Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Purpose of Bibek

Purpose of Bibek

Questionaire Extraordinaire · 11 Sep 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! I read the article on Bibek, it's probably just my lack of understanding, but what's the PURPOSE of Bibek? ¿

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Balpreet Singh · 12 Sep 2003

I think the purpose of bibek is to maintain a simple lifestyle and Guru Sahib has said that eating from non-spiritual people and non-Gursikhs has a negative effect on our own spiritual state. Please see the article for more details. So in essence, bibek is kept to further our own spiritual state and facilitate a spiritual lifestyle.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

... · 12 Sep 2003

How do you know that someone is non-spiritual or not? There are many non-spiritual so-called Gursikhs. We should not judge people like that. I think Bibek is just for personal benefit. A Bibekie can be full of proud, by thinking that he/she is precious. Hence, let world run as it is in Akal-purakh hukam. Instead of we forcing people to keep Bibek, we should make ourselves strong so that by looking at us people love sikhi and Bibek. I don't think our GURU sahib jee forced people, instead with their greater love people just followed them.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Kulbir Singh · 12 Sep 2003

Who is forcing who here? It would be beneficial if you elaborate more. All rehit including 5Ks, not doing kurahits, Daswandh and Bibek are voluntary and no one forces anyone in Panth.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Some Singhni · 12 Sep 2003

Kulbir Singhs right. Anyone who disrespects Bibek also disrespects countless Gursikhs who practiced and preached this rehit, The spiritual reasons behind Bibek in our diets are countless, Guru Sahib makes it abundantly clear in the following line of Gurbani, Sunthin Kaa Dhaanaa Rookhaa Soh Surbh Nidhaan - Greh Saakhith Shuthee Prakaar Thai Bikhoo Smaan Guru Sahib says that the food of the Gursikh is an invaluable treasure, while the tasty foods of the faithless people are like poison. There is also another line from Baanee which states how while eating from Faithless people, Bhugthee can not fully blossom within us. What more proof do we need in order for us to realize that this rehit has been alive since the time's of our Gurus?? There is one other reason behind bibek as well, when we take Amrit, it is prepared in Sarbloh by GURSIKHS. How could anyone criticize Bibeki Gursikhs for maintaining the same standards for their everyday food as was the standard in their Amrit Sinchaar???? Just in the same way Naam Kamaee transfers from the Punj Pyareh into the Amrit Nectar, the same happens even during normal cooking by Gursikhs. May Guru Sahib do kirpa on myself and countless others who do not have the will power or strength to keep this rehit yet.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Gabroo Khalistan Dah · 12 Sep 2003

i know this is gonna sound wierd but when i hear bibek it hink sarbloh pandaye etc. and yes i think its very important to eat out of sarbloh because 2day i saw sommin wierd we have a dog, and most her pandaye are of some sort of metal, and we juss got her a new bowl which is plastic, 2days without washing and it has fungii in it, and this never happened in the metal dishes which stayed clean for weeks its wierd is'nt it?> i'm not saying we're dogs juss a point

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Questionaire Extraordinaire · 13 Sep 2003

What do you lose of you don't keep bibek?

Re: Purpose of Bibek

JK · 13 Sep 2003

Veer or Bhain Ji "...", What do you mean "instead of forcing people to keep Bibek..."? No one has the right to force anyone to do anything, and no where will you find a Singh or a Singhnee who does so. Please share with the sangat where you have seen people being "forced" to do anything against their own will. You say that "...we should make ourselves strong so that by looking at us people love sikhi and Bibek". I personally believe that by keeping Bibek, we DO become stronger and with keeping Bibek our love for Sikhi will increase. I myself only became more interested in Sikhi when I met pure Rehitvaan sangat who kept Bibek. They are the ones who made me become a stronger person and increased my love for Sikhi. By seeing them every week in bana and keeping bibek, I too wanted to do the same thing. Only because of the amount of pyaar they had for Guru Sahib's rehit's, was I able to become the person I am today- there was *no* "forcing" of any kind involved AT ALL. You should seriously try coming to Tapoban Sahib yourself and meet the sangat there. I'm pretty sure that the Tapoban sangat will change your life one way or another for the better without "forcing" you to do anything, but instead by putting a greater love inside of you for Guru Sahib's rehits which we should all be keeping.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 14 Sep 2003

Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh Bibek should be kept by every gursikh. I loved to eat all sorts of junk food all the time, I would eat 2-3 chocolate bars a day. i never thought that i could give up all that yummy food. but one day i got up and decided that i'm going to keep bibek and from that day on I have kept bibek. i love keeping bibek, it makes a person feel good inside. the food that we eat affects us, eating from none amritdhari people will affect our avasta, keeping bibek helps our avasta. i personally think that i've become a better person after keeping bibek. I recommend that people start keeping bibek or atleast try it. u will feel like a better person forsure. at the beginning u will have cravings for all that junk food but think of it as a test from guru ji, he is testing u to see how strong u are and if u can keep bibek. and if u can keep bibek u have passed the test, but if u can't handle it and start to eat all the junk again u have failed guru's test. or think about it this way....if you ment guru ji would you want him to eat from ur hands? and if so then do u think that he would eat from a persons hand that eats from people that eat meat, drink, do drug, etc? or would he eat from a bibek singh that only eats from amritdhari people?? the answer is simple. it doessn't take a genious to figure it out. everyone should try to keep bibek to there bestest ability. from my own personal experience i can tell u that keeping bibek is wicked and makes u feel like a better person too. i've been bibek for over a year and can tell u that its not hard at all keeping bibek. but once again no one should be forced to keep bibek by anyone, everyone should just keep it and know for themselves that bibek is a rehit that we should all follow. Bhul Chuk Maaf Vaheguru ji ka khals Vaheguru ji ki fateh Dalrajkaur Khalsa

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Indy · 14 Sep 2003

Singhni writes 'Guru Sahib says that the food of the Gursikh is an invaluable treasure, while the tasty foods of the faithless people are like poison.' Who are these faithless? Atheists, people who do not follow Sikhi? Do people from other 'faiths' fit into this category? When Sikhi was at a young age, the langar was open to all, regardless of faith - just as it is now. Everyone mucked in to bring firewood, water, serve langar and wash up after. This sangat did not consist only of Amritdhari Sikhs. If a homeless person is inpired by the concept of langar that fed him and he feels the urge to return or pay the favour back by doing seva, who are we to stop him? Do we have any right? Is there any proof that only amritdharis can serve and cook food in a Gurdwara? Faithless in this shabad refers to people who are trapped in maya. How does this fit in with your bibek theory? Guru Ji, is explaining that the dry simple bread of Gursikhs is equal to all treasures and continues to make analogies of the basic requirements of a Bhagat compared to that of a faithless cynic. Everyone knows the line 'Jab Eh Gahey Bipran Ki Reet...' Lets not practise Brahmanism and draw a purity line around ourselves!! A Brahmin will not eat food cooked by a shudra or a dalit, a brahmin may have a problem eating food cooked by a Muslim, a Muslim may have a problem eating food cooked by an infidel, etc. People are very prejudiced. A [true] amritdhari (i.e. Khalsa) is a person who is near perfect human and who serves mankind selflessly. He/she does not distinguish and discriminate between people. Khalsa is beyond the concept of human pollution and impurities. It is also strange to note how a ref from Macauliffe can be used as Gospel from the article on this site, when he also writes that Guru Nanak Sahib, consumed meat at Kurukshetra. In another chapter he writes Guru Angad Sahib tested a Vaishanavites's loyalty by offering him a meat dish from the langar?

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Balpreet Singh · 15 Sep 2003

Indy, Have you carefully read the Bibek article? In it you'll find so much evidence from puraatan sources that says only a Sikh shoudl prepare langar. Many MANY quotes are provided in the article. The fact that langar is prepared only by amritdharis in Taksal, Nihang Jathas and even Sree Darbaar Saahib is proof enough. As for Macauliffe, I ask you, would he know more about the Sikhs of Nanded who were his contemporaries or would he know about Guru Angad Dev jee who preceded him by hundreds of years? His information about the Sikhs in Nanded and their practices is first hand, his info on Guru Angad is certainly not.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Bulanhar !! · 15 Sep 2003

Waheguru jee ka Khalsa, Waheguru jee ke Fateh!! Bibek is always used in Sprituial terms by Guru jee and this Bibek can be only achieved by doing Naam-Simran and Gurubani Abyas. Restricting yourself from only eating from AmritDhari hands (I am not suggesting to go and eat from hands of a person who smokes OR drinks) can benefit your Bibek, but no one can claim that it is the only source or channel. I personally prefer keeping Bibek i.e, Naam Jaap, Gurbani Abyaas, Sangat, Seeva as key elements instead of promoting-eating in Sarabloh pots an Bibek issue. My mother is not an AmritDhari and i love eating from her hands, she loves me and i respect her love. Guru jee has always told us about Bibek Budh and i don't think it can only be achieved by eating in Sarabloh pots. A clean pot of any kind is equally good, but Sarabloh pot can give you more quantity of iron - good for your body. If we restrict ourselves ONLY to AmritDhari Singhs/Singhnis, then we are questioning basics of Sikhism - which states that every Sikh is a CHOKIDAR of Sikhism and we are preachers. Guru Nanak Dev jee went everywhere to make people realize by their utmost love. If a Sikh does not sit with an alcoholic, then what are chances of this alcoholic person to leave this habit and if we discard him, he will definitely go back to drink more. A Sikh should be so confident and have so much faith and Barosa on Guru jee that even if he goes and sits with an alcoholic, it does not affects him, but alcoholic gets affected by the Sikhi Jeevan. What kind of Sikhs we are if we say that by sitting with alcoholic we might get his habits? Why not make yourself strong enough by following Sikhi and keep doing constant ardas to Guru jee to give you power, so that you are able to be like a rose, and keep spreading fragrance, even if you are surrounded by thorns. I remember an incident in India during a Samagam that an alcoholic person (MONA) dropped outside langar hall and was asking for food while he was on ground. Many Singhs came and decided to beat him up (which most of us would have agreed upon), but an OLD Baba (Singh) came and told these Singhs to excuse him. This OLD Baba bought food from langar Hall and fed this alcoholic person with his own hands and then took him for rest. Next morning when he got up and was in his senses, Baba and others told him the story and he was so much impressed by way of Sikh living that he pledged to have Amrit. We need that kind of selfless service. Tell me what were chance of this person to come back to Gurudwara if Singhs would have beaten him up!!! There were/are tons and tons of Gurusikhs all around world who do not keep Sarabloh Bibek and are in a great avasta, because they focussed on internal rehyat of Naam-Jap......... Hope I have not hurt any one and have made my point.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Balpreet Singh · 15 Sep 2003

I can agree that bibek extends much much beyond eating from sarbloh utensils, but it would be equally wrong to say that this is not an important part of bibek. Extending our love for non-Sikhs is important, but that doesn't mean that we should eat the food they eat or prepare. The Singh who helped the drunk and gave him langar did a great seva, but no where does it say he then ate the drunk's food. The question is simple. If 5 Khalsa can prepare amrit with naam and baaNee and create Khalsa, then why can't a manumkh have a damaging effect on spirituality as well? Could the food prepared by a drunk, smoker or immoral/unchaste person give "chardee kalaa"? If any clean pot is "equally good" then why do we only prepare amrit in Sarbloh? Why not in plastic buckets? Of course Sarbloh has something special to it that Guru Sahib went so far as to mention in BaaNi. So in conclusion, do parchaar and help people not on the Sikhi path. That's important, but that does not mean to eat with them or eat what they eat or do what they do. A person who is drowning in quick sand is saved by someone standing outside and helping, not by one who jumps in with him.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Bulanhar !! · 15 Sep 2003

Balpreet Singh Veerjee, you wrote: >>If 5 Khalsa can prepare amrit with naam and baaNee and create Khalsa, >>then why can't a manumkh have a damaging effect on spirituality as >>well? Do you really think these two examples are equivalent? Khalsa, has mehar and kirpa of GURU and i don't believe that so-called manumkh can have damaging effect on Khalsa. If with Guru jee dee Mehar you have constant displine of Naam-Abyas and Gurbani, then i don't think a manmukh can withstand Khalsa. I totally believe that, if so-called manmukh has damaging effect, then it is our own fault, we are not PAKKAE yet. I totally agree that Sarabloh is a pure DATH, and respect people who keep it, but if you start claiming that without Sarbloh, Bibek is not complete, is questionable. I still believe that Bibek is something higher than any kind of pots and we should open our minds and preach real Bibek.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Janpreet · 15 Sep 2003

Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh Singh ji, is eating out of Sarbloh "ManMatt" or is it "GurMatt"? What is really the harm in cooking and eating in utencils other than sarbloh according to Guru Sahib? For example, "mashkaan" were used to carry water around and clay has been used in sikh culture for centuries to keep the water cool.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Balpreet Singh · 15 Sep 2003

Bhulanhar, You say that Punj Pyaaray have mehar of Guru Sahib and a Khalsa will not be affected by manmukhs and that "i don't believe that so-called manumkh can have damaging effect on Khalsa". You are absolutely right. Guru Sahib has made it so that manmukhs can't have any effect on Gursikhs: that is through bibek, and like I said earlier, a big part of that is dietary bibek which has been in the Panth for centuries. If a Khalsa does not follow dietary bibek then they cannot expect to not be effected by Manmukhs. Bibek is a hukam of Guru Sahib. Please look over the bibek article in the Gurmat section and it proves without a doubt that eating from Amritdharis alone is a hukam for all Gursikhs and we should all attempt to follow it. As for clay pots for water: yes, Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee kept his water in jail in clay pots and there's nothing wrong with that. But he didn't cook in the clay pots, just stored water. I request all to read the Bibek article and if they have evidence to refute it, please do so.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Mkhalsa · 15 Sep 2003

Guru sahib says that god himself is in sarbloh. This is how special sarbloh is to guru sahib himself. Beyond that, sarbloh has always been used for langar and can still be seen in use in gurudwaras in khalistan and india. Along with that I know some gursikhs actually have a peice of Guru Hargobind Sahib's SARBLOH karahee which was used to prepare langar in his kitchen!

Re: Purpose of Bibek

jagjit singh · 15 Sep 2003

waheguru ji ke khalsa,waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I do not keep this discipline. Hopefully one day I will. But looking at the Panthic maryada, it says Gursikhan di roti beti ke sanjh Gursikhan naal. This means that every gursikh should should only eat from Gursikhs, and every gursikh should only marry another gursikh. This is said by every Panj pyare from every jathebandie in the whole Panth. In every Amrit sanchaar this is mentioned. So if we look at this carefully, does this not mean we should all be bibeki as per hukam from the Panj. Maybe I am wrong, but I think every Amritdharee in the Panth has had this hukam placed upon them. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Purpose of Bibek

singh2 · 16 Sep 2003

i have just re-read the bibek article now. it explains the idea/reason behind bibek. but it does not explain the reason(s) for sarbloh - save to say it is a tradition going back a long time. the rehitnama mentioned is not much better in this respect - tasty food in sarbloh may be a description but is not a reason. so the questions remain: why sarbloh? why was it started? one possible (anecdotal) explanation of its origins came to my mind a while back. last year at university i got to know a couple of ex-pat brahmins from gujrat. we talked abut religions in india and they mentioned the various bibek rehits of brahmins they knew of - eg. food cooked only by themselves/ family/other brahmins etc. they also mentioned certain restrictions some brahmins follow with regard to cooking utensils - they were not exactly sure but said it was something like not eating out of dishes made of everyday/common materials - mentioned something about expensive/silver materials being required or something like that. if this latter point is correct, then the question of sarbloh is perhaps another aspect of breaking brahmin taboos re spiritual significance of what our dishes are made of - ie. maybe guru sahib chose sarbloh for amrit sanchaar as a way of further opposing brahmin practices. this idea seems logical to me but can only go to explain how non-sarbloh practice amongst brahmins was rejected. it cannot explain how only-sarbloh practice can be justified as the premise is that there is no significance to the material of the utensil. so even with this possible explanation of the origins of sarbloh the 'why' question of exclusive sarbloh practice remains. these are just some rambling ideas that i have thought of as a result of my conversations with these two nri's. i may be wrong in my assumptions and/or the whole premise may be wrong if these people are wrong in their claims. perhaps balpreet singh can comment on this.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Balpreet Singh · 16 Sep 2003

Sarbloh, like I mentioned earlier, is a very special material to Guru Gobind Singh jee and very beloved to him. Something beloved to Guru Sahib is by default beloved to a Sikh. Of all the things Guru Sahib could have prepared priceless amrit in, he chose Sarbloh. Only he knows the exact reason for this. I personally feel that sarbloh is a rehit because it is mentioned in older rehits, has been practiced by all puraatan Jatehbandees and Gursikhs and due to the personal advice/experiences of other Gursikhs. Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee tells that Sarbloh Bibek is extremely powerful and he was so dedicated to it, that he chose to stay hungry and thirsty for 40 days rather than violate it. He in fact spent 15 years in prison under extreme circumstances and still refused to leave this rehit. If Bhai Sahib had received jot parkaash before entering prison and was of a very high avasthaa, then the fact that he would not leave Sarbloh Bibek no matter what the price gives us all an important lesson: Sarbloh is essential. Even though Bhai Sahib was at such a high spiritual stage, he still would not give up this rehit and considered it "hukam" and inviolable. Akali Kaur Singh jee, Baba Gurbachan Singh jee Bhindranvalay, Baba Mitt Singh jee Nihung, Sant Juaalaa Singh jee Harkhovaal, and many others were sarblohi Singhs. Gursikhs who have kept sarbloh all will say that it has made a difference in their life. So in light of all these examples and personal experiences by other Sikhs, I can only conclude that Sarbloh is important and a rehit. The reasons for keeping this rehit can only be known by those who keep it and feel the difference.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Questionaire Extraordinaire · 16 Sep 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! "Bhojanaad Moundit naal chhakey, Tankhaiyaa" or One who eats food with a Mona/non-Sikh, is guilty of a breach of conduct (Piara Singh Padam’s Rehitnamay pg. 72) Eat WITH a Mona? So idealy, a Bibekee Singh/Kaur shouldn't sit near or be in the presence of a Non-Amritdharee/Mona while eating? ----- Earlier in the Article it states: Guru-Ka-Langar, whether prepared in the Gurdwara or in the household of a Sikh can be called Guru-Ka-Langar only if it is prepared by Guru-Ke-Sikhs. I assuming that this statement establishes a truth. When food is prepared by a GurSikh, be it in thier home or Gurdwara Sahib, it is recognized at Langar. That leads to the next question... The Rehitnama Hazooree by Chaupa Singh says: "Guru kaa Sikh...apaNy langar rasoee vich Sikh rakhey. Hukaie, Topeeaa, BhaadNee, chor, yaar, jooaybaaz, kurehiteeyaa na rakhai" meaining "A Guru ka Sikh...should keep only a Sikh in his langar and kitchen. Smokers, hat-wearers, shaven people, theieves, gamblers, kurehitees should not be kept" (Padam, 85). According to this, and the statement above, on can conclude that no Non-Amritdharee/Mona is allowed to eat in Langar in the presence of GurSikhs, whether at Gurdwara Sahib or at home. Or would it be more correct to say that GurSikh's should avoid eating in the presence of Non-Amritdharee's/Monay whenever possible? Whether at Gurdwara Sahib or Home? Please correct me if I'm wrong, I'm only stating what I understood of it. ----- Also, through what medium does the 'badness'/impurity in Non-Amritdharee's/Monay get transferred through? Touch, smell, taste, sight, breath, air, presence? I don't mean to be offensive or disrespectful, just curious. ¿

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Balpreet Singh · 16 Sep 2003

"Guru kaa Sikh...apaNy langar rasoee vich Sikh rakhey. Hukaie, Topeeaa, BhaadNee, chor, yaar, jooaybaaz, kurehiteeyaa na rakhai" meaining "A Guru ka Sikh...should keep only a Sikh in his langar and kitchen. Smokers, hat-wearers, shaven people, theieves, gamblers, kurehitees should not be kept" (Padam, 85). This quote has thrown more than a few people. Let me clarify. the langar/rasoee is the preparation area for food ie. the kitchen. The area where food is eaten communally in the Gurdvara is called the "Pangat". So this rehitnama is saying that only a Sikh should be kept in the kitchen to cook. It does not mean monas/non-Sikhs cannot eat in the "langar" ie. the Pangat. It has always been a tradition that Pangat is open to anybody, although the preparation of the food has not been. The first quote about eating "with" a Mona, in my understanding, means sharing a meal with or eating food preapared by a mona. Gursikhs can share food together as is seen after amrit sinchaar when all new Khalsa brothers and sisters eat degh from a single bata. Bhai Sahib also writes about how Gursikhs fed eachother and shared food. This rehitnama is saying "sharing" food in the manner is only allowed for Gursikhs, not with a Mona/non-Sikh. The question is not of "impurity" as some may wish to frame it, it's a question of Gursikhs wanting to eat food prepared by those reciting naam and baaNee. In different articles on puraatan langars, like the one about Narangvaal's Langar, the only thing allowed in the Langar was naam. Just naam was recited. Naam is received from Satguru jee in Amrit Sinchaar and imparted by the Punj pyaaray. So, to eat food that is beneficial to spirituality, ie. prepared while reciting naam (and the vibration of naam has a powerful effect that does affect food), one must eat food prepared by Gursikhs.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Bulanhar !! · 16 Sep 2003

Veer Balpreet Singh, I have total confidence that if Naam-Jap and Gurubani Abyaas can clean your bad karams, then certainly it can over-come anything else. Hence, i focus on keeping internal Bibek than getting involved into pot issues. A Guru-ka-Sikh with a great "PEHRA" of Naam-Bani, cannot be distracted by these issues. I respect Gurusikhs who keep Sarbloh Rehat, BUT I just want to say that we all should focus more on Bibek-the real Bibek of Naam Bani, instead of streaching this issue with other things. What kind of answer i have for my parents and other people if i even stop eating from Guru-Ka langar, which is made with utmost pyar and care in every Gurughar? All of my relatives respect me as an AmritDhari individual and when ever they call me for lunch, they take real care during process of prep and give utmost respect to it. By eating food at their places, i am able to discuss Sikhi with them and convey them the message. How can i convey them the message of sikhism if i am not even ready to eat at their places? They will not even listen to you, because you are not ready to sit with them and share their feeling. I don't think we need to isolate ourselves, but we need to be in the stream and convey the real message.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

G · 16 Sep 2003

If you want to keep bibek thats good, but it doesnt mean your a better Gursikh than someone that doesnt keep bibek, if keeping bibek makes you feel good inside and helps you with your Gursikhi then its good, but it might not have the same effect on someone else as it does to you, u can believe wut food u put in ur body effects you but it doesnt one bit its all in ur mind... if u believe the food is effecting u then it will if you dont it wont... but hey if it helps you... thas good just dont judge anyone else

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Kulbir Singh · 16 Sep 2003

What kind of postings are we getting on this forum? Arguments like “Bibeki is not better than non-bibeki” are lame arguments. They have no foundation in Gurmat. You can’t back this up with Gurbani. All other things held constant, of course a bibeki person is better a non-bibeki person. Why? Because a bibeki person sacrifices his tastes of tongue, goes against the wishes of his social circle and obeys the hukam of Guru Sahib against all odds. Why is such person not better than a non-bibeki who disobeys Guru Sahib’s hukam for whatever reason? It is one mistake that some Gursikhs don’t keep bibek and eat from whoever’s hands. The second big mistake they make is when they instead of admitting their weakness, try to condone their weakness and try to argue that bibek is not a must. Guru Sahib knows that we all are at different levels of spirituality and it is quite possible that some of our veers and bhains cannot keep bibek at this time and it is fully understandable. No one should be forced to keep bibek or any other rehit but by the same token, no one should try to argue that bibek is not a rehit or that bibek does not make a person better and other such lame arguments. If there is a weakness we have, we should strive to overcome it and never justify our weakness by refusing to acknowledge a rehit of Guru Sahib. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Balpreet Singh · 16 Sep 2003

Bhulanhar jee, you said "I have total confidence that if Naam-Jap and Gurubani Abyaas can clean your bad karams, then certainly it can over-come anything else" You say this in the context to say that Bibek isn't necessary as the above will protect you. By this logic, someone may say that Kakaars aren't necessary and either are kesh as "naam jap and gurubani abyaas" will protect the individual and take care of any problems. Just like kakaars and kesh are hukam of Guru Sahib, the same way Sarbloh Bibek is also hukam of Guru Sahib. Guru Sahib gives his full kirpaa and protection if we follow his orders. So for these reasons, bibek is incomplete without dietary bibek. See, I'm sure you've heard of the story of Baba Harnaam Singh jee RampurKheray valay, who didn't like reading Jaap Sahib and substituted Sukhmani Sahib for it in his nitnem. After a lot of bhagtee, he had the blessing of seeing Guru Gobind Singh jee, but when he approached, Guru Sahib would not speak to him. When he asked why, a Singh said that it was because he was not following hukam of Jaap Sahib. So you see, someone that does massive bhagtee but does not follow a hukam cannot get full kirpa of Guru jee. Jaap Saahib takes 10 minutes and what was that daily 10 minutes in comparison to the hours and hours of naam/baaNee Baba jee was doing? But because that 10 minutes was hukam and he was not following it, he did not get full bakshish of Guru Sahib. As for "isolating" ourselves, perhaps one day someone will suggest that the best way to preach Sikhi is to assimilate and even look like non-Sikhs and do parchaar that way. Don't kakaars and baaNaa also isolate us? You said "we need to be in the stream and convey the real message". I say that the whole world is in the stream and is drowning. Why should we jump in? Let's stay on the shore and help from there. Some people will feel offended if you refuse a cigarette, or a drink, and the same way some people may feel offended by dietary bibek, but with nimartaa and proper explanation, and of course, Kirpa of Guru Sahib, people will understand and our parchaar will be all the more powerful.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Sardaro · 16 Sep 2003

>>>>>>What kind of answer i have for my parents and other people if i even stop eating from Guru-Ka langar, which is made with utmost pyar and care in every Gurughar? All of my relatives respect me as an AmritDhari individual and when ever they call me for lunch, they take real care during process of prep and give utmost respect to it. By eating food at their places, i am able to discuss Sikhi with them and convey them the message. How can i convey them the message of sikhism if i am not even ready to eat at their places? They will not even listen to you, because you are not ready to sit with them and share their feeling.<<<<<< I have been sarbloh/bibek for 2-2.5 years now and non of my mona family members have even noticed, or cared. you think they will, i used to think about it and worry about it. but not a SINGLE one of them cares!! they just think "oh hes being weird again" or something.. they still ask me if i want roti when i go to their houses, i just say "no thanks, i just ate" why say no i dont want your food? thats useless.. why even tell them of your rehat? obviously fights will happen if u go around bragging about your sarblohi!! Ive even spent the night at a mona relatives house and not eaten a single thing from their hands!! they werent offended nor did they even ask. I said i woke up early and ate my breakfast while you were sleeping. they said ok. done! so this kind of excuse while it makes sense from your viewpoint, tkae it from me, ive had experience.. nobody cares!

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Mkhalsa · 16 Sep 2003

>>>>>>I say that the whole world is in the stream and is drowning. Why should we jump in? Let's stay on the shore and help from there. <<<<<< I totally agree with you!!

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Questionaire Extraordinaire · 16 Sep 2003

I don't think this is an issue of dis-obeying Guru Sahib's Hukam. I think it is more along the lines of establishing whether Bibek really is Hukam of Guru Sahib. The article is good, but doesn't quite do the trick since many will have different interpretations of baani (and validity of rehitnama's). Here's another question that may help: Who is Faithless? Side Note: About the 'taste of the tongue' comment, this is not a very fair argument to make. By the sound of it, it accuses all Non-Bibeki's to be slaves of their tongues - I may have misinterpreted, but it does sound like a general sterotype. And besides, there are many Sarablohi/Bibeki's out there that that whip up quite extravagant dishes. Bibek does not free you from your tongues desires. I know of Bibeki's that cook Canadian/Italian/Amercan meals, only they cook it in Sarabloh and make it from scratch - that still does not release you from taste. On the other hand, there are Non-Bibekee's who only eat from the hands of lovers of God, (by that I mean devotees of God who arent necessarily Sikh and don't take it upon themselves to decide who will meet HIM and who won't) and they do not eat buttered roti or salted dhaal. Freedom from taste is not an automatic result of keeping dietary Bibek.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

..... · 16 Sep 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh With all due respect to you great Gursikhs, I don't really see any Guru miryada that prohibits us from cooking in utensils other than sarbloh. The 18/10 steel, plastic, glass and some of the other current utensils weren't at avail during Guru Sahib's time, and we weren't instructed to exclusively use sarbloh for the rest of eternity. Of course loh was considered a sign of shakti and most shashters were made out of it. So, it seems very fitting to me that, to create a SantSipahi, Deshmesh Pitah ji prepared Amrit in sarbloh. Degh has been served on leaves and clay pots has been used to cook (daal, milk etc.) and serve food for years. If we don't have any problem with buying produce, milk and other eatables grown and sold by non-gursikhs, then why do we not accept a drink of water from a non amritdhari. Phul chuk dee maafi but how different is it from a brahmin who runs for shower to cleanse himself if he ever comes in contact with a perceived lower class, yet he has no problem eating produce grown by the sweat of that same lower class. Question again is that what is GuruMatt and what is our own matt added to it. Guru Sahib didn't give the hukam of using only sarbloh. We shouldn't feel better than others for making sacrifices for our own spiritual growth. It's great to follow sarbloh but to think any less of gursikhs who don't follow sarbloh is lame, a sign of hidden ahankaar. Again, phul chuk de maafi

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Questionaire Extraordinaire · 16 Sep 2003

--- I say that the whole world is in the stream and is drowning. Why should we jump in? Let's stay on the shore and help from there. --- This does sound rather impressive, I agree with what your trying to say (if your thinking the same thing), but not with the analogy. Think of it more of a lake, or an ocean if you will. You can't save everyone from the shore (let's not get into the argument of not having to save everyone), the advantage Gursikh's have is that we know how to swim. We don't have to fish anyone out or carry them back to shore either. All we have to do is swim to them and teach them how to swim back and if they please, they will swim back. But that was off topic, just had to make a note of it.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Ranjit Singh · 16 Sep 2003

Guru Saahib is the only one who's going to teach anyone to swim. Most of us can barely stay afloat ourselves. I don't think we're going to be swimming around the sea of maya teaching others to swim. Our first task is to dedicate ourselves to our guru and save ourselves. There are so many gurdvaras, so many preachers, so many camps, all full of people trying to save others. But so many are completely stuck in maya themselves. How are they going to save anyone else? What's with all this talk about teaching about sikhee by eating other people's food? How will that help? I eat because I'm hungry, not to socialize or convert people. I've eaten with enough manmukhs and still do. They don't change because I eat their food. I might end up getting some negative effects, but they definitely haven't been changing from me eating their food. Rather than getting all defensive and trying to put down bibek, try understanding it. Don't be like those monay who spend all their time trying to argue that keeping kes won't make them better people or that shukking amrit isn't going to affect your spirituality. Dietary bibek is a panthic rehit that's been around since the beginning. If you're like me and haven't kept it, accept it as your own weakness and try getting stronger rather than attacking bibekis. Also, bibek isn't something that's associated with only certain jathebandees, as many people now think. My own family members think this despite the fact that my great grandfather, on my father's side, kept bibek. He was an akalee and did lots of seva during the morchas in the early 1900's. Unfortunately, he wasn't able to keep as strict rehit in his later years. He died at the age of 108, just a couple of years before I was born. His children weren't very religious either. However, he still tried keeping his rehit, even though he was dependant on others in his old age. All his old Akali friends were bibeki too. One of them went to jail for a few months during the punjabi suba movement and he refused to eat their food. The authorities agreed to supply him with atta, but they didn't give him any cooking facilities. So the poor singh had to resort to mixing the flour in some water and drinking it like that for his entire stay in prison. But he felt strongly enough about his rehit that he didn't give it up.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Balpreet Singh · 16 Sep 2003

Well, I can say this, if someone has evidence to refute the points brought up in the article, please do so. If someone can bring in quotes that say eat and drink what you like and from whomever you like, then I'd be happy to see them. Gursikhs have kept bibek for centuries and will continue to do so as it is a rehit of Guru Sahib. Please Janpreet jee, give me an example of where in a puraatan langar food has been prepared in clay. All old langars had and continue to have big sarbloh deghas and sarbloh utensils. The rehitnamas and Guru Sahib's baNee make clear that a Sikh should use sarbloh as it is a special material. Raw materials such as sugar, ghee, etc. can be bought, but all food need be prepared by Khalsa. Like many other debates, I'll have to say that I don't think we're going to go very much further unless someone give evidnece refuting bibek from Gurbani or rehitnamas. Let's not go in any more circles. If someone has a refutation of bibek based on Gurmat, please do bring it forward (and before doing this, do read the article!!!). Otherwise lets look at the evidence and reach our own conclusions.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

JK · 16 Sep 2003

<<>> Bhain/Veer Ji ".....", What are you talking about? Where have you come up with the conclusion that anyone here on this thread thinks less of Gursikhs who don't follow Sarbloh Bibek? Most posts on this thread have basically said that Sarbloh Bibek is one of Guru Sahib's rehit's which we should all be trying to preserve and not put down. If one can't do it just yet, fine. No one here "think[s] any less" of anyone because they don't keep Sarbloh Bibek. I think most individuals here are just trying to show others which path is the right path, instead of letting them wander along the wrong one and lose their way.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

..... · 17 Sep 2003

JK Bhain/Veer Ji, I was just referring to one of the post that suggested that sarbloh bibeki gursikhs are better than the ones who don't keep sarbloh bibek. It suggested that it's weakness that should be over come. Again, I didn't mean to hurt anyone's feeling.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Questionaire Extraordinaire · 19 Sep 2003

Before we end this thread, I'd just like to know this one little thing. Through what medium does the 'badness'/impurity in Non-Amritdharee's/Monay get transferred through? Touch, smell, taste, sight, breath, air, presence? It'll just make the whole concept and practice of Bibek a little Easier to understand. Thank you.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Questionaire Extraordinaire · 19 Sep 2003

Kulbir Singh VeerJee wrote: "...no one should try to argue that bibek is not a rehit or that bibek does not make a person better and other such lame arguments. If there is a weakness we have, we should strive to overcome it and never justify our weakness by refusing to acknowledge a rehit of Guru Sahib. " There are many people who claim many things. Saying that no one should ever question is very unfair. Many people don't believe this is rehit of Guru Sahib, others may want to keep Bibek and learn more about it by questioning the practice. Question everything about it is one of the mediums one uses to familiarize oneself with it. It is not a lame arguement, it is merely a question that some people need to ask. I don't know about anyone else, but if you read any of Questionaire Extraordinaire's posts, I never denied or agreed to Bibek, only questioned to learn more. Please be patient.

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Davinder Singh UK · 19 Sep 2003

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh! One day I mentioned to Bhai Jeevan Singh that I had heard a number of people say "Why keep Sarbloh Bibek when Bhai Sahib Jeevan Singh doesn't anymore." Bhai Sahib replied to me," It is my weakness that I have not been able to follow Sarbloh Bibek. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh once said to me, that any Gursikh who keeps Sarbloh Bibek and also does Sarbloh batey seva will have received jeevan safulta from Guru Sahib. "

Re: Purpose of Bibek

Balpreet Singh · 19 Sep 2003

>>>Through what medium does the 'badness'/impurity in Non-Amritdharee's/Monay get transferred through? Touch, smell, taste, sight, breath, air, presence?<<< I already said that framing this question in terms of "badness/impurity" is dubious. It's a question of what food has the effect of naam and what does not. The issue is of eating food prepared by amritdharis: this is a hukam of Guru Sahib. I'd be happy to see evidence that this is not the case. Otherwise, as I said before, each person must look at the facts and decide for themselves.