Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

What's Worst?

What's Worst?

someone · 09 Oct 2003

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh What's worst? Finding out in the after-world that Raag Mala was Bani all along, and we went our whole lives without ever completing a reading of the Guru Granth Sahib Ji?.... or.... Finding out in the after-world that Raag Mala was not Bani all along, and we went our whole lives reading the whole Guru Granth Sahib Ji, as well as the Raag Mala in addition? MY VIEW---i'm not gonna take any chances. Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: What's Worst?

Kulbir Singh · 09 Oct 2003

Can't you use the same argument for Keski as well? How about for Sarbloh Bibek and Bibek? What happens if you discover after death that keski in fact is a kakaar and Sarbloh Bibek was a must? What would you do then? I would say to be on the safe side, keep these rehits. Raagmala issue is a minor issue as compared to these rehits. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: What's Worst?

me me me · 09 Oct 2003

heheh...good point by Bhai Kulbir Singh Jee. i totally agree.

Re: What's Worst?

WHAT!!! · 09 Oct 2003

Kubir Singh Veerji...you said: How could you say such a thing? I know you feel that Raag Mala is not Bani...but whether or not the whole Guru Granth Sahib Ji is being recited is a MAJOR thing.

Re: What's Worst?

Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 09 Oct 2003

Interesting logic Veer Ji. I hope those who follow the earlier logic given by 'someone' will atleast start following rehit of keski at all times and bebaik. Another interesting thing is that according to Sri Akal Takhat Sahib ji Akhand Path Sahib is complete with or without the reading of Raag Maala so we can all be on the safe side by aligning ourselves with Sri Akal Takhat Sahib ji but sadly no side (pro or anti Raag maala) seems to follow the hukam of Sri Akal Takhat Sahib ji. Why is it that we are always concerned if the other person reads Raag Maala or not? Why can't we just worry about ourselves? I am sorry but I have found such behavior in both groups. Reading or not reading of Raag Maala does not hurt me that much, but I really find it upsetting when someone questions others if they read Raag Maala or not. We all need to stop this. Will knowing if the other person approves Raag Maala or rejects it make us any better?

Re: What's Worst?

jagjit singh · 09 Oct 2003

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I think your logic is wrong. The only thing I would be worried about in the afterlife, is whether I implemented what was actually written in the Sahib Siri Guru Granth Ji, not what was at the end. Does that not make sense. It is like when Hindus and muslims said to Guru Nanak dev Ji who is higher. Guru Ji replied none if the have no good deeds. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: What's Worst?

katha · 10 Oct 2003

All of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee is Ustat of Akal Purakh. Guru Sahib Does not even do ustat of any of our gurus such as Guru Nanak Dev Jee. Guru Sahib only does ustat of akal purakh and those who are merged with him. So why all of a sudden at the end something that does ustat of raags? seems a bit incredible if you ask me.

Re: What's Worst?

? · 10 Oct 2003

WHY IS AKAAL PURAKH ALL WAYS REFFERED TO AS ' H I M ' OR ' H E ' ?????

Re: What's Worst?

Gurbani premi · 10 Oct 2003

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh SATGURU BINA HOR KACHI HAI BANI|| BANI TE KACHI SATGURU BAJHU HOR KACHI BANI|| KEHDEY KACHE SUNDE KACHE KACHIEN AAKH VAKHANI|| (Anand Sahib) Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh.

Re: What's Worst?

someone · 10 Oct 2003

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Gurbani premi....you should be careful when you use Gurbani . You are calling Raag Mala kachi bani...thats takes guts. What if it was Bani all along? You can't be 100% sure...everybody just follows what one person says...but what if they are not right? like i said...don't take any chances.

Re: What's Worst?

Kulbir Singh · 10 Oct 2003

Someone, so do you agree that to be on the safe side, you should accept keski as kakaar? I am just using your logic of Raagmala. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: What's Worst?

simran_sewa_sacrifice · 10 Oct 2003

WAHEGUROO JI KA KHALSA WAHEGUROO JI KI FATEH!! it is my request that everyone stop bringing this topic up. admins should just please refer such post to the article on raagmala. this is a good forum lets not have this a trash forum like most of the other ones. no one is learning anything with these kinds of post they are just causing more tension. so lets just end this here. WAHEGUROO JI KA KHALSA WAHEGUROO JI KI FATEH!!

Re: What's Worst?

Mkhalsa · 11 Oct 2003

>>>>>>>Gurbani premi....you should be careful when you use Gurbani . You are calling Raag Mala kachi bani...thats takes guts. What if it was Bani all along? You can't be 100% sure...everybody just follows what one person says...but what if they are not right? like i said...don't take any chances.<<<<<<< I know that someone may not agree with what I say, but I am 110% sure with all my heart and soul that raag mala is not bani. And I have no qualms over calling it kachi bani. Because thats what it is. -END- And I agree with simran_seva_sacrifice that I am tired of hearing Raag Mala Supporters and also Anti-Raag mala people screaming over the same thing again and again on 100 different boards for all of time. I think we should just stop it on this board, same as Waheguroo! Network forums and I think AKJ.org have done.

Re: What's Worst?

Gurbani premi · 11 Oct 2003

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh. A Suhagan (True-loving wife) recognizes voice of her Kantt (Husband).When her husband comes back home at night and says a single word; she recognize his voice and opens the door. She will not open the door to a fake person tring to enter the house by immitating her husband's voice. If she makes mistake here , that can ruin her life. She should be very careful ,when she finds a little doubt that there is something wrong.If she has a bibek-budh she can easily find out that he is her husband or a fake person. Now, Gurbani is the voice of our true husband Akaal Purkh. And raag maala has many many doubts in it. 1.Raag maala has nothing to do with Naam simran, ustat of Akaal-Purkh and his beloved bhagats and saints; It only tells how many wives and sons a raag has and what are there names.Why these names were so important to mention in Gurbani ,while Gurbani never mentions names of the wives and sons of our Great Guru Sahibans and of Great Bhagats. 2.Raag maala tells that a raag can have five wives; which is against the hukam of Satguru ji's that."EKA NAARI JATI HOE". 3.Raag maala failed to adopt the number system used in SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI. which increases like (1)..(2)...(3)...(4) and so on as the shabad progresses.But in raag maala its like (1)..(1)..(1)..and so on till end,which is invailed. 4.And there is something wrong with raag maala so that it was(and is) not allowded to read at SIRI AKAAL TAKHAT SAHIB,by Panth khalsa.Baba Jarnail singh Bhindranwale beated his own bhateeja(nephew) with laathian(long sticks),who tried to change that maryada.Baba ji said to him that who was he to change the faisla taken by whole Panth-maharaj.But I am affraid that now massands of SGPC and some others can change this maryada of SIRI AKAAL TAKHAT SAHIB because there is no other honoest jodha like Baba Jarnail Singh is there. 5.And hundreds of doubts araised by other gursikhs. And with the kirpa of Akaal Purkh Waheguru I have no doubt about raag maala.My bibek Satguru made me 100% sure that raag maala is not Gurbani. Satguru ji say that his sikh should never be in dubida(daubt).Because this dubida has ruined many lives.And any one who is in dubida can't do bhagti. And if some one is in dubida and want to get rid of it, I have some tips which helped me out. (a)Be Guru wale by giving your head to Satguru ji to take Naam Amrit. This is the same amrit for which Sur nar (Devte) are searching and searching.You are most lucky if you got it,you are better than a devta cos he is still searching it , and you have got it ! (b)Be careful about amrit wela, always get up near 2-3 am or more early. (c) Do keshi Ishnan every day. (d) Do Naam simran at least 1-2 hrs or more as much you can do,roaring aloud. (e)Do nitnem speaking and listening (f) Do sahaj paath every day. (g)Do Dharam di kirat never use katha and keertan to making money out of it. (h) Speak Truth (i) Be honost (j) Be bibeki And Naam simran is above all "NAAM BINA SABH KOOR GAALI HOSHHIAN' Very first Thing Guru Nanak Dev ji said after defination of Akaal Purkh on very first panna of Siri Guru Granth Sahib is ||JAPP||. When Satguru ji orders his sikh to "JAPP" a sikh should obey it instently and start japping. It is very unfortunate that we donot obey the hukam given by our satguru at very first panna,but reach to the last panna to arguing each other. Not good for me too. Bhul chuk muaf karna jio. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh.

Re: What's Worst?

Khalsa Soulja · 12 Oct 2003

yeh i think debate if you want but no one should slander the ragmalla just in case. just like i believe in the dasam granth except hakayat but i would never make fun of it just in case. btw where is this line from "EKA NAARI JATI HOE".? WJKK WJKF

Re: What's Worst?

nanak naam chardi kala · 12 Oct 2003

i am of damdami taksal background, but i believe in 'not taking any chances'. i am not that narrow minded to stick with only my taksal upbringing. i belive in reading rag mala because akal takhat has said we can or cant, why take a chance. i have been given hukum for kesh as a kakar, but i keep the keski on as a kakar, never leaving me, why take a chance. the key word in all this is 'devotion'. you can read rag mala, regardless of whether its truly bani, but love waheguru that much taht you only think of him when reading it, just like whatever we do we do it in wahrguru's name. same for keski, i think of it as a gift just as i treat everything guruji has blessed me with. 'rehti pyari muj ki' -- this is imporant to the guru, so why take a chance? 'bani guru guru hai bani' - why take a cahnce and disrespect bani? these are my two cents. we have to start thinking a little bit more out of our own jathas, and look at everything from an unbiased view. sure someone mite have relation with a specific jatha, but taht jatha is not your religion. sikhi is. im sorry if someone was offended by what i siad, i am sorry.

Re: What's Worst?

Akal Takht'er · 13 Oct 2003

If Akal Takht Said we don't have to read it what chance is there? even if it is bani (which its not), guru sahib CANT and WONT blame us. Akal Takht said we dont have to read it. Someone before us would take on the paap as we did nothing but follow akal takhts instruction.