Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

brain-power · 07 Sep 2005

have you ever come across an 'intellectual' and talked to them about sikhi................. i have always found that after the conversation i feel very cold and empty..... they seem to take away the essence and faith aspect and leave you with a bunch of metaphors........ almost every 'intellectual' i have spoken to or heard does not believe in naam jaapna and other kamai that we do of bani........ and it always seems to be that the supposedly not so bright sikhs are the ones doing kaami and the bright sparks are constantly questioning...... makes me think of a shabad (not sure which one) where Guru Sahib talks of intelelctuals constantly thinking and questioning, and in the end they are left all alone and have got no where..... sometimes i think these guys should try and do some kamai maybe then they will experience something....... what does sangat think? - please these are just my own views i mean no offence or injury to anybody.

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

..... · 07 Sep 2005

you need a balance betweent the both i feel maskeen ji had that balance, he knew his stuff but still led a pious jeevan, he firmly believed in Rehat and reciting Gurbani

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

ns · 07 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh Dear Brain power ji, Hardly surprising as Guru Ji mentions clearly "Purayyee moorakh aakhyaee jes labh lobh aankaar" apologies for any mistakes. Intellectuals mostly are just have way too much ego for any faith to creep in , however the likes of Maskeen Ji, being missed heavily this was one man who had control and balance as mentioned. They are hardly a few Gursikhs like , one in a million " kotan ma kauoo"

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

Jagjit singh · 07 Sep 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I do not really think this is always true. I spend alot of time with Gursikhs from Sikh missionary who are generally very knowledgable. At times the conversations can be dry, but it depends on each individual. However I found intellectuals who come from groups based on Gurbani abyass are never dry. For example the late Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara, Bhai Jeevan Singh, Giani Amolak Singh, Bhai Jasbir Singh Khannewale were or are all intellectuals on Gurmat aswell. Some think research on Gurmat is of little value, and just do abyass. This is wrong, balance between both is required. Many issues in the Panth have risen due to a lacking of knowldge by many sants, but as people have accepted their views, however wrong, by giving them a Mahapursh label, it has divided Sikhs. Intellectualism of Gurbani need to be a part of Gursikhs jeevan, but as with all knowledge it can also lead to ego. That is why with intellectualism, a jeevan of abyass is very important. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

brain-power · 07 Sep 2005

sangat ji when i talk of intellectuals i refer to people emanating out of universitys and the like. not gurmukh souls like sant singh maskeen the late bhai joginder singh talwara, bhai sahib bhai randhir singh, bhai jeevan singh, giani amolak singh, bhai jasbir singh khanne. yes these souls were and are intellectuals on gurbani but they are normal simple souls who have been imbued with the love of gurbani. and have questioned guru sahib but then also accepted guru sahib. unlike the intellectuals who are constantly questioning and rejecting, becuase something in history does not add up or, such and such does not make sense, hence it can't be right or true. faith.

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

Ek Kaur · 07 Sep 2005

I too have felt this way. I have read messages on various boards on the internet which left me feeling empty. You're right there are some intellectuals who will deconstruct so much that there are no answers left. It's sad. A lack of faith and of nimarta is prevailant in their questioning. It's not that it's wrong to question because without doing so you don't learn but having questioned there is a need to accept answers and that's where it all falls apart.

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Sep 2005

These "intellectuals from the Universities" are actually Communist leanings, radha soamis ( can you beleive the Top people in charge of ALL the Valuable manuscripts in the Khalsa College Amrtisar Library are RADHASOAMIS..and what an opportunity to subverse the sikh manuscripts..no wonder many such are surfacing at private sales on ebay and such !! Read Punjab Monitor for this story). Many Communists who look like Siksh have been running the top Academic institutions in punjab for decades.. famous writers like sant singh sekhon etc are known communists, Jaswant Singh kanwal was a staunch communist until 1984 when his conscience woke up..Tohraa who controlled the SGPC for 25 years was a Communist..most of the internet newspapers in punjabi are communist controlled, the Punjabi dailies in punjab are communist controlled. THAT is why so much "academic research" coming out of our Universities are ANTI-SIKH/ANTI-GURMATT etc. In the west we have the Mcleods and christian missionaries on SIKH CHAIRS !!..again producing anti sikh literature by the Ton.. Being Communisty they question everything based on Shardha in Sikhi..and demolish all that by pure "academic" writings. Until we have our own writers at the ehlm this situatiuon will only get worse becasue the old hags have replaced with their new CHELAS... Brain Power is absolutley right.

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

Lionking · 07 Sep 2005

"Purayyee moorakh aakhyaee jes labh lobh aankaar" That scholar who is full of greed, arrogant pride and egotism, is known to be a fool. akalee saahib saeveeai akalee paaeeai maan || Wisdom leads us to serve our Lord and Master; through wisdom, honor is obtained.

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

John Singh · 07 Sep 2005

I had no idea Tohraa was a communist. I am curious though what does it mean when we say they are communist? Does it mean they only beleive in what they can see? Please expalin in detail.

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

ns · 07 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Thank you Lionking for correcting it beautifully.

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

AS · 07 Sep 2005

The wicked... faithless cynics, do not know the Taste of the Lord's Sublime Essence. The thorn of egotism is embedded deep within them. The more they walk away, the deeper it pierces them, and the more they suffer in pain, until finally, the Messenger of Death smashes his club against their heads. ||2|| -Guru Ram Das Ji, Sohila

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

Scientific · 07 Sep 2005

The philosophy of Gurmat is a scientific one. It can stand the challenge of intellectual argument. That is what makes it unique. With due respect most major religions like out of sync with the absolute truth of science. Intellectuals have minds which work to understand hypotheses on a more detailed and more complex plain. We must not be averse to accepting intellectual challenge because it is through such discourse that the boundaries of the truth are realised and reaffirmed. The spiritual path is a path of evolution. The word of the guru is timeless and stands true in ever age just like the truth of science. Our path is not one of blind faith. We should have no fears to challenge the fundamentals. Guru Nanak Dev Ji challenged the practices of his time like a true scientist and intellectual. Through this iterative process the fundamentals of Gurmat were formulated and communicated to the world. They stand as truths no greater nor less than the laws of science. They are open to challenge but to this day in time remain undefeated like the fundamentals of algebra. One can challenge the laws of physics until they are blue in the face but we know they cant be disproved. Why? Because they are the truth. Gurmat is the truth so welcome and encourage the challenge of the intellectual. Surely its a cop out to not engage the intellectual challenger? Converting an intellectual challenger through superior intellectual ability should be the goal. We should create a critical mass of great minds and not be concerned with the masses who are led like sheep. Scientific

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

charanjeev singh · 07 Sep 2005

Scientific, you mentioned that the philosophy of Gurmat is a scientific one. Can you please elaborate on this. What is the definition of scientific? How is Sikhi Marag scientific? What are some examples? thanking you in advance bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

Harjas Kaur · 09 Sep 2005

I think science in proving something is real and verifying it is necessary. If it has reality, you can be certain of it and not be fooled. But scientism, the religion of only trusting things you can prove and arguing to discredit things you can't is wrong. No one knows all the reality. Think about it, if you were on the moon looking down, you couldn't even see one single human brain! The brain is so tiny it would be like a bacteria. How can such a tiny brain hold the immensity of all reality? Impossible. We really don't know as much as we like to pride ourselves. The immensity is beyond us. The human eye can only perceive a fraction of the spectrum of light. We are literally blind. To pride yourself on your human blindness is silly. ham keeray kiram satgur sarnaa-ee kar da-i-aa naam pargaas. ||1|| I am a mere insect, a worm. O True Guru, I seek Your Sanctuary. Please be merciful, and bless me with the Light of the Naam, the Name of the Lord. mayray meet gurdayv mo ka-o raam naam pargaas. O my Best Friend, O Divine Guru, please enlighten me with the Name of the Lord. gurmat naam mayraa paraan sakhaa-ee har keerat hamree rahraas. ||1|| rahaa-o. Through the Guru's Teachings, the Naam is my breath of life. The Kirtan of the Lord's Praise is my life's occupation. -SGGS p. 10 [%sig%]

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

Scientific · 09 Sep 2005

Charanjeev Singh ji, 'Science is the observation, identification, description, experimental investigation and theoretical explanation of phenomena.' Gurmat is scientific in the sense that it is based on truths which are unshakable, repeatable and cannot be disproved through logic. The fact that akal purkh exists and that discovering god through gurmat can be proven as a repeatable experience makes this a science (albeit a spiritual one). Attaining bliss through gurmat in 21st century USA is no different to attaining bliss in 15th century hindustan. The laws of science may have been undiscovered 10 thousand years ago but have been absolute truths since the creation of the universe. It took great persecution and sacrifice of great scientists for the laws of science to became accepted constants of the universe. Today they stand undisputable and will remain so until the end of time. The gurus way is the same. Many dispute the existence of god, the guru and ultimate bliss. This doesnt undermine the truth of the spiritual path. Those who follow the path realise that the physical laws of science have extensions in the spiritual world. These laws for those existing on higher spiritual planes are no less real than the physical laws we studied about in physics. So this is how i have come to believe that spirituality is another science which has laws which are only discovered through spiritual experience. Scientific

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

charanjeev singh · 09 Sep 2005

With that said, then Guru Nanak Dev Jee is the biggest sceintist of all. He investigated, broke apart, and understood the very essence of the Human existence, no, even more than that, the entire expanse of existence. Guru Nanak is the Scientist of scientists. Wah, Dhan Guru Nanak Teri Vadi Kamaii. [%sig%]

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Sep 2005

100% SPOT ON Veer Charanjeev Singh Ji... Sabh te wadda SATGUR...nanak jin kall rakhee meree...Dhan Dhan Dhan Guur nanak AAP NIRANKAAR

Re: intellectuals deconstructing sikhi

Scientific · 13 Sep 2005

Wow glad we all agree on that.