Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Respect for Sikh women

Respect for Sikh women

Gurpreet Kaur · 08 Jul 2005

I just wanted to say that I dont agree with everything posted on this forum, but Ive noticed that the Sikh Veers on this board are very respectable towards Sikh women and always address them with respect. I think that is truly commendable, maybe it is the same in other forums, but Ive noticed it here recently in particular. So I want to thank the Veer Jee's who have spoken to me with respect even though at times I have not deserved it. GurFateh!

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Kulbir Singh · 08 Jul 2005

Bhain Gurpreet Kaur jeeo, thank you for your kind words. Sikh bibiyaan are princesses of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj and as such deserve utmost respect. As for why I respect bibiyaan on this forum, I am forced to do so. My Shiri Matee jee, who frequents this forum will kill me if I disrespected bibiyaan on this forum and I am sure to never get samosay and Gulaab Jaamun for rest of my life. So, I was doing you no favour by showing you respect. I was doing so in order to ensure a constant supply of Gulaab Jaamuns and Samosay. Kulbir Singh

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 09 Jul 2005

Bhen Gurpreet Kaur jio, I read your posts on Sikhsangat as well. Good posts. The point you make is valid because as Sikhs of GURU NANAK JI SAHIB we would be doing Guru Ji a great disservice IF we disrespect the Princessses of Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj. Guru nanak Ji Sahib has given us a direct Command..So kio Manda Akhiyeh ...jit jammeh rajaan...[gurbani]so ikau mMdw AwKIey ijq jMmY rwjwn[/gurbani].... And also wehn we get married during the Laavan and anand karaj ceremony we are commanded by Guru Ji to Love, and Respect and treat each other as equals... SO even if we dont get Gulab jamuns and samosays ( like veer Kulbir Singh Ji..lucky veer).... we would still respect and love our sisters mothers wives and daughters...as GURU JI's Princesses....and always accord them MAXIMUM RESPECT and HONOUR.

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 09 Jul 2005

Kulbir Singh ji: "My Shiri Matee jee"....erm, is this not a Hindi title...would be more appropriate to use "My Singhnee"?

Re: Respect for Sikh women

JSGyani "Arshi" · 10 Jul 2005

Sri mati Jee is normally used in Punjabi writings as a "humourous way" of referring to ones other half....its an expression very very common among haas rass writers....read the works of the comedy writers. The male equvilaent is Sri Maan ji...

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Kharkoo · 10 Jul 2005

What's wrong with HIndi title? Guru sahib uses Hindi in gurbani...

Re: Respect for Sikh women

The Apprentice · 11 Jul 2005

I have respect for Sikh women who follow Sikhi. But this is what I've seen: A woman's first priority should be her family and yet we see so many who are so engrossed in worldly success that their families end up suffering. Women also have a lot more moh (mamta), which does act as a drawback in terms of spirituality, but without this mamta families would fall apart. Women are controlling and in many situations lack the foresight and emotional distance to make proper decisions. They are not natural leaders. I don't mean to attack women but I feel that many of them fight against the role that God has given them and try to incorporate the modern image of what a woman should be into there Sikhi. Be traditional, look after your families, do your husband's sewa and be happy. Women just aren't leadership material and should accept this and allow there husband's to be the leader in ghrist jeeven. If they try to fight this then their are unnecessary problems within the family. It is a woman's reponsbility to raise Gursikh children and yet we see so many kids who have no idea of what Sikhi is.

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Singh · 11 Jul 2005

"The Apprentice", no offence but your views totally suck. Guru Gobind Singh Jis wife led the Khalsa Panth for many years after he left his body. Mata Bhag Kaur led many Singhs into war. In recent years there were plenty of Babbar Singhnis who have done their seva. Women can be just as good leaders or fighters as men. They might not have the same physical force but it is only because of people and views like your own that Sikh women are kept in a sub ordinate role in society. I was in town not long ago and I saw a Bibi with a Dastar who had a successful city job and it made me very proud - more Singhnian should be asserting themselves and be the breadwinners in the same way as the Singhs are.

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Jaskaran Kaur · 11 Jul 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Thanx alot "Singh" for ur post towards "The Apprentice". Could;nt be said better. BUt would like to say one thing to "The Apprentice" that before u posting this here you should be mentioning all this to your own sister and mum. Cause ifff you think tat your Mother has played a gudd role of raising a Gursikh Kid like you, then i m sorry to say that nope she has failed. Gursikhs don't have certain views in their heads the sorta views you hold in your head about Woman. May Waheguru bless you with a gursikhi knowledge. Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Min Singh · 11 Jul 2005

Apprentice, I think that you need to see a doctor, because you got some issue to sort out. Sikhi is for respect AND equality for women.

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Singhni? · 11 Jul 2005

Apprentice, Your opinion sucks!!!!!! I never want to know who you are and never want to hear from you on this message board again because its the reason why you people make me hate everything in life so much. I hope infact I pray that women not men become the most successful people in life.

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Princess · 11 Jul 2005

'The Apprentice ", don't look all women like women around you. You seem to me a man who is suffering from a woman and think all women around this world are like the one you know. The truth is that your views are against gurmat and no one learns any thing good from your post. [%sig%]

Re: Respect for Sikh women

ShaktiShali Sha Soora · 11 Jul 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh Bhai Apprentice Jee seems like you don’t much about sikhi yourself, don’t you agree. Firstly, all males should also be doing seva for females, forget about that tradition rubbish, are males that stupid they can’t make any type of food. Vaheguru Je didn’t just give hands to females so that they can cook for men HELLO! Males have hands too. Now lets go back to that tradition concept, Khalsa, what does it mean, pure. Pure means cleanse to a soul that has the panj evils in control by means in this case the male doesn’t see himself to be higher then a female even his wife as he purely thinks less of himself by giving his wife the utmost respect as she would give to him. Also that soul would see equality in both genders similarly just as the Singhs in the past went to war so did the singnees so they are both equal in strength. There’s one story when Guru Gobind Singh Jee’s army went to war but then went running home to their wives and instead their wives went to the war for them and fought bravely. So this is the reason why there aren’t so many Khalsa even though there’s so many Sikhs. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< A woman's first priority should be her family and yet we see so many who are so engrossed in worldly success that their families end up suffering. >>>>>>>>>>>>>> So you think the female should be stuck at home helping the family with the cooking and cleaning while the males are aloud to freely commit to their own desire and success in life. Fools the father and if there’s a son they can help around the house remember that word EQUALITY!! <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< It is a woman's reponsbility to raise Gursikh children and yet we see so many kids who have no idea of what Sikhi is. >>>>>>>>>>>>>> It is not only woman’s responsibility to raise their children it is also the husband’s responsibility to raise their children. For example both Guru Teghbahadar Jee and his wife raised Guru Gobind Singh Jee, Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee was raised by his Father and I also have beautifully raised sisters by my parents working together and remember once married the couple become one. And remember the one who really raises these children is Vaheguru Jee and he can raise them into manmukhs if he wants to, all the parents have to do is try and teach them as much as sikhi as they can kindly and then the rest is up to Vaheguru Jee as the children themselves have their own mind. EQUALITY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! If a Sikh does not have this Vaheguru Jee can never be seen, look beyond what the eye sees and hears from others, see right. Why don’t you put yourself in a females shoe and see how you would feel not literally. And don’t think you have not been a female in any of your past lives. Expand your brain think to the utmost level. guramukh eaek dhrisatt kar dhaekhahu ghatt ghatt joth samoee jeeo ||2|| As Gurmukh, look upon all with the single eye of equality; in each and every heart, the Divine Light is contained. ||2|| VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: Respect for Sikh women

The Apprentice · 11 Jul 2005

{ Author: Singhni? Date: 07-11-05 12:01 Apprentice, Your opinion sucks!!!!!! I never want to know who you are and never want to hear from you on this message board again because its the reason why you people make me hate everything in life so much. I hope infact I pray that women not men become the most successful people in life. } My God! You've anger problems. Such an emotional outburst shows total lack of self control. I think that equality in gurmat is in terms of spirituality. But we have different duniyavee roles. God has created women so that they are able to nurture children and are naturally inclined towards role of care taker. Can you imagine mata Kartar Kaur telling Bhai Randhir Singh to cook his own food because she has to go out. Guru Tegh Bahadur sahib was away on parchar a lot while mata jee brought up there Son. Tell you all what. Make a list of all the chardi kala bibis you know. I'll make a list of all the chardi kalal Singhs and we'll see which list is longer. I rest my case.

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Jaskaran Kaur · 11 Jul 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh "The Apprentice" i just read ur post again. May i ask in which world you living in at the moment? As far as you mentioned abuottt Mata Kartar Kaur Ji and Mata Gujri Ji... let me ask you one thing... Are todays singhs worth for tat respect from a woman???? however i m not including all singhss cause there are plenty out there with chardi kala jeevan and iff you look at them they r being treated as the way you mentioned a woman should treat them. But most of them they just like chatting andd like getting respect from woman when whereas themselvf treat a woman as a piece of object. Them singhs worth that respect?? Yesss andd one more thing Who said that only woman is the one who raise there kids as a true gurmukh its herrrr pleasure to do so. Y not singhs??? Where a Man is also as much responsible for his kids cause kids are also a sign of his existance that he is also responsible for them lot to bring into this world. As far as Guru Teg Bahadur Ji's and Bhai Randhir Singh ji's jeevan concernd... there circumstances were diff they actually went out and done parchaar towards sikhi right sooo Mata Ji brought there sons up... where as in present timee, u tell me how many singhs r doing that deed??? Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji, Bhai Sahib Radhir Singh Ji were doing good deeds soo theyyy recieved good respect aswell and yeah DO NOT FORGET that they gave too much respect to Woman aswell. So rather then seeking a respect from a woman firstttt try to give respect to Woman. You wanna namee chardi kala singhs rightt and wanttt uss to name chardi kala singhaniya's name rightt??? OK u can fullfill your wish buttt b4 that rather then me mentioning names all i would like to say is and remind you off iss this is nott some sort off compition going on and another thing which u seems like forgetting is that When chardi kala singhs went out anddd gave shahediya for sikhi that timeee Singhniya aswell went in jails andd survived on 1 glass of water and saw their lil kids dieing in front of their eyes (when a mother to see a death of her own kid "part of her body" dieing in front of her eyes, that pain is similar to dieing every secof the moment and for for whole life) they still remain in chardi kala andd said all in waheguru's hukam and moreover they cuttt those singhaniya's kids were cutt into pieces and were forced to put their own kids body pieces which were given a shape of Nacklaces arround their neck, they still remained in chardi kala. where i betttt me or you (being a singh) would have fainted stright away. Look at Mata Bhago Ji, Mata Jeeto Ji etc etc there r laods to name. List is endlesss and so as singhs. So rather then you sitting here and competing Singhs vs singhniyaaa don't you think you should look at urslf first what yourslf has achieverd or contributed towards khalsa panth that you should seek for respect.(It goes to not just you it goes to everyone outthere) I am a 19 year old Guru Ji's daughter, i do respect Guru ke pyaare and yesss i do give them respect buttt at the same time i m indipentent aswell. The things you saidd might b possible in old days butt not in these days cause these dayss if u buy your own house then not only 1 person can runn itt. Sooo offcouse you need a help. I think i could go on and on buttt i would really like to say tat think about wot i said and plzzz plzzz plzzz rather then u sitting here and judging how singh and singhaniee should b firsttt judge urslf. Bhull Chukk Maaf!!! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Singh · 11 Jul 2005

Don't you realise that it is your very attitude which is causing there to be less "Chardi Kala Bibis"? Because within Punjabi culture women are seen as inferior, confined to the house and not useful in the wider world, look at the appauling female infanticide rates in Punjab. Whilst boys are told to keep their Dastar and Kesh, girls are encouraged to remove their Kesh and appear "pretty". If Sikh girls were given more motivation and confidence to pursue Sikhi and a spiritual path instead of told no one will marry them if they take Amrit and keep their Kesh, then yes perhaps there would be more Chardi Kala Bibis. BTW there still are alot of Chardi Kala Bibis

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Me · 12 Jul 2005

I think you're being too hard on the apprentice. He has made some valid points, I am a Sikh woman myself and I agree with some of his points. Sikh women do have a duty to raise their children via gurmat, as many spend more time working outside and leave their kids to other people, they dont have so much control over their upbringing. What is wrong with a wife serving her husband out of love? I am sure many of the people who posted had grandparents who shared and loved each other, with the woman ruling or in charge of the house. The woman is more effective and running the house, thats a fact, she has an inherent nature of nurturing others, its how she was created. We have difference, lets respect them, not mould them into our own views because we are too emotional. Women need to realise that feminity is important and beautiful, why do people on this forum have an obsession to wear (bana) exactly like men? Why should we look just like them? What about your feminine side? Should that not be respected and nurtured? I dont believe all women tried to look like men during the Guru's times, doesn't make sense.

Re: Respect for Sikh women

The Apprentice's master · 12 Jul 2005

>>>> Women need to realise that feminity is important and beautiful, why do people on this forum have an obsession to wear (bana) exactly like men? Why should we look just like them? What about your feminine side? Should that not be respected and nurtured? I dont believe all women tried to look like men during the Guru's times, doesn't make sense. >>>> wow wow wow Me Jee, hold the horses. I would never in a dream tell a Singhni or anyone not to wear guru's bana. The bana is the most feminine clothing I've ever seen and the most appropriate because guru sahib designed it himself. The feminine side isn't expressed through the clothes you wear but through your actions... All the women I know who wear bana appear more feminine and beautiful to me then those women who discard guru's bana for sluttish WEstern clothing. Feminity isn't the clothes you wear but your actions.

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Harmeet-Singh · 12 Jul 2005

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa ... Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh well ''Me'' id would just like to say that ... it is not an obestion with a bana and i dont think that these bibi's try to look like singh's they do it beacuse they want to be able to be called gursikh they do it because they got pyaar 4 sikhi ... and note this !! THEY DO IT BECAUSE THEY WISH TO REPRESENT GURU JI !! not to copy any1 not to look like any1 ... i have been watching this topic for a few day's now and everything that has been said by ''ShaktiShali Sha Soora'' , ''Singh'' & ''Jaskaran Kaur'' i totaly agree with ... ( and some other's ... ) a mother alone canot bring up a gursikh ... fair enuff it might have been done before but its alot easyer if a son / daughter has the influence of thir father too ... what i dont agree with is the way u make out like a woman's place is at home ... i am sorry to say that is just wrong... i would never expect any1 to say that u gotta stay at home look after the kid's u gotta clean up u gotta make my roti at night ... and the worst thing is they do all of this aswell as achiveing something in life !! please watch what you say about fellow gursikh ... you views have been read we understand what u are saying ... but dont it get trough to you so meny people are agueing with your view?? ... at least hear them out ... sikhi is all about learning !! learn something please !! Bhull Chukk Maaf Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa ... Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Respect for Sikh women

RoopKaur · 12 Jul 2005

>Women need to realise that feminity is important and beautiful, why do people on this forum have an obsession to wear (bana) exactly like men? Why should we look just like them? What about your feminine side? Should that not be respected and nurtured? I dont believe all women tried to look like men during the Guru's times, doesn't make sense.< The bana for a Khalsa is Guru ji's, not mens'. By wearing bana, a singhnee tries to look like their pita ji, Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji, not just the singhs of the Khalsa. Khalsa is the fauj of Akaal Purkh, and bana is its uniform, it has nothing to do with gender. Even puraatan singneeaa wore banaa, such as mata Bhaag Kaur. Besides it is much easier to do housework wearing a cholaa and without the stuffy chunni around you getting in the way all the time. There is no need for Singhneea to fit the societal ideal of what is feminine and what is not.

Re: Respect for Sikh women

ShaktiShali Sha Soora · 12 Jul 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh Are you blind Apprentice, do what I’ve said below? Why don’t you put yourself in a females shoe and see how you would feel not literally. And don’t think you have not been a female in any of your past lives. Expand your brain think to the utmost level. Also don't forget that the one and only special Bhai Fauja Singh Jee cooked and helped with the cleaning around his house and let his wife rest. He also loved his wife a lot and because of this he respected her. I'm a Singh but I’ve noticed a lot of white and black people believe in equality since they love their wife a lot maybe a lot of Sikhs have forgotten to love, that could be why most of them do not reach a high level in Naam Bhagti. Remember that Sikhs are unique we don't believe what other religions do such as Muslims and Hindus, they all have certain low roles for women and treat them like slaves and as a sex object and also stupid, we have to remember that we should believe in equality that is what Sikhi is all about. But even though we say to others e.g. Muslims, Hindus, white and blacks, that we believe in equality for both genders you’ve shown to be the same as them. Also was it necessary to bring negativity up on females, what is your problem, is it because for some reason your insecure about yourself or have they done something to you. <<<<<<<<<<<< Make a list of all the chardi kala bibis you know. I'll make a list of all the chardi kalal Singhs and we'll see which list is longer. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> I’m beginning to think that you’re a kid from what your writing. Keep in mind that quality and not quantity counts. So what if there’s a longer list for males than females both are the same, within the male is the female and within the female is the male. To me it doesn’t make a difference if the males have a longer list both females and males are the same and instead of keeping a separate list between them treat them as one. Don’t forget that Vaheguru Jee treats us all as one since were all called Brides and Vaheguru Jee the Husband. In addition, once Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee went to take Amrit but the Panj Pyara told him that he can only take it if his wife takes it with him since he had selflessly went to take Amrit himself without telling his wife as he thought he could reach Saachkhand without his wife. But Bhai Sahib Jee only reached Saachkhand because his wife journeyed with him, remember once married the couple become one. There is no difference between females and males. Sikhi is unique. We believe in Equality. This is part of becoming a Khalsa. ***** har kaa naam jan ko mukath jugath || The Name of the Lord is the path of liberation for His humble servants. har kai naam jan ko thripath bhugath || With the food of the Name of the Lord, His servants are satisfied. har kaa naam jan kaa roop ra(n)g || The Name of the Lord is the beauty and delight of His servants. har naam japath kab parai n bha(n)g || Chanting the Lord's Name, one is never blocked by obstacles. har kaa naam jan kee vaddiaaee || The Name of the Lord is the glorious greatness of His servants. har kai naam jan sobhaa paaee || Through the Name of the Lord, His servants obtain honor. har kaa naam jan ko bhog jog || The Name of the Lord is the enjoyment and Yoga of His servants. har naam japath kashh naahi bioug || Chanting the Lord's Name, there is no separation from Him. jan raathaa har naam kee saevaa || His servants are imbued with the service of the Lord's Name. naanak poojai har har dhaevaa ||6|| O Nanak, worship the Lord, the Lord Divine, Har, Har. ||6|| ***** VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Search For tat · 12 Jul 2005

I think Apprentice and Apprentice Master are from that dodgy site called sikhawareness, which promotes UK nang niddar and his views of bibian inferiority. Bibi should only take amrit from kirpan not khanda, they should look feminine and wear lengas, and earrings, and all that other rubbish these nangs come out with! LOVE LIVE NEW AGE SINGNIANS WHO HAVE THE BANA OF MATA BHAG KAUR & SPIRIT OF MATA SAHIB KAUR!

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Me · 12 Jul 2005

>>There is no difference between females and males.<< I dont think you have heard of biology before. Ok I was wrong to say women shouldnt wear Bana, it is beautiful that they want to represent their faith, and not be mistaken for being Muslim women (I know how that feels, trust me). All I am saying is that Singhanees have unique differences and talents that men may not have. The fact that a mother is better suited to raising children and running the household is not a negative comment and certainly not something to be ashamed of. I mean, how many women can look after 3 children under 5, cook and keep the house in order, is that not a talent? So Harmeet Jee, staying at home is not as easy as it sounds, and women who are housewives and Singhanee's should be respected and admired for the difficult jobs they do. Now, women have certain parts of their bodies which men find attractive, without going into details, women should try to look modest in order to stop unwanted attention, if they wear a chunni with a dastaar (not on the head) around their shoulders, they are able to cover themselves better, why is that seen as a weakness? Doesnt even have to be a chunni, could be a shawl, whatever you want to call it! I just dont think we should go to extremes here, please! Let's respect and love the differences we have. Equality is good, but EQUAL OPPORTUNITY makes more sense keeping in mind the differences we have compared to men. RoopKaur Penji, I understand your sentiments, I didnt put my points across well and Im sorry about this, hope you understand what Im trying to say, I am here to learn, so despite the posts I dont like, I still post and read others opinions. GurFateh

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Jaskaran Kaur · 12 Jul 2005

Waheguru JI Ka Khalsa Waheguru JI Ki Fateh Dear "Me" can you plzzz read Harmeet Singh Veerji's post again. I think u misunderstood it. I m not gonnna tell where you where you misunderstood cause i think you are clever enough to do so. Thanx Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh

Re: Respect for Sikh women

JSGyani "Arshi" · 12 Jul 2005

I totally agree with harmeet Singh, Jaskaran kaur, Roop kaur, Shakti sha soora, and many others who have expressed Charredeekala comments about GURU ROOP/GURU BANNA. Guru Ji and Guru Banna doesnt distinguish between Singh and Kaur. In Guru Ji's eyes we BOTH have equal Status..Both are His PUTTAR.

Re: Respect for Sikh women

Me · 13 Jul 2005

Jaskaran, I think you're clever enough to realise that I dont make posts without reading the previous ones, that's all I have to say.