learning keertan
confused · 24 Jul 2005
someone asked me to pay them money for getting keertan lessons is the pseron doing something wrong? Giani Jarnail Singh and Kulbir Singh please post opinion
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
confused · 24 Jul 2005
someone asked me to pay them money for getting keertan lessons is the pseron doing something wrong? Giani Jarnail Singh and Kulbir Singh please post opinionsingh · 25 Jul 2005
this is very very wrong, do not pay themunknown · 25 Jul 2005
i think that there is nothing wrong with accepting money for teaching keertan lessons, the person teaching is probally giving up valuable amounts of his time that he could use to be making money workingDyal Singh · 25 Jul 2005
It kind of depends on what you're learning, and from whom. For example, if you're going to a regular Indian music teacher, and asking them to teach you Shabads, while they may be very capable, there is no 'sharda' (devotion) involved, and its a means to make some money for them. The other scenario is that you are learning from a GurSikh, who see's teaching you as a way of expressing his own devotion. These types of teachers are extremely rare. Some teachers also use student fee's as a way of motivating the student. That is to say, if the student is paying x amount of dollars, that forces him / her to stick with it... An alternative way that you can use to learn kirtan is through books. While it is extremely diffucult to learn an instrument like the tabla from a book, the harmonium can be picked up quite easily. I recommend a book I have as a reference - its published by Damdami Taksal, and is basically the "textbook" that they give their students. Its called Gurmat Sangeet Sagar. Its basically a big book with numerous Shabads in various raags and tunes, along with full notations. [%sig%]Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 25 Jul 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. Veero ate Bheno, IF we look at the World today...we will see many books, arts, music etc .... these books EARN MONEY..for the authors, the printers, the sellers.... Dhan Dhan GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB..the ILAHI GURBANI that GURU JI Himself brough down form Sach Khand fro our Kalyaan....Guur Ji gave us FREE of CHARGE..out of the Goodness of His Divine Heart....Guur Ji didnt charge a single futtee kaudee for his gurbani...for listenng to Ilahi keertan with Bhai mardana Ji...or with Satta balwand Ji....etc.. TODAY i can say with absolute SURETY that about 500,000 PEOPLE... raagis, granthis, gyanis, sants, kathakaars, Printers sellers of gutkas, gurbani, beers of Guru Ji...gurdwara parbhandaks,..etc etc etc are EARNING A LIVELIHOOD OUT OF GURBANI. This Ilahi GURBANI..in GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB is a "means of earning a LIVING".... for that many people....GURBANI FEEDS them and their Families, clothes them, pays their rentals, pays their electricity bills....etc etc. Gurbani says.." Rotian karen poooreh taal....How TRUE of so many SIKHS... The Truly NISHKAAM SEWAKS are few and far between. MY own Younger Brothers were taught basic tabla by a humble gursikh for absolutely NOTHING....in fact on his way to Gurdwara to teach them he would buy us sweets etc..so we would learn with extra vigour..Today my brothers are far far advanced in tabla and kirtan miles away in front of what that GURSIKH knew....but we can never forget his sewa...Today they are PHDs and the gursikh was just an unedcated watchman....BUT he set them on the Path to GURU JI and for that we are forever grateful. (This gentleman's name was SANTA SINGH MBS KL) For the veer who asked this question. This is a MATERIALISTIC WORLD... There are very FEW like OUR mahaan GURU SAHIBAANS who gave us the Priceless Treasure...FOR FREE..... we must have our priorities right...I would advise you to Learn the Kirtan....and if the teaching is "worth it" pay the man...BUT make it a point to TEACH OTHERS FREE.... Guru Ji will Reward YOU. Follow in the footsteps of good kirtaniyas..learn by being in their sangat....and once you are good at it...teach others in the way you wanted to be taught by someone !!! Jarnail Singhcharanjeev singh · 26 Jul 2005
We must do what brings us closer to Waheguruu. As for ourselves, we should do Niskhaam Seva. The Guru taught us how to live. Ang 1245 translation veechar Shalok, First Mehl: Cursed are the lives of those who read and write the Lord's Name to sell it. Their crop is devastated - what harvest will they have? Lacking truth and humility, they shall not be appreciated in the world hereafter. Wisdom which leads to arguments is not called wisdom. Wisdom leads us to serve our Lord and Master; through wisdom, honor is obtained. Wisdom does not come by reading textbooks; wisdom inspires us to give in charity. Says Nanak, this is the Path; other things lead to Satan. ||1|| Second Mehl: Mortals are known by their actions; this is the way it has to be. They should show goodness, and not be deformed by their actions; this is how they are called beautiful. Whatever they desire, they shall receive; O Nanak, they become the very image of God. ||2|| Pauree The True Guru is the tree of ambrosia. it bears the fruit of sweet nectar. He alone receives it, who is so pre-destined, through the Word of the Guru's Shabad. One who walks in harmony with the Will of the True Guru, is blended with the Lord. The Messenger of Death cannot even see him; his heart is illumined with God's Light. O Nanak, God forgives him, and blends him with Himself; he does not rot away in the womb of reincarnation ever again. ||20|| bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]confused · 26 Jul 2005
thank you veer jees, i think im gonna go with Giani Jarnail Singh's advice it seems very logical, i feel i need to gratify the person for their time and patience if what they are doing is wrong its wrong for them but i dont mind paying for learning