Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikhs part of broader Hindu religion: India Supreme Court

Sikhs part of broader Hindu religion: India Supreme Court

news · 10 Aug 2005

Jains, Sikhs part of broader Hindu religion, says SC S.S. Negi Legal Correspondent New Delhi, August 10 In a significant ruling defining the status of communities like Sikhs and Jains within the Constitutional frame work, the Supreme Court has declined to treat them as separate minority communities from the broad Hindu religion, saying encouraging such tendencies would pose serious jolt to secularism and democracy in the country. “The so-called minority communities like Sikhs and Jains were not treated as national minorities at the time of framing of the Constitution. Sikhs and Jains, in fact, have throughout been treated as part of wider Hindu community, which has different sects, sub-sects, faiths, modes of worship and religious philosophies,” a Bench of Chief Justice R.C. Lahoti, Mr Justice D.M. Dharmadhikari and Mr Justice P.K. Balasubramanyan said. Disposing of an appeal by Bal Patil and others against the Bombay High Court order, seeking direction to the Union Government to notify “Jains” as a minority community under Section 2 C of the National Commission for Minority Act, the Bench said: “We do not find that any case is made out for grant of any relief to appellants in exercise of writ jurisdiction of the High Court and hence, the writ jurisdiction of this (apex) court.” The High Court had rejected their plea. Quoting from the provisions of the Constitution and the historic background on how the Constitution had come into existence after Partition, the court said: “Encouragement of such fissiparous tendencies would be a serious jolt to the secular structure of the constitutional democracy.” “We should guard against making our country akin to a theocratic state based on multi-nationalism. Our concept of secularism, to put it in a nutshell, is that the state will have no religion,” the Bench held, while asking the National Minorities Commission to “gear up its activities” to keep all religious groups in right direction with “constitutional perspective, principles and ideals in its view”. Mr Justice Dharmadhikari, writing the judgement for the Bench, said the Constitution had clearly laid down that “the state will treat all religions and religious groups equally and with equal respect without in any manner interfering with their individual rights or religions, faith and worship.” The court said in various codified customary laws like the Hindu Marriage Act, the Hindu Succession Act, the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act and other laws of pre and post-Constitution period, definition of “Hindu” included all sects, sub-sects of Hindu religion, including Sikhs and Jains. It said if the argument for recognising every religious group within the broad Hindu religion as separate religious minority was accepted and such tendencies were encouraged, “the whole country, which is already under class and social conflicts due to various divisive forces, will further face divisions on the basis of religious diversities”. “Such claims to minority status based on religion would increase in the fond hope of various sections of people getting special protections, privileges and treatment as part of constitutional guarantee,” the court said adding “a claim by one group of citizens would lead to a similar claim by another group and conflict and strife would ensue”. The court further clarified that the framers of the Constitution had “engrafted” a group of Articles (25 to 30) in the Constitution recognising only Muslims, Christians, Anglo-Indians and Parsis as religious minorities at national level by taking into consideration the historic background on how these communities had emerged over a long period of time during the Mughal and British rule. The court also said the Union Government, in its affidavit, had taken the stand that in accordance with the law laid down by the majority judgement in TMA Pai case by the apex court regarding the statues of minority educational institutions in the country, it had been left to state governments to decide as to where Jain community should be treated as minority. The court also noted that in states like Chhattisgarh, Maharashtra and Uttranchal, Jains had already been notified as minority in accordance with the provisions of the respective State Minority Commission Acts.

Re: Sikhs part of broader Hindu religion: India Supreme Court

A S · 10 Aug 2005

These people are just asking for it. When they say things like Sikhs are a hindu sect, that's what actually starts the trouble and that's what disrupts national security. If they want Sikhs and HIndus to live peacefully together, they need to recognize us as a separate religion and peoples. We will never ever accept that Sikhism is a part of Hinduism...never. They can claim it all they want.

Re: Sikhs part of broader Hindu religion: India Supreme Court

' · 10 Aug 2005

its part of their plan, they want punjab in turmoil

Re: Sikhs part of broader Hindu religion: India Supreme Court

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 10 Aug 2005

Dont you guys see the machivallean cleverness of this TWO PRONGED staretgy to DISSIPATE SIKH ENERGY ?? One side release the nanavati report..a few sikhs get blasted and water cannoned...on the streets...the badals jagiros make noise and political hay... jagdish tytler resings..and the otherside the SC fires another SALVO...Siksh are HINDUS... woa Battle on TWO FRONTS is on... And if sikhs get their act together...on these TWIN FRONTS..they will just open up a THIRD FRONT and so on..... Chakra View of the Mahabharat used to Kill the enemey with Cleverness and staretegy !!!..cheating, slyness, anything goes.

Re: Sikhs part of broader Hindu religion: India Supreme Court

singh m · 11 Aug 2005

sikhs need to keep pressing the govt to declare sikh as separate minority. don't give up. [%sig%]

Re: Sikhs part of broader Hindu religion: India Supreme Court

Singh · 11 Aug 2005

What more evidence do we need that real attempts are made at all levels to incorporate Sikhi into the Hindu mainstream. Strange how in a real secular and democratic society like the UK Sikhs are recognised as a separate social/ethnic group distinct from Hinduism, but not in India. They constantly try and incorporate us into some thing which we are not, and than when we raise our voice they use force to persecute us. I think we need to educate ourselves (get proper leaders in place etc) than break free from this corrupt and evil Hindustan. This may sound extrem however if we are not recognised as who we are in our own so called own country there is something seriously wrong. We certainly can not rely on the Hindu mainstream to stand by us as they have proven and continue to do so that they will not, despite all the times SIkhs have defended them and India.

Re: Sikhs part of broader Hindu religion: India Supreme Court

**- · 11 Aug 2005

I agree with A S. This insistance of deluded Hindus that Sikhi is a part of Hinduism is the root of this Hindu-Sikh tension. As a Hindu I firmly believe that the government should rectify this grave mistake. Even I and many other Hindus do not want Sikhs to be included as Hindus. I find it embarassing with Hindus do this.

Re: Sikhs part of broader Hindu religion: India Supreme Court

Jasmin · 11 Aug 2005

Are their special immunities granted to minority religions under the Indian court? Or is this, however heartfelt, simply a matter of semantics? I ask this basic question simply because I don't know, and I would like to be enlightened. How might it be different for a Sikh vs. a Hindu in an Indian court?

Re: Sikhs part of broader Hindu religion: India Supreme Court

singh · 11 Aug 2005

I don't know about special immunities but the main issue is the truth. Sikhs are not Hindus as Hindus are not Sikhs. It is more than semantics. In an Indian court and as per law, everyone who gets married within India is married under the Hindu marriage act. The British made a provision during their rule for the Sikhs to be married under the Anand Marriage act. The Indian government to this day has not made this provision. As long as minorities are grouped with Hindus, they do not have a claim to misrepresentation or discrimination as the majority community can claim that both communities are in fact one and the same. This can apply in courts as well during cases involving discrimination against minorities. MK Gandhi is seen as a deceptive character by some Dalits because he welcomed them into the Hindu fold. Some jumped at the chance to be accepted by Hindus but the educated Dalits, led by BS Ambedkar were wise to Gandhi's ploy. They knew he wanted the Dalits to be classified as Hindus so that they would not join any other minority faith communities which didn't have caste distinctions. If the Dalits were to become Sikhs or Muslims or Christians, it would have empowered them and greatly reduced the size of the Hindu voting block. By classifying them as Hindus, the political authority could continue to discriminate against them on religious grounds (Varna). In short the ruling class would not like minorities to be distinguished because it empowers them. They are free to think on their own and they are not bound to the doctrines of the majority community. It is the ruling classes preference that the minorities not be empowered. When a community, which is distinct, speaks out against the government, they can portray that community as being anti-national and portray them as a common enemy to Hindutva, which is stronger if the minority communities are absorbed within it.

Re: Sikhs part of broader Hindu religion: India Supreme Court

Singh · 11 Aug 2005

It basically means that Sikhs fall under Hindu Law. For example, marriages will be classified as Hindu marriages. That of course, is just one small part. Hindu Law covers a wide range of areas. Moslems, on the other hand, don't fall under Hindu Law. They have a separate system for them.