Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

"GRANTHI" is a Stepping stone" to ??

"GRANTHI" is a Stepping stone" to ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 02 Aug 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Today on the net I came across a LIST of "FORMER GRANTHIS" in Australia who have "retired" from Granthi and gone into other businesses and outside work. A Christian friend commented on this..This is UNIQUE.... Our Christian Priests go through a LONG PERIOD of Seminary studies etc and then become PRIESTS for LIFE....Same for the IMAMS, the Rabiis and the Monks of Buddhist temples and even the SWAMIS in the Hindu mandirs.. It is ONLY in the SIKH RELIGION that any "unemplyed" or "unemployable" person can walk in to a Gurdwara and becoem a GRANTHI/GYANI overnight...and then when he gets the PR/GREEN CARD etc..he walks out to become..??? whatever he really wanted to in the First Place. The Australian List has 15 names on it.... a WORLD RECORD... I dont think we can ever find such list of hindu priests, imamas, or Christian Priests. It is proof that "GRANTHI" is just a stepping stone towards PR/Green card for those who cant get in any other way... Any wonder then that we DONT have MUCH Parchaar coming out of GURDWARAS.....the "caretakers" are just bidding their time !!!! We spend BILLIONS making magnifiecent Gurdwaras..BUT NOTHING on the GRANTHIS who will be dedicated to GRANTHI for LIFE. IN MALAYSIA/SINGAPORE too the FIRST GENERATION of GRANTHIS were Granthis for LIFE...now the ones we "import" from punjab are just marking time until they get a chance to..fly away to Australia/canada...etc etc.. IF in the emantime they can do some HAVOC locally they grab the first chance..and then they have to be "chased away" to another gurdwara only too willing to give them a safe haven...for a while..until they fly away.. Jarnail Singh

Re: "GRANTHI" is a Stepping stone" to ??

Campaign Sewadar · 03 Aug 2005

Thanks for addressing the serious issue. The global Sikh Sangat really need to do something about this, we are open to abuse because we do not have a relavent structure in place. This is why we are such a bad situation within the UK. Freelance Granthis with business cards are the norm today. We have no database of who's who.

Re: "GRANTHI" is a Stepping stone" to ??

A Singh · 03 Aug 2005

Freelance Granthis are not the problem - but the fact that Gurdwaras and other pseudo Sikh-cultural/education buildings are safe-havens for illegal immigrants and at times 'terrorists' (as defined by the country of location). This is issue that needs to be seriously tackled... Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: "GRANTHI" is a Stepping stone" to ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Aug 2005

"FREE LANCES" are for MUNDANE things like selling cars, life insurance... A SERIOUS THING like RELIGION ??? handled by Free lancers..No wonder we are a JOKE ??? Were there any "FREE LANCERS" during Guru Ji's time....?? absolutely NOT... ONLY GURMUKHI JEEWAN waleh GURMUKHS like Bhai manjh, Bhai Gurdass Ji...etc etc No wonder we now have FREE LANCE GURBANI "TEACHERS"...who work full time at other Jobs durign the week.... others are Free lance "PUNJABI TEACHERS"..simply because they are PUNJAB BORN !! (Natives ) Just like Many GORAY cant even write ABC...MOST PUNJABIS from PUNJAB dont even know what GURMUKHI is....they write HINDI...but when they come here we make them PUNJABI LANGUAGE TEACHERS.. WHAT do these TEACHERS TEACH...GIDDHA and BHANGRRA..not PUNJABI.

Re: "GRANTHI" is a Stepping stone" to ??

A Singh · 03 Aug 2005

Gyani Sahib, The issue for the point you restate boils down to the worth one puts on matters such as Gyanis, Vidvaans and ‘Ragis’ proper – we have all this bull talk of ‘it should be free seva’ and hence, why you have part timers, be they honest folk otherwise – no one wants to put their money down for education or funding the appropriate institution, the same applies to Keertanias, with their pankhandi tunes – because no one wishes to learn raag proper and largely because “the sangat prefers “SIMPLE” tunes – what the hell??? The Khalsa of Shah-e-shahen-Shah are ‘simpletons’????? So it’s hardly surprising then when one or two learned scholars, granthis, ragis or kathavachaks do turn up, the modern day “TAT” Khalsa are quick to write them off, because they accept fees for their services, or because they sing with too much “oooo-eeee” [this is the cultural appreciation of the highly spiritual and uplifted gurmukhs of today when it comes to classical raag]. The result of all of this, is either free-booters, like those you described or those above who learn a few catchy tunes on a vaja and can’t play tabla to save their lives and kick off their tax-free earning keertania careers or we have honest folk who wish to make a difference for the youth to the best of their ability and given we have no authenticated approving body for gyanis, vidvaans, ragis etc proper, they opt to do the seva themselves albeit with their limited experience and/or knowledge – this is usually a honest attempt, so I don’t believe we should be deriding them altogether, for they are far better than the free-booters in the first camp.. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: "GRANTHI" is a Stepping stone" to ??

charanjeev singh · 04 Aug 2005

Just a little point. We refer to 'raagis', - those who know 'raags', are 'raagis' How many raagis are there now? A few jewels still exist. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh