Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

India Today Survey

India Today Survey

Siddharth · 11 Aug 2005

India Today did a survey of the top states in India in different categories. It was divided between large states and small states http://www.indiatoday.com/itoday/index.html (unfortunately, registration is required to view the story). Unsurprisingly, Punjab came out on top in several categories. Kerala also did well. Category - Large state, small state 1. Law & Order - Kerala, Pondicherry 2. Health - Kerala, Mizoram 3. Education - Himachal Pradesh, Sikkim 4. Infrastructure - Punjab, Delhi 5. Consumer Market - Punjab, Delhi 6. Agriculture - Punjab, Delhi 7. Investment - Gujarat, Sikkim 8. Budget - Punjab, Delhi

Re: India Today Survey

Khalistan Zindabad · 11 Aug 2005

. Infrastructure - Punjab, NO WAY... THATS IMPOSIBLE

Re: India Today Survey

S Singh · 12 Aug 2005

The infrastructure in Punjab is a lot better than in other states. I know the roads in many areas of Punjab are bad but they are like motorways compared to those found in other states. Just a shame that the southern districts of Punjab are virtually ignored. The roads are bad and the place does not appear to have developed as much as areas north of Ludhiana.

Re: India Today Survey

Lionking · 12 Aug 2005

Siddharth - could you please "print screen" the article, and send the picture to me, and we shall upload it for sangat to read :D

Re: India Today Survey

**- · 12 Aug 2005

The India Today survey is all lies. It has been concuted by the Bahmans in order to supress the Sikhs cause and struggle [sarcasm]

Re: India Today Survey

Bhopinder Singh · 12 Aug 2005

**- It is true

Re: India Today Survey

Satwant Kaur · 12 Aug 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Well the survey can be true....but its not a matter to be delighted. We all know that Punjabi Kisan is the picture of SUFFERING today.....the level of water is going down day by day & the land of punjab is becoming barren...... farmers r not being paid what they should be. Law & order is a mess ...infanticide rate is highest.... Punjab has reached NUMBER 1 in divorces according to a survey conducted last month. & the no. of heads without turban are...........???? It might be ahead of other states but compared to the performance of previous years............we are diminishing. What about employment opportunities??? Still there r ppl who r risking their lives n going to foreign countries by illegal means to earn their bread. ...............There's a long way to go................... Guru Mehar Karan.

Re: India Today Survey

JkS · 12 Aug 2005

You really need to know how this survey was carried. A lot Punjab infrastructure is British era e.g Many Bridges and roads even the current Amritsar airport was built in WW2, look how long it is taking to upgrade it. The British invested heavily in the Punjab as pre partition it was a commercial and industrial hub for North India, Afghanistan, and Central Asia. Budget what does that mean? A substational part of Punjab budget goes on the Police, thats why there is no money to pay other public workers like teachers and doctors. A lot of money comes in from abroad, there is also a lot Black money about from scams, drugs and prostitution.

Re: India Today Survey

Siddharth · 12 Aug 2005

Dear Lion King ji - I will email it to you in the next 15 minutes. Dear Satwant Kaur Ji - I totally agree. Kisans, in general, are not doing too well. Apart frokm Punjab, in Andhra Pradesh and Maharashtra, hundreds of farmers committed suicide as their crops failed. The farmers of Karnataka and Tamil Nadu are always fighting about the Cauvery river water. If the monsoon is good (as it has been for the past 9 yeras), both groups are OK, but as soon as there is a drought, they are in arms for their share of the water. Dear JkS Ji - By budget, I think what they mean is what comes to the state via taxes etc. and what is spent on public works. States like Bihar, Orissa etc are always at the bottom of the table as there is simply no monies coming in but states like Punjab, Delhi, Gujarat are doing better because of the inflow of funds due to taxes etc. Best regards, Sid.

Re: India Today Survey

no one · 12 Aug 2005

Consumer Market - Punjab, Delhi yapeeeee yes consumer of drugs alcohol and tobacco.

Re: India Today Survey

**- · 13 Aug 2005

Sikhs have become the biggest pessimists in the world. In all developing ecomomies, you are going to get drug problems. Look at the UK and US. You can't have it all. Got to take the good with the bad. [%sig%]

Re: India Today Survey

search for tat · 13 Aug 2005

I would India Today to cover the water table level in Punjab over the last 30 years, and how in the next 20 years it will suffer from drought. Then will it be no1 for agriculture?

Re: India Today Survey

khalsa · 13 Aug 2005

** Sikhs have become the biggest pessimists in the world. In all developing ecomomies, you are going to get drug problems. Look at the UK and US. You can't have it all. Got to take the good with the bad. and in this punjab and sikhs living there you are creating khalistan [%sig%]

Re: India Today Survey

**- · 13 Aug 2005

Veer search for tat ji India is run by human beings and human beings have no power over mother nature. God forbid, if Punjab is plauged with a drought no human being - no matter how intelligent or powerful - can control what is destined to happen. Droughts are part of everyday life in Kal-Yug, this is described in the Hindu holy texts - look what is going on Africa. A day will come when Bhu-Devi (mother earth) will refuse to produce food and people will begin to eat their own offspring. Sitara [%sig%]

Re: India Today Survey

R Singh · 13 Aug 2005

Wow. Punjab did well compared to the rest of India. Woohoo. What do you expect? India is a dump. Biggest emerging economy, blah blah blah.. It's a dump. It's a pathetic country. Of course Punjab is going to come out on top. Punjabees have worked hard for generations. This isn't something that India has given Punjab. On the contrary, India has held Punjab back. Imagine if Punjab didn't have this Indian yoke around it. How well off would it be then? I find it amusing how Indians point to such surveys and expect Punjabees, particularly Sikhs, to suddenly dance for joy and thank India for this great success. People, this isn't news for us. We know we're successful. We always have been. India didn't give this to us and we don't need India pointing it out to us, as if it's some great Indian service to Punjab. In fact, this should show us all exactly how pathetic India really is. After 20 years of bloodshed, Punjab still puts the rest of India to shame. If after the amount of damage done to punjab over the last couple of decades, it is still the top state in so many categories, I shudder to think of what the other states are like. It shows just how great of a failure the Indian nation is. Imagine if we didn't have to put up with India? Punjab would be soaring.

Re: India Today Survey

Siddharth · 13 Aug 2005

Dear R Singh - Are you out of your mind??? When did I ever say that Punjabis have to thank the rest of India for its success? Stop putting words into other people's mouth and stop all these self-aggrandizing posts that you have been writing. You just can't digest the fact that India is a growing economy. You can't bear to see places like Bangalore, Chennai and Hyderabad getting their due. People like you can't even acknowledge that communities other than Punjabis have made a name for themselves within and outside India. Wake up to reality my friend. Welcome to the new world. Regards, Sid.

Re: India Today Survey

JS · 14 Aug 2005

Bombay or Mumbai was described by some people as an advanced city. They had some rain and the whole city came to halt, many employees of companies used by the west were killed. Even well off areas had no electricity or telephones for over a week. Now people are dying of disease.

Re: India Today Survey

Bhopinder Singh · 14 Aug 2005

Sitatr ji It is true for what you wrote It has been concuted by the Bahmans in order to supress the Sikhs cause and struggle [sarcasm]

Re: India Today Survey

Siddharth · 14 Aug 2005

<> Some rain??? Are you out of your mind, JS. They had 96 inches of rain in a SINGLE day. That is more rain then Cherrapunji ever had in a single day (88 inches). Get your facts straight and then talk. If that much rain ever fell in England or wherever it is you live, I can guarantee that there would be flash floods there too and you would have seen death and destruction there too. And as for many employees that you talk about. Human beings were killed my dear JS. Rain does not see whether or not this person should be killed because he/she is employed by a western company. Totally illogical.

Re: India Today Survey

R Singh · 14 Aug 2005

Sid, are you blind? Where did I say that YOU said that Punjabis have to thank India for their success? I said 'Indians,' not Siddarth. And where did I say that no other community in India is successful? Look genius, you put up a survey stating that punjab is tops in India in several categories. I didn't put this up, you did. I merely commented on how this is nothing to be surprised about and mentioned a few truths about India. You obviously can't handle this and have gotten your shorts in a knot. Everyone knows that Punjab has done well compared to the rest of the subcontinent throughout the modern age. YOUR survey backs this up. The rest of India might finally be trying to emerge out of the dark ages, but Punjab was doing so a long time ago. Without India holding us back, we would have gone quite far by now. You can brag all you want about India, but the fact remains that India is running rampant with disease (HIV to mention just one), poverty (and we're talking extreme poverty here) and illiteracy.

Re: India Today Survey

Siddharth · 15 Aug 2005

<> Well, I am an Indian so your generalization includes me as well. <> I can handle it perfectly well Paa Ji, which is the reason that I put this thread up in the first place. <> Again, like I posted in another thread; If that is the case, take the example of any western country. Take America, where I live. The rules are even here for everyone right? India is not holding you back? Then why do you think Hindus do equally well, if not better, than their Sikh brothers/sisters? By your logic, given an even environment, Hindus would do better than the Sikhs. However, in the "dark age" environment of India, Sikhs do better. I am not trying to offend you in any way, neither am I defending India. We are far far behind the rest of the world but at least we are striving to get back on track. Look at the plight of the nations that surround us: Bangladesh, Pakistan, Nepal, Burma (Myanmar), Afghanistan, Iraq, Laos, Combodia etc. (China is the exception). Look at Africa, Eastern Europe. There are problems everywhere. India is no exception but if we are pessimists for life, we will remain at the bottom. Instead, people like me are striving to make India better. To summarize, I know how India is. I've lived there for 25 years. My point is that we have to improve sometime, right? In the last 10 years, I have seen so much progress that I'm sure would not have taken place in the last 200 years before that.

Re: India Today Survey

khalsa · 15 Aug 2005

sitara what a load of rubbish. you are a sikh and belive in "BHU-DEVI" . "AkalPurkh" our father will not let His children suffer. at this moment i do not remember the exect wording but gurbani says that akalpurkh first creates "rizik" then life. gurbani says millions of creatures live in sea nobody runs any business or do "khetee barri". learn yo respect guebani. [%sig%]

Re: India Today Survey

R Singh · 15 Aug 2005

Sid, I will once again re-iterate that many Hindus are very hard working and intelligent. There are also many lazy 'sikhs', no doubt. However, as you have admitted on another thread, Sikhs as a whole have done better in India than Hindus or Moslems. When it comes to Western nations, you say that Hindus do just as well. Agreed. I responded by saying that you have a much larger pool to pull successful people from. You assumed that this was true for India only. But I was actually referring to Western nations. You have a huge population in India and many of the best and brightest go abroad. It's usually not your everyday average Indian that is leaving the nation. It's usually the cream. While for Punjabees and Sikhs in particular, the vast majority of people who came over were farmers and labourers. Yet, our community has at least matched, if not surpassed, the general Indian community in terms of economic success. I understand where your pride for India's economic 'success' comes from. Perhaps if I were in your shoes, I'd feel the same way. But look at it from our point of view. We had a successful nation even in the 19th century. Throughout the 20th century, Punjab was the breadbasket of India. We were perhaps the strongest state in India during British rule and during Indian rule. This despite the fact that Punjab was carved into several pieces. Modern Punjab is a fraction of what it once was. We also lost the more fertile land to Pakistan. Since Indian Independence, Punjab has never received a break from India. Our farmers faced bad economic policies from the center, our water situation wasn't fairly dealt with and industry was held back as well. On top of this was the political situation. Right from the outset, sikhs and punjabees had to expend vast amounts of time and energy to gain even the most basic political concessions, concessions that other states received without any effort. Issues like Punjabee Suba put a large strain on Punjab. Then came the 70's, 80's and 90's. Hundreds of thousands of our people were butchered, primarily young people. For a relatively small population, that's a very large loss to absorb. Everything in punjab was dealt a severe blow. Our educational institutions suffered, industry suffered, everything suffered. So while you rejoice at seeing India taking steps forward, we mourn at seeing all the steps we've had to take backwards due to our association with India.

Re: India Today Survey

S Singh · 16 Aug 2005

>>Bombay or Mumbai was described by some people as an advanced city. They had some rain and the whole city came to halt, many employees of companies used by the west were killed. Even well off areas had no electricity or telephones for over a week. Now people are dying of disease.>> Bocastle in Cornwall had flash floods. Areas of Shrewsbury are flooded everytime there is heavy rain.

Re: India Today Survey

Singh · 16 Aug 2005

The recent surveys carried out in the UK rate Sikhs as the most prosperous religious group, in terms of income, property and graduation levels. The Indian Goverment has also admitted (in the 60s) that the Green Revolution of North India was the result of the hard work of "Sardars" although most started as refugees (from the new Pakistan), whom employ on average at least 10 migrant workers. The hard work of Sikh's despite all possible odds has made Panajb a haven for poor Hindu workers from States like Bihar. I don’t have the exact refs with me at work for the above, but can provide these if required.

Re: India Today Survey

**- · 16 Aug 2005

Singh, --------- The recent surveys carried out in the UK rate Sikhs as the most prosperous religious group, in terms of income, property and graduation levels. -------- You are indeed correct here. But if you look at jobs in the City of London in fields such as Management Consulting, Investment Banking, Finance and other professional services, Hindus do much better than most other people. Most of these Hindus are second or third generation Asians whose parents where either refugees from East Africa or migrant workers from Gujarat/Punjab. Even in fields such as medicine and acedemia we fair a lot better than other groups even though we both have/face the same opportunities and prejudices. Look at the gold-mile in Leicester. This is testament to the success story of the Gujarati refugees that were kicked out of Uganda - virtually pennyless. The Ugandan government has recognised the mistake they have made and recently came to the Swaminarayan Mandir in London to try and persuade the Gujarati Hindus to come back and help rebuild Uganda. They didn't go to any Ramgarhia Gurudwara. If you want to play the numbers game, then the Jewish community only number 15-20 million (similar to the Sikh population) yet their contribution to fields such as science, commerce, academia, entertainment and literature over the last century eclipse those of the Sikhs. I am not trying to belittle Sikh achievements and show that Hindus or Jews are better or superior, but rather highlight that all communities have their fair share of success stories, not only the Sikhs.