The guilty must be punished
JS · 25 Aug 2005
Tribune Redeeming the promise The guilty must be punished Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s apology to the Sikhs and the nation on the 1984 riots has certainly assuaged the hurt feelings of the people. One reason why they found it acceptable was that the apology came with the promise that the government would do everything possible to bring to book those against whom the Nanavati Commission had pointed an accusing finger. As promised by him, the government has already appointed two committees, headed by two Home Ministry officials – Mr K.P. Singh and Mr D.K. Shankaran – to implement the assurances with regard to payment of compensation and other kinds of relief to the victims of the anti-Sikh riots. It is gratifying that these two committees, which have to complete their task within two months, have already started their work. The pace at which they have been addressing themselves to the given assignment, it should be possible for them to complete it within the stipulated period. However important rehabilitation of the victims may be, it cannot be a substitute for justice. As Justice Brennan of the US Supreme Court said, “Nothing rankles more in the human heart than a brooding sense of injustice”. Over 3,000 people were killed, mainly in the streets of Delhi but even after 21 years, not one has been punished for murder. Nine committees and commissions have gone into the whole question and there is now a large body of evidence in the form of affidavits, eyewitness accounts and newspaper reports against the perpetrators of violence. Yet, the tragedy is that every one of the guilty is leading a comfortable life while most of the victims are still deprived of the basic needs of life. This speaks volumes for the failure of the criminal justice system. The Nanavati Commission report provided the nation one last opportunity to undo the injustice done to the Sikh community in 1984. The report has many infirmities, the most notable being its failure to identify all those who masterminded some of the worst incidents of riot. Yet, it names some political leaders and police officers, whose complicity in the killings is an eternal shame for the country. The Prime Minister has given a solemn assurance that none of them will be spared. His apology will make sense only if his promise is redeemed and that, too, in a time-bound manner.