guru nanak ji was a hindu khatri
deepika · 30 Aug 2005
why dont khalistani sikh"s admit this guru nanak dev ji was a hindu khatri......he was borne in kalu mehta" s house...this is in our history books.. so .why they making there own lie opinons????
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
deepika · 30 Aug 2005
why dont khalistani sikh"s admit this guru nanak dev ji was a hindu khatri......he was borne in kalu mehta" s house...this is in our history books.. so .why they making there own lie opinons????**- · 30 Aug 2005
Admin, Please delete this topic or else we are going to witness a whole series of Hindu-bashing. This does nobody any good. SitaraKulbir Singh · 30 Aug 2005
Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee was surely born in a Hindu Khatri family but that does not make him a Hindu. If you read his life history, you will realize that he rejected the Hindu and Muslim faiths, right from the onset. His refusal to follow any of the Hindu rituals including wearing the janeyoo is a proof that he was not a Hindu. All you have to do is read his baani to realize that he was not a Hindu or a Muslim but the founder of the Sikh faith. Kulbir SinghAdmin · 30 Aug 2005
Please stick to the question and don't start bashing the Hindu faith. Admin.reply · 30 Aug 2005
deepika ji, Hindu can mean many different things, but isn't it necessary for a Hindu to believe in the authority of the Vedas, the varn-ashram dharam (religious duty of 4 castes), janeue (sacred thread), Raja Ram and Krishan Bhagwan? Guru Nanak Dev ji rejected these beliefs. Also, have you read Gurbani? You should find the answer to your question there. [%sig%]singh · 30 Aug 2005
What do Khalistanis have to do with this question? One is only a Hindu if one suscribes to the Hindu doctrine. One only belongs to a certain caste if one acknowledges that there is such a distinction between God's people. Now tell us that Guru Nanak Dev ji was a Hindu or a Khatri. If a child is born naked, are we to say that he is naked for the rest of his life? Once clothing is put on him he is no longer naked and it is foolish to assert as such.TAKSALI_SINGH · 30 Aug 2005
>>>>Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee was surely born in a Hindu Khatri family but that does not make him a Hindu. If you read his life history, you will realize that he rejected the Hindu and Muslim faiths, right from the onset. His refusal to follow any of the Hindu rituals including wearing the janeyoo is a proof that he was not a Hindu. All you have to do is read his baani to realize that he was not a Hindu or a Muslim but the founder of the Sikh faith.>>> well sedSingh · 30 Aug 2005
Guru Nanak Dev Jee was born to a Hindu household.... but then Guru Nanak Dev Jee outrightly rejected the Hindu Faith. So what does this tell you, deepika? Born into a faith... completely reject the faith and write against it in baanee... you don't have to be a genius to figure this one out, deepika.10th regiment · 30 Aug 2005
jesus was born into a jewish family so jesus was a jew and all christians are jews? such silly logicManjot Singh Khalsa · 30 Aug 2005
>>>>you will realize that he rejected the Hindu and Muslim faiths, right from the onset<<<<< hi(n)dhoo a(n)nhaa thurakoo kaanaa || The Hindu is blind; the Muslim has only one eye.Satnam Singh · 30 Aug 2005
hmmm......by the way how does one become a hindu anyway? what sort of initiation rites does one have to follow and what makes a hindu distinct? anyone?Harjas Kaur · 30 Aug 2005
Ik Onkkar~ simple words which forever distinguish the Sikh religion from Hinduism. [%sig%]Balbir Singh · 30 Aug 2005
Satsriakal to all and Deepika Ji! I do not know anybody, including Sikhs, who denies that Guru Nanak Dev Ji was born in a Hindu Khatri family. Sikhs do not reject anything from Guru Nanak Dev Ji. In my view, Guru Nanak Dev Ji did not reject any Hindu or Muslim. He made people aware of their orthodoxy and brought many of them to NAM Simran. It is surprising that many people have found new ways to become orthodox in Kaliyug. You may please express that is disturbing you. Balbir Singh [%sig%]Manjot Singh Khalsa · 30 Aug 2005
>>>Ik Onkkar~ simple words which forever distinguish the Sikh religion from Hinduism.<<< Yes, the right wing hindu terrorists have also figured this out. In India, I saw all sorts of blasphemous perversions of this sacred symbol, ranging from "Om Onkar" to "ik OM kar" basically purposefully changing it into a hinduized symbol. I have seen so much that hindus have copied from teh Sikh panth that used to make us unique that they are adopting to blur the lines. It saddens me.Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 30 Aug 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Balbir Singh writes: In my view, Guru Nanak Dev Ji did not reject any Hindu or Muslim.>> <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< TRUE..Guru Ji DID NOT REJECT ANY PERSON ( Hindu or Muslim..or any other..) Guru Nanak Ji Sahib REJECTED the WRONG BELIEFS of the Hindus and Muslims..not persons !! At another place Gurbani says to "reject" the PAAP...BUT "LOVE" the PAAPEE. When GUru nanak ji REJECTED the Janeau..He certainly did not REJECT the Pandit as a HINDU..But his WRONG BELIEF in the Janeau. Rejecting a Hindu as a Person and Rejecting the Hindu Beleif are two different things. TO GURU JI ALL HUMANITY..hindus, muslims, jains, buddhists..ARE ALL HUMANITY/BROTHERS/From the Same Source...so there is no question of rejecting any one.ram kalay rai · 30 Aug 2005
Jesus was a jew and infact he was a rabbi. It was after his death that the christian faith started.Singhstah · 31 Aug 2005
deepika are you crazy, read some of guru nanak dev jis bani, complely against hindu rituals, guru nanak dev ji rejected idol worship, the janeu etc. How is guru sahib still a hindu. ps. Khalistan Zindabad :)Harjas Kaur · 31 Aug 2005
[quote]Jesus was a jew and infact he was a rabbi. It was after his death that the christian faith started.[/quote] Jesus uniquely taught things that were in violation of orthodox Judaism, effectively severing his and his groups relationship, thus their persecution for blasphemy and sacrilege. For example he said things like "Before Abraham (Father of all Jews) was born, I Am." "I Am" was sacred Jewish way to express God, so by proclaiming he was God violated Judaism's fundamental and most basic tenet. "Shema Yisroel Adonai Eloheinu, Adonai Ehud." Here, O Israel, the Lord our God, the Lord is One. Jesus did not teach acceptable Judaism, but radical departure from conventional Jewish doctrines. The idea of a Trinity of God, a sacrifice of a son of God is totally foreign to Judaism and is today completely rejected by rabbinic scholars and the main body of Judaism as not of their faith. So in fact, Jesus was born and raised a Jew, lived as an unconventional rabbi, turned Jewish conventions on their head, was ostracized and condemned and founded a whole new religion with radically different beliefs. Jews for example belief in reincarnation, do not accept the concept of avatars or a Son of God, or a Mother of God as new Eve. Jesus taught he was the Messiah prophesied since time began, the true High Priest, the rightful heir to the Davidic Throne, thus King of the Jews. Jews believe Jesus was a false messiah who taught things which have been repudiated and condemned by Jews for 2,000 years. This lead to centuries of Jewish persecution in fundamentalist Christian lands, and is associated with their modern day slaughter during World War 2. Proof? Read what Jews say about it. Because Christians are missionary religion, they try to make Christianity seem like a form of Judaism which it is clearly not. They do this to convert Jews to Christian religion by deliberately blurring distinctions just like Hindu's do. [quote]"Evangelical Christianity has spent over one billion dollars in the last decade to convert Jews to Christianity. Under the guise of "Jews for Jesus" and "Hebrew Christians," a new threat of spiritual terrorism has emerged in the form of "Messianic Synagogues," whose theological tenets are identical to the Christian fundamentalists who created them. Their ultimate goal is the eradication of the Jewish people through assimilation-it is our obligation to stop them." http://www.messiahtruth.com/response.html[/quote] Also see document The ABC's of Treachery. Its very similar to the standard hindutva ploys to assimilate and destroy Sikh religion. [quote]We have peeked into the "toolbox" of the Christian missionary and selected various so-called "proof texts" and claims concerning Christian doctrines, items that are commonly used by missionaries when attempting to entice Jews into conversion to Christianity. These were examined and analyzed, and exposed as the "pious fraud" they really are. These so-called "proof texts" may be grouped into four categories, each of which representing a different method of tampering with the Hebrew Bible. These four methods are: § Mistranslating Verses/Phrases § Lifting/Quoting Verses/Phrases Out of Context § Altering Verses/Phrases From the Hebrew Bible § Creating/Inventing Reference to Non-Existing Verses/Phrases http://www.messiahtruth.com/review.html[/quote] [%sig%]Singh · 31 Aug 2005
LOL, just read Guru Nanak's bani if you think he was a Hindu. He specifically condems all amjor Hindu practises ie idols, mulitple gods, caste, sati, pilgrimages etc. To argue that Guru Nanak was a Hindu simply due to him being born in a Hindu home would mean Muhamad was an idol worshipping Pagan, as he was born into a home of Arabian Pagas. Obvously anyone with even a bit of sence knows that Muhamad was not a Pagan due to him being born in such a houshold as his message is different, the exact same thing applies to Guru Nanak. If Hindu's do not want to creat problems and have thier faith exposed they should not over step onto our beleifes in the first instance, just let us live in peace. Likwise people who claim to be Sikh but no very little about Sikhi rather than coming out with things like Guru Nanak was a Hindu should read his bani, Jap Ji Sahib would be a good start.AS · 31 Aug 2005
"...A Sikh should become a true Sikh, A Musalman should become a true Musalman, and a Hindu should become a true Hindu". -Sant-Siphai Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa BhindranwaleMehtab Singh · 31 Aug 2005
All this reaffirms my faith in Guru Gobind Singh Jee's words "raaj bina nahi dharam chaley hain". The reason we see Sikhs run after unSikh practices is because we don't have our own raaj. I keep hearing crap all the time like "oh Sikhs do this! oh they do that!" This is the reason! Look at how amazingly Islam is preached and followed in Islamic countries. They have their own raaj, thats why. No one will dare to step half an inch from whats unIslamic. As long as we are living under a non-Sikh banner, we shall continue to suffer. "dharam bina sab daley maley hain" is exactly whats happening to such Sikhs. They've got confused and mixed up as to what real Sikhi is.Harjas Kaur · 31 Aug 2005
[quote]Look at how amazingly Islam is preached and followed in Islamic countries. They have their own raaj, thats why.[/quote] I think they have a lot of outreach and education. They also have high rate of converts. People need to be able to learn, be welcomed to learn and not feel put down or different as they are learning. If someone is in your house and doesn't understand "jootha" do you explain or simply throw them out? Islam reaches people because it reaches out to them. Just reading this thread as a "gora" and all the criticism I have received in a short time, or read about towards goray Sikhs, the hostility takes my breath away. Don't you think Sikhi would benefit from being a little more welcoming? If people understand wrongly, or are racially different hairwise and you want to execute them, or offend them as some "Singhs" have said to me on this board. And what is the answer to all this? No response. No support. No outreach. No welcome. Is Sikhi just a Punjabi thing? Because thats not a way to bring Khalistan into being. If you want to welcome people in, you first have to accept them, and then you have to take the time to teach, but without insult, criticism or anger. There is a difference between not knowing, and disrespecting. [%sig%]Singh · 01 Sep 2005
Mehtab Singh you are 100% correct. It is not fanatical to want to rule yourself but is a common human right, self determination. Their is no doubt that we need to sort ourselves out first ie get people like Badal out, however this task is made more difficult with the Indian Government interfering in our politics and obviously having an interest in making sure the Khalsa does not grow and become chardi kela. Not accepting Sikhi as a separate faith/nation from Hinduism is one example, ie absorb Sikhs into the Indian/Hindu mainstream and consequently keep at bay the demand for a separate Sikh Homeland = the loss of India'a most prosperous State supplying 65% of the Countries food (at the Governments low set rates)deepika · 01 Sep 2005
???????????????????????????????i dont know how some sikh"s saying this they want there own RAAJ this is not a such thing guru nanak dev ji never give this sort of teach to anyone then how some sikh brv thinking like that. ...in india i never see this sort of thing there sikh"s like to go mundir & they do nice pooja they beliving & doing respect of hindu gods....& in guru baani u can read is there any khalistan name of thing?? no..no..so??even guru nank ji was blivin in naam jaap and that naam jaap is ram.....u can read in guru gurnth sahib there s one name is repited and that s.. ram... why dont they chage that???????????????????????????????????????????????? [%sig%]Kulbir Singh · 01 Sep 2005
Deepika, I think, there is a serious lack of Gurmat (Sikhi) knowledge on your part. I suggest that rather than posting meaningless posts on Sikh forums, you get hold of a basic book on Sikh faith and acquaint yourself about Sikhi. The words like Raam, Nirankaar, Niranjan, Bishan, Har etc are qualitative names that denote one of more of Vaheguru’s qualities. It is not wise to conclude that since Guru Sahib has used words Raam, Hari etc, they were Hindus. If we go by this argument, then what would you conclude from the use of Muslim Names for God e.g. Allah, Khuda, Rahim, Khasam etc.? Were they Muslims, since they used these words for God? Bhain Deepika, I again suggest that you get hold of an introductory book on Sikhi. Kulbir Singhrandom sikh brother · 01 Sep 2005
The Guru Granth Sahib is written in a text called Gurmukhi which cleverly binds together different eastern languages. It is for this reason that a person can find words of Arabic, Sanscrit, Hindi and others. All these languages use different words for God like WAHEGURU, PARMESAR, ALLAH, RAM etc. The Guru Granth Sahib does not praise any Hindu Gods, it praises the ONE God. For Sikh’s there is only One God. We do not worship any idols or pictures. Those who pray to photos or people have been mislead by cultural Indian influences NOT religion. In fact, the Sikh Gurus realised that the people may turn them into idols and so the final human Guru, the Tenth Guru of the Sikhs, Guru Gobind Singh Ji told the people to regard the Guru Granth Sahib as the Guru from then on. What makes a person a Guru is not how they look like but instead, what they say and the knowledge they give to the people. When Sikhs bow before the Guru Granth Sahib, it is not the pages or ink that we worship, but instead the Divine knowledge contained within the scriptures that are held in the highest of regards. This is what the Guru Granth Sahib says about idol worship: One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: You tear off the leaves, O gardener, but in each and every leaf, there is life. That stone idol, for which you tear off those leaves - that stone idol is lifeless. ||1|| In this, you are mistaken, O gardener. The True Guru is the Living Lord. ||1||Pause|| Brahma is in the leaves, Vishnu is in the branches, and Shiva is in the flowers. When you break these three gods, whose service are you performing? ||2|| The sculptor carves the stone and fashions it into an idol, placing his feet upon its chest. If this stone god was true, it would devour the sculptor for this! ||3|| Rice and beans, candies, cakes and cookies - the priest enjoys these, while he puts ashes into the mouth of the idol. ||4|| The gardener is mistaken, and the world is mistaken, but I am not mistaken. Says Kabeer, the Lord preserves me; the Lord, my King, has showered His Blessings upondeepika · 01 Sep 2005
mr, kulbir sing ji i was talking about the indian sikh and living out of india,,,indian sikh r not even beliving in any khalitan thing........Maybe · 01 Sep 2005
Indian Sikhs would be nuts to openly believe in Khalistan. Nobody wants to be dragged off to jail for no good reason and have his family starve, so it's wise to say "no" to khalistan in Public. A 20 year old sikh studying in an Indian city outside of Punjab is not going to openly say yes to khalistan...he wants to continue having a social life, continue studying, and not wanting to be picked up by the police and never see th light of day again. But i will assure you, just like every Hindu loves having India, every Sikh deep down would like to have khalistan. Deepika, don't you think it's unfair that while you can be proud to be Indian, we can't feel proud to have our own country aswell?Anbhavi Avastha · 01 Sep 2005
Bhain deepika jee, Please define what a Hindu is for me. We want Khalistan so that in another 50 years, when someone asks a Sikh that question, we are able to answer it. I hope your viewpoint isn't shared by the larger population of Indian Hindus', if that is the case, it is a most distressing situation. Do indepdent research into Sikhi and Sikh history... not the propaganda published in your text books. Don't let people tell you what to believe, make your opinions based on your own research. Live up to your name. Be a true deepak, be the light that will lead your people out of the shroud of ignorance.AS · 01 Sep 2005
I heard the word Hindu comes from a Farsi word meanin "slave". It was given to them by the Mughals. That's what i just heard, don't know if it's true or not. Can someone please clear that up for me?Straight Arrow · 01 Sep 2005
Author: AS Date: 09-01-05 14:54 I heard the word Hindu comes from a Farsi word meanin "slave". It was given to them by the Mughals. That's what i just heard, don't know if it's true or not. Can someone please clear that up for me? ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AS ji, The Sindhu river used to be called "Indus" by the Greeks (Hence the Indus valley civilization of Mohan Jodaro and Harappa) and the Persians used to call Sindhu, "Hindu". Did a muslim tell you this? Thank you.karan · 01 Sep 2005
AS is right. Hindu is a derogatory word in Persian. [%sig%]AA · 02 Sep 2005
Doesnt hindu mean a thief or somethin? [%sig%]Kulbir Singh · 03 Sep 2005
> Doesnt hindu mean a thief or somethin? > When I was young I was told that Arabs started calling Indians Hindus since they found Indians to be cheats and so on. If anyone else had found Indians to be cheats, I may have believed but Mahachor (greatest thieves) in the world are Arabs and they have been looting and plundering the world since the rise of Mohammadism. How can they give the title of "thief" to anyone? What does the word Hindu mean? I think the word Hindu has been derived from the word "Sindhu" the first river on the West side of India - present day Pakistan. It seems that, the invaders used to refer to Indians as Sindhus and this later on changed to Hindus. The word Hindu is not found in any of the old Hindu texts. It must be a relatively new word. Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee has used the word "Hindustan" for India and the word "Hindu" has been used in Gurbani several times. This proves that this word had become widely used in the 15th to 16th century. Kulbir Singhkirtan singh · 18 Sep 2005
Hinduism is after the river indus. In vedas they call it bharat raj. after the king bharat. hastinapur was the rajdhani.realhistory · 18 Sep 2005
No body can really prove whether the word Hindu comes from the persian word for slave, cheat or thief or a corruption of the word Indus. Anyway if it the latter the word Hindu and Hinduism would be unique amongst religions as it is used not to describe the adherent and the religion based on the teachings or the founder of the religion but on an area where the adherents resided. Every other religion is named after the founder or on its core beliefs such as Buddhism, Christianity, Sikhism, etc. Although Hindus have accepted the term for themselves nowadays but during the 19th century many 'Hindu' organisations rejected the usage of the term Hindu and Hinduism and passed resolutions against its usage. These resolutions referred to the word Hindu as being a term of abuse first used by the Persians.undergroundsingh · 18 Sep 2005
dhan dhan shri guru nanak dev je maharaj was born in a hindu family,but on the parkash divas of guru ji foundation of a new religion ,sikhism was laid down.also guru ji never followed the rituals and practise of any other religion.jai sri krishna · 19 Sep 2005
It is said that, “Moreover, it is correct that this name [Hindu] has been given to the original Aryan race of the region by Muslim invaders to humiliate them. In Persian, says our author, the word means slave, and according to Islam, all those who did not embrace Islam were termed as slaves.” (Maharishi Shri Dayanand Saraswati Aur Unka Kaam, edited by Lala Lajpat Rai, published in Lahore, 1898, in the Introduction) Furthermore, a Persian dictionary titled Lughet-e-Kishwari, published in Lucknow in 1964, gives the meaning of the word Hindu as “chore [thief], dakoo [dacoit], raahzan [waylayer], and ghulam [slave].” In another dictionary, Urdu-Feroze-ul-Laghat (Part One, p. 615) the Persian meaning of the word Hindu is further described as barda (obedient servant), sia faam (balck color) and kaalaa (black). So these are all derogatory expressions for the translation of the term hindu in the Persian label of the people of India. So, basically, Hindu is merely a continuation of a Muslim term that became popular only within the last 1300 years. In this way, we can understand that it is not a valid Sanskrit term, nor does it have anything to do with the true Vedic culture or the Vedic spiritual path. No religion ever existed that was called “Hinduism” until the Indian people in general placed value on that name and accepted its use. So is it any wonder that some Indian acharyas and Vedic organizations do not care to use the term?ns · 19 Sep 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh Harjas Kaur Ji You meniton:: "Don't you think Sikhi would benefit from being a little more welcoming? If people understand wrongly, or are racially different hairwise and you want to execute them, or offend them as some "Singhs" have said to me on this board. And what is the answer to all this? No response. No support. No outreach. No welcome. Is Sikhi just a Punjabi thing? Because thats not a way to bring Khalistan into being. If you want to welcome people in, you first have to accept them, and then you have to take the time to teach, but without insult, criticism or anger." I agree 100% , I've had the chance to check sikhe boards since 1996 and since then I can assure you that some boards have improved over time but most still remain a bit talibanistic. Until we don't improve further we are still in that mentality as most punajbi's. It's a difficult thing but with Guru Ji' grace I'm sure it'll happen over time... · 19 Sep 2005
Being born into a family doesnt mean you follow the same religion as your parents, fair enuff that is usually the case hwoever if for example you are born in2 a christian family but u personally dnt agree with their views then u r not a christian surly? the same applies for all religions.deepika · 23 Sep 2005
..ji is right.098 · 23 Sep 2005
I would like to point out something that Mr. Kulbir Singh Ji said, Guru Nanak ji is not founder of Sikisim, he never said that he is starting a new faith during his life time. He was a wonderful mysic poet who refused to surrender himself to man made faith. I am not making this up but this is what historian's have written and no were in baba nanak's bani he say's he is starting a new man made religion as he was apposed to it. It was later after 2nd guru that sikh faith slowly starting to became a organized religiongopi lal brindaban · 25 Sep 2005
deepika all your answers lie in gurbani please take a dip in the limitless ocean. then you shall feel the beauty of faith and spirituality. Just looking at people claiming they are equal and saying you have no religion does not born spiritual experiences or take you to higher levels. Naam abhyas of waheguru is the central crux and bani is just inexplainable to know what it is just dip into it.Kaur vs Singh · 25 Sep 2005
One of Sant Jarnail Singh's speech tells us that : You don't become a Hindu, Muslim or a Sikh just by being born in a family of a certain faith just like one doesn't gain the title of DOCTOR, Lawyer Or TEACHER etc just by taking a birth if a parent is a doctor, lawyer or teacher. Instead you have to work hard to be doctor or a teacher or a any other proffession. SO TO BE A SIKH ONE HAS TO WORK HARD TO BELONG TO A GURU. TO BE A TRUE HINDU YOU SHOULD HAVE A BODEE (long hair left hanging in the top middle part of the head and rest of the head to be shaven), should have tilaks (some sort of colour appearance exactly what hindu priests wera on the forehead) at nine places on their body, should read all the four veda and so on....( which hindu does it in today's date) And to be a true muslim, one should do the nammaz(wholeheartedly) 5times a day and some sort of their prayers to be remembered by heart and had got done the sunnat. So anyone can think of the right answer why Guru Nanak was a SIKH. I respect anyone having a true faith in ther religion. Sihks wouldn't have had demanded KHALISTAN if HINDUSTAN would had been a RAAMRAJ. (as RAAMRAJ in true sense can never be hurting any other religion, RAAMRaJ wouldn't have had attacked a MASJID OR A GURDWARA, IN RAAMRAJ NO WOMAN HAVE HAD MET A GANG RAPE BY HINDUS AND IN THE PRESENCE OF HINDU VEERS) as Hinduism and RAAMRAAJ in true sense would have had been there to protect the innocent, as Hinduism in true sense doesn't teach all that. SO GURU NANAK DID NOT CIONDEMN A HINDU< HE STOOD UP TO GUIDE THE TRUE PATH To ALL THE HUMANITY. DHAN BABA NANAK JI Sab noo summat deo ji Lets tolrate each others as true humans.ravi · 16 Dec 2005
yes guru nanak said sikhs are hindus and muslims... he has arabic verses in the bani as well as shokas from sanskrit....kabir was muslim and bahi laalo was hindu ..... the bani does not disrespect any faith but says listen s and learn do good in life seva simran and deiya... sikhism is distinct but is hindu and islam in one.fly fast · 16 Dec 2005
"yes guru nanak said sikhs are hindus and muslims" sorry i dont think guru sahib said that. guru nanak dev ji said , there is no hindu and no muslim. (i think guru sahib meant God dosent define ppl by religion rather by deeds) correct me if im wrong sikhism is distinct but is hindu and islam in one: did the sikh prophets say that? if sikhism is hinduism and islam in one, then why sikhs are forbidden practising the rituals, pilgrimages and fast confined to islam and hinduism?hmm · 16 Dec 2005
>>>sikhism is distinct but is hindu and islam in one.<<< a contradiction parji. if sikhi refuses the basic foundations of both religions how CAN it be islam adn hinduism in 1? Sikhi cant be disticnt and yet be 2 religions mingled together :s thats the only bit of your above post i wasnt too sure abtsingh · 16 Dec 2005
This sounds very ridiculous to me. This person is provoking Sikhs to respond with some sinister sense. We all know that Guru Nanak Was born in a Hindu Khatri familiy(Bedi) and his father was Hindu Patwari in Punjab. But that is the end of it. He rejected Hindu Religion at all fronts by refusing Janeu(Yagopavaeet), he rejected all Hindu Customs and said "Na Koi Hindu Na Mussalman". Can you call Jesus Christ as Jew? Afterall he was born as Jew. Can you call Budha as Hindu? He was born in a Hindu family. Sikh Gurus were defnitely closely associated with Hindus as well as Muslims but they were clearly laying out a foundation of seperate Quam/Religion/Political entity. Nobody can deny that fact. Even if you read the old books written by historians during Mughal rule, Sikhs were clearly recognised as a seperate faith and Political entity. Why this confusion.ds05 · 16 Dec 2005
fateh, We sikh should not go for khalistan with three districts in punjab. We should dream of khalasa raaj only. Which guru Gobind Singh predicted FatehLionKing (LK) · 16 Dec 2005
Author: ram kalay rai Date: 08-30-05 21:06 Jesus was a jew and infact he was a rabbi. It was after his death that the christian faith started. ****************************** a rabbi?Dust · 17 Dec 2005
Wahe Guru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahe Guru Ji Ki Fateh >>why dont khalistani sikh"s admit this guru nanak dev ji was a hindu khatri......he was borne in kalu mehta" s house...this is in our history books.. so .why they making there own lie opinons????<< in deepika's writing it seems that she is making claim over Guru Nanak but the Khalistani sikh dont admit her claim. At the time when Guru Nanak immersed His jot with Akal Purkh there was chaos among hindus and muslims. both the faiths were claiming that Baba Nanak was their. Muslims were claiming that He was our Peer and Hindus were saying that He was our Guru and we shall performs last rites according their respective faiths. As all know nothing was there for performance, only a piece of cloth and some flowers were there to do the performance. The piece of cloth and flowers were divided into half and both the faiths performed according to their customs. Proof is there at Kartarpur Sahib. who can claim that sun, moon or air belong to them, and to no body else. deepika ji if you love Baba Nanak He is yours and He loves you too not withstanding what the others say. But definitely He was not a Hindu nor a Musalmaan and He founded a new faith that is called Sikhism, the constitution of which in the form of Gurbani He started writing from the on set. Guru is perfect roop of the almighty akal purakh. And the Akal Purkh has no cast or creed then how can Guru belong to this and that caste or creed. At the time of Parkash of Shri Guru Gobind Singh Maharaj at Patna a muslim peer called Bhikhan Shah put two pots one filled with milk represeting muslims and the other filled with water represeting hindus before the Sahib to see to whom He will favour. Sahib put His two hands upon both the pots. I believe deepika ji's claim is solid as an individual but not as a hindu. Bhul Chuk Maf Wahe Guru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahe Guru Ji Ki Fateh| · 18 Dec 2005
sloku ] salok || Shalok: bhu swsqR bhu isimRqI pyKy srb FFoil ] bahu saasathr bahu simrithee paekhae sarab dtadtol || The many Shaastras and the many Simritees - I have seen and searched through them all. pUjis nwhI hir hry nwnk nwm Amol ]1] poojas naahee har harae naanak naam amol ||1|| They are not equal to Har, Haray - O Nanak, the Lord's Invaluable Name. ||1|| AstpdI ] asattapadhee || Ashtapadee: jwp qwp igAwn siB iDAwn ] jaap thaap giaan sabh dhhiaan || Chanting, intense meditation, spiritual wisdom and all meditations; Kt swsqR isimRiq viKAwn ] khatt saasathr simrith vakhiaan || the six schools of philosophy and sermons on the scriptures; jog AiBAws krm DRm ikirAw ] jog abhiaas karam dhhram kiriaa || the practice of Yoga and righteous conduct; sgl iqAwig bn mDy iPirAw ] sagal thiaag ban madhhae firiaa || the renunciation of everything and wandering around in the wilderness; Aink pRkwr kIey bhu jqnw ] anik prakaar keeeae bahu jathanaa || the performance of all sorts of works; puMn dwn homy bhu rqnw ] pu(n)n dhaan homae bahu rathanaa || donations to charities and offerings of jewels to fire; srIru ktwie homY kir rwqI ] sareer kattaae homai kar raathee || cutting the body apart and making the pieces into ceremonial fire offerings; vrq nym krY bhu BwqI ] varath naem karai bahu bhaathee || keeping fasts and making vows of all sorts nhI quil rwm nwm bIcwr ] nehee thul raam naam beechaar || - none of these are equal to the contemplation of the Name of the Lord, nwnk gurmuiK nwmu jpIAY iek bwr ]1] naanak guramukh naam japeeai eik baar ||1|| O Nanak, if, as Gurmukh, one chants the Naam, even once. ||1|| nau KMf ipRQmI iPrY icru jIvY ] no kha(n)dd prithhamee firai chir jeevai || You may roam over the nine continents of the world and live a very long life; mhw audwsu qpIsru QIvY ] mehaa oudhaas thapeesar thheevai || you may become a great ascetic and a master of disciplined meditation Agin mwih homq prwn ] agan maahi homath paraan || and burn yourself in fire; kink AsÍ hYvr BUim dwn ] kanik asv haivar bhoom dhaan || you may give away gold, horses, elephants and land; inaulI krm krY bhu Awsn ] nioulee karam karai bahu aasan || you may practice techniques of inner cleansing and all sorts of Yogic postures; jYn mwrg sMjm Aiq swDn ] jain maarag sa(n)jam ath saadhhan || you may adopt the self-mortifying ways of the Jains and great spiritual disciplines; inmK inmK kir srIru ktwvY ] nimakh nimakh kar sareer kattaavai || piece by piece, you may cut your body apart; qau BI haumY mYlu n jwvY ] tho bhee houmai mail n jaavai || but even so, the filth of your ego shall not depart. hir ky nwm smsir kCu nwih ] har kae naam samasar kashh naahi || There is nothing equal to the Name of the Lord. nwnk gurmuiK nwmu jpq giq pwih ]2] naanak guramukh naam japath gath paahi ||2|| O Nanak, as Gurmukh, chant the Naam, and obtain salvation. ||2|| mn kwmnw qIrQ dyh CutY ] man kaamanaa theerathh dhaeh shhuttai || With your mind filled with desire, you may give up your body at a sacred shrine of pilgrimage; grbu gumwnu n mn qy hutY ] garab gumaan n man thae huttai || but even so, egotistical pride shall not be removed from your mind. soc krY idnsu Aru rwiq ] soch karai dhinas ar raath || You may practice cleansing day and night, mn kI mYlu n qn qy jwiq ] man kee mail n than thae jaath || but the filth of your mind shall not leave your body. iesu dyhI kau bhu swDnw krY ] eis dhaehee ko bahu saadhhanaa karai || You may subject your body to all sorts of disciplines, mn qy kbhU n ibiKAw trY ] man thae kabehoo n bikhiaa ttarai || but your mind will never be rid of its corruption. jil DovY bhu dyh AnIiq ] jal dhhovai bahu dhaeh aneeth || You may wash this transitory body with loads of water, suD khw hoie kwcI BIiq ] sudhh kehaa hoe kaachee bheeth || but how can a wall of mud be washed clean? mn hir ky nwm kI mihmw aUc ] man har kae naam kee mehimaa ooch || O my mind, the Glorious Praise of the Name of the Lord is the highest; nwnk nwim auDry piqq bhu mUc ]3] naanak naam oudhharae pathith bahu mooch ||3|| O Nanak, the Naam has saved so many of the worst sinners. ||3|| bhuqu isAwxp jm kw Bau ibAwpY ] bahuth siaanap jam kaa bho biaapai || Even with great cleverness, the fear of death clings to you. Aink jqn kir iqRsn nw DRwpY ] anik jathan kar thrisan naa dhhraapai || You try all sorts of things, but your thirst is still not satisfied. ByK Anyk Agin nhI buJY ] bhaekh anaek agan nehee bujhai || Wearing various religious robes, the fire is not extinguished. koit aupwv drgh nhI isJY ] kott oupaav dharageh nehee sijhai || Even making millions of efforts, you shall not be accepted in the Court of the Lord. CUtis nwhI aUB pieAwil ] shhoottas naahee oobh paeiaal || You cannot escape to the heavens, or to the nether regions, moih ibAwpih mwieAw jwil ] mohi biaapehi maaeiaa jaal || if you are entangled in emotional attachment and the net of Maya. Avr krqUiq sglI jmu fwnY ] avar karathooth sagalee jam ddaanai || All other efforts are punished by the Messenger of Death, goivMd Bjn ibnu iqlu nhI mwnY ] govi(n)dh bhajan bin thil nehee maanai || which accepts nothing at all, except meditation on the Lord of the Universe. hir kw nwmu jpq duKu jwie ] har kaa naam japath dhukh jaae || Chanting the Name of the Lord, sorrow is dispelled. nwnk bolY shij suBwie ]4] naanak bolai sehaj subhaae ||4|| O Nanak, chant it with intuitive ease. ||4|| cwir pdwrQ jy ko mwgY ] chaar padhaarathh jae ko maagai || One who prays for the four cardinal blessings swD jnw kI syvw lwgY ] saadhh janaa kee saevaa laagai || should commit himself to the service of the Saints. jy ko Awpunw dUKu imtwvY ] jae ko aapunaa dhookh mittaavai || If you wish to erase your sorrows, hir hir nwmu irdY sd gwvY ] har har naam ridhai sadh gaavai || sing the Name of the Lord, Har, Har, within your heart. jy ko ApunI soBw lorY ] jae ko apunee sobhaa lorai || If you long for honor for yourself, swDsMig ieh haumY CorY ] saadhhasa(n)g eih houmai shhorai || then renounce your ego in the Saadh Sangat, the Company of the Holy. jy ko jnm mrx qy frY ] jae ko janam maran thae ddarai || If you fear the cycle of birth and death, swD jnw kI srnI prY ] saadhh janaa kee saranee parai || then seek the Sanctuary of the Holy. ijsu jn kau pRB drs ipAwsw ] jis jan ko prabh dharas piaasaa || Those who thirst for the Blessed Vision of God's Darshan nwnk qw kY bil bil jwsw ]5] naanak thaa kai bal bal jaasaa ||5|| - Nanak is a sacrifice, a sacrifice to them. ||5|| sgl purK mih purKu pRDwnu ] sagal purakh mehi purakh pradhhaan || Among all persons, the supreme person is the one swDsMig jw kw imtY AiBmwnu ] saadhhasa(n)g jaa kaa mittai abhimaan || who gives up his egotistical pride in the Company of the Holy. Awps kau jo jwxY nIcw ] aapas ko jo jaanai neechaa || One who sees himself as lowly, soaU gnIAY sB qy aUcw ] sooo ganeeai sabh thae oochaa || shall be accounted as the highest of all. jw kw mnu hoie sgl kI rInw ] jaa kaa man hoe sagal kee reenaa || One whose mind is the dust of all, hir hir nwmu iqin Git Git cInw ] har har naam thin ghatt ghatt cheenaa || recognizes the Name of the Lord, Har, Har, in each and every heart. mn Apuny qy burw imtwnw ] man apunae thae buraa mittaanaa || One who eradicates cruelty from within his own mind, pyKY sgl isRsit swjnw ] paekhai sagal srisatt saajanaa || looks upon all the world as his friend. sUK dUK jn sm idRstyqw ] sookh dhookh jan sam dhrisattaethaa || One who looks upon pleasure and pain as one and the same, nwnk pwp puMn nhI lypw ]6] naanak paap pu(n)n nehee laepaa ||6|| O Nanak, is not affected by sin or virtue. ||6|| inrDn kau Dnu qyro nwau ] niradhhan ko dhhan thaero naao || To the poor, Your Name is wealth. inQwvy kau nwau qyrw Qwau ] nithhaavae ko naao thaeraa thhaao || To the homeless, Your Name is home. inmwny kau pRB qyro mwnu ] nimaanae ko prabh thaero maan || To the dishonored, You, O God, are honor. sgl Gtw kau dyvhu dwnu ] sagal ghattaa ko dhaevahu dhaan || To all, You are the Giver of gifts. krn krwvnhwr suAwmI ] karan karaavanehaar suaamee || O Creator Lord, Cause of causes, O Lord and Master, sgl Gtw ky AMqrjwmI ] sagal ghattaa kae a(n)tharajaamee || Inner-knower, Searcher of all hearts: ApnI giq imiq jwnhu Awpy ] apanee gath mith jaanahu aapae || You alone know Your own condition and state. Awpn sMig Awip pRB rwqy ] aapan sa(n)g aap prabh raathae || You Yourself, God, are imbued with Yourself. qum@rI ausqiq qum qy hoie ] thumharee ousathath thum thae hoe || You alone can celebrate Your Praises. nwnk Avru n jwnis koie ]7] naanak avar n jaanas koe ||7|| O Nanak, no one else knows. ||7|| srb Drm mih sRyst Drmu ] sarab dhharam mehi sraesatt dhharam || Of all religions, the best religion hir ko nwmu jip inrml krmu ] har ko naam jap niramal karam || is to chant the Name of the Lord and maintain pure conduct. sgl ik®Aw mih aUqm ikirAw ] sagal kiraaa mehi ootham kiriaa || Of all religious rituals, the most sublime ritual swDsMig durmiq mlu ihirAw ] saadhhasa(n)g dhuramath mal hiriaa || is to erase the filth of the dirty mind in the Company of the Holy. sgl audm mih audmu Blw ] sagal oudham mehi oudham bhalaa || Of all efforts, the best effort hir kw nwmu jphu jIA sdw ] har kaa naam japahu jeea sadhaa || is to chant the Name of the Lord in the heart, forever. sgl bwnI mih AMimRq bwnI ] sagal baanee mehi a(n)mrith baanee || Of all speech, the most ambrosial speech hir ko jsu suin rsn bKwnI ] har ko jas sun rasan bakhaanee || is to hear the Lord's Praise and chant it with the tongue. sgl Qwn qy Ehu aUqm Qwnu ] sagal thhaan thae ouhu ootham thhaan || Of all places, the most sublime place, nwnk ijh Git vsY hir nwmu ]8]3] naanak jih ghatt vasai har naam ||8||3|| O Nanak, is that heart in which the Name of the Lord abides. ||8||3|| Sukhmanee Sahib (Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee) from www.sikhitothemax.com