Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

one problem with sikhi

one problem with sikhi

sanakharay · 03 Sep 2005

there will be argument, but its the truth. one reason i have seen, and heard from many people, is that many of the sikh groups or factions running sikhi, or who have major influence, are what you would call 'snobish' to non amridharis particularly monay. they are not welcoming at all, and do not encourage these monay if they happen to drop by. these monay are then encouraged to get into sikhi, if at all, through much more moderate groups like dodra etc who dont really encourage bana etc. anyways, the amrtidhari people should be more welcoming and hospitable.

Re: one problem with sikhi

AS · 04 Sep 2005

there's absolutely no "Problem with Sikhi" as you state in the titile of this thread. Sikhi itself, referring to the Sikh Dharam, is absolutely perfect, ok. Problem lies with some of the people who call themselves Sikhs. I think there's an important distinction although it may only seem like symantics to you. Just wanted to clear that up.

Re: one problem with sikhi

random sikh brother · 04 Sep 2005

Thats a major problem, you noted above as sikhs and sons of the the 10th nanak we must be: 1. Striving to be away from Kaam or Lust. 2. Striving to be away from Krodh or anger. 3. Striving to be away from lobh or Greed. 4. Striving to be away from moh or attachment to worldly things. 5. Striving to be away from Hankaar or Ego. A. Striving to be towards Satt or Truth. B. Striving to be towards Santokh or Contentment. C. Striving to be towards Sabr or Patience. D. Striving to be towards Daya or Compassion. E. Striving to be towards Dharam or Righteousness.

Re: one problem with sikhi

wow · 04 Sep 2005

true

Re: one problem with sikhi

question · 04 Sep 2005

Yo paaji I definitely agree with you, I tried joining a Sikh club one time, but the members told me he I would have to be a gursikh. And honestly it took me a year to get over that, I really felt betrayed that my own people, the same people I see at the gurdwara would do that. I started looking at at the other religions, Christianity particularly, but I decided to stick with my faith and started praying again, I know its hard for monas to get into sikhi. It truly is, I mean if you look at muslims they welcome people in their religion with open arms. Our people are andarla hor kush, barla hor kush and thats probably teh way it will remain.

Re: one problem with sikhi

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Sep 2005

...Thats not exactly true Shankhray ji,.......you forgot to mention..even MORE "moderate" groups like Radhasoamis...nakli narankaris..etc who besides the NO Banna rule also have NO Bani rule, no NITNEM rules,no moral rules about one wife etc....people LOVE to join these "moderate" groups..one can literally do as one's heart says... The "Problem" with SIKHE is that one has to GIVE ONES HEAD for it..(GURU ARJUN JI) .and also FOR OTHERS ( GURU TEG BAHADUR JI)...and then THOUSANDS more.... Not everyone can Give his HEAD and WALK the Fine lIne of Sharp KHANDA..this is the REAL PROBLEM these monays cant handle. It is matter of conjecture whether we say the "PROBLEM" is with SIKHE or with the MONAYS ?? Love

Re: one problem with sikhi

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Sep 2005

dear question veer Ji, The "problem" as you see it is..that Sikhs dont want to just increase numbers and "dont give a heck" afterwards.. Join the Christians, the Muslims..and see how they treat you..AFTER you have become one...the "enticements" the "pyaar" is only BEFORE you Plunge in...then its aone way road..no u turns and no coming back * This is by LAW in malaysia my country where once a Muslim..always a muslim. NO U-TURNS allowed under any crcumstances...the moment you slack off....the religious police will be after you...and you go for "rehabilitation" to make you see how wrong you are to slack off. Sikhs can also do that...tell you its all OK..THaapi on your back all the time..dont be afraid...its ok if you cant do paath..its ok..if you cant keep hair..its ok..if you want to eat chicken burgers..its OK..blah blah blah..and thus lead you up the ROSY GARDEN PATH...SIKHS MUST tell you the TRUTH at ONCE...and that is a bit hard for people to TAKE..so they Back off and say..Sikhs are too much man..they are so strict...how can man..i dotn want to be sikh man... the christians are so nice..everything is ok by them..blah blah...and they introduce you to many nice girls right on the first day at church..while the sikhs tell you Dont even DREAM about girls man..so hard... I think i am going to be christian man..its nice, easy life... I DEAL with such people all the time....Its better to be COLD TURKEY..rather than die a slow death. Jarnail singh

Re: one problem with sikhi

sanakharay · 04 Sep 2005

seeing some of your answers, this is EXACTLY what im talking about. and NO, i didnt mean SIKHI was wrong, but you guys KNEW what i trying to say..... its SO sad to see such a simple thread be turned around already. its hard not to get mad. i just made a simple comment that we as sikhs should not be such SNOBS. im wrong to say this?? why, when i have SEEN it with my own eyes. SIKHI is not just for amritdharis. SIKHI is for EVERYONE. EVERYONE has their OWN path, some might be behind us and its OUR duty to get them on the right path and feel ACCEPTED. ""The "Problem" with SIKHE is that one has to GIVE ONES HEAD for it..(GURU ARJUN JI) .and also FOR OTHERS ( GURU TEG BAHADUR JI)...and then THOUSANDS more.... Not everyone can Give his HEAD and WALK the Fine lIne of Sharp KHANDA..this is the REAL PROBLEM these monays cant handle. It is matter of conjecture whether we say the "PROBLEM" is with SIKHE or with the MONAYS ??"" This is EXACTLY what im talking ABOUT. why must everyone ALWAYS TWIST everything thats being said? [%sig%]

Re: one problem with sikhi

Harjas Kaur · 05 Sep 2005

While I do think Sikhs in general should be welcoming and hospitable to all, I agree with Gyaniji. If you are giving your head to Guruji, you become his child. There's lot of growing stages, but you obey the Panj Pyare, you respect the Khalsa Panth, and you follow Gurmat. Otherwise monay or more moderate people will only influence Gursikhs to follow and tolerate bad things. This is how corrupt influence spreads. There is no problem with Sikhi, Sikhi is the way to mukti. At least if Gursikh is wrong about something, he will respect what he is told. Mona/moderate doesn't have this connection. If a Sikh is in a Sikh club there shouldn't be anything but Gursikh influence around, or it's not a "Sikh" club.

Re: one problem with sikhi

limited · 05 Sep 2005

Amrit dharis should definately be more loving towards non-Amrit dharis, monays etc. It is an Amrit dharis duty as a true Sikh to propagate the love and social inclusion the Guru's bani speaks about. All true great Gursikhs had these qualities... one being...Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh. Old AKJ Sikhs have told me of the love they have felt from him and the love he had for monay who were SERIOUS seekers. I have seen old photos of Bhai Sahib doing keertan with some monay around him too.

Re: one problem with sikhi

.... · 05 Sep 2005

Jarnail Singh i think the original post was that Gursikhs should be more friendly and open to monay so they too can experience the Sikhi way of like and hopefully will find it much more easier for them to adopt it If we push monay away how will they know what they are missing?

Re: one problem with sikhi

simple singhani · 05 Sep 2005

ahhh! GIANI JEE i totally agree with you! sikhi aint got no problem! yes, its people that call themselves sikhs...isn't a sikh someone who gives his head to guru jee??..technically if you havn't gave your head to guru jee then you havn't got a guru. sikhi..is true and theres NOTHING wrong with it...if your saying there something WRONG with sikhi then your saying theres something wrong with guru jee!..hmm.thats not true. what do you mean? we don't welcome moneh?? who are we to welcome people. sikhi is for everyone. no1s welcomes you. you go take amrit...and ur a sikh. you dont need a invitation. your not a sikh in the first place..if you havn't given your head are you?? that sounds harsh..:$

Re: one problem with sikhi

Amritpal Singh · 05 Sep 2005

"Yo paaji I definitely agree with you, I tried joining a Sikh club one time, but the members told me he I would have to be a gursikh. And honestly it took me a year to get over that, I really felt betrayed that my own people, the same people I see at the gurdwara would do that." If they denied you to become a member thats wrong. They should let anybody JOIN the club and learn about sikhi. They should speak with Pyaar, and respect , and told you about sikhi and the absolute necessity of following Guru Sahibs Hukam. BUT, if they denied you to become one of the executive members or organizers of the club then thats perfectly fine. What do you think would happen if i were to show up at a Jewish Student Club meeting and ask to become part of the executive team? What about a christian club? Try to join a Islam club, and ask to be on the organizer team. They would all most likely say, "hey you can become a member if you want and attend and learn, but to be executive you must be Muslim, or chrisian or jew. so why cant we say this same thing to people who want to join sikh clubs. You MUST, MUST take amrit to become a sikh. This issue is black and white. But that doesnt mean you cant JOIN the club as a member and just learn from sikhs.

Re: one problem with sikhi

Pathetic Writers · 05 Sep 2005

" The "Problem" with SIKHE is that one has to GIVE ONES HEAD for it..(GURU ARJUN JI) .and also FOR OTHERS ( GURU TEG BAHADUR JI)...and then THOUSANDS more.... Not everyone can Give his HEAD and WALK the Fine lIne of Sharp KHANDA..this is the REAL PROBLEM these monays cant handle" The final sentence summarised the egotism behaviour that the original writer may have alluded too... "These Monays" - Monays ARE sikhs too and what right do you have to say that "Monays" would not give their heads? Are we just being judgemental and acting all so high and mighty especially as no-one is better or can even attempt to attain that level APART from Waheguru? Why distinguish between SIKHs and suggest other factions such as Radhasoamis...nakli narankaris - who asked you for such pathetic advice?

Re: one problem with sikhi

Lionking · 05 Sep 2005

4. Striving to be away from moh or attachment to worldly things. ________________ Only worldly things? How about family/friends?

Re: one problem with sikhi

ekta · 05 Sep 2005

there will never be a problem with sikhi, but yes with the sikhs who become sikhiban like

Re: one problem with sikhi

Guru da Kookar · 05 Sep 2005

Pyree Sadh Sangat Jio, Waheguru jee ka Khalsa, Waheguru jee kee Fateh. First of all I would like to thank Veer Jarnail Singh for his very very valuable answers.I think there cannot be more appropriate answer to this question. But onething I wanna say that there is a real problem with SIKHI coz it has given so much liberty to all the people like PATHETIC WRITERS who started saying that MONAS are also SIKHS. A SIKH is only a Sikh,he cannot be mona, radhasoami, narankari, Namdhari,etc, etc.......... He can be only Sikh or non-Sikh. Anyone can be a Sikh ( basherte ke oh Guru Nanak da Sikh howe). Not of any deras or faction. Veer PATHETIC WRITER ,you are very much right in saying that there is problem in Sikhi, ya I agree with you coz if in Sikhi only one person doing all the antisikh things and still wanna be called as Sikh just like you. People like you wanna all those things like Amritdhari Sikh and wanna call as Sikhs even while doing all the antisikh activities( cutting hair,not following the basic prinicpals of the Sikhi, and doing all manmat, and I know you know much than anyone else that what are these manmats they do, I know you have payar with Sikhi, but first be a sikh.) IF YOU REMEMBER OR ASK SOMEONE WHO KNOWS IT:::::::: THERE IS A SAYING BY 10TH NANAK ------- DHARE KES PAHUL BINA BHEKHI MURRA SIKH, Even there is no place in Sikhi for a person who keeps his hair but do not take AMRIT, leave about MONAS and how you dared to say that MONAS are also Sikhs. It just mean that you know better than Guru that who can be Sikh. In sakhis it comes as ---------- SABAT SURAT RAB DE BHANE BAEIMAN, DARGAH DHOHI NA MILE KAFIR, KUTTA, SHATAAN. CAN YOU AND PEOPLE LIKE you tell for whom these sayings or quotes are written for. It is for the people who do not keep their hairs and try to make them smart as if WAHEGURU has done something wrong or he don't know how to make so called a smart person. Think it for sometime and then try to realise it. A SIKH can only be Sikh, he cannot be monas .................................. Bhul chuk de khima, Guru da Kooker. Waheguru jee ka Khalsa, Waheguru jee kee Fateh. [%sig%]

Re: one problem with sikhi

AS · 05 Sep 2005

The truth can often be a bitter pill to swallow. I myself am a mona, and to tell you the truth....I don't consider myself to be a true Sikh yet. I may wear a Kara and go to the Gurdwara, but that's not what makes a Sikh. A true Sikh follows all of Guru Ji's Hukams, not just the ones that are convenient for him or her. Right now, I'm learning how to read and write Gurmukhi and am trying to learn Daily Nitnem. I wanna make sure I am a Sikh on the inside and I believe that will then reflect on the outside. Baba Nihal Singh Ji Harian Velan Wale said there are 2 aspects to a true GurSikh....Banee and Bana. I agree, both things need to present in order to be Pooran GurSikh. With Guru's Kirpa and with the help of my Amritdhari brothers and sisters, I will be a GurSikh in the near future. But what people like me need are role models who can help us and guide us towards becoming Sikhs. By shunning monays, pushing them away and not letting them join clubs is not the way to be good role models. Instead, people like me need your guidance the most.

Re: one problem with sikhi

Pathetic Writers · 05 Sep 2005

I did not say that there is a problem with Sikhi. I have no problem with Sikhi but I do with individuals like yourself who believe that you represent Sikhs and somehow try to make a hierarchical system in Sikhism which EVEN I as a MONAY know is not ACCEPTABLE. However, like giving you rope to hang yourself further, you have managed this by even saying that SIKHs who keep their KESH but do not take AMRIT are not SIKHS!. Do you realise how pathetic you sound and judgemental and most of all ego ridden? You should look deep into your soul and realise that these opinions of others is WRONG and is a representative of a vast majority of Sikhs who are GURUSIKHS and are loving and open minded and welcome everyone. SIKHISM is not just for people like you and I raise you to the challenge, to PROVE that a MONAY would not give their head for SIKHISM. If you can't, then take humality and THINK before you type. The power of the messages that are written on discussion boards cannot be under-estimated.

Re: one problem with sikhi

sanakharay · 05 Sep 2005

'pathetic writer' is understanding what im trying to say. there is ntohign wrong with sikhi. but there are certain people who have made sikhi a 'club' or a 'members only' event. Whats the difference between the caste system and what you do. Im not saying eat langar frmo their hands, im not let them do certain sevas amrtidharis should only do, im not saying anything along the sorts. all im saying is to get get rid of this hunkar and 'better then thou' approach so many amrtidahrs have these days. arshi giani summed it up in his sentance, but you cant argue against him becuase he will throw some ALL CAPS response trying to out do you. all i said is, for those of you that do...STOP being SNOBS - thats ALL. nothing else. Dont hate monay, dont think youre better then them, dont think becuase you wear bana or a kirpan that you are a better person. Sikhi starts frmo the ground level. we all start somewhere, and for tehse monays its their bad karam they dont have their hair, but does that mean we hold it against them? people only respond to Pyar, noone responds to hostility or crticism. Arshy giani is really setting a bad example, its hipocritical. And no, i cant do anything about it either, you probably are more knowledgeable then me, and probably have alot more experience, but i know that i dont make myself higher then anyone or think myself higher becuase im amrtidahri. my kirpan is not instant salvation to sach khand, nor is the fact i keep my kesh. its only the first step, the toe in the water...and its my job to grow from there, but also help others get to that first step. remember this, god is not just in certain people or certain things. god IS everything. hes in monay, hes in the air, ground, everything hta you see. its like the story of two water molecules in the ocean. one says to the other, let me show you the ocean. god is around us, we are immersed in him, why show distaste for another... anyways, i hope people get waht im trying to say...

Re: one problem with sikhi

ssingh · 05 Sep 2005

even if someone will die for sikhism, christianity, islam, buddhism.... does not mean they can call themselves a member of that religion. Guru Teg Bahadjur ji died defending Hindu's. Doesn't mean he can or will say he's a hindu. For the source of the what you see as a strain of "pathetic, judgemental, ego-ridden", please read some bani/hukams of Guru Gobind Singh. Such as where he says one who does not follow the code of a Sikh I will not even look upon, can not call himself a Sikh, does not have the Guru's blessings etc.

Re: one problem with sikhi

Pathetic Writers · 05 Sep 2005

OK, so SSingh thinks that Waheguru Ji, who created the Universe and beyond... will not look at Monays? Oh Waheguru Ji, please have mercy on these deluded souls for minds that can say such wicked things against Gods creatures are not of sound mind or indeed clean heart. I am a MONAY but my heart is pure and that is the essence of Sikhism too - purity. I wish you narrow minded people the best as clearly you are beyond help. I am not responding to any further comments on this thread as discussion is not being received in an open minded forum but in a 'pindu' mentality.

Re: one problem with sikhi

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 05 Sep 2005

Dear Pathetic Writer Ji, If you made an effort to do some reading you would find out that to GURU GOBIND SINGH JI..even an "AMRITDHAREE" who took the Amrit, keeps kesh and all.....BUT DOESNT KEEP REHIT....is NOT ACCEPTABLE. Guru Ji calls such people FRAUDS..BHEKHEE SIKHS. To Guru Ji ONLY a REHATWAAN AMRITDHAREE SIKH is acceptable. ALL FRAUDS and Non-Rehatwaan BHEKHEES are referrd to as DONKEYS in LION's CLOTHING. What does Guru Gobind Singh Ji say..REHIT PYAREE MUJH KO.."SIKH" PYAARAA NAHIN. So what does that make GURU JI ?? a "a pathetic GURU ??" no doubt as he dosent ACCEPT people who cannot amke a Commitment. YET GURU JI LOVES ALL HUMANITY..he had so many MUSLIM FRIENDS who GAVE their HEADS for HIM...like Pir Budhu Shah, His FOUR SONS and 700 MUrshids DIED for Guru Ji....and they were MONAY, MUSLIMS... Ask any Army General..he will say the SAME THING..DISCIPLINE FIRST and FOREMOST...."soldier" comes a distant second..Even IF the "soldier" is the Prince of Wales..IF he fails in DISCIPLINE he gets the BOOT....adn an ordinary JOE who keeps the perfect discipline gets the Command. REHIT REHIT REHIT REHIT is EVERYTHING in SIKHEE. NOTHING ELSE MATTERS.

Re: one problem with sikhi

AS · 05 Sep 2005

To pathetic Writer and Sanakharay I was just wondering if I could ask you a question: -in your opinion, what is the definition of a Sikh and how does one become a Sikh? and don't worry, I too am a Mona and i was just interested in your opinions. I'm not asking this in a condescending way. Thanks

Re: one problem with sikhi

charanjeev singh · 05 Sep 2005

The original message does not seem to be about monay being considered sikhs; but saying that Sikhs should not shunn monay for this takes them away from them coming into sikhi and hence 'becoming' sikhs. I myself do not like the company of monay for the reason that in thier company i just feel wierd. I do not look down or up towards anybody. but i live second to second. And in the company of monay outside of gurdwara i am guilty of not socializing. In general i am not a very social person, but i am guilty of being more hesitant towards being friendly with monay. I will work on this. I agree with what the original poster has said though. But in general, when sikhs get together they want to talk about Gurbaani and Gurmat (not always), and monay don't seem to enjoy this, so theres a barrier there. On a personal level i do think that we should not be as hostile towards monay. But on a panthic level, i think monays have caused a lot of problems for sikhs (comittees etc, trying to get involved in panthic matters, etc.) Generlly speaking, youth monays and sikhs should interact more on a personal level abstaining from durmat activity and talks, but older monay who seem to know it all; man i just hate them; sorry.

Re: one problem with sikhi

RoopKaur · 05 Sep 2005

>Arshy giani is really setting a bad example, its hipocritical. And no, i cant do anything about it either, you probably are more knowledgeable then me, and probably have alot more experience, but i know that i dont make myself higher then anyone or think myself higher becuase im amrtidahri. < I dont see where he is being hypocritical. Although it is important to show love and respect to everyone, an Amritdharee person who keeps rehit of guru ji is much better than those who shun guru ji;s rehit, for whetever reason. >my kirpan is not instant salvation to sach khand, nor is the fact i keep my kesh. its only the first step, the toe in the water...and its my job to grow from there, but also help others get to that first step.< Exactly! Taking amrit and starting to keep rehit is the first step into Sikhi, it is what makes you a Sikh. And although it is important for us to do parchaar of Sikhi, ultimately it is not in your hands to make someone a Sikh, it is in the hands of Guru Ji. It is firstly important for us to make sure we are following rehit I think before we can tell others to do the same. I agree that Monas should be shown love, but that does not necessarily mean that we change rules of Sikhi to do so. If we keep lowering standards of Sikhi to show "love" and acceptance to monas, pretty soon we will be facing monas who will say we want to be panj pyarey and the amritdharees are discriminating against us for not letting us be panj pyarey. before you worry about showing love to monays, shouldnt we worry about showing love to guru ji and his bakshee hoee rehit? >remember this, god is not just in certain people or certain things. god IS everything. hes in monay, hes in the air, ground, everything hta you see. its like the story of two water molecules in the ocean. one says to the other, let me show you the ocean. god is around us, we are immersed in him, why show distaste for another...< Just because God is in everything does not mean everything is acceptable. God is also in the marijuana plant, should Sikhs than be allowed to consume marijuana? God is also in the murderers, pedophiles and other freaks out there in this age of kaljug, are they all acceptable than? It is one thing to show acceptance and respect to shomeone, but it is another to compromise on rehit and Sikhi to do so. In the end, yes, Amritdharees should not be snobbish and should be respectfull and accepting towards monay, but their rehit comes first. An amritdharee cannot go clubbing with monay and then say, oh I was just trying to get them into Sikhi thats why I went with them. You can bring them to keertans with you, or get them to do paath with you. For a Sikh, rehit comes before all else and we should not compromise on Sikhi just to be politically correct and "accepting" of all.

Re: one problem with sikhi

Scientific · 06 Sep 2005

Sanakharay, Even though i am not mona I have great sympathy with your points. I think your points have been distorted and unfortunately you have proven your point quite nicely with the above messages. The problem as far as i can see it is that as a faith we have become institutionalised similar to every other faith. In my opinion ( and i am sure i am going to get blasted for this) Sikhi is an expansive thought form. The great Guru Nanak Dev Ji and the masterful Guru Gobind SIngh Ji (and all teh other gurus) collectively professed a revolutionary thought process which threatened the fabric of both Islam and mainstream Hindhusim. There thoughts and theories shook the foundations of hindustan. IN history whenever this has happened there is persecution. Persecution is borne from fear of change and percieved threats. The gurus talked of a free faith . One with few bounds. One based on spiritual devotion and meditation. One which was beyond labels. Guru Naank Dev ji didnt discard Hinduism and Islam just to create another -ism. The idea was to disregard hypocrisy and for everyone to return to the essence of true spirituality. The tragedy of great spiritual masters is that their thoughts and true meanings die with them. After they have gone there tends to be a golden period where in retrospect people finally understand what the great master really meant. During this period there tends to be tremendous recruitment into a faith. Unfortunately the grind of time takes its toll and the very people who have flocked to the faith of freedom begin to feel threatened by their own lack of boundaries. From this fear is borne the INSTITUTIONALISED FAITH. Today as a faith there seems to be little between us and what Guru Nanak Dev Ji came to eliminate. In gurbani he descibes our present state because we have become the intolerant institutionalised faith that he wanted people to move away from. Coming back to your point phaji you must not be pushed aside by narrow minded words. Your existence in this faith is needed as much as any others. Dont let anyone make you feel less of a Sikh. As for the physical characteristics of being a Sikh that is a huge topic in itself but i will say one thing- if it is the right thing for you to keep your hair surely if you practice spirituality and read gurbani the great master will manifest himself and lead you by the hand like he has lead so many. Dont look at the tree my friend and assume that since every other tree has leaves you must also have some too. Look at the seed that has manifested the tree. The seed is meditation. If you meditate your tree will become what it becomes. It may not be the same as the next mans but life is diverse. We are not all on the same path. Dont be institutionalised. Stand your ground because this is between you, your Guru and God. Scientific

Re: one problem with sikhi

Guru-Charan Preet Kaur · 06 Sep 2005

Author: RoopKaur Date: 09-05-05 20:03 >Arshy giani is really setting a bad example, its hipocritical. And no, i cant do anything about it either, you probably are more knowledgeable then me, and probably have alot more experience, but i know that i dont make myself higher then anyone or think myself higher becuase im amrtidahri.. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< I didnt get this ? IS GURU JI setting a BAD EXAMPLE by declaring..REHIT PYAREE MUJH KO..SIKH Pyarraa NAHIN... Meaning REHIT/DISCIPLINE is EVERYTHING to me..a "sikh" is NOT. ( that is IF he is just SIKH in name/Amrtidharee in Name etc ) This means in essence that a MUSLIM following his religion to the DOT is a Better person than a Half Baked "sikh" who is not following his religions rehit/discipline.. How and where does the BAD EXAMPLE come in ?? Please elaborate.. Quote the relevant message lines to show the bad example/hypocritical observatiosn made... PLease. NO where does it say..I am Amrtidharee..I am HIGHER. that is a totally false statement. GSK

Re: one problem with sikhi

charanjeev singh · 06 Sep 2005

Just to make things clear. Monay are not sikhs. People who keep Kesh and do not take Amrit are also not sikhs. A sikh is a disciple. You can talk and babble all you want. Until a person does not get permission to call themself a sikh from the Panj Pyareh, until then they are Nigura; one without a Guru. I dont care how many thousand karas you wear and how early you get up and how often you do whatever you do. Guru Gobind Singh Jee Himself took Amrit to show you; us; me, that we have to take Amrit to become a disciple. How can a person be a disciple if they dont adhere to the teacher? Does that make any sence? Yeah, im a student at a university, but i dont go to any classes and take any tests. Before you know it, you will be kicked out of this university. But eh, if you didnt even enroll in the school, how can you be a student? Common people, lets take laha of this opportunity given to us by Guru Sahib and become Gursikhs through Khande-Pahul Dee Amrit. All other babbling is useless. And yes, lets not hate anybody at the same time. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: one problem with sikhi

Guru Da Kookar · 06 Sep 2005

Waheguru jee ka Khalsa, Waheguru jee kee Fateh. Dhare Kesh Pahul Bina Phekhi Moora Sikh .......... Was not my saying Veer Pathetic Writer it is a saying by the 10the NANAK. One thing I can say that people like You who are Monas and do not follow even the simple rule of sikhi to not to cut the hair and dare to give others so many duchers( lame excueses) and suggestion about how to move with Sikhi. If u wanna be a sikh you have to follow the Prinicpal of Sikhism not of me and any other individuals. You have challenged me that even monas can give the head for sikhi. If a mona cannot keep his hair which is very easy how can you dream of giving head for Sikhi. If one person can not give his head to Gure himself( means to follow sikhims and to follow the Gurmat and leaving his own mat that is Manmat) thinking that he will give his head for sikhism is like living in fools paradise and this can happen in the dreams of people like you only. I don't have any ill will against you but the view u post I am totally aganist to those.Let me give you one simple example-----If one person has not joined the army and do not wear the army uniform and do not follow the rule and still wanna the benefits those are given to the armyman what do you say to that person I think you know better than me a big fo............................... Wahuguru jee ka Khalsa, Waheguru jee kee Fateh [%sig%]

Re: one problem with sikhi

Pathetic Writers · 07 Sep 2005

I am increasingly shocked at the sheer lack and/or ability that writers have on this particular thread to write a constructive argument without the need for slurs and personal attacks on monays. As I said earlier, I will not be drawn into any debate as frankly, it takes individuals to have a discussion and clearly the last writer is not able to comprehend this basic ability with humans.

Re: one problem with sikhi

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Sep 2005

Author: Pathetic Writers Date: 09-07-05 01:29 I am increasingly shocked at the sheer lack and/or ability that writers have on this particular thread to write a constructive argument without the need for slurs and personal attacks on monays. As I said earlier, I will not be drawn into any debate as frankly, it takes individuals to have a discussion and clearly the last writer is not able to comprehend this basic ability with humans. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< WHAT are you talking about ?? Everybody has already clearly stated that NO ONE here hates the Monays/or despises them/or ignores them..whatever inferiority complex you have is entirely your own fault. 2. Secondly it is CLEAR that even GURU GOBIND SINGH JI HAD TO CHHAK AMRIT. Means NO ONE..not even the GURU is ABOVE AMRIT....and Amrit means REHIT..of which KESH is PRIMARY !!! NO KESH..NO SIKH. PERIOD. 3. NO one can COMPROMISE on this. Rest is open to discussion. Please explain what is a "constructive argument"...?? Is it that says..YA its OK to be a MONA...and a mona can be a Sikh blah blah. Would that be constructive. NO dear Sir..a MONA CANNOt be a SIKH....he can be aleraner, he is welcome to many sewa in the Gurdawra...etc BUT he is NOT a SIKH unless he chhaks AMRIT and keeps Rehit.

Re: one problem with sikhi

Pathetic Writers · 07 Sep 2005

Dear Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi Ji Can you please stop using CAPS constantly to make your point? I have no inferority complex. I am completely happy with whom I am and I am not disputing SIKHI or taking Amrit. Have I mentioned that I am questionning any of the above? The answer is simply NO. Therefore, please refrain from directing any further posts to me as I find your comments dis-tasteful. Thank you.

Re: one problem with sikhi

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Sep 2005

IF you cant stand the heat..get out of the kitchen. Whoever writes..will get replies....and queries. its sheer "pathetic" that a post is "directed" at anyone..its actually addressed to all.( who care to read..make your own decision to "IGNORE") Sorry to offend....not the intention..but the truth got to be told.

Re: one problem with sikhi

Pathetic Writers · 07 Sep 2005

That is the problem - you take it upon yourself to keep blasting your views. It is un-necessary. PS TO ALL - You keep refering me to a MALE but I am female.

Re: one problem with sikhi

Scientific · 07 Sep 2005

lol I am a guy but keep getting called Bhenji! Scientific

Re: one problem with sikhi

Deepa (east london) · 07 Sep 2005

I don't have an opinions im always told to treat everyone the same i think religion teaches this too! Respect and you will get respect back! At khalsa camp 05 towards the end i heard from a few people that they felt left out. Is it right to say your only a true sikh if you have taken amrit?? Somthing i want to know, please reply people of even better feel free to email me personally if you wish to share an opinion!

Re: one problem with sikhi

Harjas Kaur · 07 Sep 2005

[quote]Is it right to say your only a true sikh if you have taken amrit??[/quote] Gurbani says this. Amrit means you take the Guru as your own, and he accepts you as his disciple. This is the ONLY way to have the Guru as your own. Otherwise, you do not have any bond, and you do not have a Guru. Sikh means disciple. You have to be a disciple. You must promise to keep Guruji's rehit as your own. Gurbani says the Guru loves Sikhi even more than the Sikh. So how you live is important. It doesn't say a particular Gursikh is holy, just that he has chosen to follow a Satguru. If you do not follow the hukum of the Guru, you do not belong to him, he cannot save you from catastrophe. You have to belong to him by giving yourself to him, by following his wisdom counsel. Otherwise your life is like a car without a driver going off a cliff. Even if you are keshdharee, wear a kara, come from generations of Sikh people, YOU still have no promises to the Guru. Look at it this way, if you have no promises to your wife, then she is not your wife. Marriage is a contract with binding vows. Thats what amrit is, you are binding your soul to Guruji, and he is promising to lead you to mukti. Only this relationship can give you liberation. Without it, you are as lost and alone in this world as can be. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Bhoolee bhoolee mai phiree paadhar kahai na koi. Pooshahu jaai siaaniaa dukhu kaatai meraa koi. Satigur saachaa mani vasai ut hee thaai: Confused and deluded, I wander around, but no one shows me the way. I go and ask the clever people, if there is there anyone who can rid me of my suffering. If I realize the True Guru abiding within my mind, then I see God, my best Friend, inside me (sggs 1087). Gursikhaa andar satigur vartai: The True Guru pervades inside His disciples (sggs 312). Satigur purakh milaaeiaa tis jaevadd avar na koe jeeo: The True Guru has united me with God, the Primal Being. There is no other as great as He (sggs 73). Satigur kaa bhaanaa mann layee vichahu aap gavaai. Ehaa sevaa chaakree Naam vasai manni aai: I will accept the Will of the True Guru, and eradicate selfishness from within. By this work and service, the Naam will come to dwell within my mind (sggs 34). [%sig%]

Re: one problem with sikhi

Harjas Kaur · 07 Sep 2005

Vin gur peerai ko thaayi na paayee: Without the Guru, no one is accepted (sggs 951). Jin Gur gopia aapnaa tis thayur na thaayu. Halat palat doyoo gaye dargah naahee thaayu: Those who do not affirm their Guru will have no home or place of rest. They lose both this world and the next; they have no place in the God's Court (sggs 314). Nigure kayu gat kaayee naahee. Avgan muthe chotaa khaahee: There is no salvation for those who have no Guru. Beguiled by worthless sins, they are struck down (sggs 361). Satgur baajhahu gur nahee koyee nigure ka hai naayu buraa: Without the True Guru, there is no Guru at all; and without the Guru one's name is no good (sggs 435).

Re: one problem with sikhi

Guru da Kookar · 23 Sep 2005

Satkarjog Khalsa jio, Waheguru jee ka Khalsa, Wahegurur jee kee Fateh. Really feel like thanking Veer Jarnail Singh jee for his valuable view and bibi Harjas Kaur for posting all the valuable view for the learners like us. And for the bibi pathatic writer and Secientific veer where from ur name it shown that u are male or female and veer pathetic writer if u wanna say something and have the patience to listen also not that if u don't wanna hear or like truth u will start shouting that others are not doing justice to the post. lol. It is disgusting on ur part. Sorry to use that word but think u understand this language only. [%sig%]

Re: one problem with sikhi

singh · 23 Sep 2005

'Pathetic writer' if you would like to be in the company of gursikhs and starting to come on this path please leave an email adress or something and I will be glad to introduce to sikhs who do not care if you are mona or not. Well actually I think you stated that you are a female, but I am sure there are bibian on this msg board who will have no problems becoming friends with you. I was once a mona, just like MANY of the posters on this board, and it was the love of a few gursikhs that brought me to this path. I was not interested in sikhi at all but happened to become friends with a few sikhs and it changed my life. So i cannot say i have had the same problems as you but I can clearly see why you are a bit turned off. Singhs/Singhnees should realize we are not higher than a monah, we are not higher than anyone and few do fall prey to the believe that they are.

Re: one problem with sikhi

a · 25 Sep 2005

I agree with the topic starter, singhs and singhnees can be very unwelcoming.

Re: one problem with sikhi

da singh · 25 Sep 2005

there are problems in sikhi but there aren't any with sikhi. one of the problems in sikhi is that there is a person who calls him self a guru and i saw this vcd of him in india and people were doing matha take to him, i think his name is ranjit singh. all he does in this video is that there are so many people waiting in line to meet him and that happens wen they meet him is they do matha take to him and give him a presents. i think that this is really wrong and if any1 has anything to elaboret on this subject they should start a new disscussion about it.

Re: one problem with sikhi

keeping it real · 26 Sep 2005

i really do feel for the monay out there, who try to learn about sikhi but people judge them straight away and cut them off because they have cut hair. It is frustrating to read this thread and hear the same thing over and over again. Yes i agree that we all should strive to be amrithari, but if monay are being stopped straight away from entering a club because of their outward appearance, how are they gonna change? when i first got into sikhi i was told you take one step towards God, he takes thousands of steps toward you. But it seems sum people are preventing the intial step from occuring. Bhul chuk maf karni.

Re: one problem with sikhi

Deep · 28 Sep 2005

I think the amritdharis who u might call "snobbish" just don't like the fact that the sacrifice they made for sikhi and thier guru seems to be taken for granted when in U.S, Canada, U.K there seems to be so many more monay.

Re: one problem with sikhi

we all got names · 30 Sep 2005

i'm a mona and i'm ashamed of myself i thank giani ji for reminding me that i'm dirt i also thank guru ji for letting me in his presence i thank him that i get to muta tekh to him have darshan of him dhan dhan sri guru granth sahib ji i'm not a person not a sikh i have no guru because i have not given u my head and for the person that said that its good only to have gursikhs in a club to have good sangat i was told a story once correct if i say it wrong guru nanak dev ji went to 2 villages and in one village there was bad people in the other good people and he wished that the bad people stay in the village they were in and the ones in the good village to leave each other how is anyone supposed to change when the good sangat doesnt want them in the sangat u know what i picture the whole world like a desert sand in my eyes sand in my mouth sand in my hands covered in sand i like around and there is billions like me dying of thirst and then we see a colony of people that are well of they have everything i want to change too i have so much dirt on me i want to change but the people there dont want us there so i lay in this dirt and i call out to him i have faith in god he'll come to me i cant do anything i'm so weak dont lose faith we have no guru they say every son has a father just one day his son gets down and says father and gives his head i pray for that day

Re: one problem with sikhi

Scientific · 30 Sep 2005

Dont let anyone get you down mate. No one is a saint here! Everyone is on the same path.

Re: one problem with sikhi

dog · 30 Sep 2005

"we all got names" wow.i am not a mona. hopefuly want to recieve amrit from guruji soon but i am ashamed of myself i have so much dirt i have not given my head and i also pray for that day. i also pray for sangat like you to keep me humble and on the ground. u have more than alot of "gursikhs"-nimrata i can onli pray for this gift that u have been blessed with. you dont need sangat that doesnt want you there.ur the luckiest of them all.u are saved from this type of sangat. u have faith in mahraj.you can do anything. i pray for sangat of people who have nimrata and faith...jus like you do.

Re: one problem with sikhi

Har Har · 30 Sep 2005

Sikhi is perfect and pure.... it is only individuals within Sikhi who cause problems.. for u to even stereotype all Gursikhs as snobs is very appauling.. people with a lot of ego r the ones who call Gursikhs snobs... they think that they r being discriminated against just because for example Bibek Gursikhs dont want to eat from them.... they r engrossed in themselves and fail to realise that its got nothing to do with them... so wake up and stop slurring people