Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

AnJaAn · 01 Sep 2005

Mohinder Singh SDO has a pamphlet on the differences between Gurbani and Bhai Gurdaas Vaaran. What is tapobans stand on it. Donot say that we are panthic and accept whatever panth accepts. You will have to refute it point by point to show that SDO is wrong otherwise till proven wrong it will be right. Common Gyani Ji let us have some intelligent replies to this. Request to Admin Please excercise administration so that it stays on track and we reach a conclusion. Thanks in advance.

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

Abhiyaas.Blogspot.Com · 01 Sep 2005

Sahib Guru Arjan Dev Ji has given Bhai Gurdaas Jee's Varaaraa(n) the title of 'key to the Guru Granth Sahib'. Without a Key how are we going to open the door? There is no difference between the message of Bhai Gurdaas Jee's Vaaraa(n) and the message of Gurbaanee. Bhai Sahib has just 'wrapped' up the message of our Guru Sahibaa(n) in his Vaaraa(n). Daas thinks no one can intelligently refute any point in Bhai Sahibs Vaaraa(n). It would be futile to do so.

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 01 Sep 2005

Sahib Guru Arjan Dev Ji has given Bhai Gurdaas Jee's Varaaraa(n) the title of 'key to the Guru Granth Sahib'. Without a Key how are we going to open the door? <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< KEY also signifies.....that a "LOCK" Needs one. ( ever heard of a LOCK that doesnt need its KEY.....implication is "without" its "KEY" a LOCK is just a useless piece of metal. Are we going to accept that The GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE is such a "lock" ? That Gurbani CANNOT stand on its own ?? That If the "key" were NOT USED..the "LOCK" cannot be opened/used/is USELESS. ?? I have several fine "locks" at home but MISPLACED their KEYS.... they are as good as ?? SCRAP METAL !!! Can we assign this status to Gurbani ?? I put it that GURBANI is SELF Sustaining..ETERNAL TRUTH...and it can Stand on its own and be understood with Guru's KIRPA and Grace.. 2. I honestly beleive there may have been additions and adulterations made to Bhai Sahib Ji's writings or they are being misinterpreted. Lets clear up any such "misconceptions". I point to the so callaed Khalsa Vaar of Bhai gurdass Singh the Second. WHY should a Bhai gurdass who is "SECOND" and thus DIFFERENT from the First ADD his vaar to the Vaars written by another...INTENTION is malafide....to CHEAT the readers into thinking he is the Same Author. Only recently was it known that the two authors are different due to time differences..

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 01 Sep 2005

I highly doubt that the second Bhai Gurdas was trying to cheat anybody. I also highly doubt that HE HIMSELF appended his vaar to Bhai Gurdas Ji's vaars. It was probably the act of some ignorant person in history and so it has become a inappropriate tradition that should be stopped. However the second Bhai Gurdas a.k.a. Bhai Gurdas Singh was probably an amazing Gursikh having written such a beautiful vaar. Bhai Jarnail Singh jee can you please share the shabads you think have been "altered" I have e-mailed the Shabad Avtara or whatever thier name is _ SDO mission and convincing them is like convincing the KKK that black people deserve equality with white people. SDO mission calls Bhai gurdas ji's vaars bad names and shows a lot of "baysharmi" in their actions. I understand and respect those who are looking to "clear Sikh scriptures from Brahmin intereference" but SDO mission are no Khalsa Alliance, that's for sure.

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

Singh · 01 Sep 2005

Waheguru jee ka khalsa Waheguru jee ke Fateh What is the key? I agree with veer JS Arshi that " GURBANI is SELF Sustaining..ETERNAL TRUTH...and it can Stand on its own and be understood with Guru's KIRPA and Grace" sathigur hathh ku(n)jee horath dhar khulai naahee gur poorai bhaag milaavaniaa ||7|| The key is in the hands of the True Guru; no one else can open this Gateway. with Blessing this Gateway of meeting God opens||7|| Guru Amar Daas Ji Raag Maajh 124 This is well known fact and Sikh scholars has concluded that the followinf Var is not Bhai Gurdas jee's Vaar. sathijug sathigur vaasadhaev vaavaa vishanaa naam japaavai|| Most of Bhai Gurdas jee’s Vars are in line with Gurmat. Since all of the Vars are anonymous, it was very easy for Bharamins and Udasis to infiltrate some anti-gurmat material. Thus for Gursikhs it is imperative to evaluate everything before accepting it as Gurmat. Waheguru jee ka khalsa Waheguru jee ke Fateh

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

$ingh · 02 Sep 2005

I need to point out here that it was SDO who started the kirtan of vaars when he was part of AKJ. Singhs in the Jatha of those times were not happy with it and told him not to stress on vaars too much and do kirtan of 'nirol' gurbani from guru saab. All this dhadi style kiratn tunes in akj where they do a bit of fast vaaja keys and then the vaar (or shabad pangtis) is becuase mohinder singh started doing it when he did kirtan as part of akj in india. Now that same person has come out with this publication pointing the differences between Gurbani and the Varan as we have today and speaks out that varan donot match the 'asha' (idea and theology) of gurbani. Has he seen the truth. If not it will be good that some learned soul tries counter the propganda they doing about varan Bhai Gurdaas. Otherwise if mainstream khalsa doesnot have any justifications to prove SDO wrong then I think people will start accepting that what SDO says about the vaaran is RIGHT. I fully agree with Gyani Ji that Guru Granth Sahib doesnot need a kunji. The kunji cconcept is itself brahmin ideology where only a select few can have access to understanding the scriptures (The pandits) In order to break this pandit/baman hegemony in the spiritual/religious feild Sikh Guru Sahiban made Gurbani (the ilahi hukam) availabe in the language of the masses which everyone understands. Kunji supporters tell us how do you open the lock when the lock is already open.

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 02 Sep 2005

Author: $ingh Date: 09-02-05 02:58 <<<<<<

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

Well Done!! · 02 Sep 2005

I think this discussion has already been dried out on this forum before. To my astonishement this forum actually give's that SDO Numpty more propaganda by discussing what his latest little thing is. All the chardi Kala Singhs in the AKJ that I know do not say bad word about Bhai Gurdass Jee at all. There might be some discussion on certain Varan but thats about it. These Gursikhs that actually lived in Guru Jee's time and had Sanagt of Guru Jee should be treated with the utmost respect. If we cannot hold these Gursikhs in respect then the show of respect most people have for certain youth these days should be put in under the microscope, as Gursikhs in Guru Jee's time who were respected by Guru jee as well were of a Jeevan beyond our comprehension. The worse thing is that Sikhi is being dragged down by mischeivious people who like to twist to things so that sangat gets confused. I think some of these people have a lock in their brains and need the key more than most of us. [%sig%]

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

Kunjee?? · 02 Sep 2005

Hahahaha!!! Come on guys!!! wake up!!! IMHO I think Guru Jee might have called Bhai Gurdass Jee Varan the Key to Gurbani in terms of respect to the dedication this enlightened Soul spent on learning and trying to undertand Gurbani. If Gurbani is so simple to understand then why oh why does SDO mess up all the time. he can't even say the lines right and then gets the meanings messed up aswell. He is the same as kala - afghana in most Gursikhs eyes. Also the true seekers who try to reasearch Gurbani have told me numerous times that they have to go through many Steeks just to understand one shabad. Sitting on the internet and being judgemental will not help anyone, put as much effort in trying to acheive something rather than posting rubbish. I would like to ask Kulbir Singh what his point of view is, as most people I konw think it would be different to those of Kala -Afghana and SDO. Bhul Chuk Marf Karna Harbhajan Singh [%sig%]

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

$ingh · 02 Sep 2005

i agree that bhai gurdaas ji was the most respectful of the sikhs who had the oppurtunity to do sangat of guru sahibaan and put the akali bani on paper together. but the question is are the varan we have as today matching with the gurbani and if they donot match gurbani what are the reasons behind it there is discussion on bhagat namdev being idol worshipper http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=49278&t=49278 i know in my heart gurbani is consistent all the time and according to gurbani bhagat namdev is NOT an idol worshipper now how do you reach a desision when bhai gurdas ji says (as in the vaars) that bhagat namdev ji is idol worshipper!!!!!!! not picking on anything, not supporting SDO but trying to understand why the varan differ from gurbani.

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

Kulbir Singh · 02 Sep 2005

Bhai Gurdaas jee’s baani is the “koonji” of Gurbani. What does koonji mean. Literally it means a key but it also means a study guide. Understanding Bhai Gurdaas jee’s baani aids in understanding Gurbani. Many place, Bhai Sahib has done translation of Gurbani and have explained the meanings of Gurbani. As per tradition, it is allowable to sing Bhai Gurdaas jee’s baani in kirtan. Koonji does not only mean key but it also means study guide. I personally have not seen Bhai Sahib’s baani contradicting Gurbani anywhere. In one of his Vaar(I think it is Vaar 11), he has used metaphors to make a Gurmat point. Many people interpret these metaphors as history or that Bhai Sahib accepts these stories. Read the first Vaar of Bhai Sahib and you will notice that you cannot help falling in love with it. We should not go for the SDO propaganda and criticise Bhai Sahib’s baani. Even great scholars like Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha and Professor Sahib Singh jee accepted the greatness of Bhai Sahib’s baani. And, all scholars know that the last vaar about Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee was not written by the original Bhai Gurdaas jee. I agree with Arshee Gyani that this Vaar has been added by someone else. The only other piece which is suspicious is that pauri on Vaheguru Mantra claiming that each alphabet of this Gurmantar of Khalsa has been taken from the Mantra of 4 Yugs. Other than this, scholars (besides people like SDO) are unanimous in believing in Bhai Sahib’s baani. I personally have 100 percent faith in Bhai Sahib’s baani and I love it. Bhai Sahib had to be a Brahmgiyani in order to write such great baani. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

$ingh · 02 Sep 2005

Dear Veer Kulbir Singh Ji Thank you for your reply. It is a reply full of sharda. And it is indeed beautiful to have sharda for our Guru and Gursikhs ....sharda de bere paar as they say in punjabi What about the differences? there is another thread going on about bhagat naam dev ji being moorti pujari......and gurbani doesnot say that bhagat naamdev ji was moorti pujari but Bhai Gurdaas Varan mention bhagat naam dev ji doing idol worship? Hope you come out with a reply that addresses this confusion.

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 02 Sep 2005

thanks for your post bhai kulbir singh ji.

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

Parvinder Singh · 02 Sep 2005

Well said veer kulbir singh, hope SDO followers on this forum learn something!!

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

999 · 02 Sep 2005

sdo followers have lost the plot calling brahmgyanis like bhai gurdaas jee a kucha pela will definitely not earn them any stripes, if anyone on this forum says they have fully understood every shabad in guru granth sahib jee then obviously you are very blessed, bhai sahibs vaaran also teach us how to live the gursikh way ona daily basis, he was also blessed by guru jee. how can mahamoorakhs with distorted views even be called gursikhs, they have no respect for bhai sahib, for guru jee or the panth. the jamdoots will surely show them the right path

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

singh · 02 Sep 2005

sorry for being dumb but who are sdo?? is that sikh missionary in anycase?

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 02 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. As Veer Kulbir Singh ji has so aptly pointed out..we are NOT discussing Brahmgiani Bhai Gurdass Ji..... rather we are "discussing" whether some of his writings" may have been adulterated later. This is quite possible as even the Guru Granth Ji Sahib whcih Guru Ji took so much "care to adulterate proof"...did get adulterated although only one anngg and that too at its very end..so other writings like those of Bhai Gurdass Ji were wide open for this act..and they could get adulterated. It is a historical fact that Guru Arjun Ji Himself requested Bhai Sahib Jee to be the SCRIBE for the Guru Granth Ji Sahib...and Guru ji would never choose a "kacha pilla" for this sewa....Bhai Sahib Jee is the FIRST and Foremost Shiromani Scholar of Sikhism, dedicated Preacher of Sikhi in Far off lands...and a Brahmgiani..besides being Guru Ji's saka mama ji as well. We must ensure to keep the two "subjects" apart...and concentrate only on the writings and leave Bhai sahib jee out of this discusiion. Jarnail Singh.

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

Lionking · 03 Sep 2005

$ingh - you are WRONG - Bhai Gurdas ji talks about Bhagat Namdev ji being idosl worshipping at FIRST, not tha he always was. Even Gurbani has Shabads about Bhagat NamDev ji going to Mandhir but not being allowed - Bhai Gurdas Ji Diya Vaara is a, as Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji mentioned a Study Guide - a key for a better understanding of Gurbani. Bhai Gurdas Ji Has written about our History and other things making it easier for us to put things into context! As regards to the 41-vi Vaar it is common sense that it's written by the Second Bhai Gurdas as it talks about Khande di Pahul - and it is obviously someone has written it 100 years later than the Original Bhai Gurdas ji! I agree with Kulbir Singh Ji - "The only other piece which is suspicious is that pauri on Vaheguru Mantra claiming that each alphabet of this Gurmantar of Khalsa has been taken from the Mantra of 4 Yugs." I too was a bit suspicious about it but other than that, it is WONDERFUL!!! Read Bhai Sahib Ji's Vaara you WILL fall in love with it!!! Dhan Guru Dhan GurSikh!!! Bhai Gurdas Ji is the bessssstttttttttttttttttttttttt of the besttttttt Gursikhs - Read his Vaara and Find out - there are no words to explain - Don't take things out for context Singh!

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

Singh · 03 Sep 2005

Tapoban ADMN, Last night I posted the following message on the message board. What is anti-Gurmat in my message? Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee kee Fateh Admin Note: "Singh", we did not approve your message because it was an attack on the baani of Bhai Gurdaas jee. It is a famous and well known fact that the Vaar that you referred to in your post is all metaphors or the versions of stories of bhagats popular in people of that time. Bhai Gurdaas jee has used the existing stories to point out the Gurmat principle we can learn from them. We cannot allow a Panthak messageboard like this one to be a platform to make venomous attacks on Bhai Gurdaas jee's baani. If you want, we can arrange for a private meeting to discuss your concerns about Bhai Sahib's baani. Admin

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. Bhai Gurdass ji is a Poet...a Poet Par excellence....and poets ususally have what we call poetic license. In this case imho Bhai Sahib Jee is using this poetic license to "rationalise" the spelling of WAHEGURU. We are under no mental strain to ACCEPT as Pathhar te lakeer that WAHEGURU is indeed made up of Vishnu....etc ( in a way WAHEGURU does encompass ALL these and MORE as this is the FINAL COMPLETE GURMANTAR). We must not forget that this is POETRY...NOT GURBANI...even though the Guru Khalsa panth has given it place of Merit in our Diwans and it can be Sung as Kirtan/Katha on par with GURBANI. Kabits and swiyahs of Bhai naand Lall Ji are also POETRY..and approved as Kirtan in our Diwans. Even TODAY..young children do ask questions like...From WHERE did Guru ji get this word "WAHEGURU"...and answering them with vague answers like from Sachkhand..from here and there..Guru ji just "thought" it up etc..and Bhai gurdass ji.."rationalising" it like he did is natural attempt to answer such questions. Bhai sahib Jee doesnt say..I dont know..he uses his poetic excellence to write this pauree..implying..maybe this is how the word was created !!!..and being a BRAHMGIANI of that order i am inclined to take his word for it...there is nothing to lose. Jarnail Singh

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

geiooo · 03 Sep 2005

Jarnail singh Your definiton of Bhai Gurdass ji's bani being a key is completly wrong. Bhai Kulbir singh prooved it, I beg that before posting we understand what we are posting

Re: VaRaaN BhAi GURDaaS

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Sep 2005

dear geioo ji, Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. "my definition" ?? its just my opinion jio. In my world of curious minds of five year olds and 95 year olds..."one key" seldom fits ALL locks. (The MASTER KEY can open ALL locks but then THAT key is with the MASTER !!). I have to make do with several "opinions" and we take the BEST one that we deem fit...Here Veer Kulbir Singh's mail comes in useful - DEFINITELY USEFUL. The Only thing that fits the "One difinition/sthir" for me is GURBANI in the Guru Granth Sahib Jee..and the Jeewnee of Guru sahibaans/Shahids and Gursikhs of the Guru era.." Thus the Jeewnee and Brahmginai status of Bhai Sahib Bhai Gurdass Ji is never open to question. I myself am just a nimanna Gursikh...a long way to go in my jeewnee..bani/banna/..but i try my best to understand before i write..as you suggested. Hope this clarifies..