Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 22 Aug 2005

[gurbani]dUDu ktorY gfvY pwnI ] kpl gwie nwmY duih AwnI ]1] dUDu pIau goibMdy rwie ] dUDu pIau, myro mnu pqIAwie ] nwhI q Gr ko bwpu irswie ]1] rhwau ] suoien ktorI AMimRq BrI ] lY nwmY hir AwgY DrI ]2] eyku Bgqu myry ihrdy bsY ] nwmy dyiK nrwienu hsY ]3] dUDu pIAwie Bgqu Gir gieAw ] nwmy hir kw drsnu BieAw ]4]3] {pMnw 1163}[/gurbani] This shabad has always been quoted by many derawallhs followers to prove that bahagt anmdev Ji is also a Idol worshipper just like Bhagat Dhanna Ji. They do "superficial" aarths of this shabad as "proof"... What do the readers think...???

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

**- · 22 Aug 2005

Jarnail Singh, Looking at the title of this post, it is glarringly obvious that you have already made up your mind. If anyone were to post the contrary I very much doubt that you will agree with them. Anyway if you go to Maharashtra and speak to the Vaishnavas who are in the parampara line of Bhagat Namdev, then it is obvious that he was a murti poojak (or pathar poojak as someone once called us). He use to worship a murti form of Krishna known as Vitthal Dev - this is contrary to what most Sikh historians write. They tend to view NamDev as an iconoclast etc which is in direct contrast to what his disciples and followers have written about him. To be brief, NamDev is very popular in Maharashtra and Gujarat and every non-Sikh (ergo Hindus) that follow him and his teachings are all Krishna bhaktas that worship idols of Krishna and his wife Rukhmani. I am sure that Kulbir Singh will try an proove me wrong that the NamDev whose baani is in the Siri Guru Granth Sahib was a different NamDev i.e. a chela of SatGur Nanak Dev Ji. Regards, Sitara [%sig%]

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Singh · 22 Aug 2005

There is another shabad by Bhagat NaamDev which I have heard in Kirtan but can not find the ang ref. Likewise it states how Namdev took milk to the idol, and even put a tilak on it. Does anyone know what ang this is on, as I need to read it before I can see what it means. I can't beleive any Bhagat in Guru Granth Sahib would worship idols, as Guru Ji in many places puts down idols. Hence it makes no sence adding praises of stones in Guru Granth Sahib when it contradicts Gurmat.

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Singh · 22 Aug 2005

Guru Sahib clearly says: That stone idol, for which you tear off those leaves - that stone idol is lifeless. ||1|| The sculptor carves the stone and fashions it into an idol, placing his feet upon its chest. If this stone god was true, it would devour the sculptor for this! ||3|| Rice and beans, candies, cakes and cookies - the priest enjoys these, while he puts ashes into the mouth of the idol. ||4|| Page 479Saint Kabir "You wash your stone gods and worship them. You offer saffron, sandalwood and flowers. Falling at their feet, you try so hard to appease them. Begging, begging from other people, you get things to wear and eat. For your blind deeds, you will be blindly punished. Your idol does not feed the hungry, or save the dying. The blind assembly argues in blindness. ||1|| Page 1241 Guru Nanak Dev The stone idols have drowned the world, and the Pandits, the religious scholars, have plundered it on the way. ||137|| Page 1371, Saint Kabir O fool! Fall at the feet of Lord-God, the Lord is not within the stone-idols.99. Dhasm Granth Guru Gobind SIngh I vanquished the vicious hill chiefs, they were idol-worshippers and I am idol-breaker.95. Dhasm Granth Guru Gobind SIngh Someone has tied the stone-idol around his neck and someone has accepted Shiva as the Lord; someone considers the Lord within the temple or the mosque; Someone calls him Ram or Krishna and someone believes in His incarnations, but my mind has forsaken all useless actions and has accepted only the One Creator.12. Dhasm Granth Guru Gobind SIngh Why do you worship stones ?, because the Lord-God is not within those stones; you may only worship Him, whose adoration destroys clusters of sins Dhasm Granth Guru Gobind SIngh The hollow religion became fruitless and O being ! you have lost crores of years by worshipping the stones; you will not get power with the worship of stones; the strength and glory will only decrease; In this way, the time was lost uselessly and nothing was achieved and you were not ashamed; O foolish intellect ! you have not remembered the Lord and have wasted your life in vain.21. Dhasm Granth Guru Gobind SIngh Hence do you really think Guru Ji would include the shabads of someone who worships stones in Guru Granth Sahib. It would be like saying in Guru Granth Sahib it's wrong to take drugs, than include a drug dealer and drug manual in your text. Obviously the Vaishnavas at Maharashtra would argue Bhagat Ji worshipped stones as they do, and knowing that its a futile excersise try and re-assure themselves. I doubt they even understand Bhagat NamDev who is on a higher level to any stone worhipper and have fooled themselves into thinking he was on their level. I wonder what the Vaishnavas would say to the shabads in Guru Granth Sahib when Bhagat Ji uses Islamic Refs /for/to God? Naam Dayv`s Lord and Master, the Inner-knower, the Searcher of hearts, wanders everywhere; He has no specific home. ||4||1|| Page 1167

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 22 Aug 2005

dear sitara ji, It doesnt make any difference IF "MY MIND" is made up..but this is a forum for all to post and the readers to make up "THEIR MINDS". 1. I dont doubt that Bhagat namdev could have been a moortee poojak at some point of his early life ( as you asserted)..BUT the GURBANI of a Moortee poojak would NEVER get place in Guru Granth JI. (similarly there is ample proof that Both Bhai lehana ji and Bhai Amardass Ji were DEVI poojaks and pakkeh hindus BEFORE they became SIKHS...and GURU...but then whatever GURBANI they wrote as GURUS is in the GURU GRANTH JI and there is not a single panktee by Guru Angad Ji that "promotes" pooja of devi. So this same logic can apply to namdev Ji as well for the record we are only interested in the NAMDEV of GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB...and not the one being "poojaaed" in maharashtra. Sikhs BOW to the Namdev in GURU GRANTH JI ONLY) 2. It is a well accepted fact that any one who is a KRISHAN JI follower WILL NEVER be a FOLLOWER of Sri Raam Chander Ji. Similarly a follower of Ram Chader Ji will never ever follow sri Krishan Ji. The two sets of followers are self excluisonary. BUT several examples from Bhagat namdev Ji's Bani will show that He refers to HIS ISHT by Both Raam as well as KRISHAN names and words...example...BEETHAL in Bhagat ji's Bani is also called Mere Rammiyeah.... ( beethal is the word used by krishan followers for his moortee ) How can a Krishan Follower address his moortee Beethal as Mere ramiyaah ?? contradictory isnt it ? What do you think ? ( I live next door to the World famous Batu caves Hindu mandir where there is a huge statue of a diety called SUBRAMANIAM ( tamil name for Shiva)...all call this diety Subramaniam and sometimes Shiva....never Sri raam or Sri krishan....but the Diety in the Sri raam Mandir ( also in front of the local Selayang Gurdwara) is always addressed as sri raam Ji..never as SUBRAMANIAM/SHIVA Ji etc ) How could Bhaagt namdev ji interchange these ??? For the RECORD my view as per GURMATT is that the Words used by Bhagat Namdev Ji in his bani all MEAN WAHEGURU ONLY..although the vocabulary is Hindu in origin. REF" Singh Ji, This is the same shabad that you refer to. It is on Aang 1163 I look forward to a constructive discussion on these two points before we go further.

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

ksingh · 22 Aug 2005

wjkk wjkf sitara ji just read the two shabads i am quoting goNf ] (874-13) gond. Gond: BYrau BUq sIqlw DwvY ] (874-13, goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) bhairo bhoot seetlaa Dhaavai. One who chases after the god Bhairau, evil spirits and the goddess of smallpox, Kr bwhnu auhu Cwru aufwvY ]1] (874-13, goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) khar baahan uho chhaar udaavai. ||1|| is riding on a donkey, kicking up the dust. ||1|| hau qau eyku rmeIAw lYhau ] (874-13, goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) ha-o ta-o ayk rama-ee-aa laiha-o. I take only the Name of the One Lord. Awn dyv bdlwvin dYhau ]1] rhwau ] (874-14, goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) aan dayv badlaavan daiha-o. ||1|| rahaa-o. I have given away all other gods in exchange for Him. ||1||Pause|| isv isv krqy jo nru iDAwvY ] (874-14, goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) siv siv kartay jo nar Dhi-aavai. That man who chants "Shiva, Shiva", and meditates on him, brd cFy faurU FmkwvY ]2] (874-14, goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) barad chadhay da-uroo dhamkaavai. ||2|| is riding on a bull, shaking a tambourine. ||2|| mhw mweI kI pUjw krY ] (874-15, goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) mahaa maa-ee kee poojaa karai. One who worships the Great Goddess Maya nr sY nwir hoie AauqrY ]3] (874-15, goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) nar sai naar ho-ay a-utarai. ||3|| will be reincarnated as a woman, and not a man. ||3|| qU khIAq hI Awid BvwnI ] (874-15, goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) too kahee-at hee aad bhavaanee. You are called the Primal Goddess. mukiq kI brIAw khw CpwnI ]4] (874-16, goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) mukat kee baree-aa kahaa chhapaanee. ||4|| At the time of liberation, where will you hide then? ||4|| gurmiq rwm nwm ghu mIqw ] (874-16, goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) gurmat raam naam gahu meetaa. Follow the Guru's Teachings, and hold tight to the Lord's Name, O friend. pRxvY nwmw ieau khY gIqw ]5]2]6] (874-17, goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) paranvai naamaa i-o kahai geetaa. ||5||2||6|| Thus prays Naam Dayv, and so says the Gita as well. ||5||2||6|| iblwvlu goNf ] (874-17) bilaaval gond. Bilaaval Gond: Awju nwmy bITlu dyiKAw mUrK ko smJwaU ry ] rhwau ] (874-17, iblwvlu goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) aaj naamay beethal daykhi-aa moorakh ko samjhaa-oo ray. rahaa-o. Today, Naam Dayv saw the Lord, and so I will instruct the ignorant. ||Pause|| pWfy qumrI gwieqRI loDy kw Kyqu KwqI QI ] (874-18, iblwvlu goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) paaNday tumree gaa-itaree loDhay kaa khayt khaatee thee. O Pandit, O religious scholar, your Gayatri was grazing in the fields. lY kir Tygw tgrI qorI lWgq lWgq jwqI QI ]1] (874-18, iblwvlu goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) lai kar thaygaa tagree toree laaNgat laaNgat jaatee thee. ||1|| Taking a stick, the farmer broke its leg, and now it walks with a limp. ||1|| pWfy qumrw mhwdyau Dauly bld ciVAw Awvqu dyiKAw Qw ] (874-19, iblwvlu goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) paaNday tumraa mahaaday-o Dha-ulay balad charhi-aa aavat daykhi-aa thaa. O Pandit, I saw your great god Shiva, riding along on a white bull. modI ky Gr Kwxw pwkw vw kw lVkw mwirAw Qw ]2] (874-19, iblwvlu goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) modee kay ghar khaanaa paakaa vaa kaa larhkaa maari-aa thaa. ||2|| In the merchant's house, a banquet was prepared for him - he killed the merchant's son. ||2|| Wfy qumrw rwmcMdu so BI Awvqu dyiKAw Qw ] (875-1, iblwvlu goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) paaNday tumraa raamchand so bhee aavat daykhi-aa thaa. O Pandit, I saw your Raam Chand coming too rwvn syqI srbr hoeI Gr kI joie gvweI QI ]3] (875-1, iblwvlu goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) raavan saytee sarbar ho-ee ghar kee jo-ay gavaa-ee thee. ||3|| ; he lost his wife, fighting a war against Raawan. ||3|| ihMdU AMn@w qurkU kwxw ] (875-2, iblwvlu goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) hindoo anHaa turkoo kaanaa. The Hindu is sightless; the Muslim has only one eye. duhW qy igAwnI isAwxw ] (875-2, iblwvlu goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) duhaaN tay gi-aanee si-aanaa. The spiritual teacher is wiser than both of them. ihMdU pUjY dyhurw muslmwxu msIiq ] (875-3, iblwvlu goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) hindoo poojai dayhuraa musalmaan maseet. The Hindu worships at the temple, the Muslim at the mosque. nwmy soeI syivAw jh dyhurw n msIiq ]4]3]7] (875-3, iblwvlu goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) naamay so-ee sayvi-aa jah dayhuraa na maseet. ||4||3||7|| Naam Dayv serves that Lord, who is not limited to either the temple or the mosque. ||4||3||7|| these shabads clearly states that bhagat namdev was not idol worshipper. also many times i see hindus complainting about anti hindu remarks in guru granth sahib.these remarks are also written by hindu saint namdev and not by our gurus. bhul chuk maaf

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

**- · 22 Aug 2005

Singh, Thanks for your detailed post. I am well aware of the derogatory comments that the Guru Sahibaan make about murti pooja, there is no need to reproduce reems of these quotes. It is good to see that your religion teaches you to regard Hindus as fools. ----- Hence do you really think Guru Ji would include the shabads of someone who worships stones in Guru Granth Sahib. It would be like saying in Guru Granth Sahib it's wrong to take drugs, than include a drug dealer and drug manual in your text. Obviously the Vaishnavas at Maharashtra would argue Bhagat Ji worshipped stones as they do, and knowing that its a futile excersise try and re-assure themselves. I doubt they even understand Bhagat NamDev who is on a higher level to any stone worhipper and have fooled themselves into thinking he was on their level. I wonder what the Vaishnavas would say to the shabads in Guru Granth Sahib when Bhagat Ji uses Islamic Refs /for/to God? ------ I don't know but I think that it shows the magnanimity of Guru Saahib who is willing to include baanis of idol worshippers even though he doesn't agree 100% with their views, philosophy and customs. There are other idol worshippers whose baani is included in the SGGS e.g. Jaidev and Dhanna Jat. Anyway I don't really think Vaishnavas in Mahrashtra really care what Sikhi thinks or says about NamDeyv or anything else for that matter so your point of them arguing that he was an idol worshipper is a non-issue. They are very likely take a similar view of what Sikhs take when the RSS try and depict the Guru Sahibaan as being Hindus who prayed to Hindoo Devi/Devtas.

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

**- · 22 Aug 2005

Dear Jarnail Singh ji, I don't want to offend anybody here, but based on my Yatras to Pardhanpur in Maharashtra, I don't think that the baanis in SGGS are the from NamDevy of Maharashtra. They are probably from some other NamDeyv. The main reason being: these baanis are not in Maharathi. If I want to learn about the Maharashtran NamDeyv's teachings, I would look at his 'Abhangs' which he wrote rather than the SGGS. They are in Maharathi. They contain references to Krishna and Rama (this partially answers your second point) and the idol of Vitthal Dev. If NamDeyv did realise he was following the wrong path would it not seem logical that he would re-write his Abhangs so that the other idol worshipping Hindus would know they are going down the wrong path? Regarding your second point, I beg to differ. Chaitanya Mahaprabhu was a staunch Vaishnava (in fact he was the Guru of NamDeyv's Guru) and the mantra he used to chant contained the words Rama and Krishna (e.g. Hare Krishna, Hare Rama). So I do not think that this holds any water.

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

I have Anbhavi Avastha · 22 Aug 2005

Guru sahib teaches that whatever we do is a waste unless we have naam. He doesn't just say this to hindus, but to ALL those who do not have naam. Naam is the reason we are here. If we do not have have naam and do not do simran then WE ARE FOOLS. Guru sahib has showed the light and it is up to us if we want to follow it or not. If we do not, then we are indeed fools. waheguru

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Lionking · 22 Aug 2005

Sitara ji, you never responded to the above posts with quotes where Bhagat Namdev ji says - ___________________________________ hau qau eyku rmeIAw lYhau ] (874-13, goNf, Bgq nwmdyv jI) ha-o ta-o ayk rama-ee-aa laiha-o. I take only the Name of the One Lord. ___________________________________ Also you mention about Bhagat Dhanna ji, and Bhagat Jaidev ji - Gyani Jarnail Singh ji has already responded to that - ___________________________________ similarly there is ample proof that Both Bhai lehana ji and Bhai Amardass Ji were DEVI poojaks and pakkeh hindus BEFORE they became SIKHS...and GURU...but then whatever GURBANI they wrote as GURUS is in the GURU GRANTH JI and there is not a single panktee by Guru Angad Ji that "promotes" pooja of devi. So this same logic can apply to namdev Ji as well for the record we are only interested in the NAMDEV of GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB...and not the one being "poojaaed" in maharashtra. Sikhs BOW to the Namdev in GURU GRANTH JI ONLY) ___________________________________ As mentioned, even if the above mentioend used to do moorti pooja BEFORE, the only bani included is the bani which was composed after they achieved Brahmgyan - one with formless God state.... hence why their other compositions such as the whole Abhang Gatha og BHagat Namdev ji is nto in Guru Granth Sahub ji, but only a small amount - The Bani composed after realising God. As for Bhagat Dhanan ji, there are loads of quote about Bhagat ji, that eh achieved God through innocent LOVE AND DEVOTION and NOT throught Moorti Pooja... _________________________________ I am well aware of the derogatory comments that the Guru Sahibaan make about murti pooja, there is no need to reproduce reems of these quotes. It is good to see that your religion teaches you to regard Hindus as fools. _________________________________ You yourself decide when to call the comments of the Guru Sahibaan and you yourself choose when to Call Bhagat Namdev ji a Moorti poojac. You have sen the quotes where Bhagat Namdev ji condems Moorti Pooja, and thus it was not only the Gurus who did it, but also HINDUS who had achieved the formless... But at the same time Guru Tegh Bahadhur SAhib ji showed the world the ultimate Shaheedi - givign life for something you DON'T agree with!!!

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

me · 22 Aug 2005

Sitara ji Dhan Dhan 5th Nanak Sahib Siri Guru Arjan Dev Sahib Ji would never have included any bani from any person if they were at odds with Guru Sahibs own teachings. Please try something else this line you have taken holds no water.

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

RoopKaur · 22 Aug 2005

The story of Bhagat Naamdev Ji is an alaankaar used in bani, it does not mean that Bhagat Naandev Ji was an idol worshipper during when he wrote bani, althoug he could have been one before. I agree with Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji's post.

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

**- · 22 Aug 2005

I posted a response to Jarnail Singh's post but the Admin never put it up. I am wondering if the Admin are sincerely interested in an honest debate occuring! My main point was that NaamDayv's (Maharashtra wale) baani in the SGGS is not in Maharathi (his native tongue) so it is probably another NaamDayv. If I was sincere about learning about Bhagat NaamDayv's (Maharashtra wale) teachings I would go straight to the source - i.e. his Abhangs NOT the SGGS. It is a well known fact that his Abahngs contain supplications to the Vitthal Dev Murti of Krishna in the Pardhanpur Mandir. If NaamDeyv realised he erred previously by worshipping murtis then would it not seem logical that he would destroy/reject his Abhangs and re-write them in Maharathi so that they are consistent with Gurmat? But there is no history of him doing this. Jaydev was a Murti poojak - this is a well known fact all around India (read his Gita Govinda and DasAvatara Stothram). He was one of the main individuals responsible for popularising Radha-Krishna murti pooja in and around India. Regarding point #2 raised by Jarnail Singh - I strongly beg to differ. Right now I am reading a book about Sripad MadhavaAcahrya (who was a Krishna Bhakta). His poetic works mention both Siri RaamChander, Krishna, Pashuraam, NarSingh Avtaar etc etc in the same mantras. Even staunch Krishna bhaktas like Chaytanya Mahaprabhu chants Rama and Krishna in the same mantra (e.g. Hare Krishna, Hare Rama) .

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

ksingh · 22 Aug 2005

wjkk wjkf sitara ji our religion does not regards hindus as fools.please tell me their are thousands of diffrent practices in hinduism.many of them are contradictory to each other.every pandit in india says that my practice is right other pandit,s practice is wrong.does it mean that he is regarding other pandit as fool also please tell me about the famous hindu quote " dhol shudra pashu gawar aur nari sab hain taran kai adhikari" drum, lower caste ,animals, illitrates and women are for beating does it mean that your religion is saying to beat women and lowercaste. bhul chuk maaf

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

**- · 23 Aug 2005

K Singh Ji, I think we are going off the topic. To be honest with you I have never come accross this quote. Anyway our religion does not say to beat women and lower castes (as far as I am aware).

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Singh · 23 Aug 2005

Dear Sitara, Wow you have posted really quickly, anyway I hope I can now respond to your comments. Firstly with regards to “I posted a response to Jarnail Singh's post but the Admin never put it up. I am wondering if the Admin are sincerely interested in an honest debate occuring!” I KNOW THE FEELING. I would request the admin to allow ALL posts which do not insult anyone etc for the sake of honest debate. It's horrible when the admin don't allow posts although they do not contradict the statment on the top of this site. “I don't know but I think that it shows the magnanimity of Guru Saahib who is willing to include baanis of idol worshippers even though he doesn't agree 100% with their views, philosophy and customs.” As I stated in my previous post which I would refer you back to it is crystal clear that Gurmat forbids the worship of stones. Hence not only is it a contradiction to include works which belong to idol worshippers in Guru Granth Sahib Ji it is exceptionally unbelievable. It would be like the Quran having a recipe for Pork Chops. Further to the above the idea of Guru Ji incorporating Bani’s from and for idol worshipping which Guru Ji preaches against in Guru Granth Sahib Ji also doesn’t hold as we know that Guru Arjan Ji specifically refused to include Bani’s of Saints which did not go along with Gurmat. A very famous Sakhi being of two renowned Saints who approached the Guru with their Bani’s for inclusion. However one was derogatory to woman, whilst the other was derogatory to people of lower castes, and hence Guru Ji rejected both. Therefore it is almost laughable to suggest that Guru Ji would happily include bani’s by and for idol worshipping it clearly contradict his basic teachings. As per Bhagat NamDev being an idol worshiper in the first instance this contradicts his very own words in Guru Granth Sahib as already shown previously: Naam Dayv's Lord and Master, the Inner-knower, the Searcher of hearts, wanders everywhere; He has no specific home. ||4||1|| . Page1167 Saint Nam Dev My God is All-pervading everywhere. ||1||Pause|| . Page1350 Saint Nam Dev Hence unless one has a very over active imagination we all know that an idol is not all pervading but is in a single place, exactly like the brick that has been sitting in my garden for the last few years (its only there and can not move as per common sence). “I don't want to offend anybody here, but based on my Yatras to Pardhanpur in Maharashtra, I don't think that the baanis in SGGS are the from NamDevy of Maharashtra. They are probably from some other NamDeyv. The main reason being: these baanis are not in Maharathi.” In-fact NaamDevs baani as well as other Bhagats included in Guru Granth Sahib are in the regional language/dialect of the specific Bhagat. The only change made is to the ”Lippi” ie Gurmukhi words used for the language in question. This is also the same when Guru Nanak and other Guru’s have written in other languages ie the language and dialect is whatever ie Farsi etc however the letters are all recorded in Gurmukhi. Nevertheless, if you are happy to think that it is another NamDev than fine. Bhagat NamDev also calls God by names like Allha (Islamic Refs to God). Hence this further shows how he was not a worshiper of idols as I have never heard of an idol being called Allha. It appears that the only point implying that Bhagat NamDev was an idol worshipper are other idol worshippers ie Vaishnavas in Mahrashtra. I personally would not put much faith in what they say about Bhagat Ji, as they themselves are idol worshippers and hence would not admit the great Bhagat NamDev didn’t do what they deem to be vital. If they were to say he didn’t not only would they themselves look silly and loose they social standing, but the concept of idol worship would loose even more favour and hence they would loose out financially with fewer pilgrims to “leach off” as has been done for centuries, Ref Bhagat Kabir Ji’s description in my previous post. “There are other idol worshippers whose baani is included in the SGGS e.g. Jaidev and Dhanna Jat.” Rather than having to repeat myself, the same concept applies to these and all other Bhagats Bani’s ie Guru Ji would not include Bani’s in Guru Granth Sahib Ji which contradict his own teachings out of common sence. Not wanting to go too in-depth but with regards to Bhagat Dhanna I suggest you read his famous sakhi concerning the stone which I assume you are referring to in Bhai Gurdas Ji’s var, ie Gurmat perspective. If so you would find that Bhagat Ji was no worshipper of idols but a true and sincere Bhagat who was given a stone by an arrogant Bhamin – “The brahman rolled a stone, gave it to Dhanna and thus got rid of him.”. However his true love made him into a Bhagat not the worshiper of Idols as Bhai Gurdas further states “In fact, innocence like that of Dhanna makes the sight of the Lord available.” Bhagat Ji’s own Bani makes no references to worshipping idols. With regard to Bhagat JaiDev likewise his bani in Guru Granth Sahib makes do references to idol worship, and actually shows he does not worship idols: “I worship the One who is worthy of being worshipped. I trust the One who is worthy of being trusted. Like water merging in water, I merge in the Lord.” Page1106 I think that people can claim many things about Bhagats etc. Muslims may claim Kabir, Sheik Farid and possibly even NamDev were hardcore Muslims etc. However the common sense and logical fact is that no one let alone the Guru would include bani’s of authors in Guru Granth Sahib Ji which specifically contradict and oppose the most basic tenants of Sikhism.

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Balbir Singh · 23 Aug 2005

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Sitara JI! All Moortee-Poojak (Idol Worshipers) do not wish to stick with a sculpture on the way to God. Nor any Shaastra (Scripture) restricts the Supreme in a carved piece of stone. Still, many worshipers hang on one or the other symbols. Paramatma is beyond as well as within all symbols. His complete experience is only possible by transcending these symbols. Transcending does not mean, as many may think, discarding one and capturing another state. Transcending is realizing Truth in, within and around. The growth at conscious level of mind is the awareness of the earlier state and the developed state of mind simultaneously. Our Gurus suggested Moortee-Poojaks to transcend the values and realize GOD by NAAM Simran. HE is without any shape or form too. HE is Nirankaar also. This is possible when a person comes to one name. ONE NAAM brings the person to THE intent. Dhannaa Jat is the example of it. Naamdev Ji, as I understood Gurbani, after receiving the state of ONE NAAM recognized all Devas converted into GOD. Gurbani says "ha-o ta-o ayk rama-ee-aa laiha-o." SGGS Ang 874-14 Ego! You received ONE Rama-ee-aa. "aan dayv badlaavan daiha-o." That resulted in conversion of Devas. The Naamdev, mentioned in Gurbani, is who transcended and recognized the true values of all symbols and rituals like those of the moortees, ritual of Gayatri or symbol of Shiva riding on a Balad. The Naamdev who is worshiped by many, as you mentioned, may not be the same. I feel Naamdev Ji has merged in God long back through true Simran. Many people may still be hanging on symbols and imitating Naamdev Ji. Balbir Singh [%sig%]

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

manjh payara guru ko · 23 Aug 2005

sita.......ra you said namdev ji not that namdev ji whos bani in dhan dhan sri guru granth sahib ji.so ican proof this ajuday(ram janm bhoomi)is not belongs to ram.we never said that ramayn wrot by other balmeeki this is not a good debate [%sig%]

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Singh · 23 Aug 2005

Balbir Singh I checked up the refs you provided and can not find them on ang 874. Is that correct???

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Singh · 23 Aug 2005

manjh payara guru ko - I can't even understand what you are saying

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

**- · 23 Aug 2005

Dear All, There are too many people coming at me from different angles and so as a result I cannot answer everyone’s questions [what can I do, I am a male – I can only do one thing at a time :-)]. Here is my stand on the issue: Bhagat NamDev’s sampradraya is still in existence today. If you go to Pardhanpur in Maharashtra you will see them there and they are all idol worshippers. This is not because they have some agenda (as some people on here may think) but because they feel that they are genuinely following the teachings of NamDev based on his Abhangs - which were written by him in Maharathi (his native tongue). Can the quotes in the SGGS be directly related back to any of his writings (i.e. the Abhangs). If so could somebody provide references. NamDev had disciples who were also murti-poojaks and this has continued up to now. If NamDev was against murti pooja, then why was he and his followers made, from the time of his death up to now, one of the main custodians of the Vitthal-Dev mandir in Pardhanpur? This not some bippar consiperacy! If we are to discount everything his followers in Maharashtra have to say then I think this is extremely foolish and unintelligent. This is what followers of Ashoutosh do to GurSikhs when they speak about the Guru Sahibaan. If he was an idol worshipper I think the Gurus best know the reason why his baani is in the SGGS. I just simply speculated just like everybody else here has done. No one has given me solid proof that NamDev, JaiDev or Dhanna Jat detested murti pooja. The quotes ‘Singh’ provided do not really prove that they were against idol worship. Similar quotes can be found in the works of idol worshipping acharayas such as Narada Muni [Narada-Bhakit Stotram] who has been credited by the SGGS of initiating murti pooja. Also the works of Ramnujacharaya, Kula-Shekara and Yamunacharaya describe God in a similar way. I do agree however that Bhagat Kabir and the Guru Sahibaan detested murti pooja – so there is no issue here. Anyway whether we agree he was an idol worshipper or not at least we can agree that he was a very great and spiritually elevated soul. God bless, Sitara [%sig%]

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Lionking · 23 Aug 2005

Can the quotes in the SGGS be directly related back to any of his writings (i.e. the Abhangs). If so could somebody provide references _______________________________ Dear Sitara, here are some Shabads composed by Bhai Gurdas ji, the first and most well-known and aknowledged scholars of the SIkh faith (actually I have no words of how to explain who BHai Sahib ji was). Bhai Gurdas Ji's Vaars/compositions were given the status of being the "key" of Guru Granth Sahib ji (perhaps of a better understanding) by the fifth Guru, Guru Arjan Dev ji. Please read the following Shabads - http://searchgurbani.com/main.php?book=bhai_gurdas_vaaran&action=pauripage&vaar=10&pauri=11 http://searchgurbani.com/main.php?book=bhai_gurdas_vaaran&action=pauripage&vaar=10&pauri=12 In the first Shabad there's clear mention of the moortipuja of washing the Thakur, and later of realising the true Lord/God with his innocent love. Regards

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Balbir Singh · 23 Aug 2005

Satsriakal to all and Sitara Ji! Naaraayan has infinite Roops. Naaraayan has not become limited because someone has carved a sculpture. Also, Nirvaana is not being stuck up with a sculpture. Nirvana is getting freed from all limitations. The Nirguna Parmeshwar is realized by transcending His Sarguna values. This becomes easy with ONE Naam of Hari. All sculptures or Hari's imaginations predetermined do not accompany anyone there. Once Naaraayan's both, Nirguna and Sarguna, Swaroops are realized, His infinite Swaroop becomes visible. Naamdev Ji received Nirvaana by ONE Hari's Naam. Here is a wonderful Shabad of Naamdev Ji from Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. mithi-aa jihbaa avrayN kaam. Pseudo tongue has strange activities. nirbaan pad ik har ko naam. Nirvaana state is one Hari's name. asaNkh kot an poojaa karee. Innumerable millions of different poojaas are performed. ayk na poojas naamai haree. One did not worship the name of Hari. paranvai naamday-o ih karnaa. Pranav does this to Naamdev anant roop tayray naaraa-inaa. SGGS Ang 1163-14 Infinite Roops are yours, Naaraayan. Pranav is Simran of God's name along with each breath. Pranav is not a sculpture. -------------- Here is another reference of Naamdev Ji's Shabad from Gurbani. naamday-ay simran kar jaanaaN. SGGS Ang 858 Naamdev came to know by doing Simran. It would be interesting to know if there is a protocol available which documented a Shabad from Naamdev Ji in maraathee language that He reached Nirvaana by collecting sculptures alone. -------------- All sculptures are in the outer world. Hari dwells within. Hari is found within. Naamdev Ji is singing. paachhai bahur na aavan paava-o. Afterwards there is on repetition to come. amrit banee ghat tay uchara-o aatam ka-o samjhaava-o. SGGS Ang 693-5 Amrit Baanee is spoken from heart, explains to the soul. In the same Shabad Naamdev Ji sings further. it kar bhagati karahi jo jan tin bha-o sagal chukhaa-ee-ai. The person who does Bhagatee like this, his all Bha-o is overcome. kahat naamday-o baahar ki-aa bharmahu ih sanjam har paa-ee-ai. SGGS Ang 693-9 Naamdev says why wander outside, with this Sanjam Hari is received. The crowd always follows what they receive from senses. The crowd may never follow (understand) the growth of conscious mind of the Guru, provided they receive Simran. History shows that followers never became enlightened. This is why our Gurus suggested Sikhs to be with Shabad or Naam and not with any outer symbols like a sculpture. I pray that all become enlightened and say Satsriakal. Love. Balbir Singh [%sig%]

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Singh · 24 Aug 2005

Sitara - I hope I can try and answer your questions. “Can the quotes in the SGGS be directly related back to any of his writings (i.e. the Abhangs). If so could somebody provide references.” You will find that non of the Bhagat’s Bani’s recorded in Guru Granth Sahib Ji have the same writings in their own texts. In-fact in some parts the Bhagata are directly communicating with the Guru. “If NamDev was against murti pooja, then why was he and his followers made, from the time of his death up to now, one of the main custodians of the Vitthal-Dev mandir in Pardhanpur?” I think the above is very obvious. The Guru’s were against caste, however 99% of Sikh’s believe in caste. Likewise the Guru’s were against Murti Poojar however 99% of Sikhs pooj pictures of the Guru. Hence what followers do unfortunately do not reflect the teachings of the prophets, especially in the case of Bhagats were most things are past down by oral traditions/stories and the following is not a formal organised religion. “I just simply speculated just like everybody else here has done. No one has given me solid proof that NamDev, JaiDev or Dhanna Jat detested murti pooja.” It’s not a matter of detesting murti pooja, just that they didn’t follow it. Most of the Guru’s never wrote about murti pooja, hence just because they didn’t specifically mention it this can not be taken as meaning they believed or supported it. The proof you need as communicated earlier is that if they were murti poojaks they would not have been included in Guru Granth Sahib out of common sense, and as we know Guru Ji rejected other Saints who wrote not on the same lines as Gurmat. Likewise their bani’s (in Guru Granth Sahib) do not make reference to murti pooja as a way of spirituality, but naam. Using your outlook you would expect every Bhagat and Guru etc mentioned in Sikhi to write a line condemning idol worship. “The quotes ‘Singh’ provided do not really prove that they were against idol worship. Similar quotes can be found in the works of idol worshipping acharayas such as Narada Muni [Narada-Bhakit Stotram] who has been credited by the SGGS of initiating murti pooja.” The quotes clearly show who the Bhagats in question worshipped ie the all pervading God and not an idol which is anything but all pervading. If Narada or others who believe in worshipping stone idols contradict themselves as mentioned earlier this is no big surprise, as there are thousands of different practices in Hinduism, many of which contradict each other. However the Bhagats Bani in Guru Granth Sahib make it clear that they worship the one all pervading God, and hence not an idol which is only in one place. People like Narad would naturally contradict themselves (if they consider God to be a stone) however the Bhagats in Guru Granth Sahib were on a different level (which is why they were included) and hence when they say that they worship one all pervading God its quite obvious what they mean. Going off the topic for a mo, it’s also important to note that the Guru Granth Sahib is not a text which reflects the views of different authors, but provides Gurmat as the Guru. Hence when the Guru Granth Sahib gives a view ie do not worship idols this is the message/teachings. Therefore you will not find bani’s regardless of the author in Guru Granth Sahib which contradict this message. Its also clear that Guru Ji knew in advance that people would mistake the bani’s of Bhagats as being something else which is why in the beginning of every section of the Bhagats Bani Guru Ji clearly writes the Mool Mantra (Basic Concept of God). Hence when reading Gurbani we are reminded again and again what is being referred to as God, and specifically this is done before the Bhagats Bani. Hence the concept of God does not change through Gurbani (from one author to the other) but remains consistent through out. As we all know the Mool Mantra concept of God throws out the idea of God being an idol.

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

**- · 24 Aug 2005

Singh, You still haven't proved that the Bhagats I have mentioned didn't follow idol worship rather you have only inferred that they didn't perform murti pooja - based on point of view. It is evident from your and many other posts made by Sikhs on this board that you/they do not have much of a grasp of Hindu philosophy particularly with regards to murti-pooja (I am not having a dig at you, it is not your fault). Just because Hindus perform idol worship it doesn't mean that they believe that God is not all pervading. We believe that God is all pervading and therefore he/she is also in the idol as well - the emphasis being that God in the murti is in his/her most accessible form. A crude anology of this is as follows: moisture/water is everywhere but its most accessible form can be found in the well/river/pond etc. This is how we view murti pooja in the context of an all-pervading God. Anyway I am basing my stand that these Bhagats (excluding Kabir) were indeed kattar murti-poojaks based on their own personal writings, the biographies that have been written about them and the teachings that they have passed down to their disciples. We (Hindus) do not necessarily have an agenda about everything – as you have implied previously. There have been many venerated bhagats and acharayas (past and present) who did not believe in Murti pooja, examples include Dayanand Saraswati, GaribDas, Prakashanand Swami and even the four mind-born sons of Lord Brahma (the four Kumaras) didn’t use to believe in Sargun Brahman and we accept that. I don’t know why you have such a low opinion of us (well I do, but not to this extent). Singh, if you ever go to India, please go and visit the Pandharpur Vitthal-DevJi Mandir in Mahrashtra. There is gate outside the mandir called NamDev gate. It is right near his Samadh (tomb) – which is under the steps of the Mandir. He requested that his Samadh be there, why would he do this if he didn’t follow idol worship? Just think about it, not everything is a Brahmin/bippar conspiracy. You will also notice that he and the rest of his disciplic succession have had very prominent and high profile roles in the running of this idol-worshipping mandir. As to why his baani along with baani’s of other idol worshippers such as Ramanand Swami, JaiDev, Dhanna, and Pippa, is included in the SGGS is not something I feel I am qualified to answer. Baani of Muslim saints are included as well – presumably they probably did Namaz (facing Makkah) and believed in the divinity of the black stone (Sangay-Aswaad) in the Ka’bah. [%sig%]

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Balbir Singh · 24 Aug 2005

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Sitara Ji! You know Naamdev Ji as Idol worshiper. I recognize Naamdev Ji transcending Idols. You value and stick to Hindu philosophy. Gurbani says Truth is neither Hindu nor a philosophy. In my view, this post from you is full of contradictions. You wrote "We believe that God is all pervading and therefore he/she is also in the idol as well - the emphasis being that God in the murti is in his/her most accessible form." The first thing is that all pervading God is not he or she. There is no gender. All pervading God is in the Idol as well. Great! One has recognized this truth. Has this person found God the same and equal everywhere or he still is seeing God in a murti most accessible? Is this person yet aware of differentiations? You tried to explain further ". . . moisture/water is everywhere but its most accessible form can be found in the well/river/pond etc. This is how we view murti pooja in the context of an all-pervading God." Enlightened ones have found God as Sarguna and Nirguna together as complete. Others are always busy differentiating HIS Sarguna qualities. God is water and the rest of the whole cosmos too. Ponder over it. Why God is not reached by examples like one you have given? Then you wrote "This is how we view murti pooja in the context of an all-pervading God." I do not know about millions of others. But I wish you all-pervading God by viewing murti pooja, with a request. Come to Hari Naam when you feel it is getting too late. -------------- Have you ever read Kabir Ji's dohay where he clearly mentions that God is not found by doing pooja of a stone (patthar)? Can you please give references showing Kabir Ji as murti worshiper? -------------- I wish to brief my post here. A person born in this world knows Sarguna God only in parts. God's ONENESS is recognized in HIS completeness. The easiest way is NAAM Simran. This wisdom is reserved for all Jeevs. Balbir Singh [%sig%]

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Balbir · 25 Aug 2005

“You still haven't proved that the Bhagats I have mentioned didn't follow idol worship rather you have only inferred that they didn't perform murti pooja - based on point of view.” Well I have listed why it is obviously clear why NamDev was not an idol worshiper again and again. If you still need further proof well than there is no satisfying some people. Like I said Gurbani is not based on different views of different authors with changing philosophies. You assume that just because their “followers” say they were idol worshippers and tell stories that they must be true as opposed to their own Baani in Guru Granth Sahib. Using your mind set you would expect every single person in Guru Granth Sahib to make a statement saying they reject idols, or otherwise they were murti poojaks. Whilst the fact is that Gurbani and Sikhi as a whole rejects idol worship, hence if Guru Nanak et al says it in Gurbani the same philosophy applies through out, and does not chop and change, ie idol pooja is rejected in Guru Granth Sahib in one place and is consequently rejected through out, and hence does not require every single person included to continuously state what has already been made clear. As before the proof you need as communicated earlier is that if they were murti poojaks they would not have been included in Guru Granth Sahib out of basic common sense, and as we know Guru Ji rejected other Saints who wrote not on the same lines as Gurmat. Likewise their bani’s (in Guru Granth Sahib) do not make reference to murti pooja as a way of spirituality, but clearly only naam. Most people using rational thinking would know that anyone let alone the Guru would not include writings about things against the basic tenants of their beliefs . As for the “Muslim” Bhagats likewise I suggest that you read their baani’s. Exactly like the “Hindu” Bhagats their writings are exactly in line with Gurmat ie naam being the main focus of connection with the One God ie no idols etc. It should also be noted that from a Sikh perpective these Bhagats are not regarded as Hindu or Muslim in the first instance, ie the Guru refers to them as Bhagats and nothing else. “Just because Hindus perform idol worship it doesn't mean that they believe that God is not all pervading. We believe that God is all pervading and therefore he/she is also in the idol as well - the emphasis being that God in the murti is in his/her most accessible form.” I am well aware that some argue that God is both in an idol and at the same time in all. However this concept is utterly floored (from a Sikh perpective) as God is all pervading even in stones, however this does not mean that there is any value in worshipping a stone. Using this idea it would be okay to worship trees, cars, pigs and leaves in0fact anything as God is in all these things equally as well. God is no more accessible in a brick on the floor than an idol in the temple. Both things contain God as do ALL CREATION. Hence in Gurmat Guru Ji makes it clear that we must Worhip the ONE which is INSIDE ALL, and not the things which he is in (common sense also implies this). As Guru Nanak says “Iko Simero Nananka Jo Jhal Thal Rehia Samie”, Oh Nanak remember/mediate on the ONE which is CONTAINED with in water & land. Hence worship the one which is inside ALL CREATION and not the creation itself. As Gurbani further clarifies. hak sach khaalak khalak mi-aanay si-aam moorat naahi. “The True Creator Lord is diffused into His creation; He is not just the Krishna Idol. ||2|| In-fact the idea of worshipping an idol as God (believing God is more accessible in it) is further floored as Gurbani (including the Bhagats Bani) makes it clear that God is inside each person, and is accessible inside ones very self (not an external stone). Hence the need to worship an idol/stone is contradictory to Gurbani (God is just as much in the Temple walls, cars in the car park and even people in the Pub) as God is in-fact inside the person doing the worship and only accessible in the heart. As Gurbani says: I wander around inside and outside, but I always keep Him enshrined within my heart. ||21|| Realize that the One God is inside and outside; understand this, that the Mansion of His Presence is within the home of your heart.

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Balbir · 25 Aug 2005

Sitara Ji, my original message did not get fully posted. Please see below what was left out. One thing I would like to make clear, is that if you or other Hindu's worship idols that fine, which is not the topic here. Each to thier own. What makes God more accessible in a carved idol more than a pebble or brick? The two things are exactly the same which both common sence and Gurbani reveal. As Bhagat NamDev himself clearly states in Gurbani “One stone is lovingly decorated, (idol) while another stone is walked upon. If one is a god, then the other must also be a god. Says Naam Dayv, I serve the Lord. Page 525, Line 5 -- Saint Nam Dev Hence Bhagat NamDev is making it clear that the idol is exactly the same as the stone on the floor which everyone simply walk over. God is hence inside ALL and in no way more accessible in an idol which is the same as a stone on the ground, (from a Sikh/Gurbani perpective) It is clear that the only place where the All Pervading God is accessible in Gurmat is inside ones own self where the true worship is done, ie with naam. The One who pervades the Universe also dwells in the body; whoever seeks Him, finds Him there. Page 695, Line 15 -- Saint Pipa Within the body, the Divine Lord is embodied. The body is the temple, the place of pilgrimage, and the pilgrim. Within the body are incense, lamps and offerings. Within the body are the flower offerings. ||1|| Page 695, Line 13 -- Saint Pipa In the one and in the many, He is pervading and permeating; wherever I look, there He is. Page 485, Line 2 -- Saint Nam Dev God is everything, God is everything. Without God, there is nothing at all. Page 485, Line 3 -- Saint Nam Dev In each and every heart, and deep within the very nucleus of all, is the One Lord. ||4||1|| Page 485, Line 6 -- Saint Nam Dev Regards

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

**- · 25 Aug 2005

Balbir and/or Singh, I fully understand the point you are trying to get across - i.e. if the bhagats practices were not in line with Gurmat, then the Guru Sahibaan would not have included their baani in the SGGS. This is how you are basing your proposition that the bhagats did not follow murti pooja. But this is not necassary solid proof but inference (i.e. if A imples B and B implies C then A implies C). I, on the other hand, am basing my proposition on the authentic writings that have been penned down by NamDeyv himself and not secondary writings i.e. the SGGS and the practices of his disciples (who you have claimed to all be dishonest). The very fact the NamDeyv had a very prominent role in the Pandharpur Mandir up to the time of his death and that he requested his ashes were put in the samadh within the mandirs premises speaks volumes. I know of many Sikhs (academic and non-academic) that do not dispute the fact he was a idolater and they tell me that he along with the other bhagats were reborn so that they could take Khande de Pahual from the punj payarray and get mukthi. Others have said that the NamDeyv whose baani is in the SGGS is not the same NamDeyv from Pandharpur – since he was an idolater. They say the NamDeyv in the SGGS was a Sikh of Guru Nanak Dev Ji. Regarding your comments about idol worship, I wasn't trying to vindicate murti-pooja but rather show that the idea of an all-prevading God is not limited to just followers of iconoclast philosophies. The rights and wrongs of murti pooja is another topic in itself. The topic being discussed here is whether NamDeyv was an idolator. We are not getting anywhere with this topic, we both keep repeating ourselves. You keep producing reams of quotes deriding murti-pooja and telling me not to listen to what his parampara say since they are all dishonest leachers (even though you probably never met them) whereas I reply with the fact that the practices of his followers are contrary to what you say. You are still hung up on idol worship thing where as I am still hung up on the writings of NamDeyv himself and the practices of his followers (who you have maliciously accused of being dishonest ‘leachers’). I think it is best to say ‘lets agree to disagree’ and leave it at that. The next thing somebody might say was that he was a pooran tyar-bar-tyar rehitvaan GurSikh who kept sarbloh bibek, kesh and keski. Good day to you, Sitara [%sig%]

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Singh · 25 Aug 2005

Sitara - My last two posts went up as Balbir, its a long story. Anyway: I agree that one must at some stage agree to disagree. However from a Sikh perspective all the Bhagats writings in Guru Granth Sahib come before any stories coming from his "followers" etc (which are also far from solid proof). Like I have stated before followers do not necessarily preach nor follow what the prophets did which is even the case with the majority of Sikhs. Therefore I am sure you would appreciate that in view of no bani's (which as Sikh’s we are concerned with) making reference to murti pooja but in-fact contradicting the concept ie “One stone is lovingly decorated, (idol) while another stone is walked upon. If one is a god, then the other must also be a god. Says Naam Dayv, I serve the Lord. Page 525, Line 5 -- Saint Nam Dev" their leaves little doubt in the minds of those following Sikhi as to the Bhagats positions. The “implication” as mentioned are based on common logic which amounts to proof especially when we know the Guru was steadfast and rejected Bani's by those not in line with Gurmat. Hence just like most rational people would take as proof 1 + 1 must equal 2, equally if Guru Sahib totally rejects murti pooja it would not be included in his Granth. Well we can agree to disagree. With regard to moorti pooja I think you were as I am sure you would agree revealing how the idea of worshipping an idol and the all pervading God do not contradict each other. However from a Sikh perceptive and realistic thinking I think it has been shown (in previous posts) that the two concepts are evidently contradictory.

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Balbir Singh · 26 Aug 2005

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Somebody asked "How many are two plus two?" A hungry person in the gathering spoke loudly "Chaar rotiaaN (four breads)." Dear Sitara Ji! The thread started here by Gyani Ji is "Is Bhagat Namdev an Idol Worshiper? NO Never." You spoke loudly "Namdev, the murty poojak of Maharashtra." Then you started clarifying your answer when others gazed at you surprisingly with words like "He use to worship a murti form of Krishna known as Vitthal Dev . . .Krishna and his wife Rukhmani . . .the NamDev whose baani is in the Siri Guru Granth Sahib was a different NamDev i.e. a chela of SatGur Nanak Dev Ji . . .NaamDayv's (Maharashtra wale) baani in the SGGS is not in Maharathi . . .Namdev of the Vitthal-Dev mandir in Pardhanpur, his Abhangs and sampradaya" etc. It looks like that you wish to advertise your agenda. -------------- The Murt (form) roop of God is the Universe. All are His Murtis. The Amurt Swaroop of God is Nirankar. All Jeevs in word are murti Poojak till they come to know Nirankar, the formless. The Pooja (worship) of Nirankar is only possible when HE gives Darshan as Nirankar. Only God remains after receiving HIS Darshan as Nirankar, not any stand alone murti or its pooja. The bridge between God's Murt roop and Nirankar swaroop is GURSHABAD or NAM. Those, who have not received NAM, may find Namdev Ji also today as Murti Poojak. Balbir Singh [%sig%]

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 26 Aug 2005

The Shabad mentions a Bowl made of GOLD. IS Bhagat namdev a Cheemba..rich enough to have a GOLD BOWL for a "stone idol"..and the Gharra is just claypot. Any comments? second the Moortee/idols are ususally in the Mandir...but Bhagat namdev seems to have them in his house ?? IF he has the idols in His house..why the necessity to go to the Mandir from which he was chased out as a low caste ? Can a Low caste..Keep Idols in his house ?? Can a Low caste read shatras/puraans vedas....wasnt this punishable under Mannu simrtee Laws ??

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Lionking · 02 Sep 2005

EXACTLY - SPOT ON JARNAIL SINGH ji - How was Bhagat Namdev Ji - a low caster allowed to have a "prmonent role ina Mandhir?" ___________________ The very fact the NamDeyv had a very prominent role in the Pandharpur Mandir up to the time of his death and that he requested his ashes were put in the samadh within the mandirs premises speaks volumes. ____________________ How was the allowed when he was thrown from a a Mandhir earlier on... Guru Granth Sahib ji does include a Shabad about him going to a a temple but Pandits not allowign him to enter, so how was he allowed to lead and have a prominent role?

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

$ingh · 02 Sep 2005

gyani ji this is one point of difference between gurbani and varan bhai gurdaas

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Singh · 02 Sep 2005

"gyani ji this is one point of difference between gurbani and varan bhai gurdaas" no its not, what are you talking about? Please provide refs.

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Lionking · 03 Sep 2005

$ingh - you are WRONG - Bhai GUrdas ji talks about Bhagat Namdev ji being idosl worshipping at FIRST, not that he always was. Even GUrbani has Shabads about Bhagat NamDev ji going to Mandhir but not being allowed - Bhai Gurdas Ji Diya Vaara is a, as Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji meantion a Study Guide - a key for a better understanding of Gurbani. Bhai Gurdas Ji Has written about our History and other things makign it easier for us to put things into context! Dhan Guru Dhan GurSikh!!! Bhai Gurdas Ji is the bessssstttttttttttttttttttttttt of the besttttttt Gursikhs - Read his Vaara and Find out - there are no words to explain - Don't take things out for context Singh!

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Kulbir Singh · 03 Sep 2005

------------- Regarding point #2 raised by Jarnail Singh - I strongly beg to differ. Right now I am reading a book about Sripad MadhavaAcahrya (who was a Krishna Bhakta). His poetic works mention both Siri RaamChander, Krishna, Pashuraam, NarSingh Avtaar etc etc in the same mantras. Even staunch Krishna bhaktas like Chaytanya Mahaprabhu chants Rama and Krishna in the same mantra (e.g. Hare Krishna, Hare Rama) . ---------- Arshee Gyani jee is absolutely correct in saying that the worshippers of Raam Chander never worship Krishna and vice-versa. Today the things have changed and Hindus bow to just about anyone but in the olden days i.e. during the days of Bhagat Naamdev jee, Hindus worshipped only one deity. There was a severe rivalry between the Raam Bhagats and Krishna Bhagats. Raam Bhagtee was made popular by Swami Ramanand jee where as before his advent only Krishna Bhagti was popular and it produced great Krishna bhagats like Chataniya Mahaprabhu and before him Raghwa jee and Ramanuj etc. The Mantra of Chataniya Mahaprabhus Samprada is “Hare Krishna Hare Krishna Krishna Krishna Hare Hare. Hare Rama Hare Rama Rama Rama Hare Hare”. Sitara jee, you mentioned that this mantra refers to Soorya Vanshee, Dashrath-puttar Raam Chander but you are mistaken in this. Rama here refers to Balraam, the elder brother of Siri Krishna, whom they believe was part of Krishna’s overall being. Some believe Balrama was the incarnation of Shesh Naag. Whatever the case, you can refer to the literature of Chataniya Mahaprabhu to confirm that the word Rama there is not in reference to Raam Chander of Auyodhya. The stature of Krishna is and was much greater than Rama. Krishna is 16 Kala Sampooran whereas Rama is 14 Kala Sampooran but by the same token, Rama was a superior Maryada Purshottom than Krishna. His ethics were higher than Krishna but he too made mistakes like killing Bali the elder brother of Sugreev deceitfully was not right. Krishna did many such deceits e.g. while the killing of Jaidrath, killing of Duryodhan, Karan, Dronacharya, Bheesham etc, ethics were compromised. Kulbir Singh

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. 1. No one answered my doubts about how Bhagat namdev ji, a supposedly POOR Cheemba is having a SOLID GOLD BOWL..and is supposedly worshipping a "Beethal moortee" in HIS HOUSE and NOT in a Beethal mandir as every other Beethal Poojaree does ?? Perhaps because there is no logical answer to this riddle... 2. Now to the BEETHAL. IS this Beethal of Bhagat namdev Ji the SAME Beethal Moortee found in the Beethal mandirs of Maharashtra ? My answer is NO. Bhagat namdev Ji's BEETHAL is Not the same as the Beethal Idol found in beethal mandirs...Bhagat ji's BEETHAL is actually AKAL PURAKH. Bhagat ji mentions the word BEETHAL..a total of NINE times in hsi Gurbani..GURU ARJUN JI Sahib uses the Saame BEETHAL WORD a total of SIX times. By the same "logic" then we can conclude that GURU ARJUN JI also must have been a Beethal Moortee Poojak ?? After all we are accusing Bhagat ji of being a Beethal Moortee poojak just becasue he emntions the word BEETHAL..then what will we say about GURU ARJUN ji's use of the same word ?? WHAT IS THIS ?? IF bhagat ji prayed to a beethal in a beethal mandir in Maharashtra........WHICH BEETHAL MANDIR did Guru Arjun ji go to ?? 3. Before we go further another dilemma...assails us. Bhagat Ji calls His "supposedly Krishan Beethal MERE RAMIYAAH..and also BEETHLA..and also GOVIND, MADHO, KESAV, RAAM, HAREE and ALLAH !!! Are we sure bhagat Ji's beethal is indeed the "Krishan beethal" found in the Mandirs of Maharashtra..Could that Beethal be called ALLAH ?? IS this WHY bahagt ji was KICKED out from the mandir ?? for calling krishan ALLAH ?? The ANSWER to thsi riddle is that the BEETHAL of Bhagat namdev Ji..also called by the many names mentioned above is the SARB VIAPAK Raam...the AKAL PURAKH thta is found in each of His CREATIONS... Namdev Ji declares..MY BEETHAL is NOT FOUND IN ANY MANDIR OR ANY MASJID !!! There we have got our clear cut answer in bhagat ji's OWN WORDS. 4. If we even for a moment beleive that bahagt ji is indeed a Krishan beethal Worshipper...then he must of necessity perform this worshipping in a MANDIR..THEN WHY should he be kicked out of that mandir out of the BLUE ?? OR is that becasue He called His Krishan beethal Mere ramiyah..mere Hari, mere Gobind, Mere Kesav.Mere ALLAH ?? NO Body in his right mind would go to a Krishan mandir and address the Krishan Moortee there as RAAM JI.....or call Him ALLAH !!! Thus we arrive at the only conclusion.. A> Bhagat namdev Ji NEVER went to any Mandir..and thus B. He is NOT a Beethal Worhsipper of a moortee. 5. The BEETHAL described by bahgat ji on AAng 1318 Raag kannrra is a Word for Word DESCRIPTION of AKAL PURAKH. This "Beethal" resides in each of Akal purakhs creations and this beethal is NOT bound by MAYA ....ever... Its patently obvious that Bhagat namdev Ji is using the Old word "beethal (krishan moortee)" in his own UNIQUE NEW WAY "BEETHAL = AKAL PURAKH" a Prabhu that is free of Maya and is everywhere....certainly not an idol sitting on a brick in a mandir. 6. The Final NAIL in the Idol worshipper Theory.... Bhagat namdev Ji in several Shabads declares that He found the TRUE SATGURU....who taught him how to Do Naam simran in the SAADH SANGAT...and this is the WAY to Jeewan MUKTEE. This is CONFIRMED by other Shabads written by Bhagt Kabir Ji, Bhagta Ravidass ji, Guru Amardass Ji, Guur ramdass Ji and Finally by GURU ARJUN JI . These Shaabds all tell us that Namdev Ji did SAADH SANGAT of true satguru and Did NAAM SIMRAN as a way to AKAL PURAKH. 7. And the most astonishing thing about ALL the Shabads by Bhagat kabir Ji, bhagat ravidass Ji, Guru Sahibaans mentioned in para 6 above..is that NONE even mention that bahagta namdev Ji ever performed any Moortee Pooja and that He failed to achieve anything thru that action... each Shabad ONLY MENTIONS again and again..Saadh Sangat/Satguru/Naam Simran...as THE WAY Bhagat namdev Ji travelled....to achieve the ULTIMATE. 8. BUT Namdev Ji does use a lot of "references to KRISHAN JI....in his bani. Next we will discuss WHY ?? It is a perfectly innocent reference and NOT due to Him being a Krishan Pujaree. Thank You...Jarnail Singh.

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

khush · 03 Sep 2005

jarnail singh ji that is a post which is expected of you well done please dont waste key strokes on sant bashing :P feed us with gurbani analysis

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

charanjeev singh · 03 Sep 2005

waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh The game of Waheguruu is only known to Waheguruu. As Waheguruu plays games with His Bhagats, that colour can only be known by those whom Waheguruu has chosen to enlighten. Bhagat NaamDev Jee most definately went to a mandir to pray. And was subsquently also kicked out of here. The lesson that Waheguruu wants to teach us here in my humble opinion is; I do not live in a temple; I myself turn to the Bhagats. The temple did turn around to where Bhagat Naam Dev Jee was sitting and doing Simran of Akaal Purakh Waheguruu. This astaan as been deemed by scientists that it is a fact that the building structure has indeed been rotated (however, we do not need their assurance) Bhagat Naam Dev Jee entails the details of this encounter and experience with his Beethal, Waheguruu, in Gurbaani. hasath khaelath thaerae dhaehurae aaeiaa || bhagath karath naamaa pakar out(h)aaeiaa ||1|| heenarree jaath maeree jaadhim raaeiaa || shheepae kae janam kaahae ko aaeiaa ||1|| rehaao || lai kamalee chaliou palattaae || dhaehurai paashhai bait(h)aa jaae ||2|| jio jio naamaa har gun oucharai || bhagath janaa(n) ko dhaehuraa firai ||3||6|| Laughing and playing, I came to Your Temple, O Lord. While Naam Dayv was worshipping, he was grabbed and driven out. ||1|| I am of a low social class, O Lord; why was I born into a family of fabric dyers? ||1||Pause|| I picked up my blanket and went back, to sit behind the temple. ||2|| As Naam Dayv uttered the Glorious Praises of the Lord, the temple turned around to face the Lord's humble devotee. ||3||6|| Ang 1164 bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh also, how come you refer to Guru Arjan Dev Jee only as Guru Arjan Jee? Do you feel that Dev jee is an hindu addition? (i am not being rude, but asking lovingly). The Guru refers to Guru Sahib as thus; jab lo nehee bhaag lilaar oudhai thab lo bhramathae firathae bahu dhhaayo || kal ghor samudhr mai booddath thhae kabehoo mitt hai nehee rae pashhuthaayo || thath bichaar yehai mathhuraa jag thaaran ko avathaar banaayo || japyo jinh arajun dhaev guroo fir sa(n)katt jon garabh n aayo ||6|| As long as the destiny written upon my forehead was not activated, I wandered around lost, running in all directions. I was drowning in the horrible world-ocean of this Dark Age of Kali Yuga, and my remorse would never have ended. O Mat'huraa, consider this essential truth: to save the world, the Lord incarnated Himself. Whoever meditates on Guru Arjun Dayv, shall not have to pass through the painful womb of reincarnation ever again. ||6|| Ang 1409 Bhai Gurdaas Jee has referred to Guru Arjan Dev Jee as Guru Arjan. I would assume both names are in reverence. bhul chuk mauf [%sig%]

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Sep 2005

veer charanjeev singh ji, waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. as i have explained in my message above..Bhagat namdev Ji was NOT a REGULAR Mandir Worshipper....otherwise why "accept" him all this while and "kick" him out one day. This is a local Mandir and Bhagat ji is also a local..so everyone including the pandits know his low caste from day one. The better explanation is that...in HIS MAUJ... performing Bhagtee of His BEETHAL WAHEGURU...Bhagat ji entered this mandir...and was PROMPTLY THROWN OUT. This is a One Off Visit....and certainly NOT for Doing POOJA of the Beethal moortee installed there. Thats all...I am not disputing GURBANI in any way. This Incident did happen and it is TRUE. On the name of Guru Arjun Ji Sahib..you have answered it already. I hold BOTH in reverence and use the one I always write. 2. Dear Khush Ji, Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Thank You for the kind words. I dont "sant" bash for the fun of it. In my understanding Sikhe/Gurmatt has TWO PILLARS....Pillar of GYAN (knowledge) and Pillar of SHARDHA (Wishwaash). A Good SIKH MUST have BOTH PILLARS. Some like Bhai Kala Afghana just want the Pillar of GYAN..and want to demolish the Pillar of Shardha alltogether....and others like the Sant-Samajists want to DEMOLISH the Pillar of Gyan and just retain the Shardha only..BLIND FAITH..100% follow what baba ji said...lakir in STONE...without question..even if Proven Anti-Gurmatt..never mind BABA JI BRAHMGIANI JI said it so its OK. This is the ONLY contention I have with these people..I want the KASWATTII of GURBANI (GYAN) applied to all Shardha. Hope this calrifies. Love to all jarnail Singh.

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Singh · 04 Sep 2005

Jarnail Singh wrote "Namdev Ji declares..MY BEETHAL is NOT FOUND IN ANY MANDIR OR ANY MASJID !!! There we have got our clear cut answer in bhagat ji's OWN WORDS." Please can you provide the ang refs where Bhagat Ji says this. That would be most helpful. Thanks

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

charanjeev singh · 04 Sep 2005

waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh "The better explanation is that...in HIS MAUJ... performing Bhagtee of His BEETHAL WAHEGURU...Bhagat ji entered this mandir...and was PROMPTLY THROWN OUT. This is a One Off Visit....and certainly NOT for Doing POOJA of the Beethal moortee installed there." This makes perfect sense to me. I agree with this view; in fact it gives me a new perpective and i thank you for sharing. Similary, I think it was Bhagat Kabeer Jee who was going to go for hajj, and Waheguruu Jee intervened and stopped him. Please correct me if i am wrong. With Bhagat Naamdev Jee, it seems to be the similar relationship. Bhagat NaamDev Jee was going to the mandir (out of mauj this day), and Waheguruu Jee said 'no, no', and instead turned to Bhagat Sahib. The lesson i see is that Waheguruu is within, and there is no need for rituals. In fact, Waheguruu comes to the Bhagat, the Bhagat does not need to go anywhere. Only if we could all have such direct relationships with Waheguruu Jee. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

learner · 04 Sep 2005

what's sharda?

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Sep 2005

Singh Ji, Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. This point is stressed in every Shabad of Bhagat Namdev Ji. Here is an example.. [gurbani]Awsw ] AwnIly kuMB, BrweIly aUdk, Twkur kau iesnwnu krau ] bieAwlIs lK jI jl mih hoqy, bITlu BYlw kwie krau ]1] jqR jwau, qq bITlu BYlw ] mhw Anµd kry sd kylw ]1] rhwau ] AwnIly PUl, proeIly mwlw, Twkur kI hau pUj krau ] pihly bwsu leI hY Bvrh, bITlu BYlw kwie krau ]2] AwnIly dUDu rIDweIly KIrM, Twkur kau nYvydu krau ] pihly dUDu ibtwirE bCrY, bITlu BYlw kwie krau ]3] eIBY bITlu, aUBY bITlu, bITl ibnu sMswru nhI ] Qwn Qnµqir nwmw pRxvY, pUir rihE qUM srb mhI ]4]2] {pMnw 485}[/gurbani] IS this Beethal sitting in some Beethal mandir ? NO This Beethal of namdev is in the entire creation.... Bhagat ji is smashing to bits all the empty rituals....bathing the beethal in holy water ( full of millions of dead germs and other impurities..), offering the beethal milk..that has been made impure by the Calf, offering the beethal flowers ...that have been made impure by the moth and butterfly and the bee sitting on it long before that... At the end Bhagat ji declares MY BEETHAL is EVERYWHERE....and HE doesnt "need" all this ritual bathing, offerings of flowers, and milk etc. On AAng 874 Raag gond Bhagat ji declares.. [gurbani]iblwvlu goNf ] Awju nwmy bITlu dyiKAw, mUrK ko smJwaU ry ] rhwau ] pWfy qumrI gwieqRI, loDy kw Kyqu KwqI QI ] lY kir Tygw tgrI qorI, lWgq lWgq jwqI QI ]1] pWfy qumrw mhwdyau, Dauly bld ciVAw Awvqu dyiKAw Qw ] modI ky Gr Kwxw pwkw, vw kw lVkw mwirAw Qw ]2] pWfy qumrw rwmcMdu, so BI Awvqu dyiKAw Qw ] rwvn syqI srbr hoeI, Gr kI joie gvweI QI ]3] ihMdU AMn@w qurkU kwxw ] duhW qy igAwnI isAwxw ] ihMdU pUjY dyhurw, muslmwxu msIiq ] nwmy soeI syivAw, jh dyhurw n msIiq ]4]3]7] {pMnw 874-875}[/gurbani] TODAY Nama has "seen" my BEETHAL....and He is NOT in any Masjid or in Any Mandir... Bhagat Namdev Ji is the Second Hardest Hitting Bhagat after Bhagat Kabir Jee. Just read his Gurbani and you will realise how really hard he hits the empty rituals and dharmik Pakhands...thats why the Bippar Brahmin combine worked extra hard to spread false misinformation and sakhis about him I feel so much sadness when we Sikhs DISREGARD the Bhagat's OWN writings, the Wittness provided by our OWN GURU SAHIBAANS..and fall for the half baked sakhis and false stories spread by the BIPPAR/BRAHMIN and our very own uneducated preachers. Guru ramdass ji Himself writes that Bhagat Namdev Ji got WAHEGURU through Naam Simran....but we DISREGARD that Testimony and keep on beleiving our preachers who tell us...one day namdev's father went off to town, namdev got soem milk and sat down in front of the thakur beethal moortee and prayed so hard, waheguru came out of the beethal moortee and drank the milk...his father was so surprised that his son got waheguru to drink the milk in one day..blah blah blah... when Bhagat namdev Ji in his own Hand says something ENTIRELY OPPOSITE to this false story. ( maybe false stories and sakhis are so "interesting" than the STARK TRUTH !! ) Jarnail Singh

Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Sep 2005

... Veer Charanjeev Singh Ji writes:..The lesson i see is that Waheguru is within, and there is no need for rituals. In fact, Waheguruu comes to the Bhagat, the Bhagat does not need to go anywhere. Only if we could all have such direct relationships with Waheguru Jee. >> Yes I agree..actually as per my understanding this Waheguru within us is the "SADH/SANT/GURU/SATGURU"..and to Meet this Waheguru deep within us is what Sheikh farid is telling us about when he says..Gareeban meh dekh...and when Gurbani says..Sadh/Sant BHETNA...it means to meet the SADH/SANT inside YOU..Gurbani tells us again and again that HE is within YOUR SELF..yet we RUSH HEADLONG outsied searching for HIM ?? He is in the HOUSE (GHAR) which means our BODY.. At so many places Guru Amardass Ji tells us that HE _WAHEGURU has Sajjia his HARMANDIR ( our body) for His OWN RESIDENCE..He is WITHIN..and its so easy for us to have a Personal Relationship with HIM because we are living in the SAME HOUSE !! Thank you for your kind thoughts..and sharing wonderful views.. jarnail Singh. Note to Learner: Shardha is BELIEF./ FAITH..as in SIKHS beleive Guru nanak ji to be Nirankaar's Roop on Earth.....but "beleiving " this without any GYAN is BLIND FAITH...the "GYAN" is in Guru nanak Ji's GURBANI..which if properly read, understood and applied in our daily life..JOINS US WITH NIRANKAAR..and we also become NIrankaar roop. This is why I say..SIKHI needs BOTH PPILLARS..Gyan and Shardha to be BALANCED. remove or weaken either one and the sikhe building is in danger of collapse.