Carrying a Kirpan
sikh and proud · 15 Aug 2005
can someone please clarify for me the UK law on the carrying of a kirpan by amritdhari sikhs. is their any limit on the length? Does it have to be a blunt blade? Do you need a special licence?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
sikh and proud · 15 Aug 2005
can someone please clarify for me the UK law on the carrying of a kirpan by amritdhari sikhs. is their any limit on the length? Does it have to be a blunt blade? Do you need a special licence?singhstar · 15 Aug 2005
lol special licencse - its not an ak47 - u can carry it as long its a certain lenght - 4 inche blade i think....BirRaas Singh · 15 Aug 2005
No No and NoGurpreet · 15 Aug 2005
Call me smart if u want but////////// Yes the limit of the length should always be something you can handle 2. the blade should be usable...its not for show...its for purpose 3. u need a special licence from guruji...u need to be an amritdhari, tyar bar singh...kirpa aan · 15 Aug 2005
It has to be less than 6 inches including blade, and can only be worn under your clothes, though the police here are very flexibale and i know singhs who have been stopped with three foot kirpans and combat knifes etc... and police don't say anythingsikh and proud · 16 Aug 2005
yes, but does anybody know the exact referance made in UK law.. .ie the act and the year it was passed... is it the 1978 race relations act???paad wala · 16 Aug 2005
ok lets look at this on a down to earth manner, after all we are all living on earth... Is there really a need to carry a kirpan at all??? fair enuf its part of the religion, u wear ur pug, ur karra, ur kachera, keep ur beard isn't that enuf, is there really a need to carry a knife, i mean really thats wot it is, u don't use it to cut butter, just like an extremist muslim wouldn't use a bomb to find coal...bit of thinking required there lads!!! here's a hint... there both weapons part of being a Sikh is to be and show a confident person and be physically & mentally strong, carrying a kirpan just shows a slight lack of these attributes. if u were to get into a fight, i'm sure that 95% of u would reach for ur kirpan, just like u would if u were to carry a gun. Only a handful of the 5% would know when and when not to use it. we live in a western society people, respect their turf don't show any hostility, if not then go back to India, don't like that thought do ya!!!Singh · 16 Aug 2005
Believe it or not the actual limit I believe is 3ft. All types of kirpan can be kept, however if taken out in a public place it is arrestable. Simply wear a kirpan and do not be stupid with it, as the actions of a few can easily effect the majority.ASengh · 16 Aug 2005
"paad wala" I think its because your scared to wear a kirpan right? Too many 'durpoaks' in the panth. Stop making silly excuses and wear a kirpan.Fantastic Sikhs · 16 Aug 2005
Paad Wala/Sikh & Proud/Raj, Maybe sit in an Religious Education class are your local Comprehenisive School. You'll get alot out of it. You will find that the Goray have a better understanding of the Sikh Faith than you. I wear a kirpan in my office environment, my gatra is over my shirt and is clearly visable. No white or black person has ever attacked the fact that I wear a kirpan. In fact they have alot of respect for my beliefs. Nowadays it seems the only people mock the kirpan and Sikh beliefs seem to be the modern Punjabi community. It's quite ironic that today the taunts aren't coming from the BNP or the NF or the Muslims or the GOI but from our own Punjabi relatives...Lionking · 16 Aug 2005
http://www.oxfordsikhs.com/SikhAwareness/91.aspx [u]IS IT LEGAL TO CARRY A KIRPAN IN BRITAIN? [/u] Yes it is! Under the Criminal Justice Act 1988 (section 139) and Criminal Justice 1996 (section 3 and 4) allows anyone to carry a blade exceeding the length of 3 inches for religious, cultural or work related reasons. The Criminal Justice Act and the 2003 Religious Discrimination Act safeguards the Sikhs to carry the Kirpan For more info check out the above mentioned.Singh · 16 Aug 2005
Paad Wala wrote "part of being a Sikh is to be and show a confident person and be physically & mentally strong, carrying a kirpan just shows a slight lack of these attributes" Wow you should be the next Guru, as you are obviously are more informed and wise than guru Gobind Singh who stated that Sikhs should carry a kirpan. What were we thinking following the Guru who sacrificed his all for Sikhi when there are far more superior arm chair moorakhs like you who are more in touch. "if u were to get into a fight, i'm sure that 95% of u would reach for ur kirpan, just like u would if u were to carry a gun. Only a handful of the 5% would know when and when not to use it." The above does not hold as literally hundreds of Sikh's have been verbally and in some cases physically attacked since 9/11, and not a single case had been reported of anyone pulling out their kirpan. Hence unless you have conducted your own survey to come to the conclusion that 95% of Sikh's fight with the kirpan it is nothing more than your own foolish stereotype and not based on fact. "we live in a western society people, respect their turf don't show any hostility, if not then go back to India, don't like that thought do ya!!!" Practising Sikhi given by Guru Sahib does not show hostility to anyone, but is a human right. Next you'll be saying stop keeping Kesh as this frightens people. Perhaps your brown face frightens people on the tube, you better get it bleached than. For your information our religion is protected and steps are taken by Western Countries to enhance it, ie kirpans being allowed by LAW, Sikh Servicemen not needing to wear helmets and even Sikh's not requiring to wear helmets while riding motorbikes once again by LAW. Hence it appears that in the UK the Law is specifically protecting faith and Sikhi, rather than putting it down or viewing it as hostile. As for going back to India that shows how much you know, in the UK Sikhs are regarded as a separate faith, whilst in India we are not, hence why go to a Country where you are not even recognised away from a Country which recognises and actually protects you by law. The assertion of going back to India if you want to be a Sikh sounds very, how sad. If you don't like the multi faith and multi cultural society we have, where all are allowed to freely practise their faith you need to go to the Nazi Germany or Taliban Afghanistan where all people are forced to practise one creed. It's obvious that paad wala or what ever he/she has called itself in past posts has very little knowledge about Sikhi, and is clearly not a Sikh on any level (although his mummy and daddy may claim to be). Perhaps you should get your facts right first (and learn to type properly) and if you don’t like Sikhi as created by the Guru simply get lost.Bhudysut · 16 Aug 2005
Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh I have a gut feeling (nothing more) that paad wala is another member of the group who's 'wedding' may have been 'disturbed' by the R4GGS Ji campaign. Since the beginning of the campaign, I have seen an increase of vocal ignorance from other circles. Just my humble opinion. Bhul Chuk Marf Karna Ji Dass Akaal Sahai SinghA Singh · 16 Aug 2005
Dear Paadwala I am really surprised by your comments. A kirpan is not a “knife”, that is something available to all – a kirpan is part and parcel of a Gursikh’s Kakkars or Treh Mudra. Your comparison with the fundamentalist muslim is incorrect and wholly unnecessary. I suggest you (a) read up a little more about Sikh thought and maryada and (b) political and social thought vis-à-vis multiculturalism, religious freedom and practice. It is not ‘fair enough’ to simply say you can carry four of your kakkars and not the kirpan. Paadwala, this is down right irresponsible at best on your part. Why does an external body have the right to impose such sanctions and changes in the conduct of a people’s way of life or religious practice? Carrying a kirpan shows no lack of the attributes that you described, in fact it reinforces them, unlike you who, by your statement above clearly show a timid and weak disposition on your part. Yes we live in a Western Society, but I see no relevance of that and the imposition of the ludicrous restrictions you speak of – we are not living in an oppressive regime here, please go away and think about your assertion and come back with some more constructive thought. Thanks, A SinghSingh · 16 Aug 2005
"I have a gut feeling (nothing more) that paad wala is another member of the group who's 'wedding' may have been 'disturbed' by the R4GGS Ji campaign." You are 100% correct, no doubt I guess they have a personal vendetta against Sikhi. Good luck to them as however hates and wants to see an end to Sikhi as history shows in turn burns themselves. They'll get the rewards for thier narrow minded hatred in turn. ", please go away and think about your assertion and come back with some more constructive thought." I think we will be waiting for a VERY VERY LONG TIME for Paadwala to have any real constructive thoughts.