Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

vishnu bhagat · 12 Jul 2005

I got this from the following link: http://www.sikhawareness.com/sikhawareness/viewtopic.php?t=6564 The Shabd is in Rag Maru, by Satguru Arjun, 1082 Ang. This is a Shabad by Satguru Arjun Devan Dev in praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru): [url]http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=3794 [/url] You will see names of Krishna Bhagvan like: Madhusudan (Killer of Madhu demon), Damodar, Rikhikesh, Govardhan Dhari (lifter of Gavardhan mountain), Murali-Manohar (Manohar the player of the flute), Mohan, Madhav, Murari (the flute player), Narsingh (man-lion Avatar), Narayan (the abode of man), Bavan (Avatar of Vishnu), Ram Chand, Chakrapani (wielder of the Sudarshan Chakra), Gopi-nath (Master of the Gopi's), Basudev, Niranjan and loads more. You will love this Shabad, especially if you are a Vishnu-Krishna hater. Dhan Dhan Shri Krishna Maharaj! Dhan Dhan Satguru Arjun Maharaj! [%sig%]

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

manjh payara guru ko · 12 Jul 2005

rubish

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

one_more_singh · 12 Jul 2005

I don't know of anyone being a Vishnu-Krishna hater. This shabad by Guru Arjan Dev ji has Guru Sahib paying obeisance to Akal Purakh, saying the Waheguru embodies (and is the source of) these qualities attributed to all of these god/goddesses (or in other words Waheguru IS the creator, destroyer,....., etc.) It shouldn't be misconstrued as instructions to worship these gods/goddesses. Sikhs only worship One. It says that if any of these gods/goddesses have done anything, it is only through the grace of Waheguru. Also consult the following shabad: http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=2296

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

JSGyani "Arshi" · 12 Jul 2005

Couldnt agree more with "One more Singh" ji. well said. ...and "manjh pyara Guru ko..." you have taken the words out of my mouth......it is really stretching the meanings way out to say that Guru Ji is "giving honour" to these gods and goddesses....GURU JI is GIVING HONOUR to ONLY AKAL PURAKH....the EK OANKAAR that is mentioned in the very beginning of GURBANI...We SIKHS dont beleive in any avtaars, apparitions, god, devtas, devis, krishans, vishnus, ganeshas...idols...whatever....ONLY SHAKTEE of WAHEGURU JI.

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

ksingh · 12 Jul 2005

KISAN BISAN KABHOO NEH DHYAAOO !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

charanjeev singh · 12 Jul 2005

Priceless are His Virtues, Priceless are His Dealings. Priceless are His Dealers, Priceless are His Treasures. Priceless are those who come to Him, Priceless are those who buy from Him. Priceless is Love for Him, Priceless is absorption into Him. Priceless is the Divine Law of Dharma, Priceless is the Divine Court of Justice. Priceless are the scales, priceless are the weights. Priceless are His Blessings, Priceless is His Banner and Insignia. Priceless is His Mercy, Priceless is His Royal Command. Priceless, O Priceless beyond expression! Speak of Him continually, and remain absorbed in His Love. The Vedas and the Puraanas speak. The scholars speak and lecture. Brahma speaks, Indra speaks. The Gopis and Krishna speak. Shiva speaks, the Siddhas speak. The many created Buddhas speak. The demons speak, the demi-gods speak. The spiritual warriors, the heavenly beings, the silent sages, the humble and serviceful speak. Many speak and try to describe Him. Many have spoken of Him over and over again, and have then arisen and departed. If He were to create as many again as there already are, even then, they could not describe Him. He is as Great as He wishes to be. O Nanak, the True Lord knows. If anyone presumes to describe God, he shall be known as the greatest fool of fools! ||26|| Translation JapJeeSahib Pauri, Sri Guru Granth Sahib jee There is only One Creator; the Creator who created all including krishna. We dont worship the creation, we owe allegiance to the Creator and hence Waheguruu Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguruu Ji Ki Fateh! [%sig%]

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

k · 12 Jul 2005

just to let u know even guru gobind singh ji did not worship any hindu gods or godesses when reading dasm granth u gotta understand that guru gobind singh ji ONLY worships AKAAL PURKH you can learn this by studying the viakaaran and wat not

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

Gurdaspuria · 12 Jul 2005

Vishnu Bhagat jee Before you understand the sabad you mentioned. Look the following sabad by Guru Arjun dev jee which establish relationship between God and Vishnu, Bharma,Inder, Shiva------ Bhagats. http://www.sikhitothemax.com/Page.asp?SourceID=G&PageNo=&ShabadID=4124&Format=2 This Shabad is by Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Raag Bhairao on Pannaa 1156 Bhairao, Fifth Mehl: He created millions of incarnations of Vishnu. He created millions of universes as places to practice righteousness. He created and destroyed millions of Shivas. He employed millions of Brahmas to create the worlds. ||1|| Such is my Lord and Master, the Lord of the Universe. I cannot even describe His Many Virtues. ||1||Pause|| Millions of Mayas are His maid-servants. Millions of souls are His beds. Millions of universes are the limbs of His Being. Millions of devotees abide with the Lord. ||2|| Millions of kings with their crowns and canopies bow before Him. Millions of Indras stand at His Door. Millions of heavenly paradises are within the scope of His Vision. Millions of His Names cannot even be appraised. ||3|| Millions of celestial sounds resound for Him. His Wondrous Plays are enacted on millions of stages. Millions of Shaktis and Shivas are obedient to Him. He gives sustenance and support to millions of beings. ||4|| In His Feet are millions of sacred shrines of pilgrimage. Millions chant His Sacred and Beautiful Name. Millions of worshippers worship Him. Millions of expanses are His; there is no other at all. ||5|| Millions of swan-souls sing His Immaculate Praises. Millions of Brahma's sons sing His Praises. He creates and destroys millions, in an instant. Millions are Your Virtues, Lord - they cannot even be counted. ||6|| Millions of spiritual teachers teach His spiritual wisdom. Millions of meditators focus on His meditation. Millions of austere penitents practice austerities. Millions of silent sages dwell in silence. ||7|| Our Eternal, Imperishable, Incomprehensible Lord and Master, the Inner-knower, the Searcher of hearts, is permeating all hearts. Wherever I look, I see Your Dwelling, O Lord. The Guru has blessed Nanak with enlightenment. ||8||2||5|| bhairo mehalaa 5 || kott bisan keenae avathaar || kott brehama(n)dd jaa kae dhhramasaal || kott mehaes oupaae samaaeae || kott brehamae jag saajan laaeae ||1|| aiso dhhanee guvi(n)dh hamaaraa || baran n saako gun bisathhaaraa ||1|| rehaao || kott maaeiaa jaa kai saevakaae || kott jeea jaa kee sihajaae || kott oupaarajanaa thaerai a(n)g || kott bhagath basath har sa(n)g ||2|| kott shhathrapath karath namasakaar || kott ei(n)dhr t(h)aadtae hai dhuaar || kott baiku(n)t(h) jaa kee dhrisattee maahi || kott naam jaa kee keemath naahi ||3|| kott pooreeath hai jaa kai naadh || kott akhaarae chalith bisamaadh || kott sakath siv aagiaakaar || kott jeea dhaevai aadhhaar ||4|| kott theerathh jaa kae charan majhaar || kott pavithr japath naam chaar || kott poojaaree karathae poojaa || kott bisathhaaran avar n dhoojaa ||5|| kott mehimaa jaa kee niramal ha(n)s || kott ousathath jaa kee karath brehama(n)s || kott paralo oupath nimakh maahi || kott gunaa thaerae ganae n jaahi ||6|| kott giaanee kathhehi giaan || kott dhhiaanee dhharath dhhiaan || kott thapeesar thap hee karathae || kott muneesar muon mehi rehathae ||7|| avigath naathh agochar suaamee || poor rehiaa ghatt a(n)tharajaamee || jath kath dhaekho thaeraa vaasaa || naanak ko gur keeou pragaasaa ||8||2||5||

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

. · 12 Jul 2005

Khanda Prithmai Saaj Kai Jin Sabh Saensaar Upaya Brahma Bishan Mahesh Saaj Kudratee Da Khail Rachaa(ai) Bnaya (Siri Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Jee - Vaar Siri Bhagautee Jee Kee)

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

Gurdaspuria · 13 Jul 2005

Vishnu Bhagat jee Before you understand the sabad you mentioned. Also look at the following Sabad about the birth of Shri Krishna. This Shabad is by Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Raag Bhairao on Pannaa 1136 Let that mouth be burnt, which says that our Lord and Master is subject to birth. ||3|| http://www.sikhitothemax.com/Page.asp?SourceID=G&PageNo=&ShabadID=4063&Format=2 Bhairao, Fifth Mehl, First House: One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: Setting aside all other days, it is said that the Lord was born on the eighth lunar day. ||1|| Deluded and confused by doubt, the mortal practices falsehood. The Lord is beyond birth and death. ||1||Pause|| You prepare sweet treats and feed them to your stone god. God is not born, and He does not die, you foolish, faithless cynic! ||2|| You sing lullabyes to your stone god - this is the source of all your mistakes. Let that mouth be burnt, which says that our Lord and Master is subject to birth. ||3|| He is not born, and He does not die; He does not come and go in reincarnation. The God of Nanak is pervading and permeating everywhere. ||4||1|| bhairo mehalaa 5 ghar 1 ik oa(n)kaar sathigur prasaadh || sagalee thheeth paas ddaar raakhee || asattam thheeth govi(n)dh janamaa see ||1|| bharam bhoolae nar karath kacharaaein || janam maran thae rehath naaraaein ||1|| rehaao || kar pa(n)jeer khavaaeiou chor || ouhu janam n marai rae saakath dtor ||2|| sagal paraadhh dhaehi loronee || so mukh jalo jith kehehi t(h)aakur jonee ||3|| janam n marai n aavai n jaae || naanak kaa prabh rehiou samaae ||4||1||

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

Singh · 13 Jul 2005

LOL this is one of the stupidest posts yet by vishnu bhagat. The very first teaching of the Guru is ik oan kar, hence it is clear from the start that there is only one God in Sikhi. Guru Ji speciaifaically states 1 in a number format to stop any misreadings. Vishnu bhagat really needs to read more gurbani and properly understand it. In literally numerous places Guru Ji puts down the so call the Hindu trinity. They are not worthy of worship as they are consumed by the five vices and they themselves seek Akal Purkh. Vishnu Bhagat read what Guru Sahib is saying about your gods yourself on the following angs Page394 Line 16 Raag Aasaa: Guru Arjan Dev, Page455 Line 16 Raag Aasaa: Guru Arjan Dev, Page480 Line 17 Raag Aasaa: Saint Kabir, Page509 Line 10 Raag Goojree Kee Vaar: Guru Amar Das, Page518 Line 9 Raag Goojree: Guru Arjan Dev, Page735 Line 17 Raag Soohee: Guru Ram Das, Page852 Line 12 Raag Bilaaval: Guru Amar Das, Page908 Line 1 Raag Raamkalee: Guru Nanak Dev, Page948 Line 14 Raag Raamkalee: Guru Amar Das The above is literally the tip of the iceberg, clearly showing that worshipping any gods is against gurmat. You will see that almost every time Gur Sahib mentions these gods he shows how they are not worthy of worship. So sadly Bishan Bhagat has failed to read the whole Guru Granth Sahib, and simply out of ignorance misunderstood the meaning of a shabad. Nevertheless to resolve any doubts Vishnu Bhagat please post more shadads where you feel Guru Ji is contradicting himself, and leaving the one God to worship feeble mortals like Vishnu/Krishna. As for the Sahbad it is obvious that Guru Sahib is not worshipping Bisan, Krishna etc not only because this contradicts his own teachings but from the shabad itself. Guru Sahib is clearly talking about Akal Pukh who was the force behind Krishna etc and inside them. Guru Ji makes this clear by saying, He Himself is the milk-maid, and He Himself is Krishna reffering to Akal Purkh. Guru Ji is worshipping the one who destroyed the demons, wore the robes and carried weapons ie Akal Purkh who was behind all this and the real doer including Saving of Dropadi's honor . Guru Ji speaks of all Akal Pukh being a fish in the river, and the river itself in exactly the same way. Guess Bisan Bhagat also thinks that Guru Ji is worshipping fish as there is no difference. Akal Pukh is as much Krishna as he is me and you ie in us all, and doing all our deeds as per Gurmat. Guru Ji even says in this very shabad “You have thousands of eyes, and thousands of forms”, ie all beings are his forms. Hence it was Waheguru playing the flute etc, just like it is Waheguru reading this message. Its so clear that Guru Sahib is worshipping Waheguru that he actually describes him in ways which are clearly not Vishnu, Krishna or what ever ie undying image, formless, The Supreme Lord God, imperishable, the Transcendent Lord, the Inner-knower, the Searcher of hearts., beyond need of any sustenance, free of hate, all-pervading, imperishable, eternal etc Bisan/Krishna etc are clearly not these things as per common sense and Gurbani As for names, we all know that the names in Guru Granth Sahib are used for God. They all have meanings representing his qualities, for a complete definition of each words read Mahan Khosh. Some words in this shabad are well known Karam Naams used for Waheguru, while others are words describing/praising Waheguru through what Krishna etc did. Dhan Guru Arjan Sahib Ji “He (God) hath Created millions of Krishnas like worms.” Dhasm Granth Page50 Line 18 p.s no one is Vishnu hater, only a hater of those wo distort gurbani and gurmat

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

Singh · 13 Jul 2005

would also like to say that all posts on this shabad should be allowed to be posted so we can have an honest debate.

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

Jaspal Singh · 13 Jul 2005

Vishnu Bhagat is clearly not a SIkh who follows Sikhi, as Guru Ji clearly says "eaekas kee sir kaar eaek jin brehamaa bisan rudhra oupaaeiaa || Everyone must serve the One Lord, who created Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva." Guru Amar Daas Ji Raag Bhairao 1130 "kabeer baisano hooaa th kiaa bhaeiaa maalaa maelee(n) chaar || Kabeer, what good is it to become a devotee of Vishnu, and wear four malas? " Bhagat Kabeer Ji Salok Kabeer Jee 1372 "brehamaa bisan sirae thai aganath thin ko mohu bhayaa man madh kaa || You (God) created countless Brahmas and Vishnus; their minds were intoxicated with emotional attachment." Bhatt Gayandh Svaiyay Mehl 5 1403 "He (God) created air, water and fire, Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva - the whole creation." Guru Amar Daas Ji Raag Gujri 509 It is clear that Vishnu is nothing more than another part of creation, like everything else. Vishnu is certainly not Waheguru, but Waheguru's creation like us all, and like all creation Waheguru is inside us and making us act as he wills.

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

Jaspal Singh · 13 Jul 2005

Vishnu is the sargun roop of waheguru, how funny Guru Ji blatantly says Shiva and Vishnu, and their incarnations, chant the Lord's Praise with their mouths, ang 518 The four Vedas, the Simritees and the Puraanas, Vishnu the Lord of Lakshmi and Lakshmi herself - none of them know the Lord. ||3|| 691 Forget the roop of Waheguru, Vishnu repeats the naam of Waheguru, and can not find his limits. How can Vishnu find Waheguru Ji, when Guru Sahib says Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva wander in the three qualities, while their egotism and desire increase. 852 Get a life and learn about Gurmat.

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

**- · 13 Jul 2005

Jaspal Singh Damn! Shesh...Oh no! We Hindus have got it all wrong. For the last 2000+ years before Guru Nanak graced this earth, we have been following an obselete (as Kulbir Singh puts it) incorrect path and method. Why did WaheGuru do this to us? Why did he/she/it not indicate in the four Vedas, the eighteen puranas the upanishads or the Vedanta sutras that the Sikh panth is the correct one to follow. I feal cheated! And why is he/she/it still doing it to millions of Hindus in South India, Bengal, Gujarat, Bengal, Manipur, Andhara Pradesh and Indoneisia who have never heard of Guru Nanak, let alone understand Punjabi...help us please! [%sig%]

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

search for tat · 13 Jul 2005

i think many of these neo nangs from sikhawareness and sikhstudent camp (bob, rob, knob, nids, jagdeep, & rest of goat killing gangsters) need to learn punjabi. Then they would stop believing the literal meanings in romanised translations. Plus I do not think these guys are really that thick that they actually believe it. They just do it wind people up or create controversy to advertise themselves and their egos. But if vishnu bhagat does belive it, he should openly put is full name and town. Any proud vishnu bhagat would do this? Except those who are scared of mickey take?

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

charanjeev singh · 13 Jul 2005

Dear **-, To understand the Dharam of Waheguruu, one has to have a lot of knowledge. For it is this knowledge that removes duality from one's mind. Knowledge and realization together. Knowledge of yugs, creation, and Creator. This knowledge is found in Guru GranthSahibJee and Bhai Gurdaas Jee dee Baani (please note that the knowledge here is very universal. It is not geared towards a special group of people and is knowledge for any human being. It is caste, colour, religion, etc blind) We now live in Kalyug, and in this age of fire and hypocrisy, and other vices, a path was laid by Waheguruu Himself. This path abadons all past ways, rituals, and establishes a direct connection with God through the word or Shabad. It is like cleaning the blackboard and starting from a new slate (the mind). Just because a tradition has been going on for thousands of years does not mean anything in reality. The reality is while you are following these traditions, are you truly coming closer to the Creator who is within oneself? Are you realizing who you are? These answers are not derived from scholary talks or discussions or convictions of ones' beliefs. This is only found when one themselves contemplate themselves. From this true form of contemplation one comes to understand the vices within themselves and realizes them and themselves very clearly; very clearly. They come to understand the path of Dharam which merge them with the Supreme soul while they are here on earth, and do not wait till death. Those who are waiting for death to merge with the Lord; in essence might be disappointed because the path is to Merge Now; while you are still living (however when you merge you actually die while living and this is reffered to as being Jeevan Mukat). So following what others have been doing does not dictate righteous and non-righteous. This is only realized by the individual in hand who wishes to truly realize their True Form. Very few thread this path; as it is pre-destined. This path is as fine as a edge of a sword and as fine as Kesh. Not everyone can thread this path, for it is a very fine path. A path of death actually. A constant rememberance of death; and this is known as the Rehat Maryada (Rehit-conduct while living Mar de yaad - to constantly remember the true destiny - death) It is this rememberance of death that truly makes a person one who we refer to as a sikh (disciple). It is from the one who abolishes darkness and fills one with light; Guru; that the path for self realization is obtained. Those who abandon their 'old blackboards' and start afresh on this 'new slate' obtain the gifts of knowledge and enlightment from the Guru. waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

JSGyani "Arshi" · 13 Jul 2005

Dear Author **-, ji, NOBODY would argue with you and your beleifs>>>> We Hindus have got it all wrong. For the last 2000+ years before Guru Nanak graced this earth, we have been following an obselete (as Kulbir Singh puts it) incorrect path and method. Why did WaheGuru do this to us? Why did he/she/it not indicate in the four Vedas, the eighteen puranas the upanishads or the Vedanta sutras that the Sikh panth is the correct one to follow. I feal cheated! And why is he/she/it still doing it to millions of Hindus in South India, Bengal, Gujarat, Bengal, Manipur, Andhara Pradesh and Indoneisia who have never heard of Guru Nanak, let alone understand Punjabi...help us please! >>>>>>>>>>>> YOU Could be CORRECT..who cares....BUT you see the original poster posted GURBANI..from GURU GRANTH JI of the SIKHS.....and we have a right to say what we mean on the subject .. IF he had posted from the VEDAS, Simrtees, Shastars, etc etc we woudl Have NO PROBLEM..they are HINDU religious Texts..by all means FOLLOW them to the LETTER. Vishnu, Krishna Shiv Raam etc ec are all Hindu Gods, listed a ssuch in the Vedas ..and its all PERFECTLY OK 100% with us..we are NOT criticising the Vedas, or why hidnus follow them... I hope this clarifies...GURU TEG BAHADUR JI gave hIS HEAD in DELHI for YOUR RIGHT to HINDUISM....100% as is in the Vedas shahstars, Upanishads...and we Sikhs coudnt have it any other way as well..surely YOU will give us our RIGHT to Treat GURBANI as we like ?? wouldnt you ??

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

Jaspal Singh · 14 Jul 2005

Dear **- or should I say Vishnu Bhagat “We Hindus have got it all wrong. For the last 2000+ years before Guru Nanak graced this earth, we have been following an obselete (as Kulbir Singh puts it) incorrect path and method. Why did WaheGuru do this to us? Why did he/she/it not indicate in the four Vedas, the eighteen puranas the upanishads or the Vedanta sutras that the Sikh panth is the correct one to follow. I feal cheated!” Whether Hinduism is right or wrong is not the point. The point is that in Sikhism Vishnu and the other so called trinity are not objects of worship but are shown in literally hundreds of different places as being mere creations, also caught in the cycle of births and death, and the five vices. Hence they are not to be Worshiped only the one which Guru Sahib reveals is what in Sikhi is to be worshipped, no devta. “And why is he/she/it still doing it to millions of Hindus in South India, Bengal, Gujarat, Bengal, Manipur, Andhara Pradesh and Indoneisia who have never heard of Guru Nanak, let alone understand Punjabi...help us please!” What’s your point, so what if Hindu’s have not heard of Guru Nanak, how does this change or influence Sikhi? Also the last I heard Hindu’s were falling over themselves to declare Guru Nanak a Hindu and trying to argue that Sikh’s are Hindu’s, which clearly shows the greatness of Sikhi albeit completely wrong. I would also like to say that in no way am I against Hinduism. If that’s what people want to believe in that’s great and its their human right which we as Sikhs should respect and protect. However Sikhi preaches worship of the one and no other avtar, bhut, snake or whatever. Sorry if I offended any Hindu’s as it was not my intention, I think we all respect other peoples faiths, however will not tolerate false preaching against the beauty of Sikhi.

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

**- · 14 Jul 2005

Bhai Jaspal Singh ji: - I am not Vishnu Bhagat. Bhai JSGyani Arshi Ji: - Regarding your last statement/paragraph about Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji, I think it is best to say 'lets agree to disagree' and leave it at that. We will not convince each other with our arguements about your assertion. Please forgive me if I have offended anyone on this forum. [%sig%]

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

Jaspal Singh · 15 Jul 2005

**- "Bhai JSGyani Arshi Ji: - Regarding your last statement/paragraph about Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji, I think it is best to say 'lets agree to disagree' and leave it at that. We will not convince each other with our arguements about your assertion." What assertion was being made? What is you view?

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

sinshghja · 15 Jul 2005

>>>>>>Bhai JSGyani Arshi Ji: - Regarding your last statement/paragraph about Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji, I think it is best to say 'lets agree to disagree' and leave it at that. We will not convince each other with our arguements about your assertion.>>>>>>>>> what do youy mean by that?

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

A Singh · 15 Jul 2005

What he's said! It's quite simple, he doesn't feel it's worth discussing further, let's move and close this chapter...

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

Singh · 15 Jul 2005

who is Vishnu Bhagat?

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

Singh · 15 Jul 2005

Vishnu Bhagat, you made a huge (hugely wrong) statement expressing that Guru Sahib worshipped Vihnu and/or his avtars. However the few replies to your posts both explaining the shabad and showing via Gurbani what Gurmats position is on Devta’s appear to have left you silent. I request that if you feel in any way whatsoever that in Sikhi Guru Sahib Worships Devt’a and not the One God please start a new thread explaining why you think so. All I ask is that every post has the proper page references from Gurbani. I would also request the admin to allow all Vishnu Bhagat’s post no matter how stupid, as I do not want to leave him thinking that he could not get his point across, and also as I want to have the opportunity to smash every lowly philosophy he holds to that affect. If you want to have such a discussion Vishnu Bhagat please start a post as per the above, and list why you think what you do (with proper refs), and I shall respond on Monday.

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

**- · 15 Jul 2005

On 07-15-05 08:36, Singh wrote: "and also as I want to have the opportunity to smash every lowly philosophy he holds to that affect." Why Singh, does it help boost your own ego? Does it make you feel better about yourself? This guy has obviously come to this forum to stir up some 'masalla' and I think you are doing what he has wanted. Think about it: of all the Sikh message forums, why would he post this on a Tapoban forum? [%sig%]

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

jugroop singh · 17 Jul 2005

Veer/Bhain '**_' Ji, you wrote: 'Why Singh, does it help boost your own ego? Does it make you feel better about yourself? This guy has obviously come to this forum to stir up some 'masalla' and I think you are doing what he has wanted. Think about it: of all the Sikh message forums, why would he post this on a Tapoban forum?' > you're absolutely right; this person has come to this forum, just like YOU came to this forum (and made you comments within the snake-bite thread in particular) - to stir-up argument, hatred and anger with your poisonous remarks.

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

narinder · 17 Jul 2005

Blues,Vishnu Bhagat and **- is the same person.A Punjabi Hindu living in New Delhi who has been brought up with anti sikh hate and instead of admitting the hate he has for sikhs,he puts blame on sikhs(typical of the way things work in India).May God help his wandering soul and thoughts.

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

Singh · 18 Jul 2005

"and also as I want to have the opportunity to smash every lowly philosophy he holds to that affect." Why Singh, does it help boost your own ego? Does it make you feel better about yourself? ) It does not boost my ego, and certainly does not make me feel good when Sikhi is being changed and distorted. I simply wanted to ensure that they could put their views across without any prevention and consequently only when knowing where they come from could their philosophy be argued against. Nothing to do with ego, just common sence. I guess in your opinion anyone who stands up for anything and wanting to find things out is doing it for their egos, better to walk around with your eyes closed instead. If you can’t contribute to the discussion keep out and mind your own ego.

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

Mehtab Singh · 18 Jul 2005

http://www.khaleejtimes.com/DisplayArticle.asp?xfile=data/subcontinent/2005/July/subcontinent_July618.xml§ion=subcontinent&col=

Re: In praise of Vishnu-Krishna Bhagvan (Sargun Vahiguru)

**- · 18 Jul 2005

Veer Jugroop Singh Ji You said I spread hate, what did I do? Some guy puts up a post and renders someone poisonous simply because he is a Hindu; and what should I do - just sit back and take it? It is interesting to note that gadar_singh and other posters such as ekta, in the 'Snake Bite' thread made some very derogatory and viscous comments about Hindus and Hinduism and yet you have not reprimanded them. Do you not consider this as spreading hate also? Or is this OK? Why the double standards VeerJi? Regards Sitara PS I am not Vishnu Bhagat, you can ask the moderators to verify the IP address. [%sig%]