Maaf Karniyaa
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
charanjeev singh · 08 Sep 2005
veer Harpartap Singh,
could you please type the names of our eleven Guru Sahibhaans as you would pronounce them.
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
ummmm · 09 Sep 2005
interesting that no one even commented on the point of the above pics showing the bani written in pad ched form, this board has always go on about Guru ji wrote in lardiar form etc etc etc, now jagjit singh with his photos has shown other Guru sahiban writing Bani in pad ched, yes we can say this is not the Guru Granth Sahib Bir etc but many times kulbir singh and others have quoted that Pad ched is man matt etc, whats their view on the above pics ????
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
jugroop singh · 09 Sep 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Veer/Bhain 'ummm' ji,
let us ask if these writings of Siree Guru Sahib Ji are taken from Maharaj's Saroop or from a Hukamnama. then you'll be in a position to discuss the issue you have raised adequately.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Guru-Charan-Preet Kaur · 09 Sep 2005
does the gurbani "look padchhed" ?? NO. to me it looks laridaar. some places all the lagaan matraan as kena, siharee etc are also missing..
in all the posts above one group is stressing on GURU JI....and the other group is stressing on their own SANT Ji version of events.
to me it is obvious..GURU JI personally wrote those nishans...and Guru Arjun Ji Maharaj and Guru Gobind Singh Ji maharaj had the Aad Granth Ji and Guru Granth ji..written under their direct supervision...and the other so called evidence..engravings and etc are all done by ":gursikhs" ...just like todays Kar sewa Waleh babaey are destroying Sikh history and traditional gurdwaras...by the dozen.....same types of udasis. nirmalaes, and babas were also in existence in those times these engravings were installed. so they are not proper evidence at all....this is tampered evidence..or planted evidence.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Conclusion Singh · 09 Sep 2005
Time for a Conclusion :-
1) 3 mool mantars have been presented up to Gurprasad, which are handwritten by Guru ji`s.
2) Those who believe up to Nanak hosi bhi Sach cannot present any handwritten mool manters by Guru ji.
3) Our Guru is always unquestionable, and as Guru Angad Dev ji followed all hukam without question, how can we ignore these handwritten mool mantars. We have never had to look beyond our Guru before, so why now?
4) All Mantars lead to waheguru.
5) There are numerous sources for mool mantars up to Nanak hosi bhi sach from times after Guru ji, or Gursikhs. But these cannot be more important than anything handwritten by 3 Guru jis.
6) Unless any evidence can be presented where Guru ji themselves contradict these 3 handwritten copies, whcih really makes no sense, because Guru Ji never contradicts themselves. But unless they can present something, we should all from now accept that mool mantar is only up to Gurprasad.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
ummm · 09 Sep 2005
Veer Jugroop Singh,
"let us ask if these writings of Siree Guru Sahib Ji are taken from Maharaj's Saroop or from a Hukamnama. then you'll be in a position to discuss the issue you have raised adequately"
This brings another point, if Guru Sahiban had written bani anywhere in padched form would this not mean that the format Gurbani is written in wasn't as significant as pro larivar have made it to be ???? i disagree with bhen ji above the below 2 images def look pad ched, there is NO join in the words as there is in a laridar bir.
Regarding the sihares and kanea etc, old hand likhat birs have these missing as well, it is down to the individuals style of hand writing, also many would know that here you add certain vowels etc, just like today many know how to add bindiya etc....
I await others views on this question, if Guru Sahiban had written bani in form other than of larivar, what does that mean, does it mean that the whole larivar argument is anulled, as wheter we like it or not, we are sikhs of Guru ji and not of a jathea or individual thoughts, it does create a question, which needs more thought than the black and white answers we see, Guru ji is samrath, we all accept that, we are kin kin bhulan haar, and our mat is limited, only and only Guru jis mat is Gurmat, we can but try and understand it but to claim that we are following Gurmat 100% would be our egos talking.
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa, Vaheguru ji ki fateh.....
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Kaur · 09 Sep 2005
"While fighting Baba ji progressed to the parkarma (the outer circle) of Sri Harmandir Sahib, with the Sikhs shouting war cries. Baba ji placed his head at the feet of Guru Sahib ji and after completing an ardas left the world for Sach Khand." (TAKEN FROM DAMDAMITAKSAL.COM) "
Didn't Baba Deep Singh Ji throw his head from the battle field to Darbar Sahib. I remember that there is a gurdwara in India where the battle field was and from where babaji through his head. They say that babaji threw his head to Darbar Sahib
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
A Singh · 09 Sep 2005
Veer Kulbir Singh is absolutely correct in his first post "All this talk of Maha Mantr and Mala Mantr and Gayatri Mantr is not based on Gurmat".
One can find similar references in other traditions in the multi-religious landscape of India and yes various Baba and Gyani and Sant Jees have preached that Guru Sahib when questioned by the Siddhas and others on what their equivalent of each of these mantras were elucidated by given the notions that are described above.
In reality, this is no more than talk that has been passed down, "Haseena-Baseena" to use Roop Kaur's words, from Sant to Chela over the course of time and with little historical reference or Gurbani to back this up. Sure over time, some may have documented what their Ustads told them, however that alone does not make it valid as proof.
Essentially we should concern ourselves with Naam and doing Paath - full stop. All controversial points are really nothing much, plenty of flexibility exists within the Sikh Rehit Maryada for AKJ, Taksal, the so-called Sampradhas and even eccentrics like me to practice Sikhi cohesively - if you wish to recite Raagmala, you can, if not, then don't - BUT don't have fight over it (see Gyani Jarnail's accounts of the low life activities of some anti-Raagmala people gluing together pages or physically fighting during an Akhand Path!), likewise, the meat issue is clear as per the Rehit, if you don't want to eat it, don't, if you do - then observe the practice properly (NO Halal and Jatka it properly!) so on and so on.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
uk singh · 09 Sep 2005
Kulbir Singh Ji - by contesting the authenticity of the Chakar of Baba Singh, you may as well rule out all shastars on display that supposedly belonged to Guru Ji and their Sikhs in the various Gurdwarey and Ajaib Ghars.
Bhaji, we need more faith in our historical artefacts. At this rate we can question the authenticity of any item in Sikh History and brush them aside as mere fakes.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
little I · 09 Sep 2005
if we all did mool mantar (any version) rather than spending time writing and reading the above, we'd be alot closer to Vaheguru - and have less on our minds.
Why are we so happy to waste countless hours argueing over such trivial things :(
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 09 Sep 2005
Author: uk singh
Date: 09-09-05 13:00
Kulbir Singh Ji - by contesting the authenticity of the Chakar of Baba Singh, you may as well rule out all shastars on display that supposedly belonged to Guru Ji and their Sikhs in the various Gurdwarey and Ajaib Ghars.
Bhaji, we need more faith in our historical artefacts. At this rate we can question the authenticity of any item in Sikh History and brush them aside as mere fakes.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
SO its ALL or NOTHING ?? No veer there are obviously "Falseness" mixed up among the "genuine ones"
We have to get the FALSENESS out and leave the GENUINE STUFF.
Rejecting one as false doenst mean all others are also false...
Jarnail Singh.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Logical Singh · 09 Sep 2005
Maybe the Mulmantar on the Chakkar was written way after Baba Jee became a Shaheed.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
charanjeev singh · 09 Sep 2005
maybe it wasnt.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
AVTAR · 09 Sep 2005
Veer kulbir singh and gyani Jernail singh. Both of you are very learned person and well verse in gurmat and gurbani.I really cant understand people like you are in this kind of arguement,ie women must be in panj pyare,doing kritian in darbar shaib, ragmala ,mool mantars and the list can continue ..... Can u tell me those who do mool mantar until gurpersad will go to hevan or get mukti and those do until nanak hosipe sach will go other wise. we even can go to that extend the sastra of our gurus ,great sikhs we have doubt. can some want tell me there is no sewa left for our bhanji
beside than doing kritian in darbar shaib or join the panj pyare. there are
alot of sewa to do.why we like to bring up this kind of subject which not doing any good to panth.this is just other way of people of anti sikh doing their job . sant baba jernail singh can change the maryada of akal thakth
when he was there but he did not because this will divide the sikhs.At current we should all aim for one goal that is sikh raj (khalistan) than we will call sarbat khalsa to decide on this issue.I hope all controversial subject
should not be discuss because there is no answe or out come. only hatred.
Veer kulbir and gyani ji please do not get me wrong. i do really respect your
knowledge. pls for give me .bluk chuk maaf.
waheguru ji ka khalsa ,waheguru ji ki fateh.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
uk singh · 10 Sep 2005
SO its ALL or NOTHING ?? No veer there are obviously "Falseness" mixed up among the "genuine ones"
Jarnail Singh Ji - How do you propose we do this? How do we know if the Shashtar displayed in Anandpur Sahib are really from Guru Ji's era? Are you telling me that you do not gasp in awe when you have darshan of these shashtar because you have doubts in the back of your mind about the authenticity of these?
How many Sikh Historians are there amongst the massed that have verified for certain 'all' so called Sikh antiques belong to the Singhs in history?
Next we will start questioning the validity of the Nishans posted by Jagit Singh....are we really certain that Guru Sahib wrote these? Are they copies?
< ONE correct form of pad-chedd...? >
jugroop singh · 10 Sep 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
as we all know, many people believe that pad-chedd, which is carried-out by fallible humans, is MunMat. from the evidence that the Sangat has put before me, i firmly believe this.
however, perhaps there is only ONE form of pad-chedd that is NOT MunMat - that is pad-chedd committed by the hand of Siree Guru Sahib Ji...why could this be?
because there can be ONLY ONE correct pad-chedd of GurBani done correctly and that is via Siree Guru Sahib Ji who is all perfect...so could there be a chance that these authentic pad-chedd Mool Mantars were written by Siree Guru Sahib Ji in order to elucidate regarding the ONE AND ONLY CORRECT way of reading and understanding Mool Mantar...?
the above is just a theory presented as a possibility - i don't have the gian to take part in the actual debate and i may have disrespected Siree Guru Sahib Ji by suggesting that He may have carried out padd-chedd upon Dhurki Bani...
if that is the case, bhul chuk maaf karna jio.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Singh · 10 Sep 2005
WIked POsts Kulbir singh, Jarnail Singh, Jagjit SIngh!
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Conclusion Singh · 10 Sep 2005
So no-one has any handwritten mool mantars up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach by Gurus? Then Case closed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
People here who have argued that we should look at authenticity in shasters, historical artefacts, Indian saadh mantar theories, should all look at how they can ever have more importance than Hand written Mool Mantars from Guru ji.
Some of you are even putting your group or sant ideolgue before your Guru!!
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Harjot Kaur · 10 Sep 2005
VaheGuruJeeKaaKhalsa
VaheGuruJeeKeefateh
In reply to Ummm's suggestion that the Manglacharans are pad ched. I would like to state that the concept of pad ched is to derive meanings of Gurbanee from the breaking up of the words. This clearly is not the case in the above 4 Manglacharans it may seem as though to someone who is not familiar with handwritten laridaar writing. The individual handwriting style used, may lead to this conclusion from the onset but this is misleading.
If we take the first Maglacharan for example the pad ched would be
NE RVAIR (even this is a long shot because to my eyes the N(nanna) is joined to NERBOU)
We know this can not be the correct pad ched and before some says that they ran out of paper or something we know this would be laughable as anyone that has seen any Guru Granth Sahib Jee de bir will have an idea of the width.
Anyone claiming the 1st pictured Manglacharan is pad ched needs to have a closer look. My eyesight is not brilliant but the way I see it looks as though KartapurkNirbou is joined together.
The same again occurs in the 2nd pictured Manglacharan, Mu Rat or
Pa rsad is not the correct pad ched. This particular Manglacharan seems to separate all the letters to the onlooker so how can this be pad ched. This style of writing would be more larivaar than the style of larivaar we look at today because it would be more difficult to derive words from letters seperated.
The 3rd pictured Manglacharan uses both the above styles. The 4th seems to more difficult to conclude because of the individuality of the author(Guru Sahib) but the last line seems to clear it up.
For those who still claim that the Manglacharan is pad ched then they need to look again at the concept of pad ched. We Know that only Guru Jee can do pad ched but if Guru Jee did do pad ched then it will have to be the same pad ched across all 4 Manglacharans as there is only 1 Guru.
This is not the case here, i.e it can only be Satnaam or Sat Naam. So unless the pro pad ched group can prove that their can be more than 1 correct pad ched then I rest my case.
Bhulla Dee Maafee
VaheGuruJeeKaaKhalsa
VaheGuruJeeKeeFateh
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 10 Sep 2005
Guru Granth Ji Boldey Han.... this has been proven many times in the past.
When Sardar Lachmann Singh Ji took a Hukmnama to proceed to nanakanna Sahib to oust the Mahant Narainnu..Guru Ji's Hukmanama was...."You will Succeed..but remeber, you may have to give up your body, cut to pieces and burned alive in a fire."
A few miles out from nanakanna sahib Bhai lachhman Singh Ji again did ardass and took a second Hukm.... The SAME HUKM of Guru ramdass ji was given out by guru Ji.
True enough the Singhs were shot to death, cut to pieces and Bhai lachmman Singh Ji was tied up side down to a Jand tree and set on fire alive by the mahant's goondeh.
And this is NOT a isolated incident in Sikh hsitory....several times when the Panth did a genuine ardass and asked Guru Ji....GURU JI SPOKE.
IF the Guru Khalsa Panth does take the initiative to verify all these...all it needs is a genuine ardass to Guru Ji..and Guru Ji will speak. As long as we continue to depend on our "gyan" "cleverness" "leaders" etc we will struggle along these lines
I have Full faith in My Beloved Guru Ji....Jugo Jug Attall Guru Granth ji Sahib.
My sincerest apologies if any ones feelings shardha in the puratan shastars has been hurt by my remarks.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Samandip Singh · 10 Sep 2005
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Jarnail Singh Ji is right, why r we fighting amongst ourselves over things we cannot control. Asking Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the only way out... good thinking.
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Harpartap Singh · 12 Sep 2005
Charanjeev Singh ji,
How I pronounce the names of the Guru Sahib's cannot be expressed using the medium of latin script - sorry!
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Conclusion Singh · 12 Sep 2005
Now that no evidence to the contrary has been presented, then everyone worldwide should accept Mool Mantar only up to Gurprasad.
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
HELP!! · 12 Sep 2005
I am so confused now. Thanks everyone!!
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
H · 12 Sep 2005
leaving the moolmantar issue aside.. can somone help me with the below questions?
..referring to the hukamnamas above in the first one Satnaam is one word then in the second one its Sat naam as in 2 seperate words
and in the third one satnaam is without a sihaari or a kanna.. it says sutnm
in the fourth one ik onkar has something written next to it.. what does it say and why is it there
please help
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Harpartap Singh · 13 Sep 2005
Conclusion Singh ji
There is no mention of muul mantar explicitly anywhere - the explanation provided by the sampradha's from Guru ji's time i.e. 5 mantars covers why Guru ji wrote upto Gurpraadhi - it is the maha (great) mantar...
Re: Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan
Singh · 13 Sep 2005
Nothing to be confused about! just read what your Guru has written!
hint hint, it is at the beginning of this thread
HELP!! wrote:
> I am so confused now. Thanks everyone!!