Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Pronunciation

Pronunciation

student · 15 Aug 2005

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa, Waheguroo Jee Ke Fateh I was listening to the Nitnem mp3 files on this site and had a question to ask about the words jor and sabad. Why is jor pronounced with a z sound (zor) instead of the j sound? And why is sabad pronounced as shabad when it is written as sabad. Could someone please explain this to me… trying to learn. Thank you [%sig%]

Re: Pronunciation

Tera Baap · 15 Aug 2005

my question to you is whats a sabad?

Re: Pronunciation

... · 15 Aug 2005

There are no bindis in Gurmukhi (as opposed to Punjabi which has created letters with bindis at the feet like Sh, Zz, etc.). In Gurmukhi, the reader automatically pronounced a Sussa as Shh and Jujaa as Zzz where it was necessary. An example from a non Gurbani Gurmukhi source is Shah Mohammed's Jungnama where he writes his name as "Saah Mohammed" if you don't pronounce it as Shh. Jor was pronounced as Zor before because we have Baba Zoravar Singh not Joravar Singh. It's just common sense to pronounce the bindis. It's Shabad not Sabad, shaabaash not saabaas.

Re: Pronunciation

ASengh · 16 Aug 2005

I'm always confused about this topic. How do you pronounce Gurbani? Too many times I have changed from saying shabad then start saying sabad etc. It makes no sence to change the words of Gurbani to suit you. [gurbani]AKr ilKy syeI gwvw Avr n jwxw bwxI ]1] rhwau ][/gurbani] I have sunthiya classes but even he adds the bindis in. Someone explain. [%sig%]

Re: Pronunciation

Kulbir Singh · 16 Aug 2005

Gurmukhi has 35 alphabets. Punjabi has 41. Sounds are more than 35 but alphabets for Gurmukhi are only 35. So to address this, some alphabets in Gurmukhi have two sounds namely – sassa and shasha, jajja and zazza, Fafa and Phapha etc. Lalla has two sounds i.e. one of Galaan (galbaat) and one of Galee (street). Ones who try to read Gurmukhi the way they have learned Punjabi, pronounce it wrongly. Ones who can read Gurmukhi as Gurmukhi and not as Punjabi, know that some alphabets have more than one sound. The word is Shaant and not Saant. The real word is Shabad and not Sabad. Bindiyaan in Gurmukhi are not written as often as in Punjabi. Bindiyaan are used to make plurals out of singular nouns and for plurals verbs. Bindiyaan (nasal sound) come out naturally when Gursikhs pronounce them. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh has written on the subject of bindiyaan extensively in his book – Gurbani diyaan Lagaan Maatraan dee Vilakhantaa. Please refer to that for more details. As for this pankiti that you have quoted Asengh jeeo, it has totally different meaning. It means that I only read the words that Guru Sahib has written. I don’t know any other baani. Professor Sahib Singh has done the meaning of this pankiti as I sing only those word that you have written, O Vaheguru i.e. I do that work that has been written in my Karma. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Pronunciation

student · 16 Aug 2005

Where can I find "Gurbani diyaan Lagaan Maatraan dee Vilakhantaa"?

Re: Pronunciation

Kulbir Singh · 16 Aug 2005

Sacha Sauda bookstore in toronto has it.

Re: Pronunciation

Harpartap Singh · 17 Aug 2005

Gurmuki script has 35 letters because Guru intended to only use those 35 sounds. No further letters should be added based on modern day Panjabi . The scripts preceding Gurmukhi had fewer vowels so Guru expanded these i.e. In addition, Guru ji was aware that Devnagri script used for Sanskrit had additional letters for different types of sounds i.e. 3 'l's, 2 types of 'sh'. All you have to do is look at Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji for Bawa Akhri. If Guru had wanted to, he would have added additional letters for 'sh', 'l' and 'z'. Gurmukhi letters were devised by Guru Himself. It is illogical to say that Guru ji would remedy some defects in the existing scripts but not others.

Re: Pronunciation

ASengh · 17 Aug 2005

Still makes no sence to me.

Re: Pronunciation

ASengh · 17 Aug 2005

I can understand Kulbir Singh piont of view better then Harpartap Singh's view. Harpartap Singh jee what you on about?

Re: Pronunciation

RoopKaur · 17 Aug 2005

Harpartap Singh, Thr fact is that sassa not having a bindi is not a defect, that is the way it was used in the past, it had two sounds. The sassa pair bindi we find in modern punjabi is a recent thing, before these letters all had two sounds, like the c in english. It could either be the k sound like in call or the s sound like in cell. This is not a defect, but a part of gurmukhi language that these letters have two sounds. It is important to realise that punjabi and gurmukhi are different, and not get them both mixed up. We should not read the Gurmukhi using the measures of the Punjabi script.

Re: Pronunciation

ASengh aka "boongawala" · 17 Aug 2005

Do we have proof that sassa or jujja had 2 sounds when Gurmukhi was created?

Re: Pronunciation

Kulbir Singh · 17 Aug 2005

----- Do we have proof that sassa or jujja had 2 sounds when Gurmukhi was created? ------ What else is the explanation for more sounds but less alphabets? In Gurbani there are some shabads that are in heavy Farsi. The first shabad of Tilung Raag cannot be pronounced without the correct use of bindi. The word in Jann in that shabad means women and must be pronounced as Zan. Jan means servant and Jan means servant. Same way, the word Gos (gos kunn Kartaar) means ears and should be pronounced as 'gosh" and not as gos which a bad word in Farsi. If you say that these sounds were not used at that time, then all I can say is that we are not fully informed. Heer Damodar written by Damodar between the period of Siri Guru Angad Dev jee Maharaaj to Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee Maharaaj contains all the words with sounds like "z, Khe, Fe" etc, that some of our new scholars (and some anpaR sampradayak gianis) who are trying to read Gurbani according to the contemporary Punjabi language, are trying to ban. Kulbir Singh

Re: Pronunciation

ASengh aka "boongawala" · 17 Aug 2005

hmmm I see... Looks like I need more Gurbani Santiyia. The guy I learn off does paath like they do at Darbaar Sahib (Harminder Sahib), is that acceptable?

Re: Pronunciation

Kulbir Singh · 17 Aug 2005

Just because the Granthi at Darbar Sahib does paath that way does not mean that it is the acceptable way of doing paath. The Granthi of Darbar Sahib has been trained by a Samprada that does not believe in bindiyaan and does pronunciation of Gurmukhi using the Punjabi measure. Overwhelming majority of Gursikhs do paath using bindiyaan, including most scholars. Even the ones who oppose Bindiyaan cannot avoid them. Here and there they end up using bindiyaan. Santhiya is offered at Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib on regular basis. If you are in UK, try taking santhiya from a puraatan Jatha Gursikh or a Sikh missionary preacher. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Pronunciation

Harpartap Singh · 18 Aug 2005

The Landa script derives from a variant of the Sarada script, becoming graphically distinct by the 10th century CE. It was primarily used in Punjab and Sind to write the Punjabi language, but it was not well suited as due to additional sounds present in the Punjabi language. As a consequence, during the 16th century CE, the Landa script became the template for the Gurmukhi script, which was created to better represent the Punjabi language. Gurmukhi removed the problems with Landa script and included additional vowel symbols (from Devnagri script). The latter also had additional letters for 'l' and 'sh' but Guru ji chose NOT to include them. Finally there are many written works from Medieval times from the sub continent which evidence the fact that sounds like 'sh' had fallen out of common useage since Sanskrit was spoken.

Re: Pronunciation

Harpartap Singh · 18 Aug 2005

As can be seen from looking at the Landa script - see link below: The obvious similarities with Gurmukhi can be seen in terms of the consonants. The key changes Guru ji made was to add more vowel sounds so that the extra spoken sounds could be written. However, Guru ji did not add any extra letters. This was despite the fact that there were 3 other scripts - Takri, Sarada and Devnagri which contained extra letters for 'sh' etc. Guru ji did not include them because He did not require them.

Re: Pronunciation

Singh · 18 Aug 2005

doesn't make any sense that in Guru Sahib's time there was no "sh" or "z"' sound. We have never heard of Guru Har"krisan" but always since the beginning have called Guru Sahib "Guru Harkrishan". There is no Bindi in "Zafarnama" but no one calls it "Jafarnama" and even Baba Zoravar Singh has the sound "z". Guru Har Rai Sahib had a "sheesh mehal" not a "sees mehal". I don't think it has any basis to say that "sh" and "s" didn't exist at that point.

Re: Pronunciation

TUF · 18 Aug 2005

To add to the above points, theres is also a difference in pronunciation based on who speaks it. Different parts of punjab have different pronunciations of different words... someone from Patiala may pronouce different than someone from Jullunder. There are also differences amongst castes in pronunciation. Its all based on local linguistics. Some say sabji, some say sabzi... this is true of most languages.

Re: Pronunciation

John Singh · 18 Aug 2005

""""Just because the Granthi at Darbar Sahib does paath that way does not mean that it is the acceptable way of doing paath. The Granthi of Darbar Sahib has been trained by a Samprada that does not believe in bindiyaan and does pronunciation of Gurmukhi using the Punjabi measure. Overwhelming majority of Gursikhs do paath using bindiyaan, including most scholars. Even the ones who oppose Bindiyaan cannot avoid them. Here and there they end up using bindiyaan. Santhiya is offered at Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib on regular basis. If you are in UK, try taking santhiya from a puraatan Jatha Gursikh or a Sikh missionary preacher.""""" The Sampradas say the exact same thing about you guys. LOL. I know because I have asked both sides!! It is funny we have turned into a bunch of Bahmins, everybody says they are right and the next is wrong. Everybody says they have the real pronounciation/maryada/banee/banaa etc, etc, and everybody else is wrong. I mean if God is beyond comprehension, if his expanse is so huge that it would blow our minds apart. What makes you think you can reduce the prononciation/meanings of banee to a set of a few rules by a certain person or persons? The lord created this banee and sent it to us through the Guru, it is immense and very deep. You will always have different schools of thought, that is just life. Just because the masses do something does not make it right. The so called sikh population of today is into alcohal and meat, does that make it right? Those same mentality people have now changed the Akal Takht maryada to suit there needs and say you can eat meat as long as it is not halal, does that make it right? No!

Re: Pronunciation

Tera Baap · 18 Aug 2005

nobody answered my question, what does sabad mean? (intended for harpartop mainly)

Re: Pronunciation

Harpartap Singh · 19 Aug 2005

Tera Baap Bhaji The word 'sabad' in Gurbani is what we nowadays in modern Panjabi refer to as 'shabad'. Those who advocate we pronounce it 'shabad' in Gurbani DO NOT make it clear that their are 2 types of 'sh' and the one modern Panjabi speakers and English speakers use is not the same as that in Sanskrit from which the word derives.

Re: Pronunciation

student · 19 Aug 2005

"There are no bindis in Gurmukhi" (Author: ...) Then what about Jaap Sahib: [gurbani] ZnImul iSksqY ] ZrIbul prsqY ] iblµdul mkwnYN ] zmInul zmwnYN ]122] [/gurbani] [%sig%]

Re: Pronunciation

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Aug 2005

off topic.... The "desis" ( punjabis in Punjab) always insisit on saying CO. as "KO" [gurbani] ko [/gurbani] instead of the Correct "COMPANY" [gurbani] kMpnI [/gurbani] as in " Hwelet and Packard Co." it is WRITTEN as CO..But PRONOUNCED "COMPANY" and NOT "KO" The SAME STUBBORNESS..I am going to PRONOUNCE it EXACTLY as WRITTEN !!! Example in japji sahib the word is MUSAKAT [gurbani muskq [/gurbani]..and it must be pronounced with an ADHAK ( which is NOT there) Pronouncing it as MAS-KAT makes no sense...while with Adhak the word means Labour.. many such examples of foreign words which can only be pronounced as in original langauge.. Using [gurbani] AKr ilKy syeI gwvw Avr n jwxw bwxI ]1] rhwau ][/gurbani] to base this argument is misinterpreting this tuk. [%sig%]