Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

! · 20 Jul 2005

People often say that the most detrimental of all mistakes a Sikh could make is to get involved in a relationship with the opposite sex. This doesn't necessarily mean being physically involved, but even something as "harmless" as developing feelings for another person outside of marriage can cost you everything. It seems almost impossible to recover after such a mistake. Even months and months later, there seems to be no escape in sight from all the damage it causes on a spiritual level. There was once a young Singh, perhaps in his early 20's, who used to do sevaa in Punj Pyaaray with Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee. What a high avastha that youth must have had to do sevaa amongst such chardi kalaa Gursikhs. Bhai Sahib used to warn this youth to limit his interactions and communications with the opposite sex. He was warned to be careful and to talk to bibiaan less. However, this youth, like many of us, probably gave himself a lot of credit. He probably doubted that he could fall prey to the enticement of maya and doubted he would be tempted by kaam. But, lo and behold, he fell. And very badly, too. He committed such a grave mistake that warranted presenting himself before the Punj Pyaaray to seek forgiveness. He traveled to a Smaagam to get peshed, but the Punj Pyaaray there told him to return to his hometown and get peshed there in a local Amrit Sinchaar. This youth however was extremely ashamed of his mistake and had too much pride to present himself before his local Sangat. So, instead of getting peshed and trying to continue on with his Sikhi, this Singh disappeared altogether and no one ever saw or heard from him again. Some say that he committed suicide since he was never seen again. Drastic measures? I think not. It just shows how grave the mistake can be and just how detrimental it is, often to the point of no return. This youth didn't heed Bhai Sahib's advice to steer clear of being close with the opposite gender, so who would heed my advice now? All I can say is that the stakes are very high and if a Singh of such a high spiritual avastha can fall, what makes us think we can't? I see so many youth today who are clearly emotionally attached and involved with one another in the form of a "crush" if not more. They think they are safe and their relationships are acceptable and they won't cross the line by falling prey to kaam. But I say you've already fallen once you've developed feelings of this nature for a member of the opposite sex. And I tell you, it could happen to anyone, so it's best to be vigilant. We are all like wax that will easily melt when placed in the vicinity of fire. We're better off keeping a distance from the flame because after melting, there's no going back. Try as you might, sometimes it seems that the damage is irreparable.

re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

Kulbir Singh · 20 Jul 2005

What an excellent post this is. Thanks for sharing it. Indeed, it is very easy to fall if the conditions are ripe. If we follow Gurmat and limit our interaction with the opposite sex, only then we can save ourselves from this fire. Otherwise, numerous gullible Sikh youths are falling prey to this fire of Kaam. Kulbir Singh

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

~~po punisher~~ · 20 Jul 2005

Great post tottaly agree 100000%

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

gurdeep · 20 Jul 2005

wow totally agree with the post there never heard this story before

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

hp · 20 Jul 2005

i've fallen for someone and have been trying to battle it for a few years . how do you get rid or it??????

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

Singh · 20 Jul 2005

avoid them. stay in good sangat. do more simran etc. it'll probably go away by itself.

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

Singh · 20 Jul 2005

"i've fallen for someone and have been trying to battle it for a few years . how do you get rid or it??????" You realize and come to grips with how ordinarily human they are. They're no one special. They're a temporary being. They have faults. They make mistakes. They themselves are gripped with the 5 evils. Why fall for them, an imperfect being, when you can fall instead for a perfect and faultless being?

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

jugroop singh · 21 Jul 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, this is an excellent thread. people who attend Rainsbais or Keertan programmes should make a point of spending as much time in the Diwan Hall, in the company of Siree Guru Sahib Ji and His Sangat, as opposed to milling around downstairs and amongst people of the opposite sex and a similar age... have your Langar but get straigh back up there man! if you need to talk to a fellow Singh or Singhni briefly then no-one is saying avoid eacj other like the plague but realise the danger of becoming too familiar with others... no-one is saying we should never talk to the opposite sex but its worth being economical with words when talking to the opposite sex and keeping our gaze under control. i find that if i keep doing mool mantar di Simran (i haven't received GurMantar yet), the mind becomes much more centred and less prone to endless chit-chat, or instructing my eyes to wander around. however, being economical with words in all situations i find actually helps to keep the mind more focussed upon GurBani...says the guy who writes very long posts! VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

ASengh · 21 Jul 2005

WJKK WJKF Nice post. Jugroop Singh you said.. >>people who attend Rainsbais or Keertan programmes should make a point of spending as much time in the Diwan Hall, in the company of Siree Guru Sahib Ji and His Sangat, as opposed to milling around downstairs and amongst people of the opposite sex and a similar age...<< When Sangat go to Rensbhais kirtan - especialy the youth and some of the older sangat do tend to start getting out the diwaan hall and start chatting. I think mostly in Rensbhais and kirtans when boys talk to girls these kind of relationships start to develop. How we should tackle this is by getting some of the older Singhs and bibis to start telling people to get back in the Darbaar Sahib, this worked for me quite a while ago in Leicester Rensbhai, I was outside talking to some Singhs when all of a sudden a Singh, who was about in his 70s come up to me and the Singhs and told us off, "He said the Singhs of GuruGobind Singh wear bana, look magnificent, but can't the Singhs of Guru Gobind Singh sit in the Darbaar Sahib in stead of standing outside talking." I apologised and ran back into the Darbaar Sahib. Im not sure if this still happens. But its a great idea.

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

j k · 21 Jul 2005

i believe that these relationships are becoming 'mainstream'. more and more parents are accepting them. its not like it used to be where your parents would kill you. i speak from personal experience, this relationship is not part of sikhi. you absolutely can not function as a sikh and have this type or relationship at the same time. they are two things that do not mix. we are losing sharm living in this society, we are picking up too many of the west's ideas of what a relationship is. we are being forced to look at the 'romance' in a relationship rather then functionality and sikhi. just my $0.02 [%sig%]

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

TUF · 21 Jul 2005

I disagree with what has been stated. Loving another person is not against Sikhi unless one stops being able to control themselves. I've been in a relationship for over a year and I'm going to marry this girl. We've both been true to our beliefs and know what we should and should not do before marriage. As long as two people know the boundaries and they're not lying or deceiving their parents, I think its okay. And we both believe fully in Sikhi. I think people forget that a relationship is not about kaam or physical pleasure. Its also about the meeting of two minds, in fact, its more so about the meeting of two minds. As long as we have clean hearts and good intentions, thats the main thing and kaam can be controlled. I think that arranged marriages are great, but since I found someone who is so similar to me in values, beliefs and habits, I wasn't simply going to let it go... maybe it was Waheguru's will for us to follow this path instead of an arranged path.

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

agree with TUF · 21 Jul 2005

TUF..i agree with you there..me and my partner also met each other and our marriage wasnt arranged...we were both amritdharis and got engaged and spoke to each other quite a bit before and after we were engaged..thats because we were 100% certain we were going to get married...and we did :) we were in the same boat as you TUF..we had same beliefs and values and same goals in life...there wasnt a chance that we were going to let it go as well..we had a much deeper connection and just loved spending time with each other..we didnt think it was wrong to talk to each other etc..and neither did our families..who are all amritdharis as well... you can love each other without kaam..we expressed our love through truly caring for and respecting each other as well as being there and supporting one another..and it had nothing to do with kaam.. and off course..it was wahegurus will that we didnt get an arranged marriage and that we were to meet each other the way we did..waheguru is truly amazing :)

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

peace · 21 Jul 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh I share that relationship between siks in important, else our bro & sis will turn to other races..... i am not saying interim relationship ....a realation that has its limit and follow gurmat. that way the won;t go astray... Sorry just a opinion

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

Singh · 24 Jul 2005

Tuff, Right when I read the following sentence in your post I knew your post was going off on the wrong track: "I disagree with what has been stated. Loving another person is not against Sikhi unless one stops being able to control themselves." This is a classic example of what is referred to as "manmat". You didn't point to Gurbani or Sikh history or to anything else Sikhi-related. You just gave us your own views. Well, PLEASE - you're writing posts that many Sikh youths read, I think you owe it to them all to write your posts based on SIKHI and not on your OWN beliefs and thoughts. Gurbani very clearly says that we are easily deceived by our desires and our wishes - especially in our youth. Playing the game of "relationships" - even if it's with the intention to find a spouse leads us away from Waheguru and towards a potentially easy demise. As the first poster said: But I say you've already fallen once you've developed feelings of this nature for a member of the opposite sex. And I tell you, it could happen to anyone, so it's best to be vigilant. We are all like wax that will easily melt when placed in the vicinity of fire. We're better off keeping a distance from the flame because after melting, there's no going back. Try as you might, sometimes it seems that the damage is irreparable.

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

unsure · 25 Jul 2005

wjkk wjkf sangat ji, wat about when your lookingto get married.... but your family doesn't know anyone suitable and you meet someone who is suitable? what do u do then? isn't that worth pursuing evne if your families in know way watsoever know each other .....

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

RoopKaur · 25 Jul 2005

To TUF, You never know what the future holds, including who you are going to get married to. Your posts first fault is that you refer to this as love. But falling for someone of the opposite gender is not usually love, but lust and infatuation. Although it may appear as love at first, this is fake love. Your second mistake was saying that this "love" is not against Sikhi. Infact it is. A Sikh has been told to view all other women besides his own wife as mother sister or daughter. You should be viewing all woman you meet as your sisters, not as potential marriage partners, which is the western way of thinking. Your next mistake was that you assumed you will get married to this person in a year. But nothing is ever certain. Until a Singh actually goes through the anand karaaj, even his potential wife ishould be viewed as his sister. It is only after the anand karaaj that this relationship changes. Now lets take your case for example. If your marriage does not actually go through with this Singhnee, firstly both of your repuatations are ruined in the Sikh culture because people will know you dated eachother, which is totally against Sikh culture. Secondly, when you try finding another marriage partner, this relationship will keep haunting you. Thirdly, especially for the girl, this will really affect you marry's you after. I think it is best if you and your future singhnee open your eyes to gurmat and stop dating before marriage. Although you say you both know what a Sikh should and should not do before marriage, this does not seem to be true since dating is not permitted in Sikhi before marriage. Also, you think that you might be able to control yourself, but like the above story illustrates, anyone can fall to kaam. Why thrust yourself in the fire on purpose?

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

* · 25 Jul 2005

Roop Kaur, what do you mean by this: "Thirdly, especially for the girl, this will really affect you marry's you after." (I assume you meant "this will really affect WHO marries you after"). Why is this especially for the girl? Wouldn't it affect whoever marries the guy after as well? I think it's silly to think that it's worse for a girl to date than for a guy to date and that the consequences are more severe for girls than for guys. Both lose equally and make their future partners lose as well. The consequences are the same. Thinking otherwise makes no sense and such thinking is actually quite sexist.

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

Kulbir Singh · 26 Jul 2005

Roop Kaur's post has pretty much summarised what I wanted to write or what I would have wanted to write. Bad reputation does not help build a good relationship later in life. Gurmat reasons are strongest but such reasons as keeping a good reputation should also deter a young male or female from committing stupid kaam related mistakes and forming boyfriend/girlfriend kind of manmukhi unions. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

TUF · 26 Jul 2005

I respect what all of you have written greatly. Perhaps I am mistaken in what I am doing, although I don't feel as if I am doing a wrong. We are already engaged and going to get married, and I don't see any hiccups coming along. It does not seem possible that waheguru would bring somebody into my life who is so similar to me for no reason. I understand what you are saying that all these worldly relationships are wrong and only the relationship with Waheguru is what matters. But we'll see when you all get married and are in relationships. I think it is impossible not to have feelings for your partner. Isn't a part of our beliefs to be close to naam but at the sametime to live the life of a householder?? We're not hindus in that we're supposed to give up all our relations and belongings in order to go on our voyage of union with god. Instead, the way I understand it, we are supposed to be on this journey as we live our lives, as long as we don't get lost in our lives and forget our true path. I hate when people mix up kaam with relationships. Thats a western way of thinking. Thats not what its all about.

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

g · 26 Jul 2005

Author: hp Date: 07-20-05 11:13 i've fallen for someone and have been trying to battle it for a few years . how do you get rid or it?????? I say just get married to them... then your not doing anything wrong... unless they are not who you want to marry in that case... why did you even get involved in the first place, I am easy on people who fall in love and want to get married and spend the rest of their lifes together, but when you get together with somone just for fun or for the excitment and have no intentions on ever marrying that person... I think that is really wrong, I my self had to deal with this I thought I was in love 4 diffrent times... when infact the girls where never serious, Ive never wanted to have a girlfriend I was always reluctant to call them my gf... I thought I had found somone I wanted to marry but they just wanted to play, but whatever... If you guys are serious and want to marry each other then get married(even though I know parents make it impossible) and if your not then break it off... its silly and stupid to get into a relationship without planing on marrying

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

J · 27 Jul 2005

vahegurujikakhalsa vahegurujikifateh Written by: Author: TUF Date: 07-26-05 07:27 I respect what all of you have written greatly. Perhaps I am mistaken in what I am doing, although I don't feel as if I am doing a wrong. We are already engaged and going to get married, and I don't see any hiccups coming along. It does not seem possible that waheguru would bring somebody into my life who is so similar to me for no reason. I understand what you are saying that all these worldly relationships are wrong and only the relationship with Waheguru is what matters. But we'll see when you all get married and are in relationships. I think it is impossible not to have feelings for your partner. Isn't a part of our beliefs to be close to naam but at the sametime to live the life of a householder?? We're not hindus in that we're supposed to give up all our relations and belongings in order to go on our voyage of union with god. Instead, the way I understand it, we are supposed to be on this journey as we live our lives, as long as we don't get lost in our lives and forget our true path. I hate when people mix up kaam with relationships. Thats a western way of thinking. Thats not what its all about. I am totally confussed about this topic as well, i need help too, I fully agree with you, and I do not know how its going to be for me. My Husband too, belive's in Sikhi alot and he seem to keep it before me and the family every time. my family and i feel he is just being very unfair to us and the kids by keeping us away and denying us some of the special attention that we demand to live a living. it is a very good thing that he keeps vaheguru before us and pays much attention to meditation and all that but we as a family need some attention from him as well...... please advise..................

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

J.K.K · 27 Jul 2005

I understand what you are saying that all these worldly relationships are wrong and only the relationship with Waheguru is what matters. Then why get married live a life like the Hindu brothers move to the forest is that what is expected from a Gursikh, Waheguru has given us such a wonderful jivan, asked us to live happy and love and bw loved, why deny your patner his/her rights. Its a very painfull feeling when your patner pays less attention to you, guys we have grown with time, life styles ahve changed and we need to adjust to them to live happily, do we not?? what happiness will we get from our guru if we cant perform our reponsibilities towards our family well????

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

* · 27 Jul 2005

The last few posts seem to be straying from the topic. TUF and other like-minded friends, no one is saying that having feelings for your partner is wrong. Where we differ in views is how we determine where the partnership actually starts. To you, it may start when you decide you like someone and would like to marry them. For Gursikhs, it begins only after the Anand Karaj and only after the couple is officially ordained Husband and Wife before Guru Sahib. Having feelings for the opposite sex before this is foolish and feckless, regardless of how sure you are that it is meant to be and that the rishta will happen. TUF, you wrote: "We are already engaged and going to get married, and I don't see any hiccups coming along." How often do you see hiccups coming before you actually hit them? "It does not seem possible that waheguru would bring somebody into my life who is so similar to me for no reason." There's always a reason, but not always the reason you think it is. If you think the reason was so you could fall in love before marriage, you're probably wrong. "Isn't a part of our beliefs to be close to naam but at the sametime to live the life of a householder??" Indeed, we should be close with Naam while still upholding the life of a householder. You do NOT however become a householder just because you've developed feelings for a girl/boy. The "life of a householder" in this type of context would mean being married. After marriage, of course you would love and be loved by your spouse.

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

reality check · 29 Jul 2005

this post should never be put back, people should listen to bhai sahibs adivce because this kanjaar khaana is happening within our naujawans. singhs messing with bibian, bibian messing with singhs, then move on to the next like nothing happened. I think the youth should have a good look at themselves and see if the ones doing this are really following guroosahibjee, are they living up to their fathers name, and even msn chatting is just as bad, many people use that as a meeting and flirting place. and we also have a new danger on our hands where people are meeting and adding and sending messages to each other on their and MANY singhs and bibian have fallen victim to this hi5.com. WAKE UP [%sig%]

Re: Dangers of inappropriate Relationships

story? fact? evidence? · 30 Jul 2005

wheres this story from i would like the book and page number please