Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Guess what is SGPC's next move?

Guess what is SGPC's next move?

ManjitSingh · 24 Aug 2005

Undoubtedly: Change Gurbani to neutral where ever Guru Sahib Jee call themselves as woman and Akaal Purkh as Man because this is not fair to women and is discriminatory!!!!!! A simple question please: Are sikhs faminists?

Re: Guess what is SGPC's next move?

daas · 24 Aug 2005

No Manjit singh, Sikhs are not faminists - they do not promote FAMINES !! but if you meant FEMINISTS then that is a different issue Contrary to the ignorant views of some uneducated people, Feminism does not mean "Eistree Raaj" Matriarchy and Patriarchy both has flaws Feminism is a movement to bring equality to all people it is the same type of movement as "anti-racism" and "anti-prejudice" Feminism means "Aaee Panthee Sagal Jamaatee" Feminism means "Manas Jaath Sabhai Aykai Pehchanbo" Feminism means "Bura Bhalla Kaho Kis Nu Kaheai Saglay Jee Thumaaray"

Re: Guess what is SGPC's next move?

kabadi · 24 Aug 2005

no that is not wat feminism means... feminism is when females think they run things and try to take over the world...

Re: Guess what is SGPC's next move?

Hari Singh · 24 Aug 2005

I have heard the term used in so many different contexts that I'm not quite sure what it means? Perhaps a feminist on the message board can shed some light?

Re: Guess what is SGPC's next move?

ManjitSingh · 24 Aug 2005

Sorry for spelling mistake - thanks to my good angrezi. It is Feminist who promots Feminism which is "Equality based on the Gender".

Re: Guess what is SGPC's next move?

Sister · 24 Aug 2005

fem·i·nism ( P ) Pronunciation Key (fm-nzm) n. Belief in the social, political, and economic equality of the sexes. The movement organized around this belief. So Kabadi Ji it does not mean"when females think they run things and try to take over the world..." . Even though we might be better off if that were the case......we can all see the results of men running things very clearly.

Re: Guess what is SGPC's next move?

manjh payara guru ko · 24 Aug 2005

next step of sgpc should be about laridar saroop of sri guru ganth sahib ji.it is very important [%sig%]

Re: Guess what is SGPC's next move?

reply · 25 Aug 2005

>fem·i·nism ( P ) Pronunciation Key (fm-nzm) n. >Belief in the social, political, and economic equality of the sexes. >The movement organized around this belief. All this is is the definition given by the promoters. If this were the real-life meaning, why not call it egalitarianism? Feminists have taken the name of certain class of people (females), added "ism", and now they claim that the definition really means equality of all classes of people. Hilarious. Try to think thru these: brahimism: n. The belief in equality of the castes. blackism: n. The belief in equality of the races. Actually, feminism really means advocacy of female leadership/power/supremacy. Whether this woould be a good thing or not is debatable, but at least being honest about the real intentions could lead to a real and honest debate.

Re: Guess what is SGPC's next move?

reply · 25 Aug 2005

Feminism is encouraging women to think individually and selfishly instead of for family and society. What do you think the whole "concsciusness-raising" thing is about? It's to encourage (ie., brainwash) some women into thinking only about the interests of a certain class of people (women). Every issue is determined on the basis of "is it good for women"? This is a farce. Next we'll have "childism". Every issue will be determined on the basis of "is it good for kids"? School exam tomorrow? Is it good for kids? No -- have to study, we would rather play ball. Parents say you have to clean your room -- Is is good for kids? No. And is childism in accordance with Gurbani? What about Shabad Sarang M: 4 "Why son, are you arguing and fighting with your father? It's a sin to argue with the ones who raised you" If Gurbani isn't in favor of childism, do you think it might just be possible that it's not in favor of feminism, a product of 19th century western women and marxists? THe point on marxism is a good one to ponder -- Gurbani talks about equality and humanity of the poor, but does that mean Gurbani is marxist? That stretching it far out it's real meaning to impress your marxist friends (to be able to say Guru ji was marxist before Marx). In the same way, making Gurbani into a feminist manifesto is stretching/changing it to be able to say Guru ji was a feminist.

Re: Guess what is SGPC's next move?

kabadi · 25 Aug 2005

lol, i was just joking... im all for equality... but some people take it overboard... wanting equality isnt a feminist.. thats a SIKH.. feminists take it over boardddd, feminists arent cool, Sikhs are cool

Re: Guess what is SGPC's next move?

ManjitSingh · 26 Aug 2005

There is a limit to everything but the Notanki Baba is plainly shameless. Perhaps "Besharmy ka naam isne Mummy rakh lia".

Re: Guess what is SGPC's next move?

reply · 26 Aug 2005

Manjit Singh, What is "Notanki Baba"?

Re: Guess what is SGPC's next move?

Manjot Singh Khalsa · 26 Aug 2005

While I really like sisters post and am somewhat of a feminist myself in that I feel that much equality that is deserved is not given and that the violent tendencies of men have led to a lot of bloodshed in the past. Even guru sahib showed the need for the kindness and gentleness of women during hte first amrit sanchar (patashe). But on the other hand, think about this, the real feminist movement in the US didnt take off until birth control and contraceptives became safe for use by the masses. We learned this in high school. There is a clear correlation between what they call "sexual freedom" and feminism. In that once women didnt have to worry about pregnancy and could be as promiscuous as men, they began to demand the same rights as men. It is an interesting thing. On the other hand... Sikhi says that kaam is one of the worst evils on this earth and bases equality on the soul. Guru Sahib made us equal giving us equal souls and equal duties to the panth and to gurmat. But does that mean equal duties to the family and earning structure? I think it does, others think it doesnt. Sikhis equality is thus inherently higher than the so called equality of the western world. Think about this.. women in the west want to be "equal" but want to still be considered objects in a sexual sense and in fact promote this throughout the culture. Another way to look at it would be women in the west want to use their sexual promiscuity to control men. Theres a lot of anti gurmatness in feminism in the west. I think its very different from what gursikhs would consider feminism. Did I go off on a tangent?

Re: Guess what is SGPC's next move?

reply · 29 Aug 2005

ManjitSingh ji, Actually the move to change GurBani has already started. While the normal, everyday meaning of Malik, Prabhu and other synonyms of these words is Lord in English, a professor in New York has started translating these words as Sovereign because Lord offends feminist sensibilities. This was written about in the Sikh Review (of Calcutta). More information later.