Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikhs being forced to wear Helmet in CP rail

Sikhs being forced to wear Helmet in CP rail

Kulbir Singh · 16 Aug 2005

I just got a call from a Singh who is concerned about a situation in Toronto. Some Sikhs working in CP rail are being coerced to wear a helmet. They have heard that in Vancouver Sikhs work in CP rail but are not required to wear a helmet. Could someone provide this information as soon as possible. Also you can contact Jaspreet Singh at 416-689-9409. Kulbir Singh

Re: Sikhs being forced to wear Helmet in CP rail

KhalsaJee · 17 Aug 2005

Veer jee this is true that singhs in Bc have not worn hard hats. I know that 2 yrs ago they did not wear hard hats, but this could have changed. Another note, cp did try to change there safety standards a few years back and singhs at that time fought for the right of not wearing the hat, so i think they will once again have to fight for this right. On a small note alot of these PUNJABI mundai that goto CP yard have the tendency to wear small dastars or parnai, this maybe there concern too. Veer Jaspreet Singh always has a dumalla on and i've seen alot of other singhs with full dastars, so i think this issue should be brought up too. The smaller the dastar, the more tendency of getting hurt (safety factor)

Sikhs protest hard-hat rule

Toronto Star · 25 Aug 2005

Sikhs protest hard-hat rule CP Rail wants drivers to take off turbans, put on safety gear Group plans to go to Ontario Human Rights Commission NICHOLAS KEUNG IMMIGRATION/DIVERSITY REPORTER A group of Sikh truck drivers is set to lodge a human rights complaint today against Canadian Pacific Railway, over the enforcement of a regulation requiring them to wear safety hard hats on the job in lieu of their turbans. The estimated 500 Punjabi drivers, contracted by various companies to unload and pick up containers, were outraged when they were banned from accessing CP Rail's two Greater Toronto terminals two weeks ago under a memo issued Aug. 1 to enforce the rule. "We fought for the Brits in the First and Second World Wars wearing turbans," said Major Singh, 32, who has worked at the rail terminals for seven years. "There have been no incidents of drivers being injured at the site. This is uncalled for. It completely violates our freedom of religion. This is discrimination." Paul Thurston, a spokesman for CP Rail, said the company has stepped up enforcement of the regulation out of safety concerns. The drivers — about 70 per cent of them wearing the traditional attire required by their religion — protested the rule by staging a four-hour job-stoppage on Monday at CP Rail's yards in Vaughan and Etobicoke. "Please be advised that as per CPR's Safety Policy, all drivers required to enter CPR property as well as customer locations are required to wear a hard hat. There are no exceptions to this policy," the memo reads. "We understand that this might be a concern for some drivers who are required to wear turbans as part of their religious doctrine.... There is zero tolerance at CPR with regards to this requirement." Even though CP Rail doesn't collect statistics on on-site injuries among truck drivers, Thurston said, "We have total respect for religious and ethnic diversity, but it is possible that someone can be struck by objects on the yards." In response to the drivers' protest, the company has granted a two-month grace period before enforcement is fully implemented. CP Rail has suggested the issue could be resolved by asking men to remove one of the two parts of the six-metre-long turbans: the five-metre "overturban" on top of the "underturban." "Without the overturban, protective headwear may sit comfortably on the worker's head and provide the required protection," said an accompanying advisory. But Singh, a representative for the drivers, said they are not happy with management's reply and will pursue their complaint to the Ontario Human Rights Commission this morning. It's not the first time turbans have become an issue of debate in Canada's rail industry. In 1978, a Sikh man was fired from the CN yards on Spadina Ave. for refusing to replace his turban with a hard hat. Despite a Canadian Human Rights Commission decision that found that the complainant had been discriminated against, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled seven years later that employers do not violate human rights law when they prohibit Sikhs from wearing turbans on the job. [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs being forced to wear Helmet in CP rail

kaur · 25 Aug 2005

"They have heard that in Vancouver Sikhs work in CP rail but are not required to wear a helmet." This is not true, my father has worked for CP Railway in BC for 25+ years and he says that sardars are required to wear hard hats over top of their dastaars when in the yard, regardless of their position. They made extra large hard hats to fit over the dastaar. He mentioned that it is not such a bad thing, since the majority of sardaars don't wear dumallay, their heads aren't protected anyways. They wear the boat style dastaar with no protection to the top part of their heads. He recalls an employee at his workplace being pierced through the head with a sharp iron rod once. [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs being forced to wear Helmet in CP rail

Kaura Singh · 25 Aug 2005

Kaur DO not misled and discourage singhs and their supporters fighting this battle by throwing this -ve stuff. We need courage and courage need courage. [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs being forced to wear Helmet in CP rail

Singh · 25 Aug 2005

Kaur , your Father has sacrificed sikhi principles. Since when has khalsa been able to put Topi's on their head. Theres no justification for it. Extra large helmet or not. its still a helmet. Go Singhs Go!! Chuk deh Phatey!

Re: Sikhs being forced to wear Helmet in CP rail

Manjot Singh Khalsa · 25 Aug 2005

While I agree with you Singh, attacking Kaur bhenji and her father in such a way is not a gursikhi attitude either. It sounds as if you are snapping at her. A better way to put it might be, bhenji, rehatnamas say that a sikh should never wear a topi (hat). In fact, one rehatnama says that any Sikh who wears a hat will travel through seven hells. Please advise your father on this and the choice is up to you. I think we need to bring some pyar back into our lives singho, while in punjab I noticed that the few gursikhs there are, love each other, the youth especially didnt seem to have such negative attitudes. I think forums are the number one reason us youth in the west fight and bicker and have such negative attitudes towards one another. Lets discuss with love, and if we still dont agree, so be it. Sorry for taking this off topic. Something should be done about the toronto situation.

Re: Sikhs being forced to wear Helmet in CP rail

kaur · 26 Aug 2005

I have not given any support to pro-hard hats views. I have merely made mention of the fact that it is not true that sardaars in vancouver never had to wear hard hats. I am totally against the idea and support the Singh's fighting this battle. I don't see how clarifying which rules are in effect in vancouver is making me throw a negative light into this issue. My father wasn't a Sikh when he worked in CP, since he stopped working there, he has kept his kes and was given Amrit. At no time did he support hard hats, all he said was that wearing hard hats over impractical dastaars would make more sense to protect one's head. Which makes sense when you think about it, a dastaar should be practical not a show piece. Dumallay are much more practical in this type of workplace. Perhaps the Veer's fighting this battle can demonstrate the different types of dastaars to CP and show how certain ones are more protective than others. [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs being forced to wear Helmet in CP rail

bhai sahib singh · 26 Aug 2005

wear it like old nihangs sarbloo bataaa and a dastaar