Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Question for Respect Campaign

Question for Respect Campaign

Gopi · 31 Jul 2005

Hi I've just come home from one of the weddings that was disrupted by Singhs to stop the Guru Granth Sahib Ji being taken into a hall in order to perform the Anand Karaj. I am not a praticising sikh - but read this forum regularly to gain some understanding. I therefore humbly submit some questions below which should not be taken in offence - I am just looking for some answers. In this case, the protest was successful - which resulted in the wedding party having to travel from Lakeside to SOUTHAMPTON in order to complete the Anand Karaj (which meant that the actual ceremony took place around 2pm!). Luckily - the whole sorry episode passed without any violence for which I am grateful. After the wedding party left for Southampton- I came out of the hall to talk to one of the protestors as I have read some of the 'respect' posts on this forum - and there are still I believe unanswered questions. This Singh was unable to answer my queries - so I hope that someone from the campaign can answer for me on this forum? 1. What difference is there to someone taking the Guru Granth Sahib to their house for an Akhand Path and having frozen meat in their fridge or Alcohol in their cupboards than to taking to a hall for a wedding? the offending items are still present there - but not being eaten/drunk when the maharaj is present The hall in Lakeside was completely separate to the 'party' hall - there was no alcohol or meat or smoking anywhere near it? ie. are all Akhands Path held in homes to be banned? 2. What about all the copies of the Guru Granth Sahib that people have in their houses - are they to all be confiscated if the holy book is kept on a shelf or in a drawer? 3. Why does the campaign target families? What these people managed to do today was to destroy what should be the happiest day of their lives for two young people. Why is the campaign not targetting Gurudwaras - as it is them at the end of the day which allow the Guru Granth Sahib to be taken away? Why are decent law abiding families being targetted as the enemy? I believe the girls' family was approached by the campaign (via telephone only) to re-arrange the wedding. I think it would have been better if the campaign helped by going to these peoples house and helping them re-arrange? What action is being taken to follow up with the Gurudwara which allowed this? 4. Most weddings in Gurdwaras are followed up by some member of the Gurdwara commitee 'begging' for money for the building fund. They do this because they know they have a 'captive audience' - why is this not being tackled because it is taking advantage of the fact that people are there for a wedding? 5.Why is the main Gurdwara in Southall CHARGING familes up to £1000 to hold the Anand Karaj ceremony - is this not against Sikhi? Is this not taking advantage of people? 6. Where did the group who protested at Lakeside today come from? When I got to the location - I saw the protestors laughing and joking. There was also 2-3 girls with them who were obviously not amritdhari (eg. Dyed & Cut hair) - what right have they got to be there? Whilst I felt very sorry for the family today - they could have avoided this whole situation when warned previously - and in this respect I am 100% behind the campaign. However, it is very distressing to see this in person and I had/have a sick feeling in my stomach from todays events. Whilst the campaign is targetting families who do this - what actions are being taken against the corrupt and hypocritical Gurudware commitees who are the real people to blame? All that is happening now is that this campaign is alienating a huge chunk of sikh/punjabi society because all they see is people laughing/joking whilst the wedding of their son or daughter is destroyed. If any of the questions above offend, my sincere apologies - whilst I will never be an amritdhari - I learn a lot from this forum and hope that this post can be taken in the spirit it is intended - honest and non-critical curiosity. Thanks, Gopi

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Dandilion · 01 Aug 2005

Gopi ji, you pose some good questions that we all need to discuss. <<< 1. What difference is there to someone taking the Guru Granth Sahib to their house for an Akhand Path and having frozen meat in their fridge or Alcohol in their cupboards than to taking to a hall for a wedding? the offending items are still present there - but not being eaten/drunk when the maharaj is present >>> You are right, all meat /alcohol should be removed from the house and the home thoroughly cleansed before Guru Ji comes in. However, a house and a ‘club’ are totally different things. A club is where people smoke/eat meat/drink alcohol/swear/puke/and foul things occur. The whole atmosphere is geared towards this, unlike a home. <<<< The hall in Lakeside was completely separate to the 'party' hall - there was no alcohol or meat or smoking anywhere near it? >>>> I don’t think issue is whether these things happen in the actual hall, if it is happening in the premises then the whole place is desecrated is it not? <<<< 2. What about all the copies of the Guru Granth Sahib that people have in their houses - are they to all be confiscated if the holy book is kept on a shelf or in a drawer? >>>> First of all, it is ‘saroop’ not copies and yes Guru Ji must be removed from such places. <<<< 3. Why does the campaign target families? What these people managed to do today was to destroy what should be the happiest day of their lives for two young people. Why is the campaign not targetting Gurudwaras - as it is them at the end of the day which allow the Guru Granth Sahib to be taken away? Why are decent law abiding families being targetted as the enemy? >>>> The campaign as far as I know does not only target the families, great efforts are being made to get the Gurdwaras to comply. But some committees are very pig-headed and will not listen. Families are contacted because they are the people who can change the whole situation quickly. <<<< I believe the girls' family was approached by the campaign (via telephone only) to re-arrange the wedding. I think it would have been better if the campaign helped by going to these peoples house and helping them re-arrange? What action is being taken to follow up with the Gurudwara which allowed this? >>> Agreed, but you must understand that the phone is probably the best place to start as some people may become very hostile if you turn up on their door step. <<<< 4. Most weddings in Gurdwaras are followed up by some member of the Gurdwara commitee 'begging' for money for the building fund. They do this because they know they have a 'captive audience' - why is this not being tackled because it is taking advantage of the fact that people are there for a wedding? >>>> Agreed, but one thing at a time. <<<< 5.Why is the main Gurdwara in Southall CHARGING familes up to £1000 to hold the Anand Karaj ceremony - is this not against Sikhi? Is this not taking advantage of people? >>>>> Then the Gurdwara should be approached and asked why it is doing this. <<<< 6. Where did the group who protested at Lakeside today come from? When I got to the location - I saw the protestors laughing and joking. There was also 2-3 girls with them who were obviously not amritdhari (eg. Dyed & Cut hair) - what right have they got to be there? >>> These girls may not be amridhari, but at least they had the conscience to be there to support the cause, unlike may amritdharies who should have been there. You are not a practicing Sikh and yet you have concerns, maybe these girls were the same? <<<< Whilst I felt very sorry for the family today - they could have avoided this whole situation when warned previously - and in this respect I am 100% behind the campaign. However, it is very distressing to see this in person and I had/have a sick feeling in my stomach from todays events.>>>> Gobi Ji, I understand your concern, BUT Guru Ji must be in the forefront in our thoughts and Guru Ji’s respect must be our prime concern. <<<<< Whilst the campaign is targetting families who do this - what actions are being taken against the corrupt and hypocritical Gurudware commitees who are the real people to blame? All that is happening now is that this campaign is alienating a huge chunk of sikh/punjabi society because all they see is people laughing/joking whilst the wedding of their son or daughter is destroyed. >>> I hope nobody was laughing/joking as this is a very serious issue. We must start to NAME and SHAME those granthies/Gianis/committees that are doing these things. NAME IMAGE and SHAME these people on websites on posters on leaflets that can be handed out at Gurdwaras in areas where there people do their dirty work.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

RespectForSriGuruGranthSahibJi · 01 Aug 2005

Respect for Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Campaign Press Release Over 100 Sikhs protest at the Lakeside Country Club, Camberely, Surrey. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! With Guru Ji's kirpa members of the Campaign resolved 2 separate issues this weekend where Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji was to be taken banqueting halls in Wembley and Docklands to perform 'Sikh' wedding ceremonies. We would like to thank the families who eventually co-operated with the Campaign and re-arranged the weddings at local Gurdwara Sahibs. There remained 1 unresolved issue where Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji was to be taken to the LAKESIDE COUNTRY CLUB in Camberley, Surrey to perform a 'Sikh' wedding ceremony on Sunday (31 July 2005). Regardless of the discussions and meetings that the local Sangat had with the family, who live in Southall, they were still willing to go against the Akaal Takht Hukumnama. This was despite being able to have the wedding ceremony re-arranged at a local Southall Gurdwara at short notice. On 31 July 2005 over 100 Sikhs from around the UK gathered together to peacefully protest at the Lakeside Country Club and prevent the Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji from being taken into the complex where meat, alcohol and cigarettes are served. A Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji was brought from Guru Granth Gurdwara - Mangat Hall, Southall by Tarlochan Singh Grewal. This individual, who is in a responsible position of running the Gurdwara, transported the Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji in a suitcase placed on the front seat of his van. Due to the large presence of Sikhs, Tarlochan Singh Grewal fled the scene and was unable to take Guru Ji's saroop into the premises. There was no further successful attempt to take Guru Ji's saroop onto the premises as the large presence of Sikhs hindered the entry. The family eventually re-arranged the Sikh wedding ceremony to a Gurdwara Sahib in Southampton. The Sikhs then moved on to Guru Granth Gurdwara-Mangat Hall to confront Tarlochan Singh Grewal. Five chosen Sikhs tried to peacefully discuss the issue with Tarlochan Singh Grewal, who has persistently gone against the Akaal Takht Hukumnama and taken Guru Ji's Saroop to bars, clubs, pubs, hotels etc on numerous occasions. However, he was insistent that he had done anything wrong by denying the act and stating that he does not follow any Akaal Takht Hukumnama. A further confrontational statement was made by Tarlochan Singh Grewal's son-in-law who said that they do not acknowledge any Hukumnama or Sangat request about being responsible for taking Sir Guru Granth Sahib Ji's saroop to places where meat, alcohol and cigarettes are served. He further stated that they would continue to take Guru Ji's saroop to these kinds of venues and no one would be able to stop them. Guru ji's Saroop was then taken by the Sikhs from Guru Granth Gurdwara-Mangat Hall to a Sachkhand of another Gurdwara Sahib. It is with great shame to know that Gurdwaras have better links with Banqueting Halls and Hotels than it has with its own Sangat. People like Tarlochan Singh Grewal are not ignorant to the disrespect they cause to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. They have sold their conscious and make a living out of deceit, lying to families and taking Guru Ji wherever anyone wants. Their charges range from £500 upwards depending of level of service. When did Guru Ji and Sikh Maryada become a commodity for sale or a service to be provided to suit us? On these grounds, we thus implore the Sikh community in general, whether they are involved in the offending marriage ceremonies or not, to take a step backwards and reconsider where Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji stands in their life. Is the respect we display to Guru Sahib hollow and ritualistic, or does Guru Sahib really stand at the centre of our lives? Are we truly Sikhs of the Guru? By showing the appropriate respect to Guru Sahib and giving as much love and respect as possible, there can be no doubt that Guru Ji himself will bless us in our every day living and make our life more worthwhile. GurFateh! Respect For Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Campaign. Tel: 07944-445651 Email: [address removed] www.GuruGranthSahibJi.com

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Respect for guru granth sahib · 01 Aug 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa whaeguru ji ki fateh paji i was also there at the protest too....im not sure whether or not you are aware of what actually happend before the actually protest.....this week there was 3 planned weddings to take place at hotels/clubs!! with guru ji's kirpa the other 2 agreed to move their weddings, to gurdwaree. this amily was also approached, not y'day, but several weeks ago...a singh, whi was invited to the wedding, by the name of khera, who was also at the wedding told the family, 3months ago do not do the wedding at a hall, as the hukamnama from siri akal takht in 1998 has stopped this from happening...as maharaj is beadbi is happening!! this family, who's son and daughter were getting married (sandio and satpal), were also approached by the respect for guru granth ashib campaign members and a benthi was done that the wedding location was moved, the families told the singhs that the wedding hall (where maharaj was to be) and the party hall was miles away, which was false, it was actually metres!! the familes were asked to move the wedding else where...the family responded by saying that they couldnt afford it, as they had paid a huge amount for the halls, which were non-refundable....the singhs replied that we would pay for any charge occured at the g'wara! the sikh missionary g'wara in southall was booked for the families, and all expenses were to be paid for by the campaigners, but the families said no!! what was wrong with the house of the guru, u want guru ji to wed the couple, but instead of u going to gru ji for the blessing, the guru has to come to you?? the family had even made suggestion on the day, that can we do the sedding in a warehouse! find us a local warehouse, etc?? a dirty warehouse is where u want our guru to be taken? the family were told that g'wara is available in southall - 20miles away, approx (both families are from southall) but instead they chose to go 40miles away to southampton, to a g'wara there!! i myself was approached by many guests, to ask what was going on, many guests were agreeing with what we was doing there, one woman guest had even informed me that she her slef asked the familes why they were doing this, as taking maharaj into a club is forbidden, the woman told us that the mother of the couple had said that they had seeked permission. from who is the question?? this ppl were given sufficinent notice, not a day, or 2 days, or even 3 that some of the guests had said, but in fact weeks! you said that maharaj was going to be in a differnt hall!! phaji did u go inside the hall and have a look?? in this building was a bar!! guru maharaj was going to be taken into the vacinity of a bar...! phaji, guru gobind singh ji's horse would even enter a tobacco field...when guru ji realised that his horse wouldnt enter a field he wondered why, then they realised because of the tobacco...so why should maharaj go into a building where meat, alcohol and smoking had occoured on a regular basis?? the family had blatently lied to us, when the groom had said the hall was miles away..this was just a deterant so the campaigners wouldnt come down!! i totally agree with u that the g'waree shouldnt be charging £1000 for weddings...but money was not an issue in this wedding...the ragis that were doing the wedding were charging in the excess of £2000, so if we have the money available to pay this, what is half the amount to go to the g'wara?? the issue of getting the people who are providing guru maharaj has also begun...the problem is the respect for guru ji without a doubt has decresed over the years. maharaj can be provided for these weddings from a number of sources...the sources that we know of are being dealt with...but the problem is we dont know until the day of the wedding who is proving maharaj! y'day guru ji came from...magat hall i thing it is...n with guru ji's kirpa maharaj was later on taken from this g'wara!! these culprits must be target. if beadbi is being dne every1 should know about it! those who are targeted should be told that they will be named and shamed!! as this is the only thing left to do....guru ji is being treated a as a business, and that it is not!! the kirtanis that are doing this will alos be named and shamed, they have been approached and asked not to do this, but to them this is a business, and not about religion!! you question about those that have maharaj's saroop in there houses, kept on a shelf or drawers, this is another issue that needs to be dealt with!! this is our guru we are talking about, not the book as the majority of ppl see it as!!! it is time for the panth to wake up, not stop being push overs when it comes to ur guru's beadbi!! principles are principle and should be adheered to in what ever the situation, whether it is against our freinds or falmily, we are after all talking of the beadbi of our father!! the issue of akhand paths done at ppl's houses...this again is the fault of the g'waree....before maharaj is taken to any house, or into a car, everything should be checked the the g'waree!! there should be no traces of meat, alcohol, cigarettes, n questions need to be asked, of how maharaj is repect will be done!! thses issues all need to be dealt with...but u must be able to walk beofre u can run...we need to start somewhere, n with guru ji's kirpa we have started here!! with guru ji's blessing hopefully in the long term future beadbi can be reduced! you asked where the protest come from?? where ever guru ji's beadbi is being done, akal ourkh ki fauj will arrive...who ever feels the pain of the guru will arrive!! this is not about chodhur!! no body wants popularity, the aim is guru ji's respect!! the respect that our guru deserve..n which we should be giving regardless, not because we are being told do!! the girls you are talking about maybe weren't amrithdari, and may have had their hair dyed, etc....but they are there for the love of their guru!! you cannot say to ppl u shouldnt be there beacause of ur appearance..you are there for the love of ur guru!the guru is everybodys, we ask for sarbat da pala for a reason!! if the ppl doing the wedding had any love for the guru, the guru wouldnt have been forced to go into a bar/club area!! as you, i myself had a sick feeling in my stomach...as i could never imagine that a sikh of the guru, would ever even try and insult their guru in such a way!!i coult tell you some of the stories of the people that have disrespected the guru n how they have done this...these stories bring tears to your eyes, as the guru that has given us everything, we the "sikhs" of the guru can throw it all bak at the guru in such away!! it is up 2 us all to unite an treat the guru as our guru.if we see beadbi of the guru get up n speak....support those who are aginst the beadbi...n not just go along with things just beacuse it gives us an easier life, be it our freinds or family who are doing the beadbi....many of the singhs were abused verbally by the families...but we were not there to cause trouble, or retaliate back...we were there to simply stop the beadbi happening....n with maharaj's kirpa was achieved!!! dhan siri guru granth sahib maharj!! waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!!

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Singh · 01 Aug 2005

I am not from the RFGC but will try with my limited knowledge to answer you queries. 1. What difference is there to someone taking the Guru Granth Sahib to their house for an Akhand Path and having frozen meat in their fridge or Alcohol in their cupboards than to taking to a hall for a wedding? the offending items are still present there - but not being eaten/drunk when the maharaj is present Sorry but two wrongs do not equal a right. People sadly ritualistically have akhand paths etc at home and do not prepare the home for the Guru. You would not invite Guru Nanak around and than keep beer and whatever around the house. Both things are wrong, and show how little love such people have for the Guru. 2. What about all the copies of the Guru Granth Sahib that people have in their houses - are they to all be confiscated if the holy book is kept on a shelf or in a drawer? Another case of 2 wrongs not = a right. People who do not even know or respect the Maryada for Guru Sahib should not have the saroop in their homes full stop. 3. Why does the campaign target families? What these people managed to do today was to destroy what should be the happiest day of their lives for two young people. Why is the campaign not targetting Gurudwaras - as it is them at the end of the day which allow the Guru Granth Sahib to be taken away? Why are decent law abiding families being targetted as the enemy? Its very sad that families get caught up in this, but the real culprits are the fake money driven gyanies and not the RFGC. These fake gynanaies know exactly what will happen, however they only care for the money so lead and accommodate these poor families into this mistake. The RFGC is reacting to the biadbi and not creating it. The ones creating this problem is the very few individuals who have used this as a niche market to make money, despite troubles etc which BOTH the family and Sikhs get. 5.Why is the main Gurdwara in Southall CHARGING familes up to £1000 to hold the Anand Karaj ceremony - is this not against Sikhi? Is this not taking advantage of people? Good point, why do you not ask them. The Gurdwara was made from the humble donations of the SIkh, but now we can not even afford to marry our children there. However this has nothing to do with the RFGC who are also against this, but is the responsibility of the money driven committee of the Gurdwara. 6. Where did the group who protested at Lakeside today come from? When I got to the location - I saw the protestors laughing and joking. There was also 2-3 girls with them who were obviously not amritdhari (eg. Dyed & Cut hair) - what right have they got to be there? EVERYONE has the right to protest against the biadbi not just Amridhari’s. Rather than asking what gives them the right to be there what right do you have to say they should not do sewa! I feel really sorry for the families, however the people at fault here are the greedy money grabbers who arrange this ie the wedding planners and fake gyanies.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

S Singh · 01 Aug 2005

Please do not take this the worng way I am not having a go at you. Why are you questioning the Hukumnama of the Akal Takht ? Do you question your teachers at school etc why the letter A has a particular sound etc ? The vulgar practice of taking Guru Ji to halls is banned that is the end of the story. If the girls family were not contacted and informed of the Hukumnama then I could understand your concerns. From what I understand the girls family were told prior to the wedding. If they still insist on undertaking an act of profanity then they are plain stupid if they expect no protests. If you are worried about Akhand Path in peoples homes then feel free to approach the Akal Takht secetariat and raise the issue just as the issue of tkaing Guru Ji to hotels etc was raised. As for £1000 costs for a wedding. There are plenty of Gurdwara in the UK who do not charge that much. Anyway if people can shell out £10-£20K for a hotel lunch then whats the big deal with paying £1K to the Gurdwara. Perhaps you could ask the family to stay behind and clear the dishes/rubbish up form the langar hall after the cha, samosa etc have been served. The girls family have only themselves to blame. They cant blame others for their obvious stupidity. Good thing is they may learn from this.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Campaign Sewadar · 01 Aug 2005

Firstly, there is a difference between holy books & Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. The below questions have come about because Gopi believes Guruji to be a book and not the living embodiment of Waheguru. 1. Please look at the bigger picture, why should we abuse Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji & Sikh Maryada in the name of convenience and a wedding reception? No-one can justify that they wish to hold an Anand Karaj in a Banqueting Hall for Guruji and the reception is secondary issue. The wedding reception is number one priority and the Anand Karaj & Guruji is a cultural necessity. This reduces the status of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji to a wedding machine; Guruji is the living light of Waheguru! The reasons for people doing Akhand Paths and weddings in banqueting halls differ. There is no doubt that the offending items should never be in the presence of Guruji. People should think twice before having an Akhand Path in their homes. 2. You refer to a Saroop as "copies". Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is not a bible, Sri Guru Arjan Dev Ji showed Sikhs how to respect a saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. It's a simple fact of life that if you want Guruji's Saroop in your how then you practice the correct Maryada. Those who do not understand must be taught but those who willingly ignore do not have the right to keep Guruji in their homes. Guruji is not a personal possession. Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji leads the Khalsa Panth. As a brotherhood Sikhs have the right to question fellow Sikhs and as Sangat make decisions to uphold Sikh Maryada. 3. The Sangat attempted to resolve the situation beforehand but the family refused. There is no targeting of families. The Sangat has no issue with any family, or how they wish to celebrate their wedding. However the Sangat will stand against and try its best to resolve any such issue of beadbi towards Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. The Gurdwaras and private granthis are the main cause for this beadbi, the sangat is not ignorant to this fact. The Campaign has successfully worked with Gurdwaras in Milton Keynes, Northampton & Brent in stopping this violation. Also the Campaign has the support of 80+ UK Gurdwaras who pledge to abide by the hukamnama from Sri Akal Takht Sahib. The local Sangat met with the groom & his family members at a Southall Gurdwara before the wedding. The Sangat explained their concerns and their willingness to help in anyway possible. The local Sangat gave the option of a Gurdwara within Southall that was able to perform the Anand Karaj and also offered monetary help. 4. It's up to you as an individual to judge whether you want to give money or not. 5. Ask the Main Gurdwara of Southall. Don't forget corrupt Pardhans like Grewal of Mangat Hall and Private Granthis like Sarl of Harrow don't do their seva for free aswell. The minimum they charge is £500 and that's only for kirtan services, excluding any bheta. At least the Gurdwara provide Langar facilities and a Divan Sahib. Families who wish to conduct false Sikh weddings in Halls still have to pay monies for the Banqueting Hall. These families are not so innocent that the can be manipulated so easily. Families are going to extreme lengths to throw lavish weddings while walking over Guruji. 6. Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is Jagat Guru. It shows to all that not only Amritdharis feels strongly about the abuse of Guruji. Sehjdharis are willing to stand aswell. The Sangat came from across the UK, over 100 Sikhs don't get together for no reason.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

J · 01 Aug 2005

I too was at this wedding and was shocked at what happened on the day! I agree with some points of the campaign but I do have to say that there is a way about going round these things and ruining someones special day is not the way to go about it!! I know the family and although they were contacted beforehand they never truly believed that anyone would come along and do this!! I am behind the campaign but just want to say that the sangat that gather to get their point across and stop these weddings from happening in halls etc should not be laughing and treating it like a big joke - as it was definitely not funny from where I was standing!! My parents are both Amrit Dari and they did not agree with what the protestors were doing there - laughing at someone else's misfortune!! If you wish to carry on making these protests then please take people with you that respect the sangat there and the campaign!! We are all meant to be peaceful and loving people but this is one example where I saw first hand what some sikhs are like - I was at the end of some horrible looks and talk from the protestors and it was not appreciated and made me reconsider my opinion (which was very high) of sikh disciples I hope I have not caused offense to anyone but needed to voice my opinion

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Guru Jis Puppet · 01 Aug 2005

Heres a response for you paji. Apologies for putting you out but just think, the Singhs and Singhnis were also put out having to come out to protest Guru Ji being disrespected. But more importantly, Gurj Ji Was Put Out!!! 1. What difference is there to someone taking the Guru Granth Sahib to their house for an Akhand Path and having frozen meat in their fridge or Alcohol in their cupboards than to taking to a hall for a wedding? the offending items are still present there - but not being eaten/drunk when the maharaj is present The hall in Lakeside was completely separate to the 'party' hall - there was no alcohol or meat or smoking anywhere near it? ie. are all Akhands Path held in homes to be banned? Yes the family was unfortunate in having to travel all the way to Southampton to have a wedding but if both parties are FROM SOUTHALL and traveled to Surry to have a wedding? Then is this really the issue? (take notice of the fact that the location of the wedding was very difficult to find even with the use of a map and directions, was there the same level of complaints from the family??) Punjabi culture which is what these weddings are!! Means the groom comes to the home of the bride to get married. As he is taking her from HER town to his. Not Lets pick a city where we can have a fancy lavish wedding and throw a wonderful party. Guru Ji is being disrespected in a wedding, which means sangat will congregate and prevent this happening. If persons disagree, challenge Guru Ji. Is that possible? No. Why? Nirankar is EVERYTHING. Nothing is beyond him. Nothing can challenge him Taking Guru Ji into your home is again wrong where anti Gurmat items are present. This issue will be also tackled but lets not run before we can walk. A wedding is what is the main issue here as an Akhand Paath is not yet written against Hukham. Even if the hall was separate, which is contradictory to what the wedding invite states!!! It is irrelevant. It STILL makes no difference, HUKHAM IS NOT BEING OBEYED. That is all that is RELEVANT! Lets put it this way, an Amritdharis Hukham is NOT TO CUT KESH. Therefore if he/she cuts kesh and is Amritdhari, then that’s breaking Hukham which means your going against Hukham. It’s the EXACT SAME THING! But WORSE. Question, the people who are affected are very quick to say they were put out or we are bad etc but heres a though, is Guru Ji not put out? And also, We protest PEACEFULLY. Hence a group of Singhs were doing Keertan outside NON STOP until the PEACEFUL protest had come to an end. Muslims would blow up the place if you took the Kuran into a Pork Factory, so please, take it lucky, we have respect for the families in this matter too. 2. What about all the copies of the Guru Granth Sahib that people have in their houses - are they to all be confiscated if the holy book is kept on a shelf or in a drawer? Again, this issue will be collectively dealt with and has previously been dealt with. If people make it clear the persons house im sure they will be contacted and have Guru Ji removed from their house and presented to Sach Khand at a nearby Gurdwara who will treat with up most respect. Holy Book? You claim to be a non practicing Sikh but on a learning path. Unfortunatly, you are walking the wrong way as the first thing you should be learning is, GURU JI IS NOT A BOOK. THE POLICE REFFERED TO MAHARAJ AS “GURU JI” in a letter to the campaign yet Sikhs have such a difficulty in saying Scriptures if they don’t want to say Maharaj / Guru Ji 3. Why does the campaign target families? What these people managed to do today was to destroy what should be the happiest day of their lives for two young people. Why is the campaign not targetting Gurudwaras - as it is them at the end of the day which allow the Guru Granth Sahib to be taken away? Why are decent law abiding families being targetted as the enemy? The campaign targets those who disobey Hukham. Those who disrespect Guru Ji. The Granthis and Gurdwaras who also permit this practice have been contacted and requested not to continue this practice and if you did some research into this, you will realize this. A wedding should be the happiest day of your life? Not really, the Happiest day in a Sikhs Life is when they give their Head to Guru Ji and state everything is yours. Other then that, Giving Shaheedi and becoming one with Guru Ji is the happiest day of a Sikhs Life. Western Culture indicates it to be the happiest day of your life. The campaign is not out to destroy anyones day, it is merely assisting you to realize what mistakes are being made. Hence as soon as word is passed a wedding is taking place, the families are contacted requesting they change location and the campaign has always offered an alternative location. Please visit www.sikhdreamweddings.co.uk and view the press releases. Baylis House 2005 – a year on. A keertan jatha was on hand to conduct the families Anand Karaj for FREE. That’s THOUSANDS of pounds cheaper then what you would be paying. In this actual incident, the Gurdwara were not even charging to hold the wedding so what was the problem in the family not getting married? They wanted a hotel wedding and refused. “Why are decent law abiding families being targetted as the enemy?” Law obiding of which law is the question? Please DO NOT try to make out the innocence of the families. There were Amritdhari KESKI women at the wedding who followed Baba Ranjit Singh across the country and the campaign also requested he mention this Beadbi. He declared the families should be ringing the couple, not the campaign but this failure results in the campaign getting involved. I believe the girls' family was approached by the campaign (via telephone only) to re-arrange the wedding. I think it would have been better if the campaign helped by going to these peoples house and helping them re-arrange? What action is being taken to follow up with the Gurudwara which allowed this? Correct the families are contacted by telephone as it is less intimidating if 5 strange people in Guru Ji Bana come to your door and inform you of your mistakes. I personally think it would be better if families wouldn’t plan stupid weddings and to cry about them after not because their day was spoiled, but coz they lost out on some money. But hey, we cant win on everything can we? Only the pure win, whos pure? Guru Ji! Please also note, each time a wedding is changed, a keertan jatha is hand incase the Gurdwara is able to provide a hall but not keertanis. Also, each time, the members of the campaign bend over backwards negotiating with the family and Gurdwara to find a convenient location. If is left to the last minute, ie on the day!! We can not be held responsible. If you put Guru Ji out, he WILL put you out!! What goes around comes around. Gurbani says it in Japji Sahib. Action against the Gurdwara has been taken and unfortunately they decided to cause a scene and so police were called. The police are aware of the campaign as we liaise with them before making an appearance hence the protests were allowed and not prevented under police supervision. The Gurdwara has a Saroop removed from Sach Khand. That was the Saroop taken to the hotel but not rescued. Further action to prevent this PRIVATE Gurdwara with corrupt granthis will be taken lawfully respecting BOTH SIKH MARYADA and the British Law. 4. Most weddings in Gurdwaras are followed up by some member of the Gurdwara commitee 'begging' for money for the building fund. They do this because they know they have a 'captive audience' - why is this not being tackled because it is taking advantage of the fact that people are there for a wedding? If this is such a big deal, request them not to or as someone has already said, Don’t give money. It cant get any easier. But then, if someone is able to fork out soooo much money to give to a hotel for a few hours, what is a couple of pennies for Guru Ji’s home? They only person who is being taken advantage of is Guru Ji. NO1 else has the ability to be taken for a ride. Guru Ji also does not allow himself to be taken for a ride hence he has the Khalsa Panth as his army who WILL stand up and protect him. 5.Why is the main Gurdwara in Southall CHARGING familes up to £1000 to hold the Anand Karaj ceremony - is this not against Sikhi? Is this not taking advantage of people? Again, DON’T have an Anand Karaj there. Simple solution, find a small Gurdwara and invite only those required. Guru Ji to conduct the wedding, the keertani, the Mother, Father, Brothers and Sisters. That’s it. Then the rest can meet you at your lavish hotels for a party. 6. Where did the group who protested at Lakeside today come from? When I got to the location - I saw the protestors laughing and joking. There was also 2-3 girls with them who were obviously not amritdhari (eg. Dyed & Cut hair) - what right have they got to be there? Those girls may not have been Amritdhari but shows the point. They themselves have that respect to stand up and protect Guru Ji from going into these places. That is the right they have to be there. Their appearance may not be of a Gursikh but they hold the values of respecting Guru Ji high. The protestors were from around the UK. Traveling from South, Midlands and North England. If all you saw was protestors laughing and joking you could have seen that much. Because I saw a lot of people doing Kirtan, when a coach full of people came, I saw protestors SIT on the CONCRETE FLOOR and do CHAUPEE SAHIB until the coach was checked. THIS INCLUDED THE GIRLS YOU SPEAK OFF. An Anand Karaj means wedding of Bliss. It was Guru Jis Gift to AMRITDHARIS to share. Now it is just a requirement to have a Sikh wedding. The values have been lost. Maryada has been changed and no longer important as long as a family can have their dream wedding. If the wedding is so important, by Law, the law abiding citizens you are, the requirement is you have a court marriage, which you have when you sign your certificates etc. This you can have in your fancy locations. No one will stop you. But when Gurbani is taken to these places, a Fauj sent by Waheguru will be there to greet you. The laughing a joking, whats your point? I saw and HEARD disguising language coming from the guests at the protestors. If people want to laugh and joke because they are talking to each other then so be it. Many of the conversations were discussing on how they got lost and went in circles trying to find the club therefore yep, it was quite amusing!!!! Whilst I felt very sorry for the family today - they could have avoided this whole situation when warned previously - and in this respect I am 100% behind the campaign. However, it is very distressing to see this in person and I had/have a sick feeling in my stomach from todays events. Is this feeling from Guilt? Or Fear? Fear that now you aware the Army of Guru Gobind Singh Ji STILL lives on and WILL do all in power to uphold RESPECT FOR GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI, OUR LIVING GURU. Whilst the campaign is targetting families who do this - what actions are being taken against the corrupt and hypocritical Gurudware commitees who are the real people to blame? All that is happening now is that this campaign is alienating a huge chunk of sikh/punjabi society because all they see is people laughing/joking whilst the wedding of their son or daughter is destroyed. There is a clean distinction between Sikh and Punjabi Culture. Please visit www.all-info.us, there is a section under “Discussion” you can read. If their wedding is destroyed, they should thing about Guru Ji more carefully and understand HE IS DESTROYED EACH TIME ONE WORD OF GURBANI IS NOT READ PROPERLY BUT THEN WHEN BEADBI OCCURS, ITS LIKE HAVING SOMEONE PIERCE HIS HEART! WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Gopi · 01 Aug 2005

Respected Phajis Many many thanks for the replies you have posted to my questions. I am happy that my questions have been taken in the spirit intended and not against me personally (because at the end of the day I am a mona manmukh) On that note - my sincere apologies for my manmukh terminology - Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji is the living embodiment of our Guru and I should not have been so dis-respectful or ignorant in my writing. Please forgive this time and I shall be very very careful in future to not use silly terminology. I agree 100% with your aims. I have also heard since this incident that the families in question (I am not related to them!) were unwilling to budge so my respect for their plight is certainly much much diminished. I really hope that with the publicity this campaign has got in the UK - incidents like these are avoided going forward - because it is true - with gurudwara in all cities/towns - there is no need to take Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji to clubs for the purpose of weddings. At the end of the day - no one likes this situation and I pray that things now change so that this is avoided going forward. The replies I have received today have shown that people on this forum are above petty tit-for-tat and happy to share their views to educate us all. As I have seen on many other posts, 'Bol Chuk Maaf', Sat sri Akal, Gopi PS. The Naming/Shaming must continue so that other peoples weddings are not ruined but more importantly that Guru Ji is treated with the respect they deserve.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

peteo1980 · 01 Aug 2005

i feel the way the campaign is carried out is a disgrace to those upholding the beliefs of what it is to be sikh. The resulting incident at lakeside is something that spoils the pure foundations to be a sikh. Are we not suppose to be brothers and sisters helping each out hand in hand, or are the the vulger representatives of sikhism portrayed at lakeside

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

S Singh · 01 Aug 2005

Peteo What did the protestors do wrong ? Did they shoot someone ? Did they use Siri Sahib on someone ? The protest was peaceful. The wedding organisers and Tarlochan Grewal are the disgrace in this whole episode. Perhaps if you understood the importance of our Guru Granth Sahib Ji, you would no post such pathetic rubbish. The helping hand was offered (including costs for the wedding to take place in a Gurdwara) weeks before the wedding. It was the lame attitude of the families which escalated the matter. How dare people use the issue of non refundable deposits as an excuse for beadbi of our Guru Mahraj. Shame on such people. PETEO if someone insults your parents do you not get upset ? This is our Guru Ji we are talking about and beadbi will not be tolerated.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Nobody · 01 Aug 2005

Peteol1980, please share with us all in which way you find the way the campaign is being carried out disgraceful? People peacefully stoping the beadbi of guru ji? Singhs doing gurbani keertan in the face of verbal abuse? Sitting on the floor and doing chapai sahibs? Doing everything with 5 singhs as representatives? Showing guru ji full satkar? Willing to sacrifice both their time and money for the sake of guru ji? Travelling hundreds of miles up and down the country to keep the sanctity of maharajh? Please tell me which of the above is vulgar representation of the pure foundations of sikhi? Sikhi is centrerd around the worship of vaheguru, and on this earth of Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. THIS is the foundation of sikhi! By doing what they are doing, these brothers and sisters are not spoiling that foundation but revealing it in its beauty. Well done guys, may guru ji bless you with the strength to succesfully continue with your seva. About time the sikh youth rocked the boat for some of these old corupt mahants!

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

ns · 01 Aug 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh Excellent work by the RFGC , however I was listening to Punjab radio this morning and there was caller who came on and was present at the wedding. The caller and his wife both claimed that the some sikhs from the RFGC actually swore at some of the people there. I didn't hear anyone come on from RFGC to counter that it was false.Also no one from any Gurdwara committees came on the air.Could the RFGC confirm that there was no hostile swearing or anything and in future keep in tune with Panjab Radio to counter any false claims.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

k kaur · 01 Aug 2005

is peaceful protesting a disgrace???? should we stop being peaceful 'peteo1980'? what is it to be a sikh? what beliefs are broken? pure foundations?? lost me....dont know about anyone else. a hand was given to the family....a Gurdwara was always an option for the family....from the time the groom himself met the campaigners the day before to the time they eventually reached southampton. the famililes chose not to take the helping hand. both families were from southall so a Gurdwara from southall was arranged. in the end they chose to go to southampton....and that is upto them. we are brothers and sisters....hence when my brother or sister does wrong i tell them and help them see this. whose vulger??? i saw men and women from the wedding families approach PEACEFUL protesters and shout abuse at them....swearing and name calling.....some women even had to be restrained by their men. sorry to offend anyone.....but we wont let Guru Ji be disrespected.....no matter whose day it spoils.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Campaign Sewadar · 02 Aug 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! The conduct of the protesting Sangat was excellent and no one responded negatively to the name calling that was aimed toward us. Unfortunately Punjab Radio or any other media do not always contact us when an allegation is made against us. Stories are being hugely exaggerated, we received a phone call from the senior editor of Eastern Eye Newspaper saying that we were waving swords and attacking wedding guests. Logically the police would not let us protest under these circumstances. All we can suggest is that people personally call us on 07944 445651 and hear our version of events or speak to the 100 members of Sangat who were present on the day or speak to Frimley Green Police in Surrey. GurFateh!

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

J · 02 Aug 2005

None of the arguments have convinced me that what you did was right, I know for a fact that the bride's family were only called 3 days prior to the wedding and that is what you call prior notice!! My dad is Amrit Dari and he was not impressed by the behaviour, language and attitude of the protestors there, my dad is a calm and gentle person who believes that everyone should live the life they choose to live and not have it forced upon them and he is the person I respect the most!! The protestors there (not all) some of them (minority), were making a joke out of it and that makes your campaign seem like a joke and that is why some people will not take it seriously And the comments about it not being a special day - that is rubbish!! I am sorry but marrying my husband in front of Guru ji, taking a vow to spend the rest of my life with him was one of the most special days in my life as well as giving birth to my son!! I know the value in these days and do not need anyone to tell me otherwise!! Please try to understand from all sides not just be one-sided about it all!! I would however like to say thanks for all the responses, it has been interesting and informative to see others viewpoint on this matter!

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Kartar S Clare · 02 Aug 2005

I am surprised to hear that an Amritdhari would attend a wedding as a guest where Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee would be taken in the presence of meat and sharab. This is where our kaum is so weak. What kind of example are these so-called Amritdharis setting??!! If they attend as guests then their relatives think it's OK to be there. They might as well place their feet on Guru Jees saroop and be blatant with the beadbi that they are being a part of or promoting by being there. It is no wonder why some of the above posters do not realise why the sangat came to protest and stop the beadbi of Guru jees saroop. About 7 years ago, many years before I got Guru jees kirpa, my family attended a wedding ceremony in Wipsnade Zoo in the function suite. I drank and at meat at the time as did all my family. I remember sitting through the whole ceremony where Guru Ji's saroop was placed on a small manji sahib in the function suite. The shutters were down by the bar, but you could still see the pumps and bottles of spirit. There were kegs of beer outside the building. I was pretty uncomfortable with what was going on around me but as I was a mona looking around at what looked like Gursikh elders and assumed it was OK because none of these elders were making a deal about it. The fault lies not only with the corrupt Granthis and Gurdwaras but also with the supposed Gursikhs who attend these weddings as guests. This gives the excuse for the family to play dumb. What the protesters did was right and if I knew about it I would have attended myself. Examples need to be made, people need to start thinking. So what if someones wedding got ruined!! A moral statement was needed to be made. If Guru Jee wanted the wedding to go ahead in the club then it would have happened. One suggestion to this campaign, please inform the whole sangat of your actions at all time. Tell the sangat where they need to turn up to stop the beadbi, next time I would like to be given the opportunity to be there with my family.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Singh · 02 Aug 2005

"everyone should live the life they choose to live and not have it forced upon" Yes but this does not give anyone the right to treat Guru Sahib like a convenient commodity. No one is forcing anyone to do anything, however when the most important thing in Sikhi is being disrespected by being taken to hotels, pubs or whatever due to money grabbing fake gyanies and families who treat the Guru as a commodity it is a totally different matter. Its like saying its okay to live your life as you choose, so go ahead and start drinking in the Gurdwara. No one is forcing the families to do Anand Karaj, if they want however they must conform to the Maryada rather than change it for their own selfish ends.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

J · 02 Aug 2005

Dear Kartar S Clare and All I do not appreciate my dad being called a so called Amritdhari - you do not know him or have any right to judge him or anyone else at the wedding!! Only Guru ji can tell what kind of persons we are. Do you really think that you have the right to speak for Guru ji!! I feel what I am saying is right and I can say that I am speaking for Guru ji what gives me the right or you? The wedding did simply not go ahead as the family did not want to cause any more disruption and trouble on the wedding day - not because of the actions of the protestors - they had a choice and they made it! In my heart I believe that Guru ji would allow the wedding to go ahead, I truly believe that Guru ji is there for everyone and Guru ji does not discriminate, which is what you are doing!! I am sorry for being so blunt but it just seems to be getting out of hand when you target other people that you don't know and name call - (so-called Amritdhari) you should remember to respect everyone and love everyone, is this not what our parents and Guru ji taught us!!

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

S Singh · 02 Aug 2005

J, Ask your papa ji whether he recognises the Akal Takht. It is fact that the Akal Takht has issued a Hukumnama banning this vulgar practice of taking Guru Ji to hotels.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

S Singh · 02 Aug 2005

Campaign Sewadar, It has been suggested a few times that the campaign group record demonstartions on a camera. These could then be put up on the Web and the likes of Eastern Eye could see for themselves the conduct of the demonstrators. Until you do this people will point fingers and make such accusations. This would be of great benefit to the R4GJ campaign group.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Singh · 02 Aug 2005

J "Do you really think that you have the right to speak for Guru ji!! I feel what I am saying is right and I can say that I am speaking for Guru ji what gives me the right or you? " I think you lack basic common sense. Guru Ji bans alcohol and tabacco. Hence it makes no sense using the Guru like a commodity and talking Guru Maharaj for the sad convenience of people to clubs, hotels and pubs. Would you take the saroop to a strip joint albeit well furnished and cornered off. No, why because its disrespectful and against Gurmat. The exact same thing applies to bars, hotels and pubs. Anyone who is following Gurmat and acting accordingly knows that doing the above is anti Sikhi and also a show of disrespect. Where is the sense in taking the Guru miles way to a Hotel/club etc, when their are around 450 Gurdwara's in the UK. The answer is that people couldn’t really care less about the Guru, and only want to impress their families with the wedding. While this is their personal problem, the Guru does not belong to them to use and disrespect as they wish. Everyone following the Guru has the basic human right to protest and make it 100% clear that they do not agree with their Guru being used in such a way. If people don't like that or the Maryada which comes with the Guru (marriage not in clubs/hotels) they should not have an AnandKaraj. FYI Guru Ji is there for everyone to learn from and become better SIkhs, be they clean shaven, Amridhari or what ever. However the Guru is not their to be used as a commodity. The Guru does not discriminate, hence this hole issue has NOTHING TO DO WITH DISCRIMINATION as you try to imply but the simple fact that taking the Guru to pubs/hotels is against Gurmat and should not be done. Respecting everyone does not mean tolerating insults against ones Guru and faith. Your thinking suggests that if someone starts smoking in the Gurdwara and people say no, by protesting they are not showing respect and are discriminating, lol.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Dandilion · 02 Aug 2005

J Ji, I hope you do not mind but I would like to be even more blunt. Frankly “so called amritdsahri” is too soft are phrase, an amritdhari who can stand by and see the beadbi of his Guru and then turns round and says that he is okay with it is No Sikh of Guru Gobind Singh Ji. We do not need to see what your father is like, his actions speak volumes. [%sig%]

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Respect for guru granth sahib · 02 Aug 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!! j wrote ""In my heart I believe that Guru ji would allow the wedding to go ahead, I truly believe that Guru ji is there for everyone and Guru ji does not discriminate, which is what you are doing!!"" can we honestly say, deep down in our hearts that our guru would want to be taken to a club/hall?? guru gobind singh ji's horse, nila did not enter a tobacco field, this is the example the guru has given us and would want us to follow!! history is an important factor in sikhi, it gives us a good example of what to do an what not to do!! you say the wedding would have gone ahead if guru ji wanted it to, obviously guru ji never wnated it to go ahead, so it never!! the family choose to move the wedding beacuse they had no other option, the gursikhs would not let the wedding go ahead , so with maharajs kirpa it never!! u said guru ji is there for every1, i dont disagree 1 bit!!! but if u want guru ji's blessing, shouldnt u go to guru ji, n not the guru coming to you?? when at school, you go to your teacher for help, what would be the eraction of the teacher if you told them to come to you?? your wedding day is special because your guru makes it special!! lets not disrespect the guru, who we want to bless us 2!! bhul chuk marf karna waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Lionking · 02 Aug 2005

In my heart I believe that Guru ji would allow the wedding to go ahead, I truly believe that Guru ji is there for everyone and Guru ji does not discriminate, which is what you are doing!! __________________________________________ Dear Bhenji. None of us have an iota of doubt that Guru ji discriminates i his house to his own children, why would he? He gives us so much respect, he give us so much. Tudh Sabh kish maino Sompeya ja Teyra Banda. He's given us sooo mcuh, is this the thanks we give him? Sending him into a club/bar? Is tha he we respect our Guru? You Are Right GUru ji would not discriminate is own children, but at the same time We need to respect GUru ji to te MAX. Akal Takhat has issued an edict saying that Guru ji's saroop may NOT be taken to a club/hall/pub, are we higher than Akal Takhat saying: "sadi marji, sanu ki Akal Takht ki Kehnda". Even if the family was contacted 3 day prior and it was not refundeble, does this mean that we can disrespect and send our GURU, JAGDI JYOT to a PUB ?, new arrangements were made by the campaigners. If families can pay several thousands of pounds to have parties WHY CAN THEY NOT atleast keep proper respect of the Guru. ________________________ And the comments about it not being a special day - that is rubbish!! I am sorry but marrying my husband in front of Guru ji, taking a vow to spend the rest of my life with him was one of the most special days in my life as well as giving birth to my son!! I know the value in these days and do not need anyone to tell me otherwise!! _________________________ Anand Karj is indeed a very special occasion! You are asking Guru ji to give his blessings for the douple to live together and the spiritual path and eventually become one with Akal Purakh. Why do you expect that he should come to you and give his blessings, does he NEED to give his blessings or do YOU NEED it? YOU NEED IT, so YOU SHOULD go and get it, and not ask HIM to come and give it in a PUB! Is a PUB / Club a location where you think Guru Gobind Singh ji would come to give you blessings? (talking in general not about YOU, but in general) _________________________________________________ My dad is Amrit Dari and he was not impressed by the behaviour, language and attitude of the protestors there, my dad is a calm and gentle person who believes that everyone should live the life they choose to live and not have it forced upon them and he is the person I respect the most!! _________________________________________________ No-one is forcing SIKHI on anyone, all we're saying is - respect our Guru. See how defensive you became when people begun disrespecting your father, in the same way when some people are trying to send our Father Siri Guru Granth Sahib ji to a PUB, Club etc his daughters and sons are offended and do their best to try to solve it peacefully, if not they use the methods required. The Sevadars did call in and try to sort it out peacefully, and by protesting was a method that would get their message across to others doing the same - just don't, Akal Purakh di Fauj will stand their doing Paath/Kirtan and not allow their Guru to be disrespected Bhenji, just as you can't stand your father being disrespected, the Singhnees/Singhs/Sevadars just cannot accept the pain of having their Father/Guru ji being disrespected in such a way. please forgive me if i have offended you in any way Stay in Chardikalaaaaaaaa Fatehhhhhhhhhhhhh

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Bhudysut · 02 Aug 2005

Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh Dearest Jay Lidder Ji Whether you accept it or not, as the physical embodiment of our Guru, our Guru must be treated with the upmost respect. This does not mean traipsing around London with Guru Ji sitting in some dingy suitcase. If you wish to understand how important our Guru is and how revered it's status is, please refer to the old British Raj manuals for the white comissioned officer's on how to present themselves in front of Maharaja's Hazuri. Unfortunately, your accusations of discrimination are baseless. NO-ONE tried to stop the Anand Karaj outright, in fact attempts were made to rectify the situation (even at Sangat's expense), however this was rejected by the family. I also truly believe in the concept of respecting and loving everybody, but not at our Guru's expense. REMEMBER: right is right because it is right, right is not right because everybody say's it is. Bhul Chuk Marf Karna Ji Dass Akaal Sahai Singh

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

J · 02 Aug 2005

Dear Dandilion - you have no right to judge the actions of another person - do not say things about someone you know nothing about I was just expressing my opinions and viewpoint as this was something I feel strongly about and wish to learn more about - as far as the actions of my father are concerned I know and Guru ji knows that my father is a true sikh whatever you may think I am deeply offended and never thought for a second that a fellow sikh would be this hurtful and purposefully try to go out and discriminate against one of their own Dear LionKing & Respect for guru granth sahib paajis Thank you for your responses, although I completely agree that Guru ji should not be allowed to be brought into a pub/club, my own wedding was in a Gurdwara, as this is what I believed to be right and wished to recieve blessings from Guru ji in this way The only thing I have a problem with is the way it was gone about and the attitude (as I said before) of some of the protestors there, all I am saying is take it seriously and protest peacefully and others will want to listen and hear what is said, laugh and joke and curse and give people attending the wedding horrible looks and no one will want to listen to what you rightfully have to say bhul chuk marf karna waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh p.s If you have anything horrible to say about my father please do not bother - only Guru ji knows what a good disciple of Guru ji my father is and I do not want to be hurt anymore - this is not what I came on this site for, it was to view my opinion and to be more informed about what is going on and get some questions answered from people that know more about what is going on then me

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

~~mango chutney~~ · 02 Aug 2005

Bhenji j wrote:- "Thank you for your responses, although I completely agree that Guru ji should not be allowed to be brought into a pub/club, my own wedding was in a Gurdwara, as this is what I believed to be right and wished to recieve blessings from Guru ji in this way The only thing I have a problem with is the way it was gone about and the attitude (as I said before) of some of the protestors there, all I am saying is take it seriously and protest peacefully and others will want to listen and hear what is said, laugh and joke and curse and give people attending the wedding horrible looks and no one will want to listen to what you rightfully have to say" Bhenji can i do benti to you as you feel love for Guur as we do please come join the campain and guide those individuals in the sangat into doing what is correct .

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Lionking · 02 Aug 2005

Dear Bhenji. Most campaigners were doing paath and Kirtan i.e peacefully protesting, and I think that is the way to go. Personally I wasn't able to go, however the police can confirm this. Also without knowing bhenji's father or his "majbooriya" or whatever, I think you should spare your comments, especially those of you who jump to the gun when people speak about your Sant Babey. (you know who you are)

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

search for tat · 02 Aug 2005

this conversation is good, but lets not get personal. I favour the campaign side of the argument, but people debate the issue rather than picking on J directly or indirectly! "J" - i do understand that it does ruin someones special day, but also I do also recognise that there are so many gurdwara in UK which can be booked for a wedding. It should be common sense to use a gurdwara, and not something that the Campaign need to point out to people.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

britishbornsikh · 02 Aug 2005

Quite frankly as a British born Sikh I have to say I am appalled by your behavior, who do you think you are enforcing your beliefs on the innocent? You are spoiling any chance of our culture stepping forward with the future generations. What kind of example do you think you set to the children present at Manget Hall when you ambushed the place and demonstrated total disregard for your elders, is this the teachings of our religion?....do you consider yourselves as good role models? Given that Gurmail Singh Malhi (also part of the Sikh Missionary Society) owner of the Monsoon Banqueting Hall in Southall supports your views but still choose to take the Guru Granth Shaib Ji to his venue for a blessing on his new investment are you sure that you have your own house in order???? What happened to the freedom of choice???....I suggest if you wish to exercise such traditionalist /fanatic views you and your Kirpans along with K.Kaur, Jaswinder Singh Ubhi and Malhi need to return to India where such bully boy tactics are a norm. You are currently creating a bad name for all British born Sikh residing in the UK Where is it said that Whaheguru only resides in Gudwara’s, surely he is everywhere. Currently ashamed by your actions, British Born Sikh [%sig%]

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

S Singh · 02 Aug 2005

>>You are spoiling any chance of our culture stepping forward with the future generations. What a twat. Chalo fer lets be ultra modern.why not just have the party in the Gurdwara. I am sure after the Anand Karaj everything could be cleared up and the stage set for the DJ..........N O T Grow up your britishbornsikh. This is not about stepping forward or backwards but about respecting Guru Mahraj and preventing beadbi. Would you like it if someone made fun of your family members ? Would you like it if your mother/sisters was mocked etc ? NO ! WELL THIS IS GURU JI WE ARE TALKING ABOUT. WE HAVE A RIGHT TO DEMONSTRATE. IF YOU HAVE A PROBLEM WITH PEACEFUL DEMONSTRATIONS THEN MOVE TO CUBA OR NORTH KOREA WHERE SUCH DEMOS AND RELIGION IS SUPPRESSED. What example is the idiot in charge of Mangat Hall setting to young kids with his acts of beadbi ? Is he saying to the kids beadbi is OK, lets flout Akal Takhts Hukumnama issued by Panj Singh ?

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

MickSingh · 03 Aug 2005

Fanatics, the bunch of you. You lot need to realise that times have moved on & we live in British society.... Just cos you lot wear turbans and beard, what makes you better Sikhs then others. We also go to the gurdwaras to and probably fund more gurdwaras then you fanatics ever will. You lot need to concentrate on finding decent jobs and making your family & community proud of you. Grow up or go back to Punjab. This ain't the 1700s this in 2005. How do you know Guru Nanak would not walk into a pub? I am sure if a Guru was alive today then he would not discriminate against any venue or people! People drink alcohol, what you gonna do, stop them! I'd like to see you try and stop your own relatives wedding. Bunch of losers and no hopers. Get back on the plane to Punjab or get some education & improve your lives

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Mr M · 03 Aug 2005

dear mr "MickSengh" the main mistake your post is that many of the campaigns work in the city, or are accountants, students in university and generally educated. just because they grow a pug a put on a dhari doesnt mean they are stupid or backwards (tanks.) why dont you talk to them next time you see them.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

RespectForSriGuruGranthSahibJi · 03 Aug 2005

LIVE DEBATE on AKASH RADIO TONIGHT @ 8PM Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! There will be a live debate about the RESPECT FOR SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI Campaign tonight from 8pm to 10pm (GMT) on Akash Radio - Sky Digital Channel 918 or http://www.akashradio.com/listen.htm Please call in with your comments. GurFateh!

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

.... · 03 Aug 2005

Micksingh and britishbornsikh May Waheguru Jee bless you with Gursikhi Jeevan and Pyaar for Guru Jee

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Respect 4 Guru Ji · 03 Aug 2005

1. Author: J Date: 08-02-05 04:40 Dear Kartar S Clare and All I do not appreciate my dad being called a so called Amritdhari - you do not know him or have any right to judge him or anyone else at the wedding!! Only Guru ji can tell what kind of persons we are. Do you really think that you have the right to speak for Guru ji!! I feel what I am saying is right and I can say that I am speaking for Guru ji what gives me the right or you? The wedding did simply not go ahead as the family did not want to cause any more disruption and trouble on the wedding day - not because of the actions of the protestors - they had a choice and they made it! In my heart I believe that Guru ji would allow the wedding to go ahead, I truly believe that Guru ji is there for everyone and Guru ji does not discriminate, which is what you are doing!! I am sorry for being so blunt but it just seems to be getting out of hand when you target other people that you don't know and name call - (so-called Amritdhari) you should remember to respect everyone and love everyone, is this not what our parents and Guru ji taught us!! You do not appreciate your dad being called “so called amritdhari?” Ok well heres a new one! In my eyes HE ISNT AMRITDHARI!!! By any chance is your mum one of the keski dastar wearing Bibi’s that were also at the wedding?? (not to protest but to actually go to it??) And when asked what are you doing here they replied, “we were told the wedding was at the Gurdwara”. So when asked “what are you doing here then? Come for a party??” (please take a not that this was around 10.30-11am) when the wedding would be going on!!! Listen, your dad might be a nice guy to you, but let me tell you something about my Dad. Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj! The man who gave up HIS father for a separate religion!!!! His 4 sons!! Because he knew they would give shaheedi instead of giving up their Sikhi. How do you think he will feel now, to know, your dad, decides its ok to be amritdhari and go to these places? I think you need to review what Sikhi Is!! Sikhi isn’t this peace loving ladi da religion people think it is taught in schools! There was a flippin reason Guru Ji said pick up the sword and fight back when you are attacked!!! Yes Sikhi is peace and loving BUT it is also the breeder of the Khalsa! The ARMY OF GOD! Therefore when GOD is DISRESPECTED, HIS ARMY WILL NOT LET IT HAPPEN! IF THEY DO? THEN THEY ARE NOT PART OF THAT PANTH ANYMORE AND ARE EXCOMMUNICATED UNTIL THEY STEP BEFORE PANJ PIYARAY and BEG FOR PESH!!!! Somewhere along the lines, you lost your Sikhi BIG TIME! Learn what it is to be Sikh First before making posts about whats right and wrong. You say who are we to Judge. Only Guru Ji Can. Ok, what did Maharaj say then when he initiated the Panj Singh into the Khalsa and made them Panj Piyaraay? He said where there are 5 Singhs, then you are the same as Me. Therefore, that is WHY Guru Gobind Singh Ji Obeyed THEIR HUKHAM countless times and still today WE OBEY THIS HUKHAM! Guru Ji loves everyone, true. But he clearly states, “Hamari Piyaari, Amritdhari”. And “Rehat Piyaari Muj Ko, Sikh Pyaari Ni” (please forgive for making mistakes in spelling, I am only a beginner in learning Gurbani..) therefore I think Guru Ji himself says it all. =============================================================================== Thank you for your responses, although I completely agree that Guru ji should not be allowed to be brought into a pub/club, my own wedding was in a Gurdwara, as this is what I believed to be right and wished to recieve blessings from Guru ji in this way If you agree, why make such a fuss about it?? Or are you one of these Sikhs who say, I dnt agree therefore it has nothing to do with me and so I will just go along with it. In otherwords a sheep as sheep follows. Not what animal represents a Sikhs mentality – a Salmon. Yes a Salmon! Why? Because while all other fish go down stream, the salmon swims up stream. Ie, when all the people are running from the problem, or hiding!! The Sikh is running to it! A Sikh never runs from the battlefield, he runs to it!!! Again, read into History, even out numbered!! Sikhs still go out knowing they gona die!! BUT don’t care! Why? Coz all they need to know is, by up holding the name of Vaheguru on their lips and doing the seva of Guru Ji! No matter what happens to them, they will be fine!! If you don’t wona believe in the stories of Guru Jis time, then look back jst 20-50 yrs ago and see the actual photos of the Singhs who were tortured!! These are not paintings, these are witness reports! NON EDITIED photographs!!! Then tell me, what we did was wrong! Bhai Fauja Singh gave Shaheedi because the Nirankaris were doing beadbi of Guru Ji. They are praised and rightly so!! They dserve it, they were next level Chardi Kala. Singhs and Singhnis now peacefully protest and get called horrible names and are slandered for there protection of Guru Ji. Wake up and understand what a Sikh really is! We aren’t wimps, that’s NOT why Guru Gobind Singh Ji gave us the gift of Amrit, we have have to beg for it! Maybe yourself and you father should go together infront of Guru Gobind Singh Ji and ask him why its so wrong as we cant seem to explain it well enough! That actually goes for ALL the people who cant see and walk blindly. Its true, “Even with the lights turned on, we cant see where we are going”. 2. Author: britishbornsikh Date: 08-02-05 12:50 Quite frankly as a British born Sikh I have to say I am appalled by your behavior, who do you think you are enforcing your beliefs on the innocent? You are spoiling any chance of our culture stepping forward with the future generations. What kind of example do you think you set to the children present at Manget Hall when you ambushed the place and demonstrated total disregard for your elders, is this the teachings of our religion?....do you consider yourselves as good role models? YES I DO THINK WE ARE ROLE MODELS!! IF YOU DON’T LIKE IT YOUR IN THE WRONG RELIGION!! Heres why, A set of people kept coming to Guru Gobind Singh Ji after constantly being mugged on their route through a forrest. Guru Ji said you must fight yourselves, ie help yourselves before we help you. But either way he will send Singhs to check it out. He then told his Singhs!! To mug the people to!! Until they realize they need to stand up!! Therefore Guru Ji himself says to teach people a lesson. That story though is besides the point. I was one of the Panj Singh who took maharaj from the dirty place he was kept in. Where the idiot whos wife hit a guy!! And caught ON CAMERA!! Only then to make false allegations!! And WAS PUSHED AGAINST THE WALL BY POLICE OFFICERS FOR NOT CALMING DOWN!!! WHO INFACT HAS A DRINKING PROBLEM AS DOES THE HUSBAND AND ERM, I think neighbours said so does the daughter?? The kids stood up and did matha tekh and joined in with the Simran as we went passed. Maharaj was taken peacefully, no1 was hurt. The people of the Gurdwara, had a guard outside!! Who was actually sleepin in his red van, we shoulda taken a picture!! Seriously!! Who then launched DIRTY verbal abuse and declared that whenever there is a wedding, THEY WILL SEND THE SAROOP!! Maharaj will do kirpa and by himself have the private joke of a wonabe Gurdwara shut down. Maharaj will not permit himself to be disrespected therefore will deal with the situation in hand his own way. We are role models to show that we uphold Maryada! What is the point in teaching them Gurbani, if they will never know how to respect it?? Tell me that. I doubt you can as yourself being a “british born sikh” don’t know yourself. Now are the people where these kid are going to learn about Sikhi good role models who say its ok to practice such behaviour, who Swear “Teri ma di…” and “you F**** this and F*** that”??? I wish I went to Sikhi camp like that!! Seriously!! Coz that’s obviously what Sikhi is about huna!! Yes bro, I made a mistake in taking amrit and following Rehat coz Manmukh, Modern Day Culture is the reason the Gurus gave their lives, Shaheeds gave their lives just so we can take the piss and spit on their brocken hearts. Given that Gurmail Singh Malhi (also part of the Sikh Missionary Society) owner of the Monsoon Banqueting Hall in Southall supports your views but still choose to take the Guru Granth Shaib Ji to his venue for a blessing on his new investment are you sure that you have your own house in order???? What happened to the freedom of choice???....I suggest if you wish to exercise such traditionalist /fanatic views you and your Kirpans along with K.Kaur, Jaswinder Singh Ubhi and Malhi need to return to India where such bully boy tactics are a norm. You are currently creating a bad name for all British born Sikh residing in the UK Where these are normal? Who ever the hell you are!! U best convert to islam I tell you straight!! Coz when you die!! Jamdoot are gona kick the crap outa you!! Dharamraj is gona put u through the worst tortures for the disquisting views you have on Sikhi. Don’t call yourself a Sikh. You do not have the right. Someone who thinks that these are bully boy tactics, thinks its fine to do such beadbi, you don’t know the meaning of Sikhi. You are no body. Fanatic? Yes fanatic! I love that word coz its so widely used. A fanatic is someone who practices their religion out of context who doesn’t understand the meaning of it. You don’t understand the basic concept of Sikhi else you wouldn’t make such pathetic attempts to slander. Basically Guru Hargobind was a fanatic for standing up and fighting back to Keep Sikhi Alive! As was Guru Teghbahadur, Guru Gobind Singh Ji, The four Sahibzadey, the Shaheeds of his time, The shaheeds of 84 whos hoodies you prob wear while drinking a glassy in the other hand. You talk of freedom of choice! ARE YOU THICK AS PIGS S***??? WHICH FAITH ON THIS KAL JUG PLANET HAS GIVEN COUNTLESS SHAHEEDI (MARTYDOM, incase your too stupid to understand that term) for OTHER PEOPLES FAITH!!! We give a bad name for british Sikhs? Dumb ass, its British Sikhs doing this You retard! British Sikhs doing Beadbi and BRITISH SIKHS STOPPING IT! Who cares about giving fools like you a bad name? I don’t! I care only for the beadbi being done to MY FATHER! Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj. He gave me life, and he will take it when hes ready. What is mine is his. Nothing is mine, its all his! Therefore when someone treats him with disrespect I will be there to stand up against it. If I call your dad nast names, if I took him to a brothel, would he like it? i duno, he might, but if he has sense then no he wont! He wont wona go! u will probably have a field day out tho! But Guru Sahib will ensure there is Khalsa Sikhs aswel as those attempting to walk his path to stand up and fight against it. Where is it said that Waheguru only resides in Gudwara’s, surely he is everywhere. Yes he is everywhere as ALL IS HIM!! BUT where does Guru Ji stay? In his home. Where do you stay? You have a car, a job. Where do you reside? In the boot of your car while I duno, your misses sleeps on the front seet? Kids where the engine goes?? No. In YOUR bed, in YOUR house. The same applies to Guru Ji hence the whole reason he has a Gurdwara. We go to see him, he doesn’t come to see us. U want his blessing, u go to him. U want something of the bank manager, do you go to see him or does he come to see you? Currently ashamed by your actions, British Born Sikh – like I said, u aint sikh so be as ashamed as u like. Its your choice. Just as it the campaigns choice to stand up and protest against stupid foolish minded people who think they can do what they like to Guru Ji. WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH. (The Khalsa belongs to Waheguru, Wahagurus Khalsa will have Victory) – Whats Maharaj himself says, so you gona argue with that? If you do, if you think you can prove otherwise, then you are God.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Loser Singh · 03 Aug 2005

Dearest MickSingh, Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! Living in a different society doesn't give anyone the right to re-write Religious Maryada. Its easy to brand people fanatics, don't forget there were sehajdharis there aswell, but you seem to want to direct your ignorance towards bearded & turbaned Sikhs only. We are part of British Society aswell, sorry if that upsets you. As British Citizens we exercise the right to practice our religion and our right to protest. My friend, a Guru is alive today, Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Rehit Maryada devised by the Sri Akal Takht does not allow Guruji to be taken to venues that promote anti sikh activities. Sorry if this whole episode have destroyed your personal version of Sikhi. You justify your life by tarnishing Guruji's roop as fanatic & Guruji's thinking as backwards. Your 10p donations to Gurdwaras are keeping the Panth alive, good on you! You think that Sikhi is based on how much money you have given and that you have the right for something in return. Guruji doesn't provide a service to Sikhs; he provides salvation to those who follow his teachings. Sikhs who stood up on Sunday are from this British Society, educated and professional. Our passions are beyond the 9 to 5 grind of life. It's our community that is committing the beadbi towards Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, no-one else is to blame. Everyone knows that it is wrong to take Guruji to places like banqueting halls, hotels etc, but we live lives focused on partying and dancing, that's the joke. You have reduced Guruji to your level & assumed he's like your buddies who go to any place where they can find alcohol, come back to reality Super Sant, use your common sense when thinking about Religion rather than your stupidity. You all can get drunk 24 hours a day, pee in your pants & vomit on your carpets. Do not involve Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji in your madness.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Singh · 03 Aug 2005

It makes me lought that people think protesting against the beadbi and insults to the Guru is wrong. We are all British Born and know where we live thank you, however this does not mean we will compromise our Sikhi. The Sikh's lived in Mughal India and were hunted down, but never compromised their Sikhi so why should we in a free and democratic country. Living in British Society DOES NOT mean you can treat the Guru like a piece of meat and take it around to pubs, night clubs or where ever you convenience merits. To say so that’s wrong and peacfully protest isn't a fanatic but a reasonable and common sense stance Mick (I will not call him Singh as I am sure he is not one) wrote "Fanatics, the bunch of you. You lot need to realise that times have moved on & we live in British society.... Just cos you lot wear turbans and beard, what makes you better Sikhs then others. We also go to the gurdwaras to and probably fund more gurdwaras then you fanatics ever will. You lot need to concentrate on finding decent jobs and making your family & community proud of you. Grow up or go back to Punjab. This ain't the 1700s this in 2005. How do you know Guru Nanak would not walk into a pub? I am sure if a Guru was alive today then he would not discriminate against any venue or people! People drink alcohol, what you gonna do, stop them! I'd like to see you try and stop your own relatives wedding." Bunch of losers and no hopers. Get back on the plane to Punjab or get some education & improve your lives The above proves the lack of simple Gurmat knowledge possessed by people. FYI just because you go to the Gurdwara does not make you into a Sikh of any kind. A Sikh (student/disciple) is only him/her who is following the teachings of the Guru (teacher), which the Kesh and turban is a part of. Obviously just taking these on etc DOES NOT make anyone into a Sikh on its own, however it is at least one thing not associated with being a fanatic but a nishani of those on the Path of following the teachings of the Guru. People are free to drink, smoke or do whatever know Sikh cares. However when our Guru is brought to such places due to the lazy convenience of people who could not really care less that is another matter and should never be tolerated. Suppose you also think its okay to take the Guru’s saroop to strip joints, as there is no difference as both places do things against the basic tenants of Gurmat. How can any fool even suggest that the Guru would go to a Pub, when Guru Ji’s horse would not even go over a tabacco field? Also whore houses, and drinking joints existed in the Guru’s times please tell me which Guru ever went their, the answer is none. FYI every single Amrdhari I know is a University Graduate and Professional. Protesting against disrespect to the Guru is not a backward thing but a basic human right. The only reason people are against it is because they have no real connection with the Guru, and think only by being born into a Punjabi Household they are automatically Sikh's which is wrong. Following Sikhi only makes someone a Sikh, not birth. Whilst thinking its okay to insult the Guru by paying fake gyanies money etc is a nishani of a fool who knows nothing of Sikhi in the first instance. Another example of a moorakh is the so called British born Sikh who wrote "What happened to the freedom of choice???....I suggest if you wish to exercise such traditionalist /fanatic views you and your Kirpans along with K.Kaur, Jaswinder Singh Ubhi and Malhi need to return to India where such bully boy tactics are a norm. " Freedom does not mean anyone has the right to do beadbi and insult people. Go and call a Black person a Nigger and see where you freedom gets you, jail that's where. Using such idiotic thinking means its okay to serv beer in the Langer and do all sorts as its your free choise. No when you are dealing with the Guru your free choice ends and the Guru's rules apply. This is a fundemental aspect of gurmat which I would not aspect you to even understand. If you don't like the rules which come with the Guru get lost, but don't try and change Sikhi to meet your own lowly levels. As for the individuals names I have necer heard of any of them, and frankly could not care less. If anyone is doing something they are in the same boat, however the named people are involved in the RFGC and do not represent me at all. As for you comment about Kirpans, what are you talking about. No kirpans were or should ever be used. If you are trying to imply that those who wear kirpans should go back to India you an even bigger idiot. Its like saying send back the Sikhi given by the Guru, we don't need it and by the way we still claim to be British born SIKH. LOL how can you be a Sikh and want to see an end to the Sikhi created by the Guru. Before you jump on the band wagon I know Sikhi goes beyound the 5 k's which are only one aspect, neverthless it is a requirment of the Guru and a SIkh (Student ) of the Guru lives up to it while a manmuckh can call himself a Sikh a million times but is still a looser in all respects.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

moorak · 03 Aug 2005

big up to respect campaign maybe one day guru ji will bless me to join with the khalsa in this mission, to the british born neo sikh, i think u need to do some reading i suuppose ur from the caste ridden idol worshipping meat eating piss head that claims to be a sikh that does the bhangra innit!!!!!! i think u need to get a life and get out of the pub pick up a gutka and read what guru ji is saying ps qualifications are bsc dip clin pharm mrpharms and british born and bred pps if u cant look upto ur parents as role models judging by ur poison, and i suppose were going back afew generations trace ur heritage back to the khalsa if u call urself a sikh and seek the truth

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Dandilion · 03 Aug 2005

Respect 4 Guru Ji, couldn't have put it better myself !!! [%sig%]

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Loser Singh · 03 Aug 2005

Dearest MickSingh, Living in a different society doesn't give anyone the right to re-write Religious Maryada. Its easy to brand people fanatics, don't forget there were sehajdharis there aswell, but you seem to want to direct your ignorance towards bearded & turbaned Sikhs only. We are part of British Society aswell, sorry if that upsets you. As British Citizens we exercise the right to practice our religion and our right to protest. My friend, a Guru is alive today, Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Rehit Maryada devised by the Sri Akal Takht does not allow Guruji to be taken to venues that promote anti sikh activities. Sorry if this whole episode have destroyed your personal version of Sikhi. You justify your life by tarnishing Guruji's roop as fanatic & Guruji's thinking as backwards. Your 10p donations to Gurdwaras are keeping the Panth alive, good on you! You think that Sikhi is based on how much money you have given and that you have the right for something in return. Guruji doesn't provide a service to Sikhs; he provides salvation to those who follow his teachings. Sikhs who stood up on Sunday are from this British Society, educated and professional. Our passions are beyond the 9 to 5 grind of life. It's our community that is committing the beadbi towards Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, no-one else is to blame. Everyone knows that it is wrong to take Guruji to places like banqueting halls, hotels etc, but we live lives focused on partying and dancing, that's the joke. You have reduced Guruji to your level & assumed he's like your buddies who go to any place where they can find alcohol, come back to reality Super Sant, use your common sense when thinking about Religion rather than your stupidity. You all can get drunk 24 hours a day, piss in your pants & vomit on your carpets. Do not involve Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji in your madness.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

RespectForSriGuruGranthSahibJi · 03 Aug 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! Please can the sewadars using the Campaign ID to post on this forum please not do so. Many thanks GurFateh! Respect For Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Campaign T : 07944 445651 E : [address removed] W: www.GuruGranthSahibJi.com

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Vah · 03 Aug 2005

Wow! Hope that shut some people up!

"RESPECT" situation in uk

uk singh · 03 Aug 2005

Khalsa jeeo, its time to awake up and talk openly about what is happening in the uk. We have a situation where most/every situation emerging in the panth is being hijacked by a small group of singhs. They would like to claim they are representing gursikh ideology however in reality they stink of factional dirty politics and have no Hamdardi with Akal Takhat Sahib but are strong followers of sant samaajh. We all Know of kaljaghs play and see many wrongs daily occuring in everyday lives. There are also similar events in the panth, including in uk. However these need to be addressed by the panth/elders of our panth rather than GARAM SEBHAA YOUTH who still struggling with their emotions. I hope the sangat in general as well as the silent majority youth sangat can awaken and recognize what harm these people are causing to the sikhs in the uk at a particular sensitive period. The last thing we need is a bunch of mis guided sikhs running around the country, searching for the next wrong- doing. It also has to be noted that these sikhs are hand picking their controversies, which suites their Dreaded ISYF fathers policies, who have never failed to cause mahaa pap within the Gurdwara Sahibs throughout the country. If there is one thing out of order, it is that we have let them get away with it for far too long. These are the same sikhs who have caused great difficulties for disrupting Parchaar from the Khalsa Camp to even holding Kirtan Darbaars to Smagams. While they never hesitate to attend when it suites them- "usually at the time for searching for a life partner." [%sig%]

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

CAMPAIGN ADMINISTRATOR · 03 Aug 2005

CAN YOU PLEASE NOT USE THE NAME OF "RESPECT FOR GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE CAMAPAIGN" AS UR USER NAMES....ONLY THE ADMIN FOR THE CAMPAIGN CAN USE THE NAME AS IT IS CONFUSING PEOPLES PERSONAL OPINION AND OPINIONS OF THE CAMAPIGN!!! FATEH JI!!

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Loser Singh · 03 Aug 2005

UK Singh your assumption is amusing. Very far fetched. Let me disappoint you by telling you there's no conspiracy theories involved. A Panthic stand is a Panthic stand. Talk to the protesters personally and find out the mix of individuals who felt passionately about Guru Ji's beadbi. It's very naive to assume that there is a political or monetary angle to everything.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

actually · 03 Aug 2005

actually UK SINGH may have gone slightly OTT but he does have a point. there is so much dirty politics with all the groups and yes even some of the campaign members are involved in it. but we might not agree with everyone or their motives but if the OUTCOME is good (stop GURU JIS BEADBI) we should STILL HELP!

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

S Singh · 03 Aug 2005

Ha ha just been kistening to Akash Radio, some real jokers on like some Gurpreet Kaur who claims she is a gori......speaks basic Punjabi very well. Again a benti to the campaign group. Use a camcorder and put this on the internet to avoid all the lies now being started to tarnish the image of R4GJ.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Singho · 04 Aug 2005

Reading the above posts one thing seems to jump out, and that is that those people taking part in the campaign seem relatively calm and can discuss their views while those generally against it resort to insults. This seems to be a similar to the treatment recieved by the protestors during the weekends events also. Another thing which has been at the back of mind for a while but which has been evident having read the above posts is the degree of racism within our own community. Comments such as 'take your kirpans back to india', 'go back to punjab' etc are similar to those as shouted by the white skinheads and BNP party in the UK and similar to those i would think as used by white facist groups in the US and Canada. It is also the same as those being shouted by the some Hindu groups in the late 70's and 80's telling the sikhs to take their kashere kirpan and kareh to pakistan. Seems strange that first our parents and their black and coloured friends had to endure this from the white facists in this country and now we, their children are hearing the same from people from within our own community!! The facists also thought we were stupid, uneducated and trouble makers, yet we have proved to be one fo the most educated and succesful communities. Just as these fools shouting these racist comments on this forum should realise that the chances are (without getting hunkar) that when it comes to jobs and cash, many of us are currently earning more than average and have better than avarege jobs. Which 'mick' will probably include you! A sad fact is that certain 'sikhs' are ashamed of the image of sikhi and would rather blend into society than stand proudly amongst the crowd as a lion of Guru Gobind Singh Ji. These people feel threatened that their version of the sikh lifestyle is being questioned and is untrue and as such they kick back against those who they see as practacing the faith. Finally your lucky this isnt Punjab my lad, especially a few years ago, otherwise the singhs wouldnt be sitting on the floor protesting, but it would be you guys doing betka and crawling along that floor lol

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

mr singh · 04 Aug 2005

a camcorder has been used to film the protest...which was full of bliss...with gur ji's kirtan being sung by the singh's....the photage should hopefully be out on line very soon, where u can also see some of the abuse that the singh's had to suffer along the way!!

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

LowLife · 04 Aug 2005

Good debate on Akash Radio last night. The valeti lady was definetly one of Grewals plants. She came from too many angles and was saying the same things Grewals was saying on Sunday about Guru Jis saroop on an aeroplane etc. It's a shame Grewal and Tekedar backed out of the debate, especially when they organised the debate.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

J · 04 Aug 2005

It is a shame that these posts have got to the stage where we are name calling and saying disrespectful things to one another I came on this site to voice my opinion, learn more and become more informed, but in a way feel harrassed and abused by my own people I can safely say that for a while I did consider maybe coming along to a protest to see peacefully what happens and what is said but with some people that actually attend speaking like they have on this site I have myu doubts To those of you that did actually give me some constructive feedback I would like to thank you and say that you should carry on in your campaign And for the others - please go home and wash your mouth out with soap - speak the language and words of guru ji not the kind of language on some of the posts here waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

1984 · 04 Aug 2005

There is no doubt that there is a real issue regarding the whole process of wedding halls however this needs to be addressed in a manner that is respectful by the Gursikhs as well. Some of these so called wannabe leaders need to have a good look at themselves and ask why they are creating such a negative image for the rest of us. There language and attitude stinks of anger and blown up egos. It is no surprise that they are creating such tension with the punjabi families who need a hand and humble face to show them the light within the dark tunnel. There will be no surprise if events continued in the current manner we have a situation like the one in surrey, canada some years ago. Sangat will remember how so called sikhs exploited a situation regarding the Langar Maryada and caused many problems throughout the sikh sangat. There is no doubt in my mind that things will turn to bloodshed as it is only a matter of time that they encounter some real gangsters/badmarsh. However it is some of the KALAI DIL so called youth leaders who in the past have showed their GAND-GHEY that will be responsible. Remember GURU SAHIB watches everything and everyone. One day we will be questioned and held accountable for our manmat actions. And then we will learn how sitting in the sangat can wash our mehel. [%sig%]

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

reality check · 04 Aug 2005

i too have seen and heard some of these campaign leaders views on the akj and how they target the very young there. Not least the girls who attend the programmes!!! I could say a lot more but most people are aware of why so called jatha haters attend and its not appropriate here.All that i can say is be careful to the sangat when going to the Langar halls as thats where they hang out in their little groups.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

A S · 04 Aug 2005

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Sri Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh, This might be a little bit off topic, but I felt like this needed to be said. Some people, IN MY OPINION, (again this is just my opinion) are very ignorant when they call devout Sikhs fanatics and fundamentalists. I believe there is no such thing as a moderate or fundamental Sikh. Either you are a Sikh or you're not a Sikh. Whoever follows the Blessed teachings of the Gurus, from Guru Nanak Ji to Guru Gobind Singh and Sri Guru granth Sahib, has the honour of being a Sikh. Just because you're born in to a Sikh family or you go to the Gurdwara once in a while but yet you drink, smoke, you do this, you do that, that doesn't make you Guru Ka Sikh. If you do all teh things that are strictly against what Sikhi teaches, how can you possibly call yourself a Sikh. If someone is desrespecting our Guru, then it is a true Sikh's duty to do something about it. The least we can do is protest against taking Guru Sahib to a party hall. Even our Dharam has become a business that these oppurtunistic hall owners take advantage of. What a bunch of weasels. If only these people invested the time in to reading and understanding the Gian that is actually in Sri Guru Granth Sahib, only then will they realize what it is to be a Sikh. Until then, they will be lost, aimlessly chasing after Maya. Well, those are just my two cents. Bhul Chukh Maaf DHEG TEGH FATEH Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Sri Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Attended on Sunday · 05 Aug 2005

'1984' and 'reality check' are falling into the same trap as the so called elders i.e. slandering others whilst remaining anonymous and not raising a finger to stop Guru ji saroop being abused. It's very easy to be a ''sher' sitting behind your computer at home or work. Your actions speak volumes more than weasel words... Congratulations - what fearlesss sons of Guru Gobind Singh ji you are!!! FACT 1: The Campaign does not have any leaders FACT 2: AKJ Singhs & Singhnia are fully involved in the Campaign and have been taking an ACTIVE part in contacting the families and holding meetings with them. If there are any 'leaders', these AKJ sevadars are amongst the core FACT 3: Do you know what language has been used by sevadars when speaking to the families? If you do not, then Dharam Raaj is going judge you harshly for slandering others A final benti to the Sangat on line: If anybody has constructive advice as to how the UK situation could be improved, different approaches taken etc. please put it on line. I am sure R4G sevadars will be reading it. FACT 4: If you have any proof of any wrongdoing, why don't you provide it?

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Gopi · 05 Aug 2005

Actually - I'm curious - what is the score when transporting Guru Granth Sahib Ji on an Airplane. There is meat, alcohol not only in the same location but actually being served.... Do you book a separate seat also? If the protestors are making such a big deal of weddings - surely all situations/places need catering for?

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

mr singh · 05 Aug 2005

gurfatheh!! i dnt understand those that support the campaign but what is all this about the gursikhs need to have a good long look at them selves?? what have the gursikhs done??.....they did all that was possible....1.contacted the familes. 2.provided suitable alternatives. 3.protested peacfilly so what else should they have done?? and please, all this stuff about ppls views on akj, etc, lets try and rise above this childish behaviour, the gursikhs that were there, were there do stop the beadbi of their guru! i dnt think anybody had anytime to start to voice their opinions!! lets stop trying to tarnish those that are trying to stop the beadbi, if all we are going to do is sit at home n watch! lets either join them, or not raise opinions on individual beliefs, as the goal of this campaign is maharaj, and not gaining personal goals, lets leave personal vendetas at home, as this is not the time or the place to raise them! one last final thought....the guru's khalsa, akal purkh ki fauj is no match for any gangster!! Gopi wrote:

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

S Singh · 05 Aug 2005

Gopi, Write to the Akal Takht if you are that concerned. I remind you that last year an aeroplane was chartered for transporting Guru Ji to Canada. Amazing how many people fail to read anything and are intent on diverting the topic to new areas. Start new threads if you want to go off topic.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Singh · 05 Aug 2005

“Do you book a separate seat also? If the protestors are making such a big deal of weddings - surely all situations/places need catering for?” Its funny how people look for loopholes in order to justify taking Guru Ji’s saroop to clubs etc. Two wrongs do not make a right, although common sense is often blurred when looking to justify the unjustifiable. I think Planes are now chartered to take saroops etc. If this is not done so now by all perhaps it should be looked at. Eighter way we have to walk before we can run, hence we need to first sort out the weekly if not daily beadbi of people taking Guru Ji’s saroop to clubs before we can tackle a larger issue which probably only happens once or twice a year. The difference is also that Guru Ji is being brought to a Country to do updesh and give sikhia (albeit the same respect should certainly apply). Guru Ji is not being taken to a club/pub while there are 450 clean Gurdwaras in England for the sad convenience of people who have no interest in Guru Sahibs updesh, just an interest in a big show off wedding. Guru Ji is not being brought over by Plane to be taken to a disrespectful club to be simply brushed aside once the ritualistic anandkaraj (nothing more but a ritual for such people) is done to make room for the alcoholic wedding. Mr Reality check, you are really sad. You put your own issues before the mission at hand, and obviously care for your own grass level politics over the respect deserved by Guru Granth Sahib Ji and the united stance required by the Guru Khalsa Panth. The mission at hand involves all Sikhs from all groups concerned with whats happening. Sad how we inherit termites who try or our out of being a fool attempt to destroy us from within.

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Gurus Servant · 05 Aug 2005

WJKK WJKF Rite, few things to clear up. If it did resolve to violence, who do u possibly think is going to win? A pissed up drunk or a Sober minded Gursikh following the Hukham Of Guru Ji? When clearly Maharaj says 5 SINGHS can take on the world! Really, you are uneducated people hence your views. Also you are too educated into western thinking hence you do not understand the simple basics of Sikhi. A fact, smoking is bad for you. Guru Nanak Dev Ji DECLARED this over 500yrs ago, yet your western scientist are running around making sure the Gov. put signs on packing saying its bad for you. Sikhi is SOOOOO far ahead of the little lives you live now hence you are so hell bent on going the opposite way. Maybe the Akaal Takht should now write a hukham and state formely, if you are NOT amritdhari then you are not Sikh. Harsh yes BUT it will solve so many problems!!!! ie then if Beadbi is being done by a Gursikh then no excuses!! and if its by someone who now CLAIMS to be sikh then we can formley sue your sorry ass for racial hatred and abduction as Guru Ji in india, the place who hates sikhs with a passion has been declared by the courts a Person so that would initally assist our case. PS, bare in mind, Guru Ji belongs to the Sikhs, the Sikhs are those who follow his words, therefore please dnt try and do stupid things now people!! Unbelievers of the Guru who abuse the Guru dnt deserve the right to be given the title a Sikh on their census form. I gaurentee, these people makin a fuss, they will probably be the same who if they see a muslim walkin down the street with a sikh girl will beat him up coz its danger to sikhi but then who are they to do this? YOU are the fools who give sikhi a bad name coz your not pleasing anyone. PPS, if it did turn out to be a war, i know which side i be fighting on and i know for a fact, people tryin to fight the truth, will LOSE BADLY. The issue of planes, why change the subject? Thats an easier issue to solve as it is!! The person is deliberlatly taking maharaj on the plane is he/she? There are charted flights available so agian its not the issue at hand. The issue is big spenders with fancy clothing and gold on thinking they are the way forward with thier punjabi culture. Someone said send the fanataics back to india, what you waiting for then? hurry up and go back!!! The fanatics you speak off are the Army of God so u gona have problems there. If all is God how you gona fight him? Remember he gives you life, he will take it away. He can leave u with nothing, no money no home nothing. who are you gona turn to then?? Govt? they aint gona help ou coz in their eyes ur just another paki tryin to claim free money. Salvation army will help a gora first despite what they say! So then where you gona go? Your family will tell you to get lost. They be the first!!! then where do u go? who do u beg for help of? GOD. When the going gets tuf u ask for his help. when he gives u what u want, u dnt even say thanks. instead you throw it in his face. some where along the lines you musta been droped on your head! Fair enough we want to live a comfortable life but its not a requirment. the only requirment is you have enuf money to suport your family. the rest will be given to you if you deserve it. so if you wedding gets done over, like i said, you dnt deserve it hence maharaj tell us thats when a wedding is and thats the one we need to stop. The joke is, you claim we look for the weddings targeting specific families. Ask yourself this much, where we getting the info from?? A FAMILY MEMBER WHO HAS BEEN INVITED therefore is it us you wona have a go at now? or them! AKJ are present. Theres NO leaders there. DDT are present. Theres NO leaders there. Nihang Singhs are present, theres NO leaders there. THERE IS ONE LEADER THOUGH. AKAAL PURAKH. WAHEGURU. SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI MAHARAJ!! He is our only leader!!! Maharaj tells us where to go, how to get there, even when we lost he still guides us, he provides EVERYTHING we need. Why? coz he is testing out of all his supposed Sikhs, which one will stand up and protect him. Its all good calling yourself a Sikh and its even better saying your Amritdhari but Amritdhari means youve give your head to the true Guru therefore what does that mean? Your dead! Your only job in life is to serve him hence he blesses you with this seva! You people spend so much time preparing for your weddings, months, a yr in advance what ever, when we hear of a wedding until the day of the wedding night and day is spent workin on preventing the family from doing beadbi by requesting they do not get married in that location!!! Finding alternative locations, explaining why the full works and then which on the day is more victorious? the ones who came with a pure heart to join togehter and save maharaj. How, why? u know all those Shaheeds that have given their lives just so we can live today? they are standing there with us, they are the ones fighting before we get there. They have been sent to guide us and lead us to Victory. If you follow punjabi culture over Sikhi its coz you think that it has something better to offer you. Yeh it does actually. It offers you luxary now, but its gona offer you hell when you pass over. Me personally, id rather go through hell now and then pay for mistakes iv made but knowing that i did at minimum just ONE good thing in my life!! is enough for me to say what ever happens now is fine with me coz just once i was able to protect the person who has protected me and given me everything i could ever want. SIKHI! WJKK WJKF

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Gopi · 05 Aug 2005

S Singh ji Not diverting the topic at all - was curious to this fact. Thanks for answering. Does this also mean Nagar Kirtans are also now banned because you're going through roads where there may be drunks around? or walk past a pub? agree - simple point like taking to pub/club for weddings - but where does this end?

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Gopi · 05 Aug 2005

"A pissed up drunk or a Sober minded Gursikh following the Hukham Of Guru Ji? When clearly Maharaj says 5 SINGHS can take on the world!" I think that is some silly arrogance coming out - I have been to many many weddings - and although people may drink in the party - I have never ever seen someone drunk at 9am before the Anand Karaj - Pulease get over this I have noticed some very arrogant comments from people on this forum - much as non-amritdharis tar monai with the same brush - I am getting this from amritdharis on this forum! Fanatics - this word has different meaning according to which side of the fence you are. So then I guess that makes everyone a fanatic (not in a bad way!!). Finally - this isn't a dig at all - but comments like "then which on the day is more victorious? the ones who came with a pure heart to join togehter and save maharaj" - it's easy to claim 'victory' - this wasn't a victory - it was 100 people barring someone from entering a building. This wasnt a victory - it's an envitable clash of culture and religion. Why is it that apart from Christianity - my interpretation is that the biggest gulf between religion and culture is within sikhism/punjabi??

Re: Question for Respect Campaign

Admin · 05 Aug 2005

Admin has decided to close this thread. Admin.