Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

PM bowing to Hindu Priest

PM bowing to Hindu Priest

KS · 19 Aug 2005

In this weeks Sikh Times a newspaper published in the the UK, there is a picture of Manmohan Singh bowing and touching the feet of a Hindu priest, whilst LK Advani stands next to him. I thought Sikhs could bow only to the Siri Guru Granth Sahib?

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

..... · 19 Aug 2005

i wouldn't say bowing, but more touching a pandits feet i too was shocked but thats politics... right?????

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

anonymous · 19 Aug 2005

SIMPLE FACT - MANMOHAN IS NOT A TRUE SIKH.

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

ASengh aka "boongawala" · 19 Aug 2005

SIMPLE FACT - MANMOHAN IS NOT A SIKH AT ALL.

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

Mehtab Singh · 19 Aug 2005

There was a post on sikhsangat on this issue few months ago. Here is the link : http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=11350&hl=Swami+Narayan And here is my response from page 2 of that thread: [i]does anyone even know who is that saint he is touching the feet of? he swami narayan from gujarat...i've met the saint who was his predecessor some 8 yrs back, and have also met other saints from their sect...few weeks back one of them came to my house on the wishes of my parents (they r hindus so dont take a heart attack already), and while his followers sat on the floor, he made me sit next to him, why? his respect for Sikhs n Sikhi !...these people have nothing to do with any crap thats gotten into hinduism, and they have NEVER asked any non-Hindu who comes to their keertan to become a Hindu...ppl need to go and do some research before making any comments... and ya, i dont think there is anything wrong touching feet of elders or holy ppl (well, truely genuine holy ones)...i touch feet of my elders who are not even Sikh...and if there is a holy person who i know is a genuine one, i wont hesitate to touch their feet no matter what faith he/she is from...it kills ur hankaar n haumai...and gives u a chance to see God in all... we need to get rid of "Hindu phobia" ![/i] And this from page 3 [i]Lets not judge anyone's Sikhi. I am not very much aware of what Manmohan Singh has done for Sikhs. Being a Congressia, he can't do much even if he wants to. The point is that being a Sikh is no excuse/license to NOT respect saints of other faiths and claim your or your faith's superiority over others. Lets not forget the nimarta of Guru Ram Das Jee, who was asked by Baba Srichand as to why He had such a long beard, to which Gurujee replied "To wipe the dust from the holy feet of the saints like you". This is our Gurujee and this is us, arguing over a picture.[/i] Besides, a good number of forum members over here may have an opinion that Manmohan Singh isn't a proper Sikh, if so, then why bother what he does?

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

double boonga wala · 20 Aug 2005

he is a prime minister boyz, leaders have to do things. even tony blair and prince charles visit mosques in uk and wear customery gear with muslims to show respect. Thats what leaders in politics do. POolitics is a religion by itself. Even raja ranjit singh had to be kosher with the masses. Thats life. Unless there is a raj where religion and state rule together things will always be like that. If your not kosher with your subjects you loose out. If theres a hindu prime minister of punjab you will probably find him going gujrdwara. Same for a pm in surrey. thats just how it is.

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

CAT · 20 Aug 2005

SIMPLE FACT - MANMOHAN WORKS FOR HINDUSTAN

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Aug 2005

aava ooot giyaa.... why do you all think sonia made him pm ?? in ordert o give your paltoo kutta full freedom to roam your house you must have full faith in his..kookarness...pm is just proving that to his masters that he is very very paltoo..SHAME on such Paltoos. IN MALAYSIA once a Gursikh was taken along by other such "paltoo gursikhs" to a Offical dinner at a Tamil minister's Residence. the Gursikh found to his horror that the Hindu Swami Ji invited there was chewing his food and spitting it out back on to his plate...which was then passed around the table for the other guests to spoon out to be mixed into their own food...and the "paltoo gursikhs...prominent ones at that.." happily lapped it up..the Gursikh had the guts to stand up and walk out..incurring the wrath of that minister but what the heck...( he never got invited again..but he wasnt interested anyway !!) a so called solid "guru Gobind Singh Ji's maryada follower who derided sgpc maryada as "fudoo" was one of those who lapped up this swami's parsad...no wonder he was often called to perform kirtan/ etc at this minister's house !!! you never know what comes up under all those white cholas and round pugghs..!!! Jarnail singh

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

kabadi · 20 Aug 2005

wats wrong with touching someones feet out of respect??? we shouldnt matha tek to anyone... but we touch the feet of our elders all the time.... why not the feet of a religious person? just a question

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

singh · 20 Aug 2005

This Gujarat Hindu sect Swami Narayan has close links to the RSS. The Uk government investigated them for sending earthquake money to the RSS. http://www.milligazette.com/Archives/15022001/Art01.htm Bhuj/Anjar: Relief operations in the Kutch district of Gujarat have taken a communal colour. The RSS and VHP cadres have set up relief camps in temples and largely Hindu-dominated areas of the Kutch. They have ignored Muslim populated areas like Anjar. The religious divide in relief operations is evident in the way food is being proffered in community kitchens. The largest community kitchen in Bhuj town is functioning in Swaminarayan temple in the Nirmal Singh Wadi locality. Here puris, potato curry, bread and khichdi are offered to anyone who walks into the langar (community kitchen). There are kind words and encouragement to eat well as one stands in the queue. However, for members of the minority community queuing up for food, the battle is between hunger and faith. Their lives, irreparably damaged by the monstrous earthquake, now have to contend with matters of faith. Residents of Bhuj, belonging to minority communities are being asked to chant ‘Jai Swami Narayan’ or ‘Jai Shri Ram’ by the RSS and VHP cadres, as they queue up for food in relief centres run by these organizations. Unfortunately, most of the major relief operations, launched by the government and private Gujarati relief operations, are being manned by RSS and VHP cadres.

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

dil · 20 Aug 2005

Fateh, After reading all the posts, I came to conclusion that as per all you, true amritdhari gursikh should have been PM. That cannot be possible in near future. Even in punjab also you cannot have true amritdhari gursikh as chief minister. As I understand till date I am not able to find any amritdhari gursikh got gallantry awards in defence. I also consider that to become a true gursikh is very difficult. PM has to fulfil the comitment of his position. He has to respect all the faiths. If you want every one to respect our way of life then first start from home. It is not a question of your personal faith. Bye now

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

Indy D · 20 Aug 2005

Get off your high horses and look past such ego and haankar. In india and especially in places outside of punjab touching the feet of elders is respect and humbling oneself in front of elders. And what gives you the right to have a dig at another Guru jee?? Kalyug is stronger than ever at the moment and some guru jees are sent to help.. not become a idol but to help certain souls. Guru Gobind Singh Jees panth was one of humbleness, pyaar, satkar.... What bigotry do you speak. Hindustan is what? Huh? Guru Gobind Singh Jee fought for the liberation of Hindustan did they not? Yes we bow to nobody, no idol, but the wisdom of the lord themselves, Shri Guru Granth Shaib Jee. Open your eyes wide, and see what you are doing to yourselves. Kaam krodh lobh choot ninda..... inte aap chadovoh!!

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

**- · 20 Aug 2005

The reactions on this thread are so predictable. Most Hindu do not have a problem touching the feet of Sikh sants and Nirmalas. In fact many Hindus would flock to Baba Nand Singh and touch his feet. They didn't think 'Oh this Sant is a Sikh Sant, so we should not touch his feet' but rather thought 'He is a Man of God, let me touch his feet'. Speaking for myself, if I were to see a spitually advanced Sikh person, I would not hesitate one bit in touching his/her feet - even if I didn't fully agree with their philisophy. Anyway that is me, each of us are different I suppose. Cheers, Sitara [%sig%]

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

Me · 20 Aug 2005

Ooooh, I didnt know we had the power to decide who was a Sikh and who wasn't, let's kick him out of the club yeah..can I add some more names of people I dont like to excommunicate from the Panth too?

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

AA · 20 Aug 2005

Ok, so the PM has to show respect for everyone but he shouldnt go has far has matha tekking. A handshake and a hug is good enough.

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Aug 2005

Author: Me Date: 08-20-05 13:22 Ooooh, I didnt know we had the power to decide who was a Sikh and who wasn't, let's kick him out of the club yeah..can I add some more names of people I dont like to excommunicate from the Panth too? <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Am I on your list for excommunication ?? JS

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

dosanjh kalan · 21 Aug 2005

why do you all have a problem with manmohan singh touching the feet of some guy when millions of other sikhs do the same? he is a leader of a country, thats part of his job. If you had a sikh leader of a 90% muslim country what do you think the sikh leader would do to for his country? Singho face facts first dont let the passion rise beyond common sense the man is a leader with responsibility to his people. Can you imagine the clashes this guy would come across betyween following gurmat and leading a 90% nation that is not sikh? We should first look at what our very own khalistani leaders did and do with the indian bjps before we jump against manmohan. I can think of many names but will name none but leave you with a hint "burning punjab.com" sukhbir singh osan RIP for telling the truth of our kahlistani leaders . remember rfemember brothers how our own sold us out.

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

Me · 21 Aug 2005

Yes.

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Aug 2005

Author: Me Date: 08-21-05 14:15 Yes. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> I hereby nominate "ME" for Akal takaht Jathedar...so that he can excommunicate me..and all others that think like me. ( PUN not intended !!) JS

Re: PM bowing to Hindu Priest

Me · 22 Aug 2005

*rolls eyes*, too much free time.