Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Guru Nanak Dev Jees Birth

Guru Nanak Dev Jees Birth

Singh · 30 Jun 2005

Sikhi does not agree with janam patrees right...like when a baby is born the pandits predict the course of their life. now when Guru Nanak Dev Ji was born, it is said that that Pandit that took his janam patree said that 'this is God himself' or something along those lines. So does that mean that the pandit actually did know what was going to happen and therefore these janam patrees are right...this particular pandit must have had a great following after he said this then, because it was true - Guru Nanak Dev Ji was Vaheguru himself. Now my 3 theories are that, the Pandit must have known about Guru Nanak being God because it was so obvious when he was born - i.e no crying and bright light. OR my other theory is that the pandit had riddhia siddhia and used his riddhia siddhia to know this, but a gursikh is beyond these. My last theory is that Guru Nanak Dev Ji himself made the Pandit say this, through his powers...i.e. Through his powers (guru jis), he made the Pandit speak them words. please can someone reply to this aswell. thanks

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Jees Birth

KSingh · 30 Jun 2005

1) Janam Patris CAN be true, for the instance when they are read, but Vaaheguroo's Hukam can change in a nanosecond and the janam patri can become wrong. 2) Guru ji would never make anybody call Guru ji as God, even though Guru Ji was God's Suroop 3) Ridhia Sidhia cannot compete with the Gyaan that one gets (BrahamGyaan) from Naam Simran. The Pandit may or may not know. 4) Any faith in Janam Patri or other superstitions is disallowed in Gurmat 5) Guru ji didn't need a Janam Patri to say he is God's Suroop. Guru ji just IS God's Suroop no matter who believes it or who doesn't. 5) I have never heard this Sakhi and who knows if it is even true 6) Even if it is true, points 1 - 5 above nullify the sakhi's superstitious message.

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Jees Birth

hi · 30 Jun 2005

anyone?

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Jees Birth

eman ruoy · 30 Jun 2005

Or perhaps Astrology is an actual Study that is Valid. Not everyone can read the Janam patris, but very few can and even so very few exist today who are versed in this Study.

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Jees Birth

sore · 30 Jun 2005

Nothing is constant except VAAHEGUROO and VAAHEGUROO'S hukam is above everything. Hukam can nullify ANYTHING and EVERYTHING. Hukam can make a JOKE out of any weather forecast, janam patri, hand-reader, fortune-teller, magic 8-ball, tarot cards, pandit maharaj, pir syed sahib, ajmeri baba, baneri baba, kali mata, jadu tuna, mantar jantar, ridhi sidhi, etc. etc. All things are FALSE without Naam and Hukam. If Guru ji wants, Guru ji can cause ANYTHING to happen or stop ANYTHING from happening.

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Jees Birth

Mehtab Singh · 30 Jun 2005

perhaps he was called because Guruji's parents were khatri hindus, and hindus to this day believe in astrology ([i]u have no idea how messed up it is...i personally hate it with a passion[/i])

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Jees Birth

JSGyani "Arshi" · 30 Jun 2005

imho the "janam sakhis" especially the Bhai bala one is written by the ENEMIES of Sikhe and Gurmat...those who DIDNT get Gurgadhi of Guru nanak Ji.... they taught was theirs BY RIGHT of BIRTH. Too much of what is contained in this janamsakhi is patently false and degrading towards Gurmat. imho the writer of this "sakhi" wanted to PROVE that the BRAHMIN/PANDIT..is ABOVE ALL.....even "GOD" in the Form of Guru nanak Ji Sahib. IF you have any doubts about this notion and think its just my imagination.... see HOW RAAM CHANDER JI, BHAGWAAN KRISHAN JI....have to SERVE the Brahmin/Pandit/Rishi etc as their Personal SERVANTS, washing their soiled clothes, fetching water, cleaning and sweeping their compounds, and OBEYING every command of the Brahmin/Pandit..even to the extent of becoming BEGGARS etc. A cursory viewing of the many serials on TV..about Raam Krishan Vishnu etc will reveal this. Thus the BRAHMIN?PANDIT/RISHI is the ONE with REAL POWER even over BHAGWAANS like Raam and Krishan. Raam and Krishan Ji had to learn from these Pandits and Brahmins rishis... BUT GURU NANAK JI SAHIB UPSET this apple-cart rolling along happily for so long.....and TAUGHT the PANDIT INSTEAD....read the Patti Bani of Guru nanak ji. Then Mother of all SHOCKS..the Brahmin got another slap in the face when GURU Nnak Ji REFUSED to wear the Janeau in front of everybody and again TAUGHT the Brahmin a valuable and HUMILIATING LESSON... Then of Course Guur Ji ignored the Brahmin at His WEDDING....imho the Crumbling Wall incident at batalla was an ASSASINATION attempt on Guru Ji's life to end this Anti-Brahmin Rebellion, by nipping it in the bud. From the very moment this "pandit" saw that Waheguru Himself had come down on Earth to "pull out his dirty roots"...has the Unending War between SIKHE/GURMATT and the House of nanak Vs the Brahmin/Bippar/Pandit Combine been going on with this Brahmin Camp trying its very best to counter everything that Gurmatt says.. Guru Ji didnt warn us for nothing..Jab eh Gahey BIPPARAN KEE REET..amin na karoon in kee parteet. This spurious "janam sakhi" shifted Guru nanak Jis Birth from VASAKH to November Katak..among other things... GURMATT is all about Hukam of waheguru and HUKAM only..nothing else.

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Jees Birth

tera baap · 30 Jun 2005

i think mehtab singh has the right idea, as guru jee was born into a hindu family that was high caste and well off it is obvious taht they wud call the pundit which was a tradition comin back froma long time. but that doesnt mean the astrology thingy is right.

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Jees Birth

098 · 03 Jul 2005

I don't think the sakhi is true...as arshi ji said.

Re: Guru Nanak Dev Jees Birth

JSGyani "Arshi" · 04 Jul 2005

side note: I raed somewhere that when Sobha Singh the fmaous artist who has CREATED all those "wonderful" pictures of the Sikh gurus..wanted to PAINT GURU NANAK JI's picture with the OPEN PALM....he consulted a well known Hindu palmist..as to WHAT LINES to draw on guru Ji's palm that would show Guru ji had no "bad lines"...any bad luck signs etc... WAH JI WAH ?? The mere notion that AAP NIRANKAAR coming to Earth would have bad signs/bad lines on His Palm..makes me "***" So all of you.... That very famous painting of Guru Ji with His OPEN PALM...the lines on it are as instructed by a palmist ???? Still want to go out and BURN a few Dollars on such SPURIOUS Paintings ??? think twice and use the money for something worthy. ( feed a poor beggar more like it)