Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Is it okay to clap?

Is it okay to clap?

Curious · 06 Sep 2005

Is it okay to clap in the Diwaan Hall? What about clapping "gracefully" and "respectfully"? Please share your vichaar.

Re: Is it okay to clap?

ram kalay rai · 06 Sep 2005

how do you clap gracefully and respectfully? Why wud you want to adopt western customs?

Re: Is it okay to clap?

.... · 06 Sep 2005

well we've adopted everything else, i suppose only clapping is left

Re: Is it okay to clap?

search for tat · 06 Sep 2005

it is against sikhi to clap in the diwan. You are meant to be listening to the bani....

Re: Is it okay to clap?

Singhstah · 06 Sep 2005

In the divaan hall to show appreciation we shout a jaikara, no clapping.

Re: Is it okay to clap?

hmmm · 06 Sep 2005

No its not, that westernism and is frowned upon. Jo bole so nihal Sat sri akaalaa

Re: Is it okay to clap?

Satnam Singh · 06 Sep 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!!!! Is it ok to clap? yes. In the divaan hall? probably not......why clap and result in a sound with no meaning when we can also praise Waheguru with a powerful jaikarra? When we clap we are basically saying " this is from us to you, the performer (or whoever)" . When a jaikarra is uttered we are thanking The All Knowing and Bestower of Gifts, Akal Purakh!! waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.

Re: Is it okay to clap?

charanjeev singh · 06 Sep 2005

Clapping is a sign of 'i agree with what you say'. This requires a two part agreement. Gurbaani on the other hand, does not take advice but gives only. Therefore clapping is manmatt. In the darbaar of the Guru only truth is told, whether you like it or not. Where people have used the darbaar for anti-panathic activities, these people will be punished by Guru Sahib. But for Gursikhs, the GuruDarbaar is a place to take lessons from, and not to be on equal status or to agree with. It is a place to learn to be a slave. Hence again, clapping is manmatt. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: Is it okay to clap?

.... · 06 Sep 2005

sounds funny........we are frowing upon the western way of life..... but we all want to live here.... better to say we accept the west but do not want to adopt that way in theGurdwara.....you sound anti-western .

Re: Is it okay to clap?

Curious · 06 Sep 2005

Someone forwarded me this link from a Sikh camp in the UK: http://www.sikhstudent.sikhiserver.co.uk/ on the talk "Variety of Toughts of Sikhs" - the speaker at the camp tells people to feel free to clap and applaud in the diwaan sahib!!!!! http://www.sikhstudent.sikhiserver.co.uk/audio/Variety%20of%20Sikhs%20by%20Captain%20Sukhdev%20Singh%20www.sikhstudent.org.MP3 he says about the clapping - at 1min 10 secs people start clapping in the recording which is mixed with some people doing jaikaare, then the speaker says "its okay to the clap".

Re: Is it okay to clap?

singh · 06 Sep 2005

Curious, what makes you think siri guru granth sahib was present at that time?? were you phsyically there at the camp? Lets not jump to accusations.

Re: Is it okay to clap?

AS · 06 Sep 2005

there's no need for clapping in the Diwan Hall

Re: Is it okay to clap?

Scientific · 07 Sep 2005

The great Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan visited the UK many many years ago and came to the gurudwara in Southall. He sang kwalis in praise of Guru Nanak Dev ji. In sufi music they show praise by clapping yet they were told off for doing so in the temple. Personally i think this is a joke. Will god get so angry and think " oh my god this guy clapped in praise of me. Need to keep perspective and avoid silly discussions like this. This is not the Sikh way.

Re: Is it okay to clap?

* · 07 Sep 2005

The clapping with Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan was more likely related to the style of qawali rather than his way of showing praise. But qawali style can still be achieved without the clapping which is inappropriate for in the Diwan Hall. Just out of curiousity, did he sing qawalis or Gurbani? Did anyone record it?

Re: Is it okay to clap?

charanjeev singh · 07 Sep 2005

scientific, you have no clue about the sikh way. clapping during keertan is like dancing during keertan. There is no place for this in the Darbaar of Waheguruu. The Baani of Waheguruu is to be given utmost respect, it is not a spectacle nor a show. God did get angry, and that is why he was given the treatment he was given. Please let Gursikhs handle panthic affairs and taking care of Waheguruu Jees Baani, and you can stick to your bunsen burners. It would be most wonderful if you would join the panth by being baptised by the Panj Pyareh. Until then, your comments are apprectiated, but they hold no ground. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: Is it okay to clap?

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 07 Sep 2005

The diwaan hall is the hall of the Guru- not some dance hall. Massa ranghar used sri Darbar Sahib as a dance hall and had his ugly head swiftly removed by 2 Guru de piaaray. CASE CLOSED- NO CLAPPING IN GURDWARA.

Re: Is it okay to clap?

Satnam Singh · 08 Sep 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh, Charanjeev Singh Ji, Waheguru Ji does not get angry.......guru ji cannot advice us to control our krodh when guru ji does not follow as an example. That is a simplistic human attribute. There is nothing right or wrong per se it is only a question of perspective. As Gursikhs we should endeavour to let others see from our perspective that clapping in the diwan hall in the presence of guruji is self exuberance and not thankful to The Maker who let (created) the event that caused this "clapping" to occur in the first place. It is because of our lack of endorsing the Sikh way of life that has led to many absurdities in the Gurdwara's these days. Instead of condemning others beliefs we need to ask them to question their beliefs further and in doing so sincerely they will finally discover only Gurbani is/has the Ultimate truth. Let's not break people down but strive to show them better newer methods......like not clapping but " japping" naam. satnam singh waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. [%sig%]

Re: Is it okay to clap?

Sikher · 08 Sep 2005

if clapping is a sign of i agree with you guru Ji, then why are we allowed to do a Jakara in Maharaj's hazoori, isn't it done for the same reason, i agree with you so wots the actual difference between clapping & Jakara, don't they REALLY stand for the same thing

Re: Is it okay to clap?

dfdg · 08 Sep 2005

clapping is against social custom...you just dont clap in the presence of Guruji... just like you dont clap wear a hat in church...its against custom...

Re: Is it okay to clap?

S Singh · 08 Sep 2005

Is it ok to raise your hands in the air cus ranjit dhadrian wala like to do this.

Re: Is it okay to clap?

Scientific · 08 Sep 2005

Charanjeev It appears that you are quite belittled by logical discussions and seem to be a narrow minded person who is quite easily reduced to childish reactivity. You need to articulate your answers taking more time to construct well thought out responses instead of reacting like a little child. You obviously have no control of your krodh and seem incapable of accepting alternative view points calmly. Is that the kind of 'amritdhari you are?' Scientific

Re: Is it okay to clap?

g · 08 Sep 2005

hmm this reply isnt about the clapping... but the fact that "western Culute" is looked so down upon... I supposed Punjabi culture is much better... I would much rather be around western people than punjabi people... for the most part... western people seem to be more open minded... when punjabi's seem to be so judgemental, Im not gonna sit here and argue about wich is better... the Point is They both have good things and they both have bad things... try to take the good things from both cultures and leave the bad out... but I already think its too late for you older generation to idenitfy good from bad, becuase I can sit here... and think WTH??!?! how the hell could they think that's right in anyway... when it seems so wrong on so many lvl's... the bad thing about the new generation is that... instead of taking good from both sides alot would rather abandon the old culture and take the good and bad from the new one, it just shows our inability to raise our children, you can try to pound something into their minds their whole life... but it doesnt work here... back in india Thats what everyone believed and only thing they knew... here In the "west" everyone is diffrent and many diffrent beliefs and views... so there's the problem you keep pounding something into their head that doesnt seem right... and they have another answer that seems alot more right... they are going to reject everything you are sayin eventually because you stuck to your old culture and tried to force it upon them... which I understand is all you ever knew... but the world has changed you send your children to school where 90% of people think things you say that are wrong are perfectly fine, everyone is not like minded here, you cant have it the way you want... you have to compromise and do some learning your self before you can teach your children this is not the same world you where living in during your childhood, you where sheltered... open your eyes and stop being so damn stuborn

Re: Is it okay to clap?

BirRaas Singh · 08 Sep 2005

To the person who said "clapping is a westernised thing" then i suggest you read Krishna Avtar in Sri Dasam Darbar. Anyone who knows about classical Jodi (original version of the tabla created by the Gurus themselves) clapping is used by the Jodi player. Im not saying that clapping should be allowed in the Gurus Darbar by the sangat, my post is to reply to some comments.

Re: Is it okay to clap?

learner · 08 Sep 2005

Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan did sing Gurbani

Re: Is it okay to clap?

Hari Singh · 08 Sep 2005

Is it okay to "boo" a keertaneeya if you don't like his tunes? haha. I just pictured this happening... it is a pretty funny mental picture. Or perhaps it might be okay to shout out your support for a particular granthi by cheering him on as he does chaur sahib di sewa?? There is an etiquette that is to be observed in Guru Sahibs's presence. No clapping, cheering, booing, jumping up and down, cart wheels, we should wear bana, no shorts, no skirts, must have a hazooriya etc. etc.

Re: Is it okay to clap?

charanjeev singh · 08 Sep 2005

Having no control of my Krodh is what makes me want to be a sikh (disciple). What i mean by this is i acknowledge the fact that i am brimful to neverending flow of the 5 vices that the Guru has told us about. It does seem to me that there is no end to my vices. For this, i do appologize for the method of which my comment was given. I hope you accept my appology. The kind of amritdhaari i am is the one who acknowledges the fact that the 5 vices have occupied this mind, and does not untangle. They constantly attack like snakes waking from slumber. I am the kind of amritdhaari that only has hope that the Guru in his kind Grace will untangle them for me. bhul chuk mauf karna waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Is it okay to clap?

manjh payara guru ko · 08 Sep 2005

jo kushian de jaikry gjave fathe pave nihal ho jave kalgidhar de man nu bhave sat sri akall [%sig%]

Re: Is it okay to clap?

Scientific · 09 Sep 2005

I am sorry too Charanjeev. No hard feelings Scientific

Re: Is it okay to clap?

5 · 09 Sep 2005

if your happy and you know it clap your hands.........

Re: Is it okay to clap?

Nusrat fateh · 09 Sep 2005

Yes he did shabads, the g'ware was slough singh sabha g'wara. i there are recordings on the net somewhere, i remeber he did the sabhad, koi bolea raam raam....

Re: Is it okay to clap?

Jaskaran Kaur · 10 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Well like about 3 months ago on Alpha Punjabi i was listening to Sant Maskeen Ji's Katha and he was doing Katha in Kerela (India). Majority of the listeners were Hindu's who live in KErela. Their heads were covered with with peice of cloth. Maskeen ji was doing katha in Hindi so that them people can understand. While doing Katha we say Jaikara they were clapping instead. The part which was hitting them deep down and they were clapping. So i think when that time Maskeen Ji being a great example of Gursikh did'nt mind. If he would have he would have pointed them out to not to clap. But then again i think them being from different Religion, Culture, Language and Society they are not introduced with "Jaikara" or "Fateh" so it was them lot way of showing their expression towards Maskeen Ji's Katha. But yeah if Sikhs start clapping instead of saying a Jaikara then we should be ashamed of ourselfs cause our Father gave us such a powerfull and truthfull Jaikara which reminds us of TRUE WAHEGURU then we should use that instead of clapping. If i said anything wrong then plzz forgive me. I am nothing more then Moorakh. Sarbatt Da Bhala Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh