Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Raagmala article

Raagmala article

UK Singh · 07 Oct 2003

have any prominent members of the Jatha read this following article: http://www.sikhifm.com/Sikhism/update1/Raag%20Maala%20(Damdami%20Taksal).pdf if so, do they have any comments?

Re: .

Khalsa Soulja · 07 Oct 2003

personally i believe in the ragmalla. unless anyone can tell me how it appeared in the kartarpuri bir mostly importantly, and also in copies of the damdama bir.

Re: .

{¿?}â„¢ · 07 Oct 2003

He said prominent MEMBERS of the JATHA.

Re: .

Harbhajan Singh · 07 Oct 2003

Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh Nothing new. Heard most of the arguments before. Will never convince me that Ragmalla is bani. A list of Raags which are not even CORRECT is BANI. Need a better argument than that. If anyone replies in more depth please do so. Such as Admin or Tapoban Singhs. If I have the time I will post a more detailed post. But one thing has happend continously over the Raag Malaa issue is that some points never get answered by Pro-Ragmalia as they cant make anything up at the time, but think about it later and then create a document which they think will solve all the Questions. But in my opinion stick by what Panth decided and not get railroaded into a discussion on what has turned out to be nothing New. If I have some time I will post in more depth. But efforts should be put into something more constructive than a Raag Malaa debate :) Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh

Re: .

Balpreet Singh · 07 Oct 2003

The Kataarpuri BeeR we find today is not accepted as the Kartaarpuri beeR of the past. The description given by Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha in Mahaan Kosh does not match with what exists today. Many scholars don't think that the beeR there now is the original. Baba Aalaa Singh of Patiala had a copy made of the Kartaarpuri beeR and that copy does NOT have ragmala. It was in the Patiala Household last I heard. Please read any article on this issue for more details. I personally hate debating this topic since both sides are defending Guru Sahib's sanctity.

Re: .

Gabroo Khalistan Dah · 07 Oct 2003

and so starts a fight that has b'n fought b4...........does it matter? raagmalla does it teach une thing that would help ur sikhi? no, but that does'nt mean its not bani.......but as its not important why discuss it? why bring feuds over such bull?

Re: .

Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 07 Oct 2003

Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh The Article states that Bhai Sahib has made a mistake when he never believed in raag mala, but this can be vise versa. maybe Sant Gurbachan Singh, Sant kurtar singh, Sant jarnail singh, etc could of had made a mistake. Also who wrote this? on the first page where they state singhs names, the singhs that believe in Raag Mala are directed as Sant, Bhai, etc. but when it came to the naming of the singhs that dont believe in Raag mala there names where just directly listed, no Bhai in the front for respect. except for Bhai Kahan singh Nabha. All chardi kala singhs should be directed as "Bhai Sahib ..... Singh ji" not just there names. i personally found this to be wrong and i think that it should be fixed. Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh Dalrajkaur Khalsa

Re: .

jagjit singh · 08 Oct 2003

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I managed to read through the document today. Some one has put alot of work into it, but has only repeated what the pro-raagmala camp has said for years anyway. Much of it is based on reliance on stories, opinions and a whole lot of assumptions rather than clear cut facts. Some of the arguments are a bit silly. Basically it is a document, which on the face of it will look impressive to someone new, and may convince them, but in reality when you look at it in detail it does have many holes, and is just not convincing. Again we hear the same old stories of Teja Singh manipulating views on many. A sort of conspriracy theory to justify views, just because he has a bad name for being thrown out of the Panth. Bhai sahibs views were not from him, but based on Gurbani, which is why in his books he mentions Gurbani time after time, not him. Stories by Taksal of bhai sahib accepting raagmala are false, all of his associates confirm this, aswell as his books. It demonstrates the complete lack of facts, and desperation of the pro-raagmala camp that they would stoop so low and just make up blatant falsehoods. No one else does it, so why them. Definatley not a good sign for a Gursikh organisation. The document questions Mahakavi Bhai Sontokh Singh works. Possibly so, but then why use it for most of the katha taught by the institution. Then use Gurbilas Patshai 6th. This is strange, because this document is even more controversial, and the starting point for the whole Jathedars vs kala Afghani debate in the Panth. It has many questionable items in it. The information on raags is questionable. Many noted scholars and musicians contradict it. The explanations given do not fundamenatlly answer the questions put on raagmala, and why there is so much contradiction in raags. The best explanation about the raags was given to me by Prof. Surinder singh, PHD on gurmat sangeet. He completely ripped these raag theories by Taksaal apart. On one side you say satkar yog Giani Gurbachan Singh Ji had ten diffferent meanings for each shabad in Guru Ji. I do find this strange, the meaning of the each shabad is specific. However that meaning could appply to different people in different ways. So that is strange thing to start with. Secondly the spiritual meanings put forward are not convincing at all. It leaves an impression of desperation in applying some kind of meaning to the passages, rather than anything convincing. The conclusions are assumptions rather than facts. Not every praatan bir does have raag mala. Also what about the compositions taken out which were before raagmala, which every faction in the Panth agreed to have removed. How did they get in between the bani and raagmala, if both are continous bani. Much of this document seems targeted at Bhai Randhir Singh. Yes bhai sahib was quite a personality in panthic affairs. But majority of debate by anti-raagmala camp was written not by Bhai sahib but by many other Gursikhs and scholars. Much of their debate seems completely ignored. The most convincing documents I have read on this issue has been by Sikh Missionary. In conclusion, the document is nothing new, and silly in places. I hope it does not create a trend where pro and anti camps start making large documents agianst each other. There is so much more productive things that need to be done. I speak for myself here. I do not think anyone wants any controversy in Sikhi. Especially based around Gurbani. But we have a responsibility to the truth. How can we accept what is an incorrect raagmala, and place it with bani, knowing full well Sahib Siri Guru Arjan dev Ji, was a complete master of knowledge and music. Then state he wrote it. Guru ji did not make mistakes. We have to be honest. Sikhi is the truth, not what is convenient. If sikhi was convenient, our history would be nothing. We need to be able to say the truth. The truth is aspects of the composition of raagmala are questionable, and unexplainable, no matter how hard any Pro jathebandie tries. You cannot hide that, and pretend it will go away, with flowery explanations from whichever Gursikh, hoping people will just accept them and it will be fine. I mean no disrespect to the gursikhs of taksal, but there is nothing substantial here, and it would be helpful if they stuck to a debate, rather than spread lies about Gursikhs who have passed away to dargah, and cannot respond to the lies put about them. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: .

Gupt Singh · 08 Oct 2003

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh. The writer of that article tried to prove all the gursikhs (including Bhai Randheer Singh ji) Who don't believe in Raag-Maala;are in mistake.He writes that Every one can make a mistake cos Gurbani says,'BHULAN ANDER SABH KO ABHULL GURU KARTAAR''. According to this pangti, There is only Guru Kartaar who never makes any mistake ,all other can make mistakes,then baba Gurbachan singh, baba Thakar singh and the writer of the article CAN ALSO make mistakes.Satguru ji said,'Bhulan ander sabh ko..........that means SABH KO. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh.

Re: .

asingh · 09 Oct 2003

That is a level of Brahmgyan where you understand deeper meanings of gurbani. The deeper you go into spirituality, the more you can understand gurbani, so there can be many meanings for one pangtee. Eh Bani Mahapurkh Kee Nij Kar Vasaa Hoi

Re: .

unjaan · 09 Oct 2003

funny to see how the members on this board have an answer for everything. OBVIOUSLY Bhai Randhir Singh MUST have been right and the AKJ are all knowing and are 100% sure of themselves that they are correct. Apart from the Guru - no can be so sure of anything. Does the AKJ print Saroops without this Bani? Why at Raensbhai do AKJ bow to the Guru when it contains Raagmala Who changed the Kartarpuri Bir and when? When I went to India in '99, I visited the ancestral home of Bhai Dala. As soon as we got there, we rang a bell and a girl showed us some artefacts, clothing and a gatra that belonged to Guru Gobind Singh Ji. Before we said anything, she held in front of us a tiny saroop of Guru Granth Sahib in her hand (which Guru Sahib kept on him in his wide Gatra - it even had a pocket, specifically designed for this purpose), and she said 'this contains the raag mala'. I was taken aback, and this cemented my belief in Raagmala even more.

Re: .

Mr Rice Pudding · 09 Oct 2003

If you don't beleive in Raagmala then why bow to the Guru Granth Sahib in every Rainsebai as according to people who reject raagmala the Guru's saroop is not genuine. Why did the Sikhs in 78 do shsheedi for the Saroop of Guru Granth Sahib Ji which was placed below the Nirhankari if it's not 100% genuine. Did they waste thier time, or did that copy not have the Raagmala in it. Its a conradiction to say the Raagmala and other Bani's are fake and then bow to and act all holy around Guru Granth Sahib's saroops which almost all containe the Raagmala.

Re: .

Kulbir Singh · 09 Oct 2003

Rice-Pudding (wish you had a more Gursikhi name) >>> If you don't beleive in Raagmala then why bow to the Guru Granth Sahib in every Rainsebai as according to people who reject raagmala the Guru's saroop is not genuine. >>>>> Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee contains many items that are not Gurbani but we matha tek to them too. That does not make those sections of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee Gurbani. As an example, look at the front page of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. It has the name of the publisher e.g. Bhai Jeevan Singh Chattar Singh, SGPC etc. Does it mean that since we matha tek to the name of publishers, we should start accepting them as baani? This argument that because we mathatek to Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and it contains Raagmala, so we in essence matha tek to Raagmala too is nonsense argument. We matha tek to Gurbani in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and that is it. We don’t matha tek to name of the publisher, Raagmala etc. Some Ragis say that since we matha tek to Bhagats in Gurbani, so Bhagats too are Guru. This is totally wrong. Bhagats are Bhagats of Guru Baba jee and Guru Sahibaan are Guru Sahibaan. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Raagmala article

SS · 09 Oct 2003

Wow all of a sudden I see so many posts from rice pudding and other like minded people within 1 or 2 days. Man, you guys must belong to some cult…

Re: Raagmala article

Huh? · 09 Oct 2003

Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee contains many items that are not Gurbani but we matha tek to them too - this is a weak argument as the names of the people you are mentioned are and never were considered Bani. This is blindingy obvious to any Sikh. The controversy surrounds Raagmala. Would you bow to a gutka with Gurbani mixed with some crap from a fake sant eg his own mukh bani? Or would you attempt to separate it? Jagjit Singh said he spoke to Surinder Singh (his whole background is AKJ) - IF he contradicts what Taksal and the Nihang Samprda have believed for believed for so many years, BIG DEAL? Sikhi operates as an Ocean, not as one or two drops!

Re: Raagmala article

Kulbir Singh · 09 Oct 2003

>>>>> Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee contains many items that are not Gurbani but we matha tek to them too - this is a weak argument as the names of the people you are mentioned are and never were considered Bani. This is blindingy obvious to any Sikh. >>>> If you think this arguement is weak, how rational do you think is this argument that since you matha tek to Siri Guru Granth Sahib, you also matha tek to Raagmala and must consider it baani. This is the most childish and naive argument I have ever heard in favour of Raagmala. Each Gursikh matha teks to the Jyot of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee and to Gurbani in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Raagmala article

What's Worst? · 09 Oct 2003

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh What's worst? Finding out in the after-world that Raag Mala was Bani all along, and we went our whole lives without ever completing a reading of the Guru Granth Sahib Ji?.... or.... Finding out in the after-world that Raag Mala was not Bani all along, and we went our whole lives reading the whole Guru Granth Sahib Ji, as well as the Raag Mala in addition? MY VIEW---i'm not gonna take any chances. Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Raagmala article

RS · 09 Oct 2003

"The controversy surrounds Raagmala. Would you bow to a gutka with Gurbani mixed with some crap from a fake sant eg his own mukh bani? Or would you attempt to separate it?" Actually, many old saroops did have weird stuff added in along with raag mala. People still matha taeked to these saroops, as all of Gurbanee was also contained in these. Kulbir Singh is right on this one, it's a totally childish arguement. Guru Saahib carried around a small Guru Granth Saahib Bir in his gatra??? Do you have any dates for when this bir was written, and by whom? Historically, the small birs of Guru Saahib were printed much later on (and printed, not hand written). I've never heard of the guru's writing these in any historical account. Please provide more info on this. As far as the Kartarpuri Bir goes, it's not the AKJ that pointed out that the current bir there seems different from the one seen at earlier times. Many other scholars in the panth have pointed this out. Also, there are many differences between the Kirtarpuri Bir and the Damdami Bir. In some places, even the Mahalla (the author) of some shabds is different. Obviously, the guru's wouldn't have made such oversights.

Re: Raagmala article

{¿?}â„¢ · 09 Oct 2003

CAn any pro rag mahla people explain rag mahla in their OWN words and tell us what it is? Have any of you actually seen rag mahla? Also from conclusions drwan from kheer's posts, i have come to the conclusion that he is: 1. mona 2. eats meaat 3. hates AKJ 4. doesnt follow any rehit or he is an RSS agent wannabe, unless he can prove this wrong.

Re: Raagmala article

Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 09 Oct 2003

vaaheguru ji ka khalsa vaaheguru ji ki fateh I'm not really interested in the Raag Maala debate as in past I haven't been able to get much out of it, and neither do I think I'll gain anything in future just by arguing over it. I'm just posting this message to inform Sangatta that the writer of this article removed EVERY single line which had to do with Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji after an elderly Singh erased all of his doubts about Bhai Sahib's belief on Raag Maala and Guru mantar. The article on SikhiFM.com is an older version of this article, you can read the updated one on damdamitaksal.org if you really care. That Singh was really in doubts as whatever he wrote was according to what he had been told by other Singhs who shared same beliefs with him. and yes, I do know the Singh who wrote this article. vaaheguru ji ka khalsa vaaheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Raagmala article

jagjit singh · 10 Oct 2003

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, Some of these arguments about mattha teking are very silly. I am in no dubda matha tekking before my Guru. The fact that raagmala is printed, is a Panthic decision. It never even enters my mind when matha tekking. We live in no dubda, so please do not make up silly rubbish. The only time raagmala becomes an issue, is when some "concerned" person is trying to convert. The rest of the time we are just getting on with seva, and is never discussed. If those who are pro-raagmala are so concerened about us, then just do paath for us, rather than trying to continually convert, or manipulate things. it just makes you look more desparate. I have complete belief in my Guru, and have never had any doubts about anything, and completely thank Guru maharaj for that. Something all of you should know, whether pro or anti. In missionary circles, some Gursikhs have found out that RSS is printing saroops, in a format that makes them look old, and handwritten. This is being done in Rajistan. The Singhs have seen some pages. In this they have been adding numerous other stuff into the saroops. They know most sikhs are very fickle, and will just say, its a prataan saroop, and start doing prakah, and believing. In the next few years, these saroops will start becoming widely available. Sikhs need to be very aware as this is to sitimulate debate on Guru Granth sahib ji as there already is on dasam granth. Something to bear in mind for the future. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Raagmala article

Sikhnet · 11 Oct 2003

Ragmala The Adi Granth contains the following thirty-one ragas (in the serial order): Sri raga, Manjh, Gauri, Asa, Gujri, Devagandhari, Bihagara, Wadahans, Sorath, Dhanasri, Jaitsri, Todi, Bairari, Tilang, Suhi, Bilaval, Gond (Gaund), Ramkali, Nut-Narayan, Mali-Gaura, Maru, Tukhar, Kedara, Bhairav (Bhairo), Basant, Sarrang, Malar, Kanra, Kalyan, Prabhati and Jaijawanti. But of the above thirty-one ragas, technically fourteen are ragas and the rest are raginis. It may be noted that no distinction has been made in the Scripture between a raga and a ragini. Ragmala given at the end of the scripture gives the following eighty-four melodies. Six are male (parent) ragas; the thirty raginis are their wives and the remaining forty-eight are their sons. Ths list is as follows: (1) Bhairav raga Wives: Bhairavi, Bilawali, Punyaki, Bangli, Aslekhi. Sons: Pancham, Harakh, Disakh, Bangal, Madhu, Madhava, Lalit, Bilaval. (2) Malkaus raga Wives: Gaundkari, Devagandhari, Gandhari, Seehute, Dhanasri. Sons: Maru, Mustang, Mewara, Parbal, Chand, Khokhat, Bhora, Nad. (3) Hindol raga Wives: Telangi, Devkari, Basanti, Sindhoori, Aheeri. Sons: Surmanand, Bhasker, Chandra-Bimb, Mangalan, Ban, Binoda, Basant, Kamoda. (4) Deepak raga Wives: Kachheli, Patmanjari, Todi, Kamodi, Gujri. Sons: Kaalanka, Kuntal, Rama, Kamal, Kusum, Champak, Gaura, Kanra [36]. (5) Sri raga Wives: Bairavi, Karnati, Gauri, Asavari, Sindhavi. Sons: Salu, Sarag, Sagra, Gaund, Gambhir, Gund, Kumbh, Hamir. (6) Megh raga Wives: Sorath, Gaundi-Malari, Asa, Gunguni, Sooho. Sons: Biradhar, Gajdhar, Kedara, Jablidhar, Nut, Jaldhara, Sankar, Syama. If we compare the above scheme with the ragas of the Adi Granth, we find that only two major ragas-Sri raga and Bhairav-have been included in the Scripture. The remaining male parent ragas, namely Malkaus, Hindol, Deepak and Megh have been excluded. Sri raga is the first raga in the Scripture instead of Bhairav raga of the Ragmala. Asawari used in the Scripture as a part of Asa raga is according to ragmala the wife of Sri raga. The following eleven wives (raginis) and eight sons of the parent-ragas are included in the Scripture: Bhairavi: Son: Bilaval Malkaus: Wives: Devagandhari, Dhanasri Son: Maru Hindol: Wive: Tilang (Telangi) Son: Basant Deepak: Wives: Todi, Gujri Son: Kanra Sri Raga: Wives: Gauri, Bairavi Sons: Sarang, (Sarag), Gaund Megh: Wives: Sorath, Asa, Suhi (Sooho), Malar Sons: Nut, Kedara There is no mention of Bihagara, Wadahans, Mali-Gaura, Kalyan[37], Manjh, Jaitsri, Ramkali, Tukhari, Prabhati and Jaijawanti in Ragmala.

Re: Raagmala article

. · 12 Oct 2003

can someone explain wat is meant by the parents, wives, and sons ???? in terms of different rags?? i've neva quite understood this

Re: Raagmala article

hih · 13 Oct 2003

what is a raag? and a ragini people who do kirtan? huh:S:S:S:S

Re: Raagmala article

Soorma · 13 Oct 2003

I believe in Raag Malla, becuase it is gurbani. The real reason, why people are so upset is gurbani. People think if you do take this out, this is setting up events in motion that will harm the Sikh panth. Consider Teja Bhasaur, who started printing uncomplete Sri Guru Granth Sahiabs missing various parts of Bhagata di bani. Bani is Bani, in fact if you dont' recite, abdee marzi.. Lets actually try to get more Sikhs [especially mona brothers back into the fold]. I think Goras would laugh at us, over these idiotic stuff. To all the Pro/Anti -Raag mala people, lets forget about this. Move on, talk on issues that matter more. The Panth will resolve this situation, as the youth it is our duty to encourage our brothers/sisters to stop nashai,drugs and back to the Sikh fold. I know the admin will continue to post these type of topics for no apparent reason, I suggest a complete ban. Lets work for Panthic unity, if the Akal Takhat says you can recite it or not. It is fine. Akal Takhat Mahan hai Sikh Quam da Jaan hai

Re: Raagmala article

My First and Last post · 13 Oct 2003

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguroo Jee Kee Fathe What I have got from hearing about Raag Mala over the past year (not just from Tapoban, except for the message board and their research papers) Pro - Raag Mala All Taksal Jathedars: including Baba Deep Singh ji Baba Gurbachan Singh ji Baba Kartar Singh ji Baba Jarnail Singh ji Baba Takhur Singh ji Furthermore, Bhai Sahib Mani Singh ji Bhai Gurdas Ji (Sorry if I forgot anybody) Anti - Raag Mala All AKJ: including Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji (Sorry if neglected anybody) All in favor for conflict over Raag Mala: Indian Government: including Zaalim Indira Gandhi Zaalim Nehru (sorry this list is too long to mention) oh I almost forgot the most obvious: our overeducated Sikh Youth (Don't worry, I am included in this) I have to stay optimistic about the future of Sikhi, you all (Sikhs) are contributors to this Future, I pretty sure I know my Future: hell-bound [stuck in 8.4 million reincarnation cycle] (unless Akal Purakh showers his Mercy on me)...but I thought I would save you from the same mistake. I know that this post won't stop the threads on getting longer and longer.......so why bother? Maybe it's the poison of my past that pushes me, only Akal Purakh knows I apologize too those beloved Gursikhs who might waste their time reading this, b/c this is all my manmat (it's me trying to act like I know something). Please have the heart to forgive me for all the wrong I have said This post is my last Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Dhan Dhan Guru Saroop Sat-Sangat Jee

Re: Raagmala article

Mkhalsa · 14 Oct 2003

To say that Baba Deep Singh, Bhai Gurdas Jee, Bhai Mani Singh Jee beleived in raag mala in my opinion is wrong and misguided. We dont know. If its not bani, they had guru sahib to ask in person and im sure they wouldnt have beleived in it. If it is bani then they would have, but i doubt that. So we cant just say someone in the past beleived in such and such unless u have proof.

Re: Raagmala article

Khalsa Soulja · 14 Oct 2003

Most people in the early 1900s did not believe in Ragmalla. Do yur research.........99% of the Singh Sabha founders did not see it as Gurbani!

Re: Raagmala article

domalla premee · 14 Oct 2003

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Guru peearo, Can we please move on? Arguing about this till we are blue in the face is counter-productive especially since there are far graver Panthic concern. There are people challenging the validity of the Akal Takhat for one and the entire ethos of Sikhi. What are you doing about it? Please set aside your differences and move on to something more constructive. Admins the info is out there, I request that you now close this thread. It is going nowhere fast. dass and member of the sangat