Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

Jasmin · 18 Aug 2005

I understand that Namdhari don't take armit. Could someone explain how Namdhari initiate as Sikhs and the history behind this difference. Also I would a list of Namdhari and non- Namdhari gurdwaras in the Northeast U.S. if possible. Vahiguru.

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

yup · 18 Aug 2005

From what i've been told by a well known Namdhari is that all Namdhari's MUST recieve the gift of Amrit blessed by Guru Gobind Singh Ji , iv been told there is no question in this BUT they don't wear an actual Kirpan anymore, they say we live in safe times therefoe the Kirpan is usually a miniture one ie in the Kesh or around the neck, Sikhs on the other hand don't believe any-one has the authority to change the Kakaars Guru Ji gave to us. So to your question how do Namdhari's initiate, well i reckon you will have to recieve Amrit from Namdhari Punj Pyare but i think you'll have to ask a Namdhari

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

Hari Singh · 18 Aug 2005

yup jee, Your explanation seems contradictory. Namdharis' have a guy they believe is the living guru. Why would they take amrit from "punj pyare" when this guy is still alive. Namdharis', radhaswami's and nirakari's etc. etc. have no relation to the house of Nanak and thus whatever their initiation ceremony might be, it can't be called Amrit sanchar. They definitely can't make amrit.

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

Sarabjot Kaur · 18 Aug 2005

And have a look at this too. http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=12441&t=12441 May waheguru ji bless you to understand sikhi in the true sense.

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

mmmm · 18 Aug 2005

naamdhari's dont take amrit. they dont believe in the guru's past guru arjan dev ji, so are totally pacifists. they wear white dastaars, off the ears, with rows of lines covering their foreheads usually. nice people.

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

Singh · 18 Aug 2005

Namdharis do believe in Gurus past Guru Arjan. I don't know where you go the idea that they don't. They used to have a very strict amrit sinchar ceremony and naam driR that they kept very secret. Since then, I believe they still have a ceremony they call "amrit" and it has "punj pyare" but it's pretty much a farce. They use any bowl of any substance and of course they pledge allegiance to their leader, Jagjit Sinh. They are not Sikhs and their "amrit" is not the Amrit of Dashmesh Pita.

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

khalsa · 18 Aug 2005

Namdhari's guru Baba Ram Singh was a puran gursikh. He believed in 10 sikh gurus and guru granth sahib as well. He never declared himself to be a guru. He became a political figure when he declared non co-operation movement against the british raj in india and asked all sikh/punjabis not to use any british goods. He was exiled to rangoon. Baba Ram Singh went back to the original teachings of Guru Nanak Dev Ji and Guru Gobind Singh Ji and introduced baptism ceremony to reinforce people's faith in the original tenets of Sikh religion. His followers after his death declared him as their guru and started new line of guruship. They were encouraged and supported by the Nehur family to create friction between sikhs. Now all Namdharias believe in living guru and take their own so called amrit. [%sig%]

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

manjh payara guru ko · 18 Aug 2005

they are agent of RAW. [%sig%]

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

sevak · 18 Aug 2005

Hari singh you said, Why would they take amrit from "punj pyare" when this guy is still alive. ------------------------------------------------------------- Was their not punj pyaray when Guru gobind singh ji was still alive, Is there not a living Guru now, Guru Grath sahib ji................... simply a weak response.

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

Bhopinder Singh · 19 Aug 2005

We as sikhs are not intolrant of anybody but we should be allowed the freedom of religion .We never distort any faith ,But a faith solely based and bent upon distorting any faith is spreading voilence in a society. Let them do what ever they want .They have themselves left Sikhi and even changed their name to Namdhari . British have used the same weapon against the Irish they divided the Irish on the basis of religion ( protestant and catholic) and now the same weapon could be used against them they are going for peace. Same way in Iraq the Shias have Brits and the Sunis Americans its basically a ploy to attack the very reason of strength (faith) and make a strong enemey weak,similarly in Afghanistan at the moment. Cohesive nations like Vietnam and China have not only fought but also defeated them without weapons and atomic weapons.The reason for them to spread sepratist campaign in Tibet and Tiawan. They are the people who attacked the very strength when we were fighting them and almost beat them as we were fighting cohesively. They were looking for divisions which were not their ( were political but none in faith) and the faith helped them produce the first non voilent movement the brits had no answer and were left clueless for hoe to fight them the reason for them starting factions in us and the following non Sikh govts just took over.

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

Guru Manyo Granth · 19 Aug 2005

All Sikhs believe in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji as the eternal Guru. Namdharis believe in a temporary individual who claims to be a "guru". There is a difference. You either want to follow the latest individual, I think his name is Jagit Singh Matharu as your "guru" or the eternal jyot of Akal Purakh SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI. I was born into a Naamdhari family and grew up in the environment. As far as I know they did not give me amrit but wispered in my ear. I was later blessed with Khanday Batay Da Amrit by the Punj Pyaray from the KHALSA panth. Believe me, I never felt like a complete Sikh when I was wthin a Naamdhari sangat and felt a lack of focus.

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

Hari Singh · 19 Aug 2005

Guru Gobind Singh jee started the instituation of punj pyare and gave punj pyare equal status to himself and he declared guru granth sahib maharaj the guru. My point was simply stating that when punj pyare in hazoori of guru granths sahib jee do an amrit sanchar then that is real amrit. If you belive in anyone else's authority then you are misled. No man / women alive can claim status of satguru and those who do falsely claim this will rot in hell.

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

A Singh · 19 Aug 2005

manjh payara guru ko, mmmm, Hari Singh and others, Please actually research your facts before simply telling lies. I am not in agreement with the Namdhari present outlook on many points, but they are not in the same group as Radhosoami and Nirankaris - the Akal Thakt have ruled these groups out but have not given Namdharis the same treatment. Baba Ram Singh went to lengths to do Amrit Sanchar across Punjab and effectively brought masses back to the Khalsa Rehit (he was extremely strict in his Nitnem and Simran) and to this date retain their prowess in Raag Sangeet - also contrary to the peaceful image, visit their Akhara and one can see that Shastars are still respected and Gatka praticed. The end result is not too disimilar to that discussed under the trend concerning Baba Ajaipal Singh - clearly a chardi-kala Gur Sikh at a time when all Singhs were sad following the departure of Guru Sahib, slowly some became hung up on his personalities (much like others today do on Sants, Babas, Jathedars, Singh Sahibs and Bhai Sahibs) and over time began to think of him as Guru Gobind Singh returned. This is nothing surprising, it happens today still, although not everyone openly calls someone "Guru" despite treating them as such. All the supporters of Gyani Gyan Singh Dulat should also read his views on Namdharis. For a good account of Namdharis, see Fateh Singh Bajwa's The Kuka Movement. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

Hari Singh · 19 Aug 2005

Speculation on history is endless and we only have gurbani as the eternal truth. The fact is that believing in a living human guru while claiming to be Sikhs is maha manmatt. It is a disgusting and dispicable act. Ofcouse those who follow someone out of ignorace can't be compltely held accountable and can be forgiven.

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

. · 19 Aug 2005

Its the mothimalas tha dont believe in the Gurus past Guru Arjan Dev ji

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

?? · 23 Aug 2005

like baba ram singh, given time 3rd or 4th generation of followers of sant jarnail singh bhinderanwale and bhai randhir singh ji will treat these great peosonalities as guru of their jathebandi. just wait and see. [%sig%]

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

confused · 23 Aug 2005

?? jee i wouldnt even be surprised

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

khalistani · 23 Aug 2005

wat kind of logic is tha ?? sant je himself has in audio talked strongly agasint pakhandee gurus and we allknow bhai randheer singh je belvied in guru granth sahib je only if it ws like wat ure saying, then y dont some singhs belive in sant baba gurbachan singh je, or sant sundar singh je as there guru? y not belive in baba bishan singh je as gur then? no one is gonna blive sant je or bhai sahib as guru everyone knows there were gurmukhs, and they oppsed dehdharee gurus bhula chuka maf

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

Khalsa · 24 Aug 2005

khalistani ji i'm not a namdhari and i don't treat baba ram singh ji as a guru' please don't take it wrongly. Baba ram singh believed in guru granth sahib ji and never said that he is a guru. those who followed him started to treat him as a guru many many years after his death. I'm not saying that people will treat sant ji or bhai sahib ji as guru, soon ,but after 3-4 generations. please read this; Baba Ram Singh was born at village Bhaini Raiyan, district Ludhiana on the 3rd February, 1816 A.D. His father Bhai Jassa Singh, was a carpenter. His brother-in-law, Sardar Kabul singh was a gunner in the artillery of Maharaja Ranjit Singh. In 1837 A.D., He took Baba Ram Singh with him to Lahore and got him recruited in the regiment of Kanwar Naunihal Singh. On the 18th December, 1845 A.D. the Sikh army suffered a defeat in the battle of Mudki due to mean settlement of some Dogra Generals of Sikh army with British. Baba Ram Singh could not bear the defeat of the Sikh army in this manner. He left the service of the army at Mudki and came straight to his village Bhaini. On arrival at his village, Baba Ram Singh started preaching, "Worship of eternal Being, giving up worship of the dead, keeping off the intoxicants, giving up meat, minimum expenditure on marriages and widow remarriage etc." He used to say, "I am only a messenger or a reporter and not a guru." His followers starting calling themselves 'Namdharis'. Baba Ram Singh was a supporter of reform of the 'Mahants' and priests of the gurudwaras as a result of which they were against him. Every year, on the occasion of Diwali or Baisakhi fairs he used to go to Amritsar and put his views before the congregation. The number of his audience used to touch twenty thousand. He started a movement in 1848 A.D., to force the British to leave India. He called upon his followers to boycott foreign goods and Government departments due to which people stopped buying imported cloth, gave up taking their disputes to courts and started deciding these in villages. The boycott movement of Baba Ram Singh had great effect on the work of the Government. In 1863 A.D., the Government setup a police post at his village Bhaini. Cow Slaughter was banned in Amritsar during Sikh rule. In 1870 somebody spread a false rumor in Amritsar that the Government was about to give permission to the butchers to slaughter cows in the holy city of the Guru. On the 14th June, 1870 A.D., a group of Namdharis beheaded four butchers at Amritsar. Four Namdharis were hanged and two were imprisoned for life for that crime. On the 15th July, 1872 A.D., some Namdharis had quarrel with the butchers of Malaud and Malerkotla over cow-slaughter in which ten people were killed and seventeen were injured. The deputy commissioner of Ludhiana, Mr. Crown pronounced death sentence on sixty-eight Namdharis. Forty-nine of them were blown by cannon fire and nineteen were hanged. Baba Ram singh was exiled to Burma. He went to his heavenly abode on the 29th November, 1885 A.D., in jail of Margee Island. Although the Government crushed the Namdhari movement, yet they could not extinguish the light of freedom lit by Baba Ram Singh. [%sig%]

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

RoopKaur · 24 Aug 2005

>like baba ram singh, given time 3rd or 4th generation of followers of sant jarnail singh bhinderanwale and bhai randhir singh ji will treat these great peosonalities as guru of their jathebandi. just wait and see.< These two maha purshes do not have followers since they were not gurus. THey do have people who look up to them because of their strong gurmat principles and belief in tat gurmat despite the dhills in the panth. So those who follow their footsteps for their gurmat ways will never think of them as gurus because this is manmat, but it is possible that those who are caught up in bipran kee reet and do not know much about Sikhi will overlook the strict adherence to gurmat of these individuals and start thinking of them as gurus. These people cannot be called their "followers" since these individuals promoted gurmat, and these people will be following manmat.

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

Jasmin · 24 Aug 2005

From what I'm reading it seems as if the Namdharis have some admirable qualities. Yet I don't see enough reason to became Namdhari. Maybe it's the slant of this massage broad, but it seems more logical to be mainstream. That just my intuition.

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

Sakhi · 24 Aug 2005

Jasmin, You must remember that Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharah is our only eternal living Guru, our Satguru. To be a good sikh we must adhere to the teachings of only the true Guru. I would encourage you to seek guidance from Guru Granth Sahib Ji don't fall into the traps of the countless self-proclaiming human Guru's.

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

khalistani · 24 Aug 2005

how can a human be guru when guru gobind singh je said no more dehdharee gurus are allowed after me? wat bout when they gave gurgaddi to guru granth sahib je? doesnt that mean anything to anyone how can one cross the ocean of maya on 2 boats the bohith of kaljug is dhan dhan guru granth sahib je maharaj they are guru they will always be guru guru gobind singh jes bachans, our ithihaas, is clear, guru granth sahib je is guru no man can fill that place even in purataan ithihaas, many pakhandees tried to take place of guru some tried to take place of guru tegh bahadur je, when no one knew who the guru was guru jes own brother tried so many people have tried but its always know who is guru guru is guru granth sahib je no man no matter how highly spirtual he is sants may jaap naam but guru je is the one who gives it to them guru je is th CREATOR of all sants sants are no where near guru je guru je is supreme banee is surpreme there is no need for a man to guide u, when akaal sits there in the roop of gurshabad bhula chuka maf

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 25 Aug 2005

Khalistani Veer...with you 100%. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> From the previous post... "Slaughter of cows was banned in Amrtisar.... but what about HUKKAHS and Tobacco smoking ?? Tobacco is a Bujjer Kurehit..!!! for Sikhs.. Thats why the namdahrees broke ranks with the SIKHS.....and the killing of the cow butchers did not raise any sympathy among the general sikh population. Now cow slaughter is so common in HINDU INDIA..90% of BEEF sold in MALAYSIA is INDIAN BEEF !!.. And Amrtisar is still full of Tobacco Smoke !! Must always Serve ones own religious Principles first..imho.. Jarnail Singh.

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

Jasmin · 25 Aug 2005

Dear Sakhi- I agree with you. Maybe I didn't make myself clear. Dear Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi"- I'm not that fond of either smoking, or butchering. Yet I would rather attempt to convert people to Sikhi then kill them.

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

ksingh · 25 Aug 2005

wjkk wjkf why namdharis fought with the butchers over cow slaughter.why not they fought over chicken or goat slaughter. bhul chuk maaf

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

cyberkhalsa · 25 Aug 2005

Here's a thought: How about conversing with a Namdhari Singh before making assumptions about them. I'm sure you wouldn't appreciate it if someone were to make assumptions about tapoban if they didn't know anything about it. It seems like common sense is a rare commodity these days......................

Re: Initiation- Namdhari vs. other Sikhs

Jasmin · 26 Aug 2005

Dear Cyberkhalsa- Please feel free to sure your views. I base my opinions on information, so the more the better!