Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

preaching or not

preaching or not

naamras24/7 · 15 Jul 2005

wjkk wjkf do you guyz think its right to tell other people what to do, even if they are doing paap? is it our duty to tell other sikhs what to do? how about if you don't know them? like if you saw i singh/singhani doing paap would you get up and say something even if you know that person is not going to listen to a word you say? i kind of know what i would do but its nice to listen to the sangats view which i find is quite important. wjkk wjkf [%sig%]

Re: preaching or not

Blackblueandorange Singh · 15 Jul 2005

to PREACH to someone, ONE must THINK his KNOWLEGDE is SUPERIOR to the person he is preaching to. thus INCREASING ones EGO even if INTENTIONS are GOOD, ie spread sikhi. GURMUKHS inspire by EXAMPLE, they themselves repeat NAM with EVERY BREATHE and INSPIRE others to do the same GURMUKHS eat, sleep and TALK LITTLE, they dont entertain themselves preaching. ONLY GURU can SHOW one the PATH to SALVATION.- kathhanee kehi bharam n jaaee || By preaching sermons, one's doubt is not dispelled. sabh kathh kathh rehee lukaaee || Everyone is tired of preaching and teaching. jaa ko guramukh aap bujhaaee || The Lord causes the Gurmukh to understand; Look at it this way, everyone agrees SADH SANGHAT is ABOVE any INDIVIDUAL HOW CAN AN INDIVIDUAL PREACH TO SADH SANGHAT???????

Re: preaching or not

akjgreat · 15 Jul 2005

instead of shouting out one owns words (manmat) sing out the praises of god and observe the power of gurbani - example from Bhai sahib (rangle sajjan): example 1) Bhai Arjan Singh Astonishing Happening at Ambala Once a person given to jesting and practical joking engaged innocent being, Sant Arjan Singh, in talk at Ambala. Keeping him busied in talk, he let him to the area of prostitutes. All the prostitutes gathered around and tried to incite passion and seduce young Bhai Arjan Singh Ji. Finding himself thus entrapped, he got infuriated in Divine fervor. He sang Gurubani Shabad in loud voice with heart-rending emotion. All the prostitutes were shaken into realization of their sinful lowliness. They now pleaded with Sant Ji, "O' Beloved of Guru Nanak, Gurumukh Sant Ji! Please pray to the Lord for our redemption too. We promise to give up our sinful living." example 2)Bhai harbachan singh, in youth was an atheist, his gursikh father could not change him with preaching, so he asked guruji to help him, help him he did, Bhai harbachan singh one day was walking past a kirtan programme, he could not help but to sit down and listen, so intoxicating were guru jis hymes Bhai Harbachan Singh lost bodily conciousness. Bhai sahib went on to take amrit.

Re: preaching or not

vichar · 16 Jul 2005

gursikhs have a responsibility to tell there family what is right and wrong eg- father should teach children fundamentals of gurmat this is different however from preaching to crowds in an attempt to convert people/ change their views , which i dont really agree with.

Re: preaching or not

vivek · 16 Jul 2005

well said blackblueandorange singh in response to naamras24/7, if you have a sister or cousin who is commiting bujjar kurehit i would tell them what theyre doing is wrong and advise them to stop, i wouldnt call this preaching. if he/she wants to take youre advise they can, if they dont they dont - only guru can really change someone. i see preaching as going out of youre way to convert large numbers of people into sikhi, which isnt the goal in sikhi, goal=find god. if you are determined to find god you will act in away which inspires people, without having to preach a word preaching to crowds will not take you closer to god, it will only increase youre ego kathhanee badhanee kehan kehaavan || samajh paree tho bisariou gaavan ||3|| When one comes to understand, he forgets his preaching, ranting and raving, and arguing. ||3|| kehath kabeer pa(n)ch jo choorae || thin thae naahi param padh dhoorae ||4||2||11|| Says Kabeer, the state of supreme dignity is never far from those who conquer the five demons of the body passions "aap jape avra naam japaave" , you yourself repeat naam and in doing so you will inspire others gurbani is more powerful than a mortals words, as akjgreat has explained

Re: preaching or not

naamras24/7 · 16 Jul 2005

yea...thanks all of you. i agree with viveks point..anyone else willing to give their opinion?

Re: preaching or not

im stupid and need help!! · 19 Jul 2005

well i agree with viveks point... i think that in order 2 preach to sum1 else...u must think that ur above them and therefore better than them... this increases ur ego... which is bad!! ive read alot of posts in this forum and sum of them hav evidence of preaching but i dont think those people see it as preaching... i think that in a way tellin people that are close 2 u... if their doin sumthin wrong is not actually preaching.. its jus helpin them along but tellin people that u hardly know, what 2 do... is wrong and it means that u r judgin them ... and only waheguru can judge us... sorry if ive said anything wrong or 2 upset anyone!!! wjkk wjkf ps... if any1 else has any other views... id love 2 hear them??