< Bhagat Bani - here and elsewhere...? >
jugroop singh · 02 Sep 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
can anyone list which Bhagat Bani which appears within Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji does and does not appear elsewhere in the writings attributed to those particular Bhagats.
e.g. the writings of Bhagat Kabir Sahib found within Siree Guru Granth Sahib DO NOT appear in other writings attributed to him.
thanks.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: < Bhagat Bani - here and elsewhere...? >
jugroop singh · 04 Sep 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
this reconfirms the theory (which i personally believe 100%) that the Dhurki Bani revealed to the Bhagats was ORIGINAL - regardless of people's beliefs and views as to HOW it was transmitted e.g. through Siree SatGuru Sahib Ji's connection with the Bhagats on a different plane, through their re-birth as humans who needed to take amrit etc.
those who doubt that fact that it was THROUGH Siree SatGuru Sahib Ji that this Dhurki Bani was revealed should ponder over this...
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: < Bhagat Bani - here and elsewhere...? >
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Sep 2005
author above writes:
<<>>>>
For that matter even the "banee" that the Guru sahibaans spoke is NOT in the Guru Granth Sahib Jee. By this I mean that the Guru sahibs must have spoken a lot...updesh, hukmnamas, adesh, advice, etc etc..BUT ALL that is not recorded in Guur Garnth Ji sahib. In fact not a single word from Guru Har Gobind Ji, Guru har rai ji, Guur harkrishan Ji and Guur Gobind Singh ji is recorded in Guru Garnth ji sahib.
ONLY GURBANI...DHUR KI BANNEE AYEE TIN SAGLEE CHINT MITAYEE is recorded in Guru Garnth ji sahib. In fact we have clear cut evidence of thsi..Guur nanak ji telling Bhai Mardana....mardania chherr rabab, banee aiyee eh.....and Guur Ji also tells us that..I AM NOT SAYING a word of my own..all is that What WAHEGURU makes me say...
Same for the Bhagats...Only the GURBANI is recorded. That is why the ENTIRE GURBANI is accorded the SAME STATUS of GURBANI...whether by Guru nanak ji or by Bhagat ravidass Ji....no difference in reverence..we all BOW to all GURBANI.
Jarnail singh
Re: < Bhagat Bani - here and elsewhere...? >
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 05 Sep 2005
MR. Singh Ji, you are right..but that is a "technicality"....NO absolute prrof that this slok is Guru Gobind Singh ji Kirt..or it is and Guru ji didnt write MH 10 becasue it is ONLY half a slok..the answer part to a question..this question has not been setlled..it is conjecture.
Thanks
Re: < Bhagat Bani - here and elsewhere...? >
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 06 Sep 2005
Here it is..
[gurbani]dohrw ] blu CutikE bMDn pry kCU n hoq aupwie ] khu nwnk Ab Et hir gj ijau hohu shwie ]53] blu hoAw bMDn Cuty sBu ikCu hoqu aupwie ] nwnk sBu ikCu qumrY hwQ mY qum hI hoq shwie ]54] sMg sKw siB qij gey koaU n inbihE swiQ ] khu nwnk ieh ibpiq mY tyk eyk rGunwQ ]55] nwmu rihE swDU rihE rihE guru goibMdu ] khu nwnk ieh jgq mY ikn jipE gur mMqu ]56] rwm nwmu aur mY gihE jw kY sm nhI koie ] ijh ismrq sMkt imtY drsu quhwro hoie ]57]1] (pMnw 1429)[/gurbani]
Most probably...the doubt is due to the words GUR GOBIND.....but this is NOT GURU GOBIND SINGH JI..the GUR GOBIND is AKAL PURAKH....and Guru teg bahadur Ji is "answering" his own question.
Jarnail Singh
[%sig%]
Re: < Bhagat Bani - here and elsewhere...? >
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 06 Sep 2005
avidya ji,
what is stopping the writers of the Bijak/Kabirgranth from writing those shabads...from Guru Garnth ji sahib ?? Unlike the GURU GRANTH JI which was sealed in the prsence of Guru Arjun Ji, the two granths you mention are open books..?? please elaborate on this topic please.