Sikh sentiments hurt, says Akali Dal (
Bhopinder Singh · 09 Aug 2005
Sikh sentiments hurt, says Akali Dal (A)
Sangrur, August 8
The district unit of the Akali Dal (Amritsar) at a meeting held under the presidentship of Mr Jeet Singh Alloarkh, here today criticised the Nanavati Commission Report related to the Anti-Sikh riots in 1984. The report was tabled in Parliament today.
Mr Alloarkh said the report of the Nanavati Commission had hurt the sentiments of the Sikhs. It also exposed the anti-minority face of the government. He said the party condemned the report as it had exonerated Mr Jagdish Tytler, Union Minister, and Mr Sajjan Kumar, whom the Sikhs considered “main accused” of the 1984 riots.
He said this report had rubbed salt on the wounds of the Sikhs as it had been prepared by ignoring many witnesses, who had identified the culprits. He said the Akali Dal would initiate an agitation to protest against the report and get the erring persons behind the bars.
The meeting was also attended among others by Mr Nirmal Singh Gharachon, SGPC member; Mr Satgur Singh Namol, a youth leader; Mr Hardeep Singh Loha Kherra and Mr Nirbhey Singh, all leaders of the party.
PHAGWARA: Akali Dal (A) general secretary Anoop Singh Minhas today predicted that the Nanawati Commission report, which was tabled in Parliament today, would meet the fate of reports of other commissions as the report had indicted senior Congress leaders for triggering the anti-Sikh carnage in Delhi in November 1984.
In a statement issued here today by Mr Sukhwinder Singh Khalsa and Mr Gurmit Singh, senior party leaders, Mr Minhas asserted that this report would also be consigned to the archives of parliamentary files to gather dust as the Congress agenda was to “protect the culprits”.
In case the Congress was sincere towards the minorities, it should force Jagdish Tytler to step down as minister and register cases against others, demanded Mr Minhas.
For tackling excesses against minorities, the National Commission for Minorities should be given judicial status so that it could also hand down punishment to the culprits. The NCM should not be under the Central Government but an independent body like the judiciary, he contended. It should probe or set probe panels, expose the culprits of anti-minorities riots and slap punishments, added Mr Minhas.
Re: Sikh sentiments hurt, says Akali Dal (
Kulbir Singh · 09 Aug 2005
‘Rao told me to protect friends...Rajiv told me you’re a heart patient, take rest’
For the third time, then L-G Gavai has been made the fall guy
MANOJ MITTA
Posted online: Tuesday, August 09, 2005 at 0003 hours IST
NEW DELHI, AUGUST 8: One man wasn’t surprised at all today, the Lieutenant Governor of Delhi at the time of Indira Gandhi’s assassination in 1984. Barely days before the Nanavati Commission report was tabled in Parliament, in an extensive conversation with The Indian Express at his Nagpur residence, P G Gavai was prescient: ‘‘I know I will again be made a scapegoat to shield the higher-ups.’’
Gavai is the highest executive authority to have been blamed by the Nanavati Commission for lapses related to the riots that shook the city for a week after October 31 that year.
Gavai claimed the carnage was not on account of any errors on his part but rather because the Rajiv Gandhi Government at the Centre ‘‘deliberately delayed’’ calling in the Army when the mass killings began on November 1, 1984.
For Gavai, the Nanavati report completes a dubious hat trick. The retired Maharashtra cadre IAS officer said this was the third occasion he had been made the ‘‘fall guy’’.
The first time, he said, was when Rajiv Gandhi summoned him on November 2, 1984, and told him: ‘‘Gavaiji, you are a heart patient and you should now take rest.’’ Though he was advised to proceed on leave, Gavai chose to assume ‘‘moral responsibility’’ and resign the following day, after overseeing Indira Gandhi’s funeral.
Two years later, the Ranganath Misra Commission, while exonerating the Rajiv Gandhi Government — its home minister was P V Narasimha Rao, later to become premier himself — held Gavai should have ‘‘perhaps’’ assumed more than just moral blame and kept open ‘‘the extent of his responsibility’’.
Again in the Nanavati report, the blame for administrative lapses has not gone beyond Gavai, to the Union Home Ministry or even further up. ‘‘Gavai was the person responsible for the maintenance of law and order in Delhi,’’ the Nanavati report says baldly, ‘‘and, therefore, he cannot escape the responsibility for its failure.’’
But Gavai had another view. Though law and order of Delhi came directly under the jurisdiction of the Union Home Ministry, it was convenient for everybody, he alleged, to pin the blame on him. He ascribed this to two reasons: one, he was not a Congress politician, and, two, he belonged to the Scheduled Castes.
Gavai’s chief claim to innocence is that he had asked the then commissioner of Delhi Police, S C Tandon, to call in the Army right on the morning of November 1, when the violence had just begun. But for reasons beyond his control, the Army entered only two of the then six police districts of Delhi by the evening of November 1. It became effective in all districts as late as November 3. By then, hundreds of Sikhs had been slaughtered.
‘‘The sequence of events clearly tells a tale. Political authorities purposely wasted time in keeping with their nefarious design to teach Sikhs a lesson,’’ Gavai told The Indian Express. ‘‘(P V Narasimha) Rao was calling me up to only ask me to protect his friends.’’
When Rajiv Gandhi rebuked him at their November 2 meeting for not having acted swiftly in calling in the Army, Gavai, by his own admission, kept quiet. He saw no point in defending himself: ‘‘Who was I to delay the Army? Those who could have sent the Army had purposely delayed it. When I raised this with the then Army chief, he said these things (deployment) take time. The concern that was shown was all a drama.’’
Gavai regretted that even after 21 years, the Indian state was not prepared to ‘‘face up to the political complicity’’ in the massacre: ‘‘It’s a shame they are still engaged in that drama.’’