Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

a beautiful scene

a beautiful scene

singh · 18 Jul 2005

Re: a beautiful scene

charanjeev singh · 18 Jul 2005

There is no need for the art; Guru jee is the art. Interesting how they put the hindu aspects below. This is another attempt by RSS minded people. But no matter what one tries, Guru Sahib in His most beautiful form of Larivaar is where the mind just sinks too. Dhan is the Guru who ever beautiful

Re: a beautiful scene

Singh · 18 Jul 2005

the art is nice but in doing all that artwork, it seems the scribe messed up the bani: Satnam and Nirvair are missing aunkarhs.

Re: a beautiful scene

:::::: · 18 Jul 2005

Arent all handwritten larrivaar saroops usually older saroops? Why does this one have so many mistakes? (eg what 'Singh' said, also it says 'hai BHI sach' as opposed to 'hai BHEE sach', 'akaar' as opposed to 'aakaar' etc)

Re: a beautiful scene

Singh · 18 Jul 2005

It looks like it was a Hindu trying to earn some money by writing a saroop. The pictures of hindu gods at the bottom and sanskrit-style Gurmukhi suggest that anyways. Only a dedicated Gurmukh can write a saroop really. A Gurmukh pays attention to every akhar and lagan matras because they see it as angs of their guru. This guy made so many mistakes in just one ang.

Re: a beautiful scene

singh · 18 Jul 2005

Firstly its a painting circa 1860 from Kashmir. Charanjeev, its only a painting, im sure we all agree Guru Jee is the ultimate art, but there is also beautiful sikh art to be apreciated. Every religion has its heritage, shouldnt we ?? The reason why there are mistakes is because it was probably commisioned in Kashmir, the kashmiris copied the verses of the Japji Sahib from an original source, they werent familar with Gurmukhi, they are known for making many mistakes when copying. Im sorry I posted the image, I didnt expect highly critical and offensive remarks, and this was done in the 1860s...whats the RSS got to do with it.

Re: a beautiful scene

Singh · 18 Jul 2005

singh, that's precisely our point. You can't commission a saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib to someone. A person who does write a saroop has to do it as seva and with a lot of love. Only that person will pay attention to detail. You metnioned RSS, no one else.

Re: a beautiful scene

singh · 18 Jul 2005

Also if you look at old Sikh paintings, there are many of the Gurus with Hindu dieties, even Maharaja Ranjit Singh paying Homage to a devi. These were early periods of Sikh History, you can ignore the hindu subjects, and still admire the equestrian depiction of Guru Gobind Singh ji with Sikh follwers and a nice image of the Nighung holding the battle standard. I suppose I better write to admin, to delete the post. Your a wonderful bunch.

Re: a beautiful scene

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 18 Jul 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. The "mistakes" are normal for people who DONT KNOW GURBANI GRAMMAR..and there were many such writers....even today on many Gurdwara Buildings i see the Aunkarr in Satnam missing.... people just dont understand its significance.... Secondly to think the RSS is a MODERN thing is a serious MISTAKE...the BIPPAR PROPOGANDA MACHINE (BPM) started its anti-Gurmat campaign during GURU NANAK JI's LIFETIME....as it was seen thet GURU JI was going to be the BIGGEST THREAT to Brahminism/Bippar control of the MASSES. Attempts to corrupt GURBANI during the time of the FIRST FOUIR GURUS was what made GURU JI, GURU ARJUN JI SAHIB to begin the mamoth task of Compiling GURBANI in an "UNASSAILABLE FORT called AAD GRANTH JI".. And these attempts continued...and gained momentum when the SINGHS were forced to go into the JUNGLES..and the BIPPAR minded Udasis and such got complete control of our GURDWARAS, AAD Granth Birs, All or Historical Places and all...THATS when the MOST CORRUPTION of Authentic Sikh hsitory was done.. And these ATTEMPTS continue..first with the Divison of Punajb and destruction fot eh SIKHS reducing them to Peniless REFUGEES overnight, leaving behind their beloved gurdawras and properties, then the SLOW STRANGULATION of our LANGUAGE...why was PUNJABI SUBA DENIED when others got their subas on a silver platter ?? Then the Bollywood Propoganda machine to destroy our culture subvert our youth...blah blah blah..take over of the UNIVERSITIES and Khalsa Colleges by the MARXIST ACADEMICS...preaching atheism....and then the Blatant all out assault in 1984 to have a HOLOCAUST, destroy all historical libraies, artifacts..and demolish the Akal takhat....and then slowly INFILTRATE the AKAL TAKHAT/SGPC/by corrupt "sikh looking Hindus.." and THEN the RSS ASSAULT to tie up the loose ends and complete the SLAUGHTER... There is an UNENDING and UMBROKEN link to the First Janeau Forcing Pandit to Pandit Jawaharlala Nehru....the same EVIL FORCE working day and night to strangle SIKHE and Gurmatt of GURU NANAK by asismilating into Hidnuism as Buddhuism, jainism, Mahavirism etc before this... Dont mistake this as outburst/paranoia/// i beleive in this just as much prof Udoke and others. Some HINDUS on this Forum have questioned why I "keep quiet" when MUSLIMS write about their religion here ...thats ebcasue SIKHE faces its GREATEST THREAT from INSIDE... those we have a "nauh maas da rishta" are hell bent on eating us up....I remeber that it was the HINDU HILL RAJAS that first SOLD land to Guru Teg bahadur Ji..and then WENT to DELHI to beg Aurengzeb to help them FIGHT GURU GOBIND SINGH JI ( after GURU HARGOBIND JI had set their ancestors free from Gwalior Prison of Jehangir ). The Very First Battles of Guru Gobind Singh ji were with the HINDU HILL RAJAS...while MUSLIMS under Fakir Pir Budhu Shaha were spilling BLOOD for GURU JI. Gangu ddint even have PITY on the innocents....He betrayed the Small sons of Guru ji while the Muslim Brothers nabi kahn and Ghani kahn risked their very life to SAVE GURU JI..Diwan Such nand a HINDU advised FOR the KILLING of the sahibzadahs..Nawab of Maler Kotla SHER KHAN advised AGAINST killing INNOCENTS.. MUSLIMS will NEVER say Sikhs are MUSLIMS..HINDUS say this all the time... In spite of this I have many Hindu Friends who are very dear to me..I go to the local Hindu mandir to TEACH HINDI to Hindu students..BUT then these are ordinary street HINDUS..many of whom SAVED their SIKH neighbours from the rajiv Goondas in 1984...NOT the "HINDUS" who want Sikhs dead. There is a DIFFERENCE..and I know the difference.

Re: a beautiful scene

khalistani · 18 Jul 2005

mahai na ganasai pritham manayao kisan bisan kabhoo na dhoayoo raam rheem puraan kuraan anaik kahain mathe aik na manyaoo and theres also a shabad that says who cares if raam killed a couple of demons, etc. hindu devthai are nothing they are creations of akaal like us thas it' they cannot MEET vaheguru they WISH for human joon maharaja ranjit singh, despite his seva, did MANY things anti gurmat the main problem with hindu dharm is they have forgotten one akaal and fallen into this devtha bhanga, who are NOTHING only one vaheguru our panth will not fall into the same bhanga hindus fell into well always pooj ONE SUPREME CREATOR OF ALL vaheguuuruu je no one else only vaheguru je bhula chuka maf

Re: a beautiful scene

charanjeev singh · 18 Jul 2005

We all have our biases veerji. My bias is that no pictures of the Guru should be made at all. Obviously this is not the case as you can see the position of people and their devotion to pictures. When i see pictures along side with the Guru (Gurbaani), it saddens me a little bit, no matter how well the pictures are painted, because the Guru is the Gurbaani and not the picture. It is understandable that the artist has his view, and Guru knows the condition of their heart; however views expressed on this thread also express the condition of the respected authors' hearts. About your point about hindu dieties with depictions of the Gurus paintings; this is not allowed by Gurmat; for no painting can depict the Guru; to see the Guru is to have darshan (holy vision) of Guru Granth Sahib and the Khalsa (true Gursikhs). We can learn from this thread, so i do not support the admin. removing this thread. We can learn that even while we are trying to beautify the Guru we must not alter, nor falter on Gurbaani or Gurmat. p.s. raja ranjit singh might have been a good leader, but him supporting pictures alongside with dieties etc. is not valid because Guru and Guru Panth does not support this; it is not Gurmat. bhul chuk mauf - i still thank you for sharing this, because when i see the Oankaar especially, my heart melts. wjkk wjkf

Re: a beautiful scene

singh · 19 Jul 2005

jarnail I think this was a genuine mistake by a kashmiri who copied it as explained earlier, no other motives - the painting without a doubt covered the Dasam Granth, hence the images of hindu dieties.. As stated earlier you got look at the Sikh depictions of the Gurus - (Ignore the hindu images) Our heritage is under threat - take the restoration of Golen Temple, its a complete nightmare, original gold pannels (of time of ranjit singh) in a store room. If your so worried, let me see out there protesting about Sikh heritage. Most Sikhs these days talk the talk... The post was intended to share a painting of our Gurus, many of you have just used it to attack hinduism. but i suppose you are the chosen 'SIKHS' who appear to be very arrogant who know sweet **** all

Re: a beautiful scene

A Singh · 19 Jul 2005

The responses on this thread as so predictation and point to why Sikhs today confuse "agriculture" with "culture"!!!!

Re: a beautiful scene

................. · 19 Jul 2005

A Singh please elaborate The responses on this thread as so predictation and point to why Sikhs today confuse "agriculture" with "culture"!!!!

Re: a beautiful scene

singh · 19 Jul 2005

JARNAIL - CHARANJEEV - KHALASITANI THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE GURUS AND YOU ARE: THE GURUS SAW THE LIGHT OF GOD IN ALL NO MATTER WHO THEY WERE YOU THREE SEE THE LIGHT ONLY IN YOU SELF

Re: a beautiful scene

charanjeev singh · 19 Jul 2005

singh, are you trying to imply that the dieties are Gurmat? I do not understand where you have made that statement from. Maybe you should be reminded of Guru Gobind Singh Jee's promise; translated as per veechar; as long as the khalsa remains distinct i will give them all my strength and power. when they go in the ways of the brahmin (any other way) I will not love them. please also try to do veechar of Guru Granth Sahib Jee and the views expressed about dieties. 'Brahma Bishan Mahadeo Treh Gun Rogee Vich Haumai Kaar Kamai' these are the three dieties believed to be the highest of the dieties; so if the highest are inflicted with these diseases, how can their lower subjects be greater. My simple point is this; Gurbaani should not be altered. Maybe it is you who cannot see that Guru Nanak lives in the Shabad; and you dont care when Gurbaani is altered because your eyes do not behold the Darshan of Partak Guru. As for seeing the light in myself; i wish; all i see is kaam krodh lobh moh and especially hankaar, actually especially kaam, no krodh, you know what, they all there STRONG! they jut dont want to leave and they are so much in myself, that i got no room for anything else. Singh, as i said before, this is a beautiful picture, i still see the Guru in the Akhaara, but i am saddened to see the Guru altered. p.s. i have not written any posts in anger nor in josh. They have been written with peace and calmity. I do appolgize if you have been offended in any way. No offence was meant to be targeted. 'dukalang pransee dyalang saroopeh sada ang sangeh abhangang bhebootheh' waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: a beautiful scene

singh · 19 Jul 2005

there u go again, im not impying the dieties are in any way shape or form associated with gurmat or sikhi. i agree gurbani shouldnt be altered - but it was probably a blo*dy genuine mistake by some kashmiri whilst copying - you arent listening - you are to absorbed in your own views and thoughts. you should try reading the posts. Most of your posts and others have displayed utter arrogance ..lets just leave it

Re: a beautiful scene

charanjeev singh · 19 Jul 2005

The reason I take this very seriously is this; 1000 years from now someone is going to look at this is and with conviction say 'look this is how Guru Sahib is; look this is puraatan' So i do take these mistakes very seriously. I do appologize for not being so shortsighted. As for my posts being in utter arrogance; it is because I am arrogance in the partakh form. I do appologize. As I mentioned earlier, I am absorbed by Hankaar. As your request; left. bhul chuk mauf wjkk wjkf