Taksali Sri Sahibs
.......................... · 29 Jun 2005
Honest question: what's so good about Taksali sri sahibs? i compared my regular one with my friend's taksali one and they look exactly the same. (the kirpan, not the sheath.)
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
.......................... · 29 Jun 2005
Honest question: what's so good about Taksali sri sahibs? i compared my regular one with my friend's taksali one and they look exactly the same. (the kirpan, not the sheath.)Khalsa47 · 29 Jun 2005
There is nothing good about them. I got a pure sabloh kirpan made and the miyaan is also sarbloh. Now that is what you call a nice kirpan. The Taksali kirpans just have a name, and everyone wants to own their own taksali kirpan because of the name. Its the same thing as getting cell phone. A new cell phone comes out (say the digital camera ones) and then everyone wants to own a digital camera phone because it is the new trend.charanjeev singh · 29 Jun 2005
the Sri Sahib is a gift of the Guru. if they look the same it is because they are. bhul chuk maufsore · 29 Jun 2005
Although I wouldn't go so far and be so baysharam as to say there is nothing good about them as Khalsa47 has said, I would have to agree that a pure sarbloh kirpan and sarbloh miaan that is in good working condition and has a sharp blade and a good handle with proper curvature to allow for the best usage in any potential battle will be a beautiful Sri Sahib whether it is Taksali or Not. The Sri Sahib as Charanjeev Singh jee has said is a gift of the Guru, where it physically came from or who physically made it is secondary.:) · 30 Jun 2005
"There is nothing good about them" the above is a very offensive remark.. Khalsa47 i dnt care if u hate Taksal... this is a low remark, u degrade a sri sahib.. the nishani of the Khalsa, wot makes YOU so high and mighty So according to you.. i should throw my Sri Sahib in the dustbin?????? .....for it has no value Ppl, we all have differences of opinon, but lets atleast have respect for our Guru Ji's and the gifts they have given usGurus Son · 30 Jun 2005
Wjkk WJkf wat u on bout, atleast all of them keep there sarbloh kirpans im akj singh but I see some singhs that have stainless kirpans at rensbhais, atleast all of them have a sarbloh kirpan, wats the point of havin this post, thik man wear wat u want keep remarks lyk this to ur self all u lot do is waist time. Wat u on bout the name, wat name. Its just a kirpan for god sake..... man! Talk bout sumit useful! Wjkk WJKftaksal · 30 Jun 2005
who the hell do u think u r do u now any thig about taksal dont say anything if u do not now anythingtaksali · 30 Jun 2005
Taksali kirpans rule!!...the bend in them is to even out the weight...and they are mostly hand made.... · 30 Jun 2005
I have a Sri Sahib that has something stamped on it I can make out as saying "Taksal". It is a regular 3 foot Sri Sahib from Anandpur Sahib (Tulwar) and it is not Sarbloh. It seems like a regular Sri Sahib, and it is a Puratan style. The blade is the correct shape. Taksali Kirpans, as in the one piece Kirpans worn as the Kakkar, I wear because I have no other currently. A Taksali Kirpan is not a Puratan style. Some one explained to me, that it is the same shape as Puratan Dumala shasters are, but much larger. It is the incorrect shape for slashing or stabbing so I can't understand the blade shape or weighting. Please show a martial artist or knife expert the modern Taksali Kirpan and he will be very puzzled. I have tried to research what a Puratan Kirpan is and to be honest I am not sure. I may get a custom made, 1 to 2 foot Sarbloh Kirpan with the handle and blade similar to that of a Tulwar, to keep as my Kakkar. Why don't we stop this being a Taksali bashing thread, but why not constructively discuss, what Puratan Kirpans looked like? To be honest we cannot really say any of the modern Kirpans we wear are proper, Puratan style Kirpans. What style of Kirpan, did Baba Gurbachan Singh/Bhai Randhir Singh etc wear?Amarjeet Singh · 30 Jun 2005
taksali kirpans r gr8 apart from the fact the case is too curved like almost 90 degrees which isnt so gr8.namras24/7 · 30 Jun 2005
i think '':)'' is taking ''khalsa47'''s post and twistin it to suit him or her. he meant..theres nothing good about them compared to other sri sahibs, which isn't OFFENSIVE, is it?? i think this is a pointless discussion. why don't you ask someone, you don't need a whole sangat to answer that question. i also can see that this is going to lead to a jatha discussion!duhh · 30 Jun 2005
yo taksali kirpans arent puratan deal with it!! simple :) naa u want a kirpan get a nihang singh one, thats a kirpan!!! puratan ones are damaskus not surbloh, every similar in apperance. peace ...........JSGyani "Arshi" · 30 Jun 2005
Author: :) Date: 06-30-05 13:02 Amarjeet Singh that truly is a LOW remark.... discussing issues is fine but cussing is childs play... Only fools argue... >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> MY COMENTS: It is said.. Fools ......NEVER DIFFER...and Great Minds ......THINK ALIKE. So what are you ?? a Fool or a great Mind... Actually if we read the above carefully BOTH are the SAME. Remain Calm and FLOAT on this Great Ocean, instead of letting these small storms get your mouth all full of salty water !!! Amarjeet wasnt "cussing"...he was just suggesting a "remedy to cool down"..after all this "bani" does have that "jeewan muktee" and calming effect..dont you agree.. Love and Peace to all..Amarjeet Singh · 01 Jul 2005
i wasnt arguing i was just stating a comment just as you have :) :)kaur 25 · 02 Jul 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh I totally agree with SORE, as long as its sharp useable, the rightsize and sarabloh, any siri sahib is a gift! ps i knw its a bit of a silly question but how do you get rust of a sarabloh siri sahib, mine seems to be rusting a bit and I knw how important it is to look after your gift and keep it in perfect condition, when i have ishnaan sometimes water gets in it thats wats made it a bit rusty, I have tried a couple of things the rust seems to not all shift. pul chuk maaf [%sig%]. · 03 Jul 2005
" would have to agree that a pure sarbloh kirpan and sarbloh miaan that is in good working condition and has a sharp blade and a good handle with proper curvature to allow for the best usage in any potential battle will be a beautiful Sri Sahib whether it is Taksali or Not" What's proper curvature? someone post a pic?cybersingh · 04 Jul 2005
i use sand paper to clean my shastars from rustUrm. · 04 Jul 2005
What do you mean proper curvature? Look at the blade of the common modern Taksali Kirpan. Are you going to slash someone with it? Do you know how sharp a blade has to be to cause any major damage from a slash? A Taksali Kirpan would cause minor lacerations/paper cuts only. Or will you try stabbing? A stabbing blade is meant to have a straight blade with a very sharp point. How are you going to stab someone with that ridiculous curve at the end? Those who think these modern are actaully useable, please advise me for techniques on how I am to use it. Can't any of you actually think rationally for a minute and realise all modern kirpans are actaully completely useless?Singh · 04 Jul 2005
Modern Kirpans aren't completely useless. You can sharpen it yourself and they are effective enough for slashing. You won't be able to cut off someone's arm but you can give them a deep enough cut. But, you are correct. The curve at the end is silly. What we want are straight slim double sided blades...that slip in between the ribs like a hot knife through butter. But these are dangerous and Singhs would actually have to learn how to use shasters otherwise they'd just hurt themselves. lol. The sad thing is that most amritdharis carry around these nice shiny sarbloh kirpans but very few actually know what to do with one if they ever got in a fight. Very very sad. Learn to use shasters... understand shasters and then you'll be a real shasterdhari. For most of you wearing thick sarblohi karas will be more effective as a weapon for both offense and defence. Leave the kirpan training for Singhs who actually think of guru sahib's shasters as a gift and as such, actually practice with them. Its like the time my dad bought me this amazing tennis racket and after showing it around to my friends... it hung looking real nice on my wall. total disrespect of the gift.