Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

Amandeep Madra · 01 Aug 2005

How would you like to have access to almost 100 years of illustrated newspaper articles about Punjabis in the Press? The United Kingdom Punjab Heritage Association’s new website http://www.punjabarchive.org brings you closer to that ultimate on line reference source. The new website has been described by BBC Television’s South Asia Correspondent, Navdip Dhariwal as [i]“a fascinating window into Punjab's history. . . great journalism from the past coupled with innovative technology makes [URL=http://www.punjabarchive.org]punjabarchive.org[/URL] a fascinating, informative and fun experience "[/i] This is the first step taken to create an electronic web-based archive highlighting the extensive body of material relating to the Punjab as reported in illustrated and non illustrated Victorian newspapers. The material graphically illustrates the shared heritage and contribution of Punjabis in world history, especially in relation to the building of the British Empire in the second half of the 19th century. Nearly all of the newspapers are profusely illustrated with evocative woodblock engravings and photographs, and cover a range of events and characters, many significant, some curious but nearly all little known. Highlights of the important events between Punjabi Muslims, Hindus and Sikhs with the British include: The land and people of the Punjab ruled by Maharaja Ranjit Singh The two Anglo-Sikh wars (1845-6, 1848-9) and subsequent annexation of the Punjab to British India in 1849 Maharaja Duleep Singh – the first Sikh known to have settled in England in 1854. The Punjabi contribution to the development of the British Empire in military campaigns in Asia, Africa and Europe (1860s - 1900s) The largely unheralded role of Punjabis in World War I and II UKPHA The UK Punjab Heritage Association (“UKPHA”) is a non-profit voluntary organisation based in Greater London. The Association was founded in 2001 to foster the appreciation of the Punjabi heritage in Britain and encourage the preservation of endangered items of the Punjabi material heritage. If you have a query, require assistance with your own projects or would like to support us, please contact us on [address removed] [%sig%]

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

bachan vidya · 02 Aug 2005

these are the same people who have been helping Uk nang parchaar. Amandeep is not bad, but paramjit is niddar no2 chela after jolly jagdeep, chief webmaster! The website is probably fine, but have these so-called historians corrected all the lies that appear on niddars sites. They have been pointed out so many times!!! The UK punjabi heritage association is just a group doing this to keep getting funding, when behind the scenes it is dedicated to nang parchaar.

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

ns · 02 Aug 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Bachan vidya , I must say I agree whole heartedly. Amandeep Ji this is excellent work , excellent for the upcoming sikh youth to delve into and to read about the history. But unfortunately I must also stress that Parmjit, Niddar are one in many projects, let's hope they don't disturb sikhe and stop nindyia of our mahan shaeeds of the panth especially the singh sabha movement. I originally began to contribute to UKPHA but stopped after hearing views of Parmjit Singh, this Sikh is well confused or a different mission altogether.Apologies I don't want this thread to focuse nangs and niddar but Amanadeep Ji , it's gonna get highlighted where ever you do your parchar and works due to assocation with Parmjit Singh

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

ss · 02 Aug 2005

It is unfortunate that such an important topic such as research into Sikh History has these Nang types dicrediting it. many people wanted to get involved with these projects but the Nangs have put them off. We must careful that they do not distort Sikh History by introducing idol worship and Devis etc.

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

JS · 03 Aug 2005

Amandeep should publicly distance himself from Parmjit and Niddar , this Nakali Nihang cult they pushing is damaging genuine research into Sikh History. They support Santa Singh who was Indira Gandhis servant and this person below in the news item does not come out well. The Akali Nihangs after the British occupation and under Indian rule have been heavily infiltrated by the Government. The Tribune SGPC urged to take over gurdwaras under Phoola Our Correspondent Amritsar, August 6 Col G.S. Sandhu, Chairman, Majha Ex-Servicemen Human Rights Front, and president, Poohla Eviction Committee, today urged the Jathedar, Akal Takht, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, and Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (SGPC) to take over the historic and other gurdwaras which are in illegal possession of Ajit Singh Poohla, self-styled Nihang chief of the Taruna Dal here. He appealed to Capt Amarinder Singh, Punjab Chief Minister, to order an enquiry by the Vigilance Department or some other independent and appropriate agency against the Nihang chief who had allegedly amassed a large illegal property at various places in Punjab by grabbing land and other illegal means. He alleged that at many gurdwaras under his illegal occupation he had built airconditioned mansions and was openly stealing electricity by kundi connections. Col Sandhu said five fresh cases of abduction and murders had come to light and his committee was collecting concrete evidence in this regard. He said the committee would soon make efforts to get FIRs registered against Poohla, who is in judicial remand.

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

Amandeep Madra · 03 Aug 2005

I am really astounded by some of the responses, Parmjit can defend himself I am writing here to respond to the specific allegations about this new website and UKPHA. First off, look at the site, www.punjabarchive.org is a collection of illustrated Victorian Newspapers and early journalism connected to the Punjab. The content sheds light onto the early colonial view of Sikhs. It is an extension in many ways of the textual accounts that are presented in "Sicques, Tigers or Thieves" a book that Parmjit and I published with Palgrave Macmillan earlier this year. Punjabarchive is a database that we hope to expand. Over the next few months we hope to include older newspapers (from the 1700s) and a really recent database of news stories and editorials highlighting the destruction of Sikh heritage in India and Pakistan. Alongside this will be photography that Parmjit and I have collected over the years about Sikh material heritage. the intention is to provide a positive, rich and scholarly space on the internet relating to Punjabi and Sikh heritage. "ss" this site neither 'discredits' Sikh history nor does it 'introduce idol worship' - calm down and get a sense of perspective The "Nang" tag is quite honestly laughable, childish, extremely offensive and just plain ridiculous. Measure us and UKPHA by its output not by hysteria, paranoia and hearsay on the web. Since 2001 we've carried out a full day seminar on "Preserving Sikh Heritage" at the V&A, conducted two sets of 7-month long lecture series at the V&A and a national set of 36 lectures at four separate venues all over the country. We've published "Warrior Saints" and "Sicques" and now this new website. Please measure us on our output not on internet warriors who don’t even have the courage to use their own names but spread rumour and slander. UKPHA is certainly not a front for funding nidaar or any other websites. This is simply untrue - and I suspect that "bachan vidyia" knows it. I would ask that the ADMINS remove that lie from this thread. Like virtually all Sikh projects these endeavours have sucked up thousands of pounds of my own money and they certainly don’t leave a surfeit for any purpose - let alone "nang parchaar" Finally, history and ideologies will always clash - they have been at odds for thousands of years and they have in dozens of other faiths - it's one of those facts of life. I enjoy researching and writing on Sikh history but unfortunately it wont always validate a particular religious belief or a religious interpretation of history - your job is to try to reconcile the differences not lynch the historians, burn the books or respond with lies and personal slander. "bachan vidya" - you know who I am so get in touch and talk to me before you post this kind of rubbish. Amandeep

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

MS · 03 Aug 2005

Excellent, really liked this website and agree that its ultimatly a view of what the oppressors thought of us and a collection of evidence against them. Keep it up. With regards to the Nider association, sad if its true. We should all realize the simple fact that back in the day is no different to today, simply because Nider might be able to prove Sikhs of the time may have eaten dead bodies of animals, worshiped hindu raggie dolls....... DOES NOT CHANGE THE FACT THAT GURBANI i.e. Guroo Sahib is against it therefore such ppl and acts are not truly representative of Sikhi therefore invalidating their whole view..... regardless of if this site plays into NiderIdeology or not. i.e. their ultimatly wrong because Guroo being sumpreme disagrees with them! So its on that point we should base our parchar on what Guroo Sahib says not the history of men and people. People are weak, Guroo is right for eternety, invest in Guroo!

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

*.* · 03 Aug 2005

Amandeep Madra good work, i think your doing an excellent seva which shows what the europeans perpective of Sikhs and Punjabi's was back in the day I will stress one thing, that the articles are only the perspective of the europeans therefore should be taken with a pinch of salt and not be taken as a primary source in understanding the maryada of the Sikhs back then The press can not be relied upon to be unbias in todays day and age, God knows what it must have been back then, especially when europeans main aim was to conquer Punjab and once conquered, to maintain there power Anyway its very interesting to know, we need to ensure articles and journals as such are preserved for future generations

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

Bhopinder Singh · 03 Aug 2005

Amandeep Madra ji I am requesting you to give me name and phone number of the American who participated in the seminar held at pearson convention center I think Parmjit singh participated in that and your co authored books were distributed on the ocassion It is very urgent you can send this to Admin and they can mail me PLEASE He was from SIMTHOSIAN i could br wrong in my spellings

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

bachan vidya · 03 Aug 2005

Amandeep Madra wrote: > The "Nang" tag is quite honestly laughable, childish, extremely > offensive and just plain ridiculous. Measure us and UKPHA by > its output not by hysteria, paranoia and hearsay on the web. the nang title was first introduced by Niddar to Bhai Fauja singh, Sant Jarnail Singh, and all the true modern day shaheeds. The fact that we call the real shaheeds Mahan, and these jokers from southall and birmingham nangs is only what they deserve. I am measuring UKPHA by it output which is identical to niddars websites, pushing the same agenda. Parmjit is Niddar main man, so the link is undeniable. > Please measure us on our output not on internet warriors who don’t > even have the courage to use their own names but spread rumour > and slander. You mean the internet warriors like Jagdep hounslow and his 20+aliases on so many messageboards. How can you all talk of slander when nang websites contain nothing but slander. was the 1978 killing of innocent sikhs justifiable? According to these sites it was the innocent singhs who were so-called militants and at fault. What kind of historical study or outright lie is that! lets not even start about everything these sites have said about Sant Jarnail and Sant kartar singh..... > > UKPHA is certainly not a front for funding nidaar or any other > websites. This is simply untrue - and I suspect that "bachan > vidyia" knows it. I have not seen any evidence to the contary. Openly state that you have no link with Parmjit, then it might be a start. If not, then accept association with these nangs and its baggage! > > Finally, history and ideologies will always clash - they have > been at odds for thousands of years and they have in dozens of > other faiths - it's one of those facts of life. I enjoy > researching and writing on Sikh history but unfortunately it > wont always validate a particular religious belief or a > religious interpretation of history - your job is to try to > reconcile the differences not lynch the historians, burn the > books or respond with lies and personal slander. I am not condoning any sort of censorship, only asking for historians to not disguise blatant lies as historical study. Nang websites are based on lies, which are the backbone of niddars philosophy. > > "bachan vidya" - you know who I am so get in touch and talk to > me before you post this kind of rubbish. > > Amandeep I think we should have an open debate about UKPHA. It is us taxpayers who are funding it. Why not discuss its links, its aims and objectives, and why niddars group dominate it and its funding to promote their sick thinking. Why is Parmjit singh using it to badmouth the Singh Sabha movement? Do you agree with what Parmjit says in his lectures? The only people who seem threatened by the Singh Sabha Movement are those who wish to go back to mahant times and idol worship, similar to what Niddar wants. Why do you think UKPHA is so anti-Singh Sabha?

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

Singh · 03 Aug 2005

I respect Amandeep Singh as a historian, but parmjit singh is a different character. He openly has links with the UK 'Nihangs', and has the same stance as them such as bad mouthing the Singh Sabha and Akali movements etc. It seems like a new generation of Sikh academics in the UK have followed in the path of the McLeodian group of western academics who with their Euro-centric thoughts interpret Sikhism and it’s history according to questionable and even tampered historical documents rather than the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee.

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

ns · 03 Aug 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Amandeep and Parmjit Ji , no matter what your output and seva is for Sikh history, Parmjit and Niddar have made a grave mistake by doing nindiya openly of our Shaeeds of the Singh Sabha movement and the recent 78,84 movements. Until you guys either admit or apologize to the panth for this and remove all the slandar on the nang sites you will always carry that stain with you. What I find surprising that you two are educated individuals of the UK cannot come up with the courage and admit your mistake. I look forward to your replies to bachan vidyia.

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

ouch · 03 Aug 2005

doesn't work in firefox whatever doesn't work in firefox is no good for me

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

ks · 04 Aug 2005

Niddar attacks the Shaheeds all the time and Parmjit is involved with this. This Nang cult was created in the late 80's to counter the Singh's by the Indian Govt , this is its Uk setup. Recently the Sikhs in the Uk have been raising issues about their identity and human rights , expect the nangs sponsors to increase their activities.

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

Niranjan Singh · 04 Aug 2005

>> I respect Amandeep Singh as a historian... Historian huh ???? That's a scary thought ! On several forums Amardeep Madara has openly stated that Dumallas and Chand-Torras represent Shiva's head and private parts. He stated he learned that from Santa Nihang's Buddha Dal, and then he ridicules Panth respected Baba Nihal Singh of Harian-Velan for his gurmat based opinions. This can all be found under www.SikhSangat.com forums. I appreciate Amandeep Singh's research on old Sikh paintings and photography, but that hardly makes one an historian. Especially someone who presents certain aspects of Sikhi in such a biased angle. He should openly distance himself from the likes of Paramjit and Niddar, and them he might get some credibility.

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

Amandeep Madra · 04 Aug 2005

Actually Niranjan Singh I've written about the Chand Torra on the Tapoban site - you can do your Sherlock Holmes impression on this site as well. I also always use my own name and use my email address. More than can be said for some! If you take the trouble to actually read what I’ve written you'll see that I reported that the symbolism of the chand torra according to the Buddha Dal is deeply rooted in Shiv symbolism. Some of the counter theories about it being a Nike-like swoosh or just poor craftsmanship are pretty ridiculous. At the end of the day, if you don’t like what the Buddha Dal has to say on the matter you can a) ignore it b) try to reconcile it with your own beliefs but it's pretty childish to simply throw mud at me because I present that bit of evidence you don’t like the sound of. That’s why there comes a point in every email debate when you stop. and on that note, bachanvidya will obviously never believe that UKPHA is not some kind of funding vassal for "nang parchaar" so I'm not even going to respond to his paranoid little fantasy. The offer is always open for him to talk to me - he knows exactly how to get hold of me. I suspect he wont and will continue instead to just spew his madness on the net. I cant openly distance myself from Parmjit, I write with him, I research with him, we are good friends. I will most likely continue to work with him. He is one of the finest researchers that I have ever met and a really excellent photographer, scholar and gentleman. Both Warrior Saints and "Sicques, Tigers or Thieves" were immense research efforts, and bringing to light all of the really rare and inaccessible primary resources to the wider Sikh community are a testament to Parmjit's resolute and scholarly approach. As for Nidar Singh, well I don’t really have any relationship as such with him, I’ve seen him a few times in the last 6-7 years, the last time was a talk in London. I've got more of a relationship with "ns" and his friends and some really fine upstanding AKJ/Taksal youth in West London - are they also part of the "nang" nexus that you accuse me of simply because we are one or two degrees of separation away ? Aman

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

haha · 04 Aug 2005

is that Thee Buddha Dal or pakandi niddar b Dal

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

bachan vidya · 04 Aug 2005

you have presented no evidence to the contrary. Just childish putdowns, denial, or dismissal. the facts speak for themselves. Further you say you have no association with Niddar. Are you sure? What is your stand on Buddhal dal so called maryada compared to the Singh sabha one? plus you totally ignored all my last questions.....what a historian who cannot debate??? Why is Parmjit singh using UKPHA to badmouth the Singh Sabha movement? Do you agree with what Parmjit says in his lectures? The only people who seem threatened by the Singh Sabha Movement are those who wish to go back to mahant times and idol worship, similar to what Niddar wants. Why do you think UKPHA is so anti-Singh Sabha? amandeep wrote: and on that note, bachanvidya will obviously never believe that UKPHA is not some kind of funding vassal for "nang parchaar" so I'm not even going to respond to his paranoid little fantasy. The offer is always open for him to talk to me - he knows exactly how to get hold of me. I suspect he wont and will continue instead to just spew his madness on the net.

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

uk singh · 04 Aug 2005

bachan vidya - why don't you respond to Amandeep via email. Just because he knows Parmjit Singh, does not mean he shares the sa

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

indy · 04 Aug 2005

i think aman sud distance himself from the uk nangs parmjit is one plus a few others behind the scenes aman agress with the anti 84 stand of these nangs as for a historian who gives a crap sikhi is about practice and not artwork and forgetting what we are here for to do nam simran and sewa at soho rd.

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

uk singh · 05 Aug 2005

bachan vidya - why don't you respond to Amandeep via email. Just because he knows Parmjit Singh, does not mean he shares the same sentiments as Parmjit?? Slating him on this site is not very constructive. If you live in the UK, why not arrange a meeting. Venting your anger on this site is not very productive to you or Amandeep and nothing will be resolved.

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

Singh · 05 Aug 2005

The issue of Sanatanism is now virtually a non issue; they have essentially faded from the limelight and do very little. Webmaster Veer Jagdeep Singh Ji was marvellously introspective when he made the comment on his website: "In time, these bitter and cowardly Sikh zealots will fade away into the recesses of time and remain confined in their small circles of hypocrisy."

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

bachan vidya · 05 Aug 2005

coz when you speak to them face to ace, they say they will change their websites, but they never do. They are really two-faced. This is why I want an open debate. Why is amandeep having so many problems answering the question i have poed about UKPHA and the nangs? he has at no time distanced himself from them, neither has said at anytime he disagrees with them? he has no even disclosed why UKPHA has such an anti-Singh Sabha agenda? Simple questions......... I am not slating him, just asking the REAL questions??? uk singh wrote: > bachan vidya - why don't you respond to Amandeep via email. > Just because he knows Parmjit Singh, does not mean he shares > the same sentiments as Parmjit?? > > Slating him on this site is not very constructive. If you live > in the UK, why not arrange a meeting. > > Venting your anger on this site is not very productive to you > or Amandeep and nothing will be resolved.

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

Admin · 05 Aug 2005

Thread closed. Admin.

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

. · 20 Sep 2005

good site

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

Jpeg · 21 Sep 2005

Madra Sahib, this is also something that I cannot understand. Why would someone like yourself who is very much a scholar in the western mould would still associate let alone co-author books with parmjeet Singh? I can understan Warrior Saints because during that time Parmjeet was not known outside some circles for his nang views. Now that he is well known as a nang ideologue both in the UK as well as in Canada you should understand why your association with him is suspect. If you lie with dogs you get fleas! As for the UKPHA, didn't Parmjeet Singh as well as Niddar Singh also give lectures and I persume get funding for these lectures?

Re: Introducing www.punjabarchive.org

Jpeg · 21 Sep 2005

I agree that a debate should be open. As Amandeep Singh has posted here in order to highlight the UKPHA website then he should be prepared to answer any questions posed by both Bachan Vidya and anyone else. There is no need to badmouth anyone or claim that anyone's questions are 'rubbish'. The whole idea of a forum is somewhere where frank and honest discussions can take place. Rather than asking for personal interaction maybe Amandeep Singh can answer the questions put to him. On a personal note I chose not to buy any of the books co-authored by Amandeep Singh and Paramjeet Singh solely because I do not wish my money or whatever percentage of my money to go towards promoting the nang agenda. The same goes for the UKPHA lectures. Something that Amandeep Singh may wish to ponder over.