Re: Status of Bhai Gurdas' Vaars - are they Kachi Bani?
Kulbir Singh · 06 Jul 2005
----------
I would be interested in knowing what people think about the status of Bhai Gurdas' Vaars in the Khalsa Panth and Sikhi.
Are they Bani?
---------
They are not Sachee Baani as Gurbani is but as per the hukam of Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee, Bhai Gurdaas jee’s baani is the “koonji” of Gurbani. What does koonji mean. Literally it means a key but it also means a study guide. Understanding Bhai Gurdaas jee’s baani aids in understanding Gurbani. Many place, Bhai Sahib has done translation of Gurbani and have explained the meanings of Gurbani.
As per tradition, it is allowable to sing Bhai Gurdaas jee’s baani in kirtan.
--------
If they are Bani, as they are not written by Guru Sahib Jee, are they Kachi Bani, because "Satgur Bina Hor Kachi Bani"?
--------
Please see the above paragraphy.
------------
If they are not Bani, why does the Khalsa Panth allow Keertan of Bhai Gurdas' Vaars in Gurudwaras all over the world, including Sri Darbar Sahib?
-------
Kirtan is done as per hukam of Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee who called Bhai Sahib’s baani “koonji” of Gurbani.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Status of Bhai Gurdas' Vaars - are they Kachi Bani?
Iminder Singh · 06 Jul 2005
Vaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Vaheguroo Jee Ki Fateh!
I completely agree with Bhai Kulbir Singh and Gabroo Ji. Its really sad that Bhai Gurdas Ji's compositions are being questioned as Kachee Bani. Although they are not scribed in Guru Granth Sahib Jee, they were accepted by Guru Sahibs and given the status of Gurbaani's "koonjee".
How can something like this even COMPARE to Dharnaas?????? Because initially NaamRas Jee, this kachi banee issue from your point of view to is just to show that Dharnas are acceptable (especially with numerous threads on this forum and sikhsangat forum relating to kachi banee and dharnas) ???
Like Gabroo Jee has said, what next? the gurus?
Forgive me if i've offended.
Vaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Vaheguroo Jee Ki Fateh!!
[%sig%]
Re: Status of Bhai Gurdas' Vaars - are they Kachi Bani?
JSGyani "Arshi" · 06 Jul 2005
dear naamrass ( ?? i wonder what naam and what rass) jio,
since you have already "sort of responded" on my behalf in your own opening mail...i wont give you the "rass" you lack.
The 5 posters above me have given my viewpoint as clearly as i would have done. To "compare" Bhai Gurdass ji who scribed the entire AAD Granth Ji ( can you imagine the hard work/pyaar/immense bhagtee that task would entail..what with the added task of maintaining every laag maatran as per Gurbani Viakaran...especially when this "viakaran" is NOT used by bhai ji in his own Varaan--- it was specially only for GURBANI) to the dhaarna singing "diamond merchants ??? with glass beads in their hands.." is beyond me...not worth commenting on. SORRY.
There is so much rass in Bhai gurdass ji de kabits/varaan, Bhai nand Lal Ji's Poetry.....and since the GURU KHALSA PANTH via its SIKH REHAT MARYADA has ACCEPTED these as fit for KIRTAN in Gurdwaras...who are we to QUESTION this decision ?? Are we trying to be bigger than the PANTH...? I remember another poster who seems to be GURU JI as he knows who is in sachkhand and all that ???..and he asks if "some others are playing at Guru ji ??
Wonders of wonders ??/
Re: Status of Bhai Gurdas' Vaars - are they Kachi Bani?
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 08 Jul 2005
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!!!!
in my humble opinion that bani which is written in the sharan of the satguru according to the hukam of satguru is pakki bani and cannot be kachi
therefore bhai gurdas ji's bani, which was written in the sharan of guru arjan dev ji, and is within the hukam of guru maharaj, is pakki bani
also bhai nand lal ji's bani, which was written in the sharan of guru gobind singh ji, and is within the hukam of guru maharaj, is pakki bani
but giani gian singh's writings, bhai vir singh's writings, and others', which were not written in the sharan of guru sahib, but were inspired by guru sahib, are not pakki bani . they are kachay.
kacha phal still has some nutrients - just not all of them.
some people still eat kachay phal.
have you ever had ambeeaa daa achaar ?
nonetheless, some kacha phal can even make you sick
but pakka phal can never make you sick
pakka phal is the best condition, most perfect russ
in guru granth sahib ji it is written "gur baani gaavoh bhaee"
only the bani that is written inside guru granth sahib ji, or the bani that was written by guru gobind singh sahib, is "gur bani"
"gur bani" is "dhur kee bani" and it is "sachi bani"
bhai nand lal ji's and bhai gurdas ji's bani is not "gurbani" or "dhur kee bani" but it is "pakki bani" because it was not written "without the guru" (satguru bajho) it was written in the sharan of the satguru .
we have hukam to sing "gurbani" and sing "sachi bani"
"bani tha gaavoh guru keri bania sir bani"
sing the bani of the guru which is the head of all banis
"gurbani eis jag meh chaanan"
gurbani is the divine light of this universe.
"ehi baani mahaa purakh kee"
this bani (guru granth sahib ji) is the bani of the Mahaa Purakh (the supreme Soul)
gurbani of guru granth sahib ji and guru gobind singh ji is higher than bhai nand lal ji's bani and bhai gurdas ji's bani.
however, bhai nand lal ji's and bhai gurdas ji's bani is still pakki bani, and it is higher than all other worldly banis.
we cannot call these bani's kachi because a kacha phal cannot tell the secrets of a pakka phal
how could kachi bani be the kunji of sachi bani
bhai gurdas ji's bani is pakki as well because otherwise it could not be the guide to gurbani
it is the key to gurbani, and thus it could not be kachi, even if it is not gurbani.
the difference here is "sant" and "guroo" and "kartaar"
guru and kartaar cannot make mistakes. they are abhul.
but sant can make some mistakes.
however, sant's bachan is like a priceless jewel.
"jae ko bachan kamaavai santhan kaa so gurparsaadee thareeai"
gurparsaad is the highest, gurbani is the highest, gurbani is not replaceable, gurbani is our guru, gurbani will get us across, gurbani will meet us with God, but bhai gurdas ji's bani / bhai nand lal's bachan is the way to get guru sahib's khushee and it is still pakki.
this is my humble opinion
please forgive my mistakes
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!!!!!
Re: Status of Bhai Gurdas' Vaars - are they Kachi Bani?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 09 Jul 2005
The SIKH REHAT MARYADA approved by Sri Akal Takhat sahib very clearly mentions that in SANGAT DIWAN....KIRTAN is to be performed ONLY of GURBANI- (Gurbani from Guru Granth Ji sahib, Guru Gobind Singh Jis compositions)..and it SPECIFICALLY states that Bhai Gurdass Ji and Bhai nand Lall jis compositions can be used.
Thus there is NO PLACE for anything else in the Hazooree of GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB. There is ONLY GURBANI.
The dhaarana singers drag in the DHADEES ( its very OBVIOUS to anyone that a DHADEE JATHA is NOT DOING KIRTAN...they STAND on Podium, Have their own special Instruments and they sing POETRY which is usually SIKH HISTORY. This DHADEE TRADITION has been in Sikhism from the times of the GURUS. Can anyone give evidence that GURU JI SANG DHAARNAS..instead of GURBANI ??? IF you can..then I will change my stand..otherwise LEAVE the DHADEES out of this argument...their Place in Sangat Diwan is well established from GURU JI's PERIOD. EVER NOTICE..that NO ONE ELSE sings "dhaarnas" apart from the "sants"...adn their CHElas. Its quite OK if they stand on stage and sing POETRY/KAWISHREE...as that would NOT be KIRTAN. It is the "insitence" of dhaarna being KIRTAN that is unsatisfactory..KIRTAN is a TITLE exclusively reserved for GURBANI. NO kavisher ever claims he is going to do "kirtan" nor does a Kavi ever say that he is going to do "kirtan"...but the dhaarna singing sants say they are doing KIRTAN and then they sing these two liners which are NOT even GOOD POETRY.
On a Nanaksar related website where they show "sikh videos"...they EXCLUSIVELY SING their own KAVITAS...and it is perfectly OK..as long as they dont start saying this is KIRTAN of GURBANI.
Re: Status of Bhai Gurdas' Vaars - are they Kachi Bani?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Sep 2005
The WORD KACHI BANI results from MISUSE..that is when someone tries to DO REES..copy cat of GURBANI.
I have heard a lot of Sants ( Ranjit singh Dhadriwala is the latest) saying there is no such thing as Kachi banee all is Pakee.
This means GURU AMARDASS JI in Anand sahib is ************* or what ?? because Guru Ji writes Satgur bina Hor KACHEE BANEE....and continues Kehndeh KACHEH, Sundeh KACHEH.Kachee aakh Vikhanee...
Makes one wonder If the sant ji has done nitnem of ANAND SAHIB ?? or is he trying to project a bigger picture than even GURU JI by CONTRADICTING GURU JI DIRECTLY.
a POEM a KAVITA a Dhadee Vaar Kavishree is INSTANTLY RECOGNISABLE as what it is...NO one is going to call a POEM "kachi banee"..no one is going to call a Dhadee vaar as "kachi Banee"
So called Kachee banee are the COPY CAT Banis...written by poets and they try to REES Bani of Gurbani..and they Pass it off as GURBANI..!!!
This is a MISCONCEPTIOn and it is REAL..becasue we have requests from people..Fallana "SHABAD" gao Ji....flanneh sant ne gaiyah see..or it is in a cassette I heard ji.... and when INVESTIGATED it turns out that the "SHABAD" requested is NOT GURBANI at all but a dhaarna geet. Now why did the person concenred get this MISCONCEPTION....becasue the SANT singing that dhaarana was passing it off as gurbani ( calling it simple gurbani for uneducated people !! people LOVE the dhaarna..and never get the chance to learn the "difficult" GURBANI....
Re: Status of Bhai Gurdas' Vaars - are they Kachi Bani?
charanjeev singh · 17 Sep 2005
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
sathiguroo binaa hor kachee hai baanee ||
baanee th kachee sathiguroo baajhahu hor kachee baanee ||
kehadhae kachae sunadhae kachae kacha(n)aee aakh vakhaanee ||
har har nith karehi rasanaa kehiaa kashhoo n jaanee ||
chith jin kaa hir laeiaa maaeiaa bolan peae ravaanee ||
kehai naanak sathiguroo baajhahu hor kachee baanee ||24||
Without the True Guru, other songs are false.
The songs are false without the True Guru; all other songs are false.
The speakers are false, and the listeners are false; those who speak and recite are false.
They may continually chant, 'Har, Har' with their tongues, but they do not know what they are saying.
Their consciousness is lured by Maya; they are just reciting mechanically.
Says Nanak, without the True Guru, other songs are false. ||24||
Guru Sahibs Baani is Aggadh Bodh.
I would like to present a veechar, that might be from a different angle, than that which has been taken by sangat of this pavitar shabad of Guru Sahib.
Guru Sahib says
sathiguroo binaa hor kachee hai baanee ||
"without" the True Guru, other words are false.
the key word here being "without". Was Bhai Gurdaas Jee without a True Guru? or was Bhai Gurdaas Jee a "gur"sikh. The name "bhai" which is very very very highly respected title, given by the Guru, assures us that Bhai Gurdaas Jee was infact with a Guru.
Now, the veechar is that Guru Sahib is not saying that only the Gurus' words are Paki, but Guru Sahib is saying that "without" the True Guru, all other words are false. For example: everybody talks, people sing songs, there are millions and millions of people in the world. The veechar is that "without" the True Guru, they speak of maya, they speak of falsehood, they is no truth in their words. However, when one becomes a Gurmukh, their words are True. They speak the Truth, they see the Truth, their speaking of Waheguruu is Truth, and not just mere empty ritualistic words, as the Guru says
har har nith karehi rasanaa kehiaa kashhoo n jaanee ||
They may continually chant, 'Har, Har' with their tongues, but they do not know what they are saying.
They are chanting the words empty, because they are without a Guru. They are indeed just mimmiccking like a parrot
chith jin kaa hir laeiaa maaeiaa bolan peae ravaanee ||
Their consciousness is lured by Maya; they are just reciting mechanically.
Guru Nanak Dev Jee then confims that only the Niguras words are false
kehai naanak sathiguroo baajhahu hor kachee baanee ||24||
Says Nanak, without the True Guru, other songs are false. ||24||
In conclusion, the veechar is that Guru Sahib is saying that without the True Guru, people talk lies, they speak in duality, they do not know the Truth, and they just mimmick. The ones whom have become the slaves of the True Guru (for example Bhai Gurdaas Jee, Bhai Nand Laal Jee) there words are Truth because they have been enlightened by the Grace of the True Guru.
In final conclusion, Bhai Gurdaas Jee Baani is as pakki as can be.
bhul chuk mauf
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
Please do understand, that Guru Sahibs Baani is Agaadh Bodh, i have only taken this veechar as a seperate shabad in its entirety. However, if the veehar was taken with the previous pauri of Anand Sahib, then the veechar i would present would be that Guru Sahib is indeed saying that all baani except for Dhur Ki Baani is kachi. However the greatness of Guru Sahib is only known to Guru Sahib, and the veechar presented above is this pauri as a seperate shabad altogether.
To answer the title of the thread, the first question is, what is the status of Bhai Gurdaas Jee Baani - the answer is that Bhai Gurdaas Jee Baani is the Key to Guru Granth Sahib Jee and this 'Status' was given by Guru Sahib Himself. And is this Kachi Baani? No, the Guru bestowed His Glance on Bhai Gurdaas Jee, and His Baani. Everything the Guru blesses becomes solid in both worlds, here and hereafter.
bhul chuk mauf
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
[%sig%]
Re: Status of Bhai Gurdas' Vaars - are they Kachi Bani?
Guru-Charan-Preet Kaur · 18 Sep 2005
Waddeh veer charanjeev singh ji is correct.
I have been studying the Vaars of Bhai Gurdass Ji and so far nothing anti-gurmat has been found.
As he said Gurbani is agaadh bodh... we cant be like mosquitoes sitting on the surface of this ocean..we must dive deep in.. ( mosquitoes sit on the water and spread DISEASE)
Superficially some paurrees "may" look like thay are wrong/propogating hInduu myths but when we go deeper than the surface... we find that they are indeed in tune with Gurbani.
Thanks to all
Re: Status of Bhai Gurdas' Vaars - are they Kachi Bani?
santbir singh · 19 Sep 2005
for the proof people are looking for. shaheed bhai mani singh's "gursikhan dee bhagat mala" available in a couple of different editions (one edited by bhai vir singh jee) has a story which deals specifically with this issue.
i don't have a copy of bhagat mala in front of me now, but from what i remember the story goes as such.
history teaches us that bhai gurdas spent time in agra doing parchaar of gurmat. it was there that he wrote his kavits and swaiyais, which are not as well known in the modern panth.
there was a sikh who lived in agra who had turned his home into a dharmsala. sikhs, and others, who needed a place to stay or langar would come to his house. in his house he would hold kirtan darbar in both the morning and the evening. in the morning he would perform kirtan primarily of bhai gurdas jee's bani. in the evening he would perform kirtan from guru granth sahib jee (whether this was before or after the first parkash of guru sahib jee i'm not sure, but nonetheless he performed kirtan of the gurus and bhagats).
the story begins here. a sikh was visiting from amritsar and was staying at this agra sikh's dharamsala. when time for morning divan came he grew disturbed that instead of gurbani the sikh was performing kirtan of bhai gurdas jee. as soon as he could he returned to punjab and went and made a complaint to guru arjun sahib jee. guru arjun sahib jee's response was clear and direct. guru jee stated that the writings of bhai gurdas jee are to be considered as bani and may be performed as kirtan in darbar and that instead of having done anything wrong, the agra sikh should be commended since bhai gurdas jee's writings are in fact a "key" to understanding gurmat.
while the complete authenticity of "gursikhan dee bhagat mala" or "sikhan dee bhagat mala" is still in contention, most panthic historians believe that most if not all of it is in fact the work of bhai mani singh jee. moreover, the controversial parts of the work are obvious brahminical additions which sadly most of our literature has been infected with. where this has happened is usually pretty clear.
if i understand it correctly, the person who began this thread perhaps was trying to make a point about "kachee-banee" in the modern context. to take guru amar das sahib jee's definition of kachee-banee and apply it to bhai gurdas is not something that one should do even to make a point. while we have to be inquisitive, there needs to be some respect for the great gursikhs of our heritage.
of course, the question of bhai gurdas's bani makes it difficult for people to understand what constitutes gurbani.
this is not altogether a completely complicated issue and can be pretty easily understood.
gurbani is everything in the guru granth sahib jee. this includes the bani of non-guru's, such as the bhagats, sheiks and the sikhs who have bani in guru sahib.
gurbani is also guru gobind singh sahib jee's writings (whatever they may be, i'm not about to start that discussion here). but while they are gurbani, they are not the same as the guru granth sahib jee. gurbani does not directly equate into something that needs to be treated formally as a guru. only the guru granth sahib jee can be treated as such.
bhai gurdas's writings are on a third level and are treated with the utmost respect. this is not a new idea and has been in the panth since the time of bhai gurdas himself.
bhai nand lal's bani is a bit more difficult of a question since it is hard to find direct historical proof for when this came to be considered bani and on the same level as bhai gurdas. also, bhai nand lal has writings which are clearly not bani, such as letters and so forth, and what level of respect these should be given is also problematic. however, i think this should only be an issue for those without faith. for myself, i think panthic tradition is strong enough and even if it has not been written down, the fact that bhai nand lal's bani is considered, universally, as bani, should be enough for anyone. sikhs have not taken this lightly. if it was an easy thing to have your writings considered "bani" then there would be bani from all over the place today. but there isn't. obviously, the qualification of bhai nand lal's writings were done by guru gobind singh sahib himself. i don’t think any sikhs could have had the arrogance to make such a classification themselves.
besides these four areas of bani we must be careful what we do allow to be sung as kirtan in darbar. kirtan, katha (and gurmat vichaar and debate), kavita, dhahdee and general political/social vichaar (this is especially true in times of political actions by the panth where guru granth sahib jee is always parkash in meetings, such as the sarbat khalsas) are clearly delineated panthic traditions and we can see evidence for their inclusion in guru sahib's darbar from the time of the "living" guru sahibs. outside of these qualifications it become difficult to say what should or should not be allowed since the guru's themselves only allowed these various forms of discourse to take place in their presence when formal darbars were taking place.
whether these different categories need to be amended or changed according to panthic tradition is completely alright but i personally think that everything that needs to be dealt with in darbar can fit into these categories. anything else is really superfluous. in addition, confusing kavita and dhadhee traditions with modern day "dharna" is disingenuous. kavitas and dhadhee vaaran have their own unique traditions and artistic styles. to suddenly expand their definitions for the sake of an argument is not right. this is especially true of the dhadhee tradition which is one of the corner stones of sikh life and was formalized by guru hargobind sahib himself.
whether or not dharna is kachee bani or not is something that can be argued without disrespecting bhai gurdas jee. Equating bhai gurdas jee’s writings with dharna is also highly disrespectful and even the progenitors of the dharna method of vichaar such as baba attar singh mastuanvale would have been really disappointed by such a comparison.
santbir singh
ps. the proof is always out there for questions like this. its just that we today have forgotten much of our panthic heritage. while it might not always be in neat little packages like our school textbooks it is out there. panthic tradition is a rich treasure that should not be thought of as "not real proof" just because its not written down. this is the argument that the mcleod-ites make and it is sad to see sikhs fall into the same trap. just because something is not written down, or in reverse, just because some brahmin oriented "sikh" writes some manmat down in the 1700's doesn't mean that our panthic tradition is wrong. the panth is the guru and while we forget a lot, i think a lot of what we are missing today can still be found in our oral tradition.