Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

holy books of other religion

holy books of other religion

nuri · 04 Aug 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fatehh has any one read other religious holybooks .. just to have knowladge what other religions says .. has any one read bible .. if so .. can you please tell me the link of it .. thank you waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fatehhh

Re: holy books of other religion

. · 04 Aug 2005

www.sacred-texts.com

Re: holy books of other religion

Bhopinder Singh · 04 Aug 2005

koran also

Re: holy books of other religion

Kulbir Singh · 05 Aug 2005

Before you go out to read religious books of other religions, I recommend that you first get thorough knowledge of Sikhi. Read Gurbani with meanings, Sikh history and books of Gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. Once you are well-versed in Gurbani and Gurmat, then you may go ahead and read books of other religons. Kulbir Singh

Re: holy books of other religion

nuri · 05 Aug 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fatehhh i just want to know in general .. that what makes sikhi different from christianity .. cuz in vancouver there are many many people who go from door to door telling about bible .. i m surprised to see that here .. loll .. n e ways .. does any one know what make them different... bhul chuk maafi ji waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: holy books of other religion

nuri · 05 Aug 2005

does guru ji said about christianity in bani ?

Re: holy books of other religion

nuri · 05 Aug 2005

what u say kulbir singh veerji .. about my above two posts .. does christianity believe in equal rights of women and men .. i kow they believe that all non christians would go to hell .. is that right ???

Re: holy books of other religion

no one · 05 Aug 2005

Christianity does not believe in equal rights for men and women and yes they do believe just like Muslims that ppl who do not follow their religion will go to hell. Sikhi believes in equality in gender, race etc. We belive only the one who Jap Naam and have amrit can merge with God (go to Sachkhand, the ultimate level). Other end up different lower levels such as heaven and hell.

Re: holy books of other religion

TUF · 05 Aug 2005

With knowledge and love of gurbani, its hard to look at other religious books as equal. THe bible is simply a story book with lots of loosely based on reality stories compiled together. Christians believe that you have to accept Jesus as the son of God in order to go to heaven.. If you don't accept this, then you will go to hell, no matter how good you are. This is very narrow minded in my opinion. The Bible is full of historical mistakes and inaccuracies. These are often downplayed by followers who are often stumped when one brings forth such arguments. The three western religions, Judaism (Jews), Chrisitanity and Islam all believe in the bible. As a part of these religions, they believe that women are the cause of mortal sin and the first sin was committed by Eve when she made Adam eat the forbidden fruit... from then on, all women are considered to be dispicable creatures that cannot be trusted. Further, these religions believe that women should be subordinate to man, becuz it was from man's rib that they were made so they owe men. This is sooooo absurd. The Koran of muslims and Torah of the jews have similar views on women. If anything, some hindu texts such as the bhagavad gita and the epics like ramayan and mahabarta may help to shed some light on Sikhi since these are often referred to throughout the Sri Guru Granth Sahib. Of course, I'd take these stories with a grain of salt... they've obviously been exaggerated to some extent. I'm not too sure about Buddhist Books, or the writings of Shinto or Daoist followers although Confucius has some interesting readings, but its more for a political state than a spiritual state. Again, I agree whole heartedly with Kulbir Singh, in that its important to know about Sikhi first, then you can look at other texts and get the most out of them. But as always, be skeptical and critical in what you read so you can get the good and ignore the bad out of these religious books.

Re: holy books of other religion

Parikh · 05 Aug 2005

I think its a great idea to expose ourselves to the philosophies of other religions. Part of Guru Nanak Dev Ji's message was one of the the essential truth of all religions. Broadening your understanding of other philosophies can only give you a truer, more deep understanding of what you believe. The most learned and most devout Sikhs are those who not only understand their own religion but also that of others. Understanding in this sense is not simply reading other books to criticize and see how Sikhism is "better" but rather should be part of an ongoing dialogue with people of other faiths to extend a brotherhood of well-intentioned believers. There is no reason why people of different faiths should have an honest discussion. Respectfully, Parikh

Re: holy books of other religion

Bhopinder Singh · 05 Aug 2005

In bani naam dhrian eesay moosay Bhai gurdas ji I migt be wrong in writing as I was told this by my father I think the shabad is Bhavjal andar bhambal bhoosay naam dharian= christian=new name eesay= jesus

Re: holy books of other religion

TUF · 05 Aug 2005

eesay = jesus and moosay = moses

Re: holy books of other religion

nuri · 06 Aug 2005

guru ji says there are hell and heaven ... we know who goes to hell .. as we read bhai sahib rama singh ji's bio .. but then who goes to heaven ... and does they get mukti just by going to heaven ??? i found out that none other religion teaches to get rid of maya [kaam , krodh, lobh , moh , ehankar] .. so does according to their religion do they get mukti when they go to heaven?