Re: Is drinking milk bibek?
amarjeet singh · 05 Sep 2005
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh
i agree with you 100% singh, milk from supermarket is not bibek and should be taken stright from thew cow by an amritdharee. however this is not always possible (especially in wetsern countries) so as close to the cow as possible should be tried) ie str8 from the farm, were only one person has touched it, make sure this person is a non somker tho) however sometimes even this is not possible so people do get their milk from supermarkets, whilst i wouldnt call the milk bibek, if they have no other choice, wat else can they dp. the best thing is just to do as much naam simran and bani over anything you eat or drink
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh
Re: Is drinking milk bibek?
Amrik Singh "boongawala" · 05 Sep 2005
Does that mean milk products are ok? such as butter and cheese?
Re: Is drinking milk bibek?
charanjeev singh · 05 Sep 2005
I feel everyone here has lost the point. What about dya? compassion. The first principle of sikhi is dya, compassion. The practices of society are very different than earlier days; for example as little as 80 years ago. Today we have factory farms, and drugged animals. If you are truly bibeki, you would not have any milk bought from the market today because these cows are locked up unhumanely and are drugged. Also the milk is changed by adding additional vitamins etc. Do you know where the vitamins come from? hmmmm.
So you should re-consider having milk at all in this society, unless you milk your own cow.
Everything is impure if you are impure. Bunch of ritualists.
bhul chuk mauf
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
Re: Is drinking milk bibek?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 06 Sep 2005
imho..the only truly bibek milk..was the one we received from our mothers.
ALL other is "jutha" as Bhagat namdev Ji says..the calf has already made it jutha ???.
In his Jail chitthean..BSB Randhir Singh Ji was adamant until the Jail authorities allowed him his own cow to personally milk..imho today we are not so adamant ?? maybe.
I drink Processed milk. ( cartons) and Tinned Powder milk....maybe its time to give it up..
Re: Is drinking milk bibek?
charanjeev singh · 07 Sep 2005
i would say and agree that Guru Sahib indeed did use milk. but it is my opinion that Guru sahib also gave us Bibek.
For example: Guru Sahib used milk. The milk were brought by sangat and milked by cows directly. No additives were added.
i) now lets say someone brought milk that they stole. Nonetheless it is still milk. I am sure Janee Jaan Guru Sahib would have taught the sikh that stealing is wrong, and not accepted the milk, and would have called it poison (my speculation, or belief)
what i am trying to say is that Guru Sahib gave us Bibek buddhi. We know that what we use today is definately not what was used in Guru Sahibs time (many things anyway). Everything has something or another mixed into it; even though from the appearance it seems the same.
Milk is definately accepted in Guru Sahibs langar, Mata Keevi Jee served Kheer as tasty as Amrit.
However we must also realize with Bibek Buddhi, that the milk that Guru Sahib used at that time, is not the same milk that is available in in most supermarkets today. They might be some places where 'good' milk is available, but in general, there is a lot of unacceptable practices accepted as mainstream and adopted today.
I am in the opinion that in the times of Guru Sahibaans from Guru Nanak Dev Jee to Guru Gobind Singh Jee, the cows that provided the milk were not drugged nor kept unhumanely as they are in many facilities today. Also, i do not think that other additives were added to the milk.
We should try our best to be humane Gursikhs.
I try my best to abstain from milk products at home, however in langar, i love kheer (how can i say no to what the Guru has accepted)
bhul chuk mauf
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
[%sig%]
Re: Is drinking milk bibek?
charanjeev singh · 07 Sep 2005
Scientific, as i have suggested to you on another thread; stick to bunsen burners.
Re: Is drinking milk bibek?
Jaspal Kaur · 07 Sep 2005
vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji
yeh when Gurbani supports milk it reasonable. However in those days cows were not tortured to the extreme mention in the above posts hana. So thats why i hear that some people use organic, soya or rice milk.
I'm hope this types of milk would be suitable to drink because they are produced in the right natural manner.
vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji
Re: Is drinking milk bibek?
Kulbir Singh · 08 Sep 2005
No matter what anyone else says but our Guru Sahibaan have accepted the use of milk and have called it one of the amrits. It is a known fact that is also stated in Gurbani that in the langar of Siri Guru Angad Dev jee, Mata Kheevi jee, Guru Sahib's Mahal, used to serve kheer that is made from milk. This kheer used to be full of ghee too.
Researchers can say whatever they want to say about milk but for Gursikhs it is established that milk, ghee, sugar and aata are acceptable things and very good things to eat since these have been specially accepted by Guru Sahib (these are ingredients of degh).
Doctors can say whatever they want to say about ghee i.e. it increases cholesterol etc but Gursikhs who japp Naam know that without ghee, Naam abhyaas is harder to do. Consuming ghee (gheo) helps in japping Naam and otherwise too keeps our body strong.
Memoirs of a Bengali Freedom Fighter
Drink as much milk as you can. A well-known Bengali freedom fighter wrote his memoirs after serving many years in the notorious prison of Kala Paani. Kala Paani was the prison in Andaman Nicobar Islands and this prison had majority of Sikh and Bengali freedom fighters during the early 1900s. Singhs of that time and before were known for their good eating habits and this is one reason why they were strong. Singhs used to drink buckets of milk everyday.
The Gora officer heard that Singhs of Punjab can drinks bowls of ghee (gheo) at one time and bucket of buffalo milk in one shot. He could not believe it and when he expressed doubt over this, Singhs in the Kala Paani jail challenged him to test them. The Bengali freedom fighter writes that the Firangi (Gora) officer ordered a bucket of milk and one of the singhs moved forward and drank the whole bucket within moments, without stopping to take a breath. After drinking one bucket, he offered to drink another one. The Firangi officer was very surprised.
All this talk about not drinking milk is non-sense and definitely a Western influence. Singhs must drink milk as it makes our body strong. Singhs must consume gheo since this too makes our body strong and keeps disease away. Don't listen to Goray. Guru Sahib has promised that if a Singh gets up at amritvela, does ishnaan and then does simran, his mind and body would remain diseaseless. So who else do we need to listen to? To hell with doctors.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Is drinking milk bibek?
Common Sense · 08 Sep 2005
Kulbir Singh, Degh suppose to be served as parshaad, not as a full meal. I hope you don't live strictly on Degh and Cow Milk.
Did Guru Sahib use bleached atta and refined sugar?
Would you call the milk and ghee that's available now to be same as the milk and ghee that Guru Sahib consumed? I just hope that you don't go on to drink contaminated water thinking that if Guru Sahib can drink "water" so can I. LOOK AT THE FULL PICTURE BEFORE MAKING RASH STATEMENT. Vaheguru works through these Researchers to help you! Listen to them sometimes. We have been given this brain to process information and decide for ourselves based on the facts of the time.
Re: Is drinking milk bibek?
Kulbir Singh · 08 Sep 2005
Gandalf / Common Sense,
Perhaps, as you have explained, in the changed circumstances, it is better to consume milk from your own cow. I personally want to do this but I don’t know when Guru Sahib will do kirpa in terms of enabling us to get a cow. In the meantime, I will try to shift to organic milk after consultation with sangat here.
Having said that, I don’t think it is wise to totally give up milk. The option is to either give up milk and then eat supplements to get Vitamin B12 or drink milk and don’t get supplements. I go for the second option.
Thanks for the information.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Is drinking milk bibek?
charanjeev singh · 08 Sep 2005
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
These cows are going under unhumane practices through various methods. I am of the opinion that if Gurmukh Pyareh (truly Gurmukh Pyareh) were to drink the milk from these cows, even the udhaar (emancipation, parupkaar) of that cow occurs. On this note; i would like to say that maybe a Gursikhs who is always a parupkaar towards all, is perhaps doing a sewa for these animals by drinking their milk.
I do not know what is right and what is wrong.
The rang of the Guru is magnificent.
Surely the cows whom provided the milk for the langar are greatly fortunate with this sewa written on their mastak. Truly, it might be wrong to take this sewa away from them. Afterall, the Guru and the Gurus' sikhs are protecter of the meek and oppressed. The biggest sewa is surely a parupkaar. Perhaps their milk is their sewa. The Gurus Darbaar is not an ordainary darbaar jeeos. Emancipacation occurs in such abundance, we have no clue.
bhul chuk mauf karna
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
Re: Is drinking milk bibek?
Sukhdev Singh · 11 Sep 2005
VaheGuruJeeKaaKhalsa
VaheGuruJeeKeeFateh
I didn't really want talk on this issue but I felt I had to say something, as some of the stuff said previously is way misleading.
There is alot of youth that visit this forum who would like to keep bibek and I would like them to have a well-balanced view on this subject before they commit to something.
I am not going say whether supermarket milk is bibeki or not but will state the facts as known to me.
The topic did go a bit offcourse as posters like Gandalf were promoting the idea of no milk drinking at all even if bibeki or not.
This is not according to Gurmat. Milk has been integral part of the Sikh diet ever since the Guru's time. Gurbanee mentions milk, Kheer & Ghee made from milk is a vital ingredient for Degh.
As for the thoughts put forward by Gandalf, I think they are from someone who is against cruelty to animals. This is not a bad thought but I think this overclouds his/her assumptions on milk. Any main stream scientist would be able to counter most of his/her arguments on milk. If you use organic milk then most of the arguments do not apply as only organic feed is given (unlike other cows, which led to BSE), no use of antibiotics/steroids unless for illness, no use of single pens, etc.
Allergies caused by milk occur in other foods too like wheat so do we tell everyone to stop eating Atta?
Bacteria in Milk are not all bad. Friendly bacteria in the stomach are required for a healthy digestive system. Yoghurt has plenty of this and is considered one of the best health foods it is often called natures antibiotic. Guru Jee & GurSikhs have used yoghurt to wash their hair with.
The argument that most of the people on this planet do not drink milk does not hold weight for a Sikh perspective, as most of the people on this planet are not vegetarian and have other scources.
However the most astonishing statement made by Gandalf has to be the one regarding Vitamin B12, he wrote
"There are other options for obtaining vitamin B12 (e.g. nutritional yeast, Soya milk, uncooked fruits and vegetables)."
I don't really think he/she knows what they are talking about here any half decent doctor will tell you that you can not get B12 from uncooked fruits and vegetables. As for the nutritional yeast or Soya milk B12 would have been added & therefore these are not natural scources.
Before I go any further to prove that I am not one sided in this argument. I would like to tell you a bit about my background. I stopped taking dairy products about 5 years ago this was initially because of health reasons but then carried on without them because I felt it was not necessary.
Then about a year ago I had a blood test which showed that I was deficient in Vitamin B12. I was told that some of the problems that I was getting could be linked to B12.
I can't say for certain that my problems were because of the lack B12 but it opened my eyes. I didn't even know what B12 was before the blood test what concerned me more was the fact that this lack could cause permanent damage to nerves.
This got me thinking that there had to be natural scource for B12 for a Sikh and I could only find milk as this scource. This reinforced the idea in my mind that milk had to be a raw material.
Now moving on to the subject of bibeki Milk. We first need to look at the concept of bibek. Nothing is 100% bibek except for Akal Purak but this does not give us the excuse to not exercise bibek. As a Gursikh we should be trying our best to achieve as much bibek as possible. To not to try at all is not a quality of a Gursikh.
In terms of food bibek we know that we should strive to eat Amrit everyday so we prepare our food reciting Naam/Gurbanee from raw materials.
Now there are 2 categories of raw materials. First are the items that can be washed & cleaned with water i.e. Vegetables, Fruit, Daals, various beans etc
Second are items that can not washed with water i.e. milk, ghee, oil, grinded wheat, semolina, Besan, Sugar etc.
This second category needs more attention as this is where joot or other additions can be made if not handled by an amritdhari.
This is the category were milk falls under. Even when speaking to GurSikhs in India some agree milk is a raw ingredient but for them the issue is the handling of the milk. Even the Tapoban GurSikhs think it is not right to consume Khula Dudh in India as we've heard many stories of how they get milk in india, i.e. people not cleaning hands, using dirty containers, spitting, adding items etc.
Every time I've been to India I've always got my milk from Amritdharies with their own herd because even in India injections are extensively used on Cows/Buffaloes.
Having said this there is only so much you can do even in India. Only a handful of Gursikhs I know that make there own Ghee, Atta, Oil, Gurr(sugar) but they still think its OK for other GurSikhs to use these items as they still consider them as raw materials. These are standards they have set for themselves in that environment.
Here in the U.K the milk is extracted hygienically through machines so some make think it is OK to use. This is however an Individual choice as there is no limit to bibek. Everyone has to look at their circumstances & make a choice we have to take steps that increase our bhagtee. This also means we have to look after our bodies and avoid anything that may cause harm and affect your bhagtee.
Having said all that I don't want to say that this is wrong or this is right. For those who do not wish to consume milk then I would strongly recommend you take B12 supplements (to some this too might not be proper bibek). However if you are thinking of immigrating to India in the next few years then it might not be necessary.
I would like to also mention that deficiency in B12 does not occur overnight but over years. For some it might be 5 years others 15 years everyone is different but as you get older the need is greater for all types of vitamins.
Lastly I would like ask for forgiveness in anything that has gone against Gurmat. I don't really have any real gyan these are only thoughts conjured up in my little brain but my intention was to give a balanced picture.
Bhull Chuck Maaf
VaheGuruJeeKaaKhalsa
VaheGuruJeeKeeFateh
[%sig%]