“I bow my head in shame........." - Manmohan apologises to Sikhs for ’84 riots
Tribune News Service · 12 Aug 2005
Manmohan apologises to Sikhs for ’84 riots
“I bow my head in shame that such a thing took place”
Tribune News Service
Friday, August 12, 2005, Chandigarh, India
New Delhi, August 11 - Seeking to assuage the sentiments of the Sikh community, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh today apologised on behalf of his government for the 1984 anti-Sikh riots, saying he was not standing on any “false prestige” and his head bowed in shame.
Intervening in the discussion on the Opposition-sponsored motion in the Rajya Sabha on the Nanavati Commission report, the Prime Minister said he had no hesitation in apologising to the Sikh community. “I apologise not only to the Sikh community but to the whole nation, because what took place in 1984 is a negation of the concept of nationhood enshrined in our Constitution. I am not standing on any false prestige. On behalf of our government, on behalf of the entire people of this country, I bow my head in shame,” Dr Singh said.
The Prime Minister said he had seen statements by Opposition leaders that he should seek forgiveness of the country.
The Prime Minister said he had accompanied Congress President Sonia Gandhi to Harmandar Sahib some five or six years ago. “We together prayed that give us strength and show us the way that such things never take place again in our country.”
Urging members not to play politics on the 1984 tragedy, he said, “The past is behind us. We cannot change it, but we can write the future. We must have the will power to write a better future for all of us.” Describing the assassination of the then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi as a “great national tragedy,” he said, “What happened subsequently was equally shameful.”
“We must try to find new ways so as to ensure that the country does not go this way again. Whether Gujarat or any other part of the country, such incidents should not recur,” he said.
Referring to some individuals mentioned in the Nanavati report, he said the commission has not come forward with conclusive conclusions. “These are in the realm of probabilities”.
However, he said the government would reopen cases, including those against policemen, wherever it was possible under the law. “Whosoever figures in the Nanavati report and the commission has drawn an adverse inference about their conduct or behaviour, we will reopen those cases,” he said. He promised assistance to all widows, children and the affected families so that they can lead a life of dignity and self-respect.
The Prime Minister charged the Opposition with trying to separate the Sikh community from “the great traditions of the Congress party.”
Dr Singh said the progress achieved by post-Partition Punjab would not have been possible without the leadership provided by country’s first Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru. “It is also a fact that when that glorious chapter in the history of Punjab was being written, the Akali Dal was busy dividing the people of Punjab on communal lines.”
He said after the Akali Dal came to power in Punjab in 1967, the result was there to see. Appealing to political parties “not to play politics with the sentiments of a brave community like the Sikhs,” he said everyone should help in letting the community to get out of the trauma of 1984.
“Let us not do anything that will reverse the trend....Let us also do nothing to weaken its spirit.”
He said several commissions have gone into the lapses of 1984. “We all know that we still do not know the truth, and the search must go on. This present commission is no exception to that,” he said.
The Prime Minister said the Nanavati Commission has nailed the lie that top Congress leaders were involved in the 1984 anti-Sikh riots. “This lie has been used for the past 21 years to poison the minds of Sikh youths. This lie stands nailed conclusively,” he said.
Recalling that it was late Rajiv Gandhi who provided a new deal to Punjab by signing an accord with Sant Harchand Singh Longowal, Dr Singh said after the 1984 tragedy, the uppermost thing Rajiv Gandhi had in his mind was how to bring Punjab back into the national mainstream.
He also recalled how late Indira Gandhi rejected the suggestions to change her Sikh bodyguards, saying she had no doubts about their sincerity and integrity. “Who can forget the sacrifices of this family,” he said.
He said everyone should work steadfast for mutual reconciliation.
“I respectfully submit that this is not achieved by pursuing partisan goals, apportioning blame”, he said. Dr Singh said in he framework of open society and open economy, there should be respect for all. “There have been aberrations but to err is human.”
Recalling how Nanavati Commission was set up by the previous NDA government, Dr Singh, who was then Leader of House in the Rajya Sabha, said his party had no choice with regard to the Commission’s terms of reference or on who was going to head it.
Referring to the era of terrorism in Punjab, he said it was country’s leadership that did not allow any wedge between the Sikhs and the mainstream and did not allow designs of the nation’s enemies to succeed.
Re: “I bow my head in shame........." - Manmohan apologises to Sikhs for ’84 riots
Kulbir Singh · 12 Aug 2005
Everything in this statement is fine except for two things:
1) His praise of the Gandhi family.
2) His uncalled criticism of Akali Dal.
Having said that, I personally think that Sikhs should not ask for resignation of Manmohan Singh. First of all he was not in power at the time of the riots and secondly now too he is not the one who controls everything. So why ask for his resignation? What do we gain if he resigns? I don't think it is farsighted to have him removed.
BJP is fooling the Sikhs and is leading them against a Sikh PM. BJP feels threatened by Manmohan Singh because of his clean image and sound economic policies. They know that if Manmohan Singh succeeds in bringing the economic reforms, BJP will lose their base in people forever.
It is good to have a PM in Sikhi saroop and otherwise too, he has enhanced the image of Sikhs in the world by being with world leaders in Sikhi saroop.
The Sikh anger should be directed towards the government and Congress but not against Manmohan Singh in particular.
I could be wrong. Just my thoughts.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: “I bow my head in shame........." - Manmohan apologises to Sikhs for ’84 riots
Tribune News Service · 12 Aug 2005
PM applies balm
Rare apology for ’84 riots
What should have been done by earlier Prime Ministers has finally been done by Dr Manmohan Singh. He profusely apologised to the Sikhs for and the nation for the 1984 riots. “I have no hesitation in apologising not only to the Sikh community but to the whole nation, because what took place in 1984 is a negation of the concept of nationhood enshrined in the Constitution….On behalf of our government, on behalf of the entire people of this country, I bow my head in shame,” the Prime Minister said while intervening in the raging debate in the Rajya Sabha fuelled by the Nanavati Commission report and the ATR on the subject. His words should go a long way to soothe the deep hurt of the Sikhs and the nation over the 1984 riots. His apology was sincere and came out of the heart. Hopefully, it will be followed by further action he promised in his speech meant to tackle the anger the government’s action taken report had caused among the Sikhs and the people across the country.
Dr Manmohan Singh’s speech followed Mr Jagdish Tytler’s exit from the government over the 1984 riots. This was apparently found inadequate for meeting the ends of justice which has already been delayed by 21 years. Mr Tytler was forced to go by the Congress rattled by the fierce reaction to the action taken report. Mr Tytler, as his wont, held back for two vital days. The party ended up giving the impression that it took action only under pressure from the Left and the Opposition. Had the resignation come in at the very start, and that too voluntarily, it would have been a politically correct gesture. But the Congress missed the opportunity.
There are many others like Mr Sajjan Kumar and Mr HKL Bhagat that the Congress should dissociate from. Continuing to shield them will only mean that what they did had the blessings of the party. Mr Sajjan Kumar must be asked to leave the Congress and give up his Lok Sabha seat. Then comes the task of trying the suspects quickly. Till those behind the riots pay for their horrendous crime, the victims of the 1984 violence will remain only an aggrieved lot. They have been waiting for redress for too long.
[%sig%]
Re: “I bow my head in shame........." - Manmohan apologises to Sikhs for ’84 riots
TIMES NEWS NETWORK · 12 Aug 2005
'I thought I would break down'
BHASKAR ROY
TIMES NEWS NETWORK[ THURSDAY, AUGUST 11, 2005 10:34:59 PM ]
NEW DELHI: It was an emotionally wrenching debate for him. Speaking on Wednesday in the Lok Sabha on the ’84 riots was possibly the toughest moment in PM Manmohan Singh’s parliamentary career.
"I had a fear that I would break down in the House and tried hard not to do that," he reportedly told close associates late that evening, recalling his emotional exhaustion through the long discussion.
After the debate, Singh rushed to a meeting of the trade and economic relations committee to discuss imbalances in trade with Pakistan and Bangladesh. This was around 7.30 pm. Natwar Singh, Kamal Nath, Shankersinh Vaghela, Montek Singh Ahluwalia and C Rangarajan were among those waiting for him at 7, Race Course Road.
As senior PMO officials got around Singh after the meeting, someone mentioned his speech in the House. It was then that the usually circumspect PM gave vent to the turmoil within.
Right then, a PMO official received a journalist’s SMS asking whether Tytler had quit. Told about the TV reporter’s query, he gave a wry smile: "They will get to know about it in a while."
The suspense wasn’t long as Tytler announced his resignation to the media shortly. Those who were with the PM perhaps had an inkling of his apology in the Rajya Sabha on Thursday.
Although Singh was in Mumbai in 1984 as RBI governor when the riots broke out in Delhi, it was still too close for comfort. A number of young relatives, especially the men, sought his approval to migrate abroad.
[%sig%]
Re: “I bow my head in shame........." - Manmohan apologises to Sikhs for ’84 riots
The Telegraph · 12 Aug 2005
Shame on Day II of penitence
New Delhi, Aug. 11: No apology for 21 years and today the country’s biggest head “bow(s)… in shame”.
“I am not standing on any false prestige and I bow my head in shame on behalf of the government and the people of the whole country for what happened in 1984,” Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said.
It was the second day of the scramble to save face, this time in the Rajya Sabha, which listened with rapt attention to Singh’s reply to the debate on the Nanavati Commission report on the anti-Sikh riots.
Although the Prime Minister has taken much of the Opposition sting out, first with his promise in the Lok Sabha yesterday to pursue the trail of suspicion that leads to Jagdish Tytler and Sajjan Kumar, both Congress leaders, and then with the apology, observers were left wondering about the delay.
All the action on behalf of the government followed an empty action taken report on the findings of the commission, both of which were presented on Monday.
Nearly six months had elapsed between the commission submitting the findings and the government preparing the action report, giving enough time to the political authorities — Singh, Sonia Gandhi and home minister Shivraj Patil — to formulate a response the Sikh community had been waiting 21 years to receive.
“I do not have any hesitation in apologising because what happened was the negation of nationhood,” Singh said. He did not say what hesitation held his tongue all this time.
[u]Tytler resigned as minister yesterday. Today, Sajjan Kumar quit as chairman of the Delhi Rural Development Board.[/u]
Within the Congress, whispers were being heard that the trio of Singh, Sonia and Patil had not taken the advice of other experienced leaders, which explained the belated reaction after the outrage at the government’s handling of the report.
Singh tried to make amends. “All those against whom the commission drew adverse inference, we will have a re-look at them.”[/u]
He revealed that the then BJP-led government formed the commission on the basis of a supplementary question. Singh said he believed question hour was not the appropriate time to discuss an important issue, but had kept quiet.
“But Mr Advani, the then home minister, said outside the House that ‘I want to constitute a commission on 1984 anti-Sikh riots but Manmohan Singh stopped me from doing it...’ Mr Advani owes an apology to me on this count.”
Although the government’s response has been late, it has made the BJP apprehensive that, a precedent having been set with two resignations, trouble might be in store for Narendra Modi once the Nanavati report on the Gujarat riots comes out.
Quite unlike his usual soft-spoken self, Singh was in an unsparing mood as he also took on the Akali Dal.
“They were busy dividing the people of Punjab on communal lines,” he said.
At the end of the debate, Patil announced two committees — one to look into compensation for riot victims and another to consider rehabilitation programmes for the widows and their children.
“I have committed my government to do all we can do to support the widows,” Singh said.
[%sig%]
Re: “I bow my head in shame........." - Manmohan apologises to Sikhs for ’84 riots
EXPRESS NEWS SERVICE · 12 Aug 2005
All ’84 riot victims will get relief: Patil
EXPRESS NEWS SERVICE
Posted online: Friday, August 12, 2005 at 0241 hours IST
NEW DELHI, AUGUST 11: Adopting the same reconciliatory tone used by Manmohan Singh while speaking about the Nanavati Commission report in the Rajya Sabha, Home Minister Shivraj Patil today said nobody affected by the 1984 riots would be left uncared for.
During a debate on a BJP-sponsored motion on the panel report, Patil said the Centre would set up two separate committees to monitor the relief and rehabilitation of riot victims across India.
Admitting that Sikhs attacked outside Delhi had not been adequately compensated, the minister said the twin panels would remove discrepancies in relief and consider giving jobs to dependents of those killed in the riots.
The panels would get two months to do this.
Patil promised to examine the cases of Sikh Armymen who were allegedly burnt inside the trains and whose families have not been compensated till now.
The minister sought to clear the name of the Congress and the then Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi. He said Rajiv himself went from place to place to try and end the riots. “We all were at Teen Murti Bhavan with the body of Mrs Gandhi but Rajiv Gandhi was nowhere to be seen for many hours,’’ Patil said, pointing out that Rajiv, who had been sworn in as caretaker Prime Minister by then, was out trying to control the violence.
The minister said even the NDA-appointed Nanavati Commission had not pointed fingers at top Congress leaders. “That lie, which has over the last 21 years been used to poison the minds of the Sikh youth, stands nailed conclusively,” he said.
Patil refuted the BJP’s charge that the Action
Taken Report on the probe panel’s report virtually amounted to rejecting its recommendations.
“...Whosoever figures in the Nanavati report — and the Commission has in its wisdom found it necessary to draw an adverse inference about their conduct or behaviour — we will reopen those cases,” he said.
Patil said legal experts would be consulted to reopen cases against police officers named by the Commission who had retired many years ago.
“Many of them retired many, many years ago. But within the ambit of law, whatever action we can take, we will reopen those cases also if the law of the land permits that”, he said.
[%sig%]
Re: “I bow my head in shame........." - Manmohan apologises to Sikhs for ’84 riots
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 12 Aug 2005
The apology should coem from Sonia..as it was her hubby who orchestrated this genocide...and her suss before that. Only the NEHRU DYNASTY is stained with the Blood of Innocent Sikhs..
Re: “I bow my head in shame........." - Manmohan apologises to Sikhs for ’84 riots
EXPRESS NEWS SERVICE · 12 Aug 2005
BJP steps up offensive
NEW DELHI, AUG 11: The BJP on Thursday doubledbacked to refurbish its offensive on the Congress-led government after sensing that the action of removing Mr Jagdish Tytler from the Union Cabinet and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s impressive presentation in Parliament had taken away much of the steam from its attack on the issue of the Nanavati Commission action taken report.
Contending that such actions did not absolve the Congress of its role in the 1984 anti-Sikh riots, the main Opposition party sought to bring under the ambit of fire former prime minister Rajiv Gandhi and home minister PV Narasimha Rao.
Opposing the clean chit, the Opposition party said that in the Congress “not even a leaf moves without the knowledge of the top leadership”.
Rejecting the regret expressed by PM in the Rajya Sabha, the BJP continued its tirade demanding that the Prime Minister and Congress president Sonia Gandhi “apologise to the nation for Congress’ role in the carnage”.
While the move seemed aimed at disallowing the Left parties to capture Opposition space on the issue, political circles also felt that it might be an attempt to force the Congress to be on the defensive, especially with the Liberhan panel on Ayodhya expected to submit its report soon.
Speaking to mediapersons, BJP spokesman VK Malhotra said, “Tytler’s resignation and Sajjan Kumar’s stepping down as chairman of Delhi Rural Development Board will in no way bring any respite to those who were victims of the carnage. By these resignations Congress cannot absolve itself of its role in the carnage.”
Mr Malhotra said that the government should ensure that all the FIRs on the riots are taken up and pursued in courts of law.
However, he refuted suggestions that the party was “soft” on the Nanavati panel report as Justice GT Nanavati was presiding over another panel on the Gujarat riots whose findings were awaited.
[%sig%]
Re: “I bow my head in shame........." - Manmohan apologises to Sikhs for ’84 riots
Ranjit Singh · 12 Aug 2005
I think Manmohan should resign. He is no friend of the sikhs and never has been. Having a 'sikh' as PM simply makes it harder for sikhs to ask for justice. People just point to him and say, "Hey, a sikh is the prime minister. India's pretty good for the sikhs." Remember, this is the same guy who represented India at a conference during the height of Beant's butchery in Punjab and straight out lied to the world. His brothers and sisters were being butchered, but he defended the butchers. He is no sikh of Guru Gobind Singh Jee.
I also feel no pride in the fact that his economic policies apparently saved the Indian economy. I'm sure it was a great feat on his part, but I would rather have seen India collapse economically. Our people were being slaughtered and this guy was working hard to save the economy that was paying for our slaughter. For those who might say that his work was for the 'bhallaa' of the common people.... not really. Those who already had food now have more food. Those who were without food, are still starving.
Manmohan is the definition of Uncle Tom. First that spineless Zaila, and now this guy.
Re: “I bow my head in shame........." - Manmohan apologises to Sikhs for ’84 riots
Kulbir Singh · 12 Aug 2005
--------
i heard both of Manmohan Singh's daughters are married to Hindus. >>
Is that a crime????? Also, just for the record, our PM has three daughters
--------
It is not a crime agreed. But it is certainly a sin according to Gurmat principles. A Sikh is prohibited to do Roti-beti dee saanjh with anyone other than a Sikh.
If Manmohan Singh's daughters married non-Sikhs with his wishes, then he is surely Dabroo-Ghusroo, Kacha-Pilla, Chauraasi daa Maal.
Kulbir Singh
Re: “I bow my head in shame........." - Manmohan apologises to Sikhs for ’84 riots
Kulbir Singh · 13 Aug 2005
Lionking,
Please refer to several debates on Bibek on this forum. We don't need to start another on under this thread.
Also you can refer to the following article on this site:
http://www.tapoban.org/langar.htm
Kulbir Singh
Re: “I bow my head in shame........." - Manmohan apologises to Sikhs for ’84 riots
Kulbir Singh · 13 Aug 2005
**-,
Two wrongs don't make a right. If some Sikhs are getting married to Hindu girls that too is not right according to Sikhi principles and rehit maryada. A Sikh must get married to a Sikh only.
I am sure Hindu Dharam has its requirements when it comes to Grehasth Aashram i.e. getting married. Ancient books like Mannu Simrati has many chapters devoted to what a person should look for when getting married. It talks details to a silly level. So what is wrong if Sikhs too have requirements for getting married?
Even from a logical point of view, it does not make sense to get married to a person of other religion. There will be major problems if both a religious. What religion will their children follow? What will be their names? Practically talking, it is not a good idea to do inter-religion marriages.
However, if both are not following religion, then they can do as they please.
Kulbir Singh
Re: “I bow my head in shame........." - Manmohan apologises to Sikhs for ’84 riots
Kulbir Singh · 13 Aug 2005
**-,
------------
I agree, but how are these Sikh families going to continue their progeny when their is an under supply of Sikh women in Punjab?
----------
Think about it. Why did this problem occur? Because Sikhs have given up Gurmat. Gurmat clearly prohibits Sikhs from female infanticide. If Sikhs had followed Guru Sahib's hukam, there would have been no need to go to other states for finding non-Sikh women to marry.
-------------
There are many books in Grihast Ashram in Hindu Dharam, Manu Smriti is not the only one. The details may sound silly, that is becasue ot was written thousands of years ago when the socio-economic environment was different. Manu Smriti is not sacrosant to Hindus. You never know, in a few years time, people will find aspects of Gurmat Jeevan to be silly as well, some people already do.
------------
I agree that Mannu Simriti is one of the books that Hindu Dharam follows. There are more as well. When I mentioned "Silly details', believe me I did not mean it in a negative way. Some of the stuff may sound silly today but it makes a lot of sense e.g. to leave out at 4 gotra (last name) when getting mind namely your own, your mother's, your grandfather's mother's etc. This must have been keeping in mind the genetics problem that communities like Jews and Muslims face since they marry their own cousins (pretty disgusting thing to do).
Mannu Simriti has some very objectionable stuff that even Hindus today feel uncomfortable with e.g. putting melted metal in the ears of a Shudra who listens to Vedas. I am not sure what the reason was behind this rule but it definitely does not sound very humanly. I have read Mannu Simriti and have found that most of the material is very good and actually Mannu Simriti has some great words of wisdom but the 10% objectionable stuff like the one I just mentioned above has spoiled the credibility of this book. So much so that a Hindu Brahmin from Maharashtra recently told me that the Maharashtrans have jointly rejected Mannu Simriti in the late 1800s. I asked him the reason but he was not aware of the details.
In any case, my point was that all religions have rules for getting married and if Sikhs have this rule that a Sikh can marry only a Sikh, there is nothing wrong with it. That's all.
Kulbir Singh
Re: “I bow my head in shame........." - Manmohan apologises to Sikhs for ’84 riots
Sarabjot Kaur · 13 Aug 2005
A son-in-law from another religion to be accepted as son-in-law by a sikh family if he accepts to be a sikh, a follower of guru granth sahib ji.
Its exactly the same accepting a daughter-in-law
Or you may call accepting a partner from other colour,caste and religion is only OK if that person is accepting SIKHI